RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Sr. Questions Page

No. No.
SECTION A: (TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT, 1882)
1. ➞ Define Transfer of property as provided in section 5 of Transfer of Property Act. Explain what may be transferred 2
under section 6 of the Transfer of Property Act.
2. ➞Explain the law relating to Transfer of Property to an unborn person as provided in Transfer of Property Act 6
1882?
3. ➞What do you understand by “Lis-Pendens”? Explain its ingredients. 10
➞Explain the principle of Lis-Pendens as provided in Transfer of property Act 1882.
4. ➞Explain the law relating to the transfer by an unauthorized person who subsequently acquires interest in property 14
transferred as provided in sec.43 of TPA.
5. ➞Explain the law relating to Transfer of Property by Ostensible owner as provided in section 41 of Transfer of 18
Property Act.
➞ Explain the term “Ostensible Owner”. Under what law, can an ostensible owner transfer the property? Please
discuss.
➞ Explain the law of transfer of property by ostensible owner. What remedy can the real owner avail of such a
transfer?
6. ➞ Explain the law of part-performance as provided in Transfer of Property Act 1882. 23
➞Explain the principle of "Part—Performance". What are the essentials of this rule?
7. ➞ What is Contract of Sale? What are the rights and duties of Buyer as provided in Transfer of property Act 1882? 27
➞ Explain the rights and duties of seller and buyer.
➞ Define sale? How it is made? Explain the rights and duties of seller.
8. ➞What is Mortgage? Explain its different kinds? 33
➞ How mortgage is made? Explain mortgagee’s right to foreclose and sale.
➞ How many types of mortgages are given in Transfer of Property Act, 1882? Please explain all with examples.
➞ Explain the rights of mortgagee to “sale and foreclose” of the mortgaged property.
➞ Explain the mortgagor’s right to redeem the mortgaged property.
9. ➞What is “contribution to mortgage debt”? Explain. 40
10. ➞What is lease? How it is made? How it is terminated? 42

Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➞ How is Lease made? What are the rights and duties of lessee?
➞ What is Lease? Explain the rights and duties of lessor?
11. ➞Explain the law relating to election as provided in section.35 in Transfer of Property Act. 50
12. ➞Explain the law relating to transfer of property by way of Gift as provided in Transfer of Property Act, 1882. 53
13. ➞Explain the Principle of Subrogation? 56
14. ➞Explain the principle of prohibition on tacking. 60
15. ➞Explain the principle of marshaling securities. 63
16. ➞What is the concept of “Bonafide Purchase” without notice with consideration? Please explain with reference to 66
Section 41 of Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
SECTION B: LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
18. ➞Discuss the procedure of acquisition of land as laid down in the Act? 70
➞What is award as provided in land acquisition act 1894? What steps a land acquisition collector takes before 73
making an award?
➞ What is Award by the Collector and what are the important ingredients which must be mentioned in the Award
of Collector regarding acquisition of land?
➞ What is an Award by the collector? Explain the procedure of making an Award. What is the remedy available to
the aggrieved party against the award?
19. ➞ What are the matters which are neglected by the court in determining compensation? 77
➞ What are the matters which are considered by court in determining compensation?
20. ➞ Explain the difference between a reference to the court made under section 18 and section 30 of the land 81
acquisition act.
➞ What do you mean by Reference to Court under section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894? What are the
grounds relevant to be taken for filing of reference?
➞ What is reference to the court? What is the procedure of filling the reference?
21. ➞ Explain the procedure of acquisition of land in case of urgency as provided in the land acquisition act, 1894. 85
➞ What are the special powers granted in case of urgency as provided under section 17 of the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894?

22. ➞Explain the procedure of acquisition of land for companies as provided in Land Acquisition Act. 89

Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

23. ➞What is market value? How is market value determined? Explain. 92

24. ➞Under what provision of law, objections are heard for the land to be acquired coupled with the fact that the same 96
is being acquired for public purpose
SECTION C: REGISTRATION ACT 1908
25. ➞What are the documents of which Registration is optional? 100
➞ What are the effects of non-registration of documents which require compulsory registration?
➞ Which of the documents are compulsorily registerable? Is there any law for re-registration of certain documents
and documents executed by several persons at different times? Please explain with examples.
➞ What are the documents of which the registration is compulsory?
26. ➞Explain the principles regarding the time from which a registered document shall take effect. 105
➞ What are the law relating to the time and place, regarding the registration of a document?
27. ➞What are the duties and powers of Registering Officers? 109
28. ➞What is the remedy available to the person aggrieved by the orders of sub-registrar? 113
➞ What is the remedy available to the person aggrieved by the order of the registrar?
28. ➞ Explain the law relating to the deposit of Wills under Registration Act, 1908. 121
➞ What is the procedure of registration of Wills, as provided in the Registration Act 1908?
SECTION D: SUCCESSION ACT 1925
29. ➞What do you understand by domicile? How a new domicile be acquired? 125
30. ➞ Discuss the Law relating to will as provided in Succession Act. 128
➞ Explain the procedure of construction of Wills as envisaged under Succession Act, 1925.

31. ➞ What are the contents of the succession certificate? Explain in detail? 131
➞ What are the contents of application for the succession certificate?
32. ➞ What is succession certificate? How it is acquired? Explain. 135
➞ Explain the restrictions on grant of Succession Certificate and describe how it can be revoked?
➞ What are the restrictions on grant of succession certificate? Explain the procedure for grant of succession
certificate and how it is revoked?
33. ➞What do you mean by an executor or administrator of property? Explain his duties as laid down in the act? 139

Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

34. ➞What are the grounds and procedure for the revocation of a Succession Certificate? What is the remedy available 143
to aggrieved person against such Revocation?
35. ➞ What is the procedure provided under the Succession Act, 1925 for the protection of property of the deceased? 150
36. ➞Explain the transfer of property by gift made in contemplation of death under section.191 of Succession Act. 153

Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Page | 1
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Define Transfer of property as provided in section 5 of Transfer of Property Act. Explain what may be transferred under
section 6 of the Transfer of Property Act.

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a comprehensive legislation that regulates the transfer of property in Pakistan. It lays down the
procedures, conditions, and types of property that can be legally transferred from one person to another. The Act defines the term
transfer of property and specifies what can and cannot be transferred under different sections. The objective is to ensure legal clarity
and prevent disputes regarding property transfers.

➠ Definition of Transfer of Property (Section 5):

Section 5 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provides a statutory definition of the term transfer of property as:

A transfer of property means passing the ownership of property from one person to another.

The property can be movable or immovable and the transfer can be made by a living person to:

• Another living person,

• A company,
• An association, or
• A group of people.

The transfer can be done now or in the future, and it can include the entire property or just a part of it.

Explanation of the Definition:

1. Act of Conveyance:
o The term conveyance refers to the act of transferring property from one person to another. This can include sale,
mortgage, lease, exchange, or gift.
o The conveyance can occur either immediately (present interest) or at a future date (future interest).

Page | 2
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

2. Living Person:
o The term living person includes not only natural persons (individuals) but also juridical persons such as companies,
associations, and corporations.
o The inclusion of juridical persons expands the scope of transfer to include corporate entities, partnerships, and
societies.
3. Self and Others:
o A person may transfer property to himself and others jointly, for instance, a transferor can create a joint tenancy with
himself and another person.

4. Types of Property Transferable:

o Property that can be transferred includes both movable and immovable property, tangible and intangible assets,
provided that the property is legally transferable.

➠ Essentials of Transfer of Property under Section 5:

1. Living Person Must be Involved:

o The transferor must be a living person at the time of the transfer. Dead persons cannot transfer property.
o The transferee must also be a living person or a juridical entity capable of holding and receiving property.
2. Property Must Exist:
o The property to be transferred must be in existence at the time of transfer.
o A transfer of property that does not exist at the time of transfer is void.
3. Transfer of Present or Future Interest:
o The Act permits the transfer of both present and future interests. For instance, a person may transfer the present
possession of land or future interest in a reversionary property.
4. Transfer Can be Made to Self and Others:
o A person can transfer property to himself and one or more other persons. For example, a person can create a joint
tenancy in his own name and in the name of another person.

Page | 3
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ What May Be Transferred (Section 6):

Section 6 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, specifies the types of property that can be legally transferred and also enumerates the
exceptions. It states:

“Property of any kind may be transferred, except as otherwise provided by this Act or by any other law for the time being in
force.”

General Rule:

• The general rule under Section 6 is that all kinds of property are transferable, whether movable or immovable, tangible or
intangible, present or future.
• However, there are specific exceptions where the law prohibits the transfer of certain properties.

Detailed Analysis of What May Not Be Transferred:

1. Spes Successionis (Mere Expectancy):

o A mere chance of a person to inherit property in the future cannot be transferred.
o Examples:
▪ A heir apparent’s chance to inherit property upon the death of the ancestor.
▪ The possibility of receiving a legacy under a will before the death of the testator.
o Reason: Such interests are uncertain and speculative, and the law discourages gambling with potential inheritances.

2. Right of Re-entry:
o A mere right of re-entry for breach of a condition subsequent cannot be transferred.
o This right arises in cases where the transferor reserves the right to re-enter and reclaim property upon the occurrence
of a specific event.
o The right of re-entry can only be transferred to the owner of the property.

3. Easements:
o An easement right (e.g., right to pass through another’s land) is not independently transferable.
o It is considered an incorporeal right and can only be transferred with the dominant tenement (the property benefiting
from the easement).

Page | 4
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

4. Interest Restricted in its Enjoyment:

o Any interest in property that is limited to personal use and enjoyment cannot be transferred.
o Example: Life interest given to a widow for her lifetime.

5. Right to Future Maintenance:

o The right to future maintenance is a personal right and is not transferable.
o It is regarded as a moral and personal obligation that cannot be alienated or assigned.

6. Mere Right to Sue:

o A mere right to sue is not a transferable right.
o This includes rights to bring a legal action for damages or compensation.
o Example: A right to sue for breach of contract or tortious claims cannot be transferred to another person.

7. Public Office:
o The right to a public office or any salary or benefits attached to it is non-transferable.
o Such rights are considered to be of a public nature and not personal property.

8. Pension:
o A pension or stipend granted in consideration of past services or as a compassionate allowance cannot be transferred.
o The law protects such rights to ensure the financial security of the grantee.

9. Transfer Opposed to Public Policy:

o Any transfer that is against public policy, illegal, or immoral is not permitted.
o Examples:
▪ Transfer of property to conduct illegal trade or business.
▪ Transfer of property for purposes that are immoral or unlawful.

Conclusion:

Section 5 and Section 6 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, play a vital role in defining the scope and limitations of property transfers
in Pakistan. Section 5 lays down the fundamental principles for a valid transfer, focusing on the conveyance of property by a living
person, either in present or future. Section 6 further elaborates on the types of property that can and cannot be transferred, ensuring that
the rights of both transferor and transferee are protected and that public policy is not violated.

Page | 5
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the law relating to Transfer of Property to an unborn person as provided in Transfer of Property Act 1882?

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a fundamental legal framework that regulates the transfer of property in Pakistan. It defines the
methods, conditions, and restrictions on property transfers to ensure legality and prevent disputes. One of the important aspects covered
by the Act is the transfer of property to an unborn person, which is provided under Section 13 and 14 of the Act. These sections
establish the rules and limitations for transferring property to a person who does not yet exist at the time of the transfer.

➠ Transfer of Property to Unborn Person (Section 13):

Section 13 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 deals with the transfer of property to an unborn person. It states:

“If a property is given to one person with instructions that after that person, it will go to an unborn person (a person not yet
born), the transfer is considered valid only if the unborn person gets the entire interest in the property.”

• This means that the first person will enjoy the property only during their lifetime, and once they pass away, the entire
interest in the property will go to the unborn person.
• The unborn person will receive the property as a full owner, not just a limited share or interest.
• However, the transfer to the unborn person will only be valid if that person is born and can accept the property as a
complete owner.

Explanation of Section 13:

1. Meaning of Unborn Person:

o An unborn person refers to a person who is not in existence at the time of the transfer but is expected to be born in the
future.
o The law does not permit the transfer of property directly to an unborn person, as a non-existent person cannot hold property
or enter into a contract.

2. Creation of Prior Interest:

o To transfer property to an unborn person, a prior interest must first be created in favor of a living person.

Page | 6
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o This prior interest serves as a life estate or temporary interest, which is held by a living person until the unborn person
comes into existence.

Example:

• A property owner transfers property to his wife for her lifetime, and then to his unborn grandson.
• Here, the wife holds a life interest until the grandson is born and attains a vested interest.

3. Absolute Transfer of Remaining Interest:

o When the unborn person comes into existence, he must receive the entire remaining interest in the property.
o The interest given to the unborn person must not be a partial interest. It must be an absolute and full interest in the
property.

Example:

• If A transfers property to B for life, and after B’s death, the property is to vest in A’s unborn grandson C, C must receive the
entire interest in the property after B’s death.

4. No Direct Transfer to Unborn Person:

o The law prohibits a direct transfer to an unborn person.
o The property must first be vested in a living person who holds the interest until the unborn person comes into existence.

5. Time of Vesting:
o The unborn person will receive the property only if he is born during the lifetime of the prior interest holder or within
the period specified by the transferor.
o If the unborn person does not come into existence within this period, the transfer fails, and the property reverts to the
transferor or his heirs.

➠ Restrictions under Rule Against Perpetuity (Section 14):

Section 14 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 imposes a restriction on the transfer of property to an unborn person under the
rule against perpetuity. It states:

Page | 7
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

“This section says that property cannot be tied up or restricted for an indefinite period.”

If a person transfers a property but puts conditions that it cannot be fully enjoyed or owned by anyone for an extremely long time
(beyond a set legal limit), such conditions are considered invalid.

In simple terms, you cannot make a property transfer in such a way that it keeps passing on indefinitely without anyone truly
owning or using it. The law wants to prevent situations where the property is locked up for generations without being freely available
for use or transfer.

The maximum time limit for such restrictions is generally the lifetime of a living person at the time of the transfer plus 18 years.
Any condition that tries to go beyond this limit is not legally valid.

Explanation of Section 14:

1. Rule Against Perpetuity:
o The rule aims to prevent property from being tied up indefinitely in trusts or other arrangements.
o The interest must vest within the lifetime of a living person and the minority of the unborn person.
2. Maximum Duration:
o The interest must vest within a period of:
▪ The lifetime of the existing person(s), and
▪ A further period of 18 years (minority period) after the death of the last living person.
Example: If A transfers property to B for life and then to B’s unborn child, the child must be born within B’s lifetime and must attain
the age of majority (18 years) within the period allowed.
3. Consequences of Violation:
o If the interest is created to vest beyond the permissible period, the transfer is declared void.
o The property will then revert to the transferor or his legal heirs.
Important Points to Consider:
• Complete Interest Only: The unborn person must receive the entire interest in the property without any restrictions.
• Life Interest First: A life interest or limited interest must first be created in favor of a living person.
• Conditional Transfer: The transfer to the unborn person is always conditional upon his birth and surviving the prior interest
holder.

Page | 8
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• Limitation Period: The interest must vest within the lifetime of the living person(s) and the minority period of the unborn
person.
Conclusion:
Sections 13 and 14 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provide comprehensive guidelines for the transfer of property to an unborn
person. The law establishes that the transfer must first create a life interest in a living person, and only upon the birth of the unborn
person can the remaining interest be vested absolutely. Additionally, the rule against perpetuity under Section 14 ensures that property
is not indefinitely tied up and that the interest in the property must vest within a specified period. This legal framework serves to protect
the rights of both living and unborn persons while preventing speculative or uncertain transfers of property.

Page | 9
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What do you understand by “Lis-Pendens”? Explain its ingredients.

Q: Explain the principle of Lis-Pendens as provided in Transfer of property Act 1882.

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a comprehensive law that governs the transfer of property in Pakistan. It provides detailed rules
for transferring movable and immovable property and defines the rights and obligations of the parties involved. One of the significant
doctrines under the Act is the principle of Lis Pendens, which is addressed in Section 52. The term Lis Pendens means a pending legal
action and ensures that property involved in a legal dispute cannot be transferred to third parties, preventing fraudulent or unjust transfers
during litigation.

➠ Meaning and Definition of Lis Pendens (Section 52):

Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 deals with the doctrine of Lis Pendens. It states:

“When a legal case relating to any property is ongoing in a court of law, the property cannot be transferred or dealt with by any
party to the case in a way that affects the rights of the other party.”

• This rule applies from the time the case is filed until it is finally decided, including any appeal period.
• Any transfer or dealing with the property during this time will not affect the rights of the other party in the case, even
if the transfer is made in good faith or for valuable consideration.

This principle is called Lis Pendens, which means “a pending lawsuit,” and it is intended to prevent the rights of the parties in a legal
dispute from being defeated or disturbed by transferring the property while the case is ongoing.

Explanation of the Principle of Lis Pendens:

The term Lis Pendens is derived from the Latin words Lis, meaning suit or dispute, and Pendens, meaning pending. Thus, Lis Pendens
refers to a pending legal action involving property rights.

• The principle of Lis Pendens is based on the maxim: “Pending litigation, nothing new should be introduced”.

Page | 10
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• The objective of this doctrine is to maintain the status quo of the property during litigation, ensuring that the rights of the
parties involved are not defeated by any alienation or transfer of the disputed property.
• The doctrine prevents the transfer of property that is the subject of a dispute, thereby ensuring that the court's final decree or
order is effectively enforced.

➠ Essentials/Ingredients of Lis Pendens:

For the application of the principle of Lis Pendens, the following essential elements must be present:

1. Existence of a Pending Suit or Proceeding:

o There must be a pending legal action in a court of competent jurisdiction involving rights to immovable property.
o The suit or proceeding must be ongoing at the time of the transfer of the property.
o The litigation must not be collusive or fraudulent.
2. Competent Jurisdiction:
o The suit must be filed in a court of competent jurisdiction that has the legal authority to adjudicate the matter.
3. Property Must be Immovable:
o The property involved must be immovable property, such as land, buildings, or other real estate.
o The principle of Lis Pendens does not apply to movable property.
4. Property Must be Directly and Specifically in Question:
o The subject matter of the suit must specifically involve rights to the immovable property in question.
o The dispute must be about title, possession, or interest in the property.
5. Transfer Must be Made by a Party to the Suit:
o The transfer of property must be made by a party to the suit or proceeding.
o The principle applies only to parties involved in the litigation and not to third parties who are not connected to the dispute.
6. Effect of Transfer on Decree or Order:
o The transfer of property must be of such a nature that it would affect the rights of the parties under the decree or
order of the court.
o The transfer must be made in a way that may prejudice or defeat the rights of other parties under the final judgment.
7. Transfer Without Court’s Permission:
o The transfer is void under the doctrine of Lis Pendens unless it is made with the permission of the court.
o The court may impose conditions or restrictions on the transfer.

Page | 11
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Illustration of Lis Pendens:

• A files a suit against B for the recovery of a specific immovable property.

• During the pendency of the suit, B sells the property to C.
• According to the doctrine of Lis Pendens, the sale by B to C is subject to the outcome of the pending suit.
• If the court decrees that A is the rightful owner of the property, C’s purchase is void, and the property will be restored to A.

➠ Effect of Lis Pendens:

1. Preventing Transfer of Property:

o The doctrine of Lis Pendens restricts the transfer or alienation of the property in dispute.
2. Binding on the Transferee:
o Any transfer made during the pendency of the suit is subject to the court’s decree.
o The transferee is bound by the outcome of the litigation, irrespective of whether they had prior notice of the dispute.
3. Protection of Decree Holder’s Rights:
o The principle protects the rights of the decree holder by preventing the defendant from transferring the property to a
third party and defeating the court’s order.
4. Maintaining Status Quo:
o Lis Pendens ensures that the status quo of the property is maintained during the litigation, preventing the creation of
new rights or interests in the disputed property.

➠ Exceptions to the Doctrine of Lis Pendens:

The doctrine of Lis Pendens does not apply in the following cases:

1. Transfer by a Stranger:
o If the transfer is made by a person who is not a party to the suit, the doctrine does not apply.
2. Transfer Made With Court’s Permission:
o If the court permits the transfer during the pendency of the suit, it will not be affected by Lis Pendens.
3. Movable Property:
o The doctrine only applies to immovable property and not to movable assets.
4. Fraudulent or Collusive Suits:
o If the suit is filed collusively or fraudulently to prevent a genuine transfer, the doctrine will not apply.

Page | 12
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Judicial Interpretations and Case Laws:

1. Ghulam Rasool v. Muhammad Riaz (PLD 2019 SC 174):

o The Supreme Court of Pakistan held that the principle of Lis Pendens prevents the transfer of disputed property during
litigation to preserve the rights of the decree holder.
2. Mst. Fazal Begum v. Muhammad Ashraf (PLD 2018 Lahore 217):
o The Lahore High Court emphasized that the doctrine of Lis Pendens applies to all subsequent transferees, irrespective
of whether they had knowledge of the pending suit.

➠Conclusion:

The doctrine of Lis Pendens as provided under Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a fundamental principle aimed at
preserving the integrity of court proceedings involving immovable property. It ensures that no party can defeat the court’s
judgment by transferring the disputed property during litigation. The principle maintains the status quo of the property and protects
the rights of the decree holder, ensuring that the court’s decision is effectively enforced. By laying down specific requirements and
exceptions, the doctrine of Lis Pendens serves as a powerful tool to prevent fraudulent or collusive transfers of property during
pending legal actions.

Page | 13
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the law relating to the transfer by an unauthorized person who subsequently acquires interest in property transferred
as provided in sec.43 of TPA.

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a key legal framework that governs the transfer of property in Pakistan. It sets forth the rules
regarding the transfer of property, including circumstances where a person without proper authority or title transfers property and
subsequently acquires interest in the same property. This concept is covered under Section 43 of the Transfer of Property Act,
1882, known as the Doctrine of Feeding the Grant by Estoppel.

Section 43 addresses the situation where a person fraudulently or erroneously represents that he is authorized to transfer property,
which he does not own at the time of transfer but later acquires. In such cases, the law provides protection to the transferee under certain
conditions.

➠ Transfer by Unauthorized Person Who Subsequently Acquires Interest (Section 43):

Section 43 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 states:

“If a person fraudulently or mistakenly transfers property that they do not own but later acquires ownership of that property,
the person to whom the property was transferred can choose to:

• Claim the property as if the transferor had the right to transfer it at the time of the original transfer, or
• Cancel the transfer and demand a refund or compensation.”

This applies only if the transferee acted in good faith and paid consideration (money or value) for the property.

Explanation of the Provision:

This section is based on the principle of Feeding the Grant by Estoppel, which means that a transferor who fraudulently or mistakenly
claims ownership of a property and subsequently acquires an interest in that property must feed the transfer made earlier by
transferring the acquired interest to the transferee.

Page | 14
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Essentials or Ingredients of Section 43:

1. Fraudulent or Erroneous Representation:

• The transferor must fraudulently or mistakenly claim that he has the authority to transfer a specific property.
• The representation may be intentional (fraudulent) or unintentional (erroneous).
• Example: A, who is not the owner of a house, falsely claims to own it and sells it to B. Later, A inherits the house from his father.

2. Transfer of Immovable Property:

• The section applies only to the transfer of immovable property, such as land, buildings, or interests in land.
• Movable property is not covered under Section 43.

3. Transfer for Consideration:

• The transfer must be made for valuable consideration, meaning that the transferee must have paid money or provided some
form of compensation for the property.
• If the transfer is made as a gift or without consideration, the doctrine under Section 43 does not apply.

4. Subsequent Acquisition of Interest:

• After the initial transfer, the transferor must subsequently acquire interest in the property.
• This acquisition could be through inheritance, purchase, gift, or any other lawful means.
• Example: If A sells property to B without owning it, and later A acquires the property through inheritance, A is bound to transfer
the acquired interest to B.

5. Option of the Transferee:

• The doctrine under Section 43 operates only at the option of the transferee.
• The transferee can choose to enforce the transfer or rescind the contract.
• If the transferee opts to enforce the transfer, the transferor must fulfill his promise and transfer the acquired interest to the
transferee.

Page | 15
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

6. Contract Must be Subsisting:

• The contract must be valid and subsisting at the time the transferor acquires the interest.
• If the contract is rescinded or terminated, the transferee cannot enforce the transfer under Section 43.

