Basic methods to compute NCFs for a project
Example 1: SBF sold a fixed asset with the following information: This fixed asset was purchased few
years ago at a price of 100 million VND; The accumulated depreciation of this asset up to the time of
liquidation was 80 million VND; The liquidation price (excluding VAT) was 25 million VND; The associated
cash expenses (such as repairing, dismantling, transportation costs) were 10 million VND. Requirement:
Calculate the net cash flow that NEU received from the above liquidation using the following methods:
Top-down approach, Bottom-up approach, and Tax shield approach. Assume that: Corporate income tax
rate is 20%. No delayed payment. NEU had other profitable operations that were sufficient to cover any
losses related to the given liquidation.
Top-down
NCF = Liquidation price – associated cash expenses – tax x (liquidation price – associated cash expense –
book value)
= 25 – 10 – 20% x [25 – 10 – (100 – 80)] = 16
Bottom-up
Tax shield
Example 2: NEU Corporation issued bonds worth $120,000,000 ten years ago with 20 years left until
maturity. The bonds make annual payments and have a coupon rate of 12%. The flotation cost of the
bonds ($3,600,000) is amortized over 30 years using the straight-line method. NEU has the right to
repurchase these bonds at a price 10% higher than their face value. The company's CFO is confident that
NEU can issue new bonds worth $120,000,000 with a 20-year maturity and a coupon rate of 10% to
repurchase the current bonds. To ensure sufficient funds for this debt restructuring, the new bonds will
be issued one month before the repurchase of the current bonds. The short-term investments currently
have an average interest rate of 2% per month, and the long-term interest rate is projected to be no
lower than 10% per year. The flotation cost of new bonds is $2,800,000 and will be amortized evenly
over 20 years. The corporate income tax rate is 30%. Should the company accept this debt restructuring
proposal? Why? (Assumption: Both new and current bonds are issued at par value).
NCFi (I = 1….20) = - 10% x 120 mil (new coupon payment) + 10% x 120 mil x 30% (tax savings from new
coupon payments) + 2.8 mil / 20 x 30% (tax savings from the annual amortized flotation costs of new
bonds) + 12% x 120 mil (old coupon payment) – 12% x 120 mil x 30% (tax savings from old coupon
payment) - 3.6 mil / 30 x 30% (tax savings from the annual amortized flotation cost of the old bonds) =
1.686 mil
CF0 = 120 mil - 2.8 mil – 120 mil + 120 mil x 2% x (1 – 30%) – 120 mil x 12% / 12 x ( 1 – 30%) – 120 mil –
10% x 120 mil x (1- 30%) + (3.6 mil – 3.6 mil / 30 x 10%) x 30% = -9.2836 mil
NPV = 10% x ( 1 -30%)