Week 7 Readings

Tuesday, May 21, 2024 9:08 PM

Vocabulary Terms and Definitions

1. Feminist Therapy: A therapeutic approach that emphasizes understanding and addressing the societal, cultural, and political influences on a client's life, particularly in relation to
gender inequality.
2. Patriarchy: A social system in which men hold primary power, leading to systemic inequality and oppression of women.
3. Gender Roles: Societal norms dictating the behaviors that are considered appropriate for individuals based on their perceived gender.
4. Empowerment: The process of gaining control, authority, and influence over one's life and claiming one's rights.
5. Intersectionality: A framework for understanding how various forms of social stratification (e.g., race, gender, class) interconnect and impact individuals and groups.
6. Consciousness-Raising: A technique used to increase awareness about personal, social, and political issues, particularly those related to gender inequality.
7. Relational-Cultural Theory: A psychological theory focusing on the importance of relationships and connectedness in women's lives and development.
8. Egalitarian Relationship: A therapeutic relationship that strives for equality, mutual respect, and shared power between the therapist and client.
9. Internalized Oppression: When marginalized individuals begin to believe and accept negative stereotypes and messages about their own group.
10. Social Justice: The objective of creating a fair and equal society by addressing issues of inequality and discrimination.
11. Gender Schema: Cognitive structures that dictate the expectations and behaviors considered appropriate for each gender.
12. Power Analysis: A technique in feminist therapy used to explore the power dynamics and structures that affect the client's life.
13. Reframing: Changing the way a situation, person, or relationship is viewed and interpreted, often to see it in a more positive or empowering light.
14. Advocacy: The act of supporting or promoting a cause or proposal, particularly in the context of addressing systemic issues and promoting social change.
Main Points Condensed
1. Foundational Principles: Feminist therapy is rooted in the understanding of the impact of gender, power, and societal norms on individual well-being.
2. Social Context and Oppression: Recognizing the pervasive influence of patriarchy and societal structures that perpetuate gender inequality.
3. Empowerment and Equality: The therapeutic relationship should promote equality and empower clients to take control of their lives.
4. Intersectionality: Acknowledging the interconnectedness of various forms of oppression, such as race, class, and gender, and their collective impact on the client.
5. Client's Experience: Emphasizing the client's lived experience and subjective reality as central to the therapeutic process.
6. Therapist's Role: Acting as an advocate and ally, not just a therapist, by actively working towards social justice and systemic change.
7. Techniques and Interventions: Utilizing consciousness-raising, power analysis, and reframing to help clients gain insight and empowerment.
8. Relational Dynamics: Understanding the importance of relationships and connectedness in the client's life, fostering an egalitarian therapeutic relationship.
Summary of Feminist Therapy Theory
Feminist therapy is a comprehensive approach to counseling that integrates principles of feminism, social justice, and multiculturalism into the therapeutic process. This theory
posits that individual distress cannot be understood in isolation from the broader social, cultural, and political contexts that shape one's experiences, particularly regarding
gender. Central to feminist therapy is the goal of empowerment, helping clients recognize and challenge the systemic power imbalances and internalized oppression they face.
The approach emphasizes the importance of intersectionality, acknowledging that issues such as race, class, and sexual orientation intersect with gender to create unique
experiences of oppression and privilege. Therapeutic techniques include consciousness-raising to increase awareness of societal influences, power analysis to understand and
address power dynamics, and reframing to help clients see their experiences in a more empowering light. The therapist-client relationship is collaborative and egalitarian, aiming
to foster mutual respect and shared power.
Feminist therapists also see themselves as advocates for social change, working not only to support individual clients but also to challenge and transform the societal structures
that perpetuate inequality. This commitment to social justice is a defining characteristic of feminist therapy, aiming to create both personal and societal transformation.

From <https://chatgpt.com/c/c65e53d4-2a84-4b25-b3f4-b7ba08045e66>

Introduction Main Points:

Evolution of Feminist Therapy: Originally focused on women, feminist therapy now encompasses a broader scope that includes multiple oppressions, power, privilege,
multicultural competence, social justice, and the oppression of all marginalized people.

Core Principles: Emphasizes intersections of gender, social identities, social location, and power in the therapeutic process. Understanding the social, cultural, and political
context is essential to understanding clients.

Philosophical Orientation: Integrates feminist, multicultural, and social justice concepts using various psychotherapy approaches. Central to this is acknowledging psychological
oppression and sociopolitical constraints on marginalized individuals.

Socialization and Identity: Socialization affects identity development, self-concept, goals, aspirations, and emotional well-being. Women often internalize giving away power in
relationships. Gender socialization, sexism, and other forms of discrimination are key considerations.

Representation and Theories: Most clients and many practitioners are women, but traditional theories were developed by White males from Western cultures. Feminist theory is
the first to emerge from women's collective experiences, challenging male-oriented mental health assumptions.

Contemporary Practice: While early feminist therapy focused on women's experiences and political realities, contemporary practice includes understanding multiple oppressions
and promoting multicultural competence and social justice.

Multifaceted Identity Consideration: Gender cannot be isolated from other identities like race, ethnicity, socioeconomic class, age, and sexual orientation. Recent developments
in social justice in counseling integrate themes of multiculturalism and feminism.

Systemic Perspective: Contemporary feminist therapy shares a systemic perspective with multicultural and social justice approaches, focusing on understanding the social
context of clients' lives and aiming for both social and individual change.

Timeline of the History and Development of Feminist Therapy

Late 1800s
• First Wave of Feminism: The beginnings of feminism trace back to this period, focusing on women's suffrage and legal rights.
1960s
• Second Wave of Feminism: This era laid the foundation for feminist therapy. Women united to voice their dissatisfaction with traditional female roles,
leading to the formation of consciousness-raising groups where women shared experiences and perceptions.

