1

**1. Definition of Appeal:**

- An appeal is a proceeding in which a party seeks a review of a lower

court's decision by a higher court.

**2. Right to Appeal:**

- Section 96 of the CPC grants the right to appeal from every decree
passed by any court subordinate to a High Court.

**3. Types of Appeals:**

- Appeals can be classified into two types:

1. First Appeal: An appeal from an original decree.

2. Second Appeal: An appeal from an appellate decree.

**4. Grounds of Appeal:**

- Section 100 of the CPC outlines the grounds for a second appeal, which
include:

- A substantial question of law.

- The decision being contrary to law or to some custom or usage.

- The decision being opposed to the weight of evidence.

**5. Procedure for Filing an Appeal:**

 2

- The procedure for filing an appeal is governed by Order XLI of the CPC.

- It includes provisions for filing the memorandum of appeal, the contents

of the memorandum, and the presentation of the appeal.

**6. Limitation Period for Filing an Appeal:**

- Section 3 of the Limitation Act, 1908 prescribes the limitation period for
filing an appeal, which is usually thirty days.

**7. Powers of the Appellate Court:**

- The appellate court has the power to:

- Confirm, reverse, modify, or set aside the decree.

- Remand the case with directions for further proceedings.

- Decide any issue necessary for the final adjudication of the case.

**8. Stay of Proceedings:**

- The filing of an appeal does not operate as a stay of proceedings, but

the appellate court may grant a stay if it deems fit.

**9. Execution of Decrees Pending Appeal:**

- The execution of a decree may be stayed by the appellate court pending

the decision of the appeal.
 3

**1. Definition of Pauper Suit:** section 28

- A pauper suit, also known as a suit filed by an indigent person, is a legal

action initiated by a person who is unable to afford the expenses
associated with litigation.

**2. Procedure for Filing as a Pauper:**

- Section 28 of the CPC allows a person to institute a suit as a pauper if

they are unable to pay the requisite court fees.

- The person must file an application supported by an affidavit stating

their inability to pay court fees and disclosing their assets and income.

**3. Examination of the Application:**

- The court examines the application and may require further evidence to
determine the person's indigent status.

**4. Granting of Pauper Status:**

- If the court is satisfied that the person is genuinely unable to pay court
fees, it may grant pauper status to the applicant.

**5. Consequences of Granting Pauper Status:**

- Once pauper status is granted, the person is exempted from paying

 4

court fees and other costs associated with litigation.

- The court appoints a pleader for the pauper, who is paid from the
government funds.

**6. Right to Appeal:**

- A person whose application for pauper status is rejected has the right to
appeal against such rejection.

**7. Liability for Costs:**

- If the pauper suit is successful, the court may order the costs incurred
by the government on behalf of the pauper to be recovered from the
opposite party.

**8. Limitations and Restrictions:**

- The court has the discretion to reject an application for pauper status if
it believes that the person is not genuinely unable to pay court fees.

- The privilege of filing a suit as a pauper should not be misused, and

false statements made in the affidavit can lead to penalties.

**1. Definition of Joinder of Parties:** order 1

- Joinder of parties refers to the process of joining multiple parties in a

single legal action either as plaintiffs or defendants.
 5

**2. Objectives of Joinder of Parties:**

- The primary objective is to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and to

ensure that all interested parties are bound by the outcome of the litigation.

- It promotes the complete and final settlement of all disputes arising out
of the same transaction or series of transactions.

**3. Types of Joinder of Parties:**

- Joinder of parties can be classified into two types:

1. Necessary Parties: Parties whose presence is necessary for the

complete adjudication of the dispute.

2. Proper Parties: Parties whose presence is not necessary but whose

interests may be affected by the outcome of the litigation.

**4. Procedure for Joinder of Parties:**

- The procedure for joinder of parties is governed by Order I of the CPC.

- It allows for the addition, substitution, or striking out of parties at any

stage of the proceedings.

**5. Necessary Parties:**

- Section 20 of the CPC stipulates that all persons interested in the

subject matter of the suit should be joined as parties.
 6

**6. Proper Parties:**

- While the presence of proper parties is not mandatory, the court may, at
its discretion, allow their joinder to ensure the complete and effective
adjudication of the dispute.