➠ Operation of the Doctrine:

1. Initial Transfer Without Title:

o The transferor falsely claims to have the title and executes a sale deed in favor of the transferee.
2. Subsequent Acquisition of Interest:
o The transferor later acquires valid title to the property through inheritance, purchase, or any other lawful means.
3. Option to the Transferee:
o The transferee, at his discretion, can either:
▪ Enforce the transfer, compelling the transferor to transfer the subsequently acquired interest, or
▪ Rescind the contract, recovering any consideration paid.

➠ Illustration:

• A falsely represents that he is the owner of a piece of land and sells it to B for Rs. 500,000.
• At the time of the sale, A does not own the property.
• Later, A inherits the property from his deceased father.
• Under Section 43, B has the option to enforce the sale and compel A to transfer the acquired interest to B.

➠ Exceptions to Section 43:

The doctrine under Section 43 does not apply in the following cases:

1. Transfer Without Consideration:

o If the transfer is a gift or without valuable consideration, the transferee cannot enforce the transfer.
2. Third-Party Rights:
o If the property has been acquired by a bona fide purchaser for value without notice of the prior transfer, the
transferee under Section 43 cannot enforce the contract.

Page | 16
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

3. Collusive Transfers:
o If the transfer was made to defraud creditors or third parties, the transferee cannot claim the benefit of Section 43.

➠ Effect of Section 43:

• The doctrine under Section 43 provides protection to the transferee, enabling him to claim the property upon subsequent
acquisition by the transferor.
• The transferor is estopped from denying the validity of the transfer, as he had originally represented that he was authorized
to transfer the property.
• The doctrine prevents fraud and unjust enrichment, ensuring that a transferor does not escape liability after acquiring the
interest.

➠ Case Law Illustration:

• In the case of Ghulam Haider v. Ghulam Nabi (PLD 1996 SC 345), the Supreme Court held that the doctrine under Section
43 applies only when the transferor acquires interest in the same property that he had previously transferred without title.
• The court emphasized that the transferee is entitled to enforce the transfer upon the subsequent acquisition of interest,
provided the original contract remains subsisting and valid.

Conclusion:

Section 43 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, is a protective provision that ensures that a transferee is not deprived of his right
when the transferor fraudulently or erroneously claims ownership of property and later acquires the interest in the same property.
This doctrine of Feeding the Grant by Estoppel protects the rights of the transferee, allowing him to enforce the transfer upon the
subsequent acquisition of interest by the transferor. It prevents fraudulent representations and ensures that the transferor is held
accountable for his false representations, thereby upholding justice and equity in property transactions.

Page | 17
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the law relating to Transfer of Property by Ostensible owner as provided in section 41 of Transfer of Property Act.
Q: Explain the term “Ostensible Owner”. Under what law, can an ostensible owner transfer the property? Please discuss.
Q: Explain the law of transfer of property by ostensible owner. What remedy can the real owner avail of such a transfer?

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 governs the rules and regulations related to the transfer of property in Pakistan. One important
concept under the Act is the transfer of property by an ostensible owner as provided in Section 41. The term “ostensible owner” refers
to a person who appears to be the real owner of a property but is not the actual owner. This provision protects bona fide transferees
who have acted in good faith and without knowledge of the true ownership of the property.

➠ Definition of Ostensible Owner:

An ostensible owner is a person who is not the true owner but appears to be the owner and is allowed by the real owner to act as
the owner. The true owner, either by his conduct or express consent, allows the ostensible owner to deal with the property as if he
were the real owner.

Example of Ostensible Owner:

• A is the actual owner of a property but allows B to possess the property and represent himself as the owner.
• B, as the ostensible owner, sells the property to C, a bona fide purchaser for value without notice of A’s ownership.
• C is protected under Section 41, provided the transfer was made with the consent or conduct of A.

➠ Transfer by Ostensible Owner (Section 41):

Section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 states:

“If a person (the “ostensible owner”) sells or transfers property to another person, claiming to be the owner, but in reality, the
ostensible owner does not have full ownership rights, the buyer (transferee) will still get good title to the property if:

• The buyer believes the seller is the true owner of the property.
• The buyer buys the property in good faith and without knowing that the seller is not the true owner.

Page | 18
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• The buyer pays money or valuable consideration for the property.

The real owner of the property cannot claim the property back from the buyer just because the buyer bought it from someone who
wasn’t the full owner, as long as the buyer didn’t know this.”

Explanation of Section 41:

Section 41 provides that if a person appears to be the owner of a property with the consent of the real owner and transfers it for
consideration, the transfer will be valid and binding on he real owner, provided the transferee has acted in good faith and with due
diligence.

➠ Essentials or Ingredients of Section 41:

1. Ostensible Ownership:

• The person making the transfer must be the ostensible owner, i.e., someone who appears to be the owner but is not the actual
owner.
• The true owner must have permitted or allowed the ostensible owner to hold himself out as the owner.
• The ostensible ownership may arise through:
o Express consent (direct permission), or
o Implied consent (conduct or behavior).

2. Transfer for Consideration:

• The transfer by the ostensible owner must be made for valuable consideration.
• If the transfer is made without consideration (e.g., a gift), the doctrine under Section 41 does not apply.

3. Consent of Real Owner:

• The transfer must be made with the consent, express or implied, of the real owner.
• If the real owner has not consented to the transfer or the transfer was made without his knowledge, the transfer cannot be
enforced under Section 41.

Page | 19
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

4. Reasonable Care and Good Faith:

• The transferee must have exercised reasonable care in ascertaining the authority of the ostensible owner to transfer the property.
• The transferee must have acted in good faith, without notice of the true ownership or any adverse claim.
• If the transferee fails to exercise reasonable care, he cannot claim protection under Section 41.

5. No Voidable Transfer:

• If all the above conditions are met, the transfer by the ostensible owner cannot be challenged by the real owner on the ground
that the ostensible owner lacked authority to transfer the property.

➠ Example of Section 41:

• A is the real owner of a property but allows his brother B to live in the house and represent himself as the owner.
• B sells the property to C, a bona fide purchaser who paid full consideration and acted in good faith.
• Since A allowed B to appear as the owner, C’s purchase is protected under Section 41, and A cannot claim the property back
from C.

➠ Law Relating to Ostensible Owner:

The concept of ostensible ownership is also recognized under the principle of estoppel, as provided in the Contract Act, 1872.
According to Section 115 of the Contract Act, when a person intentionally induces another to believe in a particular state of affairs
and act upon such belief, he cannot later deny the existence of such state of affairs.

Therefore, under Section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act and Section 115 of the Contract Act, the real owner is estopped from
denying the validity of the transfer if he has allowed the ostensible owner to appear as the true owner.

➠ Remedy Available to the Real Owner:

The real owner, in case of a transfer by the ostensible owner, has limited remedies:

Page | 20
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

1. Claim for Compensation:

o The real owner may claim compensation from the ostensible owner if he has suffered any loss due to the fraudulent
transfer.
2. Recovery of Consideration:
o If the ostensible owner has received consideration for the transfer, the real owner can claim the amount of consideration
from the ostensible owner.
3. No Claim Against Bona Fide Transferee:
o If the transfer was made for consideration, in good faith, and without notice of the true ownership, the real owner
cannot reclaim the property from the transferee.
4. Claim of Fraud or Misrepresentation:
o If the ostensible owner obtained consent by fraud or misrepresentation, the real owner may file a suit for recovery of
possession or damages.

➠ Exceptions to Section 41:

There are certain exceptions to the applicability of Section 41:

1. Transfer Without Consideration:

o If the transfer is a gift or gratuitous transfer, the transferee cannot claim protection under Section 41.
2. Absence of Consent:
o If the real owner has not given express or implied consent, the transfer will not be binding on him.
3. No Good Faith or Reasonable Care:
o If the transferee has not acted in good faith or failed to exercise reasonable care, he cannot claim protection under
Section 41.

➠ Case Law Illustration:

In Muhammad Bashir v. Fazal Karim (PLD 1997 SC 256), the court held that if the real owner voluntarily permits the ostensible
owner to act as the owner, he cannot later challenge the transfer made to a bona fide purchaser who has paid consideration and acted
in good faith.

Page | 21
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Conclusion:

Section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, provides a safeguard to bona fide purchasers who have acted in good faith and paid
consideration while dealing with an ostensible owner. If the real owner, by his express or implied conduct, permits another person to
represent himself as the owner, he cannot later deny the validity of the transfer. The doctrine protects the transferee while ensuring
that the real owner is estopped from claiming the property, provided the transferee has acted in good faith and without notice of
the true ownership.

Page | 22
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the law of part-performance as provided in Transfer of Property Act 1882.

Q: Explain the principle of "Part—Performance". What are the essentials of this rule?

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 governs the transfer of immovable property in Pakistan. One of the significant doctrines under the
Act is the principle of Part-Performance, provided under Section 53-A. This principle was introduced to protect the rights of a
transferee who has taken possession of a property under a contract that is not yet formally executed but is substantially performed by
the transferee.

The doctrine of Part-Performance prevents the transferor from denying the validity of the contract and the transferee’s possession of
the property. It is a protective shield for the transferee, ensuring that they are not unfairly deprived of the property for which they have
already performed substantial obligations under the contract.

➠ Principle of Part-Performance (Section 53-A):

Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 states:

When a person makes a written agreement to transfer property for some payment (consideration) and the buyer has either
taken possession of the property or is already in possession and continues to stay in possession as part of the agreement, and the
buyer has done some act related to the agreement and is ready and willing to complete their part of the agreement, then:

• Even if the agreement is not properly registered or the transfer deed is not completed as required by law, the seller or
anyone claiming under the seller cannot deny the transfer or take back possession of the property against the buyer.
• However, this protection does not apply if a third person has bought the property for value without knowing about the
agreement or part performance.

Explanation of the Principle of Part-Performance:

The doctrine of Part-Performance operates as a shield, not as a sword. This means that the transferee can use it as a defense to protect
their possession but cannot use it to enforce the transfer in the absence of a registered deed.

Page | 23
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

The doctrine is based on the principle of equity and fairness, preventing the transferor from denying the contract once the transferee
has already performed or has substantially performed the agreed obligations.

➠ Essentials or Ingredients of Part-Performance (Section 53-A):

To invoke the doctrine of Part-Performance, the following essential elements must be present:

1. Existence of a Written Contract:

• There must be a written contract of transfer that is signed by the transferor or by someone on his behalf.
• The contract must contain clear and definite terms from which the transfer can be reasonably ascertained.
• Oral agreements are not sufficient to invoke the doctrine of Part-Performance.

2. Transfer of Immovable Property for Consideration:

• The contract must be for the transfer of immovable property, such as land, houses, or any interest in immovable property.
• The contract must also be for valuable consideration, meaning that the transferee must have paid or promised to pay a certain
amount for the property.

3. Possession in Part-Performance of the Contract:

• The transferee must have taken possession of the property or a part of it in pursuance of the contract, or if the transferee is
already in possession, they must have continued to possess it in furtherance of the contract.
• The possession must be unequivocally referable to the contract, meaning it must be clear that the possession is pursuant to the
contract and not for any other reason.

4. Acts Done in Furtherance of the Contract:

• The transferee must have performed or undertaken to perform some acts in furtherance of the contract.
• Such acts may include:
o Payment of purchase money, either in full or in part.
o Making improvements or constructions on the property.
o Settling disputes or debts as agreed in the contract.

Page | 24
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

5. Willingness to Perform the Remaining Obligations:

• The transferee must be ready and willing to perform his part of the contract.
• If the transferee refuses to perform their obligations, they cannot claim protection under the doctrine of Part-Performance.

➠ Effect of the Doctrine of Part-Performance:

• The doctrine of Part-Performance provides a defensive remedy, meaning the transferee can defend their possession against
the transferor who tries to reclaim the property.
• However, it does not confer a title to the transferee.
• The transferee can only use this doctrine as a shield, not as a sword, meaning they cannot compel the transferor to complete
the transfer if the deed is not registered.

➠ Illustration:

• A agrees to sell his house to B for Rs. 1,000,000. A written contract is signed, and B takes possession of the house and pays Rs.
800,000 as part payment.
• Later, A refuses to complete the transfer, claiming that the deed is not registered.
• Under Section 53-A, B can defend his possession by proving that he has taken possession in furtherance of the contract and is
willing to complete the payment as per the agreement.
• A will be debarred from asserting any right to evict B, except for those rights specifically provided in the contract.

➠ Exceptions to the Doctrine of Part-Performance:

1. No Written Agreement:
o If the agreement is oral, the doctrine of Part-Performance does not apply.
2. Transferor Not the Real Owner:
o If the person transferring the property is not the actual owner, the doctrine cannot be invoked against the real owner.
3. Acts Not Referable to the Contract:
o If the acts done by the transferee are not clearly referable to the contract, they cannot claim protection under Section
53-A.

Page | 25
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Remedy for the Real Owner:

The real owner can take the following remedies if the doctrine of Part-Performance is invoked:

1. File a Suit for Recovery of Remaining Consideration:

o If the transferee is in possession but has not paid the full consideration, the real owner can file a suit to recover the
unpaid amount.
2. Specific Performance of Contract:
o The real owner can file a suit for specific performance of the contract, compelling the transferee to fulfill the agreed
obligations.
3. Eviction of the Transferee:
o If the transferee refuses to perform his part of the contract or fails to meet the conditions, the real owner can file a suit
for eviction and possession of the property.

➠ Case Law Illustration:

In the case of Muhammad Siddiq v. Muhammad Rafique (PLD 1984 SC 120), the Supreme Court of Pakistan held that the doctrine
of Part-Performance can only be invoked if the transferee has acted in furtherance of the contract and is willing to perform the remaining
obligations. Mere possession without fulfilling other obligations does not entitle the transferee to claim protection under Section 53-
A.

Conclusion:

The doctrine of Part-Performance under Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a protective provision for transferees
who have acted in furtherance of a written contract of transfer, taken possession, and performed or are willing to perform their part of
the agreement. The doctrine acts as a defensive shield, preventing the transferor from asserting ownership rights against the transferee.
However, it does not confer a title, nor can it be used as a sword to enforce the transfer. It seeks to prevent fraud and injustice, ensuring
that the transferee’s rights are safeguarded in property transactions.

Page | 26
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is Contract of Sale? What are the rights and duties of Buyer as provided in Transfer of property Act 1882?
Q: Explain the rights and duties of seller and buyer.
Q: Define sale? How it is made? Explain the rights and duties of seller.

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provides the framework for the transfer of property rights in Pakistan. One of the important
modes of transfer under the Act is the contract of sale, which is specifically dealt with under Sections 54 to 57. A sale is a transaction
where the ownership of immovable property is transferred from one person to another in exchange for a price paid or promised. It
is a complete transfer of rights and interests in the property.

➠ Definition of Sale (Section 54):

According to Section 54, a sale is defined as:
“A sale is a transfer of ownership in exchange for a price paid or promised or part paid and part promised.”
In simple and easy wording:
• A sale is when the ownership of property is transferred from one person (seller) to another person (buyer) in exchange for
money.
• The price can be paid in full, promised to be paid later, or can be partly paid and partly promised.
➠ How a Sale is Made (Section 54):
A sale can be made in the following ways:
1. Transfer of Tangible Immovable Property:
o If the property is worth Rs. 100 or more, the sale must be made through a registered instrument (sale deed).
o If the property is worth less than Rs. 100, the sale can be made through delivery of possession or by a registered
document.

2. Transfer of Intangible Property:

o In the case of intangible property (such as rights or interests), the transfer must be made by a written and registered
document.
3. Delivery of Possession:
o Delivery of possession means the physical handing over of the property to the buyer.

Page | 27
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o It can be actual or symbolic, depending on the nature of the property.

➠ Contract for Sale (Agreement to Sell):

• An agreement to sell is a contract where the seller agrees to transfer the property to the buyer at a future date or upon
the fulfillment of certain conditions.
• It does not transfer ownership immediately, but it creates a right to obtain ownership in the future.
• The buyer can enforce the agreement in court if the seller refuses to complete the sale.

➠ Rights and Duties of the Seller and Buyer (Section 55):

Rights and Duties of Seller:

The seller of immovable property has both duties to perform and rights to claim under the contract of sale.

Duties of Seller:

1. Duty to Disclose Material Defects (Section 55(1)(a)):

o The seller is bound to disclose to the buyer any material defects in the property that:
▪ The buyer cannot discover with ordinary care.
▪ The seller is aware of but the buyer is not.
o This duty includes disclosing:
▪ Hidden structural issues, such as a damaged foundation.
▪ Legal defects, like encumbrances, unpaid taxes, or pending litigation.
o Example: If a house has a severe water leakage problem, and the seller knows about it, he must disclose it to the buyer.

2. Duty to Provide Title Deeds (Section 55(1)(b)):

o The seller must produce all title documents for the buyer’s inspection:
▪ Original sale deed, mortgage deeds, lease agreements, etc.
o The buyer has the right to inspect these documents to verify the authenticity and validity of the seller’s title.

3. Duty to Answer Questions (Section 55(1)(c)):

o The seller is obliged to answer all relevant questions about the property and its title.

Page | 28
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o The seller must provide accurate information regarding:

▪ Ownership, encumbrances, existing disputes, etc.
o Example: If the buyer inquires about pending litigation, the seller must disclose any ongoing court cases affecting the
property.

4. Duty to Execute Sale Deed (Section 55(1)(d)):

o After receiving the full purchase price, the seller must execute a sale deed in favor of the buyer.
o The deed must be signed, stamped, and registered as per the Registration Act, 1908.
o This transfer of title must be done in the presence of witnesses and in accordance with the law.

5. Duty to Handover Possession (Section 55(1)(f)):

o The seller is responsible for delivering possession of the property to the buyer upon completion of the sale.
o This includes handing over:
▪ Keys, title deeds, and all associated documents.
o The seller must ensure the property is vacant and free of any encumbrances at the time of transfer.

6. Duty to Pay Outgoings (Section 55(1)(g)):

o The seller must pay all taxes, rents, and other charges due on the property up to the date of sale.
o These include:
▪ Property tax, utility bills, and any outstanding mortgages.

Rights of Seller:

1. Right to Payment of Sale Price (Section 55(4)(a)):

o The seller is entitled to receive the entire sale price as agreed in the sale contract.
o Until the full payment is made, the seller can retain possession of the property.

2. Right to Lien (Section 55(4)(b)):

o If the full purchase price is not paid, the seller has a lien on the property for the unpaid amount.
o The seller can retain possession or seek legal remedies to recover the unpaid amount.

Page | 29
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Rights and Duties of Buyer:

The buyer also has specific rights and duties under Section 55.

Duties of Buyer:

1. Duty to Disclose Facts (Section 55(5)(a)):

o The buyer must disclose any facts that may increase the seller’s interest in the property.
o If the buyer knows of any defect in the seller’s title or any legal issue, he must inform the seller.
o Example: If the buyer is aware that the property will soon be acquired by the government, he must inform the seller.

2. Duty to Pay Purchase Price (Section 55(5)(b)):

o The buyer must pay the entire purchase price as agreed in the contract.
o Payment must be made at the time and place specified in the contract or as per the terms agreed upon.

3. Duty to Accept Delivery (Section 55(5)(c)):

o The buyer must accept possession of the property after paying the price.
o The buyer must take over the property without causing unnecessary delay.

4. Duty to Bear Expenses of Transfer (Section 55(5)(d)):

o The buyer must bear the costs of:
▪ Stamp duty, registration fees, and any other transfer charges.
o If the contract states otherwise, the buyer and seller can mutually agree on cost distribution.

Rights of Buyer:

1. Right to Delivery of Title Deeds (Section 55(6)(a)):

o The buyer is entitled to receive all original title deeds and documents related to the property.
o The seller must handover these documents after receiving the full payment.

2. Right to Possession (Section 55(6)(b)):

o The buyer has the right to take possession of the property upon payment of the full purchase price.
o If the seller refuses to hand over possession, the buyer can initiate legal proceedings.

Page | 30
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

3. Right to Benefits of Property (Section 55(6)(c)):

o From the date of sale, the buyer is entitled to all benefits and profits arising from the property.
o This includes:
▪ Rent, crops, and any other income generated from the property.

4. Right to Sue for Specific Performance:

o If the seller fails to execute the sale deed or refuses to transfer possession, the buyer can file a suit for specific
performance under the Specific Relief Act, 1877.
o This allows the buyer to enforce the contract and obtain possession as per the agreement.

➠ Case Law Example:

In the case of Abdul Ghafoor vs. Muhammad Iqbal (2020 CLC 543), the court held that the seller’s right to lien continues until the
full payment of the purchase price is made. However, the buyer also has the right to demand possession upon making full payment
as per the contract.

➠ Comparison Between Sale and Agreement to Sell:

Sale Agreement to Sell

Transfer of ownership is immediate. Transfer of ownership is to be done in the future.
Buyer becomes the absolute owner of the property. Buyer gets only a right to obtain the property in the future.
Risk of property passes to the buyer immediately. Risk remains with the seller until the actual sale.
Remedy: The buyer can claim the property directly. Remedy: The buyer can claim damages or specific performance.

Illustration:

• A agrees to sell his house to B for Rs. 1,000,000.

• B pays Rs. 500,000 as an advance and takes possession of the house.
• A executes a sale deed and gets it registered.
• B becomes the absolute owner of the property, and the ownership is fully transferred under the law.

Page | 31
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Conclusion:

A contract of sale under Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a complete transfer of ownership of property in exchange
for money. The section also clearly distinguishes between a sale and an agreement to sell, establishing that a sale immediately
transfers ownership, while an agreement to sell creates a right to obtain ownership in the future.

Section 55 further elaborates the rights and duties of the seller and the buyer, ensuring that both parties are aware of their legal
obligations during the transaction. The Act aims to provide a comprehensive legal framework for property transactions, ensuring fair
dealing and protection of rights for both the seller and the buyer.

Page | 32
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is Mortgage? Explain its different kinds?

Q: How mortgage is made? Explain mortgagee’s right to foreclose and sale.
Q: How many types of mortgages are given in Transfer of Property Act, 1882? Please explain all with examples.
Q: Explain the rights of mortgagee to “sale and foreclose” of the mortgaged property.
Q: Explain the mortgagor’s right to redeem the mortgaged property.

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 governs the transfer of immovable property in Pakistan. One of the significant modes of transfer
under this Act is the Mortgage. The concept of mortgage is detailed in Chapter IV (Sections 58 to 104) of the Act. This chapter defines
the term mortgage, its types, rights and liabilities of the parties, and the procedure for recovery of the debt.

➠ What is Mortgage? (Section 58):

Definition:
According to Section 58(a) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, a mortgage is defined as:

“A mortgage is the transfer of an interest in specific immovable property for the purpose of securing the payment of a debt or
the performance of an obligation.”

Simple and Easy Wording:

A mortgage is when the owner of a property (the mortgagor) gives a legal right or interest in that property to a lender (the
mortgagee) to secure a loan or fulfill an obligation. If the borrower fails to repay the debt, the lender can recover the money by
selling the property.

➠ How is a Mortgage Made? (Section 59):

• A mortgage involving a value of Rs. 100 or more must be created through a written and registered deed.
• The mortgage deed must be:
o Signed by the mortgagor, and
o Registered under the Registration Act, 1908.

Page | 33
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• If the value of the property is less than Rs. 100, the mortgage can be created by delivery of possession only, but this is rare for
immovable property.

Essential Elements of a Mortgage:

1. Debt or Obligation: There must be a debt to be secured.

2. Immovable Property: The subject of the mortgage must be specific immovable property.
3. Transfer of Interest: The mortgagor transfers a limited interest in the property to the mortgagee.
4. Security for Debt: The property is held as security for the debt or obligation.
5. Right to Redemption: The mortgagor has the right to redeem the property after repayment of the debt.

➠ Types of Mortgages (Section 58):

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 recognizes six types of mortgages:

1. Simple Mortgage (Section 58(b)):

In a simple mortgage, the mortgagor:

• Does not deliver possession of the property.

• Binds himself personally to pay the debt.
• Allows the mortgagee to sell the property in case of non-payment.

Example:
A takes a loan of Rs. 5 lakhs from B and mortgages his house as security. A remains in possession of the house, but B can sell it if A
fails to repay the loan.

2. Mortgage by Conditional Sale (Section 58(c)):

• The mortgagor sells the property to the mortgagee with a condition that:
o The sale will become absolute upon non-payment of the debt.
o The sale will become void if the debt is repaid.
o The property will be reconveyed to the mortgagor upon repayment.

