0520 Muse
0520 Muse
N B Z 0KV O F 3 1 3 1
®
26
Drone Home
Changing the way
packages are delivered
by Peg Lopata
FEATURES
10 20 32 38
Up for a Challenge Powering the A System in Sync Moral Machines
Teams put their Road Ahead Smart vehicles Who decides
self-driving cars to the test. Hybrids and EVs will need smart roads. right and wrong?
by Ashley O’Brien by Monette Bebow-Reinhard by Fiona Young-Brown by Fiona Young-Brown
MAY/JUNE 2020
DEPARTMENTS
DEPARTMENTS Volume 24, Issue 05
25 Art Space: Life Is Dr, Ste 870 McLean, VA 22102. Periodicals postage paid at McLean, VA, and at additional
mailing offices. One-year subscription (9 issues) $33.95. Canadian and other foreign sub-
scribers must add $15.00 per year and prepay in U.S. dollars. GST Registration Number
Butter with Waffles 128950334. For address changes, back issues, subscriptions, customer service, or to renew,
please visit shop.cricketmedia.com, email [email protected], write to
by Nic McDougal MUSE at Cricket Media, PO Box 6395, Harlan, IA 51593, or call 1-800-821-0115. Postmaster:
Please send address changes to MUSE, Cricket Media, PO Box 6395, Harlan, IA 51593.
31 Q&A Editorial office, 70 E. Lake Street, Suite 800, Chicago, IL 60601. May/June 2020, Volume 24,
Number 05, © 2020, Cricket Media, Inc. All rights reserved, including right of reproduction in
by Lizzie Wade whole or in part, in any form. For information regarding our privacy policy and compliance
with the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act, please visit our website at cricketmedia.
42 Hands-on: com or write to us at CMG COPPA, 70 East Lake Street, Suite 800, Chicago, IL 60601.
“Q&A,” text © 2015 by Elizabeth Wade; “Do the Math,” text © 2000 by Ivars Peterson
Here to There and
Photo credits: C - arvitalyaart/Shutterstock.com; TOC - Malp / Alamy Stock Photo; 3 (RT)
Everywhere Satellite/Shutterstock.com, (LT) PsyComa/Shutterstock.com; 4 (LT) Sonsedska Yuliia/
Shutterstock.com, (RC) Nattika/Shutterstock.com; 6 (TC) Mike Mareen/Shutterstock.com,
hry Hulick
by Kathryn (LT) Kapitosh/Shutterstock.com; 7 (RT) ESB Professional/Shutterstock.com, (LB), (LB-2)
Springer Nature; 8 (LB) Le Panda/Shutterstock.com, (LB) Tanya Syrytsyna/Shutterstock.
46 Contest:
test: Start com, (RC) DenEmmanuel/Shutterstock.com, (RT) Vitsson Stock/Shutterstock.com; 9 (TC)
HUR
©ESA–K. Oldenburg; 12 (TC) 32 pixels/Shutterstock.com; 10-11, 12 (LT), (RT), (RC), 13 (LT), (TC),
(CC) SAE International; 14 (RC) Peter Hudeck / Alamy Stock Photo, (RB) Alex Oakenman/
to Finish Shutterstock.com; 15 (TC)Victor Metelskiy/Shutterstock.com; 14 (LT), (RT), (LC), (RB) Kettering
University; 20-21 GAC R&D Center; 22 (RT) Chesky/Shutterstock.com, (RC) J.D.S/Shutterstock.
com, (BC) Universal Images Group North America LLC / Alamy Stock Photo; 23 (LT) Kagai19927/
Shutterstock.com, (LC) Sergii Chernov/Shutterstock.com, (LB) EVX; 26 (TC)Solveig Been/
Shutterstock.com; 27 (RT), (RC), (LB) Wing Aviation; 28 (RB), (TC), 29 (LT), (RB), 30 (LT) Courtesy
MEMBER OF: Bera, the native
MEM of Sanjeev Sharma; 31 (TC) Jurik Peter/Shutterstock.com; 32-33 Andrey Suslov/Shutterstock.
com; 34 (RT) Zapp2Photo/Shutterstock.com, (RC) REUTERS/Mark Blinch; 35 (RT) REUTERS,
people of Mnemosyne’s (LC) Mark Andrews / Alamy Stock Photo; 36 (LT) REUTERS/Elijah Nouvelage; 37 (LC) Album /
Alamy Stock Photo, (LT) incamerastock / Alamy Stock Photo; 38 - posteriori/Shutterstock.
dimension com; 40-41 artifika2010/Shutterstock.com; 40 (RT), 41 (LT) MIT; 42 (TC) Diego Schtutman /
Alamy Stock Photo; 46 (LT) KA-KA/Shutterstock.com; 47 (TC) vectorpouch/Shutterstock.com;
F
FAVORITE ENGLISH WWORD: BC - Elena_Che/Shutterstock.com.
2
Muse Mail
3
friends love reading Muse too, of
course. (The black dragon with
orange stripes, the grey dragon
with blue swirls, etc.) I literally live
Muse Mail
4
CONTEST SPOTLIGHT
13 / New Hampshire
—NIKO C. / age
—AVA R. / age
9 / Massach
husetts
rolina
P. / age 13 / North Ca
—JULIUS P
continued on page 46 »
Something to say?
Send letters to Muse Mail,
70 E. Lake St., Suite 800,
Chicago, IL 60601,
or email them to
[email protected].
