Unit 6 Analysis
Unit 6 Analysis
Contents
6.0 Aims and Objectives
6.1 Introduction
6.2 Meaning of the Market
6.3 Elements of Market
6.4 Classification of Market
6.4.1 On the Basis of Area
6.4.2 On the Basis of Time
6.4.3 On the Basis of Nature of competition
6.5 Conditions for the Existence of Perfect Market
6.6 Short Run Equilibrium of the Firm
6.6.1 Total Approach
6.6.2 Marginal Approach
6.7 Short Run Profit or Loss?
6.8 Short run Supply Curve
6.9 Long Run Equilibrium of the Firm
6.10 Imperfect Competition
6.10.1 Monopoly Defined
6.10.2 Price and Output Determination Under Monopoly
6.11 Key terms
6.12 Answer to Check Your Progress Exercise
6.13 Model Examination Questions
6.14 References
The purpose of the unit is to explain the meaning, elements and different forms of markets
and the determination of price of a product under different periods, such as short run and long
run.
161
list the elements of the markets
classify the market on the basis of, area, time and nature of competition,
determine the pice under different time periods, namely short run and long run,
and
distinguish perfect competition from imperfect competition.
6.1 INTRODUCTION
We have learnt the analysis of cost in the earlier unit. Now let us try to introduce the concept
of market and different types of market structure. This chapter concentrates on two major
market structure, namely perfect competition and Imperfect competition. We will first deal
with the characteristics of perfect competition and equilibrium of the firm and industry in
perfect competition is short and long run. This will be flowed by discussion on price and
output determination under monopoly, an example of imperfect competition.
The term ‘market’ is and elusive concept. The word is generally used to describe the process
of exchange. The process of exchange always involves certain elements such as goods or
service, buyers, place and time.
Some element of markets are (1) there must be a commodity which is to be dealt with (2)
there must be buyer and sellers, (3) there must be a place, be it a certain province, a country or
the entire world, where the process of exchange takes place (4) there must be intercourse
between buyers and sellers.
We may classify markets into three categories according to factors such as area, time and
nature of competition
162
(a) Local markets:
markets: certain commodities, which are perishable and which are cheap have local
markets. For example, milk, fish and vegetables usually have local markets.
(b) National markets:
markets: there are some goods which have national market. For example certain
varieties of cloth, say “ Yager Lebes” (i,e, locally made national cloth), have national market.
There may not be a market for “Yager Lebes” in other nations for their mode of dress is
different. They may not wear “Yager lebes”.Similarly “Tella “ and “Tej”, a national drink of
Ethiopia, has national market.
(c ) International markets:
markets: there are certain commodities the transactions of which are
carried on through the world. For example, gold, steel, wool and tea etc..
b) Imperfect competition:
competition: A market is said to be imperfect when the buyer or seller or
both are not aware of the offers being made by others. Naturally, therefore, different
prices come to prevail for the same commodity at the same time in an imperfect
market. Imperfect market is a market in which a firm is a ”price maker”. In the real
163
world, however, we cannot find a perfect market. Especially, in this dynamic world
imperfect market is widely practiced.
Explained in section 6.4 above, perfect market (or perfectly competitive market) is one type
of market classified on the basis of nature of competition. It is a market structure
characterized by a complete absence of rivalry among the individual firms. Thus perfect
competition in economic theory has a meaning diametrically opposite to the everyday use of
this term. In practice businessmen use the word competition as synonymous to rivalry. In
theory, perfect competition implies no rivalry among firms.
164
The followings are the conditions (assumptions) for the existence of perfect market. A market
is said to be perfectly competitive when the following assumptions are fulfilled.
The number of buyers and sellers under perfect market are very large. When there are large
number of sellers and buyers, each contributing only an insignificant portion to the total
volume of goods sold and bought, it is difficult for any one seller or buyer or even a group of
sellers or buyers to affect the price. In other words, the price of the product in the market is
the result of the combined influence of all the firms in the industry and once a price is
determined, each one of the firms takes it for granted and adjusts its own output to that price.
Thus each seller is a “ price taker”.
