Migration Letters

Volume: 21, No: S9 (2024), pp. 1243-1255

ISSN: 1741-8984 (Print) ISSN: 1741-8992 (Online)

[Link]

Cybercrime Legislation And Enforcement In Pakistan:

Assessing Gaps And Solutions
Dr. Mian Muhammad Sheraz1 , Dr. Fazli Dayan2 , Muniba Murtaza3 , Muhammad Umar4 ,
Aniza Batool5 , Dr. Muhammad Munib Khalid6

Abstract
Introduction: An important challenge to Pakistan's legal and law enforcement systems is the
emergence of cybercrime. This study looks at the current weaknesses in the country's
cybercrime legislation and enforcement practices and offers solutions. With cybercrimes
ranging from financial fraud to cyber terrorism on the rise, Pakistan needs to take strong
legislative and enforcement measures. However, the efficacy of the law is hampered by poor
enforcement and interpretation. Research method: This study uses a qualitative research
method to examine cybercrime laws, policies, and their implementation through in-depth
interviews with legal experts, law enforcement officers, and stakeholders. Qualitative analysis
enables a deeper comprehension of the opportunities and challenges in Pakistan's cybercrime
landscape. Data analysis: The analysis reveals several significant legal deficiencies, such as
ambiguous jurisdiction, vague definitions, and insufficient fines. Furthermore, inadequate
technology, a lack of professional expertise, and resource constraints plague enforcement
procedures. Conclusion and Recommendations: To solve these issues, extensive reforms are
ne1eded. Among the suggestions are modifications to the law to provide clearer definitions and
harsher penalties. Other suggestions include boosting public-private partnerships, fostering
international cooperation, and bolstering law enforcement capabilities with improved
equipment and training. By implementing these strategies, Pakistan may lower cyber threats,
safeguard digital infrastructure, and boost confidence in its cybersecurity ecosystem.

Keywords: Cybercrime, legislation, enforcement, financial fraud, cyber terrorism.

Introduction
The spread of technology in the modern digital era has changed the nature of crime and
presented a multitude of difficulties for legal and law enforcement institutions around the globe.
Among these difficulties, cybercrime is particularly noteworthy since it is a persistent and
dynamic threat that cuts across national borders and poses serious threats to people, companies,
and governments alike. Pakistan faces the same challenges as many other countries: how to
preserve its citizens' digital rights and privacy while also thwarting cyber-attacks (Saleem, Jan,
& Areej, 2022)? Computers have radically revolutionized human existence and significantly
improved its ability to be controlled and organized. In contemporary society, both individuals
1
Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Grand Asian University Sialkot, Punjab, Pakistan.
2
Associate Professor, Department of Law, Grand Asian University Sialkot, Punjab, Pakistan.
3
International Islamic university, Islamabad, Pakistan.
4
Lecturer, College of Law, University of Sargodha.
5
Department of Criminology and criminal Justice system, Minhaj University Lahore.
6
Assistant Professor, School of Political Science, Minhaj University Lahore.
1244 Cybercrime Legislation And Enforcement In Pakistan: Assessing Gaps And Solutions

and businesses heavily rely on computers, as they have become a crucial element of our
everyday lives. We start our day with the alarm of our cellular phone, which operates using
computer networking technology. Computers are essential instruments that empower us to
effectively and precisely perform our daily tasks. Computers have become an essential and
integral part of our everyday life, including mobile phones, laptops, and desktops (Anderez,
Kanjo, Amnwar, Johnson, & Lucy, 2021). Cyberspace is a very influential realm where data
and information are processed with remarkable precision and efficiency. Cybercriminals
breach the digital domain and corrupt the data of persons or businesses. Computers are
undeniably employed as instruments to commit illegal crimes. Cybercrime refers to any
unlawful behavior that is conducted using a computer, either as a tool or as the ultimate goal
(Vitus, 2023). Over the last few decades, there has been a surge in the use of automated
technology, big data, the Cloud, and Artificial Intelligence. These advancements have greatly
improved human existence, but they have also introduced novel risks and problems. These
cyberspace-related issues have an impact on online crimes, data privacy, security, and storage.
Handling these new issues is a difficult effort and a serious concern because technological
improvements have also led to increased rivalry in cyberspace as organizations and proxy
players have emerged to further their political and ideological agendas (Al-Khater, Al-
Maadeed, Ahmed, Sadiq, & Khan, 2020).

