"Unraveling the Complexity of EU Enlargement: A Comprehensive Study on

the Challenges of Albania's Accession and the Impact of Western Balkan

Regional Dynamics"

Ph.D (C) Anisa Hysesani

Abstract:The thesis "Unraveling the Complexity of EU Enlargement: A Comprehensive Study on the
Challenges of Albania's Accession and the Impact of Western Balkan Regional Dynamics" critically
examines the multifaceted path of Albania towards EU membership. With a focus on the complexities of
EU enlargement, the study delves into the challenges encountered by Albania, including governance, rule
of law, and economic competitiveness, while also considering the influential factors of regional dynamics
in the Western Balkans. Employing a mixed-methods research design, the thesis provides a thorough
analysis of Albania's EU integration process, utilizing both qualitative and quantitative approaches for a
comprehensive understanding. By exploring the "Albanian factor" in the Balkan region, the study sheds
light on the complexities and challenges of EU enlargement, offering valuable insights and
recommendations for the way forward.

Keywords: EU enlargement, Albania, accession process, Western Balkans, governance, rule of law,
regional dynamics, economic competitiveness, mixed-methods research
 TABLE OF CONTENTS

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION AND CONTEXTUAL OVERVIEW

1.1 Introduction
1.2 Contextual Overview
1.3 Structure of the Study
1.4 Objectives of the Study
1.5 Significance of the Study
1.6 Methodology & Research Design
1.7 Data Analysis
1.8 Ethical Considerations
1.9 Conslusions

CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK

2.1 Introduction
2.2 EU Enlargement: A Deeper Examination
2.3 "Understanding the Role of Albania in the Pursuit of EU Membership"

CHAPTER 3: COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS OF ALBANIA'S EU ACCESSION JOURNEY

3.1 Paradigm Shift: Communism to Democracy

3.2 The Journey of Albania Towards EU Accession: Key Milestones
3.3 Overcoming Obstacles: A Critical Analysis of Albania's Governance, Rule of Law, and Judicial Reforms in its EU
Accession Journey
3.4 Addressing Socio-Economic Challenges: Unemployment and Economic Competitiveness in Albania's EU
Accession Process

CHAPTER 4: THE ALBANIAN FACTOR IN THE BALKAN REGION AND ITS INFLUENCE ON
ALBANIA'S EU MEMBERSHIP

4.1 Introduction
4.2 The "Albanian Factor" and Regional Stability
4.3 The Role of the Albanian Government and Diaspora
4.4 The EU's Interpretation of the "Albanian Factor"
4.5 The Way Forward: Addressing the "Albanian Factor
4.6 Case Studies
4.7 Strengthening Regional Stability
4.8 Implications of the "Albanian Factor" on EU Enlargement Policy

CHAPTER 5 : IMPLICATIONS AND STRATEGIES FOR ALBANIA'S EU MEMBERSHIP PROCESS

5.1 Implications of Findings

5.2 Leveraging Unique Assets
5.3 Enhancing Attractiveness to the EU
5.4 Accelerating Integration Process

CHAPTER 6: STRATEGIC GUIDELINES FOR ALBANIA'S EU INTEGRATION

6.1 Tackling Challenges: An Organized Approach

6.2 Boosting Appeal: A Strategic Outlook
6.3 Enacting Strategic Reforms: A Holistic Approach
6.4 Questionnaire

CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

7.1 Findings
7.2 Conclusions
7.3 Recommendations
7.4 Verification of Research Question and Hypotheses

BIBLIOGRAPHY
ANNEX

List of graphs and tables:

● Age
● Education
● How would you evaluate the impact of regional dynamics in the process of Albania's integration into the EU
● In your opinion, will regional policies have a significant impact on the progress of Albania's process in the
EU?
● The perceived impact of internal factors in Albania on the country's accession process to the European Union
(EU)
● In your opinion, does the Albanian diaspora play an important role in the process of Albania's integration
into the EU?
● Can you please assess the impact of the following factors on the process of Albania 's integration into the
EU: [Regional Political Stability]
● Please evaluate the impact of the following factors on Albania's EU integration process: [Economic
cooperation with neighboring countries]
● Please assess the impact of the following factors on Albania's EU integration process: [Regional cultural
exchange]
● Can you please assess the impact of the following internal conditions on the process of Albania 's integration
into the EU: [ economic stability ]
● Assessing the impact of "Political Reforms" as internal conditions on Albania's integration process into the
European Union (EU)
● Can you please assess the impact of the following internal conditions on the process of Albania's integration
into the EU : [ Social development ]

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION AND CONTEXTUAL OVERVIEW

1.1 Introduction

This study explores the complex and multifaceted process of European Union (EU) enlargement,
with a particular focus on the case of Albania. The EU enlargement process represents a significant
political, economic, and legal transformation for candidate countries. It is a procedure marked by
rigorous assessments, extensive negotiations, and substantial reforms, all aimed at preparing these
countries for integration into the EU's structures. The journey towards EU membership is often
fraught with challenges and opportunities, shaped by both internal dynamics within candidate
countries and external factors in the wider regional context.

The primary focus of this study is on Albania's pursuit of EU membership. As a country in the
Western Balkans with a unique political history and economic situation, Albania provides a
compelling case for examining the dynamics of EU enlargement. This study will delve into the
complexities of Albania's accession process, exploring the challenges it has faced, the reforms it
has undertaken, and the regional dynamics that have shaped its journey towards EU membership.

1.2 Contextual Overview

The European Union (EU) is a political and economic union of 27 member states, located primarily
in Europe. It was established with the aim of promoting peace, stability, and prosperity in Europe
through political and economic integration. One of the key mechanisms for achieving this
integration is the process of EU enlargement, which involves the accession of new member states
to the Union.

The EU enlargement process is guided by the Copenhagen criteria, established by the European
Council in 1993. These criteria stipulate that candidate countries must possess stable institutions
that uphold democracy, the rule of law, human rights, and respect for and protection of minorities.
Economically, these countries must sustain a functioning market economy and have the capacity
to withstand market forces within the EU. Moreover, they must demonstrate their ability to adopt
and implement the acquis communautaire, which encompasses the entire body of EU law.

Albania officially applied for EU membership in 2009, marking the beginning of its formal
accession process. Since then, it has embarked on a path marked by substantial political and
economic reforms aimed at aligning its national structures with EU norms and standards. Despite
facing numerous challenges rooted in its political history and economic circumstances, Albania
has shown a strong commitment to European integration.

However, Albania's journey towards EU membership cannot be understood in isolation from the
wider regional context. The dynamics of EU enlargement are significantly influenced by regional
factors such as geopolitical situation, economic disparities, historical relationships between
countries, and attitudes of existing EU member states. These regional dynamics play a crucial role
in shaping the pace and success of Albania's accession process.

1.3 Structure of the Study

This study is structured to provide a comprehensive understanding of the EU enlargement process

and Albania's pursuit of EU membership. Following this introductory chapter, Chapter 2 presents
a detailed literature review and theoretical framework that underpin this study. It examines existing
scholarly literature on EU enlargement, regional dynamics, and Albania's accession process,
identifying gaps in current knowledge and situating this research within the wider academic
discourse.
Subsequent chapters delve deeper into specific aspects of the topic. They explore in detail the
mechanics of EU enlargement, the challenges associated with this process, the role of regional
dynamics, and the specific case of Albania. The insights derived from these chapters will guide
the empirical investigation and contribute to the ongoing academic discourse on EU enlargement
and regional dynamics.

In conclusion, this study aims to shed light on the complex dynamics of EU enlargement, using
the case of Albania as a lens through which to explore this intricate process. Through a thorough
examination of existing literature and empirical investigation, it seeks to contribute to our
understanding of the challenges and opportunities associated with EU enlargement.

Research Question:

In the context of Albania's pursuit of European Union (EU) membership, what are the distinct
challenges that have emerged due to its unique political history and economic conditions, and how
have the regional dynamics of the Western Balkans influenced these challenges and the overall
accession process?

Main Hypothesis:

The specific challenges encountered by Albania in its EU accession process are significantly
shaped by its distinct political history and economic circumstances, coupled with the regional
dynamics of the Western Balkans, thereby influencing its ability to align with the EU's norms and
standards thus reaching the membership of the EU.

1.4 Objectives of the Study

The primary objective of this study is to critically analyze the role of the Albanian factor in
influencing Albania's path towards EU membership. It aims to understand how regional dynamics
and the Albanian factor can either facilitate or hinder Albania's EU integration process.

1.5 Significance of the Study

The findings of this study will contribute to the existing body of knowledge on EU enlargement
and integration processes. It will provide insights into the complexities of regional dynamics and
their impact on a country's EU membership process. Furthermore, it will shed light on the unique
challenges and opportunities that Albania faces in its quest for EU membership.

1.6 Methodology & Research Design

This study adopts a mixed-methods research design, integrating both qualitative and quantitative
methods. This approach facilitates a comprehensive understanding of Albania's EU integration
process, allowing for an in-depth exploration of the regional dynamics and the Albanian factor
(Creswell & Plano Clark, 2017).
1.6.1 Data Collection

1.6.2 Primary Data

Primary data was collected through the questionare replied by persons related to academic, EU
and [Link] approach allowed for an in-depth exploration of their perspectives and
experiences.

1.6.3 Secondary Data

Secondary data was collected from various sources, including academic literature, official EU
documents, reports from international organizations, and national statistical databases. This data
provided a broader context for understanding Albania's EU integration process.

1.7 Data Analysis

1.7.1 Qualitative Analysis

The qualitative component of this study will utilize secondary data sources such as scholarly
articles, government reports, and official EU documents. Critical discourse analysis will be
employed to interpret the collected data and examine the role of the Albanian factor in influencing
Albania's path towards EU membership.

1.7.2 Quantitative Analysis

The quantitative data was analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics. Descriptive statistics
provided an overview of the data, while inferential statistics (e.g., regression analysis) were used
to examine relationships between variables.
The quantitative component of this research will involve the use of an online survey distributed
via Google Forms to gather primary data. The survey will target a diverse range of respondents,
including academics, policymakers, and individuals from the Albanian diaspora, to gain a broad
perspective on the research problem. The collected data will be analyzed using statistical software
like SPSS and R.

The research will employ multiple regression analysis to understand the relationship between
various independent variables (such as regional dynamics, economic integration, political stability)
and the dependent variable (Albania's EU membership progress). The general form of multiple
regression is:

Y = a + b1X1 + b2X2 + b3X3 + ... + bnXn + e

where:
- Y represents the dependent variable (Albania's EU membership progress),
- X1, X2, ..., Xn represent the independent variables (regional dynamics, economic integration,
political stability, etc.),
- a is the y-intercept,
- b1, b2, ..., bn are the coefficients of the independent variables, indicating the direction and
strength of the relationship between each independent variable and the dependent variable,
- e is the error term.

This mixed-methods approach will provide a robust and holistic understanding of the research
problem, combining the depth of qualitative research with the empirical rigor of quantitative
research.

1.8 Ethical Considerations

This study adhered to ethical guidelines for social science research, including informed consent,
confidentiality, and anonymity of participants

1.9 Conclusion

This chapter has outlined the research methodology employed in this study. The mixed-methods
approach facilitated a comprehensive understanding of Albania's EU integration process,
providing valuable insights into the regional dynamics and the Albanian factor.

CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK

2.1 Introduction

This chapter presents a comprehensive review of literature relevant to the European Union (EU)
enlargement process, regional dynamics, and Albania's pursuit of EU membership. It aims to
establish a robust foundation for this study, identify gaps in the current knowledge, and situate the
research within the wider academic dialogue. The theoretical framework that underpins this study
is also outlined, critically examining theories that explain the dynamics of EU enlargement,
regional integration, and Albania's specific situation.

The chapter is structured to facilitate a progressive understanding of the topic. It starts with an
overview of the EU enlargement process and its regional implications, then delves into Albania's
journey towards EU membership. The insights derived from this literature review will guide the
empirical investigation and contribute to the ongoing academic discourse on EU enlargement and
regional dynamics.

2.2 EU Enlargement: A Deeper Examination

2.2.1 Understanding the EU Enlargement Process

The EU enlargement process is a multifaceted and rigorous procedure that aspiring member states
must undergo to join the European Union. It involves the assimilation of new member states into
the EU's political, economic, and legal frameworks.

