Plastic Analysis
Plastic Analysis
Plastic Theory
CHAPTER HIGHLIGHTS
Introduction NOTES
Plastic method of design, also known as ‘limit design’ or 1. In the above stress–strain curve, P is the proportion-
‘collapse method of design’, or ‘ultimate design’, is based on ality limit, Y1 is the upper yield point, Y2 is the lower
ultimate load rather than working load. This is just because yield point and U is the ultimate load point.
of the ductile nature of steel and, thus providing the large 2. The different zones in the stress–strain curve are e lastic
reserve strength beyond its yield point. This helps in reduc- zone (from O to point P: stress–strain r elationship is
ing the size of sections than those designed by working stress linear), yield zone (from point Y1 to Y2), plastic zone
method. Hence, the present chapter outlines the concept of (from point Y2 to C), strain hardening zone (from
plastic analysis and design of structural steel. point C to U) and Strain softening zone or necking
zone (from point U to B).
Stress–Strain Relation of Mild Steel But in plastic theory of structures, a simplified or idealized
stress–strain curves are used.
A simple stress–strain curve for mild steel is shown below:
True curve 250 250
Fail MPa
Apparent MPa
400
curve
U
Stress (MPa)
300 Y1
Stress
Stress
Fail
P B
Y2 C
200
0.12% 1% 2% 1% 2%
100 Strain Strain
(a) Elastic-Plastic (b) Rigid-Plastic
0 Idealized stress–strain relation for mild steel
0.12
10.0
20.0
30.0
2.0
CG Centroid
Plastic moment of a beam section
axis
•• At equilibrium condition:
Force in compression = Force in tension
σ <σy σ =σy σ =σy σ =σy
i.e., C = T
M < My M = My My < M < Mp M = Mp fyA1 = fyA2
Beam section Elastic Yield Elastic- Fully
under stage point plastic plastic A
bending (ii) (iii) stage stage =
A1 A=
2
(i) (iv) (v) 2
Plastic bending of beam
•• Therefore, areas above and below the neutral axis are
Assumptions equal and, hence, the neutral axis of plasticized section is
The assumptions made in plastic analysis of beams are as called ‘equal area axis’.
follows: A
•• Zp is given by, Z p = ( y1 + y2 )
1. Plane sections normal to the axis of beam remain 2
plane after bending.
Where
2. The material obeys the ideal stress–strain relationship. A = Area of cross-section of sections
The increase in strength due to strain hardening is
y1 , y2 = Distance of centre of gravity of area above
neglected.
and below the neutral axis.
3. Beam is not subjected to axial load and shear strains
are also neglected.
Hinge Length
Plastic Moment •• The value of moment at sections adjacent to the yield
•• The moment at which a plastic hinge is formed called zone of a certain length is known as hinge length.
‘plastic moment’ is denoted by Mp. •• It depends upon loading and geometry of section.
•• Consider a simply supported rectangular beam with a •• This process of formation of plastic hinges will continue
central concentrated load ‘W’ as shown below. till the ultimate load is reached.
W •• Therefore, the flexural members can sustain the ultimate
Area of yielding
loads only due to redistribution of moments.
•• Redistribution of moments is the main contributing factor
in reserving strength.
Shape Factor
•• It may be defined as the ratio of the plastic moment and
the yield moment of the section.
x •• Denoted by S.
Mp fyZp Zp
=
S = =
Mp WL My f y Ze Ze
My My 4
NOTE 1.2
Redistribution of Moments h
•• Plastic hinges are formed first at the highly stressed
2.34
sections. The sections rotate without absorbing any more
moment.
•• The less stressed sections will be in equilibrium. b
Successive formation plastic hinges occurs at these sec-
(c) Triangle
tions by proportionate increase in moment.
(Continued)
(Continued) Where
Shape Shape Factor fy = Yield stress
f = Permissible stress
S = Shape factor
fy
d = Factor of safety as in elastic design
1.7 f
•• Therefore, the load factor may also be defined as the
product of factor of safety and shape factor.
(d) Circular rod •• It depends upon the nature of loading, the support condi-
tions and the geometrical shape of structural members.
Load Factor (F) (IS: 800–1984)
d
t Dead load 1.7
4
p Dead load + imposed load 1.7
Dead load + wind/seismic load 1.7
(e) Tubular Dead load + imposed load + wind/seismic load 1.3
Mechanism
•• The conditions of mechanism occur when sufficient num-
1.14
ber of plastic hinges is formed and segments of the beam
between the plastic hinges are able to move without an
increase of load.
Wide flange
(Storng axis)
•• Number of plastic hinges required for mechanism are, N
= Ds + 1.