Thus, the large number of buyers and sellers assumed to exist in a perfectly competitive
market explains the lack of control by individual buyers over price. In a perfectly competitive
market the demand for output of each seller is perfectly elastic, indicating that the firm can
sell any amount of out put at the prevailing market price. The demand curve of the individual
firm is also its average revenue (AR) and its marginal revenue (MR) curve.( look fig 6.1)
Price (p)
Where p: market price
AR: Average revenue
MR: Marginal revenue
p p= AR=MR
0 out put
Fig 6.1
b) Product homogeneity:
The product offered for sale by all sellers must be homogenous. The goods offered for sale are
perfect substitutes for one another from buyers’ point of view. Thus, no advertising to
differentiate between the products of various sellers. From this condition of homogeneity of
the product, it follows that if a seller raises his price slightly above the current level, he will
165
lose all his customers to the other sellers. Nor will be lower his price from the ruling price,
since he can sell all his output at the prevailing price. This condition also points out to the
same conclusion that every seller under perfect competition will be content to accept the
prevailing price in the market.
d ) Profit Maximization
Fourthly, each seller is aimed at maximizing profits. The ultimate goal is possible profit. No
other goals are pursued.
e) No government regulation
The fifth requirement of perfect competition is that there is no government intervention in the
market. The government can not manage the activities (operations ) of the firm.
166
h) Perfect knowledge
Finally, it is assumed that all sellers and buyers have complete knowledge of the conditions of
the market. Buyers and sellers possess complete information (knowledge) about the prices at
which goods are being bought and sold.
NB. The first six conditions (a-f) we have enumerated above, are the conditions necessary for
pure competition, while the last two (g-h), in addition to the first seven conditions will bring
about perfect competition.
1. What is the shape of the demand curve facing a perfectly competitive firm? What is
implied by such a demand curve?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
The firm is in equilibrium when it maximizes its profits, defined as the difference between
total cost (TC) and total revenue (TR). That is total profit = TR-TC. The equilibrium of the
firm may be shown graphically in two ways. Either by using the TR and TC curves (called
total approach), or the marginal revenue (MR) and marginal cost (MC) curves (called
marginal approach). Here MR is the change in TR for a one-unit change in the quality sold.
167
Table 6.1
1 2 3 4 5
Output Price Total revenue Total cost Total Profits
(Q) (In Birr) (In Birr) (In birrr) (In Birr)
0 8 0 800 -800
100 8 800 2000 -1200
200 8 1600 2300 -700
300 8 2400 2400 0
400 8 3200 2524 +676
500 8 4000 2775 +1225
600 8 4800 3200 +1600
650 8 5200 3510 1690
700 8 5600 4000 1600
800 8 6400 6400 0
In the above table 6.1 out put (column 1) times price (column2) gives us TR (column3). TR
minus TC (column 4) gives us total profits (column 5).
So the table reveals to us the fact that total profit are maximized ( at birr 1690) when the firm
produces and sells 60 units of the commodity per time period.
The profit maximizing level of out put for this firm can also be viewed from the figure 6.2
below (obtained by plotting the values of columns 1,3,4, and 5 of the above taste). In this
figure the arrows indicate parallels lines and the TR curve is a positively sloped straight line
through the origin because price remains constant at birr 8. At 100 units of output, this firm
maximizes total losses or negative profits (point A).At 300 units of output,TR equals TC
(point B) and the firms breaks even. The firm maximizes its total profits (point D) when it
produces and sells 650 units of output. At this output level, the TR curve and the TC curve
have the same slope and so the vertical distance between them is greatest.
168
Fig 6.2 Graph
6.6.2 Marginal Approach
In general, it is more useful to analyze the short run equilibrium of the firm with the marginal
revenue – marginal cost approach. Marginal revenue (MR) is the change in TR for a one unit
change in the quantity sold. Thus, MR equals the slope of the TR curve. Since in perfect
competition, p is constant for the firm, MR equals p. The marginal approach tells us that the
perfectly competitive firm maximizes its short-run totals profits at the out put level, when MR
or p equals marginal cost (MC) and MC is rising. The firm is in short run equilibrium at this
best or optimum, level of output. look at the table 6.2 below.
