GC Detectors
GC Detectors
3
Detector Response Characteristics
4
Comparison Of GC Detectors
TCD
FID
ECD
AED
PID
NPD IRD
(N)
NPD (P)
FPD (S)
5
Increased Sensitivity With Capillary Columns
6
Capillary Columns and Detector Selectivity
7
Dynamic Range
Dynamic range is a measure of response vs. Quantity Response is
the signal produced by the sample.
Dynamic Range
Response increases reproducibly with
Response increased quantity.
Quantity
Quantity
8
Operating Conditions For Detectors
Sensitivity
Detector Typical Samples Range Gas Flow Rates (mL/min.)
Carrier +
Hydrogen Air
Make-up
FID Hydrocarbons 10-100 pg 20-60 30-40 200-500
10 ppb-99%
TCD Anything other than 5-100 ng 15-30 n.a. n.a.
carrier gas 10 ppm-100%
ECD Organohalogens 0.05-1 pg 30-60 n.a. n.a.
Chlorinated solvents 50 ppy-1 oom
& pesticides
NPD Organonitrogen & 0.1-10 pg 20-40 1-5 70-100
Organophosphorus
9
Thermal Conductivity Detector
FLOW
10
Single Filament TCD
11
Selecting the Reference Gas Flow Rate
12
Operating the TCD
13
Typical Pressure/Flow Relationships
14
TCD Troubleshooting/Maintenance
• Check Pressures/Flows
• Thermal Cleaning:
– TCD can become contaminated with deposits from column bleed
or dirty samples.
– Symptoms include:
• wandering baseline
• increased noise level
• changes in response of reference sample
• Replace the detector.
15
Flame Ionization Detector Schematic
FID Detector
Assembly
Air
Inlet
Capillary Column
End-Position
(1-2 mm from Top of Jet) Jet
H2 Inlet
+
Make-Up
CH
Column
H 4 H
2 2
CH Jet
H 4 H
2 2
17
Compounds with Little or No FID Response
18
FID Response
e
en
lu
10
To
lo
an
ol
ex
8
ic
Relative
n
H
o
ta
an
Bu
ol
Response
ex
ic
n
6
ha
n
H
(by wt.)
io
l
Et
no
op
id
ha
Pr
ic
4
Ac
et
et
Ac
M
ic
rm
2
Fo
H H H H H H H
H C OH H C C OH H C C C C OH
H H H H H H H
19
FID Variables
Kr
H2 Flow
20
FID Pneumatics (EPC)
21
Operating the FID
23
FID Exploded View
24
FID Jet Selection
Jets for the Capillary-Optimized FID
Jet Type Part No. Jet Tip I.D.
Capillary G1531-80560 0.29 mm
(0.011 in.)
High-Temp G1531-80620 0.47 mm
(use with simulated (0.018 in.)
distillation)
• Typical Problems
– Flame Out
– Spiking
– Low Sensitivity
– Noise
– Drift
• FID Troubleshooting
– Check Pressures/Flows
– Check Background signal
– Inspect Flame
– Check Electrometer Connections (spring)
– Check O-Rings
• FID Maintenance
– Clean or replace the jet
– Clean the collector
– Replace the igniter assembly
26
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
● low noise;
● stable.
1
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Best gases for TCD: H2 or He, because of highest thermal conductivity (0.170
and 0.141 J/(K*m*s), respectively, for N2 0.024). For helium and hydrogen the
temperature conductivity lowers when solute is eluted.
Gas
flow
Gas out
flow
in
Filament
2
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Detection limit: 2 pg/s. It is reduced 50% when nitrogen is used as a carrier gas
instead of helium; nitrogen is often used as a makeup gas before the eluate
enters the detector.
Linear response range: >107
3
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
The ECD uses a radioactive Beta emitter (electrons) to ionize some of the carrier gas and
produce a current between a biased pair of electrodes. When organic molecules that
contain electronegative functional groups (Hal, conjugated -C=O, -CN, -NO2,
organometallics) pass by the detector, they capture some of the electrons and reduce the
current measured between the electrodes. The detector responds by varying the frequency
of voltage pulses between the anode and cathode to maintain a constant current.