Ds = Degree of static Indeterminacy.
Types of Mechanisms
•• Various possible Independent mechanisms are as follows:
(a) Beam mechanism: All the loaded spans behave as
1.50 beam mechanism.
(b) Sway mechanism: It is a result of the lateral loads.
(c) Joint mechanism: It is due to action of moment and
Wide flange
the number of members meeting at a joint should be
(Weak axis) three or more.
(d) Gable mechanism: It occurs in gable frames.
•• Any of these two independent mechanisms may be com-
Load Factor bined to form composite (combined) mechanism.
•• It is a factor of safety based upon collapse load.
•• It may be defined as the ratio of the collapse load to the
working load.
Number of Independent Mechanisms
•• The prime function of load factor is to ensure the safety Number of Independent mechanisms, n = N - r
of structure under service conditions. Where
Collapse load (Wu ) N = Number of possible plastic hinges.
•• Denoted by F: F = r = Number of redundancies.
Working load (Ww )
L L
2 2
L L
2 2
Mp
Mp
WuL
WuL W uL
Mp 4
4 8
. .
BMD at collapse
BMD at collapse
θ θ
θ θ Δ
Δ
θ
θ +θ θ
(Continued)
(Continued)
Concentrated Load at Centre
Static Method Static Method
Wu L Wu L
= Mp = 2M p
4 4
4M p 8M p
Wu = Wu =
L L
Kinematic Method Kinematic Method
External work done = Internal work done External work done = Internal work done
L L
Wu θ = M p(θ + θ ) Wu q = Mpq + Mp(q + q) + Mp . q
2 2
4M p 8M p
Wu = Wu =
L L
Eccentric Load
Simply Supported Beam Fixed Beam
W W
a b
a b
Mp
Mp
Wuab2 Wua2b
Wuab
L2 L2
Mp L
BMD at collapse
BMD at collapse
θ θ1
θ θ1
θ1
θ1
θ
θ
Beam mechanism
Beam mechanism
Wu ab Wu ab
= Mp = 2M p
L L
M pL 2M p L
Wu = Wu =
ab ab
a
= Mp(q + q) a a
b Wuaq = Mpq + Mp(q + q) + Mp( q)
b b
L
Wu = M p L
ab Wu = 2 M p
ab
(Continued)
(Continued)
Uniformly Load Distributed
Simply Supported Beam Fixed Beam
W W
w= w=
L L
L
L
Mp
WuL
Mp Mp WuL
8 WuL
8
12
BMD at collapse BMD at collapse
θ θ θ θ
Δ Δ
θ +θ θ +θ
Beam mechanism
Beam mechanism
Static Method Static Method
Wu L Wu L
= Mp = 2M p
8 8
8M p 16M p
Wu = Wu =
L L
Exercises
1. The number of independent mechanisms the gable The length Lp of the plastic zone, when the maximum
frame will have when loaded as shown is bending moment, equals the plastic moment Mp, given
P P by
c
P
P/2 b d
LP
a e
L
(A) 2 (B) 3
Lp 1 Lp
(C) 4 (D) 5 (A) = (B) = L(1 - f )
2. Equilibrium condition, yield conditions (M ≤ Mp) and L f L
mechanism condition (formation of a plastic collapse
Lp 1 Lp 1
mechanism) are the conditions to be satisfied by any (C) = 1− (D) = 1−
correct plastic analysis results. Which of the above L f L f
conditions does the statical method of plastic analysis
7. A steel beam (with a constant EI, and span L) is fixed
consider?
at both ends and carries a uniformly distributed load
(A) Equilibrium condition alone
(w kN-m), which is gradually increased till the beam
(B) Equilibrium and mechanism conditions
reaches the stage of plastic collapse (refer to the fol-
(C) Yield and mechanism conditions
lowing figure). Assuming ‘B’ to be at mid-span, which
(D) Equilibrium and yield conditions
of the following is true.
3. For a fixed beam with span L, having plastic moment
capacity of Mp, the ultimate central concentrated load w kN/m
will be
4M p Mp
(A) (B)
L 8L A B C
6M p 8M p
(C) (D) L/2 L/2
L L
4. The plastic modulus of a section is 4.8 × 10–4 m3. The (A) Hinges are formed at A, B and C together.
shape factor is 1.2. The plastic moment capacity of the
(B) Hinges are formed at B and then at A and C
section is 120 kN-m. The yield stress of the material is
together.
(A) 100 MPa (B) 240 MPa
(C) 250 MPa (D) 300 MPa (C) Hinges are formed at A and C together and then
at B.
