Anthropocentric Urbanity in Ngugi's Implications For Environmental Discourses in Africa
Anthropocentric Urbanity in Ngugi's Implications For Environmental Discourses in Africa
Abstract
This study examines the factors responsible for environmental exploitation in Ngugi wa Thiongo’s
Matigari. Ecocriticism from the standpoint of Lawrence Buell’s position is used as theoretical
framework in this study because it centres on anthropocentric attitudes that are considered inimical for
the environment while the interpretive design is adopted for critical analysis. Ngugi’s Matigari is
selected because it reflects on ecological concerns and depicts the motif of exploited urbanity and
environmental frictions. Through Ngugi’s Matigari, the reader is shown the intricacies and
conspiracies that create socio-ecological imbalances in the society. There is a sharp environmental
contrast between the exploiters and the exploited which foregrounds the significance and urgency of
Ngugi’s intervention. Conspiracies between the privileged locals and the settlers distort and violate
environmental harmony in a way that provokes tension inimical to ecological regeneration and social
tranquility. The text studied submits that environmental rot is largely man-made. In the novel, Ngugi
cautions against activities that are inimical to environmental purity and harmony. Key words: Ngugi
wa Thiong’o, novels, exploitation, ecocriticism, Ecological violations, African novel, Matigari.
1
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
2
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
3
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
4
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
the betrayal and the conspiracies of the analyzing and interpreting data through the
settlers and the privileged locals on the employment of words and concepts. It
issues of land. Ngugi who is among the therefore entails a critical and an in-depth
foremost writers in Kenya occupies a very detailed analytical investigation of the
vantage and dominant position in the primary data in Ngugi’s Matigari. The
interpretation of ecological matters in study also employs ecocriticism as its
Kenya. He is one of the Kenyan and theoretical and analytical framework.
African writers who has seen it all and
therefore can be regarded as an authority Review of Related Literature
on Kenyan environmental discourse. Apart
from his writings, Ngugi also has a In what is regarded as a very significant
personal experience on the imbalances of and wide-ranging survey of pastoralism in
land management issues in Kenya which American literary criticism, Lawrence
amplifies the authority of his narratives. Buell (1995) explores the experience of
American pastoralists in a variety of issues
The research undertakes a detailed analysis and contexts to include social, political,
of Ngugi’s Matigari. It is pertinent to note gender-based aesthetic pragmatic and
that land and eco-social politics are the environmental discourse. He pays greater
most central issues in the historical attention to the emergent threat of
development of Kenya, and no discourse ecological holocaust, and sees
and narrative is complete without them environmental pressures that come with
(Veit P,2019:2). It is therefore safe to posit the importance of pastoralism as a literary
that socio-political and economy issues and cultural force in the future. Buell in his
and politics in Kenya are centred on land seminal book, The Environmental
and the control of environmental Imagination (1995), submits that the study
resources. The text is therefore, selected “must be conducted in a spirit of
because it captures the eco-social and commitment to environmentalist praxis”
environmental issues in Kenya and the (12). His work is regarded as very primary
attendant crisis. It is also anchored on the to ecocriticism. Buell’s ecocritical
fact that Ngugi’s writings reflect and approach can be seen in his outstanding
refract largely on the resistance and work on Henry David Thoreau, which
counter resistance that have defined the interprets Thoreau’s nature writing and the
Kenyan land struggle and the quest for formation of American culture.
environmental justice and purity. Ngugi’s
choice is anchored on the fact that he best Timothy Morton in his book, Ecology
captures the ecological issue the study is without Nature: Rethinking Environmental
undertaken to explore. Ngugi’s works Aesthetics (2007) complements Buell’s
convey the thematic concern and the work by focusing his discussion on the
principles of ecocriticism this study is all nature of nature in ecocriticism. Morton
about, which is the exploration of documents the changing definition of the
ecological and environmental degradation word “nature” and echoing Buell to a
of urban cities and crisis in Kenya and the certain extent, suggests that nature can be
various ways it is encountered in the anything. Similar to Gotfelty, Richard
novel. Kerridge in, Writing the Environment:
Ecocriticism and Literature (1998) notes
The research uses the descriptive that:
interpretative design which explores the
subject matter under discussion by
5
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
6
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
7
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
sound the argument seems to be Ngugi Matigari is shocked to see how the
takes an increasingly uncompromising children of Kenya and animals scrambled
stance in the quest to take the land and its for the rubbish from the market and the
resources back. factories. To him, this is not only
environmental disaster; it is also
Matigari seems to concern himself with humanitarian degradation and crisis.