Low sensitivity for: hydrocarbons, -OH, ketones.
4
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
● Performs quantitative analysis using nearly constant response factors. You can calibrate
with any readily available compound containing the element.
● Analyzes higher-boiling compounds with operation up to 450 °C.
● Conducts trace-level analysis. Five times more sensitive than GC-FID for carbon.
5
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Nitrogen-phosphorus detector.
6
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
The FPD uses one of two available band pass filters over a photomultiplier tube (PMT) to
selectively detect compounds containing sulfur or phosphorus as they combust in the
hydrogen flame. When compounds are burned in the FPD flame, they emit photons of
distinct wavelengths (S2 394 nm, HPO 510-526 nm doublet). Only those photons that are
within the frequency range of the filter specifications can pass through the filter to the
PMT. The PMT converts the photons it “sees” through the bandpass filter to an analog
signal, which is acquired by the Peak Simple data system.
7
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
8
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
M + e- → M+ + 2e-
9
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
GC-MS interfacing.
The pressure inside MS is ~10-5 torr. An interface should eliminate the solvent,
generate gas phase ions, and ensure pressure reduction from atmospheric to
high vacuum.
10
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
LC-MS interfaces.
● due to high energy electron impact (70 V), extensive fragmentation of the
11
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
The mass spectrometer measures the exact mass. The value is slightly different from the
expected 222.0278 and 219.0278 because these spectra were obtained with a quadrupole
instrument, which does not provide sufficient mass resolution and mass accuracy for
obtaining the exact mass.
The next smaller peaks correspond to the C13 and Cl37 isotopes.
A high resolution instrument (time of flight, sector, FTMS…), properly used with a
reference compound provides the mass information with an accuracy better than 5ppm,
which is enough to unambiguously determine the elemental composition.
12
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
MASS ANALYZERS.
The quadrupole is composed of two pairs of metallic rods. One set of rod is at a positive
electrical potential, and the other one at a negative potential. A combination of DC and
RF (radio frequency) voltages is applied on each set .
13
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
How it works.
DC voltage combined with the RF potential acts like a low pass filter:
● High m/z ions do not refocus as quickly during the RF cycle.
● High m/z ions slowly drift away from the center of the quadrupole under DC potential.
● At the end of the analyzer, high m/z ions are too far off-axis to strike the detector.
● Low m/z ions are not affected, because their trajectories are stabilized by RF.
For a given amplitude of the DC and RF voltages, only the ions of a given m/z (mass to
charge) ratio will resonate, have a stable trajectory to pass the quadrupole and be detected.
Other ions will be destabilized and hit the rods.
The performance (i.e. ability to separate two adjacent masses across the applicable range)
depends on the quad geometry, on the electronics, on the voltage settings and on the
quality of the manufacturing. Increasing the resolution means that fewer ions will reach
the detector, and consequently impacts the sensitivity.
The quadrupole is scanned with DC/RF = constant; the resolution depends on the slope of
the scan line.
The Mathieu stability diagram.
If the continuous voltage DC is switched off, the scan line is the Q axis: We have now a
transfer only device.
14
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
SIM - single ion monitoring mode (or SIR - single ion recording):
● the amplitudes of the DC and RF voltages are set to observe only a specific mass, or a
selection of specific masses;
● SIM mode provides the highest sensitivity for specific ions or fragments, since more
time can be spent on each mass;
● that time can be adjusted; it is called the dwell time;
● the mass window for observing an ion in SIM mode can be adjusted, in order to
compensate small mass calibration shift. This is the span factor.
SCAN mode:
● the RF/DC ratio is constant;
● the amplitudes of the DC and RF voltages are ramped to obtain the mass spectrum over
the required mass range;
● the sensitivity is a function of the scanned mass range, scan speed, and resolution.
15
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Second two experiments can be used for quantitation, because two subsequent analyzers
improve selectivity and signal-to-noise ratio. The limiting factor for quantitation with any
MS is “ion suppression”, and it should be always accounted.
16
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
A helium gas of about 1 mTorr within the trapping volume contracts the ion trajectories to
the center of the trap and reduces the kinetic energy of the ions. The ion packet is ejected
more quickly and efficiently than a diffuse cloud of ions may be ejected, thus improving
resolution.
