Module 2
Module 2
MODULE - 02
Meaning of Organization
Every thinker is of the opinion that an organization is a process. They further have added
that this process leads identification of work to be performed which for convenience sake should
be objectively grouped and defined. Then the work should be assigned to individuals according
to their aptitude, technical knowledge, skill and efficiency. For satisfactory working the
individuals should be given some right and authority. A mutual relationship between jobs (what
to be done) duties (to be performed) and authority (to be exercised) should be established.
Organization is just like a tool in the hands of management. Net results will be perfect if the tool
is well designed and handed properly.
Meaning of Staffing:
Staffing is the traditional management function of attraction and selection of the best
people and putting them on job where their talents and skills can be best utilized, and retention
of these people through incentives, job training and job enrichment programmers, in order to
achieve both individual and organizational objectives. This emphasizes managing human and
not material or financial resources.
Page 1
Stee Studies
CHARACTERISTICS OF ORGANISATION
Robbins defines Organization as ' a consciously coordinated social unit, composed of two
or more people, that functions as a relatively continuous basis to achieve common goals of set
of goals.
Agrawal defines organization as ' a goal oriented open system composed of people, structure
and technology.
It is an open system.
It is a goal oriented.
It is a collection of people.
It has continuity.
Page 2
Stee Studies
Organization is a collection of people: People are the main performers in any organization. In
other world, all the elements of any organization are the same except the cpeople. Even with the
same age, qualification, experience and facilities, the output of the people may vary, simply
because the needs and wants of all people are not the same. What makes them work by heart and
head is the one that differentiate organizations from one to others.
Organization consists of technology: Technology is the means of doing works. There are various
kinds of doing works. As an organization consists of more people, its performance procedure
should be of a fixed type so that each individual in the organization can exercise them well. This is
how technology initiates. Technology eases the work and shortens the time. Technology originates
a certain policy necessary to keep organizational beliefs in doings of the various people at different
structural level.
Organization has continuity: As the organization involves people, and the people generate
different needs, they can leave the organization or some may die too. This does not affect the
organization to stop or decrease in size. Hence, it is said that every organization has its own
continuity. A good manager can leave but other better man can take over the charge of the
organization.
Organizing, like planning, must be a carefully worked out and applied process. This process
involves determining what work is needed to accomplish the goal, assigning those tasks to
individuals, and arranging those individuals in a decision‐making framework (organizational
structure). The end result of the organizing process is an organization a whole consisting of unified
parts acting in harmony to execute tasks to achieve goals, both effectively and efficiently.
A properly implemented organizing process should result in a work environment where all
team members are aware of their responsibilities. If the organizing process is not conducted well,
the results may yield confusion, frustration, loss of efficiency, and limited effectiveness
Page 3
Stee Studies
the middle level, executive management fix the departmental objectives. Lastly, at the lower level,
supervisory management fix the day-to-day objectives. All the objectives of the organisation must
be specific and realistic
Page 4
Stee Studies
define the authority relationship between them. Each person should know who is his superior, from
who he should take orders, and to whom he will be answerable. Similarly, each superior should
know what authority he has over his subordinates.
PRINCIPLES OF ORGANIZATION
The success of a business organization can be ensured if the following basic principles are
used. In order to develop a sound and efficient organization structure, there is need to follow certain
principles. In the words of E.F.L. Brech, "If there is to be a systematic approach to the formulation
of organization structure, there ought to be a body of accepted principles". They are as follows:
(1) Objectives: The objectives of the enterprise influence the organization structure and hence the
objectives of the enterprise should first be clearly defined. Then every part of the organization
should be geared to the achievement of these objectives.
(2) Specialization: Effective organization must promote specialization. The activities of the
enterprise should be divided according to functions and assigned to persons according to their
specialization.
(3) Span of Control: As there is a limit to the number of persons that can be supervised effectively
by one boss, the span of control should be minimum as far as possible, the minimum, that
means an executive should be asked to supervise a reasonable number of subordinates only,
say six.
Page 5
Stee Studies
(4) Exception: As the executives at the higher level have limited time, only exceptionally complex
problems should be referred to them and routine matters should be dealt with by the lower levels.
This will enable the executives at higher level to devote time to more important and crucial issues.
(5) Scalar principle : This principle is sometimes known as the "chain of command". The line of authority
from the chief executive at the top to the front - line supervisor at the bottom, must be clearly
defined.
(6) Unity of Command: Each subordinate should have only one supervisor whose command he has to
obey. Dual subordination must be avoided, for it causes uneasiness, disorder, indiscipline and
undermining of authority.
(7) Delegation: Proper authority should be delegated at the lower level of organization also to carry out
the work effectively.
