Ch10 - Note
Ch10 - Note
Monitoring and
Information
Systems
10-2
The Planning–Monitoring–Controlling
Cycle
10-3
Three key factors to be controlled in
Monitoring system: Time - Cost - Scope
• Time: Monitoring the project's timeline is crucial to ensure that activities
are completed as scheduled and milestones are achieved within the
specified time frame. It involves tracking the progress of tasks, identifying
any delays or bottlenecks, and taking corrective actions to keep the project
on schedule.
• Cost: Monitoring the project's cost involves tracking and managing the
project's budget. It includes monitoring expenses. comparing them to the
planned budget, identifying cost overruns or variances, and implementing
strategies to control costs. Effective cost control helps ensure that the
project is financially sustainable and stays within budgetary constraints.
• Scope: Monitoring the project's scope involves ensuring that the
deliverables and objectives defined at the start of the project are being
met. It includes assessing the completeness and quality of the work
performed, identifying any scope changes or deviations, and managing
scope creep. By monitoring the project's scope, stakeholders can ensure
that the project is aligned with the intended outcomes and requirements.
10-4
How to design good monitoring system
10-7
Designing the Monitoring System
Continued
10-8
Much Data Involves
Frequency counts
Raw numbers
Subjective numeric ratings
Indicators
Verbal measures
10-9
Some types of Measures
10-11
How to collect data
Collecting: Collecting, in the context of project management. refers to the
process of gathering relevant data or information for analysis, decision-
making, or reporting purposes. It involves systematically gathering data from
various sources using appropriate methods and tools.
When you are the center manager, you have to collect customer information,
after that, the information of the team members also needs to be collected
(Staff by staff)
• Once we know the data we want, we need to decide how to collect it
• Frequency counts - How often an event occurs.
• Raw numbers - Amount of something, like hours spent on a task.
• Subjective numeric ratings - Subjective estimates often applied to quality measures.
• Indicators - Indirect measures, such as transaction processing speed, being used to
suggest customer satisfaction.
• Verbal measures - Descriptions of characteristics like the morale of the team.
• Should the data be collected after some event?
• Should it be collected on a regular basis?
• Are there any special forms needed for data collection?
• Useful, necessary, not too much, quality > quantity
10-12
How to collect data
Here's an example to illustrate the concept of collecting: a project to
develop a new mobile application. As part of the project, the project
manager wants to collect customer feedback to understand user
satisfaction and identify areas for improvement. The project manager
decides to use a survey as a data collection method.
The process of collecting data in this example involves the following steps:
• Defining the Purpose: The project manager clarifies the objective of the data collection,
which is to gather customer feedback regarding the mobile application.
• Designing the Survey: The project manager creates a survey questionnaire that includes
relevant questions related to user experience, functionality, user interface. and overall
satisfaction.
• Distributing the Survey: The project manager determines the target audience for the
survey, which could be existing users of the application or a sample of potential users.
• The survey is distributed through various channels, such as email, online platforms, or in-
app notifications.
• Collecting Responses: As users receive and respond to the survey, their feedback is
collected and recorded. The project manager ensures that the data collection process is
ongoing for a specified period or until a sufficient number of responses is received.
10-13
How to collect data
• Analyzing the Data: Once the data collection phase is complete, the project
manager analyzes the survey responses. This involves summarizing and
aggregating the data to identify patterns, trends, and areas for improvement.
Statistical analysis or data visualization techniques may be applied to gain
insights from the collected data.
• Utilizing the Findings: The project manager uses the findings from the data
collection and analysis process to make informed decisions. For example, if
certain features or functionalities receive negative feedback, the project
manager may prioritize improvements or updates in subsequent development
cycles.
10-14
Recording
is a project to giving out the information in our team members
Recording, in the context of project management, refers to the
process of documenting and organizing collected data or
information in a structured manner for future reference, analysis.
and reporting. It involves systematically capturing and storing data
in a format that is easily accessible and usable.
