Week - 1 Compiled Crux Notes Weekly - BNSS
Week - 1 Compiled Crux Notes Weekly - BNSS
A significant step towards modernising the legal framework inherited from colonial
times has been taken with the recent legislative initiatives by the Indian Parliament to
amend and replace the colonial criminal laws through the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023, the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita,
2023. The Indian Evidence Act of 1872, the Indian Penal Code of 1860, and the Code of
Criminal Procedure of 1973 were replaced with these new statutes, which brought
about important modifications to address modern issues.
Enacted by Parliament on December 25, 2023, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita (BNSS) replaced the outmoded Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, and is now
known as the Indian Citizen Safety Code. It modernizes and streamlines criminal
procedural law in India.
This Sanhita governs all aspects of criminal procedure—covering arrests,
prosecutions, and bail—along with detailed provisions on offences, penalties, and
procedural guidelines.
The BNSS is India's principal legal framework for managing procedural law related to
criminal justice, ensuring fairness and efficiency in the administration of substantive
law.
The Sanhita consists of 39 Chapters and a total of 531 Sections, covering every aspect
of criminal procedural law in detail.
Some key updates in this law include:
2(1)(b) “Bail”
2(1)(b) “Bail-Bond”
2(1)(e) “Bond”
70(3) Proof of service in such cases and when the serving officer is not
present
157 Procedure where the person against whom the order is made u/s
152 appears to show cause
250(1) Discharge
479(2), (3) Maximum period for which undertrial prisoner can be detained
497(2), Order for custody and disposal of property pending trial in certain
(3), (4), (5) cases
2(f) ‘’India”
2(t) “Prescribed”
8 Metropolitan Area
28(3) Sentences which High Courts and Sessions Judges may pass
Crime is a public wrong. This is due to the fact that when a criminal act occurs, it instils
fear, uncertainty and dread in the minds of both the victim and the general public.
Because the wellbeing of the victim of crime and the interests of society as a whole are
interconnected, it is therefore always vital to handle such situations delicately and
sensibly. It is common knowledge that the Constitution is based on a number of
fundamental principles, including non-arbitrariness, equity, justice, good conscience,
and reasonableness. Any law must adhere to these values in order to be successful, and
violating them undermines society as a whole.
In order to address the issues of delayed justice delivery due to complex procedures, a
high number of cases pending in courts, low conviction rates, low use of technology in
the legal system, delays in investigation, and inadequate use of forensics, the BNSS seeks
to establish a more rapid and efficient justice system.
The protection (Suraksha) of citizens against unfair exploitation of the criminal
procedure system, which is made possible by flaws in the former system, is the primary
goal of the (BNSS). While the BNSS mostly maintains the provisions of the CrPC, it also
attempts to streamline criminal procedure, shorten trial lengths, strengthen police
investigative capabilities, establish procedural timeframes, and more.
The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 describes how these institutions operate
from when a crime is committed to when a judgement is handed down and the case is
closed. It controls the process that democratic institutions follow and launches the
State's machinery for upholding justice and maintaining law and order. It refers to the
tools that the State will use if criminal law is wounded. These tools include those for
conducting criminal investigations, apprehending suspected offenders, gathering
evidence, determining an accused person's guilt or innocence, and determining the
appropriate punishment for those found guilty.
Opponents of the Sanhita have cautioned that the revisions may result in a "30–40%
increase in the number of cases awaiting trial." The Sanhita mandates video recordings to
be produced at the site of significant crimes and updates admissible digital evidence.
Advocates in India are worried that the Government is replacing outdated criminal
statutes from the colonial era with new laws, a move that could destabilise the country's
criminal justice system. These worries also brought to light the likelihood that the new
legislation, seemingly without any discernible justification, will substantially undermine
the safeguards that the judiciary and Parliament had painstakingly constructed around
priceless civil liberties.
CHAPTER NUMBER CLAUSES CHAPTER NAME
FIR Registration: Introduces the Zero FIR, which states that when the police get
information revealing the commission of an offence beyond the boundaries of a
police station, they must record it in the book the officer would keep. In order to
expedite the initial step of criminal cases, complaints submitted electronically
must register a formal complaint within three days.