Table 6.2
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
Output (Q) Price=MR marginal Average cost Profit/Unit Total Profits
(in Birr) cost (in Birr) (in Birr) (in Birr) (in Birr)
100 8 12.00 20.00 -12.00 -1200
200 8 3.00 11.50 -3.50 -700
300 8 1.00 8.00 0 0
400 8 1.25 6.31 +1.69 +676
500 8 2.50 5.55 +2.45 +1225
600 8 4.25 5.33 +2.67 +1602
650 8 (8.00) 5.40 +2.60 +1690
700 8 8.00 5.71 +2.29 +1603
800 8 24.00 8.00 0 0
In the above table 6.2 above, column (1) and (2) are the same as in Table 6.1. Column (3) and
(4) of table 6.2 are calculated directly from column (4) and column (1) of table 6.1 (since the
169
MC values refer to the mid points between successive levels of output, the MC at 650 units of
out put is birr 8 and is the same as the MC recorded along side 700 units of out put) . The
values in column (5) are obtained by subtracting each value of column (4) from the
corresponding value in column (2). The values of column (6) are then obtained by multiplying
each value of column (5) by the values in column (1). Note that the values of total profits are
the same as those in table 6.1 (except for two very small rounding errors). The firm
maximizes total profits when it produces 650 units of output. At that level of out put, MR=
MC and MC is rising.
The profit maximizing, or best level of out put for this firm can also be viewed from figure
6.3 below (obtained by plotting the values of the first four columns of table 6.2). As long as
MR exceeds MC (from A’ to D’), it pays for the firm to expand output. The firm would be
adding more to its TR than to its TC and so its total profits would rise. It does not pay for the
firm to produce past points D’ since MC exceeds MR. The firm would be adding more to its
TC than to its TR and so its total profits would fall. Thus, the firm maximizes its total profits
at the output level of 650 units ( given by point D’, where P or MR equals MC and MC is
rising ). The profit per unit at this level of output is given by D’D” or birr 2.60, while total
profit is given by the area of rectangle D’D”FG, which equals birr 1690.
170
Check Your Progress Exercise - 3
1. What is marginal revenue and why is price always equal to marginal revenue under
perfect competition?
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
2. What are the two conditions that should be fulfilled by the firm to maximize its total
profits using marginal approach?
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………
If, at the best, or optimum, level of output, price (p) exceeds average cost (AC) the firm is
maximizing total profits; if p is less than AC but greater that AVC, the firm is minimizing
total losses; if p is less that AVC, the firm minimizes its total losses by shutting down.
Fig. 6.4 shows hypothetical MC, AC and AVC curves for a “Representative” firm; d 1 to d4
(and MR1 to MR4) are alternative demand (and marginal revenue) curves that might face the
perfectly competitive firm. The results with each alternative demand curve are summarized in
table6.3.
171
Fig 6.4.
Table 6.3
Equilibrium Output Price (P) AC Profit/ Total Result
point (q) ( in Birr) (intirr) unit (in Profits
Birrr) (in birr)
Total
With d4 A 600 19 15.00 4.00 2,400 profits
maximized
Break
With d3 B 500 14 14.00 0 0 even point
Total
With d2 C 400 10 15.00 -5.00 -2,000 losses
minimized
Shut down
With d1 F 300 7 16.33 -9.33 -2,800 point
With d2, if the firm stopped producing, it would incur a total loss equal to its total fixed cost
(TFC) of birr 2800 ( obtained from the average fixed cost (AFC) of DE, or birr 7 per unit,
times 400). With d1 , P= average variable cost(AVC) and so TR = TVC (Total variale cost).
Therefore, the firm is indifferent to whether it produces or not ( in either case it would incur
total losses equal to its TFC). At prices below birr 7 per unit, AVC exceeds P and so TVC
exceeds TR. Therefore, the firm minimizes its total losses ( at the level of its TFC of birr
2800) by shutting down altogether.
