MODULE TWO
BEHAVIORAL MANAGEMENT THEORY:
Behavioral Management Theory, also known as the Human Relations Movement, is a
management approach that emerged in the early 20th century as a response to classical
management theories, particularly Scientific Management and Administrative Management.
Behavioral Management Theory focuses on understanding and managing human behavior in the
workplace to improve employee motivation, productivity, and job satisfaction. It emphasizes the
social and psychological aspects of work and the importance of considering human factors in
organizational management. Key aspects of Behavioral Management Theory include:
Hawthorne Studies
The Hawthorne Studies represent a pivotal moment in the history of management and
organizational psychology. Conducted at the Western Electric Hawthorne Works in Chicago
between 1924 and 1932, these studies transformed our understanding of human behavior in the
workplace and continue to shape modern management practices.
Definition
The Hawthorne Studies refer to a series of experiments and investigations conducted at the
Western Electric Hawthorne Works by researchers, primarily Elton Mayo and Fritz
Roethlisberger, in the 1920s and 1930s. These studies aimed to understand how various factors,
such as lighting, work hours, and group dynamics, influenced employee productivity and
satisfaction.
Key Contributors
1. Elton Mayo (1880-1949): Elton Mayo, an Australian psychologist and sociologist, is often
regarded as the father of the Hawthorne Studies. He played a central role in designing and
interpreting the experiments conducted at the Hawthorne Works. Mayo's work emphasized the
importance of social and psychological factors in influencing employee behavior and
productivity.
1
2. Fritz Roethlisberger (1898-1974): a Harvard sociologist collaborated with Mayo and made
significant contributions to the Hawthorne Studies. He co-authored the landmark book
"Management and the Worker" and conducted extensive fieldwork at the Hawthorne Works,
focusing on the human aspects of work.
Findings
1. Illumination Studies: One of the earliest experiments in the Hawthorne Studies examined the
impact of lighting on productivity. Surprisingly, productivity increased when lighting levels were
both increased and decreased. The findings suggested that the mere act of being observed and
involved in the study improved worker morale and productivity—a phenomenon known as the
Hawthorne Effect.
2. Relay Assembly Test Rooms Studies: These studies, led by Roethlisberger and William J.
Dickson, focused on a group of female workers who assembled telephone relays. Researchers
found that the group's output and satisfaction improved significantly when they were allowed to
set their own production targets and have a say in decision-making. This highlighted the
importance of social interactions and participative management in boosting productivity.
3. Bank Wiring Room Studies: This study investigated a group of male workers wiring bank
components. Again, social factors played a significant role. When workers were left to regulate
their own work and were part of a cohesive group, productivity and job satisfaction increased.
The findings underscored the importance of peer pressure and group dynamics in influencing
employee behavior.
Implication for Management
1. Social and Psychological Factors: The Hawthorne Studies demonstrated that employees'
social and psychological needs significantly affect their job satisfaction and productivity.
Managers must consider these factors when designing work environments and policies.
2. Participative Management: Allowing employees to participate in decision-making and
giving them some autonomy can enhance job satisfaction and performance.
2
3. Recognition and Feedback: Providing recognition and feedback to employees can motivate
them and improve their performance.
4. Group Dynamics: Understanding and managing group dynamics is crucial for creating a
positive work environment and boosting productivity.
Criticisms
1. Methodological Limitations: Critics argue that the Hawthorne Studies had methodological
flaws, such as inadequate control groups and biased observations, which may have influenced
the results.
2. Generalizability: Some argue that the findings may not be universally applicable to all
organizations and industries, as the studies were conducted in a specific context (manufacturing).
Relevance in Contemporary Organizations
1. Human-Centered Approach: The Hawthorne Studies laid the foundation for a human-
centered approach to management, emphasizing the importance of employee well-being and
motivation. This approach remains relevant today as organizations seek to create inclusive and
employee-friendly workplaces.
2. Employee Engagement: The studies highlighted the significance of employee engagement,
which remains a crucial concept in contemporary organizations. Engaged employees are more
productive and committed to their work.
3. Teamwork and Collaborations: The emphasis on group dynamics and teamwork in the
studies is highly relevant in today's collaborative work environments.
4. Organizational Culture: The Hawthorne Studies highlighted the role of organizational
culture in influencing employee behavior. Modern organizations place great importance on
shaping positive cultures to attract and retain talent.
3
Abraham Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs
Abraham Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs is a psychological theory that explains human motivation
and satisfaction. It is widely applied in various fields, including management and organizational
psychology, to understand and motivate employees effectively. The theory posits that individuals
have a set of innate needs arranged in a hierarchical manner, and they must satisfy lower-level
needs before progressing to higher-level ones. The hierarchy is often represented as a pyramid,
with five levels of needs from the most basic to the most advanced. It is widely applied in
various fields, including management and organizational psychology, to understand and motivate
employees effectively.
Key Concepts
1. Psychological Needs (Basic Needs): These are the most fundamental needs, including air,
food, water, shelter, and sleep. Until these needs are met, individuals cannot focus on higher-
level needs.