5
Muse News
text © 2020 by Elizabeth Preston BY ELIZABETH PRESTON
OOPS
I
N NOVEMBER 2019, THE CAR COMPANY TESLA REVEALED ITS One off
NEXT BIG PRODUCT: an electric truck. It’s called the Cybertruck.
ies is
these stories
It looks like . . . a UFO? Something your little brother built out of
Lego bricks?
n you
FALSE. Can
The truck’s appearance isn’t its only unusual feature. It’s also spot which one?
bulletproof, the company claims. And its windows are shatterproof— e is
er
The answer
or, they’re supposed to be, anyway. In a live demonstration, a Tesla designer on page 46.
4
threw a metal ball at one of the truck’s windows. The window shattered. The
man tried again with a second window, which also smashed.
dn’t
Standing onstage, Tesla CEO Elon Musk pointed out that at least the ball didn’t
go all the way through the windows. People who still like the look of the Cybertruck—
and have about $40,000 to spare—can pre-order one now.
6
DOG MATH
TECH DESK
Brainy
Bike Helmet
IT’S HARD FOR SCIENTISTS TO
STUDY KIDS’ BRAINS. One reason
iis that brain scanners are built for
adult-sized heads. Another problem
a
iis that little kids tend to wiggle
around. A new tool might help:
a
R
Researchers built a brain scanner
iinto a modified bike helmet. The
sscanner uses magnetoencephal-
ography, a technology that
o
measures small magnetic fields the
m
brain produces.
b
In tests, the helmet worked
ffor kids as young as two years
o
old. That could help researchers
llearn more about the brains of
tthe littlest humans.
7
NAVIGATION
Pigeons Train
Muse News
Better Drones
IN RECENT YEARS, SOME COMPANIES
HAVE BEEN TESTING OUT DRONES FOR
DELIVERING PACKAGES. Drones are small
flying robots. In the near future, drones
could carry packages to people’s doorsteps
without having to deal with pesky traffic.
Now one of those companies, Amazon, is
trying to improve its drones with the help
of birds.
Pigeons are natural experts at finding
their way around. And homing pigeons are
pigeons specially trained to fly home after
being released somewhere else. In tests,
researchers found that homing pigeons
were slightly more efficient than delivery
THE AVIAN
drones at returning to their home base. So
Amazon is experimenting with delivery
drones that have a little cage attached. A
ADVANTAGE
homing pigeon waits inside the cage. After
the drone delivers its package, it releases the
pigeon, then follows the bird back to the
launch site.
Keeping pigeons fed and housed at its
warehouses will be an extra expense for
Amazon. But the company says that the
time and battery power it saves with more
efficient deliveries will make up for the cost.
PHYSICS
8
UP IN SPACE
9
by Ashley O’Brien
O’Br
Brie
ien
University
students
compete with
cutting-edge
cars in the
AutoDrive
Challenge.
11
Year 1 (2018) focused on concept
selection. Teams completed a
concept-design paper as well
as simple missions on-site in
Arizona.
Year 2 (2019) focused on urban
driving scenarios. Teams brought
their vehicles to Mcity, a Michigan
test facility that mimics a broad
range of challenges that vehicles
encounter in urban and suburban
driving situations.
Year 3 (2020) focuses on a
ğFWLRQDOULGHVKDULQJGULYLQJ
scenario, with a longer
continuous autonomous The team from Kettering
drive. Teams can show off University has overcome
design innovations and social obstacles to compete in
responsibility statements. the AutoDrive Challenge.
12
Kettering Competes at
the Year Two Event
Kettering’s AutoDrive team arrived at
the competition at MCity and got to
work putting their car back together.
The team got the computer working
but lost its practice time.
During the test drive, Kettering’s
computer operator worked from the
Engineering student front seat. The team’s trained safety
driver sat behind the wheel, ready to
and team member take over if something went wrong.
Kathryn Cesiel An AutoDrive judge rode in the back.
defines an autono- The computer operator sent the car a
set of instructions. Off it went through
mous car as a the obstacle course.
had to build their own GPS software just one type of person, it might and we fail, it’s not the end of the
from scratch. Building GPS software not recognize someone from a world. In our eyes, we are succeeding
is a difficult engineering challenge; culture with different-looking because we saw our design being
these college students designed and clothes, or a person with an implemented. We saw what it did.”
developed something that already ability aid like a wheelchair. These
exists so they will have the skills are among the ethical issues the Ashley O’Brien teaches math and English
they need to develop something teams have to consider as part of to middle schoolers and is a lover of all
completely new. the competition. things learning.
13
Science@Work
by Ashley O’Brien
OLIVIA WANLESS
AUTODRIVE TEAM CAPTAIN
Olivia Wanless is a senior at Kettering University in Flint,
Michigan. She studies electrical engineering with a business
minor. Kettering University is a co-op-based school. That means
every three months, Olivia alternates between working at a
company and going to classes. She works at an automotive
supply company called Nexteer. There she fixes and maintains
machinery on the factory floor.
Wanless also mentors young people interested in
engineering, especially girls. She’s a team captain for the
AutoDrive Challenge, a tutor, and a former president of the
Society of Women Engineers.
14
WHAT EXPERIENCE WHAT IS IT LIKE WORKING AS A STUDENT?
INSPIRED YOU TO GO At first, kind of intimidating. I started working before I started
INTO ENGINEERING? school. I was a little scared, but in the end, that’s what sold me
When I started high school, I on engineering. I knew I liked the job. I get to learn all kinds of
figured out that I really liked things that really put me ahead at school.
math, which I had hated in ________________
elementary and middle school.