Here's an example to illustrate the concept of recording: the
project to develop a new mobile application. After collecting
customer feedback through surveys, the project manager needs to
record and organize the data for further analysis and decision-
making.
10-15
Recording
The process of recording data in this example involves:
• Data Compilation: The project manager compiles the survey responses received from
customers. This may involve aggregating the responses from different sources, such as email,
online platforms, or in-app notifications.
• Data Entry: The project manager enters the survey data into a structured format. such as a
spreadsheet or a database. Each response is recorded as a separate entry, with relevant
details captured. such as respondent ID, ratings, and comments.
• Data Verification: The project manager ensures the accuracy and integrity of the recorded data
by reviewing the entries for completeness and correctness. Any inconsistencies or errors are
corrected to maintain data quality.
• Data Organization: The recorded data is organized in a logical and meaningful manner. This
may include categorizing responses based on specific criteria, such as user demographics,
geographical location, or specific aspects of the mobile application.
• Data Storage: The project manager stores the recorded data in a secure and accessible
location, such as a centralized project repository or a dedicated database. Proper data backup
procedures may be implemented to ensure data integrity and prevent loss.
• Documentation: The project manager documents the data recording process, including details
about the data sources, collection methods, and any specific considerations or limitations. This
documentation helps maintain a record of the data collection process and provides context for
future analysis and reporting.
10-16
Information Needs and Reporting
Everyone should be tied into the reporting
system
Reports should address each level
Not at same depth and frequency for
every level
– Lower-level needs detailed information
– Senior management levels need overview
reports
Report frequency is typically high at low
levels and less frequent at higher levels
10-17
The Reporting Process
Reports must contain relevant data
Must be issued frequently
Should be available in time for control
Distribution of project reports depends on
interest
– For senior management, may be few
milestones
– For project manager, there may be many
critical points
10-18
How to make report
Reporting: Reporting in project management involves the process
of collecting project data, analyzing it. and presenting it in a
structured format to stakeholders. The purpose of reporting is to
provide stakeholders with information on project progress,
performance, and potential risks. It includes steps such as data
collection, analysis, report compilation, formatting, distribution, and
review. Effective reporting ensures transparency, facilitates
decision-making, and promotes collaboration among project
participants.
Reports must contain relevant data
Must be issued frequently
Should be available in time for control
Distribution of project reports depends on interest
o For senior management, may be few milestones
o For project manager. there may be many critical points
10-19
How to make report
Here's an example to illustrate the concept of reporting: a construction project
to build a new office building. The project manager is responsible for providing
regular reports to the project sponsor, the client, and other key stakeholders. The
reporting process involves the following steps:
• Data Collection: The project manager collects relevant data and information from
various sources, such as project plans, progress updates, financial records, and
team feedback. This data includes information on tasks completed, milestones
achieved, budget utilization, risks, and any issues encountered.
• Data Analysis: The project manager analyzes the collected data to derive
meaningful insights and trends. This involves comparing actual progress against the
planned schedule, assessing budget performance, identifying any deviations or
variances, and evaluating the overall project health.
• Report Compilation: Based on the analyzed data, the project manager compiles a
comprehensive report that includes key project information and metrics. The report
typically includes sections such as project summary, schedule status, cost status,
risk analysis, and notable achievements. It may also include graphical
representations, such as charts or graphs, to present the data visually.
10-20
How to make report
• Report Formatting: The project manager ensures that the report is properly
formatted and organized for readability and clarity. This may involve structuring the
report into sections, using headings and subheadings, and incorporating
appropriate visual aids to enhance understanding.
• Report Distribution: The project manager shares the report with relevant
stakeholders according to the agreed reporting frequency and distribution channels.
This can be done through email, project management software, or in-person
meetings. The report is sent to the project sponsor, client representatives, project
team members, and other stakeholders who require project updates.
• Report Review and Discussion: After stakeholders receive the report, they review
the information and may schedule meetings or discussions to address any
questions, concerns, or decisions that need to be made based on the report. This
allows stakeholders to gain a deeper understanding of the project's progress and
collaborate on necessary actions.