**7. Non-Joinder and Misjoinder of Parties:**

- Non-joinder refers to the failure to join a necessary party, while

misjoinder occurs when parties are improperly joined.

- The court may either direct the necessary parties to be added or strike
out improperly joined parties.

**8. Effect of Joinder of Parties:**

- All parties to the suit are bound by the judgment and are precluded from
re-litigating the same issue in subsequent proceedings.

**Topic: Inherent Power of Court** section 151

**Introduction:**

The inherent power of the court is a significant aspect of the administration

of justice under the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) of Pakistan, 1908. It
empowers the court to ensure that justice is served efficiently and
 7

effectively, even in situations not expressly covered by statutory provisions.

**Definition:**

The inherent power of the court refers to the authority vested in it to make
orders necessary for the ends of justice, to prevent abuse of the process of
the court, and to secure the interests of justice. This power is inherent in
the court by virtue of its judicial function and is not confined or limited by
specific provisions of law.

**Basis of Inherent Power:**

The inherent power of the court is derived from its status as a court of
justice and is essential for the proper administration of justice. It allows the
court to fill in gaps in the law, rectify procedural irregularities, and prevent
injustice.

**Scope and Application:**

The inherent power of the court is broad and flexible, allowing the court to:

1. **Granting Relief**: Make orders or pass decrees to meet the exigencies

of a particular case, even if no specific provision exists for such relief in the
CPC.

2. **Regulating Procedure**: Regulate its own procedure and the procedure

of subordinate courts to ensure the orderly conduct of proceedings.

3. **Preventing Abuse**: Prevent abuse of the process of the court, such as

 8

filing vexatious or frivolous litigation, or perpetrating fraud on the court.

4. **Securing Ends of Justice**: Take any action necessary to secure the

ends of justice, including staying proceedings, setting aside judgments
obtained by fraud, or recalling orders passed erroneously.

**Limitations:**

While the inherent power of the court is wide-ranging, it is not absolute.

Some limitations include:

1. **Statutory Provisions**: The court cannot exercise its inherent power in

contravention of specific statutory provisions.

2. **Judicial Precedent**: The exercise of inherent power must be

consistent with established principles of law and judicial precedent.

3. **Judicial Discretion**: The court's exercise of inherent power is subject

to its own discretion and should be exercised judiciously and sparingly.

**Conclusion:**

The inherent power of the court is a cornerstone of the judicial system,

enabling courts to fulfill their role as dispensers of justice effectively. It
serves as a safety valve to address situations not expressly covered by law
and to ensure that justice is done in every case that comes before the court.

**Topic: Appearance of Parties**

 9

*References:**

- Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (Act V of 1908), Sections 27, 28, 80, 81, 132,
135.

**Introduction:**

The appearance of parties is a crucial procedural aspect within the Civil

Procedure Code (CPC) of Pakistan, 1908. It pertains to the formal act of a
party or their representative presenting themselves before the court in a
legal proceeding.

**Modes of Appearance:**

Parties can appear before the court in the following ways:

1. **Personal Appearance**: The party appears in person before the court

without the representation of an advocate or pleader.

2. **Representation by Advocate**: The party is represented by an advocate

or pleader duly authorized to appear on their behalf.

3. **Through Authorized Agent**: In certain cases, a party may appoint an

authorized agent to represent them in court, especially in matters where
 10

personal appearance is not mandatory.

**Legal Requirements for Appearance:**

The CPC outlines certain legal requirements regarding the appearance of

parties, including:

1. **Mandatory Appearance**: Parties are required to appear before the

court in person or through a duly authorized representative as per the
summons or notices issued by the court.

2. **Authority to Represent**: Advocates or pleaders appearing on behalf of

parties must possess the necessary authorization, either through a
vakalatnama or other legal documentation.

3. **Submission of Documents**: Parties or their representatives may be

required to submit relevant documents, such as a vakalatnama, power of
attorney, or affidavit of authority, to establish their right to appear before
the court.

**Consequences of Non-Appearance:**

Failure to appear before the court may have various consequences,

including:
 11

1. **Ex Parte Proceedings**: If a party fails to appear despite due notice,

the court may proceed with the case ex parte, i.e., in the absence of that
party, and pass orders or judgments based on the evidence presented by
the other party.

2. **Dismissal or Default Judgment**: Non-appearance may lead to the

dismissal of the case or the issuance of a default judgment against the
absent party.