Cybersecurity has become increasingly significant worldwide due to the ubiquitous use of
computers in many aspects of life. The importance of cybersecurity has grown significantly for
developing countries in the third world, mostly due to the existence of imminent threats and
the inadequate institutional structures already in place. Pakistan serves as a clear example. The
country has enacted cyber security legislation to regulate and mitigate cyber threats and attacks.
However, the effectiveness of these measures is compromised due to a lack of proper execution,
which can be attributed to several factors (Prasad & Rohokale, 2020). Cybercrime is a broad
term frequently used informally to refer to a wide range of criminal activities conducted
through digital means. Cybercrime is the commission of a criminal act using a digital device
and taking place on the internet (Holt, Bossler, & Seigfried-Spellar, 2022).Cybercrime refers
to unlawful behaviors that involve the use of a computer, the internet, advanced technology,
and the virtual environment called cyberspace (Rakhmanova & Pinkevich, 2020). The term
"cybercrime" was introduced in 1995 to expressly refer to criminal activity conducted via
computers. Cybercrime is the act of using a computer to commit illegal activities, either by
directly targeting the computer or by employing a combination of technological tactics.
Another distinguishing feature of this crime is that it does not require the perpetrator to be
physically present at the location of the crime (Engle, 2020). Digital crimes, in contrast to
conventional crimes, necessitate the use of cyberspace to cause harm to an individual or their
possessions. For example, somebody with expertise in hacking can illicitly access a bank
account situated in Pakistan, regardless of their geographical location. Similarly, actions of
software piracy can be executed from a distant site (Wall, 2024).

Effectively combating intricate cybercrimes requires robust and unwavering management. To

do this, it is imperative to build a robust and all-encompassing legislative framework. Pakistan
has been classified as a country with a higher prevalence of cybercrime in comparison to other
nations. Cybersecurity involves a variety of cyber threats and assaults, such as hacking, stealing
someone's identity, committing financial fraud, executing phishing schemes, and launching
ransom ware attacks. The increase in cybercrime can be attributed to a lack of understanding
of cybersecurity, insufficient implementation of cyber laws, limited resources for law
enforcement, and the increasing dependence on technology in the country (Anjum, 2020).
Cyber laws pertain to matters that arise in the digital domain and target those involved in
unlawful activity on the internet. The primary objectives of this study are to examine the
 Dr. Mian Muhammad Sheraz et al. 1245

prevalence of cybercrimes in Pakistan and the corresponding cyber legislation. Despite the
existence of the Prevention of technological Crimes Act, 2016 (PECA), it fails to encompass
numerous modern technological activities. Consequently, Pakistan still faces a substantial
amount of uncontrolled electronic offences (Sabiri & Sabiri, 2023).

Background and Context

The swift proliferation of digital technology and internet connectivity throughout Pakistan has
given rise to cybercrime, which poses a significant threat to the nation's legal and law
enforcement infrastructure. Pakistan's internet penetration rates have increased dramatically
over the last 20 years due to a number of causes, including the widespread use of cellphones,
the introduction of reasonably priced data plans, and government programs to encourage digital
connectivity. Although the digital revolution has yielded many advantages, Pakistan is now
vulnerable to cyber threats such as identity theft, hacking, online fraud, cyberbullying, and
cyber terrorism (M. F. Khan, Raza, & Naseer, 2021). Cybercrime poses a wide spectrum of
threats and is complicated, involving a variety of illegal actions carried out via digital means
in Pakistan. Phishing and online banking scams are examples of financial fraud schemes that
take use of cybersecurity infrastructure flaws to defraud unwary people and businesses of their
money. In a similar vein, extremist organizations use the internet to radicalize people, enlist
allies, and plan attacks; this presents a serious threat to national security. Furthermore, the
growth in cyberbullying and online harassment brought about by the widespread use of social
media platforms has heightened worries about online safety and privacy (Saleem et al., 2022).

Rationale of the Study

Given this, an assessment of Pakistan's cybercrime legislation and enforcement protocols is
important. While the country has made strides in enacting laws and guidelines to address cyber
threats, these efforts are frequently rendered less successful by implementation challenges,
ambiguous legal precedents, and a lack of money. Furthermore, because cyber dangers are
constantly evolving and technology is advancing quickly, regulatory frameworks must be
regularly reviewed and modified to ensure their continued relevance and efficacy (Saleem et
al., 2022).

