Full Text
Full Text
9-2021
Onuorah, Adaorah R., "Influence of Story Books at Children’s Library on Reading Culture of Pupils in Public
Primary Schools" (2021). Library Philosophy and Practice (e-journal). 6387.
https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/libphilprac/6387
Influence of Story Books at Children’s Library on Reading Culture of Pupils in Public
Primary Schools
Adaorah R. Onuorah1
1
Department of Educational Foundations, University of Nigeria, Nsukka
Abstract
Children libraries are libraries established in schools to support learning and teaching
activities of pupils. In order to inculcate a good reading culture in pupils, they have to be
encouraged to make reading part of their everyday life. Storybooks are useful for introducing
new words, concepts and ideas into children’s language development, world and imagination.
The purpose of the study was to ascertain the influence of storybooks at children's libraries on
reading culture among primary classes 4 and 5 pupils in public schools and find out the
influence of gender on pupils’ reading culture when exposed to storybooks. A quasi-
experimental research design was adopted for this study. A total of 35 pupils were assigned to
the experimental group while 34 pupils were assigned to the control group. Mean, standard
deviation and analysis of covariance were used to analyze data. The results of the study show
that storybooks improve the reading culture of pupils in public primary schools. Also, gender
did not influence the mean reading culture scores of the pupils after exposure to the
storybooks approach, F (1, 68)=.638, p=.427, partial eta squared= .010. There was also no
significant interaction effect of methods and gender on the pupils’ mean reading culture, F (1,
68)=.184, p=.669. Therefore, exposing pupils to storybooks can help improve their culture of
reading. The study recommends among others that there should be more storybooks at
children's libraries in order to enhance the reading culture of pupils in public primary schools
in the study area.
1
Introduction
Primary education is believed to hold the key to the success or failure of the
educational system because it lays the foundation on which other levels of education for
national development is built upon. If this must be achieved, serious attention must be given
to the reading culture of pupils. It has been observed that the state of facilities such as
libraries, books, and furniture that help improve reading culture is low. Parents, teachers and
government at all levels are usually called upon to intervene to address the poor reading
culture in primary education. This study aims to ascertain the influence of storybooks on
reading culture among pupils in public schools and to find out the influence of gender on
pupils' reading culture when exposed to storybooks. Stories are passed from one generation to
another generation by word of mouth. The use of stories in education is ancient and cuts
across races, nations, religions and beliefs (Roby, 2010; Lawani, 2014). Today, stories are
written and this has brought about storybooks. Storybooks are books of stories usually for
children (Merriam, 2021). In other words, storybooks are books that contain a story or stories,
especially for children. In recent times, storybooks are now part of learning experiences that
enhances reading.
Reading is an indispensable learning skill that aids all other learning activities and
lays the foundation for independent studies and prepares the child for higher educational
opportunities (Nalusiba, 2010). Reading refers to the ability to interpret and decode an array
of words through a cognitive process (Ayoti, 2015; Enamen, 2015). It is a complex act that
deals with communication in written or visual form (Ogwu, 2010). Reading according to
Haliru et al., (2015) is a complex process of decoding symbols in order to construct or derive
meaning. It is an act of interpreting meaning from written words (Aina et al., 2011; Ogugua
et al., 2015). Reading involves several interactive processes between the reader and the text,
in which readers use their knowledge to build, create, and construct meaning (Ogbonna,
2
2014). Mikulecky (2011) asserts that reading is a complex conscious and unconscious mental
process in which the reader uses a variety of strategies to reconstruct meaning, based on data
words. It involves recognizing what is written and comprehending the matter, understanding
the main and subsidiary points as well as links between different parts of the written material.
Jegbefume, (2012) posits that while receiving and interpreting the written word, the reader is
concerned with four factors, i.e. decoding, comprehending, text analysis and response.