**Exceptions and Considerations:**

There are certain exceptions and considerations regarding appearance,

such as:

1. **Special Leave**: In exceptional circumstances, the court may grant

leave to a party to appear through an authorized representative even if
personal appearance is required.

2. **Interlocutory Applications**: In matters related to interlocutory

applications or procedural issues, the court may allow representation by an
advocate or pleader without the mandatory presence of the party.

**Conclusion:**

The appearance of parties is fundamental to the proper conduct of legal

proceedings, ensuring that the principles of natural justice are upheld and
the rights of all parties are safeguarded. Compliance with legal
 12

requirements regarding appearance is essential for the fair and efficient

administration of justice.

**Topic: Appointment of Receiver**

**Introduction:**

In legal proceedings, the appointment of a receiver is a significant remedy

available to courts under the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) of Pakistan, 1908.
It involves the court appointing a neutral third party to take possession,
manage, and preserve property that is the subject of litigation until the
dispute is resolved.

**References:**

- Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (Act V of 1908), Section 151, Order 40.

**Legal Basis:**

The authority for appointing a receiver is derived from various provisions of

the CPC, including but not limited to:

- Section 151: Inherent powers of the court to make orders necessary for
 13

the ends of justice.

- Order 40: Provides detailed procedures and guidelines for the

appointment of receivers.

**Grounds for Appointment:**

A receiver may be appointed by the court under various circumstances,

including:

1. To preserve and safeguard the property from waste, damage, or

alienation during the pendency of litigation.

2. When it is necessary to protect the interests of parties to the litigation or

prevent irreparable harm.

3. When there is a risk of dissipation of assets or fraudulent activities by

any party.

**Procedure for Appointment:**

The procedure for appointing a receiver typically involves the following

steps:

1. **Application**: A party to the litigation files an application supported by

an affidavit seeking the appointment of a receiver.
 14

2. **Grounds**: The application must demonstrate the necessity and

justification for the appointment based on the specific circumstances of
the case.

3. **Notice**: Notice of the application is served on all interested parties,

giving them an opportunity to contest or consent to the appointment.

4. **Hearing**: The court conducts a hearing to consider the application

and any objections raised by the parties.

5. **Appointment Order**: If the court deems it necessary, it issues an

order appointing a receiver, outlining the receiver's powers, duties, and
terms of appointment.

**Powers and Duties of Receiver:**

Upon appointment, the receiver is vested with certain powers and duties,
including:

- Taking possession and control of the property in dispute.

- Collecting rents, income, or profits generated from the property.

- Managing the property in a manner consistent with the court's directives.

- Making necessary repairs or improvements to maintain the property's

value.

- Submitting periodic reports to the court and accounting for their actions.
 15

**Security by Receiver:**

In some cases, the court may require the receiver to furnish security to
ensure the proper performance of their duties and to indemnify any losses
incurred by their actions.

**Conclusion:**

The appointment of a receiver is a remedial measure aimed at ensuring the

preservation and efficient management of property pending litigation. It
reflects the court's commitment to protecting the interests of parties and
maintaining the integrity of the judicial process.

**Topic: Temporary Injunction**

**References:**

- Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (Act V of 1908), Section 94, Order 39.

**Introduction:**
 16

A temporary injunction is a legal remedy provided under the Civil Procedure

Code (CPC) of Pakistan, 1908, which aims to preserve the status quo or
prevent imminent harm or injustice pending the final determination of a
legal dispute. It is a discretionary relief granted by the court to restrain a
party from certain actions during the pendency of litigation.

**Legal Basis:**

The authority to grant temporary injunctions is derived from various

provisions of the CPC, including but not limited to:

- Section 94: Grants inherent powers to the court to make orders as may be
necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the
court.

- Order 39: Provides detailed procedures and guidelines for the grant of
temporary injunctions.

**Grounds for Granting Temporary Injunction:**

A temporary injunction may be granted by the court under certain

circumstances, including:

1. **Prima Facie Case**: The applicant must demonstrate that there exists
a prima facie case in their favor, i.e., a case with a reasonable likelihood of
success.

2. **Irreparable Injury**: The applicant must show that unless the injunction
is granted, they would suffer irreparable injury or harm that cannot be
 17

adequately compensated by damages.