COUN5239-Theories Page 1
 leading to the formation of consciousness-raising groups where women shared experiences and perceptions.
• Emergence of Feminist Therapy: Feminist therapists developed the concept, emphasizing the need for improved mental health treatment for women
and focusing on social, political, and cultural influences on women's mental health.
1982
• Gilligan’s Morality of Care: Carol Gilligan's work on the development of a morality of care in women became influential.
• Self-in-Relation Model: Developed by Jean Baker Miller and the Stone Center scholars, later known as the "relational-cultural" model, focusing on
relational and cooperative dimensions of women's experiences.
1986
• Relational-Cultural Model: Continued development and influence of Miller's work, emphasizing relational aspects in feminist personality theory.
1980s
• Expansion and Diversification: Feminist therapy became more diverse, addressing specific issues such as body image, abusive relationships, eating
disorders, incest, and sexual abuse. Integration with traditional psychotherapy systems, such as psychoanalytic and Adlerian approaches, was
explored.
1991, 2000, 2004
• Enns' Contributions: New theories emerged honoring the relational and cooperative dimensions of women's experiences, with Laura S. Brown
defining feminist therapy as a postmodern, technically integrative approach.
2018
• Contemporary Definition: Brown defined feminist therapy as focusing on the analysis of gender, power, and social location as strategies for facilitating
change. Emphasis on understanding and confronting gender-role stereotypes and power dynamics, with a sociocultural perspective being central to
addressing clients' problems.
Throughout these developments, feminist therapy has maintained its focus on collaboration, mutuality, and understanding the impact of societal and
cultural forces on individuals' mental health, continually evolving to address the diverse needs of clients.

Key Concepts
Feminist therapy, which originated in the late 1800s with the first wave of feminism, has evolved significantly over time. The second wave of feminism
in the 1960s laid the foundation for the development of feminist therapy. Women united to voice dissatisfaction with traditional female roles, forming
consciousness-raising groups and establishing services like shelters and health centers. Early feminist therapists viewed therapy as a partnership
between equals, emphasizing social, political, and cultural influences on mental health rather than focusing solely on individual psychopathology.

Carol Gilligan's work in the 1980s highlighted the differences in moral development between men and women, challenging the male-centric
perspectives of existing theories. The relational-cultural model, developed by Jean Baker Miller and others, emphasized the importance of
relationships and connectedness in women's development. By the 1980s, feminist therapy had diversified, addressing issues such as body image,
abuse, and eating disorders, and integrating with other psychotherapy systems.

Recent trends in feminist therapy include relational-cultural theory, which focuses on growth through connection and emphasizes the importance of
authenticity, empathy, and mutual empowerment. This approach is applied to various marginalized groups, recognizing the impact of societal
practices on individuals' sense of connection. Transnational feminism, a more recent development, aims to encompass the diverse experiences of
women globally, particularly those in cultural borderlands. This approach promotes inclusiveness, reflexivity, and an understanding of global structural
forces that reinforce dominant ways of thinking and behaving.

Vocabulary Terms and Definitions

9. Feminist Therapy: A therapeutic approach that emphasizes understanding and addressing societal, cultural, and political influences on mental health,
particularly regarding gender inequality.
10. Patriarchy: A social system where men hold primary power, leading to systemic inequality and oppression of women.
11. Gender Roles: Societal norms dictating behaviors considered appropriate for individuals based on their perceived gender.
12. Empowerment: The process of gaining control, authority, and influence over one's life and claiming one's rights.
13. Intersectionality: A framework for understanding how various forms of social stratification (e.g., race, gender, class) interconnect and impact
individuals and groups.
14. Consciousness-Raising: A technique to increase awareness about personal, social, and political issues, particularly related to gender inequality.
15. Relational-Cultural Theory (RCT): A theory emphasizing the importance of relationships and connectedness in women's lives and development.
16. Egalitarian Relationship: A therapeutic relationship striving for equality, mutual respect, and shared power between therapist and client.
17. Internalized Oppression: When marginalized individuals believe and accept negative stereotypes and messages about their own group.
18. Social Justice: The objective of creating a fair and equal society by addressing issues of inequality and discrimination.
19. Gender Schema: Cognitive structures that dictate the expectations and behaviors considered appropriate for each gender.
20. Power Analysis: A technique in feminist therapy to explore the power dynamics and structures affecting the client's life.
21. Reframing: Changing the way a situation, person, or relationship is viewed and interpreted to see it more positively or empowering.
22. Advocacy: Supporting or promoting a cause, particularly in addressing systemic issues and promoting social change.
23. Transnational Feminism: An approach in feminist therapy that focuses on the diverse experiences of women globally, emphasizing inclusiveness and
reflexivity.
24. Positionality: Therapists examining their own social identities, power, and privilege to understand their impact on therapy.
25. Reflexivity: Self-examination regarding reliance on Euro-centric knowledge and support of oppressive systems.
26. Flexible-Multicultural Perspective: Using concepts and strategies applicable to individuals and groups regardless of their social positionality.
27. Interactionist Intersectionality: An approach considering the thinking, feeling, and behaving dimensions of human experience and environmental
factors.
28. Life-Span Perspective: The view that human development is a lifelong process with the potential for personality and behavioral changes at any stage.

Condensed Principles of Feminist Therapy

1. The Personal is Political and Critical Consciousness: Individual problems are rooted in political and social contexts of marginalization and oppression.
This principle emphasizes recognizing societal impacts on personal issues as a core tenet of feminist therapy.
2. Commitment to Social Change: Feminist therapy aims for both individual and societal change. Therapists engage in social activism, helping clients
understand their privileges and oppressions, and advocate for a society free from gender-role constraints.
3. Valuing Marginalized Voices: Feminist therapy values and honors the experiences of women and other marginalized groups, challenging traditional
androcentric and heterosexist norms. It encourages clients to use their personal experiences as a basis for reality.

