CA/HQ/EPT/Vol.
II/110
Tuesday, 2nd May, 2023
The Presiding Judge
Election Petition Tribunal
Abia State, Nigeria.
My Lord,
SENATOR MAO OHUABUNNA (PDP) VS ORJI UZOR KALU (APC)
ABIA NORTH SENATORIAL DISTRICT
I am directed by the Hon. President of Court of Appeal HON. JUSTICE M.B.
DONGBAN – MENSEN to inform you that conflicting judgment on similar facts had
dogged judicial decisions following judicial determination of election and pre-
election disputes in the past.
We are similarly in the wake of another election circle and attendant judicial
determination and it behooves us to craft a feedback system that will minimize
such conflicting judgments as it does not paint the judiciary in good light.
It is having regard to this that the Hon. President of Court of appeal has directed
that her office be informed of any decision in respect of the above subject matter
before they are delivered. Having access to judgments before they are delivered
will enable us feedback on existing Judgment (if any) on the same or similar point
of law, and will aid you in coming to decisions that will reflect a cohesion of Legal
approach instead of the conflicting judgments on similar facts that had be-deviled
our justice administration particularly on political cases.
While looking forward to your cooperation on this directive please, be assured of
our esteemed regard and kind consideration.
ADAMU M. ALIYU
Deputy Director
Election Petition Tribunal (EPT)
CA/HQ/EPT/Vol. II/114
Tuesday, 2nd May, 2023
The Presiding Judge
Election Petition Tribunal
Abia State, Nigeria.
My Lord,
NKIRUKA ONYEJUOCHA (APC) VS AMOBI ORGAH (LP)
UMUNNEOCHI / ISUIKWUATO FEDERAL CONSTITUENCY
I am directed by the Hon. President of Court of Appeal HON. JUSTICE M.B.
DONGBAN – MENSEN to inform you that conflicting judgment on similar facts had
dogged judicial decisions following judicial determination of election and pre-
election disputes in the past.
We are similarly in the wake of another election circle and attendant judicial
determination and it behooves us to craft a feedback system that will minimize
such conflicting judgments as it does not paint the judiciary in good light.
It is having regard to this that the Hon. President of Court of appeal has directed
that her office be informed of any decision in respect of the above subject matter
before they are delivered. Having access to judgments before they are delivered
will enable us feedback on existing Judgment (if any) on the same or similar point
of law, and will aid you in coming to decisions that will reflect a cohesion of Legal
approach instead of the conflicting judgments on similar facts that had be-deviled
our justice administration particularly on political cases.
While looking forward to your cooperation on this directive please, be assured of
our esteemed regard and kind consideration.
ADAMU M. ALIYU
Deputy Director
Election Petition Tribunal (EPT)
CA/HQ/EPT/Vol. II/121
Tuesday, 2nd May, 2023
The Presiding Judge
Election Petition Tribunal
Anambra State, Nigeria.
My Lord,
CHRIS UBAH (PDP) VS IFEANYI UBAH (YPP)
ANAMBRA SOUTH SENATORIAL DISTRICT
I am directed by the Hon. President of Court of Appeal HON. JUSTICE M.B.
DONGBAN – MENSEN to inform you that conflicting judgment on similar facts had
dogged judicial decisions following judicial determination of election and pre -
election disputes in the past.
We are similarly in the wake of another election circle and attendant judicial
determination and it behooves us to craft a feedback system that will minimize
such conflicting judgments as it does not paint the judiciary in good light.
It is having regard to this that the Hon. President of Court of appeal has directed
that her office be in formed of any decision in respect of the above subject matter
before they are delivered. Having access to judgments before they are delivered
will enable us feedback on existing Judgment (if any) on the same or similar point
of law, and will aid you in com ing to decisions that will reflect a cohesion of Legal
approach instead of the conflicting judgments on similar facts that had be -deviled
our justice administration particularly on political cases.
While looking forward to your cooperation on this directiv e please, be assured of
our esteemed regard and kind consideration.