3. **Balance of Convenience**: The court considers the relative

inconvenience or hardship that would be caused to the parties if the
injunction is granted or refused.

4. **Public Interest**: The court also takes into account the public interest
or the interests of third parties affected by the injunction.

**Procedure for Obtaining Temporary Injunction:**

The procedure for obtaining a temporary injunction typically involves the

following steps:

1. **Application**: The party seeking the injunction files an application

supported by an affidavit setting out the grounds for the injunction.

2. **Notice**: Notice of the application is served on the opposing party,

giving them an opportunity to contest or consent to the injunction.

3. **Interim Relief**: In urgent cases, the court may grant interim relief ex
parte pending the hearing of the application.

4. **Hearing**: The court conducts a hearing where both parties present

their arguments and evidence in support of their respective positions.

5. **Decision**: The court exercises its discretion to either grant or refuse

the temporary injunction based on the merits of the case and the principles
governing such relief.
 18

**Duration and Modification:**

Temporary injunctions are generally granted for a limited period until the
final determination of the case or until further orders of the court. The court
may also modify or vacate the injunction based on changed circumstances
or new evidence brought to its attention.

**Conclusion:**

Temporary injunctions play a crucial role in maintaining the balance of

justice and equity by preventing irreparable harm pending the final
resolution of legal disputes. They serve as a vital tool for courts to protect
the rights and interests of parties and uphold the integrity of the judicial
process.

**Topic: Suit of Interpleader**

**Introduction:**

A suit of interpleader is a legal proceeding initiated by a person holding

property or funds claimed by two or more parties, where the claimants are
in dispute regarding their entitlement to the property. The purpose of a suit
of interpleader is to enable the stakeholder to deposit the property or funds
into court and to obtain a determination of the respective rights of the
claimants.
 19

**References:**

- Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (Act V of 1908), Order 35.

**Legal Basis:**

The procedure for a suit of interpleader is governed by the Civil Procedure

Code (CPC) of Pakistan, 1908, particularly under Order 35.

**Key Features:**

1. **Stakeholder's Position**: The plaintiff in a suit of interpleader is

typically a stakeholder who is not a party to the underlying dispute but is
holding property or funds claimed by multiple parties.

2. **Deposit into Court**: The stakeholder deposits the disputed property or

funds into court to be held pending the resolution of the dispute.

3. **Notice to Claimants**: Notice of the interpleader suit and the deposit

into court is served on all claimants, giving them an opportunity to assert
their claims and participate in the proceedings.

4. **Determination of Rights**: The court conducts an inquiry to determine

the rights of the claimants to the disputed property or funds.

5. **Dismissal of Plaintiff**: Once the court determines the respective

rights of the claimants, the plaintiff stakeholder is usually discharged from
further liability, and the court directs the distribution of the deposited
property or funds according to its judgment.
 20

**Procedure for Filing a Suit of Interpleader:**

1. **Filing of Suit**: The stakeholder files a plaint in the appropriate court,

stating the nature of their interest in the property or funds and the
conflicting claims made by the other parties.

2. **Deposit into Court**: Along with the plaint, the stakeholder deposits
the disputed property or funds into court or seeks permission from the
court to deposit the same.

3. **Notice to Claimants**: Notice of the suit and the deposit into court is
served on all claimants, informing them of the proceedings and their right
to participate.

4. **Evidence and Hearing**: The court conducts a hearing where all parties
present their evidence and arguments in support of their respective claims.

5. **Judgment and Disposal**: Based on the evidence and legal principles,

the court pronounces judgment determining the rights of the claimants and
directing the distribution of the deposited property or funds.

**Conclusion:**

A suit of interpleader provides an efficient and equitable mechanism for

resolving disputes involving conflicting claims to property or funds held by
a stakeholder. It ensures that the rights of all parties are adjudicated fairly
and that the stakeholder is relieved from the burden of multiple lawsuits.
 21

**Topic: Appeals from Decrees and Orders**

**Introduction:**

In the legal system of Pakistan, the right to appeal is a fundamental aspect

of due process and access to justice. Appeals from decrees and orders
provide parties with a mechanism to challenge and seek review of
decisions made by lower courts. The procedure for filing appeals is
governed by the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) of Pakistan, 1908, and other
relevant laws.

**References:**

- Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (Act V of 1908), Sections 96-109.