17
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
How it works.
The ions are stable in the trap if the Q value lies between 0.3 and 0.9
0.3 < Q < 0.9
This parameter has important consequences when doing fragmentation (in other words
MS/MS) in a trap: the fragments which are smaller than about one third of the precursor
ion will have a Q value > 0.9 and will be lost.
By increasing the RF voltage it is possible to extract an ion (m/z is fixed) from the trap. It
is also possible to play with the voltage on the end cap electrodes, which affects the A
value.
By combining both actions, it is possible to eliminate from the trap the high masses and
low masses, and keep in the trap only the desired ions.
Resolution and performance in an ion trap are dependent upon the charge density of ions
in the trap:
● If too many ions are present at the same time in the trap, the electrical fields are
distorted, and also collisions between the ions may occur, leading to unexpected
dissociation or chemical reactions.
● A short pre-scan is achieved automatically to determine the optimum ion sampling time
so that enough, but not too many ions will be introduced.
● The optimum is to have between 300 and 1000 ions present in the trap.
Resolution of QIT is similar to this of QA, but can be greatly improved by scanning
narrow window for longer time.
18
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Ions formed in an ion source are extracted and accelerated to a high velocity by
an electric field into an analyzer consisting of a long straight ‘drift tube’. The
ions pass along the tube until they reach a detector.
After the initial acceleration phase, the velocity reached by an ion is inversely
proportional to the square root of its m/z value.
19
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
● HPLC line is connected to the electrospray probe, which consists of a metallic capillary
surrounded with a nitrogen flow.
● In the electrical field, at the tip of the capillary, the surface of the droplets containing
the ionized compound will get charged.
● Due to the solvent evaporation, the size of the droplet reduces, and the density of
charges at the droplet surface increases.
● The repulsion forces between the charges increase until there is an explosion of the
droplet.
● This process repeats until analyte ions evaporate from the droplet.
Multiply charged ions can be obtained depending on the chemical structure of the analyte.
This is why ESI is the technique of choice for analyzing proteins and other biopolymers
on quadrupole or ion trap analyzers.
20
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
The HPLC line is is connected to the APCI probe which consists normally of a glass
capillary surrounded with a nitrogen flow used for mobilization.
A metallic needle at potential of a few kilovolts is located close to the probe ("corona
discharge electrode").
The eluent vapours are ionized by the corona effect, and react chemically with the analyte
molecules in the gas phase.
If the eluent is not suitable for ionization, a small amount of modifier (reagent gas) can be
added (e.g. methane, which forms excellent proton donor CH5+).
Applicability conditions:
● the analyte must be volatile and thermally stable;
● the mobile phase must be suitable for gas phase acid-base reactions:
• - for working in positive mode, the proton affinity of the analyte must be
higher than the proton affinity of the eluent (in other words, the analyte can
catch a proton from the protonated solvent)
SH+ + M → S + MH+
• - for working in negative mode, the gas phase acidity of the analyte must
be lower than the gas phase acidity of the eluent (in other words, the
analyte can give a proton to the deprotonated solvent)
[S – H]- + M → S + [M – H]–
21
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Curtain gas design: a flow of heated gas is protects the orifice plate and helps
in the desolvatation.
“Pepper pot” design: the ions have to travel through the channels of the
metallic counter electrode, which is heated. The counter electrode protects the
sampling cone orifice and helps in ion desolvatation.
22
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
A: negative APCI;
B: negative APCI with in source fragmentation;
C: electron impact ionization.
23
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Alcohol
An alcohol's molecular ion is small or non-existent. Cleavage of the C-C bond next to the
oxygen usually occurs. A loss of H2O may occur as in the spectra below.
3-Pentanol
C5H12O
MW = 88.15
•
Aldehyde
Cleavage of bonds next to the carboxyl group results in the loss of hydrogen (molecular
ion less 1) or the loss of CHO (molecular ion less 29).
3-Phenyl-2-propenal
C9H8O
MW = 132.16
Alkane
Molecular ion peaks are present, possibly with low intensity. The fragmentation pattern
contains clusters of peaks 14 mass units apart (which represent loss of (CH2)nCH3).