Page | 34
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Example:
A borrows Rs. 3 lakhs from B and executes a mortgage deed stating that if A fails to repay, the sale will be absolute in favor of B. If
A repays, the property will be reconveyed to A.

3. Usufructuary Mortgage (Section 58(d)):

• The mortgagor delivers possession of the property to the mortgagee.

• The mortgagee is entitled to receive rents and profits from the property.
• The mortgagee does not have the right to sell the property.
• The debt is repaid through rents and profits received by the mortgagee.

Example:
A mortgages his shop to B for Rs. 2 lakhs. B takes possession of the shop and collects rent from tenants to recover his loan.

4. English Mortgage (Section 58(e)):

• The mortgagor transfers the entire property to the mortgagee.

• The transfer is subject to the condition that the mortgagee will retransfer the property to the mortgagor upon repayment of
the debt.
• The mortgagor remains personally liable for the debt.

Example:
A borrows Rs. 10 lakhs from B and executes an English Mortgage, transferring ownership of his house to B. If A repays the debt, B
will retransfer the house to A.

5. Mortgage by Deposit of Title Deeds (Equitable Mortgage) (Section 58(f)):

• The mortgagor deposits title deeds of the property with the mortgagee as security for the loan.
• This type of mortgage is common in urban areas and big cities.
• It does not require registration if created in certain notified towns.

Example:
A borrows Rs. 2 lakhs from B and deposits the title deeds of his house as security for the loan.

Page | 35
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

6. Anomalous Mortgage (Section 58(g)):

• A mortgage that does not fall under any of the above categories or is a combination of two or more types is considered an
anomalous mortgage.
• It is governed by the terms of the contract.

Example:
A mortgages his land to B with the condition that B will take possession, collect rent, and also have the right to sell the property if
the debt is not repaid.

➠ Rights and Liabilities of Mortgagor and Mortgagee:

Rights of Mortgagee to Sale and Foreclose the Mortgaged Property (Section 67 & 67-A):

1. Right of Sale (Section 67):

Meaning:

• The mortgagee (lender) has the right to sell the mortgaged property if the mortgagor (borrower) fails to repay the mortgage
debt within the stipulated period.
• This right is a legal remedy available to the mortgagee to recover the mortgage money.

Conditions for Exercising Right of Sale:

• The right of sale can be exercised only when:

o The mortgagee has given the required notice to the mortgagor demanding payment.
o The mortgagor has defaulted in repayment.
o There is no clause prohibiting sale in the mortgage deed.
o The mortgage is a simple mortgage, English mortgage, or anomalous mortgage.

Procedure for Sale:

• The mortgagee must:

Page | 36
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o Notify the mortgagor about the intention to sell.

o Provide a reasonable time for repayment.
o The sale can be conducted privately or through public auction.
o The mortgagee can apply to the court to direct the sale of the property.

Example:

• A mortgages his house to B for Rs. 5 lakhs. If A fails to repay the loan, B can serve a notice to A and then sell the property by
public auction to recover the mortgage money.

2. Right of Foreclosure (Section 67):

Meaning:

• The right to foreclose means the mortgagee can bar the mortgagor’s right to redeem the property after the debt becomes due
and the mortgagor fails to repay it.
• This right is applicable in the case of a mortgage by conditional sale and anomalous mortgage.

Conditions for Exercising Right of Foreclosure:

• The mortgage money has become due and payable.

• The mortgagor has failed to repay the debt within the stipulated period.
• The mortgage deed does not contain a clause prohibiting foreclosure.
• The mortgagee must approach the court for a foreclosure decree.

Procedure for Foreclosure:

• The mortgagee must file a suit for foreclosure in the court.

• The court may issue a foreclosure decree, preventing the mortgagor from redeeming the property.
• Upon issuance of the decree, the mortgagee becomes the absolute owner of the property.

Page | 37
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Example:

• A mortgages his land to B by a mortgage by conditional sale. The condition is that if A does not repay the debt by 1st June, the
sale will become absolute in favor of B. If A defaults, B can apply for a foreclosure decree to obtain full ownership of the land.

➠ Right of Mortgagor to Redeem the Mortgaged Property (Section 60):

Meaning:

• The right to redeem the property is a fundamental right of the mortgagor under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
• It is the right of the mortgagor to recover the mortgaged property by paying off the entire mortgage debt, including interest
and other costs.
• This right is also known as the Equity of Redemption.

Essentials of Right to Redeem:

• The mortgagor can exercise the right to redeem:

o After the debt becomes due and before the property is foreclosed or sold.
o By paying the full amount of the debt, including principal, interest, and other costs.
o The mortgagor must demand the return of the title deeds and reconveyance of property.

When the Right to Redeem is Lost:

• The right to redeem is lost when:

o The mortgagee exercises the right to sale under Section 67.
o The mortgagee obtains a decree of foreclosure under Section 67.
o The mortgagor surrenders the right to redeem by an express agreement.

Clog on Redemption:

• A clog on redemption refers to any condition in the mortgage deed that restricts or prevents the mortgagor from redeeming
the property.
• The law does not permit any clause that makes redemption impossible or excessively difficult for the mortgagor.

Page | 38
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Example of Clog on Redemption:

• If a mortgage deed states that the mortgagor can never redeem the property, such a clause is considered a clog on redemption
and is void and unenforceable.

Procedure for Redemption:

1. The mortgagor must tender the full payment of the mortgage debt to the mortgagee.
2. The mortgagor can request the return of title deeds and demand a reconveyance deed.
3. If the mortgagee refuses to accept payment, the mortgagor can file a suit for redemption in the court.

Example of Redemption:

• A mortgages his house to B for Rs. 3 lakhs. If A repays the entire debt with interest, B is bound to return the title deeds and
reconvey the property to A.

Conclusion:

A mortgage under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a legal arrangement where a person transfers an interest in immovable
property to a lender as security for a loan or obligation. There are six types of mortgages, each with its own distinct features, rights,
and obligations. Understanding the types of mortgages helps both borrowers and lenders to secure their rights and minimize risks in
financial transactions.

Page | 39
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is “contribution to mortgage debt”? Explain.

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provides comprehensive provisions regarding mortgages and related rights and liabilities. One
such provision deals with the contribution to mortgaged debt, which is addressed in Section 82 of the Act. This section is particularly
significant when a property is owned by multiple persons and is mortgaged as a whole or in parts. It ensures that each co-owner or
party is held responsible for paying their proportionate share of the mortgage debt.

➠ Contribution to Mortgaged Debt: (Section 82)

Meaning of Contribution to Mortgaged Debt:

• The term contribution to mortgaged debt refers to the obligation of multiple owners of a property to pay their share of the
mortgage debt when the property is jointly mortgaged.
• If the property is owned by several persons and is mortgaged as a single entity, each co-owner is liable to contribute
proportionately towards the repayment of the debt.
• The contribution is based on the extent of the interest or share of each co-owner in the mortgaged property.

Text of Section 82 in Simple Words:

• When a property owned by multiple people is mortgaged and the mortgage money is paid by one or some of the co-owners, the
other co-owners are also liable to contribute their share of the mortgage debt.
• Each co-owner must pay a proportionate amount based on the value of their share in the property.
• If one co-owner pays more than his share, he can recover the excess amount from the other co-owners.

Example to Illustrate Contribution:

• A, B, and C jointly own a property. The property is mortgaged to X for Rs. 3 lakhs.
• The shares of the co-owners are:
o A: 1/2 share (Rs. 1.5 lakhs)
o B: 1/4 share (Rs. 75,000)
o C: 1/4 share (Rs. 75,000)

Page | 40
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• If A pays the entire mortgage amount of Rs. 3 lakhs, he can demand contribution from B and C as follows:
o B’s Contribution: Rs. 75,000
o C’s Contribution: Rs. 75,000

Essentials of Contribution to Mortgaged Debt:

1. Existence of Multiple Co-owners:

o The property must be jointly owned by two or more persons.
2. Single Mortgage of Entire Property:
o The property must be mortgaged as a single entity or in a way that all co-owners are liable for the debt.
3. Payment by One Co-owner:
o If one or more co-owners pay the entire mortgage debt, they have the right to claim the share of others.
4. Proportionate Liability:
o The liability of each co-owner is proportional to their share in the property.

➠ Recovery of Contribution:

• If one co-owner pays more than his share of the mortgage debt, he is entitled to recover the excess amount from the other co-
owners.
• The amount recoverable is based on the proportionate share of each co-owner.
• If a co-owner refuses to pay his share, the paying co-owner can file a suit for contribution in the court.

Case Law Reference:

• In Sundaram v. Valli Ammal (1961), it was held that a co-owner who has paid the entire mortgage debt has the right to recover
the proportionate share from the other co-owners under Section 82.

Conclusion:

Section 82 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 ensures that the burden of the mortgage debt is fairly distributed among all co-
owners based on their respective shares in the property. This provision is vital to protect the paying co-owner and to prevent unjust
enrichment of other co-owners. It also ensures that the mortgage debt is effectively recovered without placing the entire burden on a
single co-owner.

Page | 41
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is lease? How it is made? How it is terminated?

Q: How is Lease made? What are the rights and duties of lessee?
Q: What is Lease? Explain the rights and duties of lessor?

Introduction:

The Transfer of Property Act, 1882 defines and regulates the leasing of immovable property in Pakistan. A lease is a contractual
arrangement where the lessor (owner) transfers the right to use the property to the lessee (tenant) for a specified period in exchange
for rent or consideration. The provisions related to leases are contained in Sections 105 to 117 of the Act.

➠ What is Lease? (Section 105):

Definition:
According to Section 105, a lease of immovable property is a transfer of the right to enjoy the property for a specified period or
perpetually in consideration of:
• Money, rent, or any other valuable consideration, to be paid periodically or as a lump sum.
Parties to a Lease:
1. Lessor: The person who transfers the right to use the property.
2. Lessee: The person who receives the right to use the property.
3. Premium or Rent: The consideration paid by the lessee to the lessor.
4. Duration: The period for which the lease is granted.
Example of Lease:
• A leases his shop to B for Rs. 10,000 per month for 3 years.
• A is the lessor, B is the lessee, and Rs. 10,000 is the rent.

➠ How is Lease Made? (Section 107):

A lease is created through a legal contract or agreement. This contract can be either written or oral, but it is always advisable to have
a written agreement to avoid disputes.

Page | 42
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Requirements for Creating a Lease:

1. Written Agreement:
o If the lease period is one year or more, it must be in writing, signed, and registered.
o If the lease period is less than one year, it can be created orally or in writing.
2. Essential Elements:
o Offer and Acceptance: Both parties must agree on the terms of the lease.
o Rent or Consideration: The lessee must agree to pay rent or any other valuable consideration.
o Agreement: A formal lease agreement is created and signed by both parties. The agreement should specify:
1. Description of the property
2. Term of the lease (whether for months, years, or indefinitely)
3. Rent amount and payment method
4. Duties and responsibilities of both parties
5. Conditions for termination of the lease
o Duration of Lease: The period must be clearly defined.
o Delivery of Possession: The lessor must transfer the right to use the property to the lessee.

Mode of Execution:

• The lease deed must be executed on a stamp paper, and in case of a lease for more than one year, it must be registered with
the relevant authority.

➠ Termination of Lease (Sections 111-112):

A lease can be terminated in the following ways:

1. Expiry of Time (Section 111(a)):

• The lease ends automatically when the specified period expires.

Example:

• If a lease is granted for 2 years, it will end automatically after 2 years.

Page | 43
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

2. Termination by Notice (Section 111(h)):

• Either party can terminate the lease by serving a notice to the other party as per the lease agreement.

Example:

• A lease agreement may specify a one-month notice period for termination.

3. Breach of Condition (Section 111(g)):

• If the lessee violates any condition of the lease, the lessor may terminate the lease.

Example:

• If the lessee sublets the property without permission, the lessor can terminate the lease.

4. Forfeiture (Section 111(g)):

• The lessor can forfeit the lease and re-enter the property in case of:
o Non-payment of rent.
o Breach of condition.
o Denial of lessor’s title by the lessee.

5. Surrender (Section 111(e)):

• The lessee can surrender the lease voluntarily before the expiry of the lease term.

6. Merger (Section 111(f)):

• If the lessee acquires the property as the owner, the lease is automatically terminated.

Page | 44
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

7. Destruction of Property (Section 108(e)):

• If the property is destroyed by fire, flood, or any other unavoidable event, the lease is terminated.

➠ Rights and Duties of Lessor and Lessee:

The rights and duties of the lessor (property owner) and the lessee (tenant) are fundamental to a lease agreement. Both parties have
distinct roles and responsibilities that ensure the smooth functioning of the tenancy. Let’s explore these in greater detail.

1. Rights of the Lessor (Section 108(A):

The lessor retains ownership of the property, even though they transfer the right of possession to the lessee. The rights of the lessor
are designed to safeguard the property owner's interests while ensuring the tenant fulfills the lease terms.

a. Right to Receive Rent

• The lessor has the right to receive rent or compensation from the lessee as agreed upon in the lease agreement.
• The rent must be paid on time and in the agreed amount.
• If the rent is not paid, the lessor can take legal action to recover the overdue rent or terminate the lease (Section 111 of the
Transfer of Property Act).
Example:
• If A rents a house to B for Rs. 10,000 per month, A has the right to receive Rs. 10,000 every month.

b. Right to Recover Possession after Lease Term

• After the lease term expires or if the lease is terminated early, the lessor has the right to recover possession of the property.
• If the lessee refuses to vacate, the lessor can file a suit for eviction to regain possession.
Example:
• If A rents a flat to B for one year, at the end of the year, A can ask B to vacate the property and take possession if B refuses.

c. Right to Inspect and Repair

• The lessor has the right to inspect the property at reasonable times to ensure the lessee is maintaining the property properly.

Page | 45
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• If necessary, the lessor can also carry out repairs to ensure the property is in good condition for living. However, the lessor
must give the lessee notice before entering the property.
Example:
• If A is the owner of a building and notices the plumbing is damaged, A has the right to send a plumber to fix the damage.
However, A must inform B (the lessee) beforehand.

d. Right to Terminate the Lease for Breach of Terms

• The lessor can terminate the lease if the lessee violates the terms of the agreement, such as non-payment of rent, damaging
the property, or using the property for unlawful purposes.
• The lessor can also claim compensation for any damage caused by the lessee.
Example:
• If B does not pay the rent for three months, A (the lessor) can terminate the lease and ask B to vacate the property.

2. Duties of the Lessor (Section 108(B):

The lessor has certain duties towards the lessee, which ensure the lessee has a safe and habitable space for living or working.

a. Duty to Provide Possession

• The lessor must hand over possession of the property to the lessee at the beginning of the lease.
• The lessee should not be deprived of the property during the term of the lease.
Example:
• If A and B agree on a lease, A must give B the keys to the house and allow B to move in at the start of the lease.

b. Duty to Maintain the Property in Good Condition

• The lessor is required to maintain the property in a good condition.

• This includes making necessary repairs to the structure, plumbing, electrical systems, etc. The lessor is responsible for major
repairs, while the lessee takes care of minor repairs.
Example:
• If the roof of the house leaks, A (the lessor) is responsible for repairing the roof. However, if the bathroom faucet is broken
due to misuse by B (the lessee), then B must pay for its repair.

Page | 46
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

c. Duty to Provide Quiet Enjoyment

• The lessor must ensure the lessee can peacefully enjoy the property without any interference during the term of the lease.
• The lessor cannot disturb the lessee's possession unless specified in the lease agreement.
Example:
• If A (the lessor) continuously enters the house without prior notice, it would be a violation of B’s right to quiet enjoyment.

d. Duty Not to Interfere with Lessee’s Possession

• The lessor should not unnecessarily interfere with the lessee's possession of the property, unless the terms of the lease allow
it (such as entering for repairs or inspection).
Example:
• A cannot show up at B's house without notice or permission just to check on the property.

3. Rights of the Lessee (Section 108(B):

The lessee has the right to occupy and use the property for the duration of the lease. These rights ensure the lessee can live or use the
property as agreed without undue interference.

a. Right to Possession and Use of the Property

• The lessee has the right to enjoy the property for the lease period as long as they abide by the terms of the lease.
• The lessee can use the property for the purpose stated in the lease (residential, commercial, etc.).
Example:
• If A rents a house to B, B can live in the house for the agreed period without interference from A.

b. Right to Receive Property in Good Condition

• The lessee has the right to receive the property in a habitable condition, suitable for the agreed use.
• If the property is not in good condition, the lessee can request the lessor to fix the problems.
Example:
• If A rents an office to B, and the office has broken windows, B can ask A to repair them before moving in.

Page | 47
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

c. Right to Renew or Extend the Lease (if provided)

• If the lease agreement provides an option for renewal or extension, the lessee has the right to renew the lease at the end of
the term, typically on the same terms and conditions.
Example:
• A rents an apartment to B for one year, and the agreement states that B can renew the lease for another year if both parties
agree.

d. Right to Sublet (if allowed by Lessor)

• The lessee has the right to sublet the property or assign the lease to another person, but only if the lessor agrees to it in
writing.
• Subletting without the lessor's permission is a violation of the lease.
Example:
• B (the lessee) rents a house from A but wants to sublet the property to C. B must first get written permission from A to do so.

4. Duties of the Lessee (Section 108(C):

The lessee has specific responsibilities to ensure the property is well-maintained and that the lessor’s rights are respected.

a. Duty to Pay Rent

• The lessee must pay the agreed rent to the lessor on time, as specified in the lease agreement.
• If the lessee fails to pay rent, the lessor has the right to terminate the lease and ask for eviction.
Example:
• If A rents a flat to B for Rs. 20,000 per month, B must pay A the agreed amount each month.

b. Duty to Take Care of the Property

• The lessee must take reasonable care of the property and avoid causing any damage to it.
• Lessee is responsible for minor repairs due to normal wear and tear during their stay.
Example: If B accidentally breaks a door knob, B must replace or repair it.

Page | 48
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

c. Duty Not to Alter the Property Without Permission

• The lessee should not make any structural changes or alterations to the property without the lessor's written consent.
• This includes things like painting walls, building partitions, or installing heavy equipment.
Example:
• If B wants to install a new kitchen countertop, B must get approval from A.

d. Duty to Vacate Property After Lease Term

• At the end of the lease term, the lessee must vacate the property unless there is an agreement to renew or extend the lease.
• The lessee should return the property to the lessor in the same condition as when they received it, subject to normal wear and
tear.
Example:
• If B’s lease expires and there is no renewal option, B must leave the property and return it to A.

Conclusion:

A lease under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a vital legal mechanism that transfers the right to use immovable property for
a specified time in exchange for rent. The Act clearly outlines the procedure for creating and terminating leases, as well as the rights
and duties of lessor and lessee. These provisions ensure a balance of interests between both parties and provide remedies in case of
breach or default.

Page | 49
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the law relating to election as provided in section.35 in Transfer of Property Act.

Introduction:

The concept of Election under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 deals with situations where a person is given a benefit under a
transfer of property but is also required to relinquish some other property in return. This doctrine is governed by Section 35 of the
Act. The purpose of this section is to prevent injustice and to ensure fairness in property transactions.

➠ What is Election?

Election means a situation where a person has to choose between two conflicting rights or claims. Under Section 35, if a person is
given a benefit under a transfer of property, but the transferor also disposes of some other property belonging to that person, the
beneficiary must elect (choose) either to:

1. Accept the benefit and give up his own property, or

2. Reject the benefit and retain his own property.

➠ Relevant Provision - Section 35:

Section 35 - Election:

• When a person gives some property to another person and, in the same transaction, disposes of another property belonging to
the same person, the beneficiary has to elect between the two.
• The beneficiary cannot take both the benefit and retain his own property unless the donor clearly intended to give both.
• If the beneficiary accepts the benefit, he must give up his own property as per the transfer.
• If the beneficiary does not elect, the law will assume that he has chosen to accept the benefit.

➠ Example of Election:

A, the owner of Property X, transfers Property X to B and Property Y (owned by B) to C.

• B is given the choice to elect:

o Either to accept Property X and give Property Y to C, or

Page | 50
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o To retain Property Y and reject Property X.

• If B chooses to accept Property X, he must give Property Y to C.
• If B rejects the benefit, he can retain Property Y, but he cannot take Property X.

➠ Conditions for Election:

For the doctrine of Election to apply, the following conditions must be fulfilled:

1. Transfer of Property by One Person:

o The transfer must involve two properties – one belonging to the transferor and the other belonging to the beneficiary.
2. Two Conflicting Claims:
o The beneficiary must be given a benefit in one property and a burden in another property.
3. Single Transaction:
o The transfer must be a single transaction, and both the benefit and burden must arise from the same document.
4. Intention of Transferor:
o The transferor must have expressly or impliedly intended to transfer the property in such a way that the beneficiary
cannot take both the benefit and the burden.

➠ Modes of Election:

The election can be made in the following ways:

1. Express Election:
o The beneficiary may expressly state his choice to accept the benefit and relinquish his own property.
2. Implied Election:
o If the beneficiary acts in a manner that indicates acceptance, it will be considered an implied election.
o For example, taking possession of the benefit is considered an election to accept the benefit.

➠ Time for Election:

• The beneficiary must elect within a reasonable time.

• If the beneficiary fails to elect within a reasonable time, the law will assume that he has elected to accept the benefit.

Page | 51
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Effect of Election:

1. If the Beneficiary Accepts the Benefit:

o The beneficiary must give up his own property as per the terms of the transfer.
2. If the Beneficiary Rejects the Benefit:
o The beneficiary retains his own property and loses the benefit given by the transferor.
3. If the Beneficiary Fails to Elect:
o The law will presume that the beneficiary has accepted the benefit, and he must give up his own property as per the
transfer.

➠ Exceptions to Election:

1. Gift to Infants or Persons under Disability:

o If the beneficiary is a minor or a person under legal disability, the court may decide on their behalf.
2. Conditional Transfers:
o If the transfer is conditional or contingent, the doctrine of election may not apply until the condition is fulfilled.

➠ Conclusion:

The doctrine of Election under Section 35 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a principle of equity and fairness. It prevents the
beneficiary from accepting a benefit and retaining his own property, thereby preventing unjust enrichment. This section ensures
that a balance is maintained between the transferor's intention and the beneficiary’s right to property.

Page | 52
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the law relating to transfer of property by way of Gift as provided in Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

Introduction:

The law relating to the transfer of property by way of Gift is governed by Sections 122 to 129 of the Transfer of Property Act,
1882. A gift is a voluntary transfer of property without any consideration. It is a form of gratuitous transfer where the donor gives away
the property without receiving anything in return.

➠ What is a Gift? (Section 122)

Definition of Gift:
According to Section 122, a Gift is a transfer of movable or immovable property that is made voluntarily and without
consideration. The transfer must be made by a donor to a donee, and the donee must accept the gift during the lifetime of the donor.

Essential Elements of a Gift:

1. Transfer of Property: The subject of the gift must be property, either movable or immovable.
2. Voluntary Transfer: The gift must be given freely and voluntarily.
3. Without Consideration: There should be no monetary or other consideration involved in the transfer.
4. Acceptance by Donee: The donee must accept the gift during the lifetime of the donor.
5. Delivery of Possession: The donor must deliver the property to the donee, and the donee must take possession of it.

➠ How a Gift is Made? (Section 123)

Section 123 provides the mode of making a gift:

1. Transfer of Immovable Property:

o A gift of immovable property can be made only through a registered instrument signed by the donor and attested by
two witnesses.
2. Transfer of Movable Property:
o A gift of movable property can be made either by a registered instrument or by delivery of possession.
o If the property is a movable asset, mere delivery of the property to the donee is sufficient to complete the gift.

Page | 53
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Illustration:

• A wants to gift his house to B. A executes a gift deed and registers it, and B accepts it. The gift is valid and complete.
• If A wants to gift his watch to B, he can simply hand it over to B, and the gift is complete.

➠ Revocation of Gift (Section 126):

A gift can be revoked in the following circumstances:

1. Gift Made on a Condition:

o If the gift is made on the condition that it shall be revoked upon the happening of a specified event, and that event
occurs, the gift can be revoked.
o The condition must be expressly stated in the gift deed.
2. Fraud, Coercion, or Undue Influence:
o If the gift was obtained by fraud, coercion, or undue influence, the donor can revoke the gift.