2. Safety Needs: Once physiological needs are satisfied, individuals seek safety and security.
This includes physical safety, job security, health, and financial stability.
3. Social Needs: Social needs come next, emphasizing the importance of relationships,
friendship, family, and a sense of belonging.
4. Esteem Needs: Esteem needs encompass self-esteem and the need for respect and recognition
from others. Both internal self-worth and external recognition are important.
5. Self-Actualization Needs: At the peak of the hierarchy is self-actualization, where individuals
strive to reach their full potential, sought personal growth, creativity, and fulfillment.
Application in Motivating Employees:
1 Understanding Employee Motivation: Managers can use Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs to
understand what motivates employees at different levels. Recognizing that employees may have
varying needs can help tailor motivational strategies.
4
2 Meeting Basic Needs: Ensure that employees have fair compensation, job security, and safe
working conditions (safety and physiological needs). Provide adequate breaks and support for
work-life balance (physiological needs).
3. Fostering a Sense of Belongingness: Encourage team building and social interactions within
the workplace (love and belongingness needs). Create a positive work culture that promotes
inclusivity and collaboration.
4 Recognizing and Rewarding Achievement: Recognize and reward employees for their
accomplishments (esteem needs). Offer opportunities for skill development and advancement.
5 Encouraging Personal Growth: Support employees in pursuing their career goals and
personal development (self-actualization needs). Provide opportunities for employees to take on
challenging projects and express their creativity.
Criticisms
1 Cultural Variation: Critics argue that the hierarchy may not apply universally across all
cultures, as cultural values can influence the prioritization of needs.
2 Overemphasis on Individualism: Some critics contend that Maslow's theory places too much
emphasis on individual needs and neglects the importance of collective and societal factors.
3 Lack of Empirical Evidence: The theory has faced criticism for its limited empirical support,
with some researchers finding inconsistencies in the hierarchy's structure.
Relevance in Contemporary Organizations
1 Employee Well-being: Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs remains relevant in contemporary
organizations as they increasingly focus on employee well-being and holistic development.
2 Personalized Management: It encourages a personalized approach to employee management,
recognizing that different employees may have varying needs.
3 Career Development: The theory supports the idea of promoting career growth and self-
actualization, which aligns with contemporary emphasis on professional development and
growth opportunities.
5
McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y
Introduction
Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y are two contrasting approaches to understanding
and managing employees. These theories have had a profound influence on management
practices and continue to shape contemporary organizational thinking.
Theory Overview and Assumptions:
1. Theory X:
Assumptions: Employees inherently dislike work and will avoid it if they can. Employees must
be closely controlled, directed, or coerced to achieve organizational goals. Most people prefer to
be directed, avoid responsibility, have little ambition, and primarily seek security.
Management Implications:
Use strict control and coercion to ensure compliance.
Supervise and micromanage employees.
Establish a rigid organizational structure.
1.2 Theory Y:
Assumptions: Work is as natural as play or rest for most people. People will exercise self-
direction and self-control if they are committed to the objectives. Employees can be creative and
innovative when solving organizational problems. The capacity for creativity, ingenuity, and
intelligence in solving organizational problems is widely dispersed throughout the population.
Management Implications:
Empower and trust employees to make decisions.
Encourage employees to take ownership and responsibility for their work.
Foster a flexible and collaborative work environment.
6
Implications for Management Styles and Employee Engagement:
1 Theory X Management Style:
Management Style:
Autocratic and directive.
Emphasis on tight control.
Limited employee involvement in decision-making.
Employee Engagement:
Low job satisfaction.
Resistance to authority.
Lack of creativity and innovation.
High turnover and absenteeism.
2 Theory Y Management Style:
Management Style:
Participative and collaborative.
Trust in employees' abilities.
Encouragement of employee autonomy.
Employee Engagement:
High job satisfaction.
Willingness to take initiative.
Creativity and innovation.
Lower turnover and absenteeism.
7
Criticisms:
1 Oversimplification: Critics argue that McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y oversimplify
human behavior and motivation by categorizing people into two rigid categories.
2 Cultural Variations: The theories may not apply uniformly across all cultures, as cultural
values can influence management and employee behavior.
3 Limited Consideration of External Factors: The theories do not adequately address external
factors (e.g., economic conditions, market dynamics) that can impact employee behavior.
Relevance in Contemporary Organizations:
1 Leadership and Management Styles: McGregor's theories continue to be relevant in guiding
leadership and management styles. Organizations are increasingly adopting Theory Y principles
to foster more inclusive, collaborative, and empowering workplaces.
2 Employee Engagement: Theory Y aligns with contemporary efforts to enhance employee
engagement, job satisfaction, and overall well-being. It supports the idea that motivated and
engaged employees are more productive.
3 Organizational Culture: Theory Y principles contribute to the development of positive
organizational cultures that value employee contributions, foster innovation, and promote a sense
of ownership.
4 Flexibility and Adaptation: In a rapidly changing business landscape, Theory Y's emphasis
on employee creativity and problem-solving aligns with the need for organizations to be
adaptable and innovative.