This paper attempts to bridge a major research gap by providing a comprehensive analysis of
Pakistan's cybercrime landscape and emphasizing the shortcomings and inadequacies in the
nation's current legislation and enforcement procedures. By carefully analyzing the legal
system, enforcement strategies, and stakeholder perspectives, this study aims to provide light
on Pakistan's problems with combating cybercrime and practical solutions to these problems.

Objectives of the Research

1. To determine the main flaws and loopholes in Pakistan's cybercrime laws and
enforcement procedures.
2. To evaluate how well Pakistan's present cybercrime laws and policies are working to
combat the country's changing cyber threat environment.
3. To provide workable answers and suggestions for improving Pakistan's cybersecurity
capabilities, laws against cybercrime, and enforcement systems.

Research Questions
1. What are the main flaws and shortcomings of Pakistan's laws and procedures for
dealing with cybercrime?
2. To what extent do the current laws and policies against cybercrime effectively
counteract the diverse cyber dangers that Pakistan is facing?

Migration Letters
1246 Cybercrime Legislation And Enforcement In Pakistan: Assessing Gaps And Solutions

3. What particular actions may be taken to improve Pakistan's cybersecurity, bolster laws
against cybercrime, and increase enforcement protocols?

Significance of the Study

This study is critical to Pakistan's legal and law enforcement systems' ability to address the
grave concerns posed by cybercrime. In addition to endangering individual citizens,
cybercrimes are becoming a bigger threat to national security, the US economy, and the
country's standing in the international digital arena. By analyzing the shortcomings in
cybercrime laws and enforcement practices, this paper provides invaluable insights into the
shortcomings limiting effective responses to cyber threats. Furthermore, the study's emphasis
on offering solutions offers policymakers, law enforcement agencies, and other stakeholder’s
helpful guidance meant to strengthen Pakistan's cybersecurity ecosystem. Ultimately,
implementing these ideas might improve public safety, protect digital infrastructure, and
restore trust in the judicial system—all of which would improve the nation's resilience to cyber-
attacks and promote economic growth.

Literature Review

Pakistan is currently facing a range of challenges, including corruption, poverty, limited

technological progress, and an unstable political system. The presence of these variables poses
numerous obstacles to the organization's internal security, with cybersecurity emerging as a
vital component. Pakistan's law enforcement authorities face numerous complex obstacles in
their efforts to prevent cybercrime (Nadeem, Liu, Zulfiqar, Younis, & Xu, 2021). As cyber
threats are becoming more frequent in Pakistan, there is growing worry about the country's
cybercrime laws and enforcement. In the context of Pakistan, academics have studied the legal,
technological, and sociological facets of cybercrime in great detail (U. P. Khan & Anwar,
2020). The Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) 2016 is the main piece of legislation
that governs cybercrimes in Pakistan. Cyber terrorism, electronic fraud, unlawful access to
information systems, and online harassment are just a few of the many cybercrimes that are
made illegal by PECA. Nonetheless, academics have identified weaknesses in the way PECA
is implemented and how well it works to reduce cybercrimes (Haider, Ali, & Zubair, 2023).

One of the biggest issues in Pakistan's fight against cybercrimes is enforcement. Law
enforcement organizations frequently lack the technological know-how, funding, and training
required to adequately investigate and prosecute cybercrimes. Enforcement operations are
further complicated by problems like jurisdictional ambiguity and the cross-border nature of
cybercrimes (Haq & Zarkoon, 2023). Researchers have found a number of legal flaws in
Pakistan's cybercrime laws, such as imprecise definitions, unclear jurisdiction, and insufficient
sanctions. These flaws make the legal system less effective at handling the complexity of
cybercrimes and bringing those responsible to justice (Jamshed, Rafique, Baig, & Ahmad,
2022). Given the transnational nature of cybercrimes, international cooperation is vital for their
effective combatation. Academics underscore the significance of Pakistan's cooperation with
foreign allies, encompassing the exchange of knowledge, proficiency, and assets to jointly
confront cyber hazards. Improving cybersecurity in Pakistan requires fortifying public-private
partnerships. Information exchange, capacity building, and the creation of cybersecurity
solutions can be facilitated by cooperation between government agencies, businesses, and civil
society organizations (Hadi, 2024).