My teacher suggested that I WHAT CHALLENGES DO YOU FACE?
try engineering. It hadn’t even My biggest challenge is trying to apply the theoretical things
been on my radar. I learned in school to my job. I took a computer networking
I joined the LITES program class last semester. I learned a lot, but getting to work, I had to
at Kettering. (That’s Lives make connections between the things I know and the physical
Improve Through Engineering things that I’m looking at. I have to figure out how those things
& Science, a program for girls play together.
entering their senior year in ________________
high school.) There I took
an optics class, and it was WHAT ABOUT YOUR FIELD EXCITES
absolutely inspirational. YOU THE MOST?
________________ I’m very interested in ethics. In addition to working on
machines, I get to think about important problems. How do
WHAT ABOUT I make sure that whoever is using this machine is going to be
ELECTRICAL safe? At school and in the AutoDrive challenge, I’m learning
ENGINEERING the same things. For AutoDrive, we have to make sure the
INTERESTS YOU? autonomous technology is safe for people, that the technology
We all have individual is going to make good decisions. I get to help make choices that
problems on the are going to change society for the better.
manufacturing floor, so each ________________
day I get to inspect something
different. There are all sorts of WHAT IS IT LIKE WORKING ON THE
interesting problems, and I am AUTODRIVE CHALLENGE?
always learning. I started working on the AutoDrive challenge 2017. Then in
________________ 2018 I became leader of the Social Responsibility Event. We
think about the effects of self-driving cars. We have to be
CAN YOU DESCRIBE socially responsible and safe. Autonomous cars are so new. As
YOUR CO-OP JOB? a little kid you grow up seeing movies, cars driving themselves.
My second semester in I thought, that’s so cool, my dad won’t have to drive me
the co-op, I went into somewhere. So getting to take part in something that you’ve
manufacturing engineering, seen is really exciting.
which really clicked for me. ________________
The most important thing I
do is fix things on the floor. WHY IS IT IMPORTANT TO BE IN THE SOCIETY OF
Whenever things are not WOMEN ENGINEERS?
working properly, it’s my job I think it’s important for both men and women. Diversity
to go out there and find out makes companies function much better. When I was in high
why. The other half of my job school, I didn’t think it was important. No one ever discouraged
text © 2020 by Ashley O’Brien
is continuous improvement. me. I didn’t understand why there weren’t many women in
I take time not just to fix the engineering. Then I took a class in electronics my senior year. I
little things that break every was the only girl. I love Society for Women Engineers because it
day, but to improve things builds a community. I know so many women at my school that I
for the long term. I want to might never have met without it.
make things easier from now
on instead of just the day-to- Ashley O’Brien is a teacher in Michigan, where she lives with her
day operations. engineer husband and three dogs.
15
Hands-On
16
Brake Time
You’re driving along, and the car ahead of you comes to
a sudden stop. Now you need to stop your car at a safe
distance behind the other vehicle to avoid an accident. How
does a human driver accomplish this? Let’s examine the two
most important factors.
+RZIDUGRHVLWWUDYHO":HFDQğQGRXWZLWKWKLVIRUPXOD
R=sxr
where
R = Reaction Distance, s = speed (how fast you’re going),
r = reaction time (how fast you can apply the brakes)
Reaction times vary. For a driver who is healthy and alert, one
estimate is 1.5 seconds. But any impairment (from being tired
or texting, for example) can make this time, and the distance
the car travels, much longer. Notice that the distance also
increases the faster we go. That’s one reason speeding is
GDQJHURXVHYHQIRUDğWGULYHU
2QHIRUPXOD\RXFDQXVHWRğQGRXWLVWKLVRQH
B = s² / (2 x g x f)
where
B = Braking Distance, s = speed, g = gravity,
f = function (how effective the brakes are)
17
Ready to Program
Using the diagram below, calculate
the distance it will take to stop
the car at each speed. Human
drivers learn distances like these
in driver’s ed. Of course, a real self-
Hands-On
18
1. Use caution when driving down hills. 2. Reduce speed in rain or snow.
The Science
A. Turning objects feel a pull toward the
center called “centripetal acceleration.”
The inward pull increases the faster you go,
PDNLQJVWHHULQJPRUHGLIğFXOW
19
20
by Monette Bebow-Reinhard
21
H
ave you ever EVs v. Hybrids
heard someone EVs are cars or trucks that run only on
electricity. They’re also known as plug-
comparing
ins, as they plug into charging stations
MPGs or wishing to power up on electricity. A powerful
for better battery stores the energy. On average,
“mileage?” Miles per gallon an EV has a range of over 100 miles
(161 km) before the battery needs to
(MPG) is the distance a vehicle be recharged; this process could be
can travel on one gallon of as short as dinner at a restaurant or
gasoline. Gas gets many of longer than a full night’s sleep. Unless
us where we need to go, but you live within a half-day’s drive of the
Grand Canyon, an EV can’t take you
fumes from this fossil fuel there on a single charge.
pollute the air. Humans have Right now, electric vehicles face
burned an unprecedented two big challenges. They have limited
range and cost a lot—more, on
amount of gas since the car
average, than a gas-powered luxury
was mass-marketed in the car. The Tesla Model 3 (a well-known
early 1900s. Fossil fuel air electric sedan) has a range of over 300
pollution is one major reason miles (483 km) and costs more than
$47,000. A number of other car makers
for climate change. have EV models too.