Hexane
C6H14
MW = 86.18
24
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Amide
Primary amides show a base peak due to the McLafferty rearrangement.
3-Methylbutyramide
C5H11NO
MW = 101.15
Amine
Molecular ion peak is an odd number. Alpha-cleavage dominates aliphatic amines.
n-Butylamine
C4H11N
MW = 73.13
Another example is a secondary amine shown below. Again, the molecular ion peak is an
odd number. The base peak is from the C-C cleavage adjacent to the C-N bond.
n-Methylbenzylamine
C8H11N
MW = 121.18
25
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Aromatic
Molecular ion peaks are strong due to the stable structure.
Naphthalene
C10H8
MW = 128.17
•
Carboxylic Acid
In short chain acids, peaks due to the loss of OH (molecular ion less 17) and COOH
(molecular ion less 45) are prominent due to cleavage of bonds next to C=O.
2-Butenoic acid
C4H6O2
MW = 86.09
Ester
Fragments appear due to bond cleavage next to C=O (alkoxy group loss, -OR) and
hydrogen rearrangements.
Ethyl acetate
C4H8O2
MW = 88.11
26
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Ether
Fragmentation tends to occur alpha to the oxygen atom (C-C bond next to the oxygen).
Halide
The presence of chlorine or bromine atoms is usually recognizable from isotopic peaks.
1-Bromopropane
C3H7Br
MW = 123.00
Ketone
Major fragmentation peaks result from cleavage of the C-C bonds adjacent to the
carbonyl.
4-Heptanone
C7H14O
MW = 114.19
27
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Qualitative analysis.
Retention data – can be used for qualitative work. The retention time is characteristic of
substance, compared to a standard.
Reproducibility of absolute retention data depends on several experimental conditions.
Adjusted retention time or volume can be used for identification of unknown compound.
For non-paraffins the index value can be calculated like it was a paraffin.
Absolute retention index:
ln V X −ln V N1
I P =N 1 N 2− N 1
ln V N2 −ln V N1
N 2 xN 1
and N1 and N2 are reference paraffins.
28
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Relative retention should be measured with internal standard – a standard is a part of the
sample or added to it before separation.
Standard should elute somewhere in the middle of chromatogram, and sample size should
be small.
Values may vary from column to column, but remains quite constant with the same
column.
Simple retention time data is suitable for simple assays like process quality control, when
it is already known, what the sample is, and how many components are present. When
new unknown compound is observed, the retention time does not give much of positive
information.
Retention plot for homologous. Very often semi log plot of retention time vs carbon
number give a linear relationship. This can be used to pick out potential series members.
In LC, the eluent can be varied, and elution orders and times will change. With additional
standards this provides more information about analyte structure.
The detectors provide some information about analyte structure: FTIR, UV/Vis, Emission,
MS.
29
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
Quantitative analysis.
Approximation for very sharp and symmetrical peaks, which are usually
produced by capillary columns: peak height is proportional to concentration.
Peak area is more reliable source of information. Peak area can be measured
automatically by detector/interface program, or can be calculated by operator.
Peak shape and tailing should be taken into account to get accurate values.
30
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
EXAMPLE.
Compound: DMAP
Standard concentration: 0.2 mg/ml
Injection volume (both standard and unknown): 5 μl.
Area DMAPstd = 1800 units
Area DMAPunk = 4100 units
Find concentration of DMAP in unknown sample.
Solution: Cunk= 0.2 ×4100/1800 = 0.456 mg/ml
ESTD calibration plot. Peak area is assigned to certain concentration of the sample.
80000
peak area
60000
40000
20000
0
0 100 200 300 400 500
conc., ng/ml
31
Lecture 4. Detectors for GC.
ISTD is the most reliable method. The known substance at a constant concentration is
added to all standards and samples.
To create ISTD calibration plot, the IST concentration is maintained constant while
changing the concentration of analyte.
ISTD calibration
3,5
3
AreaUNK/AreaIST
2,5
2
1,5
1
0,5
0
0 100 200 300 400 500
conc., ng/ml
32