Comparative Analysis of Linear and Non-Linear Data Structures
Objective
This assignment aims to analyze and compare the performance and applicability of key linear and
non-linear data structures-specifically arrays, linked lists, stacks, queues (linear) vs. binary search
trees (BST) and graphs (non-linear)-to solve a basic real-world problem. We will also evaluate their
runtime performance and provide clean, optimized code implementations.
Problem Statement
Design a system that stores and retrieves student records efficiently. The system should support the
following operations:
1. Insert a new student record
2. Search for a student by ID
3. Delete a student by ID
4. List all students in ascending order by ID
Implement this system using:
- A Linked List (Linear Data Structure)
- A Binary Search Tree (Non-Linear Data Structure)
Compare the performance of these two implementations and write a short report on findings.
Data Structure Overview
| Data Structure | Type | Key Characteristics |
|----------------|------------|--------------------------------------------------|
| Linked List | Linear | Fast insertions/deletions, slow search |
| BST | Non-Linear | Fast insert/search/delete (O(log n) average if balanced)
Performance Comparison
| Operation | Linked List (Avg Case) | BST (Avg Case) |
|------------------|------------------------|------------------|
| Insert | O(n) | O(log n) |
| Search | O(n) | O(log n) |
| Delete | O(n) | O(log n) |
| Display (Sorted) | O(n) | O(n)
Conclusion: The BST outperforms the linked list in most operations, especially for large datasets,
due to its logarithmic search and insert times (assuming it's balanced). However, linked lists are
simpler and can be more efficient for small or frequently modified data.
Technical Report Summary
- Linear structures like linked lists are easier to implement but scale poorly.
- Non-linear structures like BSTs are more complex but provide better performance for sorted
operations.
- Choosing the right data structure is crucial based on the problem constraints and expected data
size.
- Clean, readable, and modular code enhances maintainability and efficiency.