Hybrid vehicles use gas and
electricity, in two motors that work
How do we use less gas—while together. The car’s movement charges
still getting to school, work, and the electric motor. When a hybrid
everywhere else? Well, some say car goes up a hill, it uses both the gas
electric vehicles (EVs) are the future. and electric engines to push the car
Others believe hybrids are the way upward, and when it goes down, the
forward. electric engine takes over. As the car
22
SOLAR SPEED
Could the sun power the car of the future? Created by Australian
engineers and named after a super villain, the rare Immortus Solar
Car can travel 340 miles at 50 mph on a sunny day. Drop the speed to
37 mph and it can go on forever. It also has a plug-in power train.
23
ART SPACE NIC McDOUGAL
LIFE IS BUTTER
WITH WAFFLES
A MAZE
FEED THE FUZZIES!
First, choose your favorite mode
of transport. Next, cut out your
selection. Use the bike path, road
or sidewalk to deliver a delicious
ZDIĠHEUHDNIDVW)DLUZDUQLQJ
Not all modes of transport lead
WRWKHğQLVK
alk,
idew
n the s ar launch H
o Q
Whil the circul \RXUGUR
e
k for WRĠ\ H V
WKHP RWWHGOLQ
loo
8VH
SDGV ORQJWKHG
D
art © 2020 by Nic McDougal
25
Drone Home
UAVs MAY CHANGE THE WAY PACKAGES ARE DELIVERED.
by Peg Lopata
I
companies driving this transportation
t’s official! There’s a new kind of revolution. As of publication, Wing’s
drones are delivering packages in a
airline. It has no pilots on board, limited area in Virginia, as well as
locations in Australia and Finland.
and the passengers won’t be people. Like most drones, Wing’s craft fly an
average of 150 feet (45 m) above the
The aircraft of this airline are ground and can hover like helicopters.
Unfortunately, they cannot fly in all
unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), kinds of weather, such as snow or
hailstorms.
or drones. They will carry small packages,
One Sweet Delivery
such as medicine or boxes of candy. How does drone delivery work? Let’s
say you want to buy Mom a box of
chocolates. You look for just the right
kind for the right price at an online
shop that offers drone deliveries. It
can’t be an enormous box. Wing’s
What Exactly Is a Drone? very far, but specialized long-range drones, for example, can carry a
A drone is a robotic aircraft controlled models can travel several miles in a package only up to 3.3 pounds (1.5 kg).
by sensors, computers, and cameras. flight and can zoom up to 80 miles Say you place your order using Wing’s
A pilot on the ground monitors the (128 km) per hour. mobile app. The shop packs up your
craft. Drones run on rechargeable Wing, a drone maker based in order in a specialized package and
batteries. Most small drones can’t fly Palo Alto, California, is one of many requests a drone. Wing sends a drone
26
Did yo
u
that W know
i
the sa ng has
me
compa parent
ny
Goog as
le?
27
Science@Work
by Peg Lopata
SANJEEV SHARMA
TECHNOLOGY PIONEER
High-speed railroad cars, rockets, and now drones—what
will mechanical engineer Sanjeev Sharma
arma do next? Sharma is
currently head of vehicle engineering g at Matternet, a drone
company in Mountain View, California. a. Whatever lies ahead,
he’ll probably be at the forefront of new technologies that
serve others.
28
SOUNDS LIKE ADVANCED TRANSPORTATION IS YOUR
SPECIALTY. HOW DID ROCKET ENGINEERING LEAD
YOU INTO DRONES?
During my work at SpaceX, I learned a lot about aerodynamics and
the design of reliable, fully autonomous flying vehicles—drones.
Drones, like self-driving cars, will open up a new world. I grew
intrigued by this possibility and was excited to join Matternet in
2018, as they are pioneers in this emerging technology.
________________
YOU’VE WORKED
ON MANY NEW
TECHNOLOGIES.
TELL US ABOUT
SOME OF THEM.
Before joining Matternet
Matternet, I
worked with Elon Musk at
his company called Spac
SpaceX,
working on the reusable
rocket. Before that I worked
wor The Matternet Station
in design of high-speed automated drone deliveries
railroad cars for Indian Rail
R of packages, including
medical supplies.
in India, where I’m from.
from
29
Science@Work
ALL BY
THEMSELVES
Drones can deliver
packages with very few
people involved in the
ĠLJKW8VLQJQRERG\at
allLVWKHQH[WVWHS7R
DFFRPSOLVKWKLVWKH\łOO
QHHGWREHHTXLSSHG
ZLWKDUWLğFLDOLQWHOOLJHQFH
$, 5DLQWXUQVWRKDLO"$,
LQLWLDWHVDUHWXUQWRODXQFK
VLWH6DQMHHY6KDUPDKHDG
RIYHKLFOHHQJLQHHULQJDW
California drone company
WOW! THIS TECHNOLOGY SOUNDS ADVANCED. 0DWWHUQHWLVFRQğGHQW
WHAT’S BEEN YOUR GREATEST RECENT that AI will make drone
ACCOMPLISHMENT? GHOLYHULHVŃFRQYHQLHQW
As a result of a year-long effort at making drones more capable IDVWHUFKHDSHUDQGPRUH
and reliable, we now have permission from the US government UHOLDEOHń
to operate like an airline. In the US, you need permission to fly :KDWLV$,"3HRSOH
over people and cities. The government agency that gives this GHVFULEHPDFKLQHVWKDW
permission, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), gave PDNHWKHLURZQGHFLVLRQV
United Parcel Service (UPS), with us as their drone operator, DVDUWLğFLDOO\LQWHOOLJHQW,I
this permission. This is a first in aviation history for commercial DW\SLFDOGURQHHQFRXQWHUV
drones. It was a huge win for our entire team and gave me great DVLWXDWLRQIRUZKLFKLW
KDVQRLQVWUXFWLRQVLW
satisfaction.
