GORE-TEX ®
Filtration Products
Expanded-PTFE
MEMBRANE Filtration
Membrane Filtration 101
Shanghai, China
March 2004
Membrane Filtration 101
Welcome all!
Tim Fisher - Global Technical
Services
Leo Wang - Pac Rim Technical
Services
Introductions and Housekeeping
Membrane Filtration 101
Goals today:
Learn from each other
Understand Fabric Filtration Theory and Practice
Learn some of the important calculations and
“math” associated with Fabric Filters
Media Selection
Understand In-Depth Filtration vs. Surface
Understand membrane differentiation
Membrane Filtration 101
Goals today:
Effective sales techniques, tools for selling
membrane filters
Develop winning strategies and techniques:
• selling “up” from non-membrane filter systems
• selling “against” in-kind membrane competition
Market Strategies and Issues - open discussion
If time - a Case Study
Filtration
Within Gore, there are “three” main
businesses focusing on filtration:
Microcontamination
• Passive Filtration
Microfiltration
• Active Filtration
Industrial Filtration
• Active Filtration with clean-in-place systems
• Also call ourselves “Cleanable Filtration”
Filtration
It is all about separating things
solids from a gas
liquids from a gas
solids from a liquid
gases from gases …
Let’s look at just the “dry” applications
typical in industrial applications...
Separations Technology:
Mechanical Separators
Wet Scrubbers
Electrostatic Precipitators
Fabric Filters
Mechanical Separators - Cyclones
Useful for large
particle sizes
Reduces abrasive
loading to
downstream
equipment
Inexpensive
Mechanical Separators - Cyclones
Multi-clones
Mechanical Separators - Wet Scrubbers
Mechanical Separators - Wet Scrubbers
Venturi, Impingement
Plate, Spray Tower
Can be very efficient
Can condition gas
streams
Can handle wet dusts
and gas streams
Mechanical Separators - Wet Scrubbers
While the unit itself
is not expensive, it
must be part of a
very complex and
expensive system.
Not as efficient at low
particle sizes
Electrostatic Precipitators (ESP’s)
Electrostatic Precipitators (ESP’s)
Electrostatic Precipitators (ESP’s)
Multiple
Fields used for
efficiency
Few moving
parts - easier
maintenance
•Collection efficiency not good for
small particles
•Efficiency depends on dust resistivity
Fabric Filter Systems
Fabric Filtration Theory and
Practice
Fabric Filter Systems
Shaker, Reverse Air and PJ
• each has its own issues
Short discussion on Filtration Theory
Technical Guidelines and other things that go
wrong!
Issues of material selection (Temperature,
Chemical components, Physical requirements,
Cost (not necessarily “Price”)
Fabric Filter Systems
Shaker Baghouse
Collection on the inside of
the bag.
Bags mechanically shaken.
Old technology
Maintenance of motors is a
problem
Larger systems - OFF LINE
CLEANING
Fabric Filter Systems
Reverse Air Fabric Filter Systems
Baghouse
Dust collection on
inside of the bags
Bags are tensioned,
and contain anti-
collapse rings to
prevent closure of the
bag during cleaning
Gentle cleaning, bags
last a long time
Big systems - OFF-
LINE
Fabric Filter Systems
Pulse Jet Baghouse
Fabric Filter Systems
Dust collection on
outside of the bags
Bags have
cages/baskets inserted
to prevent collapse
during operation
Compressed air blast
used to clean bags -
very aggressive
Can be economical for
small volumes
Pulse Jet Baghouse
Fabric Filter Systems
Can be smaller than
low energy systems
• saves up front money
Aggressive cleaning
shortens bag life
• 2-4 years compared to
5-8 years for SH & RA
More moving parts -
more maintenance
ON-LINE/OFF-LINE
CLEANING
Cartridge Collectors
Fabric Filter Systems
Can be smaller than PJ
baghouses
• saves up front money
same principles as PJ
baghouses
Cartridges clean
differently than bags,
do not always work
Not always a
replacement for bags,
but has its place
Important Calculations
Fabric Filter Systems
Calculations/Important Numbers:
Permeability
Air/Gas to Cloth Ratio:
ACR = Volume of Gas to be filtered
Area of filter cloth
Filtration Velocity
Fabric Filter Systems
Calculations/Important Numbers:
ACR Gross / Net:
Gross ACR = Volume of Gas to be filtered
Total Baghouse Filter Area
Net ACR = Volume of Gas to be filtered
Baghouse Filter Area
Reverse Airs? during off-line cleaning
Fabric Filter Systems
Calculations/Important Numbers:
Inlet Velocities:
• = Compartment gas flow rate/inlet area
– Important for abrasion and pressure drop issues
Upward/“Vena Contracta” Velocities
• = compartment gas flow rate/total cell plate hole area
– Only for Reverse Airs and Shakers
– Important for abrasion and pressure drop
Fabric Filter Systems
Calculations/Important Numbers:
Lift/Can Velocities:
• = Compartment gas flow rate/tubesheet area between the bags
– Pulse Jets and Cartridge collectors only
– Important for RE-ENTRAINMENT
• Re-entrainment - particles are blown back up onto the bag
immediately after cleaning - results in poor cleaning, high
pressure drops
Filtration Theory
Filtration Theory
Sieving
Particle too big
to fit between
filter fibers.
“Pore Size”
important
Important
mechanism for
liquid filtration
Not important
for dry filtration
Filtration Theory
Inertial Impaction
Particle is “heavy” - can not follow gas stream
line around filter.