ADAMU M. ALIYU
Deputy Director
Election Petition Tribunal (EPT)
CA/HQ/EPT/Vol. II/125
Tuesday, 2nd May, 2023
The Presiding Judge
Election Petition Tribunal
Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria.
My Lord,
MAXWELL OKOYE (APC) VS PROF. OBY LILLIAN OROGBU (LP)
EPT/AWK/HR17/2023
I am directed by the Hon. President of Court of Appeal HON. JUSTICE M.B.
DONGBAN – MENSEN to inform you that conflicting judgment on similar facts had
dogged judicial decisions following judicial determination of election and pre-
election disputes in the past.
We are similarly in the wake of another election circle and attendant judicial
determination and it behooves us to craft a feedback system that will minimize
such conflicting judgments as it does not paint the judiciary in good light.
It is having regard to this that the Hon. President of Court of appeal has directed
that her office be informed of any decision in respect of the above subject matter
before they are delivered. Having access to judgments before they are delivered
will enable us feedback on existing Judgment (if any) on the same or similar point
of law, and will aid you in coming to decisions that will reflect a cohesion of Legal
approach instead of the conflicting judgments on similar facts that had be-deviled
our justice administration particularly on political cases.
While looking forward to your cooperation on this directive please, be assured of
our esteemed regard and kind consideration.
ADAMU M. ALIYU
Deputy Director
Election Petition Tribunal (EPT)
CA/HQ/EPT/Vol. II/128
Tuesday, 2nd May, 2023
The Presiding Judge
Election Petition Tribunal
Imo State, Nigeria.
My Lord,
CHARLES UGOCHUKWU AHIZE (LP) VS OSITA IZUNASO (APC)
IMO WEST SENATORIAL DISTRICT
I am directed by the Hon. President of Court of Appeal HON. JUSTICE M.B.
DONGBAN – MENSEN to inform you that conflicting judgment on similar facts had
dogged judicial decisions following judicial determination of election and pre-
election disputes in the past.
We are similarly in the wake of another election circle and attendant judicial
determination and it behooves us to craft a feedback system that will minimize
such conflicting judgments as it does not paint the judiciary in good light.
It is having regard to this that the Hon. President of Court of appeal has directed
that her office be informed of any decision in respect of the above subject matter
before they are delivered. Having access to judgments before they are delivered
will enable us feedback on existing Judgment (if any) on the same or similar point
of law, and will aid you in coming to decisions that will reflect a cohesion of Legal
approach instead of the conflicting judgments on similar facts that had be-deviled
our justice administration particularly on political cases.
While looking forward to your cooperation on this directive please, be assured of
our esteemed regard and kind consideration.
ADAMU M. ALIYU
Deputy Director
Election Petition Tribunal (EPT)
CA/HQ/EPT/Vol. II/130
Tuesday, 2nd May, 2023
The Presiding Judge
Election Petition Tribunal
Imo State, Nigeria.
My Lord,
CHUKWUEMEKA AHANEKU (LP) VS INNOCENT IKPAMEZIE (APC)
MBAITOLI HOUSE OF ASSEMBLY
I am directed by the Hon. President of Court of Appeal HON. JUSTICE M.B.
DONGBAN – MENSEN to inform you that conflicting judgment on similar facts had
dogged judicial decisions following judicial determination of election and pre-
election disputes in the past.
We are similarly in the wake of another election circle and attendant judicial
determination and it behooves us to craft a feedback system that will minimize
such conflicting judgments as it does not paint the judiciary in good light.
It is having regard to this that the Hon. President of Court of appeal has directed
that her office be informed of any decision in respect of the above subject matter
before they are delivered. Having access to judgments before they are delivered
will enable us feedback on existing Judgment (if any) on the same or similar point
of law, and will aid you in coming to decisions that will reflect a cohesion of Legal
approach instead of the conflicting judgments on similar facts that had be-deviled
our justice administration particularly on political cases.
While looking forward to your cooperation on this directive please, be assured of
our esteemed regard and kind consideration.
ADAMU M. ALIYU
Deputy Director
Election Petition Tribunal (EPT)
CA/HQ/EPT/Vol. II/132
Tuesday, 2nd May, 2023
The Presiding Judge
Election Petition Tribunal
Imo State, Nigeria.