(8) Responsibility: The superior should be responsible for the acts of his subordinates.
(9) Authority: Authority is a tool by which a manager accomplishes the desired objectives, which
should be clearly defined.
(10) Efficiency: The organization structure should help enterprise to function efficiently to
accomplish the objectives at lowest cost.
(11) Simplicity: The organization structure should be simple and the levels should be as minimum
as possible.
(13) Balance: There should be a reasonable balance in the size of various departments, between
centralization and decentralization, between the principle of span of control and short chain of
command and among all types of factors such as human, technical and financial.
(14) Unity of direction: Should be one objective and one plan for a group of activities having same
objectives. Unity of direction facilities unification and coordination of activities at various levels.
(15) Personal Ability: As people constitute an organization, there is need for proper selection,
placement and training of staff. Organisation structure must ensure optimum use of human
resources and encourage management development programmer.
Page 6
Stee Studies
SPAN OF MANAGEMENT
The Span of Management refers to the number of subordinates who can be managed
efficiently by a superior. Simply, the manager having the group of subordinates who report him
directly is called as the span of management.
In the past it was not uncommon to see average spans of one to four (one manager
supervising four employees). With the development of inexpensive information technology in the
1980s, corporate leaders flattened many organizational structures and caused average spans to
move closer to one to ten. As this technology developed further and eased many middle-
managerial tasks (such as collecting, manipulating, and presenting operational information), upper
management found they could save money by hiring fewer middle managers. Research Studies of
management have found that this number (span) is usually 4-8 subordinates at the upper levels of
organization and 8-15 or more at the lower levels. However this is not definite.
DEPARTMENTALISATION
7
Stee Studies
departments may work together. Here are the primary objectives of businesses that choose to
implement departmentalization:
Maintaining control
Simplifying operational processes
Grouping specialized activities together
Increasing overall efficiency
Ensuring responsibility and accountability
This is more suitable for a large organization that manufactures a vast variety of products.
Under this separate groups or departments are created and each department is controlled by a
manager who will be responsible for all the activities of that sub group. Each subgroup will have its
own facilities required for manufacture, purchase, marketing and accounting etc. This type is
advantageous where variety of products are manufactured for example (i) Godrej, that
manufactures soaps, cosmetics, refrigerators, machines, furniture etc., (ii) HMT that manufactures
machines, watches, tractors, bearings etc. (iii) TATAs that make trucks, cars, steel, machines etc.
Advantages
Performance of different product groups can be easily compared enabling the top
management to invest more and more in profitable product groups and exercise
better control on non-performers.
Managers of individual products put better effort to improve his area compared to
others.
Disadvantages
8
Stee Studies
The depart mentation is based on each major function of the organization. Depending on the
nature of organization the various functions are as follows: Marketing, Engineering, Production,
Finance, Personnel, and Purchase etc. Functional depart mentation is most widely employed basis of
organizing activities - and is present in almost every organization at some level in its structure.
Advantages
Simplifies training.
Provides means of right control at top.
Disadvantages
9
Stee Studies
Advantages
Service can be rendered, that goes beyond the normal 8 hours shift/day.
Facilitates use of processes that cannot be stopped or interrupted.
Expensive capital equipment can be better utilized.
Provides part time jobs for people who are otherwise busy during day time (students
going for part time job etc.)
Loss of product or service may increase owing to higher payment/ over time payment
during night shift.
10
Stee Studies
Advantages
This was one of the most widely used ancient methods of departmentalization. This is
achieved by tolling of persons performing the same job and grouping them together under one
supervisor. This is not in common use now.
NEED OF DEPARTMENTATION
The need for departmentation arises due to various reasons that contribute to an
organization’s overall success and efficiency. Some of the key reasons include:
11
Stee Studies
> Control: Departmentation simplifies the process of monitoring and controlling the activities
of various departments. By setting departmental goals and performance standards, managers
can evaluate each department’s progress and implement corrective actions when necessary.
> Growth and Expansion: As organizations grow, the need for departmentation becomes
increasingly critical. A well-structured departmental framework allows organizations to
expand their operations and handle increased workloads more efficiently.
COMMITTEES
Committee can be defined as a group of organizational members who discuss and develop
solutions to problems. It can be either line or staff and can be established on a standing (permanent)
or an ad hoc basis. In business enterprises, the board of directors constitutes the committee at the
highest level. The purpose of such committees is to discuss various problems and recommend
solutions to the management. It is generally found to co-exist with line and staff type of
organization. The Board of Directors of a company is an example of a committee organization. This
12
Stee Studies
form of organization is suitable for taking decisions on policy matters or laying down broad
objective for the enterprise.