Decoding or interpreting in reading refers to the process of changing the coded message into
recognize words accurately, and how words are used in varying contexts. Comprehension in
reading refers to the identification of the central theme, main ideas, supporting details and
writing patterns. After decoding and comprehending the literal meaning of a written message,
its significance is evaluated and appropriate conclusions are drawn from it. Text analysis is
essential for the critical and evaluative understanding of a text. Text analysis refers to the
process of identifying relationships among different units within the text in order to
distinguish between relevant and irrelevant information, explicit and implicit information,
facts and opinions, examples and ideas and draw inferences and conclusions. Response is our
action or reaction to the written message. It completes the reading process as it is the last step
of reading. Our response to a text depends largely on our correct understanding and
Reading is a skill which must be consciously developed and nurtured. The more one
reads, the more the reading skill develops. Reading improves one’s writing, reasoning,
communication skills and vocabulary. There is a saying that continuous reading brings about
brain automatism. Reading storybooks enhances one’s reading culture. Additionally, the
3
more pupils read storybooks, the more fluent they become and the more their reading culture
is enhanced. Reading is a culture that can be acquired, formed, developed and sustained
through the provision of the necessary infrastructure like a good functional library, school,
education system and parental support (Iloeje, 2014). Culture is an acquired behavioural
pattern often followed until it has become a part of one (Orakpor, 2012). Culture refers to the
way of life of a particular group of people (Ogugua et al., 2015). This implies that reading
can become a way of life or lifestyle for pupils in primary schools. Reading culture,
defined as a culture where reading is part of people's living and constitutes a norm among
(Orakpor, 2012). It is equally defined as the way of life of people which is characterized by
the habit of reading intensively and extensively (Nalusiba, 2010). Reading culture is a
dedicated and consistent reading lifestyle (Enamen, 2015). Pupils’ reading comprehension
difficulties are usually due to poor oral language skills which were previously inherent at the
time of school admission (Grolig et al., 2019; Nation et al., 2010). In order to inculcate a
good reading culture in pupils, they have to be encouraged to make reading part of their
everyday life.
Story Books
Stories play an essential function in children’s growth and development both at home
and in the school. The home literacy environment is an important contributor to children’s
storybook exposure (Grolig et al., 2019). Storybooks are useful for introducing new words,
concepts and ideas into children’s language, world and imagination (Carter, 2021).
Storybooks are also essential since in spite of the significant advancement in research which
has brought about improvement in our understanding of reading acquisition in recent time, a
4
considerable percentage of pupils are still experiencing severe difficulties whilst learning to
read (Castles et al., 2018; Grolig, 2020). Storybooks read by children contribute to their oral
language development (Grolig, 2020) and reading skill acquisition (Riyadi, 2010).
Storybooks exist in various formats and are relevant in promoting reading among
students’ reading ability and interest in reading (Roslina, 2017). Storybooks such as the
comprehension and chromatic concepts (Kao et al., 2017). The animated illustrations of
comprehension scores, ability to retrieve information and make inferences (Ertem, 2010).
Also, Heidemann (2012) had earlier observed that electronic storybooks can positively
influence student's reading ability. Past research also demonstrated a positive association
between storybooks reading and children’s engagement in reading (Meyer et al., 1994). Short
storybooks are helpful in modifying students’ attitude towards reading as well as motivating
students to read (Palenfo, 2018). According to recent research by Ratminingsih, Budasi and
Kurnia (2020), local culture-based storybooks are effective for improving students’
competency in reading.
Children’s Library
and students. It can be seen as the acquiring, retrieving, processing, disseminating and
housing of intellectual materials both print and non-print. Thus, the importance of libraries
higher learning. Libraries are places where books, literary documents or records are kept for
reference or borrowing. It is also a depository built to contain books and other materials for
reading and study. In addition, it is a place where the custom of reading books can be
5
acquired. Generally, libraries are referred to as a reading hall where pupils gather to consult
Children's libraries are special collections of books intended for young readers and
usually kept in separate rooms of general public libraries (Lars et al., 2003). Some children's
libraries have entire floors or wings dedicated to them in bigger libraries while smaller ones
may have a separate room or area for children. They are an educational agency seeking to
acquaint the young with the world's literature and to cultivate a love for reading. Their work
supplements that of the public schools (Aina, 2004). Services commonly provided by public
libraries may include storytelling sessions for infants, toddlers, preschool children, or after-
school programs, all to develop early literacy skills and a love of books. One of the most
popular programs offered in public libraries is summer reading programs for children,
would interest the pupils. Children libraries are expected to carry out surveys to investigate
materials that would catch the attention of their target audience and acquire such collections.