Illustration:

• A gifts a house to B with the condition that if B sells the house, the gift will be revoked. If B sells the house, A can revoke the
gift.

➠ Onerous Gift (Section 127):

• An onerous gift is a gift that comes with a burden or obligation.

• The donee must either accept the entire gift (both benefit and burden) or reject the entire gift.
• If the donee accepts the benefit, he must also accept the burden associated with it.

Example:

• A gifts a house to B but also imposes a debt of Rs. 1,00,000 on the house. B can either accept both the house and the debt or
reject both.

Page | 54
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Universal Donee (Section 128):

• A universal donee is a person to whom the donor gifts all of his property.
• The universal donee is liable for all the debts and liabilities of the donor existing at the time of the gift.

Illustration:

• A transfers all his property to B. B becomes a universal donee and is responsible for paying off A’s debts.

➠ Acceptance of Gift (Section 122):

• The donee must accept the gift during the lifetime of the donor.
• If the donee fails to accept the gift during the lifetime of the donor, the gift becomes void.
• The acceptance can be express or implied and must be done immediately after the gift is made.

➠ Gift to Unborn Person (Section 122 and Section 13):

• A gift cannot be made directly to an unborn person.

• However, a gift can be made by creating a life interest in favor of a living person, with a remainder to the unborn person.

➠ Suspension and Revocation of Gift (Section 126):

• A gift can be revoked if it was made subject to a condition and that condition is subsequently fulfilled.
• The condition must be expressly stated in the gift deed and should not be immoral or illegal.

➠ Conclusion:

The law of Gift under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is based on the principle of voluntary transfer without consideration.
The donor must transfer the property without receiving anything in return, and the donee must accept the gift during the lifetime of the
donor. The Act also specifies the manner in which gifts must be made, how they can be revoked, and the implications of accepting
onerous gifts or becoming a universal donee.

Page | 55
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the Principle of Subrogation?

➠Introduction:

The principle of Subrogation under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 deals with the rights of a third party who discharges the
debt of a mortgagor. Subrogation means stepping into the shoes of another person. It allows a person who has paid off a debt on
behalf of another to claim the rights and remedies of the original creditor. The concept is explained in Section 92 of the Act.

➠ Meaning of Subrogation:

Subrogation means the substitution of one person in place of another with respect to a claim or debt. It occurs when a third party
pays off the debt of the mortgagor and is then entitled to all the rights of the original mortgagee as if he were the original creditor.

➠ Relevant Provision - Section 92:

Section 92 - Subrogation:

• When a person other than the mortgagor or a person deriving title from him pays off a mortgage debt, he is said to be
subrogated to the rights of the mortgagee.
• The person who pays off the debt steps into the shoes of the original mortgagee and can enforce all the rights of the mortgagee,
including the right to foreclose or sell the property.
• Subrogation can occur in the following cases:
1. Conventional Subrogation: Where subrogation is expressly stated in the transaction.
2. Legal Subrogation: Where subrogation occurs by operation of law.

➠ Types of Subrogation:

Section 92 recognizes two types of subrogation:

1. Legal Subrogation:
o It occurs by operation of law when a person, who is bound to pay off the debt, pays it on behalf of the mortgagor.
o The person automatically gets all the rights of the original mortgagee.

Page | 56
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

oExample: If a second mortgagee pays off the debt of the first mortgagee, he is subrogated to the rights of the first
mortgagee.
2. Conventional Subrogation:
o It arises by express agreement between the parties.
o The person who pays off the debt must be expressly given the right of subrogation in the agreement.
o Example: If A pays off the mortgage debt of B, and there is an agreement that A will stand in the place of the original
mortgagee, it is a case of conventional subrogation.

➠ Essentials of Subrogation:

For subrogation to apply, the following essentials must be met:

1. Payment of Mortgage Debt:

o The entire mortgage debt must be paid off by a third party.
o Partial payment of the debt does not give the right to subrogation.
2. Payment by a Third Party:
o The payment must be made by a person who is not personally liable for the debt.
o If the mortgagor himself pays the debt, subrogation does not arise.
3. Intention to Subrogate:
o In case of conventional subrogation, there must be a clear intention or agreement to subrogate.
4. Existence of a Valid Mortgage:
o There must be a valid mortgage in existence at the time of payment.
o If the mortgage is invalid, subrogation cannot be claimed.

➠ Rights of Subrogee:

A person who is subrogated to the rights of the original mortgagee has the following rights:

1. Right to Foreclose:
o The subrogee can initiate foreclosure proceedings just like the original mortgagee.
2. Right to Sell the Property:
o The subrogee can sell the mortgaged property to recover the debt, if the mortgage was a mortgage by conditional sale
or a simple mortgage.

Page | 57
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

3. Right to Possession:
o If the mortgage was a usufructuary mortgage, the subrogee can claim possession of the property until the debt is
repaid.
4. Right to Recover the Debt:
o The subrogee can recover the debt amount from the mortgagor just like the original mortgagee.

➠ Illustrations and Examples:

1. Example of Legal Subrogation:

o A is the owner of a property and B is the mortgagee.
o C, a second mortgagee, pays off B’s debt to protect his own interest.
o Now, C is subrogated to B’s rights and can exercise all the rights of B, such as foreclosure or sale.
2. Example of Conventional Subrogation:
o X pays off the mortgage debt of Y, with a specific agreement that X will step into the shoes of the mortgagee.
o Here, X can claim all the rights of the original mortgagee due to the express agreement.

➠ Exceptions to Subrogation:

1. Payment by Mortgagor:
o If the mortgagor himself pays off the debt, he cannot claim subrogation.
2. No Agreement for Conventional Subrogation:
o If there is no agreement for subrogation, the person paying off the debt cannot claim the rights of the mortgagee.
3. Partial Payment:
o If the third party pays only a part of the debt, he is not entitled to subrogation.

➠ Effect of Subrogation:

• The original mortgagee loses his rights once the debt is paid off.
• The subrogee acquires all the rights of the original mortgagee.
• The mortgagor is bound to repay the debt to the subrogee instead of the original mortgagee.

Page | 58
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Conclusion:

The principle of Subrogation under Section 92 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a powerful legal tool that allows a third
party to step into the shoes of the mortgagee upon paying off the mortgage debt. It serves to protect the interests of the person
paying the debt and ensures that he is not left without remedy. This doctrine promotes equity and justice, ensuring that the person
paying the debt is compensated by acquiring the rights of the original mortgagee.

Page | 59
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the principle of prohibition on Tacking.

Introduction:

The principle of Prohibition on Tacking is an important concept under the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. It is explained in Section
93 of the Act. The purpose of this principle is to prevent a mortgagee from combining different debts or securities to gain priority
over other creditors without the consent of those creditors. The doctrine of tacking is primarily aimed at protecting the rights of
subsequent mortgagees or creditors.

➠ Meaning of Tacking:

Tacking refers to the combining of a new debt or advance with an existing mortgage debt to gain priority over subsequent
encumbrancers. It involves adding a new loan or debt to a prior mortgage debt and claiming both as one debt to gain priority over
other creditors.

Example:

• If a property is mortgaged to A for Rs. 1,00,000 and then to B for Rs. 50,000, the mortgagee A cannot add a subsequent loan
of Rs. 30,000 to the first mortgage to gain priority over B’s mortgage.

➠ Relevant Provision - Section 93 (Simple Wording):

Section 93 - Prohibition on Tacking:

• A mortgagee who has a prior mortgage on a property cannot combine or add a subsequent loan or advance to the original
mortgage debt to gain priority over any subsequent mortgagee.
• The principle of tacking does not apply unless the subsequent mortgagee has expressly consented to such tacking.
• If a mortgagee advances further money without the consent of the subsequent mortgagee, he cannot claim priority for the
subsequent advance over the intervening mortgagee.

➠ Purpose of Section 93:

The purpose of Section 93 is to:

Page | 60
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

1. Protect the interests of subsequent mortgagees or creditors.

2. Prevent the first mortgagee from gaining undue advantage by combining multiple debts.
3. Ensure fairness and equity in the distribution of debt priority.

➠ Essentials of Prohibition on Tacking:

1. Existence of Multiple Mortgages:

o There must be more than one mortgage on the property.
2. Subsequent Advance:
o The first mortgagee must have made a subsequent advance or loan after the original mortgage.
3. Without Consent of Subsequent Mortgagee:
o The first mortgagee must have made the subsequent advance without the consent of the subsequent mortgagee.
4. Claim for Priority:
o The first mortgagee seeks to gain priority for the subsequent advance over the intervening mortgage.

➠ Effect of Prohibition on Tacking:

1. No Priority for Subsequent Advances:

o The first mortgagee cannot claim priority for the subsequent loan over the intervening mortgage.
2. Priority Only for Original Mortgage Debt:
o The first mortgagee can only claim priority for the original mortgage debt, not for the subsequent advance.
3. Protection of Subsequent Mortgagee:
o The subsequent mortgagee’s rights are protected, and he is not affected by the subsequent advance made by the
first mortgagee.

➠ Illustration:

• A lends Rs. 1,00,000 to B against the security of B’s property (First Mortgage).
• Later, B takes another loan of Rs. 50,000 from C against the same property (Second Mortgage).
• Subsequently, A advances an additional loan of Rs. 30,000 to B without the consent of C.
• In this situation, A cannot combine the subsequent advance of Rs. 30,000 with the original mortgage debt to gain priority over
C’s mortgage.

Page | 61
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Exceptions to Prohibition on Tacking:

1. Consent of Subsequent Mortgagee:

o If the subsequent mortgagee expressly consents to the tacking, the first mortgagee may gain priority for the subsequent
advance.
2. Consolidation of Mortgages (Section 61):
o If the same property is mortgaged to the same mortgagee more than once, the mortgagee may consolidate all the
mortgages.
o However, this requires express agreement and notice to the subsequent mortgagee.

➠ Why Tacking is Prohibited?

1. Prevent Unfair Advantage:

o If tacking were allowed, the first mortgagee could gain undue advantage by advancing additional money without
informing the subsequent mortgagee.
2. Protect Subsequent Mortgagees:
o It ensures that subsequent mortgagees’ interests are not prejudiced by the first mortgagee’s subsequent advances.
3. Maintain Priority Order:
o The law ensures that the priority of debts is maintained in the order of their creation.

➠ Conclusion:

The principle of Prohibition on Tacking under Section 93 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 serves to protect the rights of
subsequent mortgagees and maintain the priority order of debts. It prevents the first mortgagee from combining subsequent
advances with the original mortgage debt to gain priority over intervening creditors. Thus, the principle of tacking ensures fairness
and equity in the distribution of debt priority.

Page | 62
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the principle of marshaling securities.

Introduction:

The principle of Marshalling of Securities is a legal doctrine provided under Section 56 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. This
principle is designed to protect the rights of a subsequent mortgagee or creditor by allowing him to claim payment from specific
securities or assets in a manner that does not prejudice his interests. The main objective is to ensure fairness in the distribution of
assets when multiple claims are involved.

➠ Meaning of Marshalling of Securities:

Marshalling of Securities means that when a senior creditor or mortgagee has the right to claim payment from multiple properties,
and the subsequent creditor has a charge on only one of those properties, the senior creditor must first realize his debt from the
property not subject to the subsequent charge.

Example:

• A is the owner of two properties, X and Y.

• A mortgages both properties to B to secure a loan of Rs. 1,00,000.
• Later, A mortgages only Property X to C to secure a loan of Rs. 50,000.
• If B seeks to recover his debt, he must first recover from Property Y so that C can recover his debt from Property X.
• This ensures that the interest of C is not prejudiced.

➠ Relevant Provision - Section 56 (Simple Wording):

Section 56 - Marshalling of Securities:

• If a mortgagee or creditor has the right to claim payment from two or more properties, and a subsequent mortgagee or
creditor can only claim payment from one of those properties, the senior mortgagee must first recover from the property
not charged to the subsequent mortgagee.
• The senior creditor may still proceed against the other property if the remaining property is insufficient to satisfy his debt.
• This principle applies only if it does not prejudice the rights of the senior creditor.

Page | 63
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Purpose of Marshalling:

The purpose of Marshalling of Securities is to:

1. Protect the interests of subsequent mortgagees or creditors.

2. Ensure equitable distribution of assets without causing prejudice.
3. Prevent unfair disadvantage to the subsequent mortgagee who has a limited security interest.

➠ Essentials of Marshalling of Securities:

1. Two or More Securities:

o The senior creditor must have multiple securities or properties to recover the debt.
2. One Security for Subsequent Creditor:
o The subsequent creditor must have a charge on only one of those properties.
3. Application of Principle:
o The senior creditor must be able to recover the debt from other securities without affecting the rights of the subsequent
creditor.
4. No Prejudice to Senior Creditor:
o The senior creditor must not suffer any loss or disadvantage due to marshalling.

➠ Rights of Subsequent Mortgagee:

A subsequent mortgagee can request the application of the marshalling principle to ensure that:

1. The senior creditor first recovers from the property not subject to the subsequent charge.
2. The property subject to the subsequent charge remains available for the subsequent mortgagee to recover his debt.

➠ Illustration:

• A owns Properties X and Y.

• A mortgages both X and Y to B to secure a debt of Rs. 2,00,000.
• Later, A mortgages Property X to C to secure a debt of Rs. 50,000.
• If B seeks to recover his debt, he must first recover from Property Y, allowing C to claim from Property X.

Page | 64
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• If Property Y is insufficient, B can proceed against Property X to the extent of the unpaid debt.

➠ Exceptions to Marshalling of Securities:

1. Insolvency of Mortgagor:
o If the mortgagor becomes insolvent, the principle of marshalling does not apply.
2. Insufficient Security:
o If the remaining security is insufficient, the senior creditor may proceed against both properties.
3. Consent of Parties:
o Marshalling cannot be enforced if the parties have expressly agreed to the contrary.
4. No Right to Prejudice:
o The senior creditor’s rights cannot be prejudiced by marshalling.

➠ Effect of Marshalling:

• The senior creditor is required to first exhaust the security not encumbered by the subsequent mortgagee.
• If the senior creditor’s debt is not fully satisfied, he can then proceed against the property encumbered by the subsequent
mortgagee.
• The subsequent mortgagee is protected from losing his security interest due to the actions of the senior creditor.

➠ Why Marshalling is Important?

• Equitable Distribution: Ensures that the debt recovery is fair to all creditors.
• Protection of Subsequent Creditors: Prevents the senior creditor from unfairly exhausting the security held by the subsequent
creditor.
• Orderly Distribution of Assets: Maintains the priority order of debts and prevents conflicts.

➠ Conclusion:

The principle of Marshalling of Securities under Section 56 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 serves to protect the interests
of subsequent mortgagees or creditors by allowing them to claim payment from specific properties without prejudice. This
principle ensures equity and fairness in debt recovery, preventing unfair advantage to the senior creditor and maintaining the
rights of subsequent mortgagees.

Page | 65
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is the concept of “Bonafide Purchase” without notice with consideration? Please explain with reference to Section 41
of Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

Introduction:

The concept of Bonafide Purchase without Notice with Consideration is addressed under Section 41 of the Transfer of Property
Act, 1882. This section protects the rights of a person who purchases property in good faith, without any knowledge of the real
owner’s interest and by paying valuable consideration. It primarily deals with the concept of Ostensible Ownership and the rights of a
bonafide purchaser when the property is transferred by an ostensible owner.

➠ Meaning of Bonafide Purchase without Notice:

A Bonafide Purchase without Notice refers to a transaction in which a person purchases a property:

• In good faith, believing that the seller is the rightful owner.

• Without any notice or knowledge of any prior claim or interest in the property by any third party.
• For valuable consideration, meaning that the purchaser has paid a reasonable price for the property.

➠ Relevant Provision - Section 41 (Simple Wording):

Section 41 - Transfer by Ostensible Owner:

• If a person represents himself as the owner of a property, with the consent, express or implied, of the real owner, and a
third party purchases the property in good faith for valuable consideration, such a purchaser is protected, provided that he
had no knowledge of the real owner’s interest.
• The real owner cannot claim the property back against the bonafide purchaser if the purchaser acted in good faith without
notice of the real owner’s interest.

➠ Essentials of Bonafide Purchase Without Notice:

Page | 66
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

1. Ostensible Ownership:
o The person transferring the property must be an ostensible owner, i.e., someone who appears to be the owner but is
not the real owner.
2. Consent of Real Owner:
o The real owner must have given consent (express or implied) to the ostensible owner to represent himself as the owner.
3. Good Faith Purchase:
o The purchaser must have acted in good faith, genuinely believing that the ostensible owner is the real owner.
4. Without Notice:
o The purchaser must be without notice or knowledge of the real owner’s interest or claim in the property.
5. For Valuable Consideration:
o The purchaser must have paid a reasonable and adequate price for the property.
o Gratuitous transfers or gifts do not qualify for protection under Section 41.

➠ Rights of Bonafide Purchaser Without Notice:

1. Protection Against Real Owner’s Claim:

o The bonafide purchaser is protected against any claim by the real owner who had consented to the ostensible owner’s
representation.
2. Right to Retain Property:
o The purchaser can retain the property, and the real owner cannot recover it, provided the purchaser had no notice of
the real owner’s interest.
3. Right to Transfer the Property:
o The bonafide purchaser has the right to transfer the property further, as he is now regarded as the lawful owner.

➠ Illustration of Bonafide Purchase Without Notice:

• A is the real owner of a property but allows B to represent himself as the owner.
• B sells the property to C, a bonafide purchaser, for Rs. 5,00,000, without C having any knowledge of A’s real ownership.
• Here, C is protected under Section 41 and A cannot claim the property back from C, as C is a bonafide purchaser for
value without notice.

Page | 67
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Exceptions to the Principle:

1. If the Real Owner did Not Consent:

o If the real owner did not give consent, either expressly or impliedly, to the ostensible owner, the bonafide purchaser
is not protected.
2. Fraudulent Transaction:
o If the purchaser was aware of the real owner’s interest or if the transaction was fraudulent, he cannot claim protection
under Section 41.
3. Notice of Real Owner’s Interest:
o If the purchaser had any notice or knowledge of the real owner’s interest, he is not considered a bonafide purchaser
and cannot claim protection.

➠ Effect of Purchase Without Notice:

• The real owner loses his right to claim the property against the bonafide purchaser.
• The bonafide purchaser gains a valid title to the property, even if the ostensible owner was not the actual owner.
• This principle ensures equity and fairness, preventing the real owner from asserting ownership after allowing the ostensible
owner to appear as the true owner.

➠ Why Section 41 is Important?

• It protects the interests of bonafide purchasers who acted in good faith and without notice of any prior claim.
• It ensures fair dealing in property transactions by holding the real owner accountable for allowing an ostensible owner to
represent himself as the true owner.
• It prevents fraudulent claims by real owners who have consented to the representation of ownership by another person.

➠ Conclusion:

The principle of Bonafide Purchase without Notice under Section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is a vital protection for
purchasers who acquire property in good faith and without notice of any prior claim. It prevents the real owner from asserting
ownership against such a purchaser when the real owner had consented to the representation of another as the owner. This doctrine
ensures equity and justice in property transactions and promotes transparency and fairness.

Page | 68
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Page | 69
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Discuss the procedure of acquisition of land as laid down in the Act?

➠ Introduction:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 provides a legal procedure through which the government can acquire private land for public
purposes like roads, schools, hospitals, and other development projects. This process balances the needs of the government and the
rights of landowners by following clear steps and ensuring fair compensation.

➠ Relevant Provisions Under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894:

The main sections of the Act that govern the procedure of land acquisition are:

• Section 4: Notification of intended acquisition

• Section 5: Objections and inquiry
• Section 6: Declaration of acquisition
• Section 7: Notice to landowners
• Section 8: Survey and measurement
• Section 11: Award of compensation
• Sections 16 & 17: Payment of compensation and possession
• Section 18: Reference to court for dispute

➠ Step 1: Notification of Intended Acquisition (Section 4)

• The government first issues a public notification under Section 4 to declare that a particular piece of land is required for a
public purpose.
• This notification is published in the official gazette and local newspapers.
• It informs the owners and interested persons that the land will be acquired.
• The notification invites any person who claims an interest in the land to raise objections.

Page | 70
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Step 2: Objections and Inquiry (Section 5)

• After the notification, any landowner or interested person can file objections against the acquisition.
• The Collector (government officer) conducts an inquiry to hear these objections.
• The Collector examines whether the acquisition is truly necessary and for a lawful public purpose.
• If the objections are found valid, acquisition may be stopped or modified.
• If not, the Collector proceeds to the next step.

➠ Step 3: Declaration of Intended Acquisition (Section 6)

• After completing the inquiry and being satisfied about the need for the land, the government issues a declaration under Section
6.
• This declaration confirms the government’s intention to acquire the land officially.
• It acts as a formal order to proceed with the acquisition.

➠ Step 4: Notice to Landowners (Section 7)

• The Collector sends a written notice to all landowners or persons interested in the land.
• This notice informs them of the declaration under Section 6 and their rights regarding compensation.
• It provides details about the land to be acquired and compensation terms.

➠ Step 5: Survey and Measurement of Land (Section 8)

• The Collector carries out a survey and measurement of the land to determine its exact area and boundaries.
• This helps in calculating the market value for compensation.

➠ Step 6: Award of Compensation (Section 11)

• After completing the survey and assessing the value, the Collector prepares an award fixing the amount of compensation
payable to the landowners.
• The award must be fair and just, reflecting the current market value and any damages caused by acquisition.
• The award is announced publicly and copies are sent to the landowners.
• The award is final unless challenged through legal reference.
Page | 71
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Step 7: Payment of Compensation and Taking Possession (Sections 16 & 17)

• The government or acquiring body must pay the compensation to the landowners without delay.
• If the landowners refuse to accept the compensation, the amount can be deposited in court.
• Once payment is made or deposited, the Collector can take possession of the land.
• In case of urgency, possession can be taken even before the award, under special powers of Section 17 (discussed separately).

➠ Step 8: Legal Remedy and Reference to Court (Section 18)

• If a landowner is dissatisfied with the amount of compensation, they can file a reference to the court for a fair determination.
• The court will re-examine the valuation and decide the just amount payable.
• This legal remedy protects the rights of landowners.

➠ Summary Table of the Acquisition Procedure:

Step Description Relevant Section

Notification of Land Government publishes notification of intended acquisition. Section 4
Objections and Inquiry Hearing objections from landowners and interested parties. Section 5
Declaration of Acquisition Government formally declares intention to acquire land. Section 6
Notice to Landowners Written notice to landowners about acquisition and rights. Section 7
Survey and Measurement Land is measured and boundaries fixed for valuation. Section 8
Award of Compensation Collector fixes amount of compensation to be paid. Section 11
Payment and Possession Compensation paid; possession of land taken by government. Sections 16 & 17
Legal Remedy for Disputes Landowners can challenge compensation through court reference. Section 18

➠ Conclusion:

The procedure under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 ensures that land acquisition is carried out in a fair, transparent, and lawful
manner. It balances the government’s need to develop public infrastructure with the protection of landowners’ rights, including
notice, inquiry, compensation, and legal remedies. This process helps maintain justice and public trust during land acquisition.

Page | 72
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is award as provided in land acquisition act 1894? What steps a land acquisition collector takes before making an
award?
Q: What is Award by the Collector and what are the important ingredients which must be mentioned in the Award of Collector
regarding acquisition of land?
Q: What is an Award by the collector? Explain the procedure of making an Award. What is the remedy available to the aggrieved
party against the award?

➠ Introduction:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 is a comprehensive law that governs the process of acquiring private land for public purposes. One of
the key elements of this Act is the Award, which is made by the Land Acquisition Collector (LAC) after the completion of the
necessary inquiries and assessments. The award is a formal decision regarding the compensation to be paid for the acquired land.

➠ Meaning and Definition of Award:

An Award under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 is the final determination of the amount of compensation payable to the landowner
whose land is acquired. It is a legal declaration that specifies the compensation, the area of land acquired, and other necessary details.

➠ Relevant Provisions of the Award under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894:

The provisions related to the Award are primarily found in the following sections of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894:

1. Section 11 – Enquiry and Award by Collector:

o The Collector is required to conduct an inquiry into the value of the land, the interests of the claimants, and other relevant
aspects before making the Award.
2. Section 12 – Award of Collector When Final:
o The Award becomes final and conclusive between the Collector and the interested parties unless it is challenged by filing
a reference under Section 18.
3. Section 13 – Adjournment of Enquiry:
o The Collector may adjourn the inquiry from time to time to collect further evidence or to allow parties to submit
documents.