Inertia causes it to strike filter fiber
Filtration Theory
Interception
Particle does not compress, while gas stream
can - can not follow gas stream line around
filter due to “geometry”.
Filtration Theory
Diffusion
Particle is very small. “Bounces” off of gas molecules
and other particles. Motion is random.
By random chance, it comes into contact with filter fiber.
Filtration Theory
What does it mean?
A single fiber can be a filter!
The more fibers there are, the more efficient the filter
• NOT the “tightness” of the filter (i.e.. small “pore size”)
There is a particle size that is the most difficult to collect:
Actual
Collection Interception and Impaction
Efficiency
Diffusion
0.1 - 0.3 µm Particle Size
Technical Guidelines
Temperature limits for Fiberglass:
PTFE coated fiberglass OK up to 205°C
Between 205°C - 230°C, can use ptfe coated,
but with low acid concentrations (if high, use
AR glass)
Between 230°C and 260°C, use AR glass
unless exiting good experience
AR glass turns silver white at 540°C, softens at
815°C.
PTFE off-gases at 350°C to 370°C
Technical Guidelines
Acid Gas Concentrations (for fiberglass)
SOx
Up to 2% S coal (or 1000 ppm SOx), use ptfe
coated glass or AR glass - watch dew points
Up to 3% S coal (or 1500 ppm SOx), use AR
glass or GORE-TEX woven or felt filter media
Over 3.5 % S coal (or 2000 ppm SOX), use
GORE-TEX woven or felt all-PTFE filter media
Technical Guidelines
Acid Gas Concentrations (for fiberglass)
Hydrofluric Acid
Less than 10 ppm AR glass (watch for local dew
points)
Over 50 ppm, all PTFE felt or woven materials
HCl
No known problems with either AR glass or all
PTFE felt/woven filter media (watch for stainless
steel components, dew points)
Technical Guidelines
Lift (or Can) Velocity
Off-line for bulk density less than 10 lb/ft3
• (0.16 gm/cm3)
<3 fps for “ “ between 10 - 20 lb/ft3
• <0.9 m/s (0.16 - 0.32 gm/cm3)
<4 fps for “ “ between 20 - 35 lb/ft3
• <1.2 m/s (0.32 - 0.56 gm/cm3)
<5 fps for “ “ above 35 lb/ft3
• 1.5 m/s (> 0.56 gm/cm3)
Technical Guidelines
Vena Contracta Velocity (Upward, or the
velocity through the cell plate).
< 250 fpm (76 m/min) no problem
< 350 fpm (107 m/min) with a thimble, 1x
diameter tall
Velocity can be increase if:
• Grain Load is low
• Dust is light and non-abrasive
Technical Guidelines
Inlet Velocity
Shaker/Reverse Air collectors:
Trough hopper:
• End Inlet 4500 fpm (1372 m/min) with baffle
• End Inlet 3000 fpm (915 m/min) without baffle
• Side Inlet 3500 fpm (1067 m/min) with baffle
• Side Inlet 2500 fpm (762 m/min) without baffle
Technical Guidelines
Inlet Velocity
Pulse Jets:
High Side Inlet 2500/3000 fpm with baffle
• MUST have baffle (762/915 m/min)
Trough Hopper:
• End Inlet 3500 fpm (1067 m/min) with baffle
• End Inlet 2500 fpm (762 m/min) without baffle
• Side Inlet 3000 fpm (915 m/min) with baffle
• Side Inlet 2000 fpm (610 m/min) without baffle
Technical Guidelines
Inlet Velocity
Pulse Jets:
Pyramid Hopper
• 3500 fpm (1067 m/min) with baffle
• 2500 fpm (762 m/min) without baffle
Technical Guidelines
Bag Tensioning
Reverse Air - 5 to 6 lbs per inch of diameter
• 0.09 - 0.11 kg per millimeter of diameter
• Use the lower side for difficult to clean dusts, use the
higher side for easier to clean dusts
Shakers
• Pinch the seam and rotate between 45 and 90 degrees
• Bag should be just snug at the maximum upward
throw of the shaker arm.
Technical Guidelines
Pulsing glass, fabrics
Reduce pulse pressure to 50 to 70 PSI (3.5 - 4.8 bar) for
high pressure cleaning systems
Reduce pressure to 30 PSI (2 bar) for low pressure/high
volume systems
Set pulse on-time for 250 to 500 milliseconds (up from the
normal of 100 to 150 msec for felts)
Cage vertical wire spacing less than 20 mm, horizontal
support rings at maximum 200 mm spacing. Good quality
wire, no burrs, welds contacting glass.
PERFORMANCE CONDITIONS
Owner/Location:
Process Description:
Collector Description:
Technical Guidelines
Collector Manufacturer:
Model or Size: Collector Inside Dimensions:
Design Conditions Actual Conditions Proposed Conditions
Flow Rate (acfm)
Temperature ( F)
Inlet Grain Loading
Particulate Size Distribution
Particulate Bulk Density
Gas Analysis
Differential Pressure
No. Bags/Compartment
No. Bags/Collector
Bag Dimensions
Bag Material
Air-to-Cloth Ratio (Gross/Net)
Lift Velocity
Vena Contracta Velocity
Inlet Duct Size(s)
Inlet Velocity
Cleaning Frequency
Pulse Pressure
Reverse Airflow and S.P.
Cage Construction (Cage Tol. = +0/-
1/32" dia.; +0/-1/16" L)
Tube Sheet Hole Diameter (Tube
Sheet Tolerance = +/- 1/32" dia.)
Thimble or Cell Plate Dimensions
Time for a Break?