COUN5239-Theories Page 2
 androcentric and heterosexist norms. It encourages clients to use their personal experiences as a basis for reality.
4. Egalitarian Counseling Relationship: Emphasizing authenticity, mutuality, and respect, feminist therapists strive to balance power dynamics in the
therapeutic relationship, facilitating open discussions about power and privilege.
5. Focus on Strengths and Redefining Psychological Distress: Psychological distress is viewed as a response to unjust systems rather than pathology.
Symptoms are reframed as survival strategies within oppressive contexts.
6. Recognition of All Oppressions: Feminist therapy acknowledges the impact of various forms of oppression (not just gender) and their
interconnectedness. It aims to empower clients by framing issues within their sociocultural context and promoting social change.
7. Reflexivity and Positionality: Therapists engage in continuous self-reflection and awareness of their own social identities and power dynamics to
maintain cultural humility and avoid imposing unexamined values on clients.

The Therapeutic Process

The goals of feminist therapy encompass empowerment, affirming diversity, promoting social change, and balancing independence and interdependence. Key objectives include
helping individuals view themselves as active agents, recognize and embrace personal and collective power, and challenge internalized oppression. Feminist therapists assist
clients in becoming aware of gender-role socialization, replacing oppressive beliefs with self-enhancing ones, understanding the impact of societal discrimination, acquiring
change-making skills, and fostering a sense of personal and social power. Ultimately, feminist therapy aims to transform both individuals and society by addressing and replacing
oppressive practices with equality and empowerment for all marginalized groups.

According to Worell and Remer (2003), feminist therapists help clients

♦Become aware of their own gender-role socialization process.

♦Identify their internalized messages of oppression and replace them with more self-enhancing beliefs.

♦Understand how sexist and oppressive societal beliefs and practices influence them in negative ways.

♦Acquire skills to bring about change in the environment.

♦Restructure institutions to rid them of discriminatory practices.

♦Develop a wide range of behaviors that are freely chosen.

♦Evaluate the impact of social factors on their lives.

♦Develop a sense of personal and social power.

♦Recognize the power of relationships and connectedness.

♦Trust their own experience and their intuition.

Therapist's Function and Role

The therapist's function and role in feminist therapy are grounded in feminist philosophy, focusing on the sociocultural context of clients' issues. Feminist
therapists integrate lived experiences and research on gender and other inequities into their practice, maintaining congruence between their professional and
personal lives. They are committed to understanding and addressing all forms of oppression, being emotionally present, sharing themselves, and modeling
proactive behaviors. The therapeutic relationship is nonhierarchical, aiming to empower clients to rely on their internal values. Feminist therapists emphasize
mutual empathy, but unlike person-centered therapy, they believe that action is necessary for change, not just the therapeutic relationship. They avoid replicating
societal power imbalances and work collaboratively with clients to set goals and determine therapeutic procedures, rejecting the notion of the therapist as an all-
knowing expert.

Client's Experience in Therapy

In feminist therapy, clients are partners in the therapeutic process, sharing their stories and determining their goals, as they are seen as experts on their own lives.
They explore how gender-role socialization and other intersecting identities affect them, experiencing and expressing a range of emotions in a safe environment.
This collaborative journey of empowerment leads to new perspectives, personal growth, and transformed relationships, as clients gain a deeper understanding of
their world and their place within it.

Relationship Between Therapist and Client

In feminist therapy, the client-therapist relationship is structured to model responsible use of power, maintaining an egalitarian dynamic by involving clients in
assessment and treatment. Therapists share their values during informed consent to minimize value imposition and demystify the process. They stay vigilant about
the inherent power imbalance, avoiding misuse of power through unnecessary diagnosing, unwarranted advice, or inappropriate self-disclosure. By recognizing
complex cultural identities and valuing client strengths, particularly those of marginalized groups, therapists ensure that clients feel empowered as experts on
their own lives.

Application: Therapeutic Techniques and Procedures

The Role of Assessment and Diagnosis

Feminist therapy challenges traditional diagnostic practices, critiquing their cultural biases and potential for oppression. Instead of relying heavily on diagnostic
labels, therapists focus on understanding distress within the context of social and cultural factors, emphasizing coping strategies and resilience. Diagnosis, if used,
arises from collaborative dialogue between client and therapist, with careful consideration of its implications and an emphasis on empowering clients to
understand the social and cultural influences on their problems. The therapeutic approach prioritizes wellness, resilience, and the celebration of diverse strengths,
reframing symptoms as resistance to oppression rather than evidence of pathology. Assessment is seen as an ongoing process intertwined with treatment
interventions, with a primary focus on identifying and enhancing client strengths, skills, and resources.

COUN5239-Theories Page 3
interventions, with a primary focus on identifying and enhancing client strengths, skills, and resources.

Techniques and Strategies

Feminist therapy emphasizes tailored interventions aimed at empowering clients and fostering their feminist consciousness, rather than prescribing a specific set
of techniques. Techniques like consciousness-raising are utilized to help clients challenge societal norms and differentiate between socially imposed expectations
and what is truly healthy for them. Drawing from various sources, therapists apply these interventions based on individual strengths and needs. For instance, when
working with Alma, a 22-year-old Dominican woman struggling with anxiety and identity issues related to her sexual orientation, a feminist counselor might
integrate indigenous values and spirituality to complement traditional therapeutic methods, considering Alma's unique cultural identity and experiences.

Alma, age 22, comes to counseling reporting general anxiety about a new job she began a month ago. She states that she has struggled with depression off and on
throughout her life because of bullying as a child and rejection from much of her family after coming out as a lesbian at age 14. Alma identifies as Dominican and
continues to struggle with the loss of her place within her family of origin. She now believes coming out was a selfish mistake and is trying to make amends by
keeping her feelings regarding her sexual and affectional orientation hidden. Due in part to past experiences, if she comes out to her coworkers, she is worried
that the company might find a reason to fire her. Alma says, “I would like to cut my hair short again because it is more manageable and I also prefer to wear what
is considered to be more masculine clothing, but I am worried this will cause people at work to question my femininity. I really like my job, and I worked very hard
to get it. I am afraid if I show them who I really am, they won’t want me there anymore.”