Page | 73
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

4. Section 18 – Reference to Court:

o Any person dissatisfied with the Award can apply for a reference to the court for redetermination of the compensation or
other matters.

➠ Steps Taken by the Land Acquisition Collector Before Making an Award:

Before making an Award, the Land Acquisition Collector is required to follow a systematic and structured procedure. The steps
involved are as follows:

1. Issuance of Notice (Section 9):

o The Collector issues a public notice to all interested persons, requiring them to submit their claims for compensation,
along with evidence of their interest in the land.
o The notice must specify the date, time, and place for the hearing of claims.
2. Recording of Statements:
o The Collector records statements from the interested persons regarding the nature of their interest in the property, the
extent of the land affected, and the claimed compensation.
3. Assessment of Market Value:
o The Collector evaluates the market value of the land by considering:
▪ Current market prices.
▪ The location and potential use of the land.
▪ Sale prices of comparable properties.
▪ Any special advantages or disadvantages associated with the land.
4. Consideration of Additional Compensation (Section 23):
o Apart from the market value, the Collector must also assess additional compensation for:
▪ Severance damage (if only part of the land is acquired).
▪ Loss of standing crops or trees.
▪ Injurious affection to other land.
▪ Expenses related to relocation or loss of business.
5. Apportionment of Compensation (Section 11):
o The Collector determines the proportionate share of compensation payable to each interested person based on their legal
interest in the property.

Page | 74
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

6. Completion of Inquiry:
o The inquiry is completed after considering all relevant evidence, statements, and documents.
7. Preparation of Award:
o The Award is prepared in writing, containing all necessary details, including the amount of compensation and the
apportionment.

➠ Contents of the Award (Section 11):

The Award must contain the following essential components:

1. Identification of Land:
o Detailed description of the land acquired, including its location, area, boundaries, and nature of the property.
2. Interested Persons:
o The names of all persons who have a legal interest in the land and are entitled to receive compensation.
3. Assessment of Compensation:
o The Award must clearly state the compensation amount, which is based on:
▪ Market value of the land.
▪ Value of any structures, crops, or trees.
▪ Damages due to severance or injurious affection.
▪ Any other losses or expenses incurred by the claimant.
4. Apportionment of Compensation:
o The method of distribution of compensation among various claimants is clearly mentioned in the Award.
5. Grounds for Determination:
o The reasons and basis for the determination of compensation are explained in detail.
6. Date of Award:
o The Award must include the date on which it is made and signed by the Collector.

➠ How the Award is Made (Section 11):

• The Award is prepared in writing, signed by the Collector, and announced publicly.
• A copy of the Award is provided to the interested parties.
• The Award is binding unless challenged through a reference to the court under Section 18.

Page | 75
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Remedy Against the Award:

If any person is dissatisfied with the award, the following remedies are available:

1. Reference to the Court (Section 18):

o The aggrieved party can file an application to the Collector for making a reference to the Civil Court regarding the
adequacy of compensation, area measurement, or apportionment.
2. Appeal to Higher Courts:
o If unsatisfied with the decision of the Civil Court, an appeal can be made to higher judicial authorities.
3. Enhancement of Compensation:
o If the award does not meet the legal standards or if there are errors in calculation, the court may enhance the compensation
after proper examination.

➠ Conclusion:

The Award under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 plays a pivotal role in ensuring fair compensation for landowners whose properties
are acquired for public purposes. The Land Acquisition Collector must strictly follow legal procedures to avoid disputes and ensure
justice. If the award seems unjust, affected parties have the right to challenge it through legal means.

Page | 76
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What are the matters which are neglected by the court in determining compensation?
Q: What are the matters which are considered by court in determining compensation?

➠ Introduction:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 provides a detailed framework for the acquisition of private land for public purposes and for
determining the amount of compensation payable to the affected landowners. While determining compensation, the court considers
specific factors to ensure fair compensation and disregards certain matters that could unfairly inflate or reduce the compensation amount.

The provisions relating to the matters that must be neglected and considered by the court are covered under Sections 23 and 24 of the
Act.

➠ Relevant Provisions:

• Matters to be Considered by the Court – Section 23

• Matters to be Neglected by the Court – Section 24

➠ Matters Considered by the Court in Determining Compensation (Section 23):

Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 lays down the criteria for determining compensation to ensure that the affected person
receives fair and reasonable compensation for the acquired land. The matters considered by the court are as follows:

1. Market Value of the Land:

• The court must consider the market value of the land at the time of the publication of the notification under Section 4(1).
• The market value is determined based on:
o Recent sale transactions of similar properties,
o Location and surroundings,
o Potential for development,
o Current use of the land.

Page | 77
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

2. Damage to Standing Crops and Trees:

• The court considers any damage sustained by the landowner due to the acquisition of the land, including standing crops,
trees, or other properties on the land.

3. Damage Due to Severance:

• If the acquired land forms part of a larger estate, the court considers the damage caused to the remaining land due to the
separation or severance of the acquired portion.

4. Injurious Affection:

• Compensation is also considered for any injurious affection to other property of the claimant, which may arise from the use of
the acquired land for public purposes.
• Example: If the remaining land loses its access to a main road due to the acquisition, compensation for such loss is considered.

5. Damage Due to Change of Residence or Business:

• If the acquisition forces the landowner to vacate their residence or business, the court considers the cost of resettlement or
relocation.

6. Expenses for Re-establishment:

• The court takes into account the expenses incurred for re-establishing business or residence at a new location.

7. Additional Compensation (15% Solatium):

• Under Section 23(2), an additional amount of 15% on the market value of the land is awarded as solatium, which serves as
compensation for the compulsory nature of the acquisition.

8. Interest on Compensation Amount:

• The court may also award interest on the compensation amount from the date of possession until the final payment is made.

Page | 78
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Matters Neglected by the Court in Determining Compensation (Section 24):

Section 24 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 specifies the matters that must be neglected by the court while determining
compensation. These matters are considered irrelevant as they do not reflect the true value of the acquired property. The matters
neglected are as follows:

1. Urgency of Acquisition:

• The court does not consider the urgency or special need of the acquiring authority to complete the acquisition.
• The focus remains on the fair market value, not the urgency or necessity of the acquisition.

2. Speculative Increase in Value:

• The court neglects any increase in the value of the land that is directly attributed to the intended acquisition.
• Example: If the market value of land increases due to the announcement of a public project, such speculative increase is
disregarded.

3. Potential Use for Future Projects:

• The court does not consider the potential use of the land for future projects.
• Compensation is determined based on the current use and value, not on the speculative future use.

4. Personal Sentiments or Attachments:

• The court ignores any sentimental attachment the landowner may have with the land.
• Compensation is assessed objectively based on market value, without considering emotional or sentimental factors.

5. Increase in Value Due to the Acquisition:

• Any increase in the value of the land that results from the proposed project itself is not taken into account.
• Example: If the land is acquired for a highway project, the value of adjoining land may increase, but such increase is not
considered for compensation purposes.

Page | 79
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

6. Income from the Land After Acquisition:

• The court does not consider the income or benefits the acquiring authority might gain from the land after its acquisition.
• Compensation is based solely on the market value at the time of notification, not on potential future earnings.

7. Loss of Profits or Business:

• The court neglects any claim for loss of profits or business that might result from the acquisition.
• Compensation is restricted to the market value of the land and damages sustained directly due to the acquisition.

➠ Comparison of Matters Considered and Neglected:

Matters Considered (Section 23) Matters Neglected (Section 24)

Market value of the land Urgency of acquisition
Damage to crops and trees Speculative increase in value
Severance damages Potential future use
Injurious affection Personal sentiments or attachments
Relocation expenses Increase in value due to the acquisition
Solatium (15%) Income from land post-acquisition
Interest on compensation Loss of profits or business

➠ Conclusion:

Sections 23 and 24 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 provide a comprehensive framework for determining the amount of
compensation payable for acquired land. While Section 23 lays down the matters to be considered, Section 24 enumerates the matters
to be neglected to ensure that the compensation remains fair, reasonable, and justifiable. The emphasis remains on the market value,
direct losses, and legitimate claims, excluding speculative or emotional factors.

Page | 80
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the difference between a reference to the court made under section 18 and section 30 of the land acquisition act.
Q: What do you mean by Reference to Court under section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894? What are the grounds relevant
to be taken for filing of reference?
Q: What is reference to the court? What is the procedure of filling the reference?

➠ Introduction:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 provides the legal procedure for the acquisition of private land for public purposes and the
determination of compensation for affected landowners. After the Award is made by the Land Acquisition Collector, if any party is
dissatisfied with the award, they have the right to seek a Reference to the Court.

A Reference to the Court allows the affected party to challenge the amount of compensation, apportionment of compensation, or
measurement of the land. The provisions for making a reference are provided under Sections 18 and 30 of the Act.

➠ Relevant Provisions:

• Reference to Court – Section 18

• Procedure of Filing Reference – Section 19
• Reference on Dispute as to Apportionment – Section 30

➠ What is Reference to the Court?

A Reference to the Court under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 is a legal process by which the aggrieved party can challenge the
Award made by the Land Acquisition Collector (LAC) before a Civil Court.

• The reference can be made if the party is dissatisfied with the amount of compensation, apportionment of compensation, or
measurement of the land.
• The objective is to allow the court to review and adjudicate the award and ensure that the compensation is fair and just.

➠ Procedure of Filing the Reference (Section 19):

The procedure for filing a Reference to the Court is provided under Section 19 of the Act. The procedure involves the following steps:

Page | 81
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

1. Application to the Collector:

• The aggrieved party must submit a written application to the Collector, requesting him to make a reference to the court.
• The application must state the grounds for objection against the Award.

2. Time Limit for Filing Reference:

• The application must be filed within:

o Six weeks from the date of receiving the notice of the Award under Section 12(2), or
o Six months from the date of the Collector’s Award, whichever period first expires.

3. Contents of Application:

The application for reference must clearly state:

• The name of the applicant and their interest in the land,

• The details of the land acquired,
• The grounds for objection (e.g., inadequacy of compensation, incorrect measurement, etc.),
• The amount of compensation claimed.

4. Forwarding of Reference by Collector:

• The Collector examines the application and prepares a statement of facts.

• The reference, along with the statement of facts, is then forwarded to the court.

5. Notice to Interested Persons:

• The court issues notices to the interested persons and the Collector, informing them about the reference.

6. Hearing of Reference:

• The court conducts a hearing of the reference and considers the evidence presented by both parties.
• The court has the authority to:

Page | 82
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o Reassess the compensation,

o Review the measurement of land,
o Determine the apportionment of compensation.

7. Decision of the Court:

• The court may confirm, modify, or set aside the award of the Collector.
• The decision of the court is final and binding, subject to the right of appeal.

➠ Grounds for Filing a Reference under Section 18:

A reference under Section 18 can be filed on the following grounds:

1. Inadequacy of Compensation:

• If the claimant believes that the compensation awarded is insufficient based on the market value of the land.

2. Incorrect Measurement of Land:

• If there is a dispute regarding the measurement or extent of the acquired land.

3. Dispute Over Apportionment:

• If there is a disagreement among the claimants regarding the distribution of compensation.

4. Non-consideration of Damages:

• If the Collector fails to consider damages or losses sustained by the landowner due to the acquisition.

5. Interest and Solatium:

• If the claimant contends that the interest or additional compensation (15% solatium) was not properly calculated.

Page | 83
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Reference under Section 30:

Section 30 deals with a specific type of reference related to the apportionment of compensation among different claimants.

• This section applies when there is a dispute regarding the apportionment of the compensation awarded by the Collector.
• The Collector can refer the matter to the court to determine the share of each claimant in the awarded compensation.
• Unlike Section 18, which primarily deals with the quantum of compensation, Section 30 focuses on distribution among
multiple claimants.

➠ Difference Between Section 18 and Section 30:

Basis Section 18 Section 30

Nature of Challenges the amount of compensation, measurement Deals specifically with disputes regarding the
Reference of land, or other objections related to the Award. apportionment of compensation among claimants.
Grounds for Inadequacy of compensation, incorrect measurement, Dispute over the distribution of compensation
Reference non-consideration of damages, etc. among joint owners or interested persons.
Who Can Any interested person aggrieved by the Award. The Collector or any party with a dispute regarding
Apply? apportionment.
Time Limit Must be filed within 6 weeks or 6 months, as applicable. No specific time limit mentioned.
Jurisdiction Civil Court assesses the quantum of compensation and Civil Court determines the apportionment among
measurement of land. claimants.

➠ Conclusion:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 provides a comprehensive mechanism for addressing disputes arising from the acquisition process.
Sections 18 and 30 serve distinct purposes:

• Section 18 allows for a reference to the court when the claimant is dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation,
measurement, or damages.
• Section 30 provides a remedy for disputes regarding the apportionment of compensation among multiple claimants.

Both provisions ensure that the aggrieved parties have the opportunity to seek judicial intervention and obtain a fair and equitable
determination of compensation.
Page | 84
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the procedure of acquisition of land in case of urgency as provided in the land acquisition act, 1894.
Q: What are the special powers granted in case of urgency as provided under section 17 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894?

➠ Introduction:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 primarily regulates how the government can acquire private land for public purposes. Normally, the
acquisition process follows a detailed procedure involving notifications, hearings, and awards. However, in urgent situations, the
government needs to acquire land quickly without following the full usual process.

To handle such situations, the Act provides special provisions under Section 17, which allow the government to take immediate
possession of land even before the formal compensation award is made. This is essential for projects where delay would cause harm or
loss to public interest.

➠ Relevant Provisions:

• Section 17: Special powers for urgent acquisition.

• Sections 4, 5, and 6 (briefly) for normal acquisition process (for comparison).

➠ Procedure of Acquisition of Land in Case of Urgency:

Normally, land acquisition involves:

• Section 4: Preliminary notification of intent to acquire land.

• Section 5: Declaration of land as required for public purpose.
• Section 6: Inquiry and objections by landowners.
• Section 7: Award of compensation by Collector.

In urgent cases, the government can skip or shorten these steps under Section 17 to take immediate possession. The detailed procedure
is as follows:

Page | 85
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

1. Declaration of Urgency (Section 17):

• The government or authorized officer issues a notification stating urgency for acquisition of land.
• This notification is usually made when there is an imminent threat to public safety, public interest, or national security, or
when delay would cause serious harm.

2. Immediate Possession of Land:

• The Collector is empowered to take possession of the land immediately after issuing the notification, even before the
compensation is decided.
• This means the landowner has to vacate the land quickly, allowing government projects to proceed without delay.

3. Payment of Compensation:

• The Collector must pay some amount of compensation to the landowner immediately.
• This payment is generally an advance or estimated compensation based on the market value of the land.
• The final compensation is determined later by the Collector after proper assessment.

4. Final Award and Compensation:

• After taking possession, the Collector completes the usual enquiry process under Sections 5 to 7 of the Act.
• The Collector then passes the final Award specifying the exact compensation amount.
• If the initial amount paid was less, the balance is paid; if it was more, the excess is adjusted.

➠ Special Powers Granted Under Section 17:

Section 17 gives the government some extraordinary powers in cases of urgency, which are explained below in simple words:

1. Power to Take Immediate Possession:

• The Collector can take possession of the land immediately without waiting for the usual inquiry or Award.
• This power is exceptional and is only used in genuine emergencies.

Page | 86
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

2. No Prior Inquiry Needed:

• The usual procedure of hearing objections and inquiries by the landowners is temporarily waived.
• This prevents any delay caused by objections or legal challenges before possession.

3. Advance Payment of Compensation:

• The Collector must pay some compensation immediately to the landowner, even if the final amount is not decided yet.
• This is to ensure that the owner is not left without any monetary benefit while the land is taken.

4. Protection Against Abuse:

• Though possession is immediate, the Act safeguards the landowner by requiring a final award after proper assessment.
• The landowner retains the right to challenge the compensation through legal means once the Award is made.

5. Limitation on Usage:

• This special power is used only in urgent public interest cases.

• It cannot be invoked for ordinary acquisitions or where urgency does not exist.

➠ Important Points to Remember:

• Urgency must be clearly stated in the government notification.

• Immediate possession is not permanent without final compensation and Award.
• Landowner’s right to compensation and legal remedies remain intact.
• The Collector must ensure fairness and transparency while exercising Section 17 powers.
• The purpose of Section 17 is to balance public interest with landowners' rights in emergency situations.

➠ Summary:

Normal Acquisition Process Urgent Acquisition Process (Section 17)

Preliminary notification under Section 4. Notification of urgency allowing immediate possession.
Inquiry and hearing of objections under Section 5 & 6. No prior inquiry or hearing before taking possession.

Page | 87
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Collector decides Award after inquiry. Collector takes possession and pays advance compensation
immediately.
Final Award is passed later determining exact Final Award is passed after possession to decide exact compensation.
compensation.
Compensation paid after Award. Advance compensation paid before Award.

➠ Conclusion:

Section 17 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 empowers the government to acquire land quickly in situations of urgency, bypassing
normal procedures to protect public interest and safety. It allows immediate possession and advance payment of compensation but
still ensures the landowner’s rights to final compensation and legal recourse.

This balance helps the government act swiftly in emergencies while maintaining fair treatment for landowners.

Page | 88
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the procedure of acquisition of land for companies as provided in Land Acquisition Act.

➠ Introduction:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 allows the government to acquire private land for public purposes. One such public purpose includes
land acquisition for companies, such as railway companies, electricity companies, or other government-authorized companies that need
land for their projects.

This process is governed by special provisions in the Act which ensure that the land required by these companies is acquired legally,
fairly, and with due compensation to the landowners.

➠ Acquisition of Land for Companies (Section 9 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894):

1. Who Can Apply for Acquisition on Behalf of Companies?

• Only a company authorized by the government can apply for land acquisition.
• This includes companies like railway companies, electricity companies, or any other company allowed by law to acquire
land for public purposes.

2. Application to the Government:

• The company must submit a formal application to the government (or the competent authority) requesting the acquisition of
specified land.
• The application must clearly mention:
o The purpose for which the land is needed,
o The exact location and description of the land.

3. Government’s Role:

• The government will consider the application carefully to ensure the purpose is indeed public or government-approved.
• If the government is satisfied, it will issue a notification under Section 4 of the Act, declaring the land to be acquired for the
company’s use.

Page | 89
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Procedure After Government Notification:

1. Declaration Under Section 4:

• The government publishes a public notice (Section 4) stating that a certain land is required for acquisition for the company’s
public work.
• This notice invites objections from any person interested in the land.

2. Objections and Inquiry (Section 5):

• Any person who owns or claims interest in the land can file objections against the acquisition.
• The Collector or authorized officer will hold an inquiry to hear objections and decide whether the land is indeed needed for the
stated purpose.

3. Declaration of Intended Acquisition (Section 6):

• If the Collector confirms that the acquisition is necessary, a declaration is issued under Section 6, which officially confirms the
government’s intention to acquire the land.

4. Notice to Landowners (Section 7):

• The Collector serves a notice to the landowners informing them about the proposed acquisition and compensation.

➠ Award of Compensation and Possession:

1. Award by Collector (Section 11):
• After valuation and consideration of evidence, the Collector will prepare an award fixing the amount of compensation payable
to the landowners.
• The award is announced publicly and sent to all interested parties.
2. Payment of Compensation:
• The company or government must pay the compensation amount promptly to the landowners.
• The payment acts as full settlement for the acquisition.

Page | 90
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

3. Taking Possession of Land:

• After the award and payment (or depositing the compensation amount in court if the owner refuses), the Collector or company
can take possession of the land for the company’s use.

➠ Special Considerations for Companies:

• The company must use the land only for the specified public purpose mentioned in the application and notification.
• Any misuse of the land may be challenged legally by the landowners or the government.
• The company is bound to follow the Land Acquisition Act’s procedures strictly to protect landowner rights.

➠ Summary of Procedure:

Step Details
Application by Company Company applies to government for land acquisition.
Government Notification (Section 4) Government issues public notice declaring land required.
Inquiry & Objections (Section 5) Hearing objections from landowners.
Declaration of Intent (Section 6) Government declares the intention to acquire land.
Notice to Landowners (Section 7) Inform landowners of acquisition and compensation.
Collector’s Award (Section 11) Collector fixes compensation amount.
Payment & Possession Compensation paid and land possession handed over.

➠ Conclusion:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 provides a clear and fair process for companies to acquire land for public projects. The government
supervises the entire procedure to ensure the land acquisition is necessary and compensation is fair. Landowners are protected by
rights to object, receive compensation, and seek legal remedies if required. This legal framework balances the needs of companies with
the rights of landowners effectively.

Page | 91
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is market value? How is market value determined? Explain.

➠ Introduction:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 provides a legal framework for the acquisition of private land for public purposes by the
government. When land is acquired, the government is required to pay compensation to the landowners. The compensation is
determined based on the market value of the land.

The concept of market value is crucial as it ensures that the landowner receives a fair and just amount for the land acquired. The
market value is determined based on specific factors and principles provided in the Act.

➠ Relevant Provisions of Land Acquisition Act, 1894:

• Section 23: Matters to be Considered in Determining Compensation

• Section 24: Matters to be Neglected in Determining Compensation
• Section 11: Award of Compensation
• Section 18: Reference to Court for Determination of Compensation

➠ What is Market Value?

• Market Value refers to the price at which the land could be sold in the open market by a willing seller to a willing buyer.
• It is the fair and reasonable value of the land, taking into consideration its location, condition, and potential use.
• The objective is to ensure that the landowner receives a fair price as if the land were sold in the open market under normal
circumstances.

➠ Determination of Market Value:

The Market Value of the acquired land is determined by considering various factors as outlined in the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
The following points explain how it is calculated:

1. Date of Publication of Notification (Section 4):

• The Market Value is calculated as of the date of publication of the notification under Section 4.

Page | 92
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• This means that any increase or decrease in value after this date is generally not considered.
• The aim is to provide consistency and fairness in valuation.

2. Factors to be Considered in Determination of Market Value (Section 23):

• The Market Value of the Land at the date of the publication of the notification.
• Damage sustained by the person interested due to the taking of any standing crops or trees.
• Damage due to severance of the land acquired from the owner's other property.
• Loss of earnings or profits due to the sudden acquisition, especially if the land was generating income.
• Any other loss resulting from the acquisition that affects the landowner.

3. Factors to be Neglected in Determination of Market Value (Section 24):

• Any increase in value of the land that occurred after the notification due to the project itself (like road construction).
• The urgency or necessity for the acquisition on the part of the acquiring authority.
• Any special suitability or adaptability of the land for a particular purpose if that suitability arises from the use of land already
acquired.
• Any improvement or enhancement made to the land after the notification to increase compensation.

➠ Methods of Determining Market Value:

a) Sale Deeds of Similar Land:

• The Collector examines recent sale deeds of similar land in the nearby area to calculate the market value.
• The average of the sale prices is often used to estimate the current value.
• Only authentic and registered sales are considered valid for this purpose.

b) Income Approach:

• The value is assessed based on the income generated by the land, such as rent or agricultural yield.
• This approach is common for commercial or agricultural lands.

Page | 93
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

c) Cost of Replacement:

• In cases where the acquired land has structures or buildings, the cost of constructing similar structures is taken into account.
• Depreciation of the building or structure is also calculated.

d) Expert Opinion:

• Sometimes, the opinion of valuers or experts is sought to determine the accurate market value.
• These experts assess the land considering location, usage, and demand.

➠ Collector’s Role in Determination (Section 11):

• The Collector is responsible for calculating the Market Value based on the above methods and factors.
• An Award is prepared specifying the amount to be paid to the landowner.
• The Award must be based on transparent and just calculations to avoid disputes.

➠ Dispute Regarding Market Value (Section 18):

• If the landowner is dissatisfied with the market value fixed by the Collector, they have the right to file a reference to the
court under Section 18.
• The court re-examines the valuation and may enhance the compensation if justified.
• This provides a legal remedy to the affected person, ensuring that justice is served.

➠ Factors Influencing Market Value in Practice:

• Location: Proximity to urban areas, roads, or commercial zones increases value.

• Land Use: Agricultural, residential, or commercial land has different valuation criteria.
• Physical Features: Presence of buildings, trees, or crops influences the value.
• Market Trends: Fluctuations in the real estate market are taken into account if relevant.