This will arouse the interest of pupils in reading in the children library (Adeyemi, 2021).
Ajidahun (2011) posits that any country which wants its people to be informed, articulate,
efficient, productive and current, must give priority attention to the development of its
libraries. Not only does a library help to inculcate the culture of reading but it also helps to
create a thirst for knowledge, which ultimately makes a person humble and open to other
people's ideas. Nigeria, like other nations of the world, has an obligation to prepare its
citizens for life in a world that is characterized by rapid social, economic, political and
technological changes. A library can be a public library, school and children’s library.
Children libraries are libraries established in nursery and primary schools to aid and
support learning and teaching activities (Redford, 2011). The purpose of establishing
6
children’s libraries is to meet the information needs of pupils in schools. A school library is
managed by a school librarian (Busayo, 2011). Children’s library provides a range of learning
opportunities for pupils with a focus on intellectual content, information literacy, cultural and
social development. Children’s libraries contain books, films, recorded sound, realia, and
digital media. These items are not only for the education, enjoyment, and entertainment of the
pupils, but also to enhance their reading culture (Hassen, 2016). Thus, all these are geared
(2014) may operate within or outside a school as a teaching and learning centre that provides
an active instructional program integrated into curriculum content, with emphasis on the
capabilities, reading and literacy capabilities, personal and interpersonal capabilities and
learning management capabilities. The children library exists to provide a range of learning
opportunities with a focus on intellectual content and information literacy. Children libraries
are similar to public libraries in that they contain storybooks, films, recorded sound, realia,
and digital media. A storybook ignites a passion for reading and reading culture among
pupils, which inevitably places the library at the centre of the twenty-first-century reading
According to Aina et al., (2011), there is also an overriding desire among pupils to
spend more time with their friends and peers playing than remain at home reading. Children
glue more to televisions, watching cartoons, home videos as a way of enjoying their leisure
instead of reading. This therefore may lead to a decline or poor reading culture. Aina, et al
(2011) also opined that delinquency, school violence, and even incidence of examination
malpractice have a higher correlation with poor reading culture. With poor reading culture
eating deep among pupils in public primary schools, it has become necessary for schools to
7
Research Questions
schools?
storybooks?
3. Is there significant interaction effect of method and gender on the pupils’ mean
reading culture?
Methodology
Ethical approval for this study which was conducted among primary school pupils in
Enugu State, Nigeria was obtained from Research Ethics Committee of the Department of
design was adopted for this investigation. Intact classes comprising primary 4 and 5 pupils
were used for this research. A total of 35 pupils (50.7%) were assigned to the experimental
group, and were exposed to storybooks and the other 34 pupils (49.3%) were assigned to the
control group and were not exposed to storybooks but were exposed to the usual classroom
teaching. Out of the 35 pupils assigned to the experimental group, 17 were males (50%)
while 18 were females (51.4%). In the control group, out of 34 pupils, 17 were males (50%)
while 17 were females (48.6%). The pupils' mean age was 9.20±.92years. To determine the
baseline status of pupils in the experimental and control groups before the experimental
process, the 15-item with four-point rating scale questionnaire (Strongly agree to Strongly
pretest in the first week. The RCQ was validated by experts in Childhood Education and
Library and Information Science. Trial testing of the RCQ was carried out outside the study
area. The internal consistency of the RCQ was determined and results showed that it is
8
reliable for research purposes using Cronbach's alpha (0.84). One week was given to the
During the implementation period, pupils in the experimental group were given
storybooks intervention. On the other hand, pupils in the control group were exposed to the
usual classroom teaching. At the end of the two-week implementation, the reading culture
questionnaire (RCQ) was administered as a posttest. Data were analyzed using mean and
standard deviation to answer the research questions and ANCOVA (analysis of covariance)
Data in Table 1 shows the mean reading culture of the pupils by group and gender
before and after their exposure to the storybooks. The pretest reading culture score for the
experimental group was 25.66±2.07 while their posttest reading culture score was 44.14±
2.19. The pretest reading culture score for the control group was 27.82±0.90 while their
posttest reading culture score was 34.00± 0.82. This suggests an improvement in the reading
9
culture of the pupils after exposure to the storybooks method. By gender, the posttest reading
culture score of the males (43.94±2.28) in the experimental group seems similar to those of
Data in Table 2 shows that there was a significant positive influence of the storybooks
approach on the reading culture of pupils in public primary schools, F(1, 68)= 383.423,
p=.000, partial eta squared= .857. Therefore, the storybooks approach appeared to have
yielded more improvement in the pupils' reading culture compared to the conventional
approach. Also, gender did not influence the mean reading culture scores of the pupils after
exposure to the storybooks approach, F (1, 68)=.638, p=.427, partial eta squared= .010.
