THE GREEN REVOLUTION
(The Third Agricultural Revolution) And Biotechnology
THOMAS MALTHUS
19th century economist Believed that because population grows geometrically and food production arithmetically famine was inevitable. Slowing the growth of population was the only possibility to prevent starvation
History (so far) has proven Malthus wrong . . .
POPULATION and FOOD PRODUCTION GROWTH Percentage increases 1980-1990
LDCs POPULATION MDCs
FOOD PRODUCTION
PER CAPITA INCREASE IN FOOD PRODUCTION 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45%
INCREASE IN AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION PER CAPITA
GREEN REVOLUTION
A complex of improvements which greatly increased agricultural production Since 1950s Greatest effect felt in LDCs Agricultural output outpaced population growth even without adding additional cropland Adoption of new, improved varieties of grains Application of better agricultural techniques
Irrigation Mechanization Use of fertilizer Use of pesticides
Principal Beneficiaries of the Green Revolution WHEAT
Mexico Egypt Turkey
RICE
Thailand Vietnam Korea Indonesia
BOTH
India China Pakistan
Golden Rice
THE GREAT YELLOW HOPE
In 1982, the Rockefeller Foundation funded research into rice varieties to promote global health Nutritionally enhanced rice
Used a daffodil gene Rice now produces beta-carotene The body converts beta-carotene to vitamin A Blindness in LDCs is caused by vitamin A deficiencies
Time Magazine declares: This rice could save a million kids a year. Greenpeace acknowledged: Golden rice is a moral challenge to our position.
Golden Rice
THE GREAT YELLOW HYPE An 11 year-old child would need to eat 15 pounds of golden rice a day to satisfy the minimum daily requirement of vitamin A Conversion of beta-carotene to vitamin A requires fat and protein in the diet (these are lacking in LDCs) Asians may not want to eat golden rice they prefer white rice over the more nutrient rich brown rice which has always existed Education to push golden rice costs money why not just hand out vitamin A? Golden rice cost more than $100 million to develop it is just a PR stunt for genetically altered foods
Green Revolution benefits
Core exports high-yield miracle seeds
Needed oil-based fertilizers, pesticides Asian rice crop up 66% in 1965-85 Favored areas with good soil, weather
Green Revolution
Green Revolution drawbacks
Favored farmers who could afford seeds, inputs, machines, irrigation Indebted farmers lost land, moved to cities New monocrops lacked resistance to disease/pests Environmental contamination, erosion Oriented to export cash crops, not domestic
Biotechnology: Using organisms to
Make or modify products
Improve plants or animals Develop new microorganisms Crossing natural divides between species
Not just crossbreeding
Genetic Engineering
Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO)
Consumer concerns began in Europe, now in U.S. too
FRANKENFOODS
G ENETICALLY MODIFIED CRO PS - 2000
Others, 9%
Argentina, 23%
USA, 68%
Biotechnology benefits in agriculture
Increase yields
Increase pest resistance Grow crops in new areas
Biotechnology drawbacks in agriculture
High costs (available to few)
Monocrops have less tolerance to disease
Possible health effects Contamination of wild crops (superweeds) Corporate patents on life forms
Bovine Growth Hormone (BGH)
Starlink corn
Cloning
First calf cloned in Wisconsin, 1997.
Many clones die of complications.
Ethical and economic conflicts
San Francisco Farmers Market
Minneapolis airport flower stand