oppression faced by the peasants and Having witnessed the deaths and
workers. He resolutely feels that those who sufferings of Kenyans during the invasion
sow are alone qualified to enjoy the full of the imperialists and the violation of
use of the benefits and fruits of their environmental purity,
labour. To the tillers of the land and the
owners of the lands, independence is …his thoughts
nothing but a mirage because their now turned to
sufferings just got multiplied and the the railway and
hopes of land restoration completely the tunnel. He
dashed. Their labour is like nectar in a shivered. How
many lives had
sieve. The non-colonial Kenyan people are been claimed by
ecologically exploited. After fighting the the railway and
colonial rule in the forest, Matigari comes the tunnel at the
back to discover that injustice and time they were
oppression still exists in different ways in built? He
the realms of eco-social order. Despite his remembered the
earlier resolve to put on a belt of peace, he explosions of
decides to go back to the forest and fight dynamite and the
for the restoration of environmental justice screams of the
of his fellow Kenyans. This is as a result workers
of what he comes to understand as what is whenever the
walls caved in
going on since his return to build his home
often burying
(Kenya). To his utter amazement each them alive. And
child; the groans, as
some were
… had to pay a flattened by the
fee to enter. A rollers, came
ticket to enable back to him so
them fight it out vividly… the
with dogs, blood curdling
vultures, rats, all cries of the
sorts of dying…
scavengers and swallowing up
vermin, for the tea-leaves,
pieces of strings, the coffee, the
patches of cloth, cotton, the sisal,
odd bits of the wheat. In
leather, shoe, fact, all the
soles, rubber produce from all
bands, threads, the land that
rotten tomatoes, settler William
sugarcane chaff, and his like had
banana pads, stolen from the
bones… people (8).
anything (11)!
8
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
These memories above coupled with what In Weep Not, Child, Jacobo attempts to
he is seeing provoke him into action with subdue Ngotho brutally and hinders the
“armed words” otherwise the land and its early attempts of the black natives to get
resources will not be restored to the back their occupied lands. The cruel ways
people. Matigari’s resolve is predicated on of the askaris (home guards) during the
the fact that the Kenyans who are emergent era of Mau Mau to subdue the
supposed to distribute food and produce natives are depicted clearly in Weep Not,
from the land, market and factories among Child, A Grain of Wheat, Petals of Blood,
themselves have become terribly selfish and Devil on the Cross. This is similar to
that they even prefer to share the waste Matigari, which mainly deals with the
with animals and children at a cost. This is Kenyan elite who has mastered the
unacceptable to Matigari. settlers’ ways of defrauding the people of
their lands and environmental resources.
The pain of Matigari and by extension Ngugi’s focus on Matigari is to depict the
Ngugi himself is such that the black suffering, struggle and the revolt of
exploiters have become more brutal than Kenyans against ecological exploitation
the White settlers. He becomes very and deprivation, both in the hands of
critical of the evidence of the pact they White settlers and their native
(the Whites and their local agents) entered collaborators who have reduced the
with one another to perpetually subjugate independence gains of the people to what
the natives. After independence, the local they can find from refuse dumpsites.
agents modified the pact which made them “Yes…these are our gains, the things we
become worse than the Whites in the found in the pit” (13). It is shocking to still
violation of the land and the dispossession find out that the people are not even
of its resources. allowed the good things they get from the
dumpsite as they are deprived of them,
One of the greatest challenges of education “when they see that we’ve found things
in Kenya is that instead of using it as an like shoes, belts, pieces of leathers or cloth
avenue to reclaim the land for the people, in good condition, they pretend to get
the educated class only appropriates the angry, and they growl at us” (13). “They”
land for themselves. This point is raised here stands for the agents of the oppressive
earlier and in so doing, they perpetuate the and depraved class while “us” are the
ecological disaster brought about by the children who represent the deprived
rampaging imperialists. This is the main Kenyans. It is shocking to Ngugi that
worry and concern for Ngugi in his children in his native Kenya,
ecologically-driven thematic thrust. Ngugi metaphorically pay to enter garbage sites
shows how the early pro-western to scavenge for rubbish instead of enjoying
education and religious natives in an the produce which the fertility of their land
attempt to prove how good Christians they offers. Passivity has taken a better
are and how valuable western education is, advantage of the people, when Matigari
have tried to suppress ruthlessly their own comes to the rescue to save his scattered
native customs than even the settlers have and deprived children, having spent his life
done. For instance, in The River Between, in the struggle with the settlers
a particular set of people, mainly the (imperialists) in “the forests, mountains,
natives who accept the new religion on the valleys, ditches, caves, plains, rivers, hills,
pretext of sustaining their native traditions all over the country” (15). This portrays
exploit the unsuspecting public for their the fact that the settlers spare nowhere in
selfish ends thereby violating the sanctity Kenyan environment and resources in the
of the land. course of the plundering.