10-22
Benefits of Detailed and Timely Reports
• Mutual understanding of goals: Reports help ensure that all
stakeholders have a clear understanding of the project's objectives and
goals. It helps align everyone towards a common vision and minimizes
misunderstandings.
• Awareness of progress: Project reports provide visibility into the
progress of parallel activities. They help team members and stakeholders
understand how different tasks and activities are progressing and how
they relate to each other.
• Task relationship understanding: Reports highlight the
interdependencies and relationships between tasks. This allows project
participants to see how one task's completion or delay can impact other
tasks and the overall project timeline.
• Early warning signals: Reports serve as early warning signals for
potential issues or problems. By monitoring key metrics and progress
indicators, project managers can identify and address challenges
proactively, preventing them from becoming major obstacles later on.
10-23
Benefits of Detailed and Timely Reports
• Minimizing confusion: Reports promote clarity and minimize confusion
by providing structured and organized information about the project's
status. activities, and milestones.
• They help stakeholders stay informed and avoid misunderstandings.
• Higher visibility for top management: Reports provide higher visibility to
top management. enabling them to make informed decisions and provide
necessary support. They offer a comprehensive overview of the project's
progress. challenges. and achievements. allowing management to stay
involved and take timely actions.
• Keeping clients informed: Project reports keep clients updated on
project progress. milestones, and any deviations from the original plan.
Regular communication through reports helps build trust, manage
expectations, and maintain a positive client relationship
10-24
Report Types
Routine - Reports that are issued on a regular
basis or each time the project reaches a
milestone
Exception - Reports that are generated when
an usual condition occurs or as an
informational vehicle when an unusual
decision is made
Special Analysis - Reports that result from
studies commissioned to look into unexpected
problems
10-25
Report Types
In project management, there are different types of reports that serve specific purposes:
• Routine Reports: These reports provide regular updates on the project's progress.
They typically include information on task completion, milestones achieved. and any
deviations. from the schedule. Routine reports help stakeholders stay informed
about the project's status and ensure ongoing communication.
• Special Analysis Reports: Special analysis reports are the most important type of
report as they involve in-depth analysis and examination of specific project aspects.
These reports often involve gathering and analyzing data, identifying trends, root
causes of issues, and the resulting impact. Special analysis reports provide insights
and recommendations to address problems, optimize performance, or make
informed decisions.
10-26
The main benefits of monitoring: PM,
organization, client, team members
Monitoring in project management provides several benefits to different
stakeholders involved in the project:
Project Manager:
Progress Tracking: Monitoring allows the project manager to track the
progress of the project, ensuring that it stays on schedule and meets the
defined milestones.
Early Issue Detection: By regularly monitoring project activities, the project
manager can identify any issues or risks that may arise and take proactive
measures to address them before they escalate.
Performance Evaluation: Monitoring provides data on the performance of the
project team and individual team members. enabling the project manager to
assess their effectiveness and make necessary adjustments.
Decision-making Support: Monitoring provides the project manager with real-
time information and insights, facilitating informed decision-making regarding
project adjustments, resource allocation, and risk mitigation.
10-27
The main benefits of monitoring: PM,
organization, client, team members
Organization:
Resource Allocation: Monitoring helps organizations allocate
resources effectively by providing visibility into resource utilization,
identifying areas of inefficiency or overallocation.
10-28
The main benefits of monitoring: PM,
organization, client, team members
Client/Stakeholders:
Transparency: Monitoring provides clients and stakeholders with
visibility into project progress, allowing them to have a clear
understanding of the project's status and any potential risks or
challenges.
10-29
The main benefits of monitoring: PM,
organization, client, team members
Team Members:
Performance Feedback: Monitoring provides feedback to team
members on their performance and progress, allowing them to assess
their contributions and make improvements as needed.