5. The shape factor of the section shown in the figure is (D) Hinges are formed at A and C only.
100 mm
h 20 mm
100 mm
b
bhσ y 2bhσ y 20 mm
(A) (B)
4 9
(A) 15 mm
bhσ y bhσ y (B) 60 mm
(C) (D) (C) 20 mm
2 3
(D) 40 mm
10. At the location of plastic hinge
16. The number of possible independent mechanisms for a
(A) radius of curvature is infinite. portal frame shown in the figure is
(B) curvature is infinite.
(C) moment is infinite. 2P
(D) flexural stress is infinite.
2P
11. Which one of the following is the load factor?
Live load Failure load
(A) (B)
Dead load Working load
List I List II 12 8
(A) Mp (B) Mp
a. Simply supported beam with a central L L
8M p
point load. 1.
L 6 3
(C) Mp (D) Mp
b. Fixed beam with a central point load
L L
6M p 22. Given figure shows a portal frame with load. All mem-
2.
L bers have the same plastic moment of resistance Mp.
c. Propped cantilever with a central The ratio P1 to P2 for beam and sway mechanism is
4M p _______.
point load 3.
L P1
Codes:
a b c a b c P2
(A) 3 1 2 (B) 3 2 1
(C) 2 1 3 (D) 1 2 3
W2
MP
L/2 L/2
MP MP L
(A) 1 (B) 2
(C) 3 (D) 4
23. A portal frame has a collapse mechanism as shown
L/2 L/2 below. What is the type?
3. In the theory of plastic bending of beams, the ratio of 7. For formation of collapse mechanism in the follow-
plastic moment to yield moment is called ing figure, the minimum value of Pu is cMp/L. Mp
[GATE, 2009] and 3Mp denote the plastic moment capacities of
(A) shape factor beam sections as shown in this figure. The value of c
(B) plastic section modulus is ______. [GATE, 2015]
(C) modulus of resilience
Pu
(D) rigidity modulus
4. As per IS:800–2007 the cross-section in which 1m 1m
extreme fiber can reach the yield stress but cannot
develop the plastic moment of resistance due to local MP
3 MP
buckling is classified as [GATE, 2013]
2m
(A) plastic section
(B) compact section
(C) semi-compact section 8. The semi-compact section of a laterally unsupported
(D) shear section steel beam has an elastic section modulus, plastic sec-
5. Match the information given in List I with those in tion modulus and design bending compressive stress
List II. [GATE, 2014] of 500 cm3, 650 cm3 and 200 MPa, respectively. The
design flexural capacity (expressed in kN-m) of the
List I List II
section is ______. [GATE, 2016]
P. Factor to decrease ultimate 1. Upper bound on
strength to design strength ultimate load 9. A rigid member ACB is shown in the figure. The
Q. Factor to increase working 2. Lower bound on member is supported at A and B by pinned and guided
load to ultimate load for ultimate load roller supports, respectively. A force P acts at C as
design shown. Let RAh and RBh be the horizontal reactions at
R. Statical method of ultimate 3. Material partial supports A and B, respectively, and RAv be the vertical
load analysis safety factor reaction at support A. Self-weight of the member may
S. Kinematical mechanism 4. Load factor be ignored. [GATE, 2016]
method of ultimate load
analysis
B
P
(A) P - 1; Q - 2; R - 3; S - 4 2m
(B) P - 2; Q - 1; R - 4; S - 3 C
(C) P - 3; Q - 4; R - 2; S - 1
(D) P - 4; Q - 3; R - 2; S - 1
6m
6. The ultimate collapse load (P) in terms of plastic
moment Mp by kinematic approach for a propped
cantilever of length L with P acting at its mid-span as
shown in the figure, would be [GATE, 2014] A
P
1.5 m 1.5 m
X Y
L L Which one of the following sets gives the correct
2 2 magnitudes of RAv, RBh and RAh?
2M p 1 2
(A) R=
Av = 0; RBh =P ; and RAh P
(A) P = 3 3
L
4M p 2 1
=
(B) R Av = 0; RBh = P; and RAh P
(B) P = 3 3
L
6M p 3 1.5
(C) R=
Av = P; RBh =P; and RAh P
(C) P = 8 8
L
8M p RAv = P; RBh 1=
(D) = .5
P; and RAh
1.5
P
(D) P = 8 8
L
Answer Keys
Exercises
1. C 2. D 3. D 4. C 5. C 6. D 7. C 8. B 9. A 10. B
11. B 12. A 13. D 14. B 15. C 16. D 17. C 18. D 19. A 20. C
21. C 22. B 23. D