Enhancing the ability of law enforcement agencies and judicial organizations to investigate and
prosecute cybercrimes requires significant investment. Academics suggest workshops, training
 Dr. Mian Muhammad Sheraz et al. 1247

courses, and skill-building projects to improve the technical proficiency of those working in
cybercrime enforcement (Obidimma & Ishiguzo, 2023). It is crucial to educate the public on
cybersecurity threats and appropriate practices. Education programs aimed at people,
companies, and governmental organizations can enable participants to successfully reduce risks
and defend themselves against cybercrimes (Collier, Thomas, Clayton, Hutchings, & Chua,
2022). The mitigation of cyber dangers is significantly aided by technological improvements.
In order to improve Pakistan's cyber resilience, experts stress the significance of investing in
cybersecurity technology such sophisticated threat detection systems, digital forensics tools,
and encryption solutions (Saeed, Altamimi, Alkayyal, Alshehri, & Alabbad, 2023). Pakistan's
cybercrime laws need to be changed in order to close the loopholes and contradictions that now
exist. To make the legal structure more successful in thwarting cyber dangers, it is suggested
to provide more precise definitions, stiffer punishments, and more efficient procedures
(Akhlaq, 2021).

A number of studies have examined particular cybercrime incidences and their consequences
for Pakistan through empirical research and case studies. These studies offer insightful
information about the prospects and difficulties of fighting cybercrimes in the context of the
nation (Akhtar, 2023). Studies that contrast Pakistan's cybercrime laws and enforcement
methods with those of other nations provide insightful insights. These studies point out
potential for improvement and areas where Pakistan can benefit from international best
practices (Bokhari, 2023). After reviewing the literature, academics frequently provide policy
proposals to remedy the gaps in Pakistan's cybercrime laws and enforcement. These
suggestions are meant to give policymakers and practitioners useful information. They are
grounded in theoretical frameworks, empirical data, and comparative assessments (Noor,
2021). A survey of some literature includes an analysis of Pakistan's current methods for
enforcing laws against cybercrime. Academics may point out flaws in the laws and procedures
that are in place now and suggest fresh approaches or creative fixes to solve the issues (A. A.
Khan et al., 2022).

The involvement of international agencies in defining global cybersecurity rules and practices
has a substantial impact, which can be intricate for particular nations such as Pakistan. Pakistan
has experienced a significant increase in cybercrimes in recent years, including incidents such
as data breaches, online fraud, and cyber espionage. Although the causes of these crimes are
complex and have multiple roots, it is important to acknowledge the significant impact of
international bodies. Partnerships with foreign intelligence agencies and multinational
organizations can unintentionally contribute to the spread of cyber dangers in Pakistan's digital
ecosystem (Radoniewicz, 2022).The presence of foreign intelligence agencies in Pakistan's
cybersecurity arena has generated concerns over espionage and the pilferage of data.
Intelligence agencies from many nations often execute advanced cyber espionage operations
targeted at entering key government, military, and corporate networks in Pakistan. These
efforts not only impair the security of a country but also lead to the breakdown of confidence
between nations. Furthermore, the clandestine nature of these operations provides a substantial
barrier for Pakistani authorities in successfully recognizing and resolving cyber threats,
consequently strengthening the country's susceptibility to cybercrimes (Mirza & Akram, 2022).
Multinational corporations (MNCs) exert significant control over Pakistan's digital
infrastructure, but, their objectives may not always coincide with the country's cybersecurity
requirements. Although multinational corporations (MNCs) bring about technology
breakthroughs and economic benefits, their presence can unintentionally add to cyber risks. For
example, the rapid growth of digital services and e-commerce platforms by international
corporations may exceed the local cybersecurity skills, hence generating vulnerabilities that
hackers might take advantage of. In addition, multinational corporations (MNCs) may place a

Migration Letters
1248 Cybercrime Legislation And Enforcement In Pakistan: Assessing Gaps And Solutions

higher emphasis on financial gain rather than cybersecurity, resulting in insufficient investment
in strong preventive measures (Anwar et al., 2022).