ZRQłWNQRZZKDWWRGR
________________ +RZHYHUDQ$,PDFKLQH
ZLOOJREH\RQGIROORZLQJ
THIS BUSINESS OF USING DRONES FOR DELIVERIES DVHWRILQVWUXFWLRQV,W
MUST BE GROWING AND GROWING. WHAT WOULD FROOHFWVH[SHULHQFHVDVZH
YOU ADVISE A YOUNG PERSON INTERESTED IN GRDQGWKHQOHDUQVEDVHG
GETTING INTO YOUR FIELD AS A DRONE ENGINEER? RQWKRVHH[SHULHQFHV
This is a great field to be in. You need to learn engineering and :LWKPDFKLQHOHDUQLQJ$,
computers. Robotics requires specialization in various fields like ŃEUDLQVńZRUNPRUHOLNH
mechanical, electrical, software, or computers. You could choose KXPDQEUDLQV
from a wide array from what appeals to you the most. ,I\RXDUHIDVFLQDWHG
ZLWK$,\RXZHUHERUQDW
________________
WKHULJKWWLPHŃ2XUIXWXUH
LVJRLQJWREHGRPLQDWHG
EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES, SUCH AS DRONES, ARE E\LQWHOOLJHQWPDFKLQHV
EXCITING, BUT SOMETIMES CHALLENGING. HAVE WKDWWDNHRYHUPRVWRIWKH
YOU HAD DISAPPOINTMENTS? PXQGDQHWDVNVIUHHLQJ
Though it may seem frustrating sometimes, it’s never KXPDQVWREHPRUH
text © 2020 by Peg Lopata
30
Q&A BY LIZZIE WADE
31
32
A System
in Sync
by Fiona Young-Brown
Smart cars
need smart
roads.
33
i
t is time to go to
school. You go to the
bus stop and at exactly
the correct time, the
bus arrives. There is
no driver. The bus can
drive itself. You get on,
sit down, and the bus
continues its journey. In
the lane next to you, you
see several cars, but no one is
driving them either. Instead,
people are chatting or even
reading a book. The bus stops
at an intersection because it
has communicated with the
WUDIğFOLJKWVDQGNQRZVWKDW
pedestrians are crossing the
road. It is just pulling away
when it stops again. It has
detected a child running into
the street. A few minutes later,
you arrive at school, safe and
ready to start your day.
34
”
ory
t r a ject that
ht “ ctory ing
oug a
I th be a f ic-look t’s
i g h t r a g ss i r
m
k es t t I gue o
m a u rd f
o y s. B ong wo
t a l th.”
just “pa
That would alert the car that it’s at a cars with traffic lights so that they
stoplight. But Rowe asks, what if the work together. Signals might tell cars
sun is shining in a way that makes the about a red light and help ensure a
light hard to see? What if it’s raining safe stop. Glenn Beach, president of
heavily or there is thick fog? Suddenly Cybernet Systems, foresees a possible
the camera can’t perceive the red light network of control towers, rather
any better than a human driver could. like that found in airports. However,
Then there are other problems. Is the these would be fully automated and
red light in your lane or another lane? look like a radio transmitter. Signals
Is it a stoplight or a store sign? How far from cars and roadways would all
away is it? Obviously, we don’t want a come to and from these towers,
self-driving car that stops immediately allowing communication among the
every time it detects red; that could be entire network. Rowe agrees: “Each
run on their own—autonomously. He very dangerous. So knowing not just intersection would act like an air-
explains that a vehicle needs lots of how to react but when to react is vital. traffic control tower, communicating
sensors to do the job that our eyes and with each other and able to route
ears would usually do. These sensors Can a Car Talk traffic along alternate routes to
include cameras, radar, and lidar. with a Road? alleviate traffic congestion.” That’s
Each one works in a different way to Self-driving cars don’t just need to right, smart roads could mean fewer
sense objects that might get in the be able to drive. They also need to traffic jams!
path of the car. Making the sensors be able to communicate with other
work so that they do “see” things in vehicles on the road, with the road What about
their way is fairly easy. But then using itself, and with traffic signals, lights, Pedestrians?
the sensors to interpret what they and more. Engineers and scientists Where will pedestrians and
see is much more complicated . . . have imagined lots of different ways bicyclists fit into the road system of
even when it’s something that sounds that a smart car might be able to tomorrow? If vehicles and streets
simple. Rowe gives one example of a communicate with a smart road. For are communicating by radio signals
sensor recognizing that a light is red. example, radio signals might link and sensors, does that make things
35
The small inset image is
from a video captured by a
self-driving car. The larger road could light glow-in-
image shows the same the-dark lanes, providing
street, with data visualized better navigation for drivers
by the car’s computer.
at night. The Netherlands
experiment was so successful
that in 2019, tests started on
two other roads with heavier
traffic (i.e. cars and trucks).
China is testing a similar
system in the hope that solar
roads could eventually melt
snow and light signals to help
warn traffic of hazards. Many
experts believe that China
has the resources to win the
race in having truly smart
roads, although this is still
several years from becoming
a reality.