Strategies:

Empowerment:
Feminist therapy focuses on empowering the client through egalitarian and tailored strategies, emphasizing informed consent as a cornerstone of the therapeutic
relationship. Alma's therapist ensures clear communication, collaborative goal-setting, and active involvement from Alma in the therapeutic process. By
demystifying therapy and inviting Alma to actively participate, the therapist interrupts feelings of powerlessness and encourages Alma to recognize her own
agency. This approach is especially crucial given Alma's cultural background, where she may perceive the therapist as holding authoritative knowledge.

Self-Disclosure:
Feminist therapists use self-disclosure judiciously to enhance the therapeutic relationship, empower clients, and establish informed consent, ensuring it aligns with
the client's best interests. For instance, Alma's therapist may share personal experiences to model healthy coping mechanisms and normalize collective
experiences, fostering a sense of mutual understanding. The therapist's authenticity and transparency contribute to an egalitarian atmosphere, allowing Alma to
actively participate in evaluating therapeutic interventions and goal achievement. This process unfolds gradually to prioritize Alma's exploration of her concerns
without overshadowing her experience.

Gender-Role and Social Identity Analysis:

Gender-role analysis, a cornerstone of feminist therapy, helps clients like Alma recognize the influence of their gender-role socialization on their beliefs and
behaviors. Referred to by some therapists as social identity analysis to encompass all relevant facets of identity, this process involves exploring messages received
from various societal sources regarding gender, sexuality, race/ethnicity, and appearance. Alma, identifying as female, lesbian, and Dominican, grapples with
marginalized identities within societal norms. Through guided reflection, Alma uncovers internalized oppressive messages and strives to replace them with
affirming beliefs, fostering a more empowered self-perception. The therapist facilitates Alma's journey towards adopting authentic and supportive internal
narratives, promoting self-awareness and resilience amidst societal pressures.

Gender-Role and Social Role Intervention

Through gender-role and social role intervention, the therapist contextualizes Alma's concerns within societal expectations for women, shedding light on the
impact of social issues on her well-being. Addressing Alma's apprehensions about changing her appearance, the therapist highlights society's emphasis on
unrealistic beauty standards imposed on females, fostering insight into how these norms contribute to Alma's anxiety and depression. By framing Alma's
experience in this broader social context, the therapist encourages solidarity among women and empowers Alma to contemplate her potential role as a positive
influence on younger generations. Increasing her awareness of media's influence on self-esteem, Alma may be inspired to engage in collective action with other
women to challenge harmful societal norms and promote meaningful change.

Power Analysis
Power analysis is an assessment technique used in therapy to illuminate societal power dynamics, particularly highlighting the devaluation experienced by women
and marginalized groups. In Alma's case, this approach helps her recognize power differentials based on gender, sexual orientation, and ethnicity in society.
Through this analysis, Alma identifies alternative forms of power and learns to challenge societal messages that limit her agency. Therapeutic interventions aim to
bolster Alma's self-confidence, appreciate her intrinsic attributes, and set culturally aligned goals for personal fulfillment.

Bibliotherapy
Bibliotherapy encompasses various resources like books, films, and videos that therapists can utilize to support clients. Specifically, reading materials on feminist
and multicultural perspectives can challenge self-blame in women facing common issues like sexual violence. The therapist recommends relevant books to Alma,
bridging knowledge gaps and reducing the power disparity between them. These materials supplement therapy sessions, allowing Alma to explore her reactions
and find empowerment through narratives of women with similar identities.

Assertiveness Training
Assertiveness training helps women recognize their rights, challenge gender norms, and shift negative beliefs, empowering them to enact change in their lives.
Alma explores how sexism has influenced female passivity, considering cultural norms and potential consequences of assertive behavior. By learning and practicing
assertiveness, Alma gains confidence and agency, addressing depression and anxiety while asserting her right to advocate for herself in the workplace.

Reframing and Relabeling

In feminist therapy, reframing shifts focus from internalizing problems to considering societal influences, addressing social pressures and norms that contribute to clients' issues
like depression and anxiety. Relabeling interventions encourage clients like Alma to change self-perceptions, promoting positive identities and challenging negative labels
associated with gender norms.

Social Action

COUN5239-Theories Page 4
 Social Action
Feminist counseling emphasizes social action, encouraging clients to engage in activities like volunteering or advocacy to address gender issues and empower
themselves. Clients like Alma may join organizations challenging societal norms, boosting self-esteem and personal power as they connect personal experiences to
broader social contexts.

The Role of Men in Feminist Therapy

Men can actively participate in feminist therapy as both therapists and clients, dispelling the misconception that it's exclusively for women or anti-men. While
initially led by women, male therapists now embrace feminist principles, acknowledging male privilege and working to redefine traditional masculinity. These
principles extend to counseling men from diverse backgrounds, challenging societal norms around masculinity, and creating a safe space for reflection and growth.
Female therapists can employ relational-cultural theory to facilitate discussions on men's experiences, fostering an environment of acceptance and authenticity.
For a deeper understanding, therapists can refer to specialized resources and guidelines such as those provided by Englar-Carlson, Evans, and Duffey (2014) and
the APA Guidelines for Psychological Practice with Boys and Men (American Psychological Association, 2018a).

Application of the Feminist Approach to Group Work

Feminist therapists often recommend transitioning from individual therapy to group settings like support or political action groups, offering a sense of community
and validation for women's experiences. These groups provide a platform to share, explore societal messages, and develop effective coping strategies in a
supportive environment. Through group participation, women realize the systemic roots of their individual challenges and are inspired to take social action. Alma
and her therapist may consider joining a women's support or LGBTQ+ alliance group to enrich Alma's sense of belonging and foster collective healing and growth.