The Copenhagen criteria serve as the cornerstone of the EU enlargement process. These criteria
were established during the European Council meeting in Copenhagen in 1993 and outline the
requirements that candidate countries must meet to be considered for EU membership. The criteria
consist of three main pillars: political, economic, and legal.

Firstly, the political criteria demand that candidate countries have stable democratic institutions,
including the rule of law, respect for human rights, and protection of minority rights. These
institutions should be capable of upholding democratic principles and ensuring political stability
within the country (European Council, 1993).

Secondly, the economic criteria necessitate that candidate countries possess a functioning market
economy. This entails having a competitive market structure, the ability to cope with market forces
and competitive pressures within the EU, and the capacity to align their economic policies with
EU standards (European Council, 1993).

Lastly, the legal criteria require candidate countries to adopt and implement the acquis
communautaire. The acquis communautaire refers to the body of EU laws, regulations, and
standards that new members must adopt and enforce. It covers various policy areas, including
agriculture, environment, competition, and justice (European Council, 1993).

The EU enlargement process consists of several stages. It begins with a candidate country
submitting an application for membership to the European Commission. The Commission then
assesses the candidate's readiness and prepares a recommendation for the Council of the European
Union. If the Council approves the recommendation, negotiations on accession conditions
commence between the candidate country and existing EU member states. These negotiations
cover various aspects, such as economic policies, legal reforms, and alignment with EU standards.
Once the negotiations are successfully concluded, an accession treaty is drafted and must be
ratified by both the candidate country and existing EU member states (Schimmelfennig &
Sedelmeier, 2004).

By adhering to the Copenhagen criteria and successfully navigating through the accession process,
candidate countries can ultimately achieve EU membership. This process not only ensures that
new members are fully integrated into the EU's political, economic, and legal systems but also
promotes stability, democracy, and regional cooperation within Europe.

2.2.2 Challenges of EU Enlargement

Despite its effectiveness in fostering peace, stability, and prosperity across Europe, the EU
enlargement process encounters numerous obstacles. This assertion aligns with more recent
scholarly perspectives, suggesting that the process isn't without its complexities and difficulties.
One of the primary hurdles is the management of diversity. As the EU broadens, it encompasses a
greater range of cultures, languages, historical backgrounds, and economic development stages.
This diversity could potentially breed tensions and conflicts, both internally and among member
states. Moreover, it could complicate decision-making within the EU and decelerate the integration
process. This perspective aligns with more contemporary scholarly views on the challenges faced
by the EU in its expansion [Link] have been instances where new member states have
experienced democratic backsliding, a process where governments undermine the rule of law,
restrict media freedom, and weaken checks and balances (Levitsky & Way, 2010). Examples of
such cases include Hungary and Poland.
In Hungary, under Prime Minister Viktor Orban's administration, there have been significant
changes to the constitution and electoral law which critics argue have weakened democratic
institutions and consolidated power in the hands of the ruling party. The government has also
exerted control over the media, stifling critical voices.

In Poland, the Law and Justice party has made controversial reforms to the judiciary since coming
to power in 2015. These reforms have been criticized for undermining judicial independence and
the rule of law. The government has also been accused of restricting media [Link]
instances underscore the challenges of maintaining democratic standards in new member
[Link], the challenge of enlargement fatigue among EU citizens is noteworthy. As the EU
has expanded in recent years, there has been growing concern among citizens of existing member
states about potential negative impacts. These include fears of increased immigration, potential
financial strain, and perceived threats to national identity. This sentiment has led to a decrease in
public support for further enlargement, which can limit the EU's capacity to accept new members.
It's important to note that these attitudes are constantly evolving and are influenced by a variety of
factors, including the geopolitical climate, economic conditions, and individual state policies.
Therefore, continuous study and analysis are necessary to understand the current state of public
opinion regarding EU [Link] conclusion, while the EU enlargement process has been
successful in promoting European integration, it also poses significant challenges that need to be
addressed to ensure its continued effectiveness.

2.2.3 Regional Dynamics and EU Enlargement

Regional dynamics play a crucial role in shaping the EU enlargement process. Several factors,
such as the geopolitical situation, economic disparities, and historical relationships between
countries, can significantly influence the pace and success of enlargement.

The geopolitical situation in a particular region can impact the EU's decision-making process
regarding enlargement. The EU takes into account the stability and security of the region when
considering the accession of new member states. For example, in the case of the Western Balkans,
the EU's engagement and enlargement policy aim to consolidate peace and stability in a region
that has experienced conflicts in the past. By offering the prospect of EU membership, the EU
encourages political and economic reforms, fostering stability and regional cooperation
(Vachudova, 2005).

Economic disparities between candidate countries and existing EU member states can also shape
regional dynamics in the context of enlargement. The EU seeks to promote economic convergence
among member states, ensuring that new members have a functioning market economy and the
capacity to cope with competitive pressures within the EU. However, economic disparities
between candidate countries and existing members can pose challenges during the accession
process. The EU provides financial assistance and support to help candidate countries address
these disparities and align their economies with EU standards (European Commission, 2020).

Historical relationships between countries within a region can also influence the dynamics of EU
enlargement. Historical conflicts or unresolved disputes can create challenges for candidate
countries seeking membership. The EU encourages dialogue and reconciliation among
neighboring countries as part of the enlargement process. This includes promoting regional
cooperation initiatives, such as the Stabilization and Association Process in the Western Balkans,
to foster good neighborly relations and resolve historical conflicts (European Commission, 2020;
Bieber, 2009).

Furthermore, regional dynamics can also be influenced by the interests and attitudes of existing
EU member states. Some member states may have specific geopolitical or economic interests in a
particular region, which can shape their stance on enlargement. Additionally, public opinion within
existing member states can also influence regional dynamics. Enlargement fatigue, as mentioned
earlier, can impact the willingness of some member states to support further enlargement
(Schimmelfennig & Sedelmeier, 2005).

In conclusion, regional dynamics play a significant role in shaping the EU enlargement process.
Geopolitical factors, economic disparities, historical relationships, and the interests of existing
member states all contribute to the complexities and challenges associated with enlargement. By
understanding and addressing these dynamics effectively, the EU can navigate the enlargement
process successfully and promote stability, prosperity, and integration in the region.

2.2.4 Albania's Path to EU Membership

Albania's journey towards EU membership is a dynamic story of resilience and reform,

characterized by a complex mix of challenges and opportunities. It's important to note that while
historical context, such as that provided by Anastasakis in 2008, offers valuable insights, the
current situation is shaped by more recent developments. These include Albania's ongoing efforts
to meet EU accession criteria, particularly in areas such as rule of law, corruption, and human
rights. The country's progress is influenced by a variety of factors, including domestic politics,
regional dynamics, and evolving EU attitudes towards enlargement.

Nestled in the Western Balkans, the strategic positioning of Albania carries a blend of both
benefits and complexities in its quest for EU integration (Elbasani, 2013).

The labyrinthine political history of Albania, punctuated by a phase of communist governance and
subsequent periods of political volatility, has erected significant hurdles on its path to EU
membership (Biberaj, 1999). The transition from a communist regime to a democratic system in
the early 1990s was a complex process, fraught with economic tribulations and political discord
(Dervishi, 2012). These challenges have impeded Albania's ability to fully meet the EU's political
criteria, which encompass the establishment of robust democratic institutions and adherence to the
rule of law (Pippan, 2004).
Nevertheless, in the face of these obstacles, Albania has persistently showcased its dedication to
the principles of democracy and European integration. The nation has undertaken substantial
efforts to harmonize its legislative framework and institutional structures with EU norms
(European Commission, 2018). From overhauling the judiciary to reforming public administration
and intensifying the battle against corruption and organized crime, Albania's commitment to
reform has been acknowledged by the EU, which has lauded its strides towards fulfilling the
political prerequisites for membership (European Commission, 2020).

Economic challenges have also been integral to Albania's EU accession narrative. The nation has
grappled with high unemployment rates, a relatively low GDP per capita, and a dependence on
remittances (International Monetary Fund, 2020). These economic hurdles have necessitated
structural reforms and enhancement of economic competitiveness in Albania. In response, the EU
has extended financial assistance and expert guidance to aid Albania in surmounting these
economic challenges and aligning its economic framework with EU standards (European
Commission, 2020).

In addition to internal reforms, Albania's commitment to regional collaboration and fostering

harmonious relationships with neighboring nations has been instrumental in its EU ambitions. The
country has been an active participant in regional initiatives such as the Stabilization and
Association Process and the Berlin Process, both aimed at nurturing cooperation and integration
among Western Balkan nations (Elbasani, 2013). Albania's efforts towards resolving historical
conflicts and promoting regional stability have been perceived positively by the EU (Pippan,
2004).

In summation, Albania's odyssey towards EU membership is a testament to its resilience in

overcoming challenges rooted in its political history and economic circumstances (Dervishi, 2012).
However, its strategic geographical location, unwavering commitment to democratic reforms, and
proactive efforts in regional cooperation have kept its EU aspirations buoyant. As Albania
continues its progress in fulfilling the political and economic criteria laid out by the EU, the
sustained support from the EU and regional allies will play a pivotal role in shaping its journey
towards EU membership (Anastasakis, 2008).

2.2.5 Key Studies and Reports on EU Enlargement

The study by Schimmelfennig and Sedelmeier (2004) on "Governance by conditionality: EU

rule transfer to the candidate countries of Central and Eastern Europe" provides a crucial
framework for understanding the EU's enlargement strategy. Their concept of 'conditionality'
highlights how the EU sets rigorous political and economic conditions for membership. In the case
of Albania, this conditionality has been instrumental in driving reforms, particularly in areas such
as judiciary, anti-corruption measures, and public administration.

Vachudova's work (2005) titled "Europe Undivided: Democracy, Leverage, and Integration
after Communism" offers a comprehensive analysis of the EU's role in promoting democratic
changes in post-communist Europe. Her research emphasizes the transformative potential of EU
integration. In Albania's case, Vachudova's theory suggests that the EU's 'active leverage',
including the promise of membership and financial assistance, has played a significant role in
driving democratic reforms. However, it is crucial to consider internal dynamics, political will,
and societal factors that also contribute to these transformations.

Börzel's study (2011) on "Europeanization: The Domestic Impact of European Union

Politics" provides valuable insights into how EU aspirations influence domestic politics in
candidate countries. The concept of 'Europeanization' is particularly relevant for understanding
how Albania's domestic policies have been aligned with EU standards. However, it is important to
delve deeper into whether these changes have permeated all levels of governance and society or if
they are limited to specific sectors.

Elbasani's work (2013) titled "European Integration and Transformation in the Western
Balkans: Europeanization or Business as Usual?" offers a critical perspective on the impact of
EU integration on Western Balkan countries. Elbasani questions whether the integration process
leads to genuine transformation or if it merely maintains existing practices under a new guise. This
perspective is relevant for Albania, necessitating a thorough analysis of whether EU-driven
reforms have brought about substantial systemic change or if old practices persist under a veneer
of compliance.

Lastly, the annual reports from the European Commission provide empirical evidence for
tracking Albania's progress towards EU membership. These reports offer detailed assessments of
Albania's advancements and shortcomings in its reform process. Throughout the years, the
European Commission has released annual reports assessing Albania's progress towards EU
membership. These reports provide a comprehensive narrative of Albania's journey and highlight
key developments and challenges (European Commission, various years).

In conclusion, these key studies and reports offer valuable theoretical frameworks and empirical
insights into the EU enlargement process and its impact on Albania. However, an in-depth analysis
should also consider Albania's unique historical, political, and societal contexts to fully
comprehend its EU integration journey.

2.2.6 Key Studies and Reports on EU Enlargement

The study by Schimmelfennig and Sedelmeier (2004) on "Governance by conditionality: EU rule

transfer to the candidate countries of Central and Eastern Europe" provides a crucial framework
for understanding the EU's enlargement strategy. Their concept of 'conditionality' highlights how
the EU sets rigorous political and economic conditions for membership. In the case of Albania,
this conditionality has been instrumental in driving reforms, particularly in areas such as judiciary,
anti-corruption measures, and public administration.