Since, in perfectly competitive market we can read from the MC curve how much the firm
will produce and sell at various prices, the firm’s short-run supply curve is given by the rising
portion of its MC curve (over and above its AVC curve). If factor prices remain constant, the
competitive industry short run supply curve is obtained by summing horizontally the short run
MC SMC curves (over and above their respective AVC curves) of all the firms in the
industry.
Panel A of the figure 6.5 below gives the short run supply curve derived from that portion of
the MC curve that lies above the minimum point of AVC ( please see fig6.4 above).
172
Fig 6.5
The industry or market short run supply curve shown in panel B above is obtained on the
assumption that there are 100 identical firms in the industry and factor prices remain constant
to this industry regardless of the amounts of inputs it uses (The “ “ sign refers to the “
summation of “.) Note that no output of the commodity is produced at prices below birr 7 per
unit.
In the long run, all factors of production and all costs are variable. Therefore, a firm will
remain in business in the long run only if (by constructing the most appropriate plant to
produce the best level of out put) its TR equals or is greater than its TC. The best, or
optimum, level of out put for a perfectly competitive firm in the long run is given by the point
173
where P or MR equals long run MC (LMC) and LMC is rising . If, at this level of out put, the
firm is making a profit, more firms will enter the perfectly competitive industry until all
profits are squeezed out.
In the figure 6.6 below, at the market price of birr 16, the perfectly competitive firm is in long
run equilibrium at point A, where P or MR = SMC=LMC = SAC=LAC. The firm produces
and sells 700 units of out put per time period, utilizing the most appropriate scale of plant
(represented by SAC 2) at point B. The firm makes a profit of birr 5 per unit (AB) and a total
profit of birr 3500.
Fig 6.6
Since the firm in fig. 6.6 is making profits, in the long run more firms will enter the industry,
attracted by those profits. The market supply of the commodity will increase, causing the
market equilibrium price to fall. This will continue until all firms just break even. In figure 6.6
this occurs at point E, where P=MR=SMC=LMC=SAC=LAC=8 birr. The firm will operate
the optimum scale of plant (represented by SAC 1,) at the optimum rate of output (400units)
and will make zero profits. All firms in the industry find themselves in the same situation (if
all firms have identical cost curves) and so there is no incentive for any of them to leave the
industry or for new firms to enter it.
174
2. Explain the adjustment process through which long-run equilibrium of a firm is achieved
under perfect competition.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………………………………………
In real life, neither pure competition nor perfect competition exists.Rather there are different
varieties of imperfect competition. An imperfectly competitive firm is one that can exercise
some control over the price it receives for its product. There are two main reasons a firm
might have some control over the price it charge (1) each firm produces a sizable share of the
market and (2) each firm sells a product that is distinguishable fro competitors’ products.
These two reasons are the opposite for a perfectly competitive firm. It is sufficient for a firm
to fulfill either of these requirements to be imperfectly competitive.
MR,P
(in birr)
0 MR Quantity
Fig. 6.7
175
6.10.2 Price and Output Determination Under Monopoly
As in the case of perfect competition, it is more useful to analyze the short run equilibrium of
the pure monopolist with the marginal approach. This tells us that the short run equilibrium
level of output for the monopolist is the output at which MR= SMC and the slope of the MR
P AVC).
curve is smaller than the slope of the SMC curve (provided that at this output P
Table6.4 below indicates that the monopolist maximizes total profits (at birr 3.75) when
producing and selling 2.5 units of output at the price of birr 5.50. At this level of output, MR
= SMC (= 3 birr); MR is falling and SMC is rising (so that the negative slope of the MR curve
is smaller than the positive slope of the SMC curve). As long as MR SMC, it pays for the
monoplist to expand output and sales since doing so would add more to TR than to STC (so
profits rise). The opposite is true when MR SMC. Thus total profits are maximized where
MR = SMC.