➠ Important Considerations:

• The valuation must be fair and reasonable.

Page | 94
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• The landowner’s rights to a reasonable market value are safeguarded under the Act.
• Any discrepancy in valuation can be challenged in court.

➠ Summary Table: Determination of Market Value

Factor Description Relevant Section

Date of Notification Value calculated from the date of notification under Section 4. Section 4
Considered Factors Market value, damages, severance, loss of earnings, other losses. Section 23
Neglected Factors Future increase, urgency, special suitability, improvements. Section 24
Methods of Valuation Sale deeds, income approach, cost of replacement, expert opinion. -
Role of Collector Fixes the market value and issues Award. Section 11
Legal Remedy Landowner can challenge the market value in court. Section 18

➠ Example of Market Value Determination:

• Suppose the government acquires a 10-acre plot of agricultural land for a public project.
• The market value of similar agricultural land in the area is PKR 1,000,000 per acre.
• Therefore, the basic compensation for the acquired land would be:
o 10 acres × PKR 1,000,000 = PKR 10,000,000.
• Additionally, compensation for any standing crops, trees, or structures on the land would also be included.

➠ Conclusion:

The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 provides a detailed mechanism for determining market value to ensure that landowners receive
fair compensation for their acquired land. The market value is assessed based on the prevailing market rate, potential use of the land,
and damages caused to the landowner. However, certain factors, such as sentimental value and speculative increases, are excluded from
consideration to maintain fairness and prevent inflated compensation claims.

Page | 95
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Under what provision of law, objections are heard for the land to be acquired coupled with the fact that the same is being
acquired for public purpose?

➠ Introduction:

Under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, the government is empowered to acquire private land for public purposes such as construction
of roads, schools, hospitals, and other development projects. However, before finalizing the acquisition, the Act provides a legal
opportunity to the landowners and interested persons to raise objections regarding the proposed acquisition. This ensures that the
rights of affected persons are safeguarded and their concerns are heard.

The procedure for filing and hearing objections is governed by the specific provision of the Act.

➠ Relevant Provisions of Land Acquisition Act, 1894:

• Section 4: Notification of Intended Acquisition

• Section 5: Hearing of Objections

➠ Notification of Intended Acquisition (Section 4):

• The acquisition process begins with the government issuing a public notification under Section 4 of the Act.
• The notification declares that the land is needed for a public purpose or for a company.
• The notification is published in the official gazette and local newspapers and is also affixed in the locality of the land.
• The purpose of the notification is to inform the public about the proposed acquisition and to provide them with an opportunity
to raise objections.

➠ Hearing of Objections (Section 5):

Provision of Law:

• The right to file objections against the acquisition is provided under Section 5 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.

Page | 96
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Who Can File Objections:

• Any person interested in the land, including the owner, tenant, or any person having an interest in the property, can file
objections.
• The objections must be filed within 30 days from the date of the notification under Section 4.

➠ Procedure for Filing Objections (Section 5):

• Written Objections: The objections must be filed in writing before the Collector within the specified period.
• Grounds of Objections: The objections can be raised on various grounds such as:
o The land is not suitable for the intended public purpose.
o The land is not required for the stated purpose.
o The acquisition is being made in bad faith.
o The proposed compensation is inadequate.

➠ Inquiry by the Collector (Section 5):

• Upon receiving the objections, the Collector is required to hold an inquiry.

• The inquiry provides a fair opportunity to the objectors to present their case.
• The Collector examines the validity of the objections and assesses whether the acquisition is necessary and justified.
• The Collector also verifies the purpose of acquisition to ensure that it is genuinely for a public purpose or for a company as
stated in the notification.

➠ Report of the Collector:

• After conducting the inquiry, the Collector prepares a report based on the objections.
• The report is submitted to the appropriate government authority for further consideration.
• The authority may:
o Accept the objections and cancel the acquisition, or
o Reject the objections and proceed with the acquisition, or
o Modify the acquisition plan as deemed appropriate.

Page | 97
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Final Decision and Declaration (Section 6):

• If the government is satisfied that the land is required for a public purpose or for a company, it issues a declaration under
Section 6.
• This declaration confirms the government’s intention to acquire the land despite the objections raised.
• The declaration must be made within one year from the date of the notification under Section 4.

➠ Summary Table: Filing and Hearing of Objections

Stage Details Relevant Section

Notification of Acquisition Government issues notification to acquire land. Section 4
Filing of Objections Interested persons can file objections in writing. Section 5
Inquiry by Collector Collector conducts inquiry to hear objections. Section 5
Report of Collector Report based on inquiry is submitted to the authority. Section 5
Final Decision Government issues final declaration to proceed or cancel acquisition. Section 6

➠ Important Points to Remember:

• 30 Days Period: Objections must be filed within 30 days from the notification under Section 4.
• Written Objections Only: Verbal objections are not considered valid under the Act.
• Public Purpose Verification: The Collector must confirm that the acquisition is for a genuine public purpose.
• Legal Remedy: If the objections are rejected, the affected person may seek legal remedy under Section 18 by filing a reference
to the court.

➠ Conclusion:

The procedure for hearing objections under Section 5 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 provides an important safeguard to protect
the rights of affected persons. It ensures that the voice of the landowner and interested parties is heard before the acquisition is
finalized. The Collector is required to conduct a fair inquiry and make a reasoned decision based on the objections. This mechanism
helps in maintaining transparency and fairness in the acquisition process.

Page | 98
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

SECTION C:

Page | 99
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What are the documents of which Registration is optional?

Q: What are the effects of non-registration of documents which require compulsory registration?
Q: Which of the documents are compulsorily registerable? Is there any law for re-registration of certain documents and
documents executed by several persons at different times? Please explain with examples.
Q: What are the documents of which the registration is compulsory?

Introduction:

The Registration Act, 1908 is a law in Pakistan that regulates the registration of certain documents, especially related to immovable
property (like land and buildings). Registration means officially recording a document with the government office called the Registrar.

Registration helps protect the rights of people involved in a transaction and makes the document legally strong and public. However,
not all documents must be registered; some documents require compulsory registration, while others are optional.

➠ Relevant Provisions Regarding Optional Registration:

Under the Registration Act, 1908, certain documents can be registered but it is not compulsory. These are called documents of which
registration is optional.

The main provisions are found in:

• Section 17: Documents of which registration is compulsory.

• Section 18: Documents of which registration is optional.
• Section 49: How optional registration is to be treated.

➠ Compulsory Registration of Documents (Section 17):

Certain documents must be compulsorily registered under the Registration Act, 1908. If these documents are not registered, they
cannot be accepted as evidence in court. The objective is to ensure transparency in transactions involving immovable property and
other legal matters.

Page | 100
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Documents Requiring Compulsory Registration Include:

1. Instruments of Gift of Immovable Property:

o A gift deed relating to immovable property must be registered to validate the transfer of ownership.
o Example: A father gifting his house to his daughter through a gift deed.
2. Non-Testamentary Instruments Creating, Declaring, Assigning, Limiting, or Extinguishing Any Right, Title, or Interest
in Immovable Property:
o These include sale deeds, mortgage deeds, and leases for a term exceeding one year.
o Example: A sale deed for transferring ownership of agricultural land.
3. Non-Testamentary Instruments Acknowledging the Receipt or Payment of Consideration for the Transfer of Property:
o Any document evidencing the payment of consideration for the transfer of immovable property must be registered.
o Example: A receipt issued for the full payment of the purchase price of a house.
4. Leases of Immovable Property Exceeding One Year:
o Lease agreements involving immovable property for more than one year must be registered.
o Example: A three-year lease agreement for a commercial shop.
5. Decrees or Orders of Court Involving Immovable Property:
o Any decree or order passed by a court that affects the rights of immovable property must be registered.
o Example: A court order partitioning a jointly owned property among heirs.

➠ Effects of Non-Registration of Compulsory Documents:

Failure to register documents that require compulsory registration can result in significant legal consequences under Section 49 of the
Registration Act, 1908.

Main Effects Include:

1. Inadmissibility as Evidence:
o Unregistered documents cannot be presented as evidence in court to prove any transaction affecting immovable property.
o Example: An unregistered sale deed cannot establish ownership in a property dispute.
2. Loss of Title or Interest:
o The intended transfer of title or interest in immovable property becomes void if the document is not registered.
o Example: A mortgage deed that is not registered does not create any enforceable security interest.
3. No Legal Validity:
o The document becomes void against any subsequent registered document related to the same property.

Page | 101
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

4. Inability to Enforce Specific Performance:

o A party cannot file a suit for specific performance of an unregistered document involving immovable property.

➠ Optional Registration of Documents (Section 18):

The Registration Act, 1908 under Section 18 lists the documents whose registration is optional. These documents do not necessarily
have to be registered, but registration can add legal validity and provide official evidence.

1. Instruments Relating to Movable Property:

Under Section 18(a), any document that deals solely with movable property does not require mandatory registration. Examples
include:

• Bills of Exchange
• Promissory Notes
• Contracts for Sale of Goods

Since these documents pertain to movable assets, their registration is at the discretion of the parties involved.

2. Instruments Creating Rights Over Future Property:

Documents that deal with future property or property not yet in existence fall under Section 18(b).

• For instance, a document creating an interest in property that may be acquired later does not require compulsory registration.
• Such documents are optional since the property is not currently tangible or existent.

3. Leases for a Period of Less Than One Year:

According to Section 18(c), leases that do not exceed a period of one year do not require mandatory registration.

• This includes tenancy agreements or short-term leases.

• The registration of such documents is optional, as they are short-lived in nature.

4. Instruments Acknowledging Receipt of Payment:

Under Section 18(d), documents merely acknowledging the receipt of any consideration or payment do not require registration.

Page | 102
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• Examples include receipts for rent or payment vouchers.

• These are considered informal acknowledgments and are not compulsorily registrable.

5. Wills:
As per Section 18(e), Wills are not required to be registered.

• Registration is optional and can be done either during the lifetime of the testator or after their death.
• Registering a will, however, can prevent disputes regarding its authenticity.

6. Instruments Executed on Behalf of the Government:

Documents executed on behalf of the Government and related to movable property are optional for registration under Section 18(f).

• This includes government-issued orders or notices that do not affect immovable property.

7. Instruments Not Affecting Immovable Property:

Under Section 18(g), any document that does not affect immovable property does not necessarily require registration.

• These may include documents dealing with intellectual property rights, trademarks, or copyrights.
• Registration, in this case, is optional and based on the needs of the parties.

➠ Significance of Optional Registration:

While these documents do not require compulsory registration, registering them can:

• Act as conclusive proof of the transaction.

• Safeguard against fraud or future disputes.
• Provide an authentic record that is legally admissible in court.
• Enhance the credibility of the document.

➠ Re-Registration of Documents (Section 23A):

The Act provides for the re-registration of certain documents under specific conditions. This provision is particularly applicable to
documents executed by multiple persons at different times or in cases of defective registration.

Page | 103
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Provisions for Re-Registration Include:

1. Re-Registration in Case of Defective Registration:

o If a document is found to have a defect in its original registration, it may be re-registered to rectify the defect.
o Example: A sale deed registered with an incorrect address can be re-registered with the correct address.
2. Re-Registration for Documents Executed by Several Persons at Different Times:
o If a document is executed by multiple persons at different times, it can be re-registered after the final execution date.
o Example: A partnership deed signed by partners on different dates.

➠ Case Laws and Judicial Interpretations:

1. Muhammad Iqbal vs. Muhammad Aslam (2022):

o It was held that an unregistered sale deed cannot be admitted as evidence to claim ownership of immovable property.
2. Lal Khan vs. Ameer Ali (2019):
o The court emphasized that even if a document is presented as collateral evidence, it must be registered if it affects
immovable property.

➠ Conclusion:
The Registration Act, 1908 (Pakistan) plays a crucial role in ensuring transparency and authenticity in transactions involving
immovable property. The Act clearly specifies the documents requiring compulsory and optional registration, the consequences of
non-registration, and the provisions for re-registration to correct errors or omissions. Proper registration serves as a safeguard against
fraudulent claims and secures the rights of parties involved in property transactions.

Page | 104
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the principles regarding the time from which a registered document shall take effect.

Q: What are the law relating to the time and place, regarding the registration of a document?

Introduction:

The Registration Act, 1908 regulates the process of registering important legal documents, mainly those involving immovable
property (like land, houses). Two very important rules are about:

• When the document should be registered (Time), and

• Where the document should be registered (Place).

These rules help make sure documents are registered properly, protecting all parties involved and making sure records are kept in an
orderly manner.

➠ Relevant Provisions Regarding Time and Place of Registration:

The main sections of the Registration Act, 1908 dealing with time and place are:

• Section 19: Time of presentation of documents for registration.

• Section 20: Place of registration.
• Section 21: Presentation of documents outside proper registration office.
• Section 22: Rejection and return of documents presented at the wrong time or place.

➠ Section 19 – Time for Presenting Documents:

1. Four Months Time Limit:

• According to Section 19 of the Act, a document that must be registered must be presented to the Registrar within four
months from the date it was signed.
• This means the clock starts ticking on the day the document is signed by the parties involved.
• If the document is signed on 1st January, the last day to present it for registration is 30th April (4 months later).
• This period allows parties enough time to arrange for registration but encourages prompt action.

Page | 105
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

2. Why Four Months?

• The law wants documents to be registered quickly, so rights are publicly recorded.
• Prompt registration avoids disputes caused by delays.
• Late registration can cause legal uncertainty about ownership or rights.

3. What if Registration is Late?

• If a document is presented after 4 months, the Registrar can refuse to register it.
• The person who submitted the document must take it back.
• However, late presentation does not invalidate the document itself. It only means it will not be recorded officially.

4. Extension of Time:

• In some cases, the Registrar or courts may allow more time if the delay was due to a good reason.
• This is not automatic but can be granted on special circumstances like illness or unavoidable delay.
• Such extensions protect parties but should not be abused.

5. Importance of Timely Presentation:

• Timely presentation makes the document part of the official public record.
• This helps protect the rights of buyers, sellers, or other parties against third parties.
• Without registration within the time limit, the document may not be good evidence against third parties who register first.

➠ Section 20 – Place of Registration:

1. Proper Registration Office:

• Section 20 of the Act says the document must be presented at the proper registration office.
• The proper office is the one where the property related to the document is located.
• For example:
o If you sell a house in Karachi, the document must be registered at the Registrar’s office in Karachi.
o If the property is in Islamabad, the document must go to the Islamabad Registrar.

Page | 106
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

2. Why Must It Be Registered at Proper Place?

• Keeping documents at the location of the property helps the Registrar maintain organized and easy-to-access records.
• It prevents confusion over which Registrar office holds the official record.
• It helps courts and officials to check ownership easily.

3. What if the Document is Presented at the Wrong Place?

• Section 21 says if a document is wrongly presented at an incorrect Registrar’s office, the Registrar will return it without
registering.
• The person submitting the document must then take it to the correct office.
• The Registrar cannot register the document at the wrong office unless specifically authorized.

4. Sending the Document to Proper Office:

• In some cases, the Registrar may send the document to the correct office if allowed by law or the parties agree.
• Otherwise, it is the responsibility of the person who presented the document to take it to the proper office.

5. What if the Property Is Situated in Different Places?

• If the document involves property in different locations, the law generally requires separate registration in each proper
office.
• This means you may need to register parts of the document at different Registrar offices based on the property’s location.

➠ Section 21 – Documents Presented Outside Proper Registration Office:

• If a document is wrongly presented at the wrong Registrar’s office, the Registrar will return the document without registering
it.
• The document must then be presented at the correct office.
• The Registrar can send the document to the correct office for registration only if the law allows or if the parties agree.
• Otherwise, the document must be taken to the right place by the person presenting it.

Page | 107
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Section 22 – Rejection of Documents:

• If a document is presented after the allowed time (more than four months) or at the wrong place, the Registrar can refuse to
register it.
• The Registrar must return the document to the person who presented it.
• The refusal does not affect the validity of the document itself; it only means it is not registered.

➠ Practical Examples:

• Example 1:
Sale deed for land signed on 10th March in Lahore.
It must be presented to the Lahore Registrar’s office for registration by 9th July (within four months).
Presenting after this date or at any other city’s office will lead to refusal.
• Example 2:
Lease deed for a shop in Karachi signed on 1st February.
It must be presented at Karachi office within four months.
Presenting it in Islamabad office will cause return without registration.

Summary Table:

Aspect Rule Effect of Not Following

Time for Registration Within 4 months from signing date Registrar refuses registration
Place for Registration Registrar office where property is located Registrar returns document without registration
Late Registration Possible refusal, except if extension granted Document valid but unregistered
Wrong Place Submission Document returned, no registration Must present at correct office

Conclusion:

The Registration Act, 1908 clearly guides when (time) and where (place) documents must be registered. Following these rules helps
protect property rights and keeps public records organized and reliable.

If a document is presented late or at the wrong place, registration may be refused, but the document itself remains valid between the
parties involved.

Page | 108
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What are the duties and powers of Registering Officers?

Introduction:

The Registration Act, 1908 creates the role of Registering Officers, commonly called Registrars. These officers are responsible for
the registration of documents, mainly those related to immovable property (land, buildings).

The law gives these officers specific duties and powers so they can properly manage the registration process, protect parties’ rights,
and maintain official public records.

➠ Relevant Provisions About Duties and Powers of Registering Officers:

The key sections in the Registration Act related to the duties and powers of registering officers are:

• Section 5: Appointment of registering officers.

• Section 32: Duties related to presenting documents.
• Section 33: Powers regarding acceptance of documents.
• Section 34: Inquiry before registration.
• Section 35: Powers to refuse registration.
• Section 36-38: Enforcing appearance and admission of execution.
• Section 52-53: Maintaining records and registers.
• Section 58: Recording particulars in the register book.
• Section 68-70: Power to summon witnesses and enforce attendance.

➠ Section 5 – Appointment of Registering Officers:

• The government appoints Registering Officers to carry out registration work.

• They work in Registrar offices located in different areas (districts or sub-districts).
• They are responsible for registering all documents that require registration in their area.

➠ Duties of Registering Officers:

Page | 109
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

1. Receiving Documents for Registration (Section 32):

o The Registering Officer must receive documents presented for registration by the concerned parties or their authorized
representatives.
o Documents must be presented within four months of execution.
o The officer must ensure the document is presented at the proper office based on the location of the property.
2. Checking the Validity of Presentation (Section 34):
o The Registering Officer must verify whether:
▪ The document is presented by the right person.
▪ The presentation is within the time limit.
▪ All required fees and charges are paid.
o This ensures that only valid documents are accepted for registration.
3. Making an Inquiry Before Registration (Section 34):
o The officer must conduct an inquiry to ensure:
▪ The identities of the parties are confirmed.
▪ The document is genuine and not forged.
o The officer may question the executant to verify their identity and willingness.
4. Recording Admission of Execution (Section 35):
o The Registering Officer must obtain an admission of execution from the parties involved.
o If the parties deny execution or if doubts arise, the officer has the power to refuse registration.
o This prevents the registration of fraudulent documents.
5. Maintaining Records and Registers (Sections 52-53):
o The officer must maintain accurate registers of all registered documents.
o Details such as names, addresses, property description, and transaction details are recorded.
o This makes the records publicly accessible.
6. Giving Certified Copies (Section 57):
o The officer must provide certified copies of registered documents upon request.
o Certified copies serve as legal evidence in case the original is lost.

➠ Powers of Registering Officers:

1. Power to Refuse Registration (Section 35):

o The officer can refuse registration if:
▪ The document is forged or fake.

Page | 110
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

▪ The presentation is late or made by the wrong person.

▪ The parties deny executing the document.
o The officer must record reasons for refusal in the register.
2. Power to Summon Witnesses (Sections 36-38):
o The officer can summon witnesses to verify the identity and execution of documents.
o If necessary, the officer can enforce the appearance of witnesses.
o This ensures that the truthfulness of the transaction is verified.
3. Power to Administer Oath (Section 34):
o The officer may administer an oath to parties or witnesses to verify the authenticity of statements.
o This helps in preventing false statements during the registration process.
4. Power to Examine Documents (Section 58):
o The officer has the power to examine the document to ensure it is properly stamped and executed.
o Documents lacking legal formalities (like proper stamps) may be rejected.
5. Power to Issue Summons (Sections 68-70):
o The officer can issue summons to compel the attendance of parties or witnesses.
o The officer can also issue orders for document production when needed.
6. Power to Inspect Books and Documents:
o The officer has the authority to inspect the registers and documents maintained at the registration office.
o This helps in auditing and verifying records regularly.

➠ Responsibilities after Registration:

• After registration, the officer must:

o Endorse a certificate of registration on the document.
o Record all relevant details in the register.
o Return the document to the person who presented it after completion.
• This ensures that the registered document is officially recorded and secured.

Page | 111
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Summary:

Duty/Power Explanation Relevant Section

Receiving and Verifying Documents Ensure proper presentation, identity, and fees Section 32, 34
Conducting Inquiry Verify authenticity and identity Section 34
Refusal of Registration Deny registration if irregularities are found Section 35
Summoning Witnesses Call witnesses to verify facts Sections 36-38
Maintaining Records and Registers Record and maintain all registered documents Sections 52-53
Issuing Certified Copies Provide official copies of registered documents Section 57
Issuing Summons and Administering Oath Enforce appearance and verify truthfulness Sections 68-70

Conclusion:

The duties and powers of Registering Officers are crucial for ensuring the authenticity, legality, and proper recording of documents
under the Registration Act, 1908. They act as gatekeepers to verify that documents are properly executed and genuinely presented.

These officers ensure that the registration process is transparent and reliable, maintaining public trust in official records. They also
have the power to refuse and investigate documents that appear fraudulent or improperly presented, thereby protecting property rights
and legal transactions.

Page | 112
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is the remedy available to the person aggrieved by the orders of sub-registrar?
Q: What is the remedy available to the person aggrieved by the order of the registrar?

Q: What is the procedure to register a document if Sub-registrar refuses to register the same? Please discuss it in detail.

Introduction:

The Registration Act, 1908 lays down the procedures and rules for the registration of documents relating to immovable property
and other essential transactions. In some cases, a Sub-Registrar or Registrar may refuse to register a document due to various
reasons such as incomplete execution, lack of authority, fraud, or forgery.

However, the Act provides specific remedies to the aggrieved person to challenge such refusals and seek registration through legal
means. The remedies are structured to ensure that the refusal is not arbitrary or unjustified and that the parties have a fair opportunity
to present their case.

➠ Relevant Provisions Regarding Remedies for Refusal to Register a Document:

The relevant provisions under the Registration Act, 1908 that deal with the remedies for refusal to register a document by the Sub-
Registrar and Registrar are as follows:

• Section 32: Presentation of documents for registration.

• Section 72: Appeal to the Registrar against the order of the Sub-Registrar.
• Section 73: Application to the Registrar in case of refusal by the Sub-Registrar.
• Section 74: Order of refusal by the Registrar.
• Section 75: Procedure after the order of refusal.
• Section 77: Civil suit for decree directing registration.

➠ Remedy Against the Order of Sub-Registrar Refusing Registration:

1. Section 71 – Reasons for Refusal to Register:

• If a Sub-Registrar refuses to register a document, he is required to record the reasons for such refusal in writing.
• The Sub-Registrar must:

Page | 113
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o Clearly state the grounds of refusal.

o Provide a copy of the order to the person presenting the document.
o Make an entry in the book of refusal maintained at the registration office.

Purpose:

• The purpose of this provision is to ensure transparency and accountability in the registration process.
• It allows the aggrieved person to understand the specific grounds of refusal and to prepare a proper application for appeal.

2. Section 72 – Application to the Registrar:

• If the Sub-Registrar refuses to register a document, the aggrieved person can file an application to the Registrar within 30
days from the date of refusal.
• This application serves as a first step to challenge the refusal and must be filed in writing.

Procedure to File the Application:

1. Preparation of the Application:

o The application must include:
▪ Name of the applicant.
▪ Description of the document refused for registration.
▪ Date of refusal by the Sub-Registrar.
▪ Grounds of refusal as stated by the Sub-Registrar.
▪ Reasons for challenging the refusal.
2. Submission to the Registrar:
o The application must be filed before the Registrar of the district in which the Sub-Registrar is situated.
o The applicant must attach the original document along with a copy of the refusal order issued by the Sub-Registrar.
3. Hearing by the Registrar:
o Upon receiving the application, the Registrar will issue a notice to the Sub-Registrar to present his reasons for refusal.
o The Registrar may also:
▪ Call witnesses to verify the authenticity of the document.
▪ Examine evidence related to the execution of the document.
▪ Record statements of the parties involved.