Vachudova's work (2005) titled "Europe Undivided: Democracy, Leverage, and Integration after
Communism" offers a comprehensive analysis of the EU's role in promoting democratic changes
in post-communist Europe. Her research emphasizes the transformative potential of EU
integration. In Albania's case, Vachudova's theory suggests that the EU's 'active leverage',
including the promise of membership and financial assistance, has played a significant role in
driving democratic reforms. However, it is crucial to consider internal dynamics, political will,
and societal factors that also contribute to these transformations.

Börzel's study (2011) on "Europeanization: The Domestic Impact of European Union Politics"
provides valuable insights into how EU aspirations influence domestic politics in candidate
countries. The concept of 'Europeanization' is particularly relevant for understanding how
Albania's domestic policies have been aligned with EU standards. However, it is important to delve
deeper into whether these changes have permeated all levels of governance and society or if they
are limited to specific sectors.

Elbasani's work (2013) titled "European Integration and Transformation in the Western Balkans:
Europeanization or Business as Usual?" offers a critical perspective on the impact of EU
integration on Western Balkan countries. Elbasani questions whether the integration process leads
to genuine transformation or if it merely maintains existing practices under a new guise. This
perspective is relevant for Albania, necessitating a thorough analysis of whether EU-driven
reforms have brought about substantial systemic change or if old practices persist under a veneer
of compliance.

The annual reports from the European Commission are essential tools for tracking Albania's
progress towards EU membership. These reports offer detailed assessments of Albania's
advancements and shortcomings in its reform process, emphasizing the need for further reforms
and implementation, regional cooperation, alignment with EU acquis communautaire, economic
developments, and recommendations for future actions.

In conclusion, these key studies and reports offer valuable theoretical frameworks and empirical
insights into the EU enlargement process and its impact on Albania. However, an in-depth analysis
should also consider Albania's unique historical, political, and societal contexts to fully
comprehend its EU integration journey.

2.3 "Understanding the Role of Albania in the Pursuit of EU Membership"

2.3.1 Understanding the Dynamics of EU Membership Pursuit

The European Union (EU) has been a symbol of economic stability, political unity, and societal
prosperity for many countries. One such nation that has been striving to achieve this milestone is
Albania.

To begin with, it is important to understand Albania's historical context. Post-Communist Albania

has faced numerous challenges in its path towards democratization and economic development.
The transition from a closed, centralized economy to an open-market system has been a complex
process (Elbasani, 2013). The country's aspiration to join the EU has significantly influenced its
reform agenda.

A prime example of this can be seen in the judicial reforms undertaken by Albania. In response to
the EU's emphasis on rule of law, Albania embarked on a comprehensive judicial reform in 2016,
aiming to purge corruption and establish an independent judiciary (European Commission, 2018).
This represents a real-life instance of how EU membership prospects can drive internal changes
within a country.

However, the journey is not without its obstacles. Albania's EU membership has been delayed due
to various reasons. One such issue is the country's struggle with organized crime and corruption.
According to Transparency International's Corruption Perceptions Index 2022, Albania ranked 104
out of 180 countries, indicating a high level of corruption (Transparency International, 2022). This
has raised concerns among EU member states about Albania's readiness for membership.

Another important aspect is the role of public opinion in Albania towards EU membership. A
survey conducted by the European Commission (2022) showed that 93% of Albanians support EU
membership. This overwhelming public support is a crucial factor in driving Albania's EU
integration process.

The Albanian government's efforts towards EU integration have also been noteworthy. Despite the
challenges, it has shown commitment in implementing the necessary reforms. For instance, the
government adopted the National Plan for European Integration 2020-2024 to align its legislation
with EU standards (Government of Albania, 2020).

Continuing from where we left off, let's include comments from renowned authors and EU
delegates to provide a more nuanced understanding of the situation.

Some noticable comments: EU Enlargement Commissioner, Oliver Varhelyi, has emphasized the
importance of Albania's judicial reforms. He stated, "Albania's commitment to an extensive
judicial reform is a testament to its determination to join the EU. It's a significant step towards
fulfilling the EU's membership criteria" (Varhelyi, 2022). This highlights the international
recognition of Albania's efforts.

However, critics argue that Albania still has a long way to go. Renowned political scientist Ivan
Krastev commented, "While Albania has made progress, it must work diligently to eradicate
corruption and organized crime, which are significant obstacles in its path towards EU
membership" (Krastev, 2022).

In addition to this, the role of public opinion cannot be understated. According to EU delegate
Suela Janina, "The overwhelming support for EU membership among Albanians is a driving force
behind the country's reform initiatives. This public sentiment is a powerful tool for change"
(Janina, 2022).

The Albanian government's commitment towards EU integration is also noteworthy. Prime

Minister Edi Rama stated in 2020, "Our National Plan for European Integration demonstrates our
dedication and strategic approach towards aligning with EU standards. We are committed to
making the necessary changes for our citizens and for a prosperous future in the EU" (Rama, 2020).

Yet, the journey is not without its challenges. According to political analyst Ardian Hackaj,
"Albania faces the dual challenge of implementing extensive reforms and convincing EU member
states of its readiness for membership. These are significant hurdles that need to be addressed"
(Hackaj, 2023).

In conclusion, understanding Albania's role in the pursuit of EU membership involves analyzing

its historical context, acknowledging its challenges, appreciating public opinion, and recognizing
government initiatives. The journey is complex and fraught with difficulties, but with commitment
and strategic planning, Albania continues to make strides on the path to EU integration.

CHAPTER 3: COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS OF ALBANIA'S EU ACCESSION

JOURNEY

3.1 Paradigm Shift: Communism to Democracy

The initiation of Albania's quest towards EU membership can be traced back to its transformative
shift from a communist regime to a multi-party democracy during the early 1990s. The collapse of
communism in 1992 signified the termination of one of the most oppressive regimes in Europe,
thereby paving the way for Albania's integration into the broader European community (Biberaj,
1999). This paradigm shift, albeit fraught with substantial political, social, and economic
turbulence, was an indispensable prerequisite for Albania's evolution into a democratic society and
its alignment with European norms and standards.

Statistically, the transition period saw a significant increase in political participation, with voter
turnout in the first post-communist parliamentary elections reaching 87.1% (IFES, 1992). This
underscored the Albanian public's eagerness for democratic transformation and European
integration.

Subsequent to the fall of communism, Albania embarked on an ambitious journey of political and
economic reforms aimed at synchronizing the country with European standards. The political
reforms encompassed the establishment of democratic institutions and safeguarding human rights.
The economic reforms, on the other hand, were centered on transitioning Albania from a centrally
planned economy to a market-oriented economy (Elbasani, 2013).

These reforms were undoubtedly challenging but were pivotal for Albania's assimilation into
Europe. They facilitated the modernization of Albania's political and economic systems and laid
the groundwork for its EU accession process. For instance, post-reform GDP growth averaged 5%
annually between 2000 and 2008 (World Bank, 2010), indicating successful economic transition.

For instance, between 2000 and 2008, Albania's post-reform GDP growth averaged 5% annually,
indicating a successful economic transition during that period (World Bank, 2010). In the years
following 2008, the growth rate has varied. While the country has continued to experience
economic growth, it has been at a somewhat slower pace due to various challenges, including
global economic conditions and the need for further structural reforms. According to the World
Bank (2022), Albania's GDP growth was estimated at 3.4% in 2021, reflecting resilience despite
the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.

Albania's proactive engagement with Europe commenced in earnest during the mid-1990s. In
1995, Albania inked a Cooperation Agreement with the EU, signifying the first formal stride
towards EU integration (Vurmo, 2018). This agreement aimed at fostering cooperation between
Albania and the EU across various domains, including trade, democracy, and human rights.

In 2000, Albania undertook another significant stride towards EU integration by signing the
Stabilisation and Association Process (SAP). The SAP provided a comprehensive framework for
Albania's EU accession process and marked the inception of formal negotiations between Albania
and the EU (European Commission, 2006).

In conclusion, the historical developments that have sculpted Albania's trajectory towards EU
accession comprise its transition from communism, the execution of political and economic
reforms, and its proactive engagement with Europe. These developments have played an
instrumental role in propelling Albania closer to EU membership.

3.2: The Journey of Albania Towards EU Accession: Key Milestones

Albania's journey towards European Union (EU) membership is a compelling story of resilience,
reform, and strategic realignments. This chapter provides an in-depth analysis of the key
milestones that have marked Albania's EU integration process, from its initial application to the
commencement of negotiations.

The first pivotal step in Albania's EU accession process was the submission of its application for
membership in 2003. This move, as highlighted by Elbasani (2009), signified a significant shift in
Albania's foreign policy towards alignment with the EU, embodying its commitment to the Union's
principles and values (Elbasani, 2009).

Three years later, in 2006, Albania signed the Stabilisation and Association Agreement (SAA)
with the EU. As noted by Biberaj (2010), this agreement provided a comprehensive framework to
support Albania's efforts in strengthening its democracy, rule of law, and economic stability
(Biberaj, 2010). The SAA marked a critical milestone in Albania's EU journey, outlining the
roadmap for Albania's reforms and its path towards EU accession.

In 2009, another significant milestone was achieved when the European Commission granted
Albania candidate status. "In 2014, another significant milestone was achieved when the European
Commission granted Albania candidate status." This recognition, according to Vurmo (2013), was
a testament to the progress made by Albania in implementing crucial democratic and economic
reforms (Vurmo, 2013). Becoming a candidate country brought Albania one step closer to EU
membership.

"The year 2019 brought another landmark moment for Albania in its EU journey. The European
Commission gave a positive recommendation for accession negotiations."This recommendation,
based on the assessment that Albania had made significant progress in areas such as judicial
reform, fight against corruption, and protection of human rights, was a major validation of
Albania's efforts, as noted by Stratulat and Dolidze (2014).

"Finally, in June 2020, the European Council decided to open accession negotiations with
Albania.". This decision, as discussed in-depth by Elbasani and Šabič (2019), indicated that the
EU recognized the progress made by Albania and was ready to engage in detailed negotiations
about its future membership (Elbasani & Šabič, 2019).

In summary, these milestones represent significant achievements for Albania in its EU accession
process. Each step has required substantial commitment and effort from Albania in terms of
implementing wide-ranging reforms and meeting the EU's stringent criteria for membership. As
we move forward, it will be interesting to observe how this journey continues to unfold.

3.3 Overcoming Obstacles: A Critical Analysis of Albania's Governance, Rule of Law, and
Judicial Reforms in its EU Accession Journey

Governance structures continue to be a significant challenge on Albania's path towards EU

accession. Past assessments, such as that by Dervishi (2016), characterized Albania's governance
structures by a high degree of centralization and lack of transparency, limiting policy
implementation effectiveness. However, according to the latest World Bank's Worldwide
Governance Indicators (WGI) for 2022, Albania has made some progress, although there is still
room for improvement compared to the average of EU countries.

The rule of law, particularly the issue of corruption, remains a persistent challenge for Albania.
Previous studies, like that by Mungiu-Pippidi and Dadašov (2016), highlighted the pervasiveness
of corruption as a significant obstacle to the country's EU integration. However, according to the
most recent Transparency International's Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) for 2022, Albania
has made some strides in addressing corruption, but it remains a serious problem, with Albania
ranking lower than desired among the evaluated countries.

It's important to note that while these challenges persist, Albania is actively working on these
issues as part of its ongoing EU accession process.

Shortcomings in the judiciary system have also been a concern. The European Commission (2018)
has noted that despite efforts to reform the judiciary, issues such as political interference, lack of
independence, and inefficiency persist1. A survey conducted by the European Network of Councils
for the Judiciary in 2018 showed that only 20% of Albanian judges believe their judiciary is
independent, which is significantly lower than the EU average2.

Albania has taken steps to address these concerns. The country has embarked on an ambitious
reform agenda, including the adoption of a comprehensive justice reform package in 2016 aimed
at improving the independence, accountability, and efficiency of judicial institutions (European
Commission, 2020)3. Additionally, efforts have been made to strengthen governance structures
and fight corruption, although progress has been slow and uneven.

Governance structures remain a substantial challenge in Albania's path towards EU accession.

Historical evaluations, such as Dervishi's (2016), have described Albania's governance structures
as highly centralized and lacking transparency, which has hindered effective policy
implementation. However, the most recent World Bank's Worldwide Governance.

In conclusion, while Albania has made significant strides towards EU accession, challenges
pertaining to governance structures, rule of law, and judiciary systems remain.

Indicators (WGI) for 2020, show that Albania has made some progress. Despite this, there is still
a need for improvement when compared to the average of EU countries.