Table 6.4
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9)
P Q TR MR STC SMC SAC profits/ Total
(in birr) (output) (in birr) (in birr) (in birr) (in birr) (in birr) unit profit
(in birr) (in birr)
8.00 0 0 --- 6 --- --- --- - 6.00
7.00 1 7.00 7 8 2 8 -1.00 -1.00
6.00 2 12.00 5 9 1 4.50 +1.50 +3.00
5.50 2.5 13.75 (3) 10 (3) 4.00 +1.50 +3.75
5.00 3 15.00 3 12 3 4.00 +1.00 +3.00
4.00 4 16.00 1 20 8 5.00 -1.00 -4.00
3.00 5 15.00 -1 35 15 7.00 -4.00 -20.00
The profit maximizing or best level of output for this monopolist can also be viewed in fig 6.8
(obtained by plotting the values of columns 1,2,4,6 and 7 of table 6.4 above).
In fig 6.8, the best, or optimum, level of output for monopolist is given by the point where the
SMC curve intersects the MR curve from below (so that at the intersection point, the slope of
the MR curve which is always negative, is smaller than the slope of the SMC curve, which is
176
usually positive). At this best output level of 2.5 units, the monopolist makes a profit of 1.50
birr per unit (the vertical distance between D and SAC at 2.5 units of output) and birr 3.75 in
total (2.5 units of output times birr 1.50 profit per unit). Note that the best level of output is
smaller than that associated with minimum SAC and smaller than the output level at which
P= SMC.
Fig 6.8
2. Describe the process of price and output determination under monopoly and compare it
with under perfect competition.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………….………
Marginal cost
Characteristics of perfect competition
P = MC as maximum profit conditions
Firm’s supply curve and its MC curve
177
P = MC = AC, break even point
Shut down point where P = MC = AVC
6.12 ANSWERS TO CKECK YOUR PROGRESS EXERCISES
2.
a. there must be a commodity
b. there must be buyer and sellers
c. there must be a place
d. there must be competition among buyers and sellers
1. Marginal revenue is the additional revenue obtained from the sale of one extra unit of
output. It is equal to price under perfect market because every good is sold at constant
price in this market.
178
6.13 MODEL EXAMINATION QUESTIONS
I. Multiple choice
1. Total profits are maximized where
a. TR equals TC
b. The TR and the TC curve are parallel
c. The TR curve and TC curve are parallel and TC exceeds TR.
d. The TR curve and the TC curve are parallel and TR exceeds TC.
2. The best, or optimum, level of output for a perfectly competitive firm is given by the
point where.
a. MR equals AC
b. MR equals MC
c. MR exeeds MC by the greatest amount
d. MR equals MC and MC is rising
3. At the best, or optimum, short run level of output, the firm will be
a. Maximizing total profits
b. Minimizing total losses
c. Either maximizing total profits or minimizing total losses
d. Maximizing profits per unit
4. The short run supply curve of the perfectly competitive firm is given by
a. The rising portion of its MC curve over and above the shut down point
b. The rising portion of its MC curve over and above the break-even point
c. The rising portion of its MC curve over and above the AC curve
d. The rising portion of its MC curve.
5. At the best, or optimum, level of output for the monopolist
a. MR = SMC
b. P = SMC
c. P = lowest SAC
d. P is highest
6. In a perfectly competitive market economy.
a. Producers are price makers, while consumers are price takers
179
b. Producers are price takers, while consumers are price makers
c. Neither producers and nor consumers are price makers
d. Neither producers nor consumers are price-takers
e. Both producers and consumers are price makers
7. The total revenue of a perfectly competitive firm depends on
a. Profit of a firm
b. The quantity of output
c. The price of its product
d. All of the above
e. None of the above
8. Which of the following statements is correct?
a. If MC is less than AC, AC will rise with a rise in use of inputs
b. If marginal product is greater than average product (AP), then AP will decrease
with increased use of an input
c. When MR us greater than MC, a profit maximizing firm would expand output
d. All of the above
e. None of the above
9. One of the following is true about MR in perfectly competitive market
a. MR is the product of price of a commodity and MP
b. MR is the ratio of change in total revenue and change in quantity of output
c. MR equals price of output
d. All of the above
e. None of the above
10. The monopoly firm faces
a. Vertical demand curve
b. Horizontal demand curve
c. Diagonal demand curve that goes through the origin
d. Upward slopping demand curve
e. Down ward slopping demand curve.
180
6.14 REFERENCES
181