ASSIGNMENT:2
MOTION ANALYSIS METHODS
INTRODUCTION:
Motion analysis in the human body is a critical aspect of
understanding the biomechanics, physiology, and pathology of
human movement. For physiotherapists, an in-depth
comprehension of motion analysis can assist in diagnosing
musculoskeletal dysfunctions, formulating effective treatment
strategies, and improving rehabilitation outcomes. The complexity
of human movement requires a combination of technological
methods and clinical expertise to provide a comprehensive
analysis.
OBJECTIVE:
This assignment will explore various methods of motion analysis,
their applications in physiotherapy, and discuss their reliability,
validity, and limitations.
IMPORTANCE OF MOTION ANALYSIS IN PHYSIOTHERAPY:
Human motion is a complex interaction between bones, muscles,
nerves, and joints. Understanding movement patterns is crucial
for:
✓Assessing Movement Disorders: Identifying pathological gait
patterns, joint dysfunctions, or muscle weaknesses.
✓Monitoring Rehabilitation Progress: Measuring improvements in
range of motion, gait, or muscle activation during therapy.
✓Preventing Injuries: Analyzing biomechanics to detect faulty
movement patterns that may predispose patients to injuries.
✓Optimizing Performance: Improving efficiency and mechanics in
sports or daily activities.
TYPES OF MOTION ANALYSIS METHODS
✓QUALITATIVE METHODS:
1. Observational motion analysis
It relies on the clinician’s ability to visually assess the quality of a
patient’s movement. This technique can include an evaluation of
posture, gait, joint movement, and muscle activation.
Application in Physiotherapy:
- Gait Observation: Used in everyday clinical practice to
evaluate patients with movement disorders, like cerebral
palsy, stroke, or musculoskeletal injuries.
- Posture Assessment: Identifies abnormal postural patterns,
muscle imbalances, and compensatory movements that
might contribute to pain or dysfunction.
- Movement Screening: For athletes or patients post-surgery,
observational analysis is often used to screen for movement
abnormalities that could cause future injuries.
Advantages:
- Quick and requires no equipment. Can be applied in various
settings, including the clinic or at home.
Limitations:
- Subjective and depends heavily on the observer’s expertise.
- It lacks the objectivity and quantification necessary for
precise diagnostic or research purposes.
Reliability & Validity:
Observational motion analysis has low reliability due to inter-
observer variability. Its validity is moderate for gross movements
but poor for subtle or complex motions.
✓QUANTITATIVE METHODS:
1. Optical Motion Capture Systems (MoCap)
Optical motion capture (MOCAP) systems use multiple cameras to
record the movement of reflective markers placed on the
patient’s body. This method allows for accurate 3D reconstruction
of human movement in real time.
Example: The Vicon motion capture system is a commonly used
marker-based system. It is capable of capturing fine details of
motion, making it ideal for applications like animation and
medical analysis.
Application in Physiotherapy:
- Gait Analysis: MOCAP is widely used in gait analysis,
especially for patients with walking difficulties due to
neurological or orthopedic conditions. It provides a precise
evaluation of joint kinematics and movement patterns.
- Post-Injury Rehabilitation: Helps in monitoring the recovery
process, especially in cases like ACL reconstruction or joint
replacements. Quantitative data helps compare pre- and
post-intervention movement quality.
- Sports Performance Analysis: In athletes, MOCAP is used to
detect inefficiencies or improper mechanics, aiding in
performance optimization and injury prevention.
Advantages:
- High accuracy in tracking complex movements
- Established technology with a wide range of applications
Limitations:
- Expensive and requires controlled environments
- Marker placement can be cumbersome and intrusive for
subjects
Reliability & Validity:
Optical motion capture systems have high reliability and validity
when used in controlled environments, making them the gold
standard for motion analysis in biomechanics research.
2. Inertial Measurement Units (IMUs)
IMUs are wearable sensors that combine accelerometers,
gyroscopes, and magnetometers to measure linear acceleration,
angular velocity, and orientation of the body in real time.
