MHA 306 (RS)
Business Decision-Making
Characteristics
• Sequential
• Complex - risks & trade-offs
• Personal influence
• Business environment
MHA 306 (RS)
Business Decision-Making
Characteristics
• Creativity
• Imagination
• Foresight
• Understanding of human behaviour
MHA 306 (RS)
Business Decision-Making
Characteristics
Decisions - Solve one problem,
but create others in the long run
MHA 306 (RS)
Decision Quality
• No “Right” or “Wrong” decisions
• Rationality in decision-making
• Different views of a situation
• Outcome bad - decision may still be
rational (a “good” decision)
MHA 306 (RS)
Dimensions of Rationality
• Satisfaction of human interest
• Feasibility of attaining objective
• Consistency
Gross Bertram
MHA 306 (RS)
Types of Rationality
• Objective
• Subjective
• Conscious
• Organizational
Herbert Simon
• Personal
MHA 306 (RS)
Decision Process
Intelligence Problem discovery
• What is the problem?
MIS
Solution discovery
Design • Analyze possible solutions
DSS
Choice Choose best solution
DSS
MIS Implementation
MHA 306 (RS)
Decision-Making Systems
• Closed system - known environment
– Known set of alternatives
– Rule/method for evaluation
– Choice based on a clear objective
– Quantitative techniques
• Open system
MHA 306 (RS)
Classification of Decisions
• Structured / Unstructured / Semi-
structured
• Decision-making under:
– Certainty
– Risk
– Uncertainty
MHA 306 (RS)
Law of Requisite Variety
Efficient Structured Decisions
• All alternatives/choices in each state
• Rules to handle the situation
• Method to generate the choice
MHA 306 (RS)
Selection of Decision Alternatives
• Optimisation Techniques (OR)
• Pay-off Matrix
• Decision Tree analysis
MHA 306 (RS)
Real-World Decisions
Problem areas
• Problem definition
• Information Quality
• Management “Filters”
• Organizational inertia
MHA 306 (RS)
Decision Making: Some Examples
• Decide what product to manufacture
• Tie-up, acquisition or research
• Investments for portfolio management
• Restructuring of organisation
• In-house trg, outsourced or pre-trained
MHA 306 (RS)
The Decision Process
LIST ALL VIABLE ALTERNATIVES
IDENTIFY OUTCOMES
CONSTRUCT A PAY-OFF TABLE
SELECT DECISION CRITERION
MHA 306 (RS)
Key Elements of Decision
• Choices (actions, alternatives)
• States (uncertain elements)
• Outcome
– Payoff: Reward attached to each outcome
• Probability
MHA 306 (RS)
Decision-Making Environment
Certainty No doubt about future
Uncertainty Insufficient knowledge
Risk Probabilities to SON
MHA 306 (RS)
Decision under Uncertainty
Maximin Criterion
• Consider worst possible outcome
• Choose highest of minimum payoffs
• Maximum of Minimum payoffs
MHA 306 (RS)
Example Maximin Criterion
Product Recession Normal Boom
Growth
1 -10 -5 20
2 -15 0 15
3 -7 -1 25
4 -3 2 17
MHA 306 (RS)
Example Maximin Criterion
Product Recession Normal Boom Min
Growth Payoff
1 -10 -5 20 -10
2 -15 0 15 -15
3 -7 -1 25 -7
4 -3 2 17 -3
MHA 306 (RS)
Example Maximin Criterion
Location Rain Dry Min Payoff
Indoor 10,00,000 10,00,000 10,00,000
Outdoor 0 100,00,000 0
MHA 306 (RS)
Decision under Uncertainty
Minimax Criterion
• Minimize the maximum regret
• “Regret” ≡ Difference between optimal
and actual payoff
MHA 306 (RS)
Example Minimax Criterion
Product Recession Normal Boom
Growth
1 -10 7 -5 20
2 -15 12 0 15
3 -7 4 -1 25
4 -3 0 2 17
MHA 306 (RS)
Example Minimax Criterion
Table of “Regrets”
Product Recession Normal Boom Max
Growth Regret
1 7 7 5 7
2 12 2 10 12
3 4 3 0 4
4 0 0 8 8
MHA 306 (RS)
Example Minimax Criterion
Location Rain Dry
Indoor 10,00,000 10,00,000
0
Outdoor 0 100,00,000
10,00,000
MHA 306 (RS)
Example Minimax Criterion
Location Rain Dry Max Regret
Indoor 0 90,00,000 90,00,000
Outdoor 10,00,000 0 10,00,000
MHA 306 (RS)
Decision under Risk
• Probability of each state
• Maximize the Expectation
MHA 306 (RS)
Decision Tree
• Probability of each state
• Maximize the Expectation
MHA 306 (RS)