TYPES OF COMMITTEES
Ad-Hoc committee – what is an ad-hoc committee? The word ad-hoc is derived from the
Latin language, which means ‘for a specific purpose’. An ad hoc committee is therefore a
committee that is set up for the main purpose of performing a specific task or dealing with a
specific situation. Having completed the specific task and submitted its report, the ad hoc
committee is then dissolved. Majority of committees in business organizations and other places
are ad hoc types.
Executive committee – as the name suggests, this type of committee is made up of people
occupying top positions in an organization that have the powers to administer the day to day
affairs of the organization. Executive committees are mainly made up of senior management
personnel, and just like any other committee in a business organization, the executive committee
is given the mandate to perform special assignments or tasks.
13
Stee Studies
Advantages:
1. Pooling of Opinions:
The members of committees come from different background and areas of expertise and have
different viewpoints and values. When persons with varied abilities sit together and discuss a
problem, various aspects of the case are highlighted and pros and cons are assessed. The pooled
opinion will help in taking a realistic view of the problem.
2. Better Co-Ordination:
Committee form of organization brings more co-ordination among different segments of the
organization when representatives of different departments sit together, they understand and
appreciate the difficulties faced by others. This type of frank discussions help on fixing the targets
of different departments and better co-ordination is achieved through this type of decision making.
3. Balancing of Views:
This type of organization helps in balancing the views expressed by different persons. There
is a tendency to over emphasize the aspects of one’s own department by ignoring the inter
dependent character of problems of different departments. A committee helps to bring out an
agreed view of the problem by taking into account divergent views expressed in such meetings.
4. Motivation:
The committees consist of managers as well as subordinates. The views of subordinates are
given recognition and importance. It gives them encouragement and makes them feel as an
integral part of decision making process. Such committees boost the morale of subordinates and
motivate them to improve their performance.
5. Dispersion of Power:
14
Stee Studies
The concentration of power in few persons may lead to misuse of authority and wrong
decisions. By spreading powers among committee members this problem can be solved.
7. Better Communication:
It is a better forum for discussing matters of mutual interest and reaching certain
conclusions. These decisions can be properly communicated to subordinates through committee
members. The members will transmit correct and authentic information and also convey the
background of taking those decisions.
8. Executive Training:
Committees provide a good forum for training executives. They learn the value of interaction,
group dynamics and human relations. They are exposed to various view points and learn the art of
reaching decisions and solving organizational problems.
1. Delay:
The main drawback of committee form of organization is delay in taking decisions. A
number of persons express their viewpoints in meetings and a lot of time is taken on reaching a
decision. The fixing of committee meetings is also time consuming. An agenda is issued and a
convenience date is fixed for the meeting. The decision making process is very slow and many
business opportunities may be lost due to delayed decisions.
15
Stee Studies
2. Compromise:
Generally, efforts are made to reach consensus decisions. The view point of the majority is
taken as a unanimous decision of the committee. The thinking of the minority may be valid but
it may not be pursued for singled out. They may accept less than an optimal solution, because of
a fear that if their solution proves wrong then they will be blamed for it.
3. No Accountability:
No individual accountability to be fixed if these decisions are bad. Every member of the
committee tries to defend himself by saying that he solves a different solution. If
accountability is not fixed then it is the weakness of the organization.
5. Strained Relations:
Sometimes relations among committee members or with others become strained. If some
members take divergent stands on certain issues, some may feel offended. In case some issue
concerning other persons is discussed in a committee and members taking stand not liked by
those persons may offend them. The discussions in the meetings are generally leaked to other
employees. Some unpleasant decisions may not be liked by those who are adversely affected. It
affects relations of employees not only on the job but at personal level also.
6. Lack of Effectiveness:
The role of committees is not effective in all areas. The committees may be useful where
grievance redressal or inter personal departmental matters are concerned. Committees may not be
effective where policies are to be framed and quick decisions are required. Individual initiative
16
Stee Studies
will be more effective in these cases. So committees have a limited role to play.
In order to make the working of committees effective, the members should follow these
guidelines:
1. The members should ensure that the atmosphere at the meetings is cordial and informal.
2. The members should express their views clearly and logically and listen to the
reactions calmly.
3. Disagreement should not be ignored. They should not compromise just for the sake of
harmony. Criticism should be directed on the issues and not on persons.
4. It should be ensured that chairman does not excessively dominate. His views should also be
treated in same way as that of others. His views should not be taken as final.
5. The disagreement in meeting should not be taken in personal level. The spirit of competition
should be avoided and co-operation should be enhanced.
All these guidelines will not only smoothen the working committees but will also make them an
effective instrument of the organization.