Finally, there was no significant interaction effect of method and gender on the pupils’ mean
reading culture, F (1, 68)=.184, p=.669, partial eta squared= .003. Figure 1 further
10
Figure 1: Interaction effect of method and gender on pupils’ reading culture
(I) Group (J) Group Mean Std. Sig.b 95% Confidence Interval for
Difference Error Differenceb
(I-J)
Experimental Control 9.947* .508 .000 8.932, 10.962
*
Control Experimental -9.947 .508 .000 10.962, -8.932
*
. The mean difference is significant at the .05 level.
b
. Adjustment for multiple comparisons: Least Significant Difference (equivalent to no
adjustments).
Data in Table 3 shows the mean reading culture score of pupils in experimental and
control groups with a more significant mean gain observable in pupils who were in the
This study revealed that storybooks enhance the reading culture of pupils in public
schools since there was a significant mean difference in the reading culture scores of pupils
exposed to storybooks in the experimental group compared to pupils in the control group.
11
The study also found no significant difference in the reading culture score of male and
female pupils in public primary school exposed to storybooks intervention. This result agrees
with Katherine et al., (2013) assertion that storybooks enhance pupils reading culture and
influences children’s school outcomes. According to Roslina (2017), storybooks influence the
reading culture of pupils. Strouse, Nyhout and Ganea (2018) opined that a child who reads
storybooks builds a good reading culture. The authors further asserted that storybooks
should be seen as a leisure activity if a strong reading culture must be developed. Developing
a strong reading culture takes quality time, dedication and consistency. Related literature has
acknowledged that strong reading culture is beneficial to pupils and the nation at large
(Ogugua et al., 2015). Reading culture is a routine and repetitive behaviour, it is not
instinctive like hunger or thirst. Good reading culture may lead pupils in the right direction.
Therefore, to develop a good reading culture, pupils need to be exposed to reading strategies,
The promotion of reading culture cannot take place in a vacuum. It has to be initiated.
Enabling reading culture among pupils in primary schools requires a publishing industry,
which must engage a cadre of appropriate writers and produce their work in a pleasing form.
A system of distribution, which may include bookstores, and libraries are needed. It is very
important to recognize that, parents, teachers, and librarians have vital roles to play among
pupils in public primary schools to enable them to embark on voracious reading and
developing good reading culture. Children's and school libraries should also organize
programmes, book clubs, storybooks, pictures, computers storytelling and use them to
inculcate reading culture among pupils. Therefore, the study recommends that there should be
more storybooks at children's libraries in order to enhance the reading culture among pupils
12
in public schools. Secondly, the school authorities should employ qualified school librarians
to be in charge of the children's libraries. Government should equip the existing children's
libraries with good, up-to-date, and sufficient library resources. In addition, the ministry of
education should introduce library periods into the school curriculum. Local governments
should promote reading through school-based organisations such as the press and reading
clubs.
Conclusion
reading culture among pupils in public schools. We conclude that storybooks enhance
reading culture among pupils in public schools since there is a significant difference in the
the control group. Lastly, there was no significant mean difference in reading culture of male
and female pupils in public primary school when exposed to storybooks. Therefore, exposing
13
References
Adeyemi, A. A. (2021). Promoting reading culture, the role of stakeholders and ICT for
Aina, A. J., Okusaga, T. O., Taiwo, A. and Ogundipe, T. C. (2011). The role of library in
168–179.