Feminist Social Justice Principles Applied to School Counseling

During the school years, students undergo significant gender-related changes within a complex cultural system, guiding school counseling practices. Feminist social
justice principles advocate for understanding the costs of traditional gender socialization, intersectionality, and sociocultural contexts in addressing students'
concerns. Gender-related socialization negatively impacts both boys and girls, influencing issues like emotional expression, body image, and career aspirations.
Social identity and gender role analysis assist students in comprehending their experiences holistically, exploring intersecting identities and societal pressures.
Feminist counselors prioritize contextual understanding over formal diagnosis, emphasizing coping skills and resilience-building. Trauma-related experiences,
particularly among girls and women, are addressed through trauma-informed services, given the prevalence of traumatic events in childhood. Expressive arts
therapies and action-based activities cater to diverse student needs, promoting gender equality and social change within school communities. Through
collaboration with community programs and advocacy efforts, counselors aim to create safer and more inclusive environments for students.

An Expert's Perspective on Feminist Therapy

1. Feminist therapy emphasizes understanding individuals within their ecological spheres, acknowledging systemic barriers like racism, sexism, and
heterosexism. By reframing individual problems within social contexts, it highlights the importance of social change alongside personal growth.
2. Key concepts of feminist therapy for individual counseling include critical consciousness, resilience, strength, and intersectionality. These concepts
encourage awareness of social injustices, promote personal agency, and recognize the complex interplay of multiple identities and oppressions.
3. While feminist therapy prioritizes conceptual frameworks over specific techniques, practitioners can draw from various approaches to empower clients
and enact social change. Social identity analysis, examining clients' intersecting identities and experiences of oppression, serves as a foundational
technique, facilitating deeper understanding and self-awareness in therapy.
4. Feminist theory in counseling embraces diversity and advocates for social justice by addressing various forms of bias and oppression, including
gender, race, ethnicity, class, and more. It prioritizes centralizing the perspectives of marginalized groups, emphasizing intersectionality to value
diversity and difference.
5. While individual therapy is valued, feminist counseling recognizes that achieving equity requires activism and advocacy. Therapists are encouraged to
combat social injustices and contribute to social change beyond the therapy room.
6. In brief therapy, feminist counselors believe in clients' strengths and capacity for growth, viewing other supportive avenues like self-help groups,
bibliotherapy, and community involvement as empowering. Group work and skill-building activities complement individual counseling, reinforcing
growth and fostering empowerment.
7. The feminist approach to therapy is evolving to be more intersectional, multicultural, and transnational, recognizing the complexities of oppression and privilege
worldwide. While some therapists may hesitate to label their practice as feminist due to social misconceptions, many integrate feminist principles into their work,
often using terms like "feminist social justice therapy" or "multicultural feminist therapy." There's a growing awareness of the need for ongoing self-examination
and decolonization within feminist practice to ensure inclusivity and avoid imposing Western ideals on other cultures. Despite challenges, feminist consciousness
and therapies, particularly those embracing multicultural and transnational perspectives, are expected to remain influential in the 21st century.

Discussion Questions Related to the Feminist Therapy Perspective

1.A wide range of techniques associated with diverse counseling approaches are compatible with a feminist framework provided they can be used to empower
clients and enact social change; facilitate egalitarian goals, equity, and power sharing; and facilitate social structural as well as individual change. What are some
techniques used in feminist therapy that you particularly like?

2.Feminist therapy rests on the assumption that movement toward a society in which equity exists requires a commitment to activism and advocacy. If you accept
this premise, how would this affect your role as a counselor?

3.Feminist therapy involves a commitment to equality and efforts to eradicate all forms of bias and oppression including gender bias, racism, ethnocentrism,
classism, colonialism, ableism, ageism, heterosexism, and any other abuses of power. What practical implications does this commitment to eradicate all forms of
bias and oppression have for you as a counselor?

Feminist Therapy from a Multicultural and Social Justice Perspective

Strengths from a Diversity Perspective
Feminist therapy aligns closely with multicultural and social justice perspectives, aiming to address societal oppression and promote empowerment. These
approaches emphasize the need for social, political, and environmental change within counseling, rejecting the idea of individual problems solely originating from

COUN5239-Theories Page 5
approaches emphasize the need for social, political, and environmental change within counseling, rejecting the idea of individual problems solely originating from
within. Embracing the principle that "the personal is political," therapists are encouraged to become activists and challenge unjust systems in society. Culturally
competent feminist therapists acknowledge the complexities of cultural contexts, seeking to understand and challenge discriminatory beliefs and practices while
working within the client's cultural framework. Through this lens, therapists become allies in the pursuit of a more just society.

Shortcomings from a Diversity Perspective

Feminist therapists advocate for social change, including equality in relationships, self-determination, and career opportunities, which may clash with some clients'
cultural values. Therapists must navigate this complexity, empowering clients to make decisions that align with their individual goals while respecting their cultural
background. It's crucial for therapists to acknowledge their own cultural biases and discuss their values openly with clients to prevent imposing their beliefs on
them.

Feminist Therapy Applied to the Case of Stan

See the APA (2018a) “Guidelines for Psychological Practice with Boys and Men” for instructions on how to apply these new guidelines for understanding Stan.

Stan’s fear of women and his gender-role socialization experiences make him an excellent candidate to benefit from feminist therapy. A therapeutic relationship
that is egalitarian will be a new kind of experience for Stan.

Stan has indicated that he is willing and even eager to change. Despite his low self-esteem and negative self-evaluations, he is able to identify some positive
attributes. These include his determination, his ability to articulate his feelings, and his gift for working with children. Stan knows what he wants out of therapy
and has clear goals: to stop drinking, to feel better about himself, to relate to women on an equal basis, and to learn to love and trust himself and others.
Operating from a feminist orientation, I will build on these strengths.