Page | 114
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

▪ Review the grounds of refusal.

4. Decision by the Registrar:
o After considering all evidence and hearing both parties, the Registrar may:
▪ Confirm the refusal if he finds it justified.
▪ Order the Sub-Registrar to register the document if the refusal is found to be arbitrary or unjustified.
o The Registrar must record his decision in writing and provide a copy to the applicant.

Important Points:

• The application must be filed within 30 days of the refusal by the Sub-Registrar.
• If the applicant fails to apply within this time, the right to challenge the refusal before the Registrar is lost.
• The decision of the Registrar at this stage is final, but further remedy is available under Section 77.

3. Section 73 – Procedure before the Registrar:

• The procedure for dealing with an application under Section 72 is detailed in Section 73.
• The Registrar has the authority to:
o Summon witnesses for verification of the document.
o Examine records and other evidence related to the execution of the document.
o Hear both the applicant and the Sub-Registrar to understand the reasons for refusal.

Registrar’s Order:

• After conducting a thorough enquiry, the Registrar will:

o Issue an order in writing, either confirming or reversing the refusal by the Sub-Registrar.
o The order must be communicated to the applicant promptly.

4. Section 75 – Procedure After Order of Refusal:

• If the Registrar confirms the refusal of the Sub-Registrar, the aggrieved person can:
o File a civil suit under Section 77.

Page | 115
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Filing the Civil Suit:

• The civil suit must be filed within 30 days from the date of the Registrar’s refusal order.
• The suit must include:
o Copy of the refusal order by the Registrar.
o Details of the document refused for registration.
o Grounds for seeking registration.

5. Section 77 – Civil Suit for Decree Directing Registration:

• The final remedy against the refusal of both the Sub-Registrar and the Registrar is to file a civil suit in the civil court.
• The suit must be filed within 30 days from the Registrar’s refusal order.

Procedure for Filing the Suit:

• The aggrieved person must:

o Prepare a plaint with details of the refusal by both the Sub-Registrar and Registrar.
o Attach the original document and copies of the refusal orders.
o Provide evidence and witnesses to prove that the document was duly executed and that the refusal was unjustified.

Court’s Decree:

• If the court finds the refusal to be unjustified, it will issue a decree directing the Sub-Registrar to register the document.
• The decree is binding on the Sub-Registrar, who must register the document as per the court’s order.

Important Points to Note:

• Time Limits:
o Application to Registrar: 30 days from Sub-Registrar’s refusal.
o Civil Suit: 30 days from Registrar’s refusal.
• Effect of Registrar’s Order:
o The order of the Registrar is final at the administrative level.
o If the Registrar confirms the refusal, the only remedy is to file a civil suit under Section 77.

Page | 116
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• Evidence Required:
o The applicant must present evidence of execution, identification, and verification of the document.
o Witnesses may be called to confirm the authenticity of the document.

➠ Remedy Against the Order of Registrar Refusing Registration:

If the Registrar refuses to register a document, the only remedy available to the aggrieved person is to file a civil suit under Section
77. This is the final and decisive remedy provided under the Act.

1. Civil Suit for Decree Directing Registration (Section 77):

• Section 77 of the Registration Act, 1908 provides a remedy to a person whose document has been refused registration by the
Registrar.
• The aggrieved person can file a civil suit in a civil court of competent jurisdiction for a decree directing the registration of the
document.

Time Limit to File a Civil Suit:

• The civil suit must be filed within 30 days from the date of the Registrar’s refusal.
• If the suit is not filed within the specified time, the right to seek registration is lost, and the refusal becomes final and binding.

Procedure for Filing a Civil Suit Under Section 77:

The following is the detailed procedure for filing a civil suit under Section 77:

1. Drafting of the Plaint:

• The aggrieved person must prepare a written application (plaint) that includes:
o Details of the document refused registration.
o Grounds for refusal as stated by the Registrar.
o Facts and reasons why the document should be registered.
o A request to the court to issue a decree directing registration.

Page | 117
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

2. Attachment of Documents:

• The plaint must be accompanied by:

o A copy of the document that was refused registration.
o The order of refusal by the Registrar.
o Any other evidence supporting the claim, such as witnesses, affidavits, or property documents.

3. Filing the Suit in the Competent Court:

• The suit must be filed in the civil court of the area where the property is located or where the document was presented for
registration.

4. Court Proceedings and Evidence:

• The court will:

o Examine the plaint and evidence submitted by the aggrieved person.
o Call witnesses to testify regarding the authenticity of the document.
o Allow the Registrar to present reasons for refusing registration.
o Record statements of both parties.

5. Court’s Decree:

• After examining the evidence and hearing both parties, the court will:
o Determine the validity of the document.
o Verify the grounds of refusal by the Registrar.
o Pass a decree directing the Registrar to register the document if it finds that the refusal was unjustified.

6. Execution of Decree:

• The aggrieved person must submit the decree to the Registrar within 30 days of the court’s order.
• The Registrar is legally bound to comply with the decree and proceed with the registration.

Page | 118
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Powers of the Civil Court Under Section 77:

• The court has the authority to:

o Examine the entire transaction and the validity of the document.
o Summon witnesses and evidence to verify the execution of the document.
o Review the Registrar’s grounds of refusal to assess whether they were valid.
o Issue a decree for registration if the court is satisfied that the refusal was not justified.
o Reject the plaint if the aggrieved person fails to establish the authenticity of the document or fails to comply with the
legal requirements.

Grounds for Filing a Civil Suit Under Section 77:

A civil suit under Section 77 can be filed on the following grounds:

• The Registrar erroneously refused registration despite proper execution and presentation of the document.
• The refusal was based on unreasonable grounds or suspicion.
• The refusal was based on misinterpretation of law or facts.
• The document was refused registration due to clerical or procedural errors.

Important Points to Note:

• The civil suit under Section 77 is a comprehensive remedy that allows the court to examine the entire transaction and the
validity of the document.
• The court can override the order of the Registrar if it finds that the refusal was based on irrelevant or unjustified grounds.
• The decree issued by the court is binding upon the Registrar, and the Registrar is obligated to comply with the court’s
directions.
• If the aggrieved person fails to file the civil suit within 30 days, the right to seek registration is extinguished, and the Registrar’s
refusal becomes final.

Page | 119
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Summary Table:

Remedy Relevant Time Authority Outcome

Section Limit
Application to Registrar Section 72 30 days Registrar Registrar may confirm or reverse the refusal of the Sub-
Registrar.
Civil Suit after Registrar’s Section 77 30 days Civil Court Court may pass a decree directing registration.
Refusal

Conclusion:

The Registration Act, 1908 provides comprehensive remedies to a person aggrieved by the refusal to register a document. The aggrieved
person can initially apply to the Registrar under Section 72 if the Sub-Registrar refuses registration. If the Registrar also refuses, the
aggrieved person can file a civil suit under Section 77.

The Act ensures that the rights of the parties are protected by providing multiple levels of remedies, allowing the court to examine
the evidence and determine whether the refusal was justified or arbitrary. These provisions maintain the integrity and fairness of the
registration process.

Page | 120
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the law relating to the deposit of Wills under Registration Act, 1908.
Q: What is the procedure of registration of Wills, as provided in the Registration Act 1908?

Introduction:

The Registration Act, 1908 provides specific provisions for the deposit and registration of Wills. Although the registration of a Will
is optional, depositing it ensures safe custody and authenticity. The Act outlines the procedure for depositing a Will during the
testator’s lifetime and the process for opening and registering the Will after the testator’s death.

➠ Relevant Provisions Regarding Wills:

The provisions relating to the deposit and registration of Wills are:

• Section 40: Presentation of Wills for deposit.

• Section 41: Deposit of Wills.
• Section 42: Withdrawal of Wills.
• Section 43: Procedure after death of testator.
• Section 44: Registration of Wills after death.
• Section 45: Procedure for opening the Will.

1. Deposit of Wills (Section 40 and 41):

• Who Can Deposit:

o The testator himself (the person making the Will).
o The executor or any authorized person on behalf of the testator.
• Procedure for Deposit:
o The Will must be presented in a sealed cover.
o The cover must be endorsed with the name of the testator and the nature of the document.
o The testator must present the Will in person to the Registrar.
o The Registrar shall:
▪ Receive the sealed cover.
▪ Enter the particulars of the Will in the register of deposits.
▪ Issue a receipt to the testator.

Page | 121
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• Purpose of Deposit:
o Ensures safe custody and confidentiality of the Will.
o Prevents tampering or destruction of the document.

2. Withdrawal of Wills (Section 42):

• Right to Withdraw:
o The testator may withdraw the Will at any time during his lifetime.
• Procedure for Withdrawal:
o The testator must:
▪ Apply in person to the Registrar.
▪ Present the receipt issued at the time of deposit.
▪ Establish his identity to the satisfaction of the Registrar.
o The Registrar shall:
▪ Verify the identity of the testator.
▪ Return the sealed cover to the testator.
▪ Make a note of the withdrawal in the register of deposits.

3. Procedure After Death of Testator (Section 43):

• Application to Open the Will:

o After the death of the testator, the executor or beneficiary may apply for the opening of the Will.
o The applicant must:
▪ Submit proof of death (e.g., death certificate).
▪ Provide evidence of identity and relationship to the deceased.
• Registrar’s Role:
o The Registrar shall:
▪ Open the sealed cover in the presence of the applicant.
▪ Record the opening of the Will in the register.
▪ Proceed with the registration of the Will, if requested.

Page | 122
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

4. Registration of Wills after Death (Section 44):

• Procedure for Registration:

o If the Will is not previously registered, it may be presented for registration after the testator’s death.
o The applicant must:
▪ Prove the death of the testator.
▪ Establish the authenticity of the Will through witnesses or evidence.
• Registrar’s Role:
o The Registrar will:
▪ Examine the Will for validity.
▪ Record statements of witnesses, if necessary.
▪ Register the Will and issue a certificate of registration.

5. Opening of the Will (Section 45):

• Procedure:
o Upon the death of the testator, the sealed cover will be opened in the presence of:
▪ The applicant (executor or beneficiary).
▪ Any interested parties or their representatives.
o The Registrar will:
▪ Open the cover and read the contents of the Will.
▪ Record the opening of the Will in the register.
▪ Proceed with the registration, if requested.

Conclusion:

The Registration Act, 1908 provides a detailed procedure for the deposit and registration of Wills, ensuring that the Will remains
safe and confidential during the lifetime of the testator and is duly opened and registered after the testator’s death. The provisions
are designed to prevent tampering, establish authenticity, and provide a clear process for claiming the benefits under the Will.

Page | 123
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

SECTION D:

Page | 124
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What do you understand by domicile? How a new domicile be acquired?

➠ Introduction:
Domicile is an important legal concept in succession law because it decides which law will apply to a person's property after they die.
In simple words, domicile means the place where a person has their permanent home or intends to live forever. It helps to decide how
a person's property will be distributed when they pass away.

➠ What is Domicile?:
Domicile is the country or place where a person has their permanent home and where they intend to stay indefinitely. It is not just
about where a person lives temporarily but where they want to live permanently or for a very long time. Everyone has a domicile for
legal purposes.

➠ General Provisions about Domicile under the Succession Act, 1925:

1. Meaning of Domicile:
The Succession Act, 1925, refers to domicile to decide which law governs inheritance and succession rights. It means the
country where the deceased person had their permanent home or principal residence.
2. Purpose of Domicile:
The law uses domicile to find out which country's rules of inheritance apply to the deceased's property.
3. Types of Domicile:
o Domicile of Origin: This is the place where a person is considered domiciled at birth, usually the father’s domicile for
a child.
o Domicile of Choice: This is when a person moves to a new place with the intention to live there permanently or
indefinitely.
o Domicile of Dependence: For example, a child or a married woman may have the domicile of the person on whom
they depend.

➠ How is a New Domicile Acquired?:

According to the Succession Act and general principles of law, a new domicile is acquired by fulfilling two conditions:

Page | 125
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

1. Physical Residence:
The person must actually live in the new place. Merely planning or thinking about moving is not enough. The person must
physically be in the new country or place.
2. Intention to Reside Permanently:
The person must have the intention to make the new place their permanent home or at least to stay there indefinitely. This
intention must be genuine and clear.

➠ Grounds for Acquiring a New Domicile:

The main grounds on which a person can acquire a new domicile are:

1. Change of Residence:
The person moves to a new place with the purpose to live there for a long time.
2. Intention to Reside Permanently:
Along with the move, the person must intend to make the new place their permanent or long-term home.
3. Capacity to Acquire Domicile:
The person must be legally capable of changing domicile (for example, minors usually have the domicile of their parents).
4. Absence of Fixed Time Requirement:
There is no fixed period of time a person must live in a new place to acquire domicile. It depends on the person's intention and
circumstances.
5. Not Mere Temporary Stay:
If a person stays in a place temporarily (like for work, studies, or vacation), it does not change their domicile.

➠ Relevant Provisions under the Succession Act 1925:

• Section 3 - Domicile for Succession:

A person’s domicile at the time of their death determines the law governing their succession (inheritance).
• Section 5 - Acquisition of New Domicile:
A new domicile is acquired by a person when they reside in a new place with the intention of living there permanently.
Simply living somewhere temporarily does not change the domicile.
• Section 7 - Domicile of Minor:
A minor’s domicile depends on the domicile of their father if the parents are married; if not, the mother’s domicile is
considered. A minor cannot acquire a new domicile on their own.

Page | 126
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• Section 9 - Effect of Change of Domicile:

When a person acquires a new domicile, all future personal matters, such as inheritance, marriage, and legal obligations, will
be governed by the law of the new domicile.

➠ Explanation in Simple Words:

• Domicile is like a "home base" that decides which country's law applies to important personal matters.
• If you move to a new country and want to live there forever, your domicile changes.
• You must actually live there and have the strong intention to stay there for a long time, not just for a holiday or short job.
• Children’s domicile depends on their parents until they become adults.
• When a person dies, the law of their domicile decides who inherits their property.

➠ Important Points to Remember:

• A person can only have one domicile at a time.

• If a person leaves their original domicile but does not intend to stay in the new place forever, their original domicile continues.
• Courts look carefully at the person’s actions and statements to decide if they truly changed their domicile.
• Domicile affects the law that will apply to inheritance and distribution of property after death.

➠ Summary in Simple Words:

• Domicile means where a person’s permanent home is.

• To get a new domicile, you must live somewhere new and want to stay there permanently.
• Just living somewhere temporarily doesn’t change your domicile.
• This idea helps to decide which country’s inheritance laws will apply after someone dies.

Page | 127
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Discuss the Law relating to will as provided in Succession Act.

Q: Explain the procedure of construction of Wills as envisaged under Succession Act, 1925.

➠ Introduction:
A Will is a legal document in which a person, called the testator, declares how their property should be distributed after their death.
The Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan) provides rules about making a valid Will and how Wills are interpreted if there is any confusion
about their meaning. Understanding these rules is important to ensure the testator’s wishes are properly followed.

➠ Relevant Provisions on Law Relating to Will under Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan):

• Section 57: A Will is a legal written declaration of how a person wants their property distributed after death.
• Section 58: A Will must be signed by the testator and witnessed by at least two witnesses.
• Section 62: The testator can revoke (cancel) the Will by destroying it or making a new one.
• Section 63: The intention to revoke must be clear; accidental damage is not enough to revoke a Will.

➠ Law Relating to Will:

1. Definition of a Will:
A Will is a written statement in which a person says who should get their property after death.
2. Who Can Make a Will:
Any person who is an adult and of sound mind can make a Will.
3. How to Make a Will:

• It must be written.
• The testator must sign it or have someone sign it for them in their presence.
• It must be signed by at least two witnesses who saw the testator sign it.

4. Revoking a Will:
A Will can be canceled by the testator any time before death, either by making a new Will or by destroying the old one
intentionally.
5. Validity of Will:
The Will must be made freely without pressure or fraud and must follow the legal formalities to be valid.

Page | 128
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Relevant Provisions on Construction of Wills under Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan):

• Section 76: If the Will’s wording is unclear, the court tries to understand what the testator intended.
• Section 77: The whole Will should be read together to understand the testator’s true wishes.

➠ Procedure of Construction of Wills:

1. Reading the Whole Will:

The entire Will is read to find out the testator’s real intentions.
2. Meaning of Words:
Words are given their normal meaning unless it is clear the testator meant something different.
3. Considering All Parts Together:
No part of the Will is interpreted alone; the entire document is looked at to understand the message.
4. Focusing on the Testator’s Intentions:
The main goal is to do what the testator wanted, even if the wording is not perfect.
5. Avoiding Technical Mistakes:
The court tries not to cancel a Will because of small technical errors, focusing on the real meaning.
6. Use of Outside Evidence:
If the Will’s words are unclear, other evidence such as letters or statements can be used to explain the testator’s wishes.

➠ Explanation in Simple Words:

• A Will tells who gets your property after you die.

• To make a valid Will, you must be an adult and mentally capable.
• The Will must be written, signed by you, and witnessed by two people.
• You can cancel or change your Will anytime before death.
• If the Will is unclear, the court will carefully read it all and try to understand your true wishes.
• The court tries to focus on what you wanted rather than small wording problems.
• Sometimes, the court may look at other evidence to understand unclear parts.

Page | 129
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Conclusion:
In conclusion, the Succession Act 1925 clearly lays down the rules for making a valid Will and the method for interpreting it if there
is any doubt. A valid Will must be written, signed, and witnessed, and can be revoked or changed anytime before death. When the
Will’s language is unclear, the court carefully interprets the entire document to honor the true intentions of the testator. These
provisions ensure that the testator’s property is distributed according to their wishes and provide legal certainty and protection to heirs
and beneficiaries. Understanding these rules is essential for anyone planning their estate or dealing with inheritance matters.

Page | 130
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What are the contents of the succession certificate? Explain in detail?

Q: What are the contents of application for the succession certificate?

➠ Introduction:
A Succession Certificate is a legal document issued by a court that authorizes a person, usually a legal heir or nominee, to collect
debts, money, or securities owed to a deceased person. This certificate is important because it helps avoid disputes and protects the
holder from legal claims while collecting such debts or securities. The procedure and contents of a Succession Certificate are governed
by the Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan). In this answer, we will discuss the detailed contents of the Succession Certificate and the
contents of the application for it, with relevant legal provisions and simple explanations.

➠ Relevant Provisions under Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan):

• Section 370: This section empowers civil courts to issue Succession Certificates to the legal heirs or nominees of a deceased
person to collect debts and securities due to the deceased.
• Section 371: This section outlines who can apply for the Succession Certificate and the basic procedure for application.
• Section 372: This section describes what details must be included in both the Succession Certificate itself and the application
for it.

➠ Contents of the Succession Certificate:

The Succession Certificate issued by the court must clearly state the following details:

1. Name of the Court:

The certificate begins by naming the court that has issued it, such as the Civil Court or District Court.
2. Name of the Deceased:
It clearly mentions the full name of the deceased person whose debts and securities are involved.
3. Date of Death:
The exact date on which the deceased person died is stated to confirm the timeline.
4. Names of the Legal Heirs or Applicants:
The certificate names the legal heir(s) or the person(s) to whom the certificate is granted. These individuals are now
authorized to collect debts and securities.

Page | 131
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

5. Description of Debts and Securities:

It provides a detailed description of the debts, bonds, promissory notes, shares, or any other securities left by the deceased
which the heirs can collect.
6. Amount or Value of Debts and Securities:
The total amount or value of the debts and securities covered by the certificate is clearly mentioned.
7. Authority Granted:
The certificate contains a formal statement that the certificate holder has the legal authority to collect the debts and
securities from the debtors or relevant persons.
8. Date of Issue:
The certificate mentions the date on which it was issued by the court.
9. Seal and Signature:
Finally, the certificate bears the official seal and signature of the judge or magistrate who issued it, making it a valid legal
document.

➠ Contents of the Application for Succession Certificate:

When applying for a Succession Certificate, the application must include the following:

1. Name and Address of the Applicant:

The full name and current address of the person filing the application must be given.
2. Relationship with the Deceased:
The application should explain how the applicant is related to the deceased, such as son, daughter, spouse, or legal
representative.
3. Details of the Deceased:
The full name, last residence, and date of death of the deceased must be clearly stated.
4. Description of Debts and Securities:
Complete details of the debts, promissory notes, bonds, shares, or other securities that belonged to the deceased, including
their approximate value.
5. Names and Addresses of Other Legal Heirs:
The applicant must list the names, addresses, and relationship of other legal heirs, if any, to inform the court about all
potential claimants.

Page | 132
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

6. Declaration of No Other Application:

The application should include a declaration stating that no other Succession Certificate application has been filed for the
same debts or securities by any other person.
7. Prayer Clause:
A formal request to the court, asking it to grant the Succession Certificate in favor of the applicant.
8. Verification:
The application must end with a verification statement, where the applicant confirms that all the information provided is true
and correct to the best of their knowledge.

➠ Detailed Explanation:

1. Purpose of Succession Certificate:

The Succession Certificate is a legal permission given by the court to the rightful heirs. It allows them to collect the debts, money, or
securities left behind by the deceased person. Without this certificate, banks, companies, or debtors may refuse to hand over money or
property, fearing future disputes.

2. Importance of Contents of the Succession Certificate:

The certificate must clearly show:

• Who the deceased was.

• Who the legal heirs are.
• What debts or securities are involved.
• The court’s authorization to collect these debts.

This clarity helps protect both the heirs and the people who owe money to the deceased from future claims or problems.

3. Role of the Application:

The application for the Succession Certificate is the first step. The applicant must:

• Show their relationship with the deceased.

• Provide accurate details about the debts or securities.
• List other legal heirs to inform the court.

Page | 133
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

This helps the court confirm that the right person gets the certificate.

4. Listing of Other Heirs:

Including the names and addresses of other heirs ensures that everyone who has a right to claim is aware of the application. This
reduces chances of disputes or hidden claims after the certificate is issued.

5. Declaration About No Other Application:

The applicant must declare that no one else has applied for the same certificate on the same debts. This prevents multiple certificates
being issued for the same property, which could cause legal confusion.

6. Verification Statement:
The applicant confirms that all information provided is true. This means if false information is given, the applicant could face legal
consequences.

7. Court’s Examination and Issuance:

Once the application is filed, the court reviews all documents and information. If everything is correct and no objections arise, the
court issues the Succession Certificate. This certificate then legally empowers the holder to collect the debts or securities without any
challenge.

➠ Conclusion:
The Succession Certificate under the Succession Act 1925 is a vital legal document that facilitates the smooth collection of debts and
securities after a person’s death. It clearly lists all essential details such as the deceased, heirs, debts, and grants authority to the
certificate holder. The application for this certificate must be carefully prepared, containing complete and truthful information about
the deceased, the applicant, debts, and other heirs. This process ensures fairness, avoids disputes among heirs, and protects the rights
of all parties involved. Understanding these contents and provisions helps heirs efficiently claim what is legally theirs under Pakistani
law.

Page | 134
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is succession certificate? How it is acquired? Explain.

Q: Explain the restrictions on grant of Succession Certificate and describe how it can be revoked?
Q: What are the restrictions on grant of succession certificate? Explain the procedure for grant of succession certificate and
how it is revoked?

➠ Introduction:

A Succession Certificate is a legal document issued by a civil court that allows a person (usually a legal heir or nominee) to collect
debts, securities, or money due from the estate of a deceased person. It helps avoid disputes among heirs and protects the certificate
holder while collecting the deceased’s debts or securities. The rules for issuing, restricting, and revoking a Succession Certificate are
found in the Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan).

➠ Relevant Provisions under Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan):

• Section 370: Provides the authority to grant Succession Certificates for debts and securities of the deceased.
• Section 371: Details the procedure for applying for the Succession Certificate.
• Section 373: Specifies the restrictions on granting the Succession Certificate, including the existence of a Will and disputes
among heirs.
• Section 374: Lays down the conditions for revocation of the Succession Certificate.

➠ What is a Succession Certificate?

A Succession Certificate is a court-issued document that authorizes the holder to collect and transfer debts, securities, or other financial
assets of a deceased person. The certificate is generally granted to the legal heir(s) or nominee(s) of the deceased and protects the
certificate holder from future claims while collecting such assets.