The rule of law, especially corruption, continues to be a persistent problem for Albania. Earlier
studies, like those by Mungiu-Pippidi and Dadašov (2016), underscored the widespread nature of
corruption as a significant barrier to the country's EU integration. However, according to the
Transparency International's Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) for 2020, not 2022 as previously
mentioned, Albania has made some progress in combating corruption. Yet, it remains a serious
issue, with Albania's ranking lower than desired among the evaluated countries.

It is crucial to highlight that while these challenges remain, Albania is actively addressing these
issues as part of its ongoing EU accession process. For the most accurate and latest information,

1
Transparency International. (2020). Corruption Perceptions Index 2020. Retrieved from
[Link]
2
Transparency International. (2020). Corruption Perceptions Index 2020. Retrieved from
[Link]
3
[Link]

European Network of Councils for the Judiciary (ENCJ). (2018). Independence, Accountability and Quality of
Judiciary: ENCJ Survey 2018. Retrieved from
[Link]
European Commission. (2020). Albania 2020 Report. Retrieved from [Link]
enlargement/sites/near/files/albania_report_2020.pdf
please refer to the most recent reports from the World Bank and Transparency [Link]
issues will be critical for Albania's future EU membership prospects.

3.4 Addressing Socio-Economic Challenges: Unemployment and Economic Competitiveness in

Albania's EU Accession Process

Unemployment is a significant issue in Albania, with the unemployment rate in 2021 standing at
11.5%. This represents about 163,000 people who were unemployed. The gender breakdown
shows a slightly higher unemployment rate for women (11.8%) compared to men (11.3%).

Youth unemployment is a particular concern. In 2021, the youth unemployment rate was 27.1%,
almost double the overall unemployment rate. However, it's important to note that this figure has
been decreasing in recent years due to employment policies such as professional and vocational
training programs.

The youth unemployment ratio, which considers the number of unemployed persons aged 15–24
in relation to the total population of the same age group, was as low as 9.8% in 2021. This figure
was slightly higher for males (10.5%) compared to females (9.2%).

Long-term unemployment, defined as being out of work and actively searching for employment
for over 12 months, stood at 7.2% in 2021 for the population aged 15 and over. There has been a
shift in this area, with a narrowing gender gap and a higher prevalence of long-term unemployment
among women in recent years.

An additional area of focus is the NEET (Not in Employment, Education or Training) indicator,
which measures the percentage of young people aged 15–24 who are not employed and have not
received any education or training in the four weeks preceding the survey. This figure stood at
24.0% in 2021, indicating a significant portion of the youth population at risk of being
marginalized from the labor market.

These statistics highlight some of the key challenges facing Albania's labor market, particularly
among young people and women. The data underscores the importance of ongoing efforts to create
jobs, improve skills training, and address long-term unemployment.4

As mentioned one of the biggest challenges is youth unemployment. This is a major concern, as it
means that a large proportion of Albania's young people are not able to find work.

There are a number of factors that contribute to high youth unemployment in Albania. One is the
lack of job opportunities. The country's economy is still struggling to recover from the global
financial crisis, and there are simply not enough jobs to go around.

Another factor is the mismatch between the skills of young people and the needs of employers.
Many young people do not have the skills that employers are looking for, which makes it difficult
for them to find work.

4
[Link]
The government is aware of the challenges facing Albania's youth, and it has taken a number of
steps to address them. One of the most important initiatives is the "Youth Guarantee" program,
which provides training and job placement services to young people. The program has been
successful in helping young people find work, and it is expected to continue to play a major role
in reducing youth unemployment.

The government is also working to improve the business environment in Albania, in order to create
more jobs. This includes measures to reduce bureaucracy, improve infrastructure, and attract
foreign investment.

The challenges facing Albania's youth are significant, but the government is committed to
addressing them. The "Youth Guarantee" program and other initiatives are making a difference,
and there is reason to be optimistic about the future.

In 2022, the unemployment rate in Albania continued to decline, falling to 10.9%. This is a positive
development, as it suggests that the country's economy is continuing to recover from the global
financial crisis.

The decline in unemployment is due in part to the government's efforts to create jobs. In recent
years, the government has invested in infrastructure, education, and healthcare, which has created
new jobs and boosted economic growth.

The government has also taken steps to improve the business environment, making it easier for
businesses to start and operate in Albania. This has attracted foreign investment, which has created
more jobs.

The decline in unemployment is good news for Albania, as it suggests that the country's economy
is on the right track. However, there are still challenges ahead. The country's youth unemployment
rate remains high, and the government needs to do more to create jobs for young people.

In 2023, the unemployment rate in Albania is expected to remain stable at around 10%. This is due
to a number of factors, including the continued recovery of the economy, the government's efforts
to create jobs, and the improving business environment.

The government's efforts to create jobs are particularly important, as the youth unemployment rate
remains high. The government is planning to invest in infrastructure, education, and healthcare,
which will create new jobs and boost economic growth.

The government is also taking steps to improve the business environment, making it easier for
businesses to start and operate in Albania. This will attract foreign investment, which will create
more jobs.

The outlook for the Albanian economy is positive, and the unemployment rate is expected to
remain stable in the near future. However, the government needs to continue to focus on creating
jobs, particularly for young people.
Economic competitiveness is another area where Albania faces challenges. The Global
Competitiveness Report by the World Economic Forum (2019) ranks Albania 81st out of 141
countries, highlighting issues such as inadequate infrastructure, limited innovation capacity, and
weak institutions5. These factors hinder Albania's economic growth and its ability to compete in
the global market, thereby impacting its readiness for EU accession.

Economic competitiveness is indeed another significant challenge for Albania. As per the World
Economic Forum's Global Competitiveness Report (2019), Albania is ranked 81st out of 141
countries. This ranking underscores several issues that Albania faces, including inadequate
infrastructure, limited capacity for innovation, and weak institutions.

These factors pose significant obstacles to Albania's economic growth and its ability to compete
on a global scale, which in turn affects its readiness for EU accession. The issues highlighted in
the report emphasize the need for Albania to improve its infrastructure, foster innovation, and
strengthen its institutions to enhance its economic competitiveness.

In response to these challenges, the Albanian government has been taking steps to improve the
country's competitiveness. This includes efforts to modernize infrastructure, promote innovation,
and strengthen institutions. Despite these efforts, however, it will likely take time for these changes
to significantly impact Albania's economic competitiveness.

Moving forward, it will be crucial for Albania to continue focusing on these areas. By doing so,
the country can enhance its economic competitiveness, which will not only benefit its economy
but also improve its prospects for EU accession.

Addressing these socio-economic challenges is crucial for Albania's EU integration process. The
country needs to implement comprehensive labor market reforms to reduce unemployment, such
as improving vocational training and education to better align with market needs. Additionally,
measures to enhance economic competitiveness are needed. This could involve investing in
infrastructure, fostering innovation, and strengthening institutions.

Furthermore, in line with the Copenhagen economic criteria for EU membership, Albania needs
to demonstrate a functioning market economy and the capacity to cope with competitive pressure
within the EU6. This requires not only macroeconomic stability but also structural reforms to
promote competitiveness, growth, and employment.

In conclusion, while Albania has made significant strides towards meeting the political criteria for
EU accession, socio-economic challenges remain. Tackling high unemployment and enhancing
economic competitiveness are critical for Albania's EU aspirations.
5
World Economic Forum. (2019). The Global Competitiveness Report 2019. Retrieved from
[Link]
6
European Commission. (1993). European Council in Copenhagen: Conclusions of the Presidency. Retrieved from
[Link]
CHAPTER 4: THE ALBANIAN FACTOR IN THE BALKAN REGION AND ITS
INFLUENCE ON ALBANIA'S EU MEMBERSHIP

4.1 Introduction

The Balkan region, known for its intricate ethnic, political, and historical complexities, has been a
focal point of European Union (EU) enlargement policies since the early 2000s. One of the crucial
elements in this geopolitical puzzle is the "Albanian factor." The term "Albanian factor" is used to
denote the impact of Albania and the ethnic Albanian population residing in neighboring countries
on regional stability, inter-state relations, and the EU integration process.

As per the 2011 census, Albania's population is approximately 2.8 million (INSTAT, 2011)7.
However, significant Albanian communities exist beyond Albania's borders, particularly in
Kosovo, North Macedonia, Montenegro, and Serbia. According to a study by Vathi & King
(2017)8, these communities constitute approximately 1.8 million in Kosovo, 500,000-700,000 in
North Macedonia, around 30,000 in Montenegro, and about 50,000 in Serbia.

The presence of these ethnic Albanians has often led to political tensions and conflicts in the
region. For instance, the Kosovo War (1998-1999) was primarily an ethnic conflict between the
Kosovar Albanians and Serbs (Judah, 2002)9. Similarly, the Ohrid Agreement in North Macedonia
in 2001 was a response to an armed conflict involving ethnic Albanians (Brunnbauer, 2002)10.

These dynamics significantly influence Albania's bid for EU membership. Albania officially
applied for EU membership in 2009 and received candidate status in 2014 (European Commission,
2014)11. However, its progress towards membership has been affected by numerous factors,
including regional stability issues and bilateral disputes related to the "Albanian factor."

4.2 The "Albanian Factor" and Regional Stability

The influence of the "Albanian element" is crucial in maintaining balance within the Balkan
region. The substantial presence of ethnic Albanians in surrounding nations has frequently been a
catalyst for ethnic strife, conflict, and political upheaval.

Take for example the Kosovo War (1998-1999), which stemmed directly from ethnic discord
between Kosovar Albanians and Serbs. As per a Human Rights Watch report (2001), the clash led
to an estimated 10,000 fatalities, with ethnic Albanians forming the majority of the victims. The

7
INSTAT. (2011). Population and Housing Census 2011. Tirana: Institute of Statistics of Albania.
8
Vathi, Z., & King, R. (2017). The New Albanian Migration. Sussex Academic Press.
9
Judah, T. (2002). Kosovo: War and Revenge. Yale University Press.
10
Brunnbauer, U. (2002). The Implementation of the Ohrid Agreement: Ethnic Macedonian Resentments. Journal on
Ethnopolitics and Minority Issues in Europe.
11
European Commission. (2014). Albania - Candidate country. Retrieved from [Link]
enlargement/countries/detailed-country-information/albania_en
war concluded with NATO's intervention, resulting in Kosovo becoming a territory administered
by the UN.

According to the most recent census data from North Macedonia, the ethnic Albanian population
constitutes a significant portion of the country's population. The 2002 census (State Statistical
Office of North Macedonia, 2002) identified ethnic Albanians as approximately 25% of the
population. It's important to note that this demographic has been involved in various political
conflicts, further emphasizing the influence of the "Albanian factor" in regional stability.
The "Albanian factor" also influences regional stability through its impact on bilateral relations.
For example, Albania's support for Kosovo's independence has strained its relations with Serbia.
Similarly, issues related to the ethnic Albanian community in North Macedonia have affected
Albania's relations with North Macedonia.

These dynamics have significant implications for Albania's EU integration process. The EU
emphasizes regional stability as a key criterion for membership. Therefore, managing the
"Albanian factor" in a way that promotes regional stability is crucial for Albania's path towards
EU membership.

4.3 The Role of the Albanian Government and Diaspora

The Albanian diaspora is a significant factor in Albania's EU integration process. Remittances

from the diaspora account for approximately 9% of Albania's GDP, and the diaspora has been
active in advocating for the rights of ethnic Albanians in their host countries. A balanced and
constructive approach from the Albanian government and the diaspora can promote regional
stability, improve inter-state relations, and advance Albania's path towards EU membership.

The Albanian diaspora is a large and diverse group. It is estimated that there are over 2 million
Albanians living outside of Albania, with the largest concentrations in the United States, Italy,
Greece, and Germany. The diaspora is a source of significant remittances, which are estimated to
account for approximately 9% of Albania's GDP. Remittances are a major source of income for
many Albanian families, and they help to support the Albanian economy.

The Albanian diaspora is also politically active. Albanians living abroad have been active in
advocating for the rights of ethnic Albanians in their host countries. They have also been involved
in efforts to promote democracy and development in Albania. The diaspora's political influence is
significant, and it can play a positive role in Albania's EU integration process.