In the first session, I focus on establishing an egalitarian working relationship to help Stan begin to regain his personal power. It is important that the therapeutic
relationship does not replicate other relationships Stan has had with significant figures in his life. I consciously work to demystify the therapeutic process and
equalize the relationship, conveying to Stan that he is in charge of the direction of his therapy. I spend time explaining my view of the therapy process and how it
works.

A gender-role analysis is conducted to help Stan become aware of the influence of gender-role expectations in the development of his problems. First, I ask him to
identify gender-role messages he received while growing up from his parents, teachers, the media, faith community, and peers. In his autobiography Stan has
written about some of the messages his parents gave him, and this provides a natural starting point for his analysis. He remembers his father calling him “dumb”
and his mother saying, “Why can’t you grow up and be a man?” Stan wrote about his mother “continually harping at” his father and telling Stan how she wished
she hadn’t had him. He describes his father as weak, passive, and mousy in relating to his mother and remembers that his father compared him unfavorably with
his siblings. Stan internalized these messages, often crying himself to sleep and feeling very hopeless.

I ask Stan to identify the damaging self-statements he makes now that are based on these early experiences. As we review his writings, Stan sees how societal
messages he received about what a man “should” be were reinforced by parental messages and have shaped his view of himself today. For example, he wrote that
he feels sexually inadequate. It appears that he has introjected the societal notion that men should always initiate sex, be ready for sex, and be able to achieve and
sustain an erection. Stan also sees that he has already identified and written about how he wants to change those messages, as exemplified in his statements that
he wants to “feel equal with others” and not “feel apologetic” for his existence and develop a loving relationship with a woman. Stan begins to feel capable and
empowered as I acknowledge the important work he has already done, even before he entered therapy.

I follow this gender-role analysis with a gender-role intervention to place Stan’s concerns in the context of societal role expectations.

Therapist: Indeed, it is a burden to try to live up to society’s notion of what it means to be a man, always having to be strong and tough. Sometimes real strength
comes through our vulnerability. Those aspects of yourself that you would like to value—your ability to experience your feelings, being good with children—are
qualities society tends to label as “‘feminine.”

Stan: [Replies wistfully] Yeah, it would be a better world if women could be strong without being seen as domineering and if men could be sensitive and nurturing
without being seen as weak.

Therapist: Are you sure that’s not possible? Have you ever met a woman or a man who was like that?

Stan ponders for a minute and then with some animation describes the college professor who taught his Psychology of Adjustment class. Stan saw her not only as
very accomplished and strong, but also as someone who empowered him by encouraging him to find his own voice through writing his autobiography. He also
remembers a male counselor at the youth rehabilitation facility where he spent part of his adolescence as a man who was strong as well as sensitive and nurturing.
I ask Stan if there are other people in his life now who might support his efforts to be more accepting and affirming of his androgyny.

As the first session draws to a close, I invite Stan to talk about what he learned from our time together. Stan says two things stand out for him. First, he is
beginning to believe he doesn’t need to keep blaming himself. He knows that many of the messages he has received from his parents and from society about what
it means to be a man have been undesirable and one-dimensional. He acknowledges that he has been limited and constrained by his gender-role socialization.
Second, he feels hopeful because there are alternatives to those parental and societal definitions—people he admires have been able to successfully combine
“masculine” and “feminine” traits. If they can do it, so can he. I ask Stan whether he chooses to return for another session. When he answers in the affirmative, I
give him W. S. Pollack’s (1998) book Real Boys to read. I explain that this book descriptively captures the gender-role socialization that many boys experience.

Stan comes to the following session eager to talk about his homework assignment. He tells me that he gained some real insights into his own attitudes and beliefs
by reading Real Boys. What Stan learned from reading this book leads to a further exploration of his relationship with his mother. He finds it helpful to understand
his parents’ behavior in the context of societal expectations and stereotypes rather than continuing to blame them. I help Stan to see how our culture tends to
hold extreme positions about mothers—that they are either perfect or wicked—and that neither of these extremes is true. We talk briefly about what he has
learned about mothers as saints or sinners. As Stan learns to reframe his relationship with his mother, he develops a more realistic picture of her. He comes to
realize, too, that his father has been oppressed by his own socialization experiences and by an idealistic view of masculinity that he may have felt unable to

COUN5239-Theories Page 6
realize, too, that his father has been oppressed by his own socialization experiences and by an idealistic view of masculinity that he may have felt unable to
achieve.

Stan continues to work at learning to value the nurturing and sensitive aspects of himself. He is learning to value the “feminine” as well as the “masculine” aspects
of his personality. He continues to monitor and make changes in his self-talk about what it means to be a man. He is gaining awareness of these messages that
come from current sources such as the media and friends, and each day he adds to his journal, noting how these messages are transmitted and the ways that he is
challenging them.

Throughout our therapeutic relationship, we discuss with immediacy how we are communicating and relating to each other during the sessions. I am self-
disclosing and treat Stan as an equal, continually acknowledging that he is the “expert” on his life.

Questions for Reflection

♦What unique values do you see in working with Stan from a feminist perspective as opposed to working from the other therapeutic approaches you’ve studied
thus far?

♦If you were to continue working with Stan, what self-statements regarding his view of himself as a man might you focus on, and what alternatives might you
offer?

♦In what ways could you integrate cognitive behavior therapy with feminist therapy in Stan’s case? What possibilities do you see for integrating Gestalt therapy
methods with feminist therapy? What other therapies might you combine with a feminist approach?

Feminist Therapy Applied to the Case of Gwen

Powerlessness is the theme I hear from Gwen at the beginning of this session. She talks about her sadness in seeing her granddaughter going through the same
things she experienced as a young girl. Gwen feels invisible and unappreciated. I want to help Gwen become aware of how gender-role socialization has influenced
her and help her reclaim her personal power.

Gwen: I can’t tell you how many times in one day I tell myself that I’m not worth anything.