Application in Physiotherapy:
- Functional Movement Analysis: IMUs are used to analyze
movement in more naturalistic settings, such as during daily
activities or athletic performance. They are particularly
useful in remote patient monitoring.
- Gait and Balance Assessments: IMUs provide quantitative
data on gait parameters (e.g., cadence, stride length) and
balance control, especially in elderly populations or post-
stroke patients.
- Rehabilitation Monitoring: In the rehabilitation process, IMUs
help track changes in movement quality over time, enabling
objective assessment of progress.
Advantages:
- Portable and less expensive than optical systems
- Can be used outdoors and in less controlled environments
Limitations:
- Susceptible to drift errors over time
- Less accurate than optical systems for capturing fine or
complex movements
Reliability & Validity:
IMUs have shown good reliability for dynamic tasks such as
walking or running but may have lower validity for tasks requiring
precision joint kinematics, especially in complex multi-joint
movements.
3. Computer Vision-Based Techniques
Computer vision-based methods used Artificial intelligence to
analyze motion from video data to estimate human pose and
motion, typically without requiring physical markers. These
methods have seen significant development due to advances in
machine learning and artificial intelligence.
*️⃣2D Pose Estimation: These systems detect and track human
joints and body parts in a 2D space. They are commonly used in
video surveillance, gesture recognition, and sports broadcasting.
While they can estimate joint movements, depth information may
be limited.
Example: OpenPose is a popular open-source framework
used for detecting human poses in 2D.
*️⃣3D Pose Estimation: This method involves estimating the position
of joints in 3D space, often using multiple camera views or depth
sensors. Machine learning techniques are also used to improve
accuracy by learning from large datasets of human movements.
Example: The DeepLabCut framework uses deep learning
techniques to track and analyze animal and human poses,
and has been used in neuroscientific studies and behavioral
research.
*️⃣Mobile applications: They are becoming a valuable tool for
physiotherapists and athletes, offering a convenient and
accessible way to track and analyze movement in various
settings.
Example: Hudl technique, dartfish, Coach’seye, Myomojo, Physio
lab, Kinetisense etc.,
Advantages:
- Non-invasive and does not require physical markers
- Can be used in real-world, uncontrolled environments
Disadvantages:
- Accuracy depends on lighting conditions and camera quality
- Can struggle with occlusion and overlapping body parts
4. Force Plates
Force plates measure the ground reaction forces (GRF) exerted by
the body during movement, providing data on balance, weight
distribution, and force generation during tasks like walking or
jumping.
Application in Physiotherapy:
- Balance and Postural Control: Force plates are used to assess
balance in patients with vestibular disorders, postural
instability, or following a stroke.
- Gait Analysis: Force plates provide data on the vertical,
anterior-posterior, and medial-lateral forces during walking,
offering insights into symmetry, gait patterns, and load
distribution.
- Jump and Landing Mechanics: In sports rehabilitation, force
plates help analyze jumping mechanics, landing forces, and
shock absorption strategies, especially in athletes recovering
from lower limb injuries.
Advantages:
- Provides highly accurate and detailed data on the forces
involved in various movements.
- Useful in both clinical and research settings.
Limitations:
- Expensive, and limited to controlled laboratory
environments.
- The setup may not fully replicate real-world conditions.
Reliability & Validity:
Force plates are highly reliable and valid for analyzing ground
reaction forces, making them a valuable tool in gait analysis,
balance assessment, and sports performance evaluations.
5. 3D Gait Analysis Systems
3D gait analysis systems integrate several technologies, including
optical motion capture, force plates, and EMG, to provide a
comprehensive assessment of gait dynamics. These systems are
used to assess the entire kinetic chain during walking or running.
Application in Physiotherapy:
- Gait Rehabilitation: Used in patients with gait impairments
due to conditions like cerebral palsy, stroke, or joint
replacements. It provides detailed data on joint angles,
muscle activity, and ground reaction forces.