Updates for Victims and Informants: Within 90 days, victims and informants
will get regular updates regarding the investigation's progress, promoting
openness and informing all parties involved.
Finger imprints and signatures: The BNSS gives a magistrate the authority to
require anyone to produce sample handwriting or signatures. This is expanded in
the Sanhita to incorporate voice samples and finger impressions. It makes it
possible to obtain these samples from someone who hasn't been taken into
custody.
Police Custody: The BNSS allows for a maximum of 15 days of police custody,
which may be approved in segments within the first 40, 60, or 90 days of judicial
detention. If the authorities do not use up all 15 days of custody, this could result
in the entire period of bail being denied.
Use of handcuffs: The BNSS authorises the use of handcuffs during the arrest
process or when presenting an individual before the Court who is a habitual or
repeat offender, who has escaped from custody, or who has committed an offence
involving organised crime, terrorism, drugs, sexual offences, or offences against
the State, among other offences.
(1) This Act may be called the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
[Corresponding Section of CrPC: Section 1(1)
(2) The provisions of this Sanhita, other than those relating to Chapters IX, XI and
XII thereof, shall not apply—
(a) to the State of Nagaland;
(b) to the tribal areas,
but the concerned State Government may, by notification, apply such provisions or any of
them to the whole or part of the State of Nagaland or such tribal areas, as the case may be,
with such supplemental, incidental or consequential modifications, as may be specified in
the notification. [Corresponding Section of CrPC: Sec. 1(2)]
Explanation—In this section, "tribal areas" means the territories which immediately
before the 21st day of January, 1972, were included in the tribal areas of Assam, as
referred to in paragraph 20 of the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution, other than those
within the local limits of the municipality of Shillong.
(3) It shall come into force on such date as the Central Government may, by notification in
the Official Gazette, appoint.
Comment: A crucial component of the statute is the title. The statute's title provides a
decent indication of the content of the law and the subject matter it addresses.
Identification, not description, is the goal of the brief title. Subclause (2) is identical to
the CrPC, with the exception that it does not apply to the entirety of India. The Sanhita
went on air to go into effect on July 1, 2024, as announced by the Central Government. It
is mostly a procedural (adjective) law. The purpose of the Sanhita is to establish a
system of punishment for those who violate substantive criminal laws, such as the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. It is recommended to study the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita
and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita simultaneously.
While the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita is a procedural law, several of its
provisions are similar to substantive law, for example, Prevention of Offences and
Maintenance Proceedings.
SECTION 2: DEFINITIONS:
(a)"audio-video electronic means" shall include the use of any communication device
for the purposes of video conferencing, recording of processes of identification,
search and seizure or evidence, transmission of electronic communication and for
such other purposes and by such other means as the State Government may, by
rules provide.
Comment: The addition of provisions allowing the use of "audio-visual electronic
means" for evidence recording is a significant change that emphasises the value of
technology in enhancing crime scene investigations and court cases. This is important to
prevent evidence manipulation. Although audio and video recordings might enhance the
quality of the evidence, they must be safeguarded from manipulation, whether
deliberate or accidental, that could alter, modify, or transpose the data.
(b)"bail" means the release of a person accused of or suspected of the commission of
an offence from the custody of law upon certain conditions imposed by an officer or
Court on execution by such person of a bond or a bail bond.
Comment: In contrast to the Criminal Procedure Code, the BNSS has significantly
altered the bail requirements. Stricter criteria for individuals facing numerous offences
and wider eligibility for bail, particularly for first-time offenders, are among the major
modifications. While gang rape cases involving children are not covered by the BNSS's
anticipatory bail, it is under the CrPC. To ensure that undertrial detainees receive
equitable treatment while maintaining accountability, it creates new definitions and
processes for bail.
(c)"Bailable offence" means an offence which is shown as bailable in the First
Schedule, or which is made bailable by any other law for the time being in force;
and "non-bailable offence" means any other offence. [Corresponding Section of
CrPC: Sec. 2(a)]
Comment: In a criminal trial, the charge framing is crucial. This phase is when a
criminal case might take several turns and result in various outcomes. Generally
speaking, the ultimate objective of the charge is to provide the accused with a clear
understanding of the accusations made against him and the purpose of the trial.
