Our Feature: Unlimited access of video recording | Paper solution |

conceptual clarity | Model Test

LEVEL UP COACHING NIKUNJ TAILOR

Ancient Indian Audit and modern Audit

Definition of Ancient Audit

Ancient audit may be defined as:
“The systematic checking, verification, and examination of revenue, expenditure, and resources of
the State by appointed officials in order to ensure accountability, prevent fraud, and maintain
financial discipline in accordance with the principles of Dharma (righteousness).”

Importance of ancient Indian audit

The importance of ancient Indian audit lies in how it shaped accountability, governance, and
financial discipline in early civilizations. In ancient India, audit was not just a financial practice—it
was also a moral and administrative tool. Here are the key points:

1. Ensured Accountability in Administration

 Ancient texts like the Arthashastra (by Kautilya/Chanakya) emphasized checking public
officials’ accounts.
 Kings employed auditors (Akshapataladhyaksha, Samaharta) to prevent misuse of revenue.
 Officials had to present clear records of income and expenditure, ensuring responsibility in
governance.

2. Prevented Corruption and Fraud

 Systematic verification of state finances reduced chances of embezzlement.

 The Arthashastra mentions different types of frauds and how auditors should detect them.

Download : Level up coaching App from play store

Our Feature: Unlimited access of video recording | Paper solution |
conceptual clarity | Model Test

LEVEL UP COACHING NIKUNJ TAILOR

 Severe punishments were prescribed for misappropriation, highlighting the seriousness of

audits.

3. Strengthened Economic Management

 India’s economy in ancient times relied on agriculture, trade, and taxation.

 Audit ensured proper collection of taxes, tolls, and tributes, helping maintain economic
stability.
 Accurate financial records allowed kings to plan expenditures on public works, military, and
welfare.

4. Promoted Transparency and Good Governance

 Auditing created a culture of fairness and openness in administration.

 By cross-verifying accounts, rulers gained public trust and legitimacy.
 It aligned financial management with the principle of Dharma (righteousness).

5. Moral and Ethical Dimension

 Audit was seen not only as a financial check but as a duty to society and the king.
 Dishonesty in accounts was considered both a legal and moral failure.
 This ethical dimension of audit distinguished ancient Indian practices from purely technical
record-keeping.

6. Foundation for Modern Audit

 Many principles of auditing today—verification, detection of fraud, accountability, and

transparency—can be traced back to ancient Indian practices.
 The idea that “public money must be safeguarded” has continued into present-day
government and corporate auditing.

Ancient Indian audit was important because it ensured financial discipline, prevented corruption,
strengthened governance, and upheld ethical values. It laid the foundation for modern auditing
systems by linking financial accountability with moral responsibility.

Download : Level up coaching App from play store

Our Feature: Unlimited access of video recording | Paper solution |
conceptual clarity | Model Test

LEVEL UP COACHING NIKUNJ TAILOR

Objects of Ancient Indian Audit

The object (objective/purpose) of ancient Indian audit was broader than just financial checking — it
served administrative, ethical, and economic goals. Based on texts like the Arthashastra and other
historical records, the main objects were

1. Accountability of Officials
o To ensure that all government officers (Amatyas, treasurers, collectors, etc.) were
responsible for the funds and resources entrusted to them.
o Prevented misuse of state resources.
2. Detection and Prevention of Fraud
o To identify embezzlement, false reporting, or concealment of revenue.
o Kautilya listed various methods of fraud, showing that the main object of audit was
to expose such malpractices.
3. Verification of Revenue and Expenditure
o To check accuracy in the collection of taxes, customs, tributes, and fines.
o To ensure proper utilization of public funds on administration, defense, and welfare.
4. Good Governance and Public Trust
o To uphold fairness and transparency in the king’s administration.
o Strengthened the trust of citizens in the ruler and the state.
5. Moral and Ethical Supervision
o Audit was not just financial control but also a duty of Dharma (righteousness).
o The object was to align administration with justice and ethical governance.
6. Efficient Economic Management
o To make sure resources were optimally used.
o Helped rulers plan future expenditures, store reserves, and maintain stability of the
kingdom.

The object of ancient Indian audit was to secure accountability, detect fraud, verify
revenue/expenditure, ensure transparency in governance, uphold moral duty, and maintain
economic stability.

Download : Level up coaching App from play store

Our Feature: Unlimited access of video recording | Paper solution |
conceptual clarity | Model Test

LEVEL UP COACHING NIKUNJ TAILOR

Difference between ancient audit and modern audit

Feature Ancient Indian Audit Modern Indian Audit

(as per Arthashastra)
Primary Prevention and detection of fraud To express an opinion on the true and
Objective and embezzlement of state funds. fair view of financial statements and the
adequacy of internal controls.
Scope Primarily focused on government Covers all forms of entities -
treasury and state-owned government, public, and private
enterprises. companies, non-profits, etc.
Methodology Detailed and exhaustive checking of Risk-based approach, using sampling,
all transactions. analytical procedures, and technological
tools.
Focus Proprietary and control-oriented – Attestation and assurance-oriented –
ensuring proper use of resources. providing credibility to financial
information.
Reporting Direct reporting to the king on the Reporting to shareholders, the board of
fidelity of financial administration. directors, and regulatory authorities
through a formal audit report.
Regulatory Based on royal decrees and Governed by the Companies Act,
Framework administrative procedures outlined Standards on Auditing (SAs) issued by
in texts like the Arthashastra. ICAI, and other specific statutes.
Technology Manual record-keeping and Extensive use of computers, data
verification. analytics software, and other advanced
technologies.
Auditor's Role A direct agent of the king, ensuring An independent professional,
the loyalty and honesty of officials. accountable to the shareholders and the
public.
Beyond Limited to financial and compliance Expanded to include performance audit,
Financials aspects. efficiency audit (value for money),
environmental audit, and IT audit.

Download : Level up coaching App from play store