STAFFING
Staffing is defined as "filling and keeping filled, positions in the organization structure". It is also
known as "human resource management". This includes identifying the requirement of work-force,
taking inventory of people available, recruiting, selecting, placing, promoting, appraising, planning
the employee's careers, training them to suit the job, developing the staff to carry out the defined job
effectively and efficiently.
A business cannot be successfully run without the right kind of people. It is very important to fill
the jobs with suitable people who will carry out the job effectively. The staffing is very important
because of following reasons.
17
Stee Studies
(i) It helps in discovering talented and competent workers and developing them to move the
organization ladder.
(ii) Staffing is important to put the right person at right job which results in increased
production.
(iii) It avoids sudden disruption of the production due to shortage of workers, since it plans
and fills the positions.
(iv) It maintains harmony and creates healthy atmosphere in any organization by planning the
promotions, training needs and additional skills required.
(v) It plans the requirement of man power at various time and levels of a project and cater to
it.
Elements of staffing:
While carrying out the staffing function, the management should ensure that right people are
engaged for a job. The jobs cannot be changed to suit the people. The main elements involved in
staffing are:
(iv) Providing necessary training for the people to carry out the job.
Functions of staffing:
Staffing plays a vital role in organization. It has key roles to play for the well being of any
organization. The following are some of the functions of staffing.
The first function of staffing is to plan the requirement of man power in various levels of
18
Stee Studies
organization to achieve the objectives of the organization. Man power planning involves short term and
long term. Short term is the immediate requirement of man power to reach the targets where as long
termplanning involves the requirement of people for future proposed projects.
(ii) Development:
Development means preparing the people of an organization to develop required skills to perform
their tasks. This involves training of people.
The staffing defines and fixes the responsibilities of people. The specification and qualifications
of people to be put on a particular job are prepared.
The staffing identifies and specifies sources of selection like internal or external sources. A
position may be filled by people from internal source available with in the organization either by
transfer or promotion. External sources may be considered for filling a position from outside
organizations.
(v) Selection:
After having identified the sources of selection, next function is selection process. People are
selected as per specifications and qualifications set earlier and recruited. The selected people are
placed on the job.
(vi) Training:
If required, the selected people are given necessary training to carry out the specific job.
In addition to the above functions, the staffing also involves in promotion, transfer, punishment,
19
Stee Studies
SELECTION PROCESS
Selection of personnel for the organization is one of the most important managerial
responsibilities. According to the requisition, a primary selection is done for the suitable candidates,
to be called for the interview. The final selection is done by the executives in the case of higher
posts and for lower posts recruitment, the per- sonnel officer is present in all selections and keeps
an eye on the recruitment activities with an aim:
To find out whether the candidate can be suitable employee. For this, the candidate should be
clearly told about the nature of the job, terms and conditions.
To know the suitability for the particular jobs, he can be cross questioned and thus the suitability
can be judged.
If the selection of the worker, admitted to the firm is not working skillfully then the result will be,
either there will be a poor level of work or there will be a high rate of labour turnover. Both will be
harmful to the firm in the long run. Therefore every effort should be made to make proper selection.
Techniques of selection
Application Banks
Preliminary or Initial Interview
Interview
Group discussion
Employment tests.
It is invariably used as one of the selection tools and can be helpful at the interview stage. It
provides actual information needed for evaluating the candidate's suitably. It is also used as a basic
record of his personnel data is about educational qualifications, training, experience etc.
20
Stee Studies
Many large companies use such application forms which determine, whether the candidate
possesses the basic minimum requirement about the Qualifications, Knowledge and Skills or not.
(iii) Interview
It is one of the least reliable and valid selection techniques. It relies upon a considerable extent
in accepting or rejecting a candidate. The interview is left with the inevitable personality variables
and for this he has nothing to depend upon except his subjective judgment.
> In structural pattern or directive pattern: In structural pattern of Interviewing, a list of questions
based on job specification is prepared in advance. The interview may be occasionally separated from
the prepared list of questions and put other questions. The candidate is supposed only to answer the
21
Stee Studies
questions and the interviewer can learn a lot about the candidate's ability and knowledge, but this
technique imposes serious limitation in drawing out his personality. It is not very effective.
> Unstructured or non-directive or unpatented: It is one of the most effective interviewing technique.
The interviewer, instead of asking too many questions initiates the candidate to create a kind of
permissive atmosphere in which the candidates talks usually quite revealingly about his
experiences, aspirations, fear, weakness etc. This kind of interview requires a high degree of
interviewing skill and it can therefore be conducted by only trained interviewers In some large
organizations, the candidate has to go through a review of two or three panel interviewers. After
each panel interviewer some candidates are eliminated and only those candidates, who succeed in
the first interview are sent on to the second interviewing panel and so on.