Aina, L.O. (2004). Library and information science text for Africa. Ibadan, Nigeria: Third
Aliyu, M. B. (2013). Delivery of information services in school libraries in the 21st century:
Challenges and prospects. In A.O. Issa, K.N. Igwe and C.P. Uzuegbu (ed). Provision
Ayoti, A. L. (2015). Free newspaper and reading culture: A culture of the People Daily,
Busayo, I.O. (2011). The School library as a foundational step to children’s effective reading
https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/libphilprac/665/
Carter L. (2021). Why are Stories Important for Children? Retrieved from
https://www.writersbureau.com/writing/Why-are-stories-important-for-
children.htm
Castles, A., Rastle, K., & Nation, K. (2018). Ending the reading wars: Reading acquisition
from novice to expert. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 19(1), 5-51.
14
Cirocki, A, & Farrelly, R. (2016). Research and reflective practice in the EFL classroom:
Dike, V.E. (2017). Poverty and brain development in children: Implications for learning.
Enamen, J. (2015). The role of picture books in promoting reading culture among Nigerian
155.
Grolig, L. (2020). Shared storybook reading and oral language development: A bioecological
Grolig, L., Cohrdes, C., Tiffin-Richards, S. P., & Schroeder, S. (2019). Effects of
Haliru, R. A., Abdulkarim, M., Dogara, A., & Dangani, B. U. (2015). An assessment of
reading habit among secondary school students in Kaduna metropolis. IOSR Journal
secondary schools in Addis Ababa and Dessie. Journal of Education and Practice,
7(22).
15
Heidemann, C. (2012). Implementing electronic storybooks and the effects on reading
https://scholarworks.uni.edu/grp/183
Ibrahim, U. (2014). Library and information work for young people: A text for students and
Iloeje, M. U. (2014). Restoring reading culture and use of library among young Nigerian
adults: Implications for empowering the citizens and Nigerian society. A keynote
Jegbefume, C. M. (2012). Cultivating good reading culture among students in Nigeria. Jewel
Kao, G. Y. M., Tsai, C. C., Liu, C. Y., & Yang, C. H. (2016). The effects of high/low
Katherine, S., Antonia, L., & María, R. L. (2013) Effects of storybook reading style on
Lars, A., John, D., Kathy, E., Leikny, H. I., Susanne, K., Ulga, M., Rita, S, & Ivanka, S.
(2003). The background text to the Guidelines for Children's library services. IFLA.
16
Lawani, L.A.(2014). The effect of digital storytelling on kindergarten Pupils’ achievement in
moral instruction in basic Schools in Oyo State. IOSR Journal of Research and
Retrieved on 1/09/2021.
Meyer, L. A., Wardrop, J. L., Stahl, S. A., & Linn, R. L. (1994). Effects of reading
Nalusiba, P. (2010). Strategies for the development of a reading culture in Uganda primary
Nation, K., Cocksey, J., Taylor, J. S. H., & Bishop, D. V. M. (2010). A longitudinal
investigation of early reading and language skills in children with poor reading
Ogbonna, I. M. (2014). Books, libraries and reading in the digital age. Enugu: Eminota
Publishers.
Ogugua, J. C., Emerole, N., Egwim, F. O., Anyanwu, A. I., & Haco-Obasi, F. (2015).
13(1), 62–67
17
Palenfo, A. (2018). The effect of short story books on students' attitudes and motivation
Ratminingsih, N. M., Artini, L. P., & Padmadewi, N. N.(2018). Incorporating self and peer
10(4), 165–184.
Redford, K. (2011). Classroom strategies: Creating a reading culture for struggling readers
Riyadi, W. (2010). Teaching English using story book to improve reading skill. University of
Roby, T. (2010). Opus in the classroom: Striking CoRDS with content-related digital
144.
Linkoping.
Strouse, G. A., Nyhout, A., & Ganea, P. A. (2018). The role of book features in young
in Psychology, 9, 50.
18
Udomisor, I., Udomisor, E., & Smith, E. (2013). Management of communication crisis in a
3,(8),13–21.
19