10-30
Meetings
Reports do not have to be written
They can be delivered verbally in
meetings
Projects have too many meetings
The trick is to keep them to as few as
possible
10-31
Meeting Rules
Use meetings to make group decisions
Start and end on time and have an
agenda
Do your homework before the meeting
Take minutes
Avoid attributing remarks to individuals in
minutes
Avoid overly formal rules of procedure
Call meeting for serious problems
10-32
Common Reporting Problems
Too much detail
Poor interface between the
data/procedures of the project and the
information system of the parent
company
Poor correspondence between the
planning process and the monitoring
process
10-33
Common Reporting Problems
Common reporting problems in project management include:
• Inaccurate or incomplete data: Reporting relies on accurate and
complete data. If the data collected or entered into the reporting system is
incorrect or incomplete, it can lead to inaccurate reports and misleading
information.
• Lack of consistency: Inconsistent reporting formats, terminology, or
metrics can create confusion and make it challenging to compare and
analyze data across different reports or projects. Consistency in reporting
ensures clear communication and facilitates data analysis.
• Poor data visualization: Reports that lack clear and effective data
visualization can make it difficult for stakeholders to interpret and
understand the information. Visual elements such as charts, graphs, and
diagrams should be used to present data in a visually appealing and easily
understandable manner.
10-34
Common Reporting Problems
• Overwhelming or irrelevant information: Reports that contain excessive
or irrelevant information can overwhelm stakeholders and make it
challenging to identify key insights or important trends. It is important to
focus on presenting concise and relevant information that aligns with the
stakeholders' information needs.
• Lack of context or insights: Reports should not only present data but
also provide context and insights. Without proper analysis or interpretation
of the data, reports may fail to provide meaningful information or
actionable insights for decision-making.
• Delayed or infrequent reporting: Timely reporting is essential to keep
stakeholders informed and enable prompt decision-making. Delayed or
infrequent reporting can lead to missed opportunities for course correction
or addressing issues in a timely manner.
Lack of stakeholder engagement: Reports should be tailored to the
needs and preferences of the intended audience. Inadequate stakeholder
engagement in the report development process can result in reports that
do not meet stakeholders' information requirements or fail to effectively
communicate the desired message. 10-35
Earned Value Analysis
Have covered monitoring parts
– Timing and coordination between individual
tasks is important
Mustalso monitor performance of entire
project
– Crux of matter should not be overlooked
One way is by using an aggregate
performance measure called earned
value
10-36
Why is the Earned Value Chart a key
element in Earned Value Analysis ?
• measure project performance that incorporates scope.
time, and cost data.
• displaying earned value management metrics over
time.
• lines that represent budget (planned project cost),
actual cost and earned value - how much progress has
been made.
Overall, the Earned Value Chart is a powerful tool in Earned Value Analysis as it
provides a visual representation of the project's cost and schedule performance,
facilitates variance analysis, trend analysis, and forecasting. It enables project
managers to make informed decisions. take corrective actions, and ensure project
success.
10-39
The Earned Value Chart and Calculations
50-50 rule
0-100 percent rule
Critical input use rule
Proportionality rule
10-41
Rules to Aid in Estimating Percent
Completion
50-50 rule: Fifty percent completion is assumed when
the task is begun, and the remaining 50 percent when
the work is complete. This seems to be the most
popular rule, probably because it is relatively fair and
does not require the effort of attempting to estimate
task progress.
10-42
Rules to Aid in Estimating Percent
Completion
10-43
Rules to Aid in Estimating Percent
Completion
10-44
Rules to Aid in Estimating Percent
Completion
10-45
The Earned Value Chart
10-47
Cost Variance (CV)
CV = EV – AC
10-48
Schedule Variance (SV)
SV = EV – PV
10-49
Time Variance (TV)
TV = ST – AT
10-50
Indices
Cost Performance Index
CPI = EV/AC
Schedule Performance Index
SPI = EV/PV
Time Performance Index
TPI = ST/AT
Cost Schedule Index
CSI = EV2/(AC)(PV)
10-51
“To complete” and “At Completion”
Project manager reviewing what is
complete and what remains
Final cost and final completion date are
moving targets
The project manager compiles these into
a to complete forecast
Actual + forecast = final date and cost at
completion
10-52
ETC and EAC
10-53
Milestone Reporting
Reports that are created when a project
reaches a major milestone
They are designed to keep everyone up-
to-date on project status
For executives and clients, these may be
the only reports they receive
10-54
Computerized PMIS (Project Management
Information Systems)
10-56
PMIS Desirable Attributes
Graphics
Friendliness
Charts
Schedules
Migration
Calendars
Consolidation
Budgets
Access
Reports
10-57
Define "Monitoring".