In this technique candidates are brought together in group of 6 or 8 persons for informal
discussion and the selectors observe them and evaluate them. There are two kinds of group
discussions, one where a problem is given to a group to discuss and the individual member is free to
choose his own approach. In the second type, each individual is given an initial position and
supplied with supporting information to defend his own position.
Most of the large companies use one or other kind of employment tests. Before a company use
employment test it should take following points into ac- count.
Since the tests are aimed at predicting future success in a job situation, they should be selected or
designated on the basis of a sound job analysis programmer.
In deciding upon the test to be used as a selection tool, its specialty should be taken into
considerations.
Tests should be valid. Before a test is selected for use as an employment, its validity should be
determined in relation to the specific job.
22
Stee Studies
They are not fool proof and therefore instead of using single test, often a batch of tests is
used. A variety of tests are used as selection tools. The object of these scientific methods of
selection is to ensure that a person selected possesses those physical and mental qualities in
required degrees which are essential if he is to become an efficient and successful worker.
> Intelligence Test: It is a measure of an individual's capacity of reasoning and verbal comprehension.
It is used in the selection and classification of workers for almost every kind of job from the
unskilled to the highly skilled, administrative and professional jobs.
> Vocations Aptitude Test: Physical strength and general intelligence are not enough to enable a
person to perform a task efficiently. Besides, he must possess the ability for the performance of that
job. In fact from the point of view of future achievements, a person of high natural ability is likely
to prove more successful than one who through training and experience has gained more knowledge
but possesses less natural ability. If this is correct, then it makes it necessary to find out whether the
applicant possesses the necessary vocational aptitude or not.
> Analytical Test: In this method, a job is analyzed in terms of key qualities or abilities as speed and
quality of observations, ability to keep one's head and not get confused when a quick decision is
called for. A test or a combination of tests is then taken which measure the degree to which these
abilities are present or lacking in the candidate.
> Synthetic Test: In case of jobs which are complex and for which the analytical tests can't be
performed, synthetic tests may be adopted. It presents the candidate a complex situation more or less
similar to the one normally present in actual task and his success or failure in the test is accepted as
the possession or absence of the required vocational aptitude.
RECRUITMENT PROCESS
23
Stee Studies
Following are the various sources from where the personnel may be recruited
Applications Introduced by friends and relatives: Often the employees introduce their relative's
application to find a good job for them. Many companies prefer to take such candidates because their
background can be known. In this way a good worker can bring a good worker. However this may
lead to nepotism and favoritism.
Campus recruitment: As a large numbers of management institutes like IIM, XLRI, IIT etc., are
engaged in giving the professional training, many companies find it easier to pick up the best talent
straight from the institute to fill its managerial position. In fact these professional institutes have
provided recruitment source to firms.
Casual callers: Sometimes on his own initiative, the applicant sends his application for the job. The
personnel office keeps the record of applications and the suitable candidates can be selected from
the callers.
24
Stee Studies
Through advertisements: Companies advertise in the newspaper for their vacancies. Generally the
senior posts are filled by this method when they can't be filled by promotions. The advertisement
gives a wide range of choice. It also depends upon the employer’s fame. If the name is not reputed
one some of the good personnel do not apply.
Field trips and college recruitment: This method is being used for private industrial firms. These
firms send their selecting teams to respective colleges and universities, interview the candidates
who are nearing completion of their studies and make selection. This is no doubt very expensive
and time consuming but has the advantage of choosing the cream from the lot.
Employment exchange: The recruitment is also done through the employment exchange of the
persons who are enrolled in the exchange.
> To supply information about persons in need of jobs and about jobs that are available.
> To introduce selected employees with personnel department and policies of the company.
> To look-after the employee canceling and operating the system seriously.
Labour Contractors: The casual vacancies may be filled up by the company through labour
contractors. Usually unskilled candidates are appointed in this manner.