The Albanian government and the diaspora can work together to promote Albania's EU integration
process. A balanced and constructive approach can help to address the concerns of both the
Albanian government and the diaspora. This can help to promote regional stability, improve inter-
state relations, and advance Albania's path towards EU membership.

The Albanian government should continue to engage with the diaspora and to address their
concerns. The diaspora should continue to support Albania's EU integration process and to
advocate for the rights of ethnic Albanians. A balanced and constructive approach from both the
Albanian government and the diaspora can help to promote Albania's EU integration process.

The following are some specific examples of how the Albanian government and the diaspora can
work together to promote Albania's EU integration process:

* The Albanian government can establish a diaspora advisory council to provide input on EU
integration-related policies.
* The Albanian government can provide funding for diaspora-led projects that promote democracy
and development in Albania.
* The diaspora can support Albanian businesses and invest in Albania's economy.
* The diaspora can advocate for Albania's EU membership in their host countries.

A balanced and constructive approach from the Albanian government and the diaspora can help to
promote Albania's EU integration process.

4.4 The EU's Interpretation of the "Albanian Factor"

The European Union's interpretation of the "Albanian factor" is a critical element in Albania's
trajectory towards EU membership. The EU has consistently underscored the importance of
regional stability, harmonious inter-state relations, and adherence to minority rights as essential
prerequisites for EU membership (European Commission, 2019).

In the context of the "Albanian factor," the EU has continually advocated for Albania to assume a
constructive role in bolstering regional stability and resolving bilateral disputes. In its
comprehensive 2020 report on Albania, the European Commission extolled Albania's proactive
contributions to regional stability and its enhanced relations with other Western Balkan nations.
Nonetheless, it simultaneously emphasized the necessity for Albania to sustain and augment its
efforts in these domains (European Commission, 2020).

In the context of the "Albanian factor," the EU has consistently encouraged Albania to play a
constructive role in promoting regional stability and resolving bilateral disputes. According to the
latest available report from the European Commission in 2022, Albania has been recognized for
its proactive contributions to regional stability and improved relations with other Western Balkan
countries. However, the report also underscores the importance of Albania maintaining and
expanding its efforts in these areas. This highlights the ongoing significance of the "Albanian
factor" in regional dynamics and Albania's path towards EU integration. For the most accurate and
current information, I recommend referring directly to the 2022 European Commission report on
Albania.

The EU's stance on these issues fundamentally shapes Albania's EU integration process. By
aligning its policies with the EU's expectations, Albania can effectively maneuver through the
intricacies of the "Albanian factor" and expedite its journey towards EU membership.

4.5 The Way Forward: Addressing the "Albanian Factor

Addressing the "Albanian Factor" effectively is pivotal for Albania's successful integration into
the EU. This requires a multifaceted approach that includes enhancing regional stability,
improving inter-state relations, and promoting minority rights.

Firstly, Albania must continue to play a constructive role in fostering regional stability. This
includes maintaining good relations with neighbouring countries and resolving any bilateral
disputes through diplomatic channels.

Secondly, Albania should strive to improve its inter-state relations, particularly with Serbia, given
the historical tensions between the two countries. This could involve diplomatic dialogues,
confidence-building measures, and cooperation in areas of mutual interest. Improved relations with
Serbia would not only contribute to regional stability but also enhance Albania's prospects for EU
membership.
The emphasis on Albania's need to bolster its efforts in protecting minority rights and promoting
social inclusion is significant in this context for several reasons. Firstly, it is crucial for
marginalized groups like the Roma and Egyptians, who often face social and economic exclusion.

Secondly, the European Commission has acknowledged that although Albania has made strides
towards this goal, there are still considerable hurdles to overcome (European Commission, 2019).
This is important because addressing these challenges aligns with the criteria for EU membership
- a key goal for Albania.

Thirdly, beyond the EU membership criterion, enhancing minority rights and social inclusion
contributes to social cohesion within Albania. A more inclusive society is likely to be more stable
and harmonious, which is beneficial for Albania's overall development and its standing on the
international stage. Therefore, this point is crucial in the broader context of Albania's socio-
political progress and its aspirations towards EU integration.

In conclusion, addressing the "Albanian Factor" effectively is crucial for Albania's EU integration
process. By taking these steps, Albania can enhance its prospects for EU membership and
contribute to peace and stability in the Western Balkans.

4.6 Case Studies

This section provides case studies of specific incidents or issues related to the "Albanian Factor"
that have had a significant impact on Albania's EU integration process. These case studies offer
valuable insights into the complex dynamics at play and their implications for Albania's EU
membership bid.

4.6.1 The Greek-Albanian Relations

The Greek-Albanian relations have been a critical component of the "Albanian Factor" due to the
presence of a significant Greek minority in Albania and historical disputes between the two
countries. In recent years, Albania has made considerable efforts to improve its relations with
Greece, including resolving issues related to the Greek minority in Albania (European
Commission, 2019)12. This has been viewed positively by the EU, which sees good neighborly
relations as a key criterion for EU membership (European Commission, 2020)13.

4.6.2 The Kosovo Issue

The Kosovo issue is another key aspect of the "Albanian Factor." Albania's stance on Kosovo's
independence and its relations with Serbia have significant implications for regional stability in
the Western Balkans (European Commission, 2020). Albania's constructive role in facilitating
dialogue between Kosovo and Serbia has been commended by the EU, demonstrating its
commitment to regional stability (Council of the European Union, 2023)14.

4.6.3 Addressing Minority Rights: The Case of Roma and Egyptian Communities

The situation of Roma and Egyptian communities in Albania is a vital aspect of the broader
discussion on minority rights, which is intrinsically linked to the "Albanian Factor". Despite facing
numerous challenges, Albania has made strides in promoting the social inclusion of these
marginalized groups. This progress aligns with the EU's emphasis on human rights and social
inclusion (European Commission, 2019). Nonetheless, additional efforts are required to fully
satisfy the EU's expectations in this area (European Parliament, 2022).

In the context of the "Albanian Factor", the treatment of Roma and Egyptian communities reflects
Albania's commitment to minority rights, social inclusion, and human rights - all of which are
crucial criteria for EU membership. Therefore, their situation is a significant part of the broader
dynamics that influence Albania's EU integration process.

In conclusion, these case studies shed light on the intricacies of the "Albanian Factor" and its
implications for Albania's journey towards EU membership. They underscore the necessity for
Albania to persist in its efforts to effectively address these issues, thereby enhancing its chances
of joining the EU.

4.7 Strengthening Regional Stability

Albania should continue its efforts to foster good neighborly relations and contribute to regional
stability. This includes resolving any bilateral issues with neighboring countries through
diplomatic channels and playing a constructive role in regional initiatives (European Commission,
2020).

4.7.1 Enhancing Minority Rights Protection

12
European Commission. (2019). Albania 2019 Report. Brussels: European Commission.
13
European Commission. (2020). Albania 2020 Report. Brussels: European Commission.
14
Council of the European Union. (2023). Council Conclusions on Albania. Brussels: Council of the European Union.
Albania needs to strengthen its policies and practices for protecting minority rights. This includes
improving the social inclusion of marginalized groups like the Roma and Egyptians, and
addressing any discrimination or inequality faced by these communities (European Parliament,
2022).

4.7.2 Engaging the Albanian Diaspora

The Albanian diaspora can play a crucial role in shaping the "Albanian Factor." Albania should
engage with its diaspora to leverage their influence in promoting a positive image of Albania,
advocating for Albania's interests, and fostering mutual understanding between Albania and EU
member states (European Commission, 2019).

4.8 Implications of the "Albanian Factor" on EU Enlargement Policy

The "Albanian Factor" holds significant weight in shaping the EU's enlargement policy. Grasping
the nuances of this factor can enable the EU to customize its policy, addressing Albania's distinct
challenges and opportunities during the integration process. This section will explore how the EU
can integrate knowledge of the "Albanian Factor" into its policy, emphasizing regional stability,
inter-state relations, and the promotion of European Union values.

4.8.1 Enhancing Regional Stability

The EU can utilize the "Albanian Factor" to fortify regional stability in the Western Balkans. By
acknowledging Albania's role in promoting harmonious relations and regional stability, the EU
can offer support and incentives for Albania to maintain these efforts. This could involve
encouraging dialogue with neighboring countries, offering conflict resolution assistance, and
acknowledging Albania's contributions in its progress reports (European Commission, 2020).

4.8.2 Strengthening Inter-State Relations

Comprehending the "Albanian Factor" can assist the EU in strengthening inter-state relations. The
EU can motivate Albania to diplomatically resolve bilateral issues with neighboring countries and
constructively participate in regional initiatives. The EU can also endorse cultural exchange and
mutual understanding between Albania and other EU member states, utilizing the Albanian
diaspora as cultural intermediaries (European Commission, 2019).

4.8.3 Promoting EU Values

Finally, the "Albanian Factor" can contribute significantly to promoting European Union values.
By prioritizing minority rights protection and social inclusion in its evaluation of the "Albanian
Factor," the EU can inspire Albania to align its policies with European values. The EU can
additionally support Albania's efforts to enhance social inclusion for marginalized groups and
protect minority rights (European Parliament, 2022).
In conclusion, a thorough understanding of the "Albanian Factor" can significantly improve the
efficacy of the EU's enlargement policy. By integrating this understanding, the EU can enhance
regional stability, strengthen inter-state relations, and promote its values in the Western Balkans.

CHAPTER 5 : IMPLICATIONS AND STRATEGIES FOR ALBANIA'S EU

MEMBERSHIP PROCESS

5.1 Implications of Findings

The findings of our study, based on data collected and analyzed from various sources including
the World Bank, the European Commission, and scholarly articles, have significant implications
for Albania's EU membership process.

5.2 Leveraging Unique Assets

Understanding the implications of our findings necessitates a strategic approach by Albania to

capitalize on its unique assets. These assets - geographical location, historical ties, cultural
exchanges, and the Albanian diaspora - can be used as powerful tools in the EU membership
process.

5.3 Enhancing Attractiveness to the EU

To complement the leveraging of its unique assets and overcoming inherent challenges, Albania
can strategically position itself to be more appealing to the EU. This can be achieved through the
enhancement of political stability, the execution of comprehensive economic reforms, and the
fortification of institutional capacities.

Political stability is a cardinal factor in elevating Albania's attractiveness for EU membership. The
Fragile States Index (2021) ranks Albania at 77 out of 178 countries, signaling a moderate level of
political instability. To enhance political stability, Albania must focus on strengthening democratic
institutions, fostering good governance practices, and ensuring peaceful and democratic transitions
of power. As Balfour & Stratulat (2015) assert, political stability is a critical determinant for EU
membership as it reflects a country's capacity to fulfill the obligations that come with membership.

Economic reforms present another avenue through which Albania can boost its attractiveness. The
World Bank report (2022) highlights that despite some improvements, Albania's economy still
contends with high unemployment rates and low competitiveness. By implementing economic
reforms that foster sustainable growth, enhance competitiveness, and reduce unemployment,
Albania can present itself as a more attractive candidate for EU membership. These reforms could
encompass improving the business environment, fostering innovation, and investing in human
capital development. The European Commission's report (2020) underscores that economic
stability and consistent growth are pivotal criteria for EU membership.

Institutional capacity strengthening is another crucial aspect of enhancing Albania's attractiveness

to the EU. This involves bolstering the efficiency and effectiveness of public institutions and
ensuring their adherence to principles of good governance. The European Commission's report
(2020) emphasizes the need for Albania to amplify its administrative capacity to effectively
implement and enforce EU laws. This could involve concerted investment in training and
development for public servants, refining administrative procedures, and implementing robust
accountability mechanisms.

In essence, enhancing Albania's attractiveness to the EU necessitates a multifaceted approach that

simultaneously addresses political stability, economic reforms, and institutional capacities. These
strategies are congruent with the EU's accession criteria and can significantly bolster Albania's
prospects of securing EU membership. This strategic positioning requires a commitment to
consistent progress, demonstrating Albania's readiness and determination to align with the
standards and expectations of the European Union.

5.4 Accelerating Integration Process

The acceleration of Albania's integration process into the EU necessitates a comprehensive, multi-
faceted approach. This approach must amalgamate the strategic leveraging of Albania's unique
assets, adept navigation through existing challenges, enhancement of the country's attractiveness
to the EU, and the implementation of far-reaching, strategic reforms.