(f)"cognizable offence" means an offence for which, and "cognizable case" means a
case in which, a police officer may, in accordance with the First Schedule or under
any other law for the time being in force, arrest without warrant. [Corresponding
Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(c)]
Comment: An offence that permits an arrest without a warrant under the BNSS is
considered a cognizable offence. The majority of crimes that fall under the category of
cognizable offences are more serious and do not qualify for bail. A police officer may
make an arrest without a warrant in situations involving cognizable offences, either in
line with the First Schedule or under any other applicable law.
(i) in relation to any State, the High Court for that State;
(iii) in relation to any other Union territory, the highest Court of criminal
appeal for that territory other than the Supreme Court of India.
[Corresponding Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(e)]
Comment: A High Court is defined by the BNSS as the highest Court of criminal appeal
for a Union Territory, apart from the Supreme Court of India, as well as the High Court
for a State or a Union Territory if the State High Court's jurisdiction has been extended
to it by legislation.
(k) "inquiry" means every inquiry, other than a trial, conducted under this Sanhita
by a Magistrate or Court. [Corresponding Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(g)]
Comment: A formal investigation aimed at discovering the facts and circumstances
surrounding a legal matter is called an inquiry under BNSS, and the Court or a
magistrate can carry it out. Different from a trial, it is a crucial procedural step in the
criminal justice system that usually comes after the investigation stage. The purpose of
the inquiry is to evaluate the evidence and legal considerations in order to decide if the
case should go to trial.
(l) "investigation" includes all the proceedings under this Sanhita for the collection
of evidence conducted by a police officer or by any person (other than a Magistrate)
who is authorised by a Magistrate on this behalf. [Corresponding Section of
CrPC: Sec. 2(h)]
(m) "judicial proceeding" includes any proceeding in the course of which evidence is
or may be legally taken on oath. [Corresponding Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(i)]
Comment: Any process where testimony can be lawfully obtained under oath is
considered a judicial proceeding. A judgement, sentence, or final order based on
recorded evidence may be issued in these proceedings.
(n) "local jurisdiction", in relation to a Court or Magistrate, means the local area
within which the Court or Magistrate may exercise all or any of its powers under
this Sanhita and such local area may comprise the whole of the State, or any part of
the State, as the State Government may, by notification, specify. [Corresponding
Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(j)]
Comment: When a crime is committed at a specific location, the Court with jurisdiction
over the offence typically has the authority to look into and try the case. Territorial
jurisdiction, or jurisdiction over an area's locale or bounds, is referred to as local
jurisdiction.
Comment: The term "notification" refers to a notice that has been published in the
Official Gazette, and the terms "notify" and "notified" will be interpreted in that light.
Notification is written or printed information that provides information.
(q) "offence" means any act or omission made punishable by any law for the time
being in force and includes any act in respect of which a complaint may be made
under section 20 of the Cattle Trespass Act, 1871. [Corresponding Section of
CrPC: Sec. 2(n)]
Comment: A criminal or illegal act that is punishable by law and about which a
complaint can be registered with a police or Magistrate is referred to as an offence. An
offence can be categorised as either cognizable or non-cognizable, bailable or
non-bailable, or compoundable or non-compoundable, depending on its nature, severity,
and seriousness.
(r) "officer in charge of a police station" includes, when the officer in charge of the
police station is absent from the station-house or unable from illness or other cause
to perform his duties, the police officer present at the station-house who is next in
rank to such officer and is above the rank of constable or, when the State
Government so directs, any other police officer so present. [Corresponding
Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(o)]
Comment: The Station House Officer (SHO), commonly referred to as the Police
Inspector (PI), is the person in command of a police station under the BNSS. The SHO is
in charge of managing the police station's operations. The Government sets the SHO's
rank, which ranges from Inspector to Sub-Inspector.
(s) "place" includes a house, building, tent, vehicle and vessel. [Corresponding
Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(p)]
Comment:
(u) "police station" means any post or place declared generally or specially by the
State Government, to be a police station, and includes any local area specified by
the State Government in this behalf. [Corresponding Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(s)]
Comment: "Police Station" can refer to any location that the State Government has
specifically or generally designated as a police station; it cannot simply indicate "a place
where police officers are stationed."