REVIEW QUESTIONS
25
Stee Studies
Direction means issuing of orders, leading and motivating subordinates as they go about
executing orders. It is also defined as the process and techniques used for issuing instructions to
carry out a job and making sure that the operations are carried out as per the plan. Directing is the
interpersonal aspect of managing by which subordinates are lead to understand and contribute
effectively and efficiently to the attainment of enterprise objectives. The direction has two major
activities namely
DEFINITION OF DIRECTION:
"Directing is the interpersonal aspect of managing by which subordinates are led to understand and
contribute effectively to the attainment of enterprise objectives. (Harold D Koontz &O’Donnell)
"Directing consists of the processes and techniques utilized in issuing instructions and making
certain that operations are carried on as originally planned". (Haimann)
"Direction is telling people what to do and seeing that they do it to the best of their ability. It
includes making assignments, corresponding procedures, seeing that mistakes are corrected,
providing on-the-job instruction and issuing orders". (Ernest Dole)
"Directing is the guidance, the inspiration, the leadership of those men and women that constitute
the real core of the responsibilities of the management". (Urwick and Breach)
26
Stee Studies
REQUIREMENTS OF DIRECTION:
The role of a manager is to understand the needs, motives and attitudes of his subordinates. He
should use appreciate strategies according to the people and situations. The following are some of
the principles of effective direction:
This principle implies that an employee should receive orders and instructions only from
one supervisor or boss. Otherwise, there may be indiscipline and confusion leading to conflicting
orders, divided loyalties and reduced results.
(iii) Efficiency:
If the superior consults with the subordinates in decision-making, then there would be a
sense of commitment. This makes the direction easy and improves the efficiency of subordinates.
Managers should have direct face-to-face contact with the subordinates. Personal touch
with subordinates will ensure successful direction.
The supervisor must have good communication skills. He must clearly communicate the
plans, goals, policies, responsibilities and the duties to the subordinates. In communication,
comprehension is more important than the content.
27
Stee Studies
The management should monitor the behavior and performance of subordinates to exercise
effective control over subordinates.
(vii) Follow-through:
Direction is a continuous process. Having given the directions may not ensure carrying out
them. Hence a manager should follow-through the performance of his subordinates. Follow up is
very important function of direction.
GIVING ORDERS
The order is a devise employed by a line manager in directing his immediate subordinates to
start an activity, stop it and modify it. A staff executive does not issue orders. To some men the
matter of giving orders and having them obeyed seems a very simple affair but the fact is that it is
surrounded by many difficulties. Mary Parker Follett lays down the following principles which
should be followed in giving orders:
1. The attitude necessary for the carrying out of an order should be prepared in advance. People
will obey an order only if it appeals to their habit patterns. Therefore, before giving orders, it should
be considered how to form the habits which will ensure their execution.
3. An order should be depersonalized and made an integral part of a given situation so that the
question of someone giving and someone receiving does not come up. Thus the task of the manager
is to make the subordinates perceive the need of the hour so that the situation communicates its
own message to them.
Chester Barnard lays down four conditions which make an order acceptable. These are:
28
Stee Studies
5. Orders may be communicated verbally or in writing. Written orders are appropriate when the
subject is important, many details are involved and there is geographical distance between the
order- giver and the recipient.
A manager may follow four types of methods to ensure compliance to his orders:
1. Force
2. Paternalism
3. Bargain, and
4. Harmony of objectives.
The formula followed in "force" is: "Do what I say or else ... ", meaning thereby that an employee
will be punished if he does not follow orders. The results are frustration, restriction of output,
sabotage, militant unionism, etc.
The formula followed in "paternalism" is: "Do what I say because I am good to you." The result
here is that the employees develop a feeling of gratitude and indebtedness toward the manager which
they do not like. Further, paternalism operates in violation of the law of effect. Instead of increased
rewards following increased compliance, the paternalistic manager provides rewards first and
expects the compliance to follow.
The formula followed in "bargain" is: 'You do as I say in certain respects and I do as you say in
certain other respects.' The result of this method is that the manager's control is gradually reduced.
The formula followed in "harmony of objectives" is: "If we perform together each will achieve his
goal". This in fact is the best formula for ensuring compliance to order.
MOTIVATION
29
Stee Studies
Among the three factors which affect performance, we can see the multiplying effect
motivation has on ability and knowledge in determining performance.
Therefore motivation is a very important factor because it deals with human behavior.
Motivation is nothing but the task of making someone to act in the desired manner.
(i) Motivation is a general term applying to the entire class of drives, desires, needs, wishes and
similar forces that induces an individual or a group of people to work'. -
(ii) 'Motivation is the process of attempting to influence others to do your work through the
possibility of gain or reward'. - Edwin B. Flippo (iii) 'Motivation means a process of stimulating
people to action to accomplish desired goals' - Scott
NATURE OF MOTIVATION
Motivation is not an easily observed phenomenon. We observe an individual's actions and then
interpret his observed behavior in terms of underlying motivation. This sometimes leaves a wide
margin of error. Our interpretation does not necessarily reveal the individual's true motivation. The
following points reveal the complexities involved in understanding true motivation:
30
Stee Studies
The stranger walked on to the third man and repeated the same question.