- Orthotic and Prosthetic Evaluation: Helps assess the
effectiveness of orthotic devices or prosthetics in restoring
normal gait patterns in amputees or patients with limb
deformities.
- Sports Performance: Offers in-depth analysis of running
biomechanics to help athletes improve efficiency and
prevent overuse injuries.
Advantages:
- Provides the most comprehensive analysis of gait by
integrating multiple data sources (kinematics, kinetics, and
EMG).
Limitations:
- Expensive, requires highly controlled settings, and the
integration of multiple data types can be time-consuming
and complex.
Reliability & Validity:
These systems offer high reliability and validity, particularly when
evaluating complex gait patterns and designing personalized
rehabilitation interventions.
6. Marker-based Photogrammetry
Photogrammetry is the process of recording and analyzing two-
dimensional images to measure three-dimensional movements. It
is widely used in environments where high precision is necessary
but optical motion capture is too expensive or complex.
How it Works:
High-speed cameras capture multiple images of a subject
performing a motion.
The images are analyzed using photogrammetry software to
reconstruct a 3D model of the motion based on the positions of
the markers in the images.
Advantages:
- High precision and accuracy for complex movements.
- Can be adapted for various applications, including in-field
data collection.
Limitations:
- Requires a well-lit, controlled environment for accuracy.
- Limited to capturing motion from a specific field of view.
Reliability and Validity:
Photogrammetry shows good intra-rater and variable inter-rater
reliability. It’s validity is high for static measurements like posture
and joint angles and less valid for complex movements.
Conclusion:
Human motion analysis is a dynamic field that employs a wide
range of technologies and methods to understand and capture
human movement. The choice of method depends on the specific
requirements of the application, with factors like cost, accuracy,
and complexity playing significant roles. As technology continues
to evolve, especially in the areas of AI and computer vision,
motion analysis methods are becoming more accessible and
versatile across various fields.
References:
Welch, G., & Foxlin, E. (2002). Motion tracking: No silver bullet,
but a respectable arsenal. IEEE Computer Graphics and
Applications, 22(6), 24-38.
Roetenberg, D., Luinge, H. J., & Slycke, P. J. (2009). Xsens MVN:
Full 6DOF human motion tracking using miniature inertial sensors.
Xsens Technologies BV, 1-7.
Shotton, J., Fitzgibbon, A., Cook, M., Sharp, T., Finocchio, M.,
Moore, R., & Blake, A. (2011). Real-time human pose recognition
in parts from a single depth image. In Proceedings of the IEEE
conference on computer vision and pattern recognition (pp. 1297-
1304).
Winter, D. A. (2009). Biomechanics and motor control of human
movement. John Wiley & Sons.
Pfister, T., Charles, J., & Zisserman, A. (2015). Flowing convnets
for human pose estimation in videos. In Proceedings of the IEEE
International Conference on Computer Vision (pp. 1913-1921).
Han, J., Shao, L., Xu, D., & Shotton, J. (2013). Enhanced computer
vision with Microsoft Kinect sensor: A review. IEEE Transactions on
Cybernetics, 43(5), 1318-1334.
De Luca, C. J. (2006). Electromyography. In Encyclopedia of
medical devices and instrumentation. John Wiley & Sons.
Cao, Z., Hidalgo, G., Simon, T., Wei, S. E., & Sheikh, Y. (2019).
OpenPose: Realtime multi-person 2D pose estimation using part
affinity fields. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine
Intelligence, 43(1), 172-186.
Whittle, M. W. (2014). Gait analysis: An introduction. Butterworth-
Heinemann
Abdel-Aziz, Y. I., & Karara, H. M. (2015). Direct linear
transformation from comparator coordinates into object space
coordinates in close-range photogrammetry. Photogrammetric
Engineering & Remote Sensing, 81(2), 103-107.