(v) "Public Prosecutor" means any person appointed under section 18, and includes
any person acting under the directions of a Public Prosecutor. [Corresponding
Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(u)]
Comment: In the criminal justice system, the State's interests are represented by a
public prosecutor. After the police have completed the investigation and filed the charge
sheet with the Court, they assume this responsibility. They don't take part in the
investigation.
(w) "sub-division" means a sub-division of a district. [Corresponding Section of
CrPC: Sec. 2(v)]
Comment: Cases initiated on a summons are for crimes carrying a maximum two-year
prison sentence. These cases are minor or petty offences, which are handled through a
legal process where the accused is called to appear in Court upon the Magistrate's
summons. When compared to warrant proceedings, the process is typically quicker and
easier.
(y) "victim" means a person who has suffered any loss or injury caused by reason of
the act or omission of the accused person and includes the guardian or legal heir of
such victim. [Corresponding Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(wa)]
Comment: Warrant cases are those involving offences that carry a sentence of
"imprisonment" longer than two years. Compared to a summons case, the nature of the
offence is more serious in a warrant case.
Sub-section (2): Words and expressions used herein and not defined but defined in
the Information Technology Act, 2000 and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 shall
have the meanings respectively assigned to them in that Act and Sanhita.
[Corresponding Section of CrPC: Sec. 2(y)]
(1)Unless the context otherwise requires, any reference in any law, to a Magistrate
without any qualifying words, a Magistrate of the first class or a Magistrate of the
second class shall, in relation to any area, be construed as a reference to a Judicial
Magistrate of the first class or Judicial Magistrate of the second class, as the case
may be, exercising jurisdiction in such area. [Corresponding Section of CrPC:
Sec. 3(3)]
(2) Where, under any law, other than this Sanhita, the functions exercisable by a
Magistrate relate to matters—
(a) which involve the appreciation or shifting of evidence or the formulation of any
decision which exposes any person to any punishment or penalty or detention in
custody pending investigation, inquiry or trial or would have the effect of sending
him for trial before any Court, they shall, subject to the provisions of this Sanhita, be
exercisable by a Judicial Magistrate; or
(b) which are administrative or executive in nature, such as, the granting of a
licence, the suspension or cancellation of a licence, sanctioning a prosecution or
withdrawing from a prosecution, they shall, subject to the provisions of clause (a)
be exercisable by an Executive Magistrate. [Corresponding Section of CrPC: Sec.
3(4)]
Explanation: Any law that refers to a magistrate without naming the class—first or
second—will refer to either a Judicial Magistrate first-class or second class depending
on the territory over which they have jurisdiction. A Judicial Magistrate must carry out
these duties if a law other than BNSS requires a Magistrate to make decisions about the
following: evaluating and appreciating the evidence, determining punishments,
directing detention or custody before trial, or summoning a witness for trial.
(1) All offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 shall be investigated, inquired
into, tried, and otherwise dealt with according to the provisions hereinafter contained.
(2) All offences under any other law shall be investigated, inquired into, tried, and
otherwise dealt with according to the same provisions, but subject to any enactment for
the time being in force regulating the manner or place of investigating, inquiring into,
trying or otherwise dealing with such offences. [Corresponding Section od CrPC: Sec. 4]
Explanation: The investigation, trial, and other legal processes specified in this section
shall apply to any offences committed under the BNSS. Unless another law specifies a
different course of action for an investigation, questioning, or trial of the offence, the
same procedural principles will apply to crimes under other laws. Then, those particular
laws will be superseded.
SECTION 5: SAVING
Nothing contained in this Sanhita shall, in the absence of a specific provision to the
contrary, affect any special or local law for the time being in force, any special jurisdiction
or power conferred, or any special form of procedure prescribed, by any other law for the
time being in force. [Corresponding Section of CrPC: Sec 5]
Explanation: Existing local or special laws are protected under this section. It makes
clear that the following situations are exempt from the BNSS if there is no clear conflict:
any special law that is in effect at the moment, any special authority or jurisdiction
granted to specified authorities, or any particular legal process mandated by other laws.
Put another way, unless otherwise specified, this law will not conflict with existing legal
frameworks or procedures.