My Lord,
CHIKWEM ONUOHA (LP) VS MIRIAM ODINAKA OWOHA (APC)
ISIALA MBANO / ONUIMO FEDERAL CONSTITUENCY
EPT/IM/HR/9/2023
I am directed by the Hon. President of Court of Appeal HON. JUSTICE M.B.
DONGBAN – MENSEN to inform you that conflicting judgment on similar facts had
dogged judicial decisions following judicial determination of election and pre-
election disputes in the past.
We are similarly in the wake of another election circle and attendant judicial
determination and it behooves us to craft a feedback system that will minimize
such conflicting judgments as it does not paint the judiciary in good light.
It is having regard to this that the Hon. President of Court of appeal has directed
that her office be informed of any decision in respect of the above subject matter
before they are delivered. Having access to judgments before they are delivered
will enable us feedback on existing Judgment (if any) on the same or similar point
of law, and will aid you in coming to decisions that will reflect a cohesion of Legal
approach instead of the conflicting judgments on similar facts that had be-deviled
our justice administration particularly on political cases.
While looking forward to your cooperation on this directive please, be assured of
our esteemed regard and kind consideration.
ADAMU M. ALIYU
Deputy Director
Election Petition Tribunal (EPT)
CA/HQ/EPT/Vol. II/135
Tuesday, 2nd May, 2023
The Presiding Judge
Election Petition Tribunal
Enugu State, Nigeria.
My Lord,
BARR. JONATHAN CHIJIOKE EDEOGA (LP) VS PETER MBAH (PDP)
ENUGU STATE GOVERNORSHIP
I am directed by the Hon. President of Court of Appeal HON. JUSTICE M.B.
DONGBAN – MENSEN to inform you that conflicting judgment on similar facts had
dogged judicial decisions following judicial determination of election and pre-
election disputes in the past.
We are similarly in the wake of another election circle and attendant judicial
determination and it behooves us to craft a feedback system that will minimize
such conflicting judgments as it does not paint the judiciary in good light.
It is having regard to this that the Hon. President of Court of appeal has directed
that her office be informed of any decision in respect of the above subject matter
before they are delivered. Having access to judgments before they are delivered
will enable us feedback on existing Judgment (if any) on the same or similar point
of law, and will aid you in coming to decisions that will reflect a cohesion of Legal
approach instead of the conflicting judgments on similar facts that had be-deviled
our justice administration particularly on political cases.
While looking forward to your cooperation on this directive please, be assured of
our esteemed regard and kind consideration.
ADAMU M. ALIYU
Deputy Director
Election Petition Tribunal (EPT)
CA/HQ/EPT/Vol. II/138
Tuesday, 2nd May, 2023
The Presiding Judge
Election Petition Tribunal
Enugu State, Nigeria.
My Lord,
PRINCE CORNELIUS NNAEDOZIE NNAJI (PDP) VS PROF. NNAMCHI PAUL SUNDAY (LP)
ENUGU EAST / ISI UZO FEDERAL CONSTITUENCY
I am directed by the Hon. President of Court of Appeal HON. JUSTICE M.B.
DONGBAN – MENSEN to inform you that conflicting judgment on similar facts had
dogged judicial decisions following judicial determination of election and pre-
election disputes in the past.
We are similarly in the wake of another election circle and attendant judicial
determination and it behooves us to craft a feedback system that will minimize
such conflicting judgments as it does not paint the judiciary in good light.
It is having regard to this that the Hon. President of Court of appeal has directed
that her office be informed of any decision in respect of the above subject matter
before they are delivered. Having access to judgments before they are delivered
will enable us feedback on existing Judgment (if any) on the same or similar point
of law, and will aid you in coming to decisions that will reflect a cohesion of Legal
approach instead of the conflicting judgments on similar facts that had be-deviled
our justice administration particularly on political cases.
While looking forward to your cooperation on this directive please, be assured of
our esteemed regard and kind consideration.
ADAMU M. ALIYU
Deputy Director
Election Petition Tribunal (EPT)