Therapist: Give me an example of something that happens to you and the message you hear inside yourself.

Gwen: Well, in a meeting at work with the partners, I may make a suggestion about something we might do, but I’m ignored. Then Joe, this White guy, makes the
same suggestion with just a little twist and the partners are all over it.

Therapist: So your voice is ignored, but the White man gets heard. What do you tell yourself?

Gwen: I get really angry! If I say something, I am accused of “always making it about race.” Then I say to myself, “they are right because most of the time it is about
race.” I usually think, “here we go again!”

Therapist: Even though you push back against their message, a part of you believes them—that you are making too big a deal out of your voice being ignored.

Gwen: No, I don’t believe that. Some things are about being a woman of color and not being heard, and that’s just how it is. Society ignores it, but it is real. When
someone does not know what it’s like to be invisible and unheard, they are privileged! This is an old, tired story for me.

Therapist: What did you learn growing up about the value of your voice and your value as a girl and a young woman?

Gwen: I learned that boys were valued more than girls. I received the message that being a girl meant you were not strong enough, not smart enough, and that
you were required to be in the kitchen cleaning up after a meal.

I asked Gwen to write a gender-role analysis before our next session. In it she provides more information about the gender-role expectations in her home and in
her community as she was growing up. Gwen also writes about telling an adult that her older cousin had touched her inappropriately. She was told to be quiet
about the situation, and her sexual abuse was never spoken of again. Gwen learned early that her voice did not matter. In this session, I work toward validating
her experiences and the value of her voice. I acknowledge her pain and let her know that society has perpetuated this unequal and devaluing view of women and
girls globally.

Therapist: Gwen, I read your gender-role analysis thoroughly, and I really appreciate you trusting me with the information you shared.

Gwen: It was hard.

Therapist: I’m sure it was. I was especially struck with how early in your life you learned a lesson that too many girls learn—that your voice didn’t count and that
your body was not yours. I am so sorry that you had the experience of sexual abuse as a child [It is important to name the reality of her experience and not side-
step it].

Gwen: I don’t think I realized until this moment what a strong message was sent to me that day—the day I tried to share with my mother what had happened to
me.

Therapist: What message did you receive?

Gwen: My mother said, “Are you sure that happened? I think you are making it up to get him in trouble!”

COUN5239-Theories Page 7
Therapist: In a culture where males are valued more than females and where males have much more power than females, the response you got from your mother
is often given directly or indirectly to girls and women when they tell their truth about being abused.

Gwen: I thought my mother would believe me and would support me.

Therapist: You were and still are disappointed because your mother, a person you trusted, silenced you. And you’re confused about why she, as a woman, would
do this.

Gwen: Yes, I am.

Therapist: Keep in mind that your mother was raised in the same culture in which the men are raised. Women hear the same messages discounting females that
the men hear.

Gwen: You know, at work I get more angry at the women than at the men. When I’m being discounted and being told that I’m too angry and using the “race card,”
I rage more at the women than I do at the men.

Therapist: What do you think that is about?

Gwen: Perhaps it is that I’m more disappointed in the women for not standing with me. Or perhaps, like my mother, I value the men more. It really hurts me to
believe that might be true.

By placing Gwen’s issue in a larger societal context, she begins to understand that her experiences resonate with the experiences of other women. It helps her to
understand that she, too, might be working from a model of males being valued more than females. If she can get a clear understanding of this, she can move
more easily to a place of truly believing in her own value.

Gwen is a professional woman with an MBA from a prestigious university. She has had to continuously negotiate minefields of racism, sexism, and multiple forms
of inequality. Institutional racism perpetuates the oppression she has experienced and continues to experience, but she sees that using her voice might begin the
process of healing her personal wounds from this societal injustice. I discuss with Gwen the potential risks of using her voice (becoming more outspoken) in her
present professional environment.

Gwen: I’m really tired of feeling angry all the time, but I can tell you I’m also really tired of being treated as “less than.”

Therapist: Tell me more about your experiences of being treated as less than.

Gwen: If I raise my voice or express frustration at work—even if I’m not angry—I am told that I’m too emotional and too angry. I really feel that I’ve been labeled
“the angry black woman,” and no matter how appropriate I am with my frustration or with my voice, it is always seen as “there goes that angry black woman
again.”

Therapist: So, people at work have written this story about you—angry black woman—and many things that you do are filtered through the lens of that story.

Gwen: Yes, that’s right.

Therapist: Think about the times when you are appropriately speaking your mind and sharing your frustration. Tell me what words you use to describe yourself.

Gwen: [Pause] Sometimes I am angry, and I have a right to be, but I would say that I am being passionate and assertive.

Therapist: I really like that! How might it be for you to make sure that you restate in your own head that message: “Gwen, you are being passionate and assertive.”
This is a way to define yourself.

Gwen: It is definitely something I would like to do.

Therapist: You have walked a path cluttered with micro-aggressions for over 50 years, sometimes experiencing these toxic messages multiple times a day. As a
woman of color, you are bombarded with the messages from a culture that devalues people of color and women. We can draw on the strength of those who came
before us. We are standing on the shoulders of those who fought for our rights as people of color and as women. We know there is injustice in the fabric of our
society. What will you do to make changes that are important to you?

Gwen: [Listening intently and reflecting on ways she has been slighted] It feels good to talk about all this.

Therapist: You are an intelligent, passionate, creative, and strong woman. I’m wondering how you might use these parts of you to design your life to be more the
way you want it to be.

Gwen: I’m not sure. I do know that I want to be more proactive in my community and more patient with my mother. I’m learning that I still hold resentments from
my childhood, and I want to let that go.

Therapist: That sounds like a good place to start.

Gwen: I also want to make sure that I handle my voice and my frustration in the workplace appropriately.