In the meantime, we can
expect to find self-driving
safer or more complicated for those vehicles and roadways would need vehicles in smaller areas.
traveling by foot? One possibility is to use the same system. Otherwise, For example, some factories and
that roads continue to have sidewalks chaos could follow. Then there is the warehouses now have automated
and bicycle lanes, as they do now. In problem of cost. The various sensors carts that use sensors and guided
this case, we would still need familiar in self-driving cars built for smart routes to move materials from one
lights and signals. Crosswalks could roads can exceed $100,000 per vehicle. spot to another. Tram and similar
be equipped with sensors so that they That price means very few people public-transportation systems could
light up green or red, depending on could afford one. In addition, roads also work in city centers within a
whether it is safe to cross. And this would require massive renovations. few years.
could be taken one step further. What This would be very expensive to both
if the road detects that someone has states and the federal highway system. Exciting
stepped onto its surface and sends Another hurdle? Even if people Discoveries Ahead
a signal to stop any oncoming cars? build all of this infrastructure, there Fully autonomous cars and smart
However, this could cause problems will not be an overnight switch from roads may seem a long way off.
too. People might be tempted to step human to robot. Rather, it will take But there are many reasons to
into the road as they like, without care many years, as people move on from feel inspired. Beach calls this an
for traffic, and fast-moving cars would one car to another. Beach estimates exciting time, much like the space
not have enough time to stop. Another the transition period could take 20 race in the 1960s. Many items that
possibility is that we design two years or longer. Even then, there may we take for granted now developed
separate systems: roads for motorized still be some people who prefer to from technologies designed for
and automated vehicles and pathways drive themselves and don’t want to use in space. GPS systems, camera
for pedestrians and cyclists. change to automation. Therefore, the phones, and memory-foam
system will need to work with both mattresses all have their roots in
Hurdles to Leap automated and human operators. space exploration. Beach says that
text © 2020 by Fiona Young-Brown
While this all sounds very futuristic, engineers are likely to come up with
there are a number of obstacles Smarter Roads lots of new products as they work
to overcome before we see fully in the Making? on building smarter cars. What new
automated vehicles and roads. For Some countries have already been inventions can you think of that
starters, the technology is complex, experimenting with different types of might be with us soon?
especially when each part needs to smarter roads. A solar-powered cycle
interact with everything else. Rowe path opened in the Netherlands in Fiona Young-Brown is the author of more
notes that there is no agreement at 2014. Solar panels in the path make than a dozen books. She lives in Lexington,
the moment as to what information electricity that powers public lighting Kentucky, and enjoys going on long drives.
needs to be sharied—and how that and traffic signals. Some experts say She would like a self-driving car that lets
communication will happen. All that in the future, solar panels in the her enjoy the scenery more as she travels.
36
BY IVARS PETERSON
37
Moral
Machines
by Fiona Young-Brown
H
ave you ever heard
of the trolley
problem? It is a
set of imaginary
scenarios used by ethicists—
people who ask questions
about right and wrong.
38
39
Quizzing Drivers
More than 40 million people took an online quiz that asked ethical questions
Here’s one scenario. Say you are about driving. But, for most people, these questions are purely what-ifs, not
driving a car down a curvy mountain the stuff of real life.
road when you suddenly meet a flock
of sheep. You don’t have time to stop.
You could swerve into the mountain
(and probably die). You could swerve
in the other direction, off the side of
the mountain (and definitely die). Or
you could plow into the sheep (which
will probably kill some sheep and
damage your car, but you will likely
be OK). Yikes. What do you do?
What if it is not a flock of sheep
but a pair of bicyclists? Would your
answer be different now?
Now imagine you are in heavy
traffic and your car’s brakes start to
fail. If you keep going straight, you
will go into the back of a semi-truck
and probably die. But if you swerve
to avoid the truck, you risk hitting an
elderly woman or a group of children.
What do you do?
These are extreme choices. But
every day, drivers around the world
have to make split-second decisions
to avoid accidents. Often, they react
without even having time to think.
But what would a driverless car do?
Self-driving cars are programmed
to deal with all sorts of situations,
from understanding traffic rules to
planning the easiest route that avoids two pedestrians in front of you or So who should decide? Some people
construction. These programming swerve to hit a concrete wall? Does it say that the carmaker should program
decisions are straightforward. Ethics, depend on how many people are in the car. Others say that perhaps
on the other hand, is not. How do you the car? On whether the pedestrians each car owner should choose a set
program a car to decide what to do are male or female? Young or old? of programs when they buy the car.
in an accident? How do you choose In total, more than 40 million Others say governments should decide.
which life is more valuable? And people around the world have
who gets to choose? Should it be the answered the 13 questions in the Problems with the
car owner? The manufacturer? The quiz. The results are interesting. Trolley Problem
government? This is a problem that The scientists found that there is The trouble with the trolley problem and
ethicists, lawyers, and car makers are no one “correct” set of answers. the Moral Machine test is that they are
all wondering about. Everyone’s answers are typically not really very accurate for the type of
based on their own age, gender, situations we will face in the real world.
The Moral Machine Test culture, religion, and more. It might A car’s sensors might be able to detect
In 2016, a group of professors at be possible to make a car that can an object, as well as its size and whether
the Massachusetts Institute for drive by itself. But since everyone it is moving. But they cannot currently
Technology (MIT) created the Moral has different ideas about right and interpret that information to understand
Machine. This is an online quiz that wrong, who should decide how a if the object is a dog or a child, an old
anyone can take. It measures people’s self-driving car behaves? The results man or a young woman, or even if the
responses to ethical problems. One of of the Moral Machine test show person is or isn’t wearing a safety helmet.
the quizzes focuses on driving. Sample that what might be considered the So all of those detailed choices about
questions include equivalents of the correct choice in one place would whether it is better to hit the sheep or the
trolley problem. Should you hit the be wrong in another. bicyclist are not very realistic.