Monitoring refers to the systematic and ongoing process of
collecting, recording, and analyzing information or data
about a project, program, or activity. It involves the regular
observation. measurement, and assessment of progress,
performance, and results against predetermined goals,
targets, or standards. It aims to provide real-time insights
into the implementation of a project, allowing for timely
identification of any deviations, challenges, or
opportunities. It involves tracking activities, outputs,
outcomes, and impacts, to ensure that they align with the
intended objectives and expectations.
10-58
Define "Monitoring".
The key elements of monitoring include:
Data Collection: Gathering relevant data and information through
various methods, such as surveys, interviews, observations, document
reviews, or data tracking systems.
Data Analysis: Analyzing the collected data to assess the status.
trends, patterns, and quality of project implementation. This involves
organizing, interpreting, and drawing conclusions from the data to
identify any issues, gaps, or successes.
Feedback and Reporting: Providing feedback and reporting the
findings to stakeholders, including project managers, and other
relevant parties. It often used to communicate the monitoring results,
highlighting key insights and recommendations for improvement.
10-59
Describe the three variances of an earned
value chart and explain their significance.
10-63
What is the purpose of "earned value?"
The purpose of "earned value" in project management is to measure
and assess the value of work that has been actually accomplished in
relation to the planned work and associated costs. It is a method used
to evaluate the progress and performance of a project by integrating
the measurement of work completed, time expended, and the
corresponding budget.
The key purposes of earned value are as follows:
– Performance Measurement: Earned value provides a quantitative
measurement of project performance. By comparing the planned value
(PV) or budgeted cost of work scheduled with the earned value (EV) or
budgeted cost of work performed, it indicates how much of the planned
work has been completed at a given point in time. It enables project
managers to assess the actual progress of the project and determine if it is
meeting the desired milestones and targets.
10-64
What is the purpose of "earned value?"
The key purposes of earned value are as follows:
– Cost Analysis: Earned value facilitates cost analysis by comparing the
actual cost of work performed with the earned value (EV) or budgeted cost
of work performed. This analysis provides insights into the cost efficiency of
the project, identifying if it is under or over budget. It helps in monitoring
and controlling project costs and making informed decisions related to
resource allocation and cost management.
– Schedule Analysis: Earned value supports schedule analysis by comparing
the planned value (PV) or budgeted cost of work scheduled with the earned
value (EV) or budgeted cost of work performed. It allows project managers
to assess the project's schedule performance and determine if it is ahead
of or behind schedule. It helps in identifying schedule deviations. analyzing
the causes, and taking corrective actions to keep the project on track.
10-65
What is the purpose of "earned value?"
The key purposes of earned value are as follows:
– Performance Forecasting: By analyzing earned value data over time,
project managers can forecast the future performance of the project. It
enables project managers to estimate the project's completion date,
forecast the remaining work, and predict potential cost overruns or
schedule delays. This information aids in proactive decision-making and
effective resource management.
– Performance Reporting: Earned value provides a standardized and
objective basis for reporting project performance to stakeholders. It allows
for clear and concise communication of progress, cost efficiency, and
schedule adherence. Project managers can use earned value metrics,
such as schedule variance (SV), cost variance (CV), and schedule
performance index (SPI), to present a comprehensive picture of the
project's status and performance trends.
10-66
What tools are available to a PM to use to
control a project?
10-67