Summary

COUN5239-Theories Page 8
 Summary
Feminist therapy challenges traditional therapy models by emphasizing:
- Viewing problems within a sociopolitical and cultural context
- Acknowledging clients as experts on their own lives
- Creating an egalitarian therapeutic relationship
- Including clients in all phases of assessment and treatment
- Recognizing unique experiences of marginalized groups
- Advocating for social change and empowerment

Feminist practice continues to evolve, aiming for personal and social change by promoting equality, diversity, and client empowerment. Therapists apply a range
of techniques, including gender-role analysis, power analysis, and advocacy, across various modalities to achieve these goals.

Contributions of Feminist Therapy and Multicultural and Social Justice Perspectives

Feminist therapy has significantly influenced counseling and psychotherapy by promoting gender-sensitive practice and awareness of **cultural context** and
**multiple oppressions**. It emphasizes social change, critiques traditional counseling theories, and advocates for addressing oppressive societal factors. Feminist
movement contributions include highlighting ethical issues like sexual misconduct and abuse in therapy, leading to changes in professional codes of ethics. Its
principles and techniques are applicable across various therapy models, fostering collaboration, empowerment, and demystifying therapy for clients.

Limitations and Criticisms of Feminist Counseling

Feminist therapists advocate for social change and aim to avoid imposing their values on clients, recognizing the need to address biases in therapy. They
encourage clients to examine their choices within the context of gender and culture but respect their autonomy in decision-making. However, challenges include
ensuring clients are informed and ready for change while balancing exploration of internal and external factors contributing to their issues. Training in feminist
therapy lacks standardization, and there's a need for research on its efficacy and recognition as an integrative approach in therapy.

Self-Reflection and Discussion Questions

1.What key concepts or principles of feminist therapy could you incorporate in your counseling practice regardless of your theoretical orientation?

2.Feminist therapists engage in self-disclosure only when it is judged to be therapeutically helpful to the client. How could you assess the degree to which your
personal disclosures are appropriate, timely, and helpful to your client?

3.Feminist therapy aims to include social change as well as individual change. How competent will you be in facilitating work with your clients in the area of social
action?

4.This approach to therapy places value on exploring issues of power, privilege, oppression, and discrimination. Do you see yourself as being comfortable with and
interested in exploring these facets with your clients?

5.A number of feminist therapy techniques are described in this chapter. What one technique do you find particularly interesting? Why?

Where to Go From Here:

Other Resources
- **APA DVDs**: Check out "Feminist Therapy Over Time" by L. S. Brown (2009) from the APA Psychotherapy Video Series.

- **Psychotherapy.net**: Visit www.psychotherapy.net for monthly updates on feminist therapy videos and interviews. Recommended DVDs include:
- "The Abused Woman: A Survivor Therapy Approach" by L. Walker (1994).
- "Feminist Therapy (Psychotherapy With the Experts Series)" by L. Walker (1997).

- **Jean Baker Miller Training Institute**: Explore workshops, courses, and resources on relational-cultural approach at www.wellesley.edu/JBMTI/.

- **APA Divisions**:
- Division 17: Counseling Psychology’s Section on Women - www.div17.org
- Division 35: Psychology of Women - www.apa.org/divisons/div35

- **Association for Women in Psychology (AWP)**: Attend their annual conference and engage with feminist contributions to psychology. Learn more at
www.awpsych.org.

- **Psychology of Women Resource List (POWR)**: Join discussions on women's psychology by subscribing to POWR-L. Send a subscription request to
[email protected] with the command "Subscribe POWR-L Your name".

- **University Programs**:
- University of Kentucky: Counseling women and feminist therapy is offered as a minor specialty. Contact Dr. Pam Remer at
www.uky.edu/Education/edphead.html.
- Texas Women’s University: Explore training programs focusing on women's issues, gender issues, and family psychology at
www.twu.edu/as/psyphil/Counseling_Home.htm.

Recommended Supplementary Readings for Chapter 12

• Feminist Perspectives in Therapy: Empowering Diverse Women (Worell & Remer, 2003) is an outstanding text that clearly outlines the foundations of empowerment in feminist
therapy. The book covers a range of topics: integrating feminist and multicultural perspectives on therapy, changing roles for women, feminist views of counseling practice,

COUN5239-Theories Page 9
 therapy. The book covers a range of topics: integrating feminist and multicultural perspectives on therapy, changing roles for women, feminist views of counseling practice,
feminist transformation of counseling theories, and a feminist approach to assessment and diagnosis. There also are excellent chapters dealing with depression, surviving sexual
assault, confronting abuse, choosing a career path, and lesbian and ethnic minority women.

• Oxford Handbook of Feminist Multicultural Counseling Psychology (Enns & Williams, 2013) is a 26-chapter handbook that integrates feminist and multicultural scholarship and
applies the perspective to a variety of women’s diverse identities related to race/ethnicity, social class, disability, religion, culture, and so forth. Multiple chapters focus on the
practice of feminist multicultural therapy, pedagogy, mentoring, and social advocacy.

• Psychological Practice With Women: Guidelines, Diversity, Empowerment (Enns et al., 2015) discusses the assessment of women’s social identities and diversity and features
chapters that focus on psychotherapy with African American women; Latinas; Asian American and Pacific Islander women; Native American women; lesbian, bisexual, and
transgender women; women with disabilities; and women in transnational practice. Each chapter includes the application of the APA (2007) guidelines through one or more case
studies.

• Feminist Therapy (Brown, 2018) provides an interesting perspective on the history of feminist therapy and speculates about future developments of the approach. Brown clearly
explains key concepts of feminist theory and the therapeutic process.

• Introduction to Feminist Therapy: Strategies for Social and Individual Change (Evans et al., 2011) emphasizes the practical applications of feminist theory to clinical practice. They
provide useful information on social change and empowerment, the importance of establishing an egalitarian relationship, and intervention strategies when working with people
from diverse cultural backgrounds.

COUN5239-Theories Page 10