**Types of Decrees and Orders:**

1. **Decree**: A decree is a formal expression of the adjudication in a civil

proceeding, conclusively determining the rights of the parties with regard to
all or any of the matters in controversy.

2. **Order**: An order is a formal expression of any decision of a civil court

which is not a decree.

**Grounds for Appeal:**

 22

Parties may appeal from decrees and orders on various grounds, including:

1. Error of Law: Where the lower court has misinterpreted or misapplied the
law.

2. Error of Fact: Where the lower court has made factual errors that
materially affect the outcome of the case.

3. Procedural Irregularities: Including violations of procedural rules or

principles of natural justice.

4. Manifest Injustice: Where the decision of the lower court results in

manifest injustice or unfairness.

**Procedure for Filing Appeals:**

1. **Notice of Appeal**: The aggrieved party files a notice of appeal in the

appropriate appellate court within the prescribed time limit.

2. **Grounds of Appeal**: The notice of appeal sets forth the grounds on

which the appeal is being filed and may be accompanied by a
memorandum of appeal detailing the legal and factual basis for the
challenge.

3. **Appellate Record**: The appellant obtains copies of the relevant

documents from the lower court record, including the decree or order being
appealed from, and submits them to the appellate court.

4. **Hearing**: The appellate court schedules a hearing where both parties

 23

present their arguments and evidence in support of their respective

positions.

5. **Judgment**: The appellate court delivers its judgment, either affirming,

modifying, or reversing the decree or order of the lower court based on its
review of the case.

**Types of Appeals:**

1. **First Appeal**: An appeal from a decree of a trial court lies to the

appropriate appellate court as provided by law.

2. **Second Appeal**: In certain cases involving substantial questions of

law, a second appeal may lie to the High Court from the judgment or decree
of the appellate court.

**Limitation Period for Appeals:**

The CPC prescribes specific limitation periods within which appeals must
be filed. Failure to adhere to these time limits may result in the appeal
being time-barred and dismissed.

**Conclusion:**

Appeals from decrees and orders are essential for ensuring the fairness
and correctness of judicial decisions. They provide parties with the
opportunity to have their cases reviewed by higher courts and to seek
 24

redress for errors or injustices that may have occurred in the lower courts.

Review

**Definition**:

Review is the re-examination or reconsideration of a judgment or order by

the same court that passed it, upon an application made for that purpose.

**References**:

- Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (Act V of 1908), Sections 114-117.

Grounds for review

**1. Discovery of New and Important Matter or Evidence:**

- This ground allows for review when new and significant evidence or
matter, which was not available or known to the petitioner at the time of the
 25

original proceedings, is discovered.

- It provides an opportunity to present crucial evidence that could

potentially alter the outcome of the case.

- The discovery must be genuine and not merely a pretext to reopen the
case.

**2. Mistake or Error Apparent on the Face of the Record:**

- Review can be sought if there is a clear mistake or error evident from the
record of the original proceedings, without the need for extraneous
evidence.

- This includes errors in law, such as misinterpretation of statutory

provisions or precedents, as well as errors in fact that are apparent from
the record.

- The mistake must be evident and manifest, requiring no further

investigation or examination of evidence beyond what is already on record.

**3. Any Other Sufficient Reason:**

- This catch-all ground allows for review based on any other reason
considered sufficient by the court.

- It provides flexibility for addressing situations not specifically covered by

the first two grounds, such as procedural irregularities, violations of natural
justice, or exceptional circumstances warranting review.
 27

- The petitioner must demonstrate to the satisfaction of the court that the
reason presented is indeed sufficient to warrant review.

**Procedure for Filing a Review Petition**:

- The petition for review must be filed within the prescribed period.

- It should state the grounds on which the review is sought.

- Notice must be given to the opposite party.

- The court may dismiss the petition summarily or issue notice to the
opposite party and hear arguments.

**Powers of the Court**:

The court has the discretion to either allow or dismiss the review petition
after considering the grounds and arguments presented by both parties.

**Scope of Review**:
The review is limited to the grounds mentioned in the petition and cannot
be expanded to cover new issues or evidence that was not raised in the
original proceedings.

**Effect of Review**:
If the review is allowed, the original judgment or order may be modified,
reversed, or affirmed, as the reviewing court deems fit.