9
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
10
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
vastness of the plantation makes them and foreigners! Therefore, the tiller must
wonder if it actually belongs to one person reap what he sows” (63). With this, Ngugi
and for a whole day, they are walking and sounds a revolutionary warning to the
seem lost inside the plantation; “… they violators of Kenyan’s ecosystem. Using
decided to walk down between the rows of ecological metaphors to drive his point, he
the tea-bushes… they walked and walked also calls on the people not to relent thus;
and walked down the slope, but they were “…farmer whose seeds have not
still nowhere near the end of the estate. germinated does not give up planting”
One ridge simply gave way to the next” (64). Therefore, a person who seeks
(41). environmental justice is never tired of the
search until he finds it. He is strongly of
Though Ngugi seems to have braced up for the opinion that the products of “our
the consequences of his literary action, he labour should go back to us who produce
is of the opinion that it is high time people the wealth of this country” (74). This
demanded the restoration of the land to the suggests that Ngugi’s concern is centred
rightful owners through revolutionary on the restoration of the land and its allied
means. His main character in Matigari resources to the people. He considers
braces up to undertake the act of restoring armed resistance as the only option for
the land and its resources to the ancestral lifting the Kenyans out of poverty and
owners. He says, “The builder demands slavery on their own land. The search for
back his house, and the tiller his land… ecological justice and truth which is the
For, from this day on, the builder refuses major concern of Ngugi in Matigari is to
to beg for a place where he can lay his be looked into with ecological
head; the tiller refuses to starve…” (46). consciousness: “… in the grass in the
From the decision of Matigari to reclaim bushes. He searched among the thorns, in
the land and its resources to the owners, the shrubs, the ditches and the molehills,
Ngugi seems to have set the stage for and in bud nests. He searches for them in
confrontation with the settlers which is not the whole nature” (86). This brings the
likely to be a tea party. This is a significant ecological angle to resolving the land
departure from the beginning of his alienation of the Kenyans.
narratives where most of his characters are
indifferent to real resistance against land As the resistance culture grows which is
alienation. arises from the awareness Matigari is
creating, reasons are adduced why the
Matigari therefore, begins his real settlers should not be allowed to enjoy the
questioning of the deprivation of his sweat and the land resources of the people.
people’s resources and environmental Songs of resistance are composed by
justice by asserting that “…the land Matigari to awaken the weakened spirit of
belongs to the tiller and not to parasites the Kenyans:
With this song in mind, Ngugi argues that African neo-colonial business class is
the imperial tradition is maintained by the reflected in its culture of parrotry as
international bourgeoisie using the portrayed in Matigari. This is brutally
multinational and the local compradors. enforced on restive Kenyans through
The economic and political reliance of the police boots, barbed wire, a compromised
11
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
clergy and corrupt judiciary, as echoed because killing of animals is violating the
strongly by Matigari thus: purity of the environment and the
ecological resources, as animals are part of
The house is their restoration struggle:
mine because I
built it. The land … animals are
is mine too man’s friends?
because I tilled it When we were
with these hands. in the forest, we
The industries never killed any
are mine because animal at any
my labour built cost unless we
and worked were and had run
them. I shall out of food.
never stop Even when we
struggling for all came across an
the products of injured animal,
my sweat. I shed we would mend
blood and I did their broken
not shed it in limbs. Animals
vain. One day were very useful
the land will to us… if you
return to the stay in the
tiller, and the forests and
wealth of our mountains for a
land to those long time; you
who produce it. get to learn how
Poverty and to talk to them.
sorrow shall be Sometimes, the
banished from animals talk to
our land (124). you. You just
remain silent,
This is a demonstration of the fact that the listening to them
end of poverty and sorrow of the Kenyan (143).
people is connected and tied to the
restoration of the land and its resources The above suggests that even animals are
hence, the demand for environmental against the dispossession of the land by
justice by Matigari. He resolves that in the settlers hence, their cooperation with the
pursuit of the restoration of his people’s fighters for the restoration of land to the
land neither arms nor words alone can dispossessed. This amplifies the fact that
restore the environmental justice but “one the culture of resistance pervades and
had to be armed with armed words” (31) to arouses the feelings of both human and
make it possible. The resistance tradition is non-human objects in Kenya.
being carried out by the army of informed
workers assisted by patriotic students and Conclusion
other progressive individuals of the middle
class though with some level of passivity. Having got to the full consequences of
This resistance is reflected in their land alienation there is a need therefore, to
patriotic defence and protection of even rebuild, though belatedly the devastated
Kenyan animals in the forest that form and violated environment. This is the
parts of the land resources. Even during thrust of Ngugi’s environmental concern in
dire needs and at the verge of starvation which he has consistently maintained that
the animals are protected; this is so serious and concerted efforts are required
12
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
13
Dele Maxell Ugwanyi CJLS 9(2), 2021
-------------. Matigari. London; Heinemann, Veit, P. 2019. Brief: history of land conflicts
1987. in Kenya in Focus on Land in Africa
Newsletter. World Resources Institute
------------- . Devil on the Cross. London;
Heinemann, 1981. Worster, Donald. 1994. Nature’s
Economy: A History of Ecological
--------------. Petals of Blood. London; Ideas. New York:
Heinemann, 1978. Cambridge University Press.
14