Defining the competitive set
Competition is a necessary evil
How much competition ??????
The key to competition is not whether two
products compete , but the extent to which they
compete.
The degree of competition is a continuum, not a
discrete yes or no.
Defining competition therefore requires a
balance between identifying too many
competitors (and therefore complicating instead
of simplifying decision making) and identifying
too few (and thus overlooking a key competitor
Hypothetical Market Structure
10% 20% 30% 40%
Market Market Market Market
Nichers Follower Challenger Leader
Optimal Market Share
General Attack Strategies
Frontal Attack Flank Attack
Encirclement
Bypass Attack
Attack
Guerrilla Warfare
Industry Concept of Competition
• Number of sellers and degree of
differentiation
• Entry, mobility, and exit barriers
• Cost structure
• Degree of vertical integration
• Degree of globalization
Porter’s 5 force Model OF Industry
Competition
Levels of Market Competition Budget Competition
Generic
Tea competition
Coffee
Regular Colas
Ice
Wine Cream
Diet Pepsi Lemon
Ice Cream Diet Colas
Coke Diet Rite Juices
Vanilla Cola
Coke
Pepsi Blue
Bottled Tea
Water Movies
Beer
Product
Product Form Category
Competition Fast Food competition
Product Form Competition:
The narrowest perspective of competition
Products pursue the same market
segment,having similar features.
Competition comes from only those products that
look the “same” as the product in the question.
Offers a short run approach to understanding
competition.
Product Category Competition
Based on products/services with similar features.
Sets of all TV’s, PC’S
Traditional way to determine competition.
Also known as the industry form of competition.
Form Competition
Focuses on substitutable products .
Those products and services that fulfill the
same customer – need.
It is the customer who decides what
alternative products and services solve the
same problem at hand.
Budget Competition
It is the broadest sense of understanding
competition.
It considers all products and services competing
for the fixed customers disposable income.
Difficult to implement as it implies to enormous
number of competitor.
Competitive Level Task
Product form Convince that brand is better than
others in the product form
Product Category Convince that product form is best
in the category
Generic / Form Convince that product category is
the best way to satisfy needs
Budget Convince that the generic benefits
are the most appropriate way to
spend discretionary income
Strengths and Weaknesses
Share of market
Share of mind
Share of heart
Fake brands in Rural Markets
• Look-alike
• Spell-alike
• Duplicates
Strategic approach to competition
Blue ocean vs.
Create uncontested market.
Make competition irrelevant
Create and capture new market spaces
Red ocean strategy
Compete on existing market.
Beat the demand
Exploit consumer demand
Principles of Blue ocean
There is perpetually no high performing
company.
Companies can be brilliant and wrongheaded
sometimes.
Value innovation is the cornerstone of this
strategy.