The third man replied. "Me, what am I doing? You see that cathedral up there. I am helping
to build that. Is not it great?" In this story the major source of satisfaction to the first man was the
wages he earned. The job itself contributed very little. But job itself was the outstanding source of
satisfaction to the second man. The third man viewed the completion of his group goal the building
of the cathedral as his primary source of satisfaction. This means that there is no single motive that
determines how all workers will react to the same job and, therefore, there can be no single strategy
that will keep motivation and productivity high for everyone everywhere. The manager has to deal
with human diversity.
Later on, it was found that the reason why she disliked her foreman was that she had a step-
father whom she feared and whose physical appearance was very much like her foreman, with the
result that she had unconsciously transferred to her foreman the unfavorable characteristics of her
step-father.
3. Motives change:
Hierarchy of motives of each individual called "structure" is not fixed. It changes from time
to time. An individual's primary motive today may not be primary tomorrow, even though he may
continue to behave in the same way. For example, a temporary worker may produce more in the
beginning to become permanent. When made permanent he may continue to produce more—this
time to gain promotion, and so on.
The ways in which motives are eventually translated into actions also vary considerably
between one individual and another. One individual with a strong security motive may play' it safe
and avoid accepting responsibility for fear of failing and being fired. Another individual with the
same security motive may seek out responsibility for fear of being fired for low performance. Even
the same individual may express his motive differently at different times. Thus, an employee who
in the beginning works hard to get promotion may, when frustrated, indulge in anti- management
union activities for the same purpose. Different expressions completely mislead a manager because
he does not know what the employee's true motivation is.
(i) Approach-
approach conflict where the person desires to do two things which he likes equally well, but
it is possible to do only one. For example, there is the person who has the choice of either
remaining at his present place of posting with the present salary, or going to a new place with a hike
in salary. In such situations, two different behaviors are aroused in him which block each other.
32
Stee Studies
(ii) Avoidance-
avoidance conflict where the person is forced to choose between two alternatives, both of
which are considered equally undesirable by him. For example, there is the person who, being
dissatisfied with his present job, wants to leave it but also wants to avoid unemployment.
(iii) Approach
avoidance conflict where the person is attracted to the positive characteristics of his choice,
but wants to avoid its negative characteristics. For example, a person may be motivated to work
overtime for extra pay but may not like to be scolded by his wife for reaching home late.
MOTIVATION THEORIES
There is no shortage of motivation theories. We can classify them under three broad- heads:
1. Content theories
2. Process theories
3. Reinforcement theory:
The content theories tell us what motivates an individual. They throw light on the various
needs and incentives which cause behavior. The process theories, on the other hand, answer the
question how behavior is caused. Reinforcement theory explains the ways in which behavior is
learned, shaped or modified.
There are several theories of motivation based on different structures of human needs and
expectations. Some of them are
33
Stee Studies
According to Maslow, all human needs can be arranged in an order of priority. In other words, human
needs have an hierarchy and they have to be satisfied from the lowest level moving in the ascending
order.
Physiological Needs:
Includes food, shelter, clothing, water, sleep, sex and other bodily needs. The physiological
needs are the basic needs in life. These are essential for everybody to remain alive. These needs
motivate the person to work and earn sufficient amount of money to fulfill them.
Includes security and protection from physical, emotional and economic harm. Once the
34
Stee Studies
physiological needs are satisfied, the safety needs or security needs become predominant. Physical
safety may be protection from fire and accidents. Economical security may be in terms of job
security, health and insurance programme, retirement plan etc., Emotional needs may be the
necessity to be happy and be free from mental disturbances.
Includes affection, belongingness, acceptance and friendship. Social needs come into the
picture when the primary needs are taken care of. Since man is a social animal, he has to interact
with the society, and live with respect in society. He desires to love and be loved; accept others and
be accepted; show affection and be shown affection an so on. Social needs make his work
enjoyable. Esteem Needs Includes self-respect, autonomy, status, recognition, responsibility,
attention, achievement, prestige, etc., Esteem needs represent an individual's concern for feeling
important and be respected by others. These needs are primarily satisfied by the individuals
themselves. However, the management may create a proper climate to help individuals to fulfill
these needs.
According to Maslow, if a lower level need is satisfied, a higher level need emerges. This
goes on till the highest level needs are satisfied. This theory of human motivation by Maslow has
been a landmark is the field of Management. However, it has been also criticized on the following
grounds:
(ii) Most of the human needs are recurring and are never satisfied fully indeed.
(iii) Most of the needs co-exist and there is no such hierarchy whatsoever.
35
Stee Studies
(iv) Boundaries between different levels of needs may be hazy and overlapping.
(v) Although behavior depends on need, or the lack of it, it may not be fully dependent.