40
Casey is a fellow at the Center
for Automotive Research. He
teaches at Stanford Law School.
Casey says that what a self-
driving car does in a crash is not
an ethical issue at all. Instead,
it is a legal issue. If a driver has
a collision now, the law decides
if he was driving dangerously or
if it was truly an accident. If the
driver was dangerously careless,
he faces penalties, often a fine or
jail. If a malfunction caused the
crash, the manufacturer might
be at fault. Either way, laws exist
to determine what is wrong, and
who is responsible. Casey says
that will not change with the
arrival of self-driving cars.
He does not believe that
self-driving cars are capable of
thinking and making decisions
for themselves. So who will
decide what cars should do?
According to Casey, laws will
guide carmakers’ choices.
We expect self-driving cars to
be very safe, safer than human
drivers because computers can
react more quickly. And indeed,
a well-designed autonomous
vehicle should be able to make
The Ethicist Opinion surrounding self-driving cars. They dozens of calculations at a time,
Patrick Lin teaches robotics and published a lengthy report, and in slowing down or speeding up
ethics at California Polytechnic State one chapter, Lin discusses the ethical in relation to its surroundings.
University. He says that it might seem problems. He wrote that any type Nevertheless, accidents can
easy to say that self-driving cars must of decision-making based on age, always happen. This means that
follow certain rules, such as to minimize gender, or any similar factor would drivers, manufacturers, and
harm, but he says, “even that quickly be discrimination and therefore lawmakers will need to deal with
leads to morally murky decisions.” He against professional codes of ethics. new problems as they arise.
gives an example: on one side of you He explained that even the safest car Driving laws have changed
is a motorcyclist wearing a helmet; on runs the risk of having accidents, and over time to reflect updates in
the other is a motorcyclist not wearing that the responsibility for program- technology. And they will keep
a helmet. If the car’s computer tells it ming will lie with the manufacturer. changing. Remember the trolley
to minimize harm during a necessary Whether that decision is to protect problem? What would you have
text © 2020 by Fiona Young-Brown
swerve, that might mean hitting the passengers at all costs, or to avoid the done in each situation? And even
person with the helmet. After all, they most damage, or something else en- more important—how would you
are better protected and so less likely to tirely, Lin says it is a no-win situation. decide what is right or wrong for
be hurt. But, Lin asks, aren’t you being Just as with human drivers, there will a car without a driver?
unfair to the responsible motorist? always be accidents where someone
On the other hand, hitting the person gets hurt. Fiona Young-Brown is a writer from
without a helmet could be described England who now lives in Kentucky.
as “street justice.” The Legal Opinion 6KHLVDIDQRIVFLHQFHğFWLRQPRYLHV
In 2015, German carmaker Daimler- But some experts say we don’t need especially those with cars that can
Benz started to look at some of the issues to worry about this problem. Bryan drive themselves!
41
Hands-On
Funny sentences
Cate.
Kathryn Hulick
42
<RXUDODUPBBBBBBBBBEODVWVBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB<RXBBBBBBBBDQG
NOUN A POPULAR SONG VERB
SXOO\RXUEODQNHWRYHU\RXUBBBBBBBBBB<RXZHUHKDYLQJVXFKDJUHDW
BODY PART
GUHDPDERXWBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB7KHQ\RXUHPHPEHU<RXłUH
ADJECTIVE PLURAL NOUN
VXSSRVHGWRPHHWBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBWKLVPRUQLQJDWBBBBBBBBBBB
NAME OF A PERSON PLACE
,WłVWKHFKDPSLRQVKLSBBBBBBBBBBBBBJDPHWRGD\+RZDUH\RXJRLQJ
SPORT
WRJHWWKHUH"7KDWłVHDV\<RXWDSDQDSSRQ\RXUBBBBBBBBBBVFUHHQ
NOUN
to call a ride.
City dwellers already call for rides from their phones all
the time. In the future, it’s likely that few people will own
cars. They will use ride services or public transportation
instead.
2QWKHZD\RXWWKHGRRU\RXORQJLQJO\VWDUHDWWKHBBBBBBBBBBBB
ADJECTIVE
MHWSDFNKDQJLQJRQWKHZDOORIWKHBBBBBBBBBB,WEODVWVDSHUVRQ
ROOM
WKURXJKWKHDLUDWBBBBBBBBBBBBBPLOHVSHUKRXU,WKDVZLQJVVKDSHG
LARGE NUMBER
OLNHBBBBBBBBBBDQGJX]]OHVBBBBBBBBBIXHOEXW\RXKDYHWREHDW
NOUN LIQUID
OHDVWBBBBBBB\HDUVROGWRXVHLW
NUMBER
’s
6FLHQFHğFWLRQZULWHUVKDYHLPDJLQHGDOOVRUWVRIRXWODQGLVKZD\V
IRUSHRSOHWRJHWDURXQGLQWKHIXWXUH:KRZRXOGQłWORYHWREODVW
RIIWKHJURXQGDQG]LSWKURXJKWKHDLUZLWKDMHWSDFN"5HDOMHWSDFNV
exist, but they can keep a person in the air for only a few seconds
RUPLQXWHVDWDWLPHEHIRUHEXUQLQJWKURXJKDOOWKHLUIXHO :DWHU
SRZHUHGMHWSDFNVFDQUXQIRUXSWRWZRKRXUVEXWRQO\LI\RXĠ\ORZ
RYHUZDWHUXVLQJDKRVHWRGUDZXSPRUHZDWHUWRNHHS\RXJRLQJ
$OVRLWWDNHVDKLJKOHYHORIVNLOOWRVDIHO\RSHUDWHDQH[SORVLYH
HQJLQHVWUDSSHGWR\RXUEDFN$Ġ\LQJPRWRUF\FOHOLNHYHKLFOHWKDW
carries one person would be safer and more practical. The company
-HW3DFN$YLDWLRQLVEXLOGLQJRQHWKDWVKRXOGEHDEOHWRĠ\IRU
minutes at a time.