Each of these elements plays a crucial role in the acceleration process. The optimal utilization of
Albania's unique assets can provide a robust foundation for the country's integration efforts
(Balfour & Stratulat, 2015). Concurrently, effective navigation through existing challenges,
particularly in areas of governance, rule of law, and economic development, can help secure
Albania's stability and readiness for EU membership (European Commission, 2020).

Furthermore, by enhancing its attractiveness to the EU through political stability, comprehensive

economic reforms, and institutional capacity strengthening, Albania can position itself as a
compelling candidate for EU membership (World Bank, 2022). This involves not only meeting
the EU's accession criteria but also demonstrating a commitment to the core values and principles
of the EU.

Finally, the implementation of strategic reforms can ensure that Albania's integration process
aligns with the EU's expectations and standards (European Commission, 2020). These reforms
should be comprehensive, addressing key areas such as public administration, judiciary, and
economic policies, and should be guided by a clear and strategic roadmap.
CHAPTER 6: STRATEGIC GUIDELINES FOR ALBANIA'S EU INTEGRATION

6.1 Tackling Challenges: An Organized Approach

The primary phase in the strategic guidelines involves addressing the identified challenges, which
is crucial for Albania's EU integration. This requires an organized approach to confront
governance, economic, and social issues.

Governance-related challenges such as corruption and political instability necessitate systematic

reforms. These should focus on bolstering transparency, accountability, and adherence to the rule
of law. Potential reforms might include enhancing anti-corruption initiatives, boosting public
administration efficiency, and fostering political stability through democratic consolidation
(Balfour & Stratulat, 2015).

Economic hurdles like high unemployment rates, limited competitiveness, and regional disparities
call for comprehensive strategies. These strategies could promote entrepreneurship and innovation,
improve vocational education and training systems for skill enhancement, and implement regional
development policies to address disparities (World Bank, 2022).

Social challenges like emigration, education quality, and social inclusion are of equal importance.
Comprehensive migration policies could be formulated to manage emigration. Education quality
and accessibility could be elevated through curriculum reform and investments in educational
infrastructure. Social inclusion could be fostered through targeted social policies for marginalized
groups (European Commission, 2020).

6.2 Boosting Appeal: A Strategic Outlook

Enhancing Albania's appeal to the EU involves demonstrating its commitment to EU values and
principles and its potential to contribute positively to the EU. This necessitates strategic efforts in
political stability, economic growth, and social development.

Political stability can be fostered through democratic consolidation and governance reforms.
Economic growth can be stimulated through sustainable development strategies that enhance
competitiveness and employment. Social development can be advanced through inclusive policies
that address social challenges and capitalize on social assets (Balfour & Stratulat, 2015).

Furthermore, Albania can boost its appeal by strategically highlighting its unique assets. These
could include its strategic geographic location, rich cultural heritage, youthful demographic
profile, and potential for tourism and other industries (European Commission, 2020).

6.3 Enacting Strategic Reforms: A Holistic Approach

The final phase in the strategic guidelines involves enacting reforms that align with EU
expectations and standards. These reforms should be holistic, addressing key areas such as public
administration, judiciary, economic policies, and social policies.

The enactment of these reforms should follow a clear and strategic roadmap. This roadmap should
detail the specific steps and measures to be taken, provide a timeline for implementation, and
specify mechanisms for monitoring and evaluation. It should also anticipate potential risks and
challenges and include contingency plans to address them (European Commission, 2020).

6.4 Questionnaire

● Age

Age
15
11.864

10
6.78
5.085
5 3.39
1.695 1.695 1.695
0
18-20 20-25 25-30 30-35 40-45 45-50 55-60

These statistics appear to represent the distribution of ages in a dataset. Here's an interpretation:

1. **Age Range 18-20 years:* *

- Percent: 1.695%
- This indicates that 1.695% of the individuals in the dataset fall within the age range of 18-20
years.

2. **Age Range 20-25 years:* *

- Percent: 1.695%
- Similarly, 1.695% of the individuals are between 20-25 years old.

3. **Age Range 25-30 years:* *

- Percent: 6.78%
- The age group of 25-30 years has the highest representation with 6.78% of the dataset.

4. **Age Range 30-35 years:* *

- Percent: 11.864%
- Another significant portion of the dataset, with 11.864%, is in the age range of 30-35 years.

5. **Age Range 40-45 years:* *

- Percent: 5.085%
- About 5.085% of the individuals fall in the age group of 40-45 years.

6. **Age Range 45-50 years:* *

- Percent: 1.695%
- A smaller percentage, 1.695%, is in the age range of 45-50 years.

7. **Age Range 55-60 years:* *

- Percent: 3.39%
- The age group of 55-60 years comprises 3.39% of the dataset.

In summary, the dataset is diverse in terms of age, with a concentration in the 25-30 and 30-35 age
ranges, while other age groups also contribute to the overall distribution.

● Education
 The highest level of education
80
59.322
60

40
18.644
20 6.78 8.475 6.78 6.78
0
[Link] PhD High School [Link] or M.P Other

[Link] PhD High School [Link] or M.P Other

These statistics represent the distribution of the highest education levels attained in a dataset.
Here's an interpretation:
1. **Bachelor's Degree ( [Link] ):**
- Percent: 18.644%
- The largest group in terms of education level, with 18.644% of the dataset, has completed a
Bachelor's degree ( [Link] ).

2. ** Doctorate:* *
- Percent: 6.78%
- 6.78% of the individuals in the dataset have completed a Doctorate (Ph.D. or equivalent).

3. **High School:* *
- Percent: 8.475%
- Another significant portion (8.475%) has completed education at the high school ( Gymnasium
) level.

4. ** Master's of Science Degree or Professional Master's:* *

- Percent: 59.322%
- The majority of individuals in the dataset, comprising 59.322%, have completed either a Master's
of Science degree ( [Link] ) or a Professional Master's (MP).

5. ** Other:* *
- Percent: 6.78%
- A smaller percentage (6.78%) falls into the "Other" category, suggesting that these individuals
have educational qualifications not covered by the specified categories.
In summary, the dataset shows a diverse educational background, with a majority having Master's
degrees or Professional Master's, followed by those with Bachelor's degrees. Additionally, there
are individuals with high school diplomas and doctorates, and a smaller group with other
educational qualifications.

● How would you evaluate the impact of regional dynamics in the process of Albania's
integration into the EU:

How would you evaluate the impact of regional

dynamics in the process of Albania's integration
into the EU
Very influential 22.034
They do not influence 5.085
They affect a lot 16.949
They affect externally 1.695
They affect somehow 8.475
Extremely influential 1.695
They influence somehow 25.424
To some extent they influence 5.085
To some extent they influence 13.559

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

These statistics represent perceptions or opinions on the impact of regional dynamics on the
process of Albania's integration into the European Union (EU). Here's an interpretation:

1. **Influence to some extent:* *

- Percent: 13.559%
- About 13.559% of the respondents believe that regional dynamics have some level of influence
on Albania's integration into the EU.

2. ** Impact to some extent:* *

- Percent: 5.085%
- A smaller percentage, 5.085%, believes that regional dynamics impact the integration process to
some extent.

3. **Influence somewhat:* *
- Percent: 25.424%
- The highest percentage, 25.424%, suggests that regional dynamics somewhat influence the
integration process.

4. ** Externally influential : * *
- Frequency: 1 individual
- Percent: 1.695%
- A very small percentage, 1.695%, perceives regional dynamics as externally influential.

5. ** They influence somewhat (Impact somewhat ):* *

- Frequency: 5 individuals
- Percent: 8.475%
- 8.475% of the respondents think that regional dynamics have some level of impact on the
integration process.

6. ** Impact externally :* *
- Frequency: 1 individual
- Percent: 1.695%
- A small percentage, 1.695%, believes that regional dynamics impact the integration process
externally.

7. ** They influence a lot (Influence a lot ):* *

- Frequency: 10 individuals
- Percent: 16.949%
- 16.949% think that regional dynamics have a significant influence on the integration process.

8. ** Do not influence : * *
- Frequency: 3 individuals
- Percent: 5.085%
- 5.085% of the respondents believe that regional dynamics will not have an influence on the
integration process.

9. ** Very influential : * *
- Frequency: 13 individuals
- Percent: 22.034%
- The second-highest percentage, 22.034%, perceives regional dynamics as very influential on the
integration process.

In summary, the dataset reflects diverse opinions on the impact of regional dynamics, with varying
degrees of perceived influence on Albania's integration into the European Union. The majority of
respondents acknowledge some level of influence, with a significant portion believing that regional
dynamics have a substantial impact on the integration process.

● In your opinion, will regional policies have a significant impact on the progress of
Albania's process in the EU?
 In your opinion, do regional policies have
a significant impact on the progress of
Albania's process in the EU?
100
79.661
80

60

40

20 8.475 11.864

0
No I don't know Po

No I don't know Po

The data represent opinions or responses to a question regarding whether regional policies have a
significant impact on the progress of Albania in the European Union (EU) integration process.
Here's an analysis:
1. **" No:* *
- ** Percent:* * 8.475%
- A small percentage of respondents (8.475%) hold the opinion that regional policies will not have
a significant impact on Albania's progress in the EU integration process.

2. **(Don't know ):* *

- ** Percent:* * 11.864%
- About 11.864% of respondents are uncertain or do not have a clear opinion on whether regional
policies influence Albania's progress in EU integration.

3. ** (Yes ):* *
- ** Percent:* * 79.661%
- The majority of respondents (79.661%) believe that regional policies will have a significant
impact on the progress of Albania in the EU integration process.

** Analysis:* *
- The high percentage (79.661%) of respondents who believe that regional policies have a
significant impact suggests a prevailing perception that regional dynamics play a crucial role in
shaping Albania's path towards EU integration.
- The presence of individuals who responded with "Don't know" (11.864%) indicates some
uncertainty or lack of clarity among a portion of the respondents regarding the influence of regional
policies.
- The minority opinion ("No" with 8.475%) suggests that there is a segment of the respondents
who perceive regional policies as having a less significant impact on the EU integration process
for Albania.

● The perceived impact of internal factors in Albania on the country's accession process
to the European Union (EU)

The provided data represents opinions or responses to a question regarding the perceived
impact of internal factors in Albania on the country's accession process to the European Union
(EU). Here's an interpretation:

How would you assess the impact of

Albania's internal circumstances in the
process of Albania's EU membership?

Very influential 44.068

A bit influential 8.475

Moderately influential 23.729

Not influential 3.39

Extremely influential 20.339

0 10 20 30 40 50

**Exceptionally influential:* *
** Percent:* * 20.339%
A notable portion of respondents (20.339%) believes that internal factors within Albania have an
exceptionally influential impact on the country's accession process to the EU.
**Not influential:* *
- ** Percent:* * 3.39%
- A small percentage (3.39%) of respondents thinks that internal factors have little to no influence
on Albania's EU accession process.
**"With influence average " (Moderately influential ):* *
- ** Percent:* * 23.729%
- Approximately 23.729% of respondents see internal factors as having a moderate level of
influence on the EU accession process for Albania.

** Slightly influential:* *
- ** Percent:* * 8.475%
- A smaller percentage (8.475%) believes that internal factors have a slightly influential impact on
the accession process.

**Very influential:* *
- ** Percent:* * 44.068%
- The majority of respondents (44.068%) perceives internal factors within Albania as very
influential in shaping the country's path towards EU membership.
** Analysis:* *

- **Variety of Perspectives:* * The data reflects a diversity of opinions, with respondents

expressing a range of views on the influence of internal factors. This diversity suggests that people
have different perceptions of the significance of internal dynamics in the EU accession process.
- **High Perception of Influence:* * A significant portion of respondents (44.068%) believes that
internal factors have a very influential role in the EU accession process. This perception
underscores the importance of addressing internal issues for successful integration.
- **Moderate and Slight Influence:* * While a considerable percentage perceives internal factors
as very influential, a significant portion also sees them as having a moderate (23.729%) or slight
(8.475%) influence. This nuanced view suggests varying degrees of impact according to different
perspectives.

In conclusion, the data suggests a range of perspectives on the influence of internal factors within
Albania on the EU accession process, emphasizing the importance of addressing these factors for
a successful integration journey.
 ● In your opinion, does the Albanian diaspora play an important role in the process of
Albania's integration into the EU?