(vi) The concept of self-actualization is theoretical and academic. No person can ever know his
maximum or best potentials.
The Motivation-Hygiene theory or the Two-Factor theory was proposed by Frederick Herzberg
in the year 1959. He carried out a survey on the experiences and feelings of a group of 200
engineers and accountants working in a few industries in Pittsburgh, USA. He concluded that
people had two categories of needs which are independent of each other and affect behaviour in
different ways. He said that satisfaction or dissatisfaction in work arise from these two different sets
of factors. They were
(ii) Motivators.
(1) Hygiene-Factors
He found that certain factors did not motivate the employee when present on the job but their
absence caused dissatisfaction. These factors were called Hygiene factors because they primarily
prevented dissatisfaction just like hygiene conditions prevent sickness. These factors are:
(2) Supervision
Herzberg said that the opposite of satisfaction was not dissatisfaction but 'No satisfaction' and
likewise the opposite of dissatisfaction was not satisfaction but it was No dissatisfaction'. Hygiene
36
Stee Studies
factors are also known as maintenance factors or Dissatisfiers and are necessary to sustain a
reasonable level of 'No dissatisfaction' among employees.
(ii) Motivators: According to Herzberg, Motivational factors are essential to provide job
satisfaction and to maintain high job performance. Motivators act as stimuli to make people work
hard voluntarily and be happy in the organization. Motivators or `Satisfiers' include the following
factors :
(2) Responsibility
(3) Recognition
(5) Achievement
Herzberg said that these factors helped in increasing job satisfaction. However a decrease in
these factors would lead to satisfaction' and not dissatisfaction. Motivators generally help attaining
higher output by the employees.
(ii) Motivators:
(i) People may not be accurate in reporting their satisfying or dissatisfying experiences.
(ii) A factor that causes dissatisfaction is one person may bring satisfaction to another.
37
Stee Studies
(iii) People are biased and they tend to credit themselves for successful events while blaming outside
events for their failures.
(iv) The theory does not measure the levels of satisfaction and dissatisfaction Over simplification.
Both theories concentrate on the factors which motivate employee's behavior to achieve
higher output. Which Maslow formulated the theory in terms of needs, Herzberg in terms of goals.
While Maslow gave a hierarchy to his needs, Herzberg divided them into two groups but without
hierarchy. While Maslow said that all needs are motivators, Herzberg said only higher order needs
are motivators. Actually the first three ascending levels of needs according to Maslow correspond
to the Hygiene factors of Herzberg and the last two higher levels of needs of Maslow correspond to
Motivators as per Herzberg.
COMMUNICATION
Simply stated, communication means the process of passing information and understanding
38
Stee Studies
from one person to another. A proper understanding of information is one very important aspect
of communication. If the information is not understood by the receiver in the same meaning in
which its sender wants him to understand it, the purpose of communication is defeated. This
may result in confusion, chaos and organizational inefficiency, leading to non-fulfillment of
business goals.
IMPORTANCE OF COMMUNICATION
In any organization, a manager spends most of his time communicating i.e., reading,
writing' Speaking or listening. Communication is the means by which he persuades, informs,
motivates and leads his employees towards organizational goals through communication that
there is a transmission of information among employ • It is without communication no work can
get accomplished.
39
Stee Studies
When manager listens carefully to employees grievances and take necessary action, it
improves morale and motivation of the workers. Without communication, it is impossible to
understand others and make them understand. Good communication helps in addressing workers
problems and therefore keeps their morale and motivation high.
PURPOSES OF COMMUNICATION
40
Stee Studies
41
Stee Studies
on the basis of division of labour and specialization, there is need for coordination among its
component parts. This can be achieved only through communication. A good communication
system is the basis of all interdependent activities which we find being carried out in different
departments of an organization. By providing information to each unit about the relevant
activities of others, a good system of communication makes the interdependence of each unit
acceptable to it. In the absence of communication, no unit would tolerate this interdependence.
This will make coordination difficult. In the words of March and Simon, "The greater the
efficiency of communication within the organization, the greater the tolerance of a unit for
interdependence."
10. Communication increases managerial efficiency. It is said that the world of modem
management is the world of communication and the success of a manager in the performance of
his duties depends on his ability to communicate. Administrators in business and industry
reportedly spend between 75 and 95 per cent of their time communicating. Naturally then, an
effective system of communication is very essential for the efficiency of a manager. Benjamin
Balinsky has rightly remarked that, if there is any shortcut to executive effectiveness, it is the
mastery of the art of face to face communication.
2. Explain Maslow's Need-Hierarchy theory. How does it compare with the Two-Factor
Theory?
42
Stee Studies
43