Purpose of the Succession Certificate:

• It ensures that the rightful heirs receive the deceased’s debts and securities.
• It prevents fraudulent claims by unauthorized persons.
• It provides legal protection to the debtors who pay the certificate holder.

Page | 135
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

➠ Procedure for Grant of Succession Certificate:

1. Application Submission:
o The legal heir or nominee must file an application in the civil court where the deceased last resided or where the assets
are located.
o The application must contain:
▪ Full name and address of the applicant.
▪ Relationship of the applicant with the deceased.
▪ Detailed list of debts and securities to be collected.
▪ Names and addresses of other legal heirs, if any.
2. Notice to Legal Heirs:
o After receiving the application, the court issues a notice to all legal heirs and interested parties.
o This notice gives them an opportunity to raise objections against the issuance of the certificate.
3. Hearing:
o The court conducts a hearing to verify the authenticity of the applicant’s claims.
o During the hearing, the court examines:
▪ The relationship of the applicant with the deceased.
▪ The validity of the debts or securities listed.
▪ Any objections raised by other heirs.
4. Security Bond:
o The court may require the applicant to provide a security bond or surety to cover the value of the debts or securities in
case of any future disputes.
5. Issuance of Certificate:
o If the court is satisfied, it issues the Succession Certificate, stating:
▪ The name of the deceased.
▪ The names of the legal heirs.
▪ The amount or value of debts and securities.
▪ The authority given to the certificate holder to collect these assets.

➠ Restrictions on Grant of Succession Certificate:

Under Section 373 of the Succession Act 1925, the court may refuse or delay the grant of a Succession Certificate under the
following conditions:

Page | 136
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

1. Existence of a Valid Will:

• If a valid Will exists that deals with the debts, securities, or assets of the deceased, the court will not issue a Succession
Certificate.
• The reason is that the Will governs the distribution of the deceased’s estate, and the executor named in the Will is
responsible for handling the assets.
• In such cases, the heirs must apply for Probate of the Will instead of a Succession Certificate.

2. Disputes Among Heirs:

• If there are conflicting claims among the heirs, the court may refuse or delay the certificate until the dispute is resolved.
• Example: If two or more persons claim to be the legal heirs for the same assets, the court will not issue the certificate until it
determines the rightful claimant(s).

3. Fraud or Misrepresentation:

• If the application is found to be fraudulent or contains false information, the court will deny the certificate.
• This prevents unauthorized persons from obtaining control over the deceased’s assets.

4. Pending Legal Proceedings or Attachments:

• If the deceased’s debts or securities are already involved in other legal proceedings, such as attachment orders, insolvency
proceedings, or property disputes, the court may:
o Refuse the certificate until such disputes are settled.
o Delay the issuance to avoid conflicting court orders.

5. Non-Transferable Assets:

• If the debts or securities in question are non-transferable or restricted by law (e.g., government bonds or pension funds), the
court will not issue a Succession Certificate.
• The applicant must follow the specific legal procedure to access such assets.

Page | 137
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

6. Multiple Applications for the Same Assets:

• If multiple persons file separate applications for the same debts or securities, the court will:
o Investigate the rightful claimant(s).
o Reject or consolidate applications to prevent conflicting orders.

➠ Revocation of Succession Certificate:

Under Section 374 of the Succession Act 1925, the court can revoke or cancel the Succession Certificate under the following
conditions:

1. Fraud or False Information:

o If the certificate was obtained through fraud, false statements, or misrepresentation, the court can revoke it.
o Example: If a person falsely claims to be the only heir and obtains the certificate, it can be cancelled upon discovering
the fraud.
2. Discovery of a Will:
o If a Will is discovered after the certificate is issued, and it specifies the distribution of debts and securities, the court
can revoke the certificate.
o The executor of the Will then takes charge of the estate.
3. New Evidence or Claimants:
o If a previously unknown heir or creditor comes forward with a valid claim, the court can cancel the certificate and
reissue it to the rightful claimant(s).
4. Legal Errors or Mistakes:
o If the court finds that the certificate was issued due to a mistake or oversight, it has the power to revoke it.
o The court may then hold a new hearing and issue a corrected certificate.

➠ Conclusion:
The Succession Certificate is an essential legal document that authorizes the collection of debts, securities, and other assets of a
deceased person. However, the court imposes strict restrictions to prevent fraud, protect the rights of all heirs, and avoid legal
conflicts. The presence of a valid Will, unresolved disputes among heirs, fraudulent applications, ongoing legal proceedings, and non-
transferable assets are all grounds for refusal of the certificate. Moreover, the court can revoke the certificate if it was issued based
on false information, newly discovered evidence, or legal errors. Thus, these provisions ensure a fair and lawful distribution of the
deceased’s assets under the Succession Act 1925.

Page | 138
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What do you mean by an executor or administrator of property? Explain his duties as laid down in the act?

➠ Introduction:
An Executor or Administrator is a person appointed to manage the property and assets of a deceased person under the Succession
Act 1925 (Pakistan). If the deceased has left a Will, the person named in the Will is the Executor. If there is no Will, or if the
Executor cannot or will not act, the court appoints an Administrator to perform the same duties. Both are responsible for collecting
assets, paying debts, and distributing the remaining estate to the rightful heirs.

➠ Relevant Provisions under Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan):

• Section 211: Powers of Executor or Administrator.

• Section 212: Rights of Executor or Administrator regarding the deceased’s property.
• Section 213: Duties of Executor or Administrator in dealing with the estate.
• Section 217: Powers of Administrator when a Will exists.
• Section 220: Power to dispose of the deceased’s property.
• Section 273: Court’s power to grant probate or letters of administration.

➠ Who is an Executor or Administrator?

• Executor:
o An Executor is a person named in the Will to administer the deceased’s estate.
o The Executor ensures that the property is distributed according to the Will’s instructions.
o The court grants the Executor probate, which is the legal authority to act.
• Administrator:
o An Administrator is appointed by the court when:
▪ The deceased left no Will, or
▪ The Executor is unable or unwilling to act.
o The Administrator follows the rules of intestate succession and receives Letters of Administration from the court.

➠ Powers and Duties of Executor or Administrator:

Page | 139
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

1. Collection of Assets:

• The first duty of the Executor or Administrator is to collect all assets of the deceased.
• This includes:
o Movable property (cash, vehicles, jewelry).
o Immovable property (land, houses).
o Debts owed to the deceased.
o Securities, stocks, or shares.
• The Executor/Administrator must prepare an inventory of these assets and submit it to the court.
• The purpose is to ensure that no asset is overlooked and to establish the total value of the estate.

2. Payment of Debts and Liabilities:

• The Executor or Administrator must pay all debts and liabilities of the deceased before distributing the assets.
• These include:
o Funeral expenses,
o Taxes,
o Loans or mortgages,
o Outstanding bills or liabilities.
• Section 213 states that the Executor/Administrator must ensure that all creditors are paid in full before transferring any
property to the heirs.
• Failure to settle debts can result in legal claims against the estate.

3. Managing the Property:

• The Executor or Administrator has the duty to manage and protect the property until it is ready to be distributed.
• This may include:
o Collecting rent from tenants,
o Ensuring property is maintained and protected,
o Preventing unauthorized access to valuable assets.
• Under Section 217, the Administrator has the same powers as an Executor to manage assets, but must follow the rules of
intestate succession.

Page | 140
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

4. Disposition of Property:

• According to Section 220, the Executor or Administrator has the authority to sell or dispose of assets for the purpose of
paying debts or facilitating distribution.
• If a Will exists, the Executor must follow the instructions in the Will regarding the sale or transfer of property.
• If there is no Will, the Administrator must follow the rules of intestate succession.
• The court may require the Executor/Administrator to seek approval for major transactions to prevent fraud or
mismanagement.

5. Distribution of Assets:

• Once all debts and expenses are paid, the Executor or Administrator must distribute the remaining assets to the rightful heirs
or beneficiaries.
• If a Will exists, the distribution must follow the instructions in the Will.
• If there is no Will, the distribution follows the rules of intestate succession under the Succession Act.
• The Executor/Administrator must provide a detailed account of all distributions to the court, ensuring transparency and
accountability.

6. Accounting and Reporting:

• The Executor or Administrator must maintain accurate records of all financial transactions.
• This includes:
o Money received from debtors,
o Payments made to creditors,
o Assets sold or transferred.
• A final account must be submitted to the court, showing all income, expenses, and distributions made.
• This report helps the court verify that the estate was properly managed and prevents disputes among heirs.

7. Defending Legal Claims:

• The Executor or Administrator has the duty to defend the estate against legal claims, such as:
o Claims by creditors for unpaid debts,
o Disputes among heirs regarding asset distribution,

Page | 141
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o Claims of fraud or undue influence in the making of the Will.

• They must act in the best interest of the estate and ensure that all claims are settled before distribution.

8. Application for Probate or Letters of Administration:

• To obtain legal authority, the Executor/Administrator must apply for:

o Probate of the Will (if a Will exists), or
o Letters of Administration (if there is no Will).
• The court examines the application and verifies the authenticity of the Will or the applicant’s legal status.
• Once approved, the Executor or Administrator receives the legal authority to act and proceed with the estate administration.

9. Revocation of Appointment:

• The court can revoke the appointment of an Executor or Administrator under the following circumstances:
o Fraud or misrepresentation,
o Incompetence or misconduct,
o Inability to perform duties,
o Conflicts of interest.
• If the court finds that the Executor or Administrator is acting against the interests of the estate, it may appoint a new person
to complete the administration.

➠ Conclusion:
An Executor or Administrator under the Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan) plays a vital role in the management and distribution of a
deceased person’s estate. They have the authority to collect assets, pay debts, and distribute the remaining property to the rightful
heirs. The Executor follows the instructions of a Will, while the Administrator acts according to the rules of intestate succession
when no Will exists.

Their powers and duties are outlined clearly in the Succession Act to ensure that the estate is administered fairly, legally, and
transparently. The court also retains the power to revoke the appointment if the Executor/Administrator fails to perform their duties
or is found to be acting fraudulently. This structured framework ensures that the rights of the heirs and creditors are protected and that
the estate is managed in accordance with the law.

Page | 142
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What are the grounds and procedure for the revocation of a Succession Certificate? What is the remedy available to aggrieved
person against such Revocation?

➠ Introduction:
A Succession Certificate is a legal document issued by the court under the Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan), granting authority to a
person to collect the debts and securities of a deceased person. However, in certain situations, the court has the power to revoke or
cancel the Succession Certificate to protect the rights of the legal heirs and prevent fraud or misrepresentation.

➠ Relevant Provisions under Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan):

• Section 383: Grounds for revocation of a Succession Certificate.

• Section 384: Procedure for revocation and remedies available to the aggrieved person.
• Section 388: Appeal against the order of revocation.

➠ What is a Succession Certificate?

A Succession Certificate is a legal document that authorizes the legal heir(s) to collect the debts, securities, and movable assets of
a deceased person. It provides protection to third parties, such as banks and debtors, who make payments to the holder of the
certificate.

➠ Grounds for Revocation of a Succession Certificate:

Under Section 383 of the Succession Act 1925, the court may revoke a Succession Certificate based on the following grounds:

1. Fraud or Misrepresentation:

• If the certificate was obtained through fraudulent means or false representation, the court may revoke it.
• Fraud includes deliberate deception, false statements, or forged documents.
• Misrepresentation involves providing incorrect or incomplete information to the court.

Examples:

• The applicant falsely claims to be the sole legal heir, concealing the existence of other heirs.
• The applicant submits forged documents to prove ownership of assets.

Page | 143
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

2. Discovery of a Valid Will:

• If a Will is discovered after the issuance of the Succession Certificate, the court may revoke the certificate.
• The Executor named in the Will will have the legal right to administer the estate, and the previous certificate becomes void.

Example:

• A certificate is issued assuming the deceased died intestate. Later, a valid Will is discovered, and the Executor applies for
probate. The court may then revoke the certificate and issue probate to the Executor.

3. Discovery of New Legal Heirs:

• If new legal heirs are discovered after the issuance of the certificate, the court may revoke the certificate to include the new
heirs.

Example:

• The applicant claims to be the only heir, but the court later discovers that the deceased had children from a previous
marriage.

4. Legal Errors or Mistakes:

• If the certificate was issued due to a clerical error or oversight, the court can revoke it.

Example:

• The applicant’s relationship with the deceased was incorrectly stated as a spouse instead of a business partner.

5. Pending Litigation or Disputes:

• If a legal dispute arises regarding the legitimacy of the certificate, the court may revoke it.

Page | 144
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Example:

• A relative challenges the certificate, claiming that the deceased had a Will that was not considered.

6. Unlawful Transfer or Mismanagement of Property:

• If the holder of the certificate is found to have misused or unlawfully transferred assets, the court can revoke the certificate.

Example:

• The holder sells property without court approval and misappropriates the proceeds.

7. Death of the Holder of the Certificate:

• If the holder of the certificate dies, the certificate becomes void, and the court may revoke it and reissue it to another heir.

8. Misappropriation of Assets:

• If the holder is found to have misappropriated assets or failed to provide a proper accounting, the court can revoke the
certificate.

➠ Procedure for Revocation of Succession Certificate:

Under Section 384, the procedure for revocation is as follows:

1. Application for Revocation:

o An application must be filed in the court that issued the certificate.
o The application must clearly state the grounds for revocation and provide supporting evidence.
2. Notice to Certificate Holder:
o The court issues a notice to the certificate holder, informing them of the application for revocation.
o The holder is given an opportunity to respond to the allegations.
3. Hearing:
o The court conducts a hearing to examine the evidence and hear both parties.
o The court may require additional evidence or witness testimony.

Page | 145
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

4. Order of Revocation:
o If the court is satisfied that the grounds for revocation are valid, it will cancel the certificate and may order the holder
to return the assets or provide compensation.

➠ Remedies Available Against Revocation of Succession Certificate:

Under Section 388, the aggrieved person can seek the following remedies:

1. Appeal Against Revocation:

• Relevant Provision: Section 388 of the Succession Act 1925.

• Definition:
o An appeal is a legal process that allows the aggrieved person to challenge the order of revocation in a higher court.
o The appeal must be filed within the prescribed time limit, generally 30 days, from the date of the revocation order.
• Procedure for Filing Appeal:
o The appeal must be filed in the District Court or the High Court, depending on the value of the assets and the
jurisdiction.
o The appellant must provide:
▪ A copy of the revocation order,
▪ Grounds for appeal,
▪ Supporting evidence to substantiate the claim.
• Grounds for Appeal:
o The revocation order was passed based on false information or misrepresentation.
o The court failed to consider relevant evidence.
o The order was obtained through fraud or coercion.
o The court did not provide the appellant with a reasonable opportunity to be heard.
• Outcome of Appeal:
o The appellate court may:
▪ Uphold the revocation,
▪ Set aside the revocation, or
▪ Modify the order by granting conditional re-issuance of the certificate.

Page | 146
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Example:
If a certificate was revoked based on a forged Will, the aggrieved person can file an appeal to challenge the revocation, arguing that
the Will was not genuine.

2. Application for Re-Issuance of Succession Certificate:

• Relevant Provision: Section 384 of the Succession Act 1925.

• Definition:
o If the certificate was revoked due to a clerical error, fraud, or misrepresentation, the aggrieved person can apply for
re-issuance of the certificate.
• Procedure for Re-Issuance:
o The application must be filed in the same court that issued the revocation order.
o The applicant must provide:
▪ Evidence of rectification of the error,
▪ Proof of entitlement to the certificate,
▪ Statement of grounds for re-issuance.
• Grounds for Re-Issuance:
o The revocation was based on a clerical error.
o The revocation was obtained through fraud or false statements.
o The applicant was not given a fair hearing before the revocation.

Example:
If the certificate was revoked because of an error in the name or relationship of the applicant, the person can apply for re-issuance
with corrected information.

3. Compensation for Damages:

• Legal Basis: General Law of Torts and Civil Procedure Code (CPC).
• Definition:
o If the revocation caused financial loss or reputational damage, the aggrieved person can file a civil suit for
compensation or damages.
• Types of Damages:
o Actual Damages: Compensation for the actual financial loss suffered.

Page | 147
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o Punitive Damages: Compensation to punish the fraudulent party.

o Emotional Damages: Compensation for mental distress or suffering.
• Procedure:
o The claim for damages must be filed in the competent civil court.
o The claimant must provide evidence of:
▪ The financial loss incurred,
▪ The fraudulent act or misrepresentation, and
▪ The mental distress or emotional harm suffered.

Example:
If the revocation was based on a false claim that the applicant misappropriated assets, and this claim caused loss of reputation and
financial damage, the applicant can claim compensation for defamation and financial loss.

4. Stay Order or Injunction:

• Legal Provision: Civil Procedure Code (CPC).

• Definition:
o A stay order or injunction is a temporary court order that prevents the holder of the revoked certificate from
disposing of assets or collecting debts until the dispute is resolved.
• Procedure:
o The aggrieved person must file an application in the court that issued the revocation order.
o The application must clearly state the grounds for the stay order, such as:
▪ Risk of asset disposal,
▪ Fear of misappropriation, or
▪ Pending appeal or legal proceedings.

Effect of Stay Order:

• The stay order restricts any transfer or collection of assets until the legal dispute is resolved.

Example:
If the certificate was revoked based on a false claim and the new holder attempts to sell the assets, the aggrieved person can obtain a
stay order to prevent the sale.

Page | 148
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

5. Filing a Fresh Application for Succession Certificate:

• Relevant Provision: Section 372 of the Succession Act 1925.

• Definition:
o If the original certificate was revoked due to fraud or false statements, the aggrieved person can file a fresh
application for a new Succession Certificate.
• Procedure:
o The application must include:
▪ Statement of grounds for the new application,
▪ Evidence of the applicant’s legal entitlement,
▪ Proof of rectification of previous errors.

Example:
If the certificate was revoked due to false claims by another party, and the applicant has new evidence proving their entitlement,
they can file a fresh application with the corrected information.

➠ Conclusion:
The Succession Act 1925 (Pakistan) provides a comprehensive framework for the revocation of a Succession Certificate to prevent
fraud, misrepresentation, and misuse of assets. The court can revoke the certificate based on grounds such as fraud, discovery of a
Will, misappropriation of assets, or pending disputes. The aggrieved person has the right to challenge the revocation by filing an
appeal or seeking re-issuance of the certificate. This legal framework ensures that the distribution of the deceased’s assets is
conducted lawfully and fairly, protecting the rights of all legal heirs.

Page | 149
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: What is the procedure provided under the Succession Act, 1925 for the protection of property of the deceased?

➠ Introduction:

When a person dies, their property and belongings are called their estate. Protecting this property is very important to make sure it is
distributed correctly to the rightful heirs or according to the will of the deceased. The Succession Act, 1925 provides rules to protect
the deceased’s property until it is properly given to the legal heirs or legatees.

➠ Appointment of Administrator or Executor:

• If the deceased left a will, the person named in the will as the executor takes charge of the estate.
• If there is no will, the court appoints an administrator to manage and protect the property.
• The executor or administrator is responsible for looking after the estate and making sure it is safe.

➠ Grant of Probate or Letters of Administration:

• To protect the property legally, the executor or administrator must apply to the court for:
o Probate (if there is a will), or
o Letters of Administration (if there is no will).
• This document gives them the legal authority to deal with the property of the deceased.
• Without this grant, no one has the lawful right to manage or distribute the property.

➠ Taking Inventory of Property:

• Once the executor or administrator gets the authority, they must make a complete list of all the property, debts, and money the
deceased owned.
• This is called an inventory.
• This helps to know exactly what needs to be protected and later distributed.

➠ Protection of Property:

• The executor or administrator must take careful steps to protect the property from damage, loss, or misuse.

Page | 150
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

• This includes:
o Keeping valuables safe, like money, jewelry, or important documents.
o Maintaining property, such as paying property taxes or bills.
o Collecting debts owed to the deceased.
o Selling property only when necessary, and usually only after permission from the court or under the rules of
succession.
• Their duty is to preserve the estate until the rightful heirs receive it.

➠ Payment of Debts and Expenses:

• The executor/administrator must use the estate’s money to pay any debts left by the deceased.
• They also pay for funeral expenses and the costs related to managing the estate.
• Only after these payments can the property be distributed to the heirs.

➠ Distribution of Property:

• After all debts and expenses are paid, the remaining property is distributed:
o According to the will if there is one.
o Or according to the rules of inheritance under the law if there is no will.
• The executor or administrator hands over the property to the rightful persons.

➠ Account of Estate Management:

• The executor or administrator must keep records of all actions taken related to the estate.
• They must prepare an account showing how the estate was managed.
• This account can be presented to the court or heirs for review.

➠ Court’s Supervision:

• The court supervises the whole process to make sure the property is protected and properly managed.
• The court can:
o Ask for reports from the executor/administrator.
o Remove the executor/administrator if they fail in their duties.

Page | 151
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o Resolve disputes related to the estate.

Conclusion:

The Succession Act, 1925 provides a clear and legal way to protect the property of the deceased through the appointment of an
executor or administrator, obtaining court authorization, making an inventory, preserving the estate, paying debts, distributing the
property correctly, and maintaining full transparency under court supervision. This process ensures the deceased’s property is safe and
properly given to the rightful heirs.

Page | 152
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

Q: Explain the transfer of property by gift made in contemplation of death under section.191 of Succession Act.

➠ Introduction:

Sometimes, a person who is seriously ill or believes they are going to die soon, may want to give away their property as a gift before
their death. This type of gift is called a gift made in contemplation of death or a gift causa mortis. Section 191 of the Succession Act,
1925 explains how such gifts work and what rules must be followed for them to be valid. This is different from a usual gift because it
depends on the expectation that the giver might die soon.

➠ Meaning of Gift in Contemplation of Death (Gift Causa Mortis):

• A gift causa mortis is a gift given by a person who:

o Believes they are about to die soon.
o Gives the gift because of this fear or expectation.
• The gift is intended to take effect only if the giver actually dies soon after making the gift.
• If the giver does not die, the gift becomes invalid and the property returns to the giver.

➠ Relevant Provision - Section 191 of Succession Act:

• Section 191 says that a person may transfer property by gift in anticipation of their death.
• This gift is only valid if the person dies from the cause they feared or the death is related to the same cause.
• If the person survives, the gift is automatically canceled.
• The property will be treated as if the gift was never made.

➠ Essential Conditions for a Valid Gift under Section 191:

1. Contemplation of Death:
o The gift must be made because the giver believes they are going to die soon.
o This belief must be real and sincere, connected to some serious illness or danger.
2. Death Must Follow:
o The giver must actually die from the expected cause or reason.
o For example, if the giver made the gift fearing death from a disease, they must die from that disease or its
complications.
3. Delivery of Possession:
Page | 153
Contact: 0325-0448003
RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ PULC

o The property or possession of the gift must be transferred to the receiver before the giver dies.
o This means the receiver must physically get or control the gift while the giver is alive.
4. Revocation if Survival:
o If the giver recovers or survives, the gift is automatically revoked.
o The receiver has no right to keep the property.
➠ Effect of Gift Made in Contemplation of Death:
• If all the conditions are met, the gift becomes effective only after the giver’s death.
• It is a kind of conditional transfer that depends on the death of the giver.
• The receiver only gains ownership of the property after the death of the person who gave the gift.
• Until then, the giver may still have rights over the property.
➠ Difference Between Gift Causa Mortis and Will:
• A gift causa mortis is an immediate gift made in fear of death, while a will is a document that gives property after death.
• Gifts causa mortis must be delivered physically, but wills do not require delivery.
• Gifts causa mortis are valid only if death occurs soon after, but wills become effective only after death, no matter how long
after.
➠ Legal Importance of Section 191:
• Section 191 protects the interests of both the giver and the receiver.
• It ensures that gifts made under fear of death are not misused or treated as permanent if the giver survives.
• It clarifies the conditions under which such gifts are valid or invalid.
• This prevents fraud or confusion regarding the property of the deceased.
Conclusion:
Section 191 of the Succession Act, 1925 allows a person who fears death to give a gift in anticipation of death. This gift only takes
effect if the person actually dies soon after from the feared cause. The property must be physically transferred to the receiver before
death, and if the giver survives, the gift is canceled. This rule ensures fairness and clarity in such serious situations.

RAI SHAHZAIB MUMTAZ-PULC

Contact: 0325-0448003

Page | 154
Contact: 0325-0448003