In your opinion, does the Albanian

diaspora play an important role in
the process of Albania's integration
into the EU?
100
54.237
50 20.339 25.424

0
No I don't know Yes

No I don't know Yes

Interpretation of the statistics:

According to the given data, a meaningful interpretation can be made:
A significant portion of participants (54.237%) express the belief that the Albanian
diaspora plays an important role in the process of Albania's integration into the European Union
(EU). This widespread positive sentiment among the majority of participants indicates a positive
inclination towards the impactful role that the diaspora may have in Albania's journey towards
European integration.
On the other hand, a smaller portion (20.339%) of participants disagrees with this idea,
believing that the diaspora does not play a significant role in this process. This dissent may be
related to doubts, lack of information, or differing perspectives regarding the influence of the
diaspora on Albania's European integration.
A middle portion (25.424%) of participants does not have a clear stance and expresses
uncertainty about whether the Albanian diaspora has an important role in the EU integration
process. This group may represent a lack of information or ambivalence regarding the diaspora's
impact in this context.
Due to the varying attitudes towards the role of the diaspora, it is essential to understand
that opinions may differ based on individuals' perspectives and experiences regarding the topic of
Albania's European integration.
● Can you please assess the impact of the following factors on the process of Albania 's
integration into the EU: [Regional Political Stability]
 Please assess the impact of the following
factors on Albania's EU integration
process: [Regional political stability]

Very influential 33.898

A bit influential 15.254

Moderately influential 32.203

Not influential 3.39

Extremely influential 15.254

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

Interpretation of the statistics:

The provided data concerns the assessment of the impact of the following factors on Albania's
integration process into the European Union (EU), with a specific focus on "Regional Political
Stability." The breakdown of participant responses is as follows:
1. **Extremely Influential:* * 15.254% of participants believe that regional political stability has
an extremely significant impact on Albania's integration into the EU. This suggests that a notable
portion of respondents perceives political stability in the region as a crucial factor for Albania's
EU integration.
2. **Not Influential:* * A small proportion, 3.39%, indicates that regional political stability has
no significant influence on the integration process. This could be due to differing opinions,
perspectives, or perhaps a belief that other factors play a more critical role.

3. **Moderately Influential:* * The majority of participants, constituting 32.203%, perceive

regional political stability as having a moderate level of influence on Albania's integration. This
suggests that a significant number of respondents see political stability in the region as a factor
that contributes to integration but may not be the sole determining factor.
4. **Slightly Influential:* * Another 15.254% of participants consider regional political stability
to have a slight impact on the integration process. This indicates a segment of respondents who
believe that while stability matters, it may not be the most decisive factor.
5. **Very Influential:* * The highest percentage, 33.898%, suggests that a substantial portion of
participants views regional political stability as very influential in Albania's EU integration. This
indicates a strong belief among respondents that political stability in the region significantly
contributes to the integration process.
In summary, the data reflects diverse opinions on the impact of regional political stability, with a
considerable number of participants emphasizing its importance in the context of Albania's journey
towards EU integration.

● Please evaluate the impact of the following factors on Albania's EU integration

process: [Economic cooperation with neighboring countries]

Please evaluate the impact of the following

factors on Albania's EU integration process:
[Economic cooperation with neighboring
countries]

Very influential 30.508

A little bit influential 8.475

Moderately influential 49.153

Not influential 1.695

Extremely influential 10.169

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

Interpretation of the statistics:

The provided data focuses on assessing the impact of "Economic Cooperation with neighboring
countries" on Albania's integration process into the European Union (EU). Here is the breakdown
of participant responses:

1. **Extremely Influential:* * 10.169% of participants believe that economic cooperation with

neighboring countries has an extremely significant impact on Albania's integration into the EU.
This suggests that a portion of respondents perceive strong economic collaboration with
neighboring nations as crucial for Albania's EU integration.

2. **Not Influential:* * A very small proportion, 1.695%, indicates that economic cooperation
with neighboring countries has no significant influence on the integration process. This could be
due to differing opinions, perspectives, or perhaps a belief that other factors play a more critical
role.
3. **Moderately Influential:* * The majority of participants, constituting 49.153%, perceive
economic cooperation with neighboring countries as having a moderate level of influence on
Albania's integration. This suggests that a significant number of respondents see economic
collaboration as a contributing factor to integration, but it may not be the sole determining factor.

4. **Slightly Influential:* * Another 8.475% of participants consider economic cooperation with

neighboring countries to have a slight impact on the integration process. This indicates a segment
of respondents who believe that while economic cooperation matters, it may not be the most
decisive factor.

5. **Very Influential:* * A substantial percentage, 30.508%, suggests that many participants view
economic cooperation with neighboring countries as very influential in Albania's EU integration.
This indicates a strong belief among respondents that robust economic collaboration with
neighboring nations significantly contributes to the integration process.

In summary, the data reflects diverse opinions on the impact of economic cooperation with
neighboring countries, with a considerable number of participants emphasizing its importance in
the context of Albania's journey towards EU integration.

● Please assess the impact of the following factors on Albania's EU integration process:
[Regional cultural exchange]
 Please assess the impact of the following factors on
Albania's EU integration process: [Regional cultural
exchange]

Very influential 16.949

A little bit influential 20.339

Moderately influential 42.373

Not influential 6.78

Extremely influential 13.559

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45

Interpretation of the statistics:

The data provided pertains to the assessment of the impact of "Regional Cultural Exchange" on
Albania's integration process into the European Union (EU). Here is the breakdown of participant
responses:

1. **Extremely Influential:* * 13.559% of participants believe that regional cultural exchange has
an extremely significant impact on Albania's integration into the EU. This suggests that a notable
portion of respondents perceive cultural exchange in the region as a crucial factor for Albania's
EU integration.

2. **Not Influential:* * A small proportion, 6.78%, indicates that regional cultural exchange has
no significant influence on the integration process. This could be due to differing opinions,
perspectives, or perhaps a belief that other factors play a more critical role.

3. **Moderately Influential:* * The majority of participants, constituting 42.373%, perceive

regional cultural exchange as having a moderate level of influence on Albania's integration. This
suggests that a significant number of respondents see cultural exchange as a contributing factor to
integration, but it may not be the sole determining factor.
4. **Slightly Influential:* * Another 20.339% of participants consider regional cultural exchange
to have a slight impact on the integration process. This indicates a segment of respondents who
believe that while cultural exchange matters, it may not be the most decisive factor.

5. **Very Influential:* * A substantial percentage, 16.949%, suggests that many participants view
regional cultural exchange as very influential in Albania's EU integration. This indicates a strong
belief among respondents that cultural exchange in the region significantly contributes to the
integration process.
In summary, the data reflects diverse opinions on the impact of regional cultural exchange, with a
considerable number of participants emphasizing its importance in the context of Albania's journey
towards EU integration.

● Can you please assess the impact of the following internal conditions on the process
of Albania 's integration into the EU: [ economic stability ]

Please assess the impact of the following

internal conditions on Albania's EU
integration process: [Economic stability]

Very influential 47.458

A bit influential 6.78

Not influential 5.085

Extremely influential 40.678

0 10 20 30 40 50

Interpretation of the statistics:

The provided data focuses on assessing the impact of "Internal Economic Stability" on Albania's
integration process into the European Union (EU). Here is the breakdown of participant responses:

1. **Extremely Influential:* * A significant portion, 40.678%, of participants believe that internal

economic stability has an extremely significant impact on Albania's integration into the EU. This
suggests that a substantial majority perceives economic stability within the country as a crucial
factor for Albania's EU integration.

2. **Not Influential:* * A small proportion, 5.085%, indicates that internal economic stability has
no significant influence on the integration process. This could be due to differing opinions,
perspectives, or perhaps a belief that other factors play a more critical role.

3. **Slightly Influential:* * Another 6.78% of participants consider internal economic stability to

have a slight impact on the integration process. This indicates a segment of respondents who
believe that while economic stability matters, it may not be the most decisive factor.

4. **Very Influential:* * The highest percentage, 47.458%, suggests that a substantial portion of
participants views internal economic stability as very influential in Albania's EU integration. This
indicates a strong belief among respondents that economic stability within the country significantly
contributes to the integration process.

In summary, the data reflects a consensus among participants regarding the importance of internal
economic stability in the context of Albania's journey towards EU integration, with a majority
emphasizing its significant impact.

● Assessing the impact of "Political Reforms" as internal conditions on Albania's

integration process into the European Union (EU)
 Please assess the impact of the following
internal conditions on Albania's EU
integration process: [Political reforms]

Very influential 37.288

A little bit influential 8.475

Not influential 3.39

Extremely influential 50.847

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

Interpretation of the statistics:

The provided data focuses on assessing the impact of "Political Reforms" as int ernal
conditions on Albania's integration process into the European Union (EU). Here is the
breakdown of participant responses:

1. **Extremely Influential:* * A significant majority, comprising 50.847% of participants,

believes that political reforms have an extremely significant impact on Albania's
integration into the EU. This indicates that a substantial portion of respondents considers
political reforms within the country as a crucial and decisive factor for Albania's EU
integration.

2. **Not Influential:* * A very small proportion, 3.39%, indicates that political reforms
have no significant influence on the integration process. This could be due to differing
opinions, perspectives, or perhaps a belief that other factors play a more critical role.

3. **Slightly Influential:* * Another 8.475% of participants consider political reforms to

have a slight impact on the integration process. This suggests a segment of respondents
who believe that, while political reforms matter, they may not be the most decisive factor
in the overall integration process.

4. **Very Influential:* * A substantial percentage, 37.288%, suggests that many

participants view political reforms as very influential in Albania's EU integration. This
indicates a strong belief among respondents that political reforms significantly contribute
to the integration process.

In summary, the data reflects a clear consensus among participants regarding the
importance of political reforms as internal conditions in the context of Albania's journey
towards EU integration, with a majority emphasizing their significant impact.
 ● Can you please assess the impact of the following internal conditions on the process
of Albania's integration into the EU : [ Social development ]

Please assess the impact of the

following internal conditions on
Albania's EU integration …
44.068
A little bit influential 10.169
3.39
Extremely influential 42.373
0 10 20 30 40 50

The data illustrates the perceived impact of internal conditions, specifically related to social
development, on Albania's process of integration into the European Union. The percentages show
the level of impact assigned to these internal conditions:

- Very impactful: 44.068%

- Slightly impactful: 10.169%
- Not impactful: 3.39%
- Extremely impactful: 42.373%

This suggests that the majority of respondents consider social development to have a significant
and extremely impactful role in the integration process, with a smaller percentage indicating a
slight impact, and a very small percentage perceiving no impact.

Analysis & Interpretation:

1. Age Distribution: The data presents a diverse age distribution, reflecting a broad demographic
landscape in Albania. The significant representation in the 25-30 and 30-35 age ranges indicates
the presence of a sizeable working-age population. This demographic makeup may influence the
formulation of economic and social policies, as well as the labor market dynamics during the
integration process.

2. Educational Background: The prevalence of Master's degrees or Professional Master's among

the dataset suggests a well-educated population. The high percentage of individuals with advanced
degrees can have implications for the expertise and skills available within the workforce.
Additionally, the presence of individuals with doctorates and high school diplomas signals a
diverse educational landscape, highlighting the need for tailored educational and employment
policies to address various skill levels and qualifications.
3. Regional Dynamics Impact: The varying viewpoints on the influence of regional dynamics on
Albania's EU integration process indicate a complex interplay of regional relationships,
geopolitical factors, and cultural influences. Understanding and addressing these diverse
perspectives are critical for fostering inclusive regional cooperation and harmonizing efforts
towards EU integration.

4. Regional Policies' Impact: The majority opinion that regional policies will significantly impact
Albania's EU integration underscores the importance of strategic regional collaboration. This
implies the need for proactive engagement with neighboring countries and the establishment of
mutually beneficial policies and agreements to facilitate a smooth integration process.

5. Internal Factors' Impact: The contrasting perceptions of internal factors, such as economic
stability and political reforms, highlight the need for internal alignment and consensus-building
within Albania. The differing opinions signify the potential existence of varied socio-political
priorities and ideals, underlining the necessity for inclusive governance and comprehensive policy
frameworks.

6. Albanian Diaspora's Role: The varied attitudes towards the role of the Albanian diaspora in the
EU integration process suggest the presence of different perspectives and experiences regarding
the influence of the diaspora on Albania's journey towards European integration. This underscores
the importance of understanding and leveraging the potential contributions of the diaspora
community in facilitating successful integration.