43
While you’re waiting on the front steps, you decide to order
Hands-On
You or someone you know may already own a drone. These small aircraft are
fun to play with, but they could also revolutionize how stuff moves around the
JOREH,QUHPRWHSDUWVRIWKHZRUOGVHOIĠ\LQJGURQHVDUHDOUHDG\KHOSLQJWR
deliver life-saving drugs, blood products, and other important supplies. In the
future, drones could deliver toothpaste, oranges, toilet paper, or anything else
you need. Google’s drone delivery service, Wing, launched in Australia in 2019.
And Amazon plans to launch Prime Air. The idea is that when a customer places
an order, a drone takes off from the nearest warehouse with the goods and
ĠLHVLWVHOIWRWKHSHUVRQłVKRPHDOOZLWKLQPLQXWHV:K\GRQłWZHKDYHWKLV
VHUYLFH\HW"*HWWLQJSHUPLVVLRQWRĠ\SDFNDJHVDOORYHUWKHSODFHKDVQłWEHHQ
easy. Drones have to meet strict safety standards to make sure they don’t
crash into anything.
Self-driving cars could make the roads much safer. Their computer systems wouldn’t fall
asleep or get distracted by a text message or feel road rage. However, self-driving cars
aren’t safe enough yet. They may not notice or understand how to handle certain obstacles
LQWKHURDGOLNHWKHĠDVKLQJOLJKWVDQGEODULQJVLUHQVRIHPHUJHQF\YHKLFOHV$KXPDQGULYHU
must still be prepared to take over. Smaller, self-driving bikes or scooters would move more
slowly than cars and could drive in bike lanes or pedestrian areas. So they may be ready to
go sooner. MIT engineers Kent Larson and Michael Lin designed and tested the Persuasive
Electric Vehicle (PEV). They hope that it will someday deliver packages or bring people to
work in cities. Riders can let the bike drive itself or pedal and steer. The car-sharing company
Uber is also looking into self-driving electric bikes and scooters.
44
When you arrive, your friend looks ___________. The championship
EMOTION
was cancelled due to _________________. You decide to go to
NATURAL DISASTER
__________ instead. Time for another ride. This time, you call a car
PLACE
so you can talk about ____________ together on the way. You’ve
PLURAL NOUN
only been traveling ________ minutes when something goes
NUMBER
wrong. The car’s high-tech _________ system starts
NOUN
___________________. You ask the car to drive _________ to the
VERB ENDING IN -ING ADVERB
closest fuel station. Most cars these days run on fuel made from
__________ or ________________.
LIQUID CHEMICAL ELEMENT
Burning gasoline and other fossil fuels for transportation releases greenhouse gases that worsen climate
change. In the US, cars, trucks, aircraft, and other vehicles add more of these dangerous gases to the atmo-
sphere than any other industry. What could power vehicles instead? Electric engines are one option. These
run on batteries. They don’t worsen climate change—as long as the energy to make and charge the batteries
comes from a renewable source like wind farms or solar panels. Another option is a hydrogen fuel cell. This
ZRUNVDORWOLNHDEDWWHU\%XWLQVWHDGRIFKDUJLQJLWDWDQRXWOHW\RXğOOWKHFHOOZLWKK\GURJHQJDV+\GURJHQ
(the most abundant element in the universe) is cheap and easy to produce. The process requires electricity,
which hopefully comes from a renewable source. In the fuel cell, the hydrogen gets converted back into elec-
WULFLW\WRUXQDQHQJLQHOHWWLQJRIIKDUPOHVVVWHDP)XHOFHOOVFDQEHUHğOOHGLQDIHZPLQXWHVZKLOHDEDWWHU\
may take hours to fully charge. Some people already drive electric cars and hydrogen fuel cell cars. As these
vehicles get less expensive and charging stations or hydrogen fueling stations become more common, more
people will likely switch to the new technology.
ARTICLE OF CLOTHING
championship is back on! This time, you walk a few blocks to
45
CONTEST
NEW CONTEST
ANSWERS
PAGES 6–9
Muse News False Story “Pigeons Train Better Drones”
PAGES 16–19
Calculate the Distance (rounding to nearest whole number): 65 ft, 113 ft, 170 ft, 238 ft
Science in the Driver’s Seat: 1D, 2C, 3A, 4B
46
Your Tech BY KATHRYN HULICK
47
BY NANCY KANGAS GRETA SONGE
RETHINKING
PIZZA
Last Slice
DELIVERY
Sure, new technology is changing the way we
move ourselves—and our stuff—from one place
to another. But pizza? Let’s not mess around! We
suggest: robotic llamas and ropes and pulleys.
You’re welcome.
d lots of batteries.
CONCERN: Robotic llamas nee
RAN OU T OF BAT TERIES BEFORE THEY
WHAT IF THEY
GOT TO MY HOUSE?
robotic llamas! Their
RESOLUTION: Solar-powered
hats are actually solar pan els!
48
Growing Up? We grow with you!
Our future is
going to be dominated
by intelligent machines
that take over most
of the mundane tasks,
freeing humans to be
more creative.