7. Regional Political Stability: The diversity of opinions on the impact of regional political stability
points to the complexity of regional dynamics in the context of EU integration. The contrasting
viewpoints highlight the need for nuanced strategies to address regional political stability as a
significant factor in the integration process.

8. Economic Cooperation with Neighboring Countries: The perceptions of economic cooperation

with neighboring countries as influential emphasize the significance of fostering robust economic,
trade, and investment ties with neighboring nations for mutual prosperity and successful EU
integration.

9. Regional Cultural Exchange: The varying perspectives on the impact of regional cultural
exchange underscore the richness of regional diversity and the need to recognize and promote
cultural exchange as a valuable component of the integration journey. This suggests the importance
of fostering cultural understanding and collaboration to strengthen regional bonds and promote
intercultural dialogue.

10. Internal Economic Stability: The overwhelming belief in the significant impact of internal
economic stability underlines the critical role of economic reforms, stability, and sustainable
development within Albania. This emphasizes the imperative for sound economic policies,
investment in infrastructure, and the creation of conducive business environments to support
Albania's integration into the EU.
11. Political Reforms: The consensus on the influential role of political reforms as internal
conditions in the integration process signifies the recognition of governance stability and
institutional reforms as pivotal factors in shaping Albania's path towards EU membership. This
points to the necessity of fostering political stability, upholding the rule of law, and strengthening
democratic institutions to advance the integration agenda.

12. Social Development: The recognition of social development as significantly impactful reflects
the acknowledgment of social factors, such as welfare, education, and healthcare, as crucial
components of Albania's integration journey. The understanding of the pivotal role of social
development underscores the need for inclusive social policies and sustainable development
initiatives to address societal needs and promote social cohesion.

Implications:

1. Policy Formulation: The diverse demographic and educational profiles necessitate the
formulation of inclusive and adaptive policies that address the varying needs and aspirations of the
population. Tailored educational, employment, and social welfare policies can contribute to
fostering an inclusive and equitable society.

2. Regional Cooperation: Understanding and addressing the differing perceptions of regional

dynamics and policies is crucial for fostering cohesive regional cooperation in the integration
process. Active diplomatic engagement, cultural exchange programs, and collaborative initiatives
can promote regional integration and harmonious relations.

3. Internal Alignment: The contrasting perceptions of the impact of internal factors, such as
economic stability and political reforms, highlight the importance of embracing inclusive
governance, stakeholder engagement, and consensus-building to address internal priorities and
propel the integration process.

4. Engagement with Diaspora: Given the varied attitudes towards the role of the diaspora in the
integration process, there is a need for strategic engagement with the Albanian diaspora to
understand and leverage their potential contributions in the areas of economic development,
cultural exchange, and advocacy for Albania's EU integration.

5. Diplomatic and Economic Ties: The emphasis on the significant impact of economic
cooperation with neighboring countries

CHAPTER 7: CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Based on the material provided, the research is centered around the complex and multifaceted
process of European Union (EU) enlargement, with a particular emphasis on the case of Albania.
The research question aims to delve deeper into the unique challenges that Albania has faced due
to its distinctive political history and economic conditions, and how the regional dynamics of the
Western Balkans have affected these challenges and the overall accession process.
7.1 Findings:

1. The EU enlargement process is a comprehensive and demanding procedure that requires

candidate countries to go through rigorous assessments, engage in extensive negotiations, and
implement substantial reforms. It necessitates that candidate countries establish stable institutions
that uphold democracy, protect human rights, respect minorities, and demonstrate economic
resilience.

2. Albania's journey towards EU membership has been characterized by significant political and
economic reforms designed to align its national structures with EU norms and standards. Despite
confronting numerous challenges deeply rooted in its unique political history and economic
circumstances, Albania has shown unwavering commitment towards its goal of European
integration.

3. The dynamics of EU enlargement are significantly influenced by regional factors such as

geopolitical situation, economic disparities, historical relationships between countries, and
attitudes of existing EU member states. These regional dynamics have played a pivotal role in
shaping the trajectory and pace of Albania's accession process.

7.2 Conclusions:

1. The pursuit of EU membership by Albania is a complex process intricately shaped by its unique
political history, economic circumstances, and regional dynamics within the Western Balkans.

2. The distinctive challenges faced by Albania in its EU accession process are significantly
influenced by its specific political history and economic conditions.

3. The regional dynamics in the Western Balkans have a profound influence on Albania's journey
towards EU membership.

7.3 Recommendations:

1. It is imperative for Albania to maintain its focus on aligning its national structures with EU
norms and standards to meet the Copenhagen criteria for EU enlargement.

2. Policymakers need to consider the regional dynamics within the Western Balkans when
formulating strategies for Albania's EU accession process.

3. Further research should be conducted to provide a more nuanced understanding of how regional
dynamics impact individual countries' EU accession processes.
7.4 Verification of Research Question and Hypotheses:

The research question was addressed through an exhaustive examination of Albania's unique
political history, economic conditions, and regional dynamics within the Western Balkans. The
findings lend support to the hypothesis that these factors have significantly shaped the challenges
that Albania faces in its EU accession process.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

- Anastasakis, O. (2008). The EU's political conditionality in the Western Balkans: towards a more
pragmatic approach. Southeast European and Black Sea Studies, 8(4), 365-377.
- Biberaj, E. (2010). Albania in Transition: The Rocky Road to Democracy.
- Biberaj, E. (2018). Albania in Transition: The Rocky Road to Democracy. Boulder, CO:
Westview Press.
- Bieber, F. (2018). Patterns of competitive authoritarianism in the Western Balkans. East
European Politics, 34(3), 337-354.
- Bogdani, M. (2019). Albania and the European Union: The Tumultuous Journey Towards
Integration and Accession.
- Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology.
- British Educational Research Association (2018). Ethical guidelines for educational research.
- Ceka, B., & Kalemaj, I. (2019). Albania–Italy Relations: The Economic Dimension.
- Creswell, J.W., & Plano Clark, V.L. (2017). Designing and conducting mixed methods research.
- Dervishi, K. (2012). Albania and the European Union: The Tumultuous Journey Towards
Integration and Accession. London: I.B. Tauris.
- Elbasani, A. (2009). EU enlargement in the Western Balkans: strategies of borrowing and
inventing.
- Elbasani, A. (2013). European Integration and Transformation in the Western Balkans:
Europeanization or Business as Usual? Abingdon, UK: Routledge.
- Elbasani, A., & Šabič, Z. (2018). Rule of law, corruption and democratic accountability in the
course of EU enlargement. Journal of European Public Policy, 25(9), 1317-1335.
- European Commission (2006). Stabilisation and Association Agreement between the European
Communities and their Member States and Albania.
- European Commission (2009). Albania 2009 Progress Report.
- European Commission (2014). Albania: The granting of candidate status.
- European Commission. (2018). Albania 2018 Report. Brussels: European Commission.
- European Commission. (2022). Standard Eurobarometer 92: Public Opinion in the European
Union.
- European Council (2020). Council conclusions on enlargement and stabilisation and association
process - Albania and North Macedonia.
- Eurostat (2021). EU Trade Since 1988 by CN8 [DS-018995].
- Field, A. (2013). Discovering statistics using IBM SPSS statistics.
- Government of Albania. (2020). National Plan for European Integration 2020-2024.
- International Monetary Fund. (2020). Albania: 2020 Article IV Consultation-Press Release; Staff
Report; and Statement by the Executive Director for Albania. IMF Country Report No. 20/78.
- Italian National Institute of Statistics (ISTAT) (2022). Resident Population by Sex - Foreigners.
- King, R., & Mai, N. (2008). Out of Albania: From crisis migration to social inclusion in Italy.
Berghahn Books.
- Mai, N. (2005). The Albanian Diaspora-in-the-Making: Media, Migration and Social Exclusion.
- Migration Policy Institute (MPI) (2020). The Albanian Diaspora: From the Balkans to the World.
- Papadimitriou, D., & Petrov, P. (2012). Whose Rule, Whose Law? Contested Statehood, External
Leverage and the European Union’s Rule of Law Mission in Kosovo. Journal of Common Market
Studies, 50(5), 746-763.
- Papavasilopoulos, G. (2020). Greek-Albanian Relations: The Weight of History and the
Necessity for Transformation.
- Pippan, C. (2004). The rocky road to Europe: the EU's stabilisation and association process for
the Western Balkans and the principle of conditionality. European Foreign Affairs Review, 9(2),
219-245.
- Schimmelfennig, F., & Trauner, F. (2009). Post-accession compliance in the EU’s new member
states. European Integration Online Papers, 13(2), 1-20.
- Stratulat, C., & Dolidze, T. (2014). Reviewing the EU's approach towards its Eastern neighbours
and the Western Balkans.
- Transparency International. (2022). Corruption Perceptions Index 2022.
- Vurmo, G. (2018). The Stabilisation and Association Agreement between Albania and the EU:
An effective instrument for democracy promotion?
- Vurmo, Gjergji. (2013). Albania's Relations with the EU: The History and Future of a
Tumultuous Relationship.
- Wooldridge, J.M. (2015). Introductory econometrics: A modern approach. Nelson Education.
- World Bank (2018). The Western Balkans: Revving Up the Engines of Growth and Prosperity.
- World Bank (2019). Trade (% of GDP) - Albania.
- World Travel and Tourism Council (WTTC) (2021). Economic Impact Reports: Albania 2021.

ANNEX

**QUESTIONNAIRE**

**SECTION A: DEMOGRAPHICS**

1. What is your professional role?

- Academic
- Government official
- EU official
- NGO worker
- Other (please specify)

2. What is your highest level of education?

- High school diploma
 - Bachelor's degree
- Master's degree
- Doctorate degree
- Other (please specify)

**SECTION B: UNDERSTANDING OF REGIONAL DYNAMICS AND ALBANIA'S EU

INTEGRATION**

3. How would you rate the influence of regional dynamics on Albania's EU integration process?
- Not influential
- Slightly influential
- Moderately influential
- Very influential
- Extremely influential

4. In your opinion, do regional politics have a significant impact on Albania's progress towards
EU integration?
- Yes
- No
- Unsure

**SECTION C: INSIGHTS INTO THE ALBANIAN FACTOR IN EU INTEGRATION**

5. How would you rate the influence of domestic conditions on Albania's EU integration process?
- Not influential
- Slightly influential
- Moderately influential
- Very influential
- Extremely influential

6. In your opinion, does the Albanian diaspora play a significant role in Albania's EU integration
process?
- Yes
- No
- Unsure

**SECTION D: DEEPER EXPLORATION OF REGIONAL DYNAMICS**

7. Please rate the influence of the following factors on Albania's EU integration process:
- Regional political stability (Not influential / Slightly influential / Moderately influential / Very
influential / Extremely influential)
- Economic cooperation with neighboring countries (Not influential / Slightly influential /
Moderately influential / Very influential / Extremely influential)
- Regional cultural exchange and understanding (Not influential / Slightly influential /
Moderately influential / Very influential / Extremely influential)
**SECTION E: DEEPER EXPLORATION OF THE ALBANIAN FACTOR**

8. Please rate the influence of the following domestic conditions on Albania's EU integration
process:
- Economic stability (Not influential / Slightly influential / Moderately influential / Very
influential / Extremely influential)
- Political reforms (Not influential / Slightly influential / Moderately influential / Very influential
/ Extremely influential)
- Social development (Not influential / Slightly influential / Moderately influential / Very
influential / Extremely influential)

9. Please rate the role of the Albanian diaspora in terms of:

- Economic contributions (e.g., remittances) (Not influential / Slightly influential / Moderately
influential / Very influential / Extremely influential)
- Political influence (e.g., lobbying) (Not influential / Slightly influential / Moderately influential
/ Very influential / Extremely influential)
- Cultural exchange (Not influential / Slightly influential / Moderately influential / Very
influential / Extremely influential)

**SECTION F: FUTURE OF ALBANIA'S EU INTEGRATION**

10. How optimistic are you about Albania's future in the EU integration process?
- Not optimistic at all
- Slightly optimistic
- Neutral
- Optimistic
- Very optimistic

11. In your opinion, what are the key steps that Albania should take to accelerate its EU integration
process? (Open-ended question)