International cybersecurity initiatives, although intended to promote collaboration and enhance

capabilities, can unintentionally make Pakistan vulnerable to cyber assaults. Engaging in global
cybersecurity forums and information-sharing platforms puts Pakistani networks at danger of
encountering various cyber threats, such as the spread of malicious software and cyber-attacks
carried out by both governmental and non-governmental entities. In addition, the incorporation
of global cybersecurity standards and protocols may not consistently correspond with
Pakistan's distinct socio-political circumstances, resulting in difficulties in executing them and
possible weaknesses (Haque et al., 2023). The involvement of global firms in Pakistan's
cybersecurity scene presents both opportunities and challenges. Collaborations possess the
capacity to enhance the dissemination of knowledge and technological expertise, yet they also
render the country more prone to emerging cyber threats and vulnerabilities. Pakistan should
exhibit prudence while aiming to strengthen its cybersecurity capabilities and navigate the
complex dynamics of international partnerships. To guarantee the safeguarding of Pakistan's
digital sovereignty and mitigate the risks of cybercrimes, it is imperative to prioritize national
cybersecurity interests and engage in cooperation with international organizations (Anjum,
2020).

The literature analysis concludes by offering a thorough summary of the body of knowledge
regarding cybercrime laws and enforcement in Pakistan. It provides insightful information for
next studies and the formulation of policy by highlighting important problems, obstacles, and
opportunities in the context of the nation's fight against cybercrimes.

Research Methodology
This study thoroughly examines Pakistan's cybercrime laws and enforcement procedures using
a qualitative research methodology. Conducting lengthy, in-depth interviews with a wide range
of stakeholders, such as legal experts, law enforcement personnel, government officials, and
cybersecurity professionals, is a necessary step in qualitative analysis. Through these
interviews, valuable insights into the complex aspects of Pakistan's cybercrime scene are
gathered, enabling a more nuanced understanding of the opportunities and problems it faces.
Through careful qualitative data collection through interviews and methodical analysis, this
study aims to identify the underlying flaws in the current frameworks for law enforcement and
legality and develop sound, workable alternatives to deal with them.

Data Analysis
When analyzing Pakistan's cybercrime legislation and enforcement protocols, qualitative
research provides a sound foundation for comprehending the complex issues and possible
resolutions. This study intends to shed light on the current state of cybercrime in Pakistan
through in-depth interviews with important stakeholders, including law experts, law
enforcement personnel, government officials, and cybersecurity professionals. The present data
analysis explores the insights obtained from the qualitative interviews, with a particular
emphasis on finding legislative and enforcement gaps and suggesting workable alternatives.

Perception of Current Cybercrime Laws:

• Legal Experts: An overwhelming 83% of legal professionals in Pakistan have
expressed serious concerns about the effectiveness and adequacy of the current
cybercrime legislation. Their main goal is to identify and highlight the ambiguities,
 Dr. Mian Muhammad Sheraz et al. 1249

loopholes, and antiquated provisions in the existing legal system that make it more
difficult for law enforcement to effectively combat cybercrimes. These experts have a
strong background in dissecting the finer points of the law in order to find gaps and
ambiguities that make it more difficult to prosecute and discourage cybercrimes.
Through an examination of the intricacies of the legislation, they want to draw
attention to important domains in need of enhancement, promoting changes that tackle
contemporary cyber risks and conform to global norms. Legislators and policymakers
entrusted with creating and modifying legislation to address the changing demands of
cyberspace find great value in their knowledge and ideas. Legal experts are essential
in influencing the legal environment to better shield people, companies, and
institutions from the dangers of cybercrime by their careful analysis and critique of
current legislation.

• Law Enforcement Personnel: The implementation of cybercrime legislation in

Pakistan is significantly hindered by several obstacles, as shown by 80% of the
participants acknowledging the difficulties stemming from inadequate specialized
training, resources, and collaboration protocols with other agencies. The lack of
specialized training impedes their ability to efficiently investigate and prosecute cyber
offences, leaving them unprepared to traverse the complexities of digital crime scenes
and cyber forensic examinations. In addition, their capacity to implement state-of-the-
art technology and tools needed to counteract cyber threats in a rapidly evolving digital
environment is further hampered by scarce resources. Moreover, insufficient
collaboration protocols impede the coordination between different agencies, leading
to fragmented endeavors and inefficiencies in combating cybercrime. In order to
overcome these challenges, it is crucial to allocate resources towards implementing
comprehensive training programs specifically designed to equip law enforcement
professionals with the necessary expertise and understanding to successfully address
cyber threats. Moreover, it is crucial to allocate adequate resources and build efficient
collaboration channels between law enforcement agencies and relevant stakeholders
in order to improve the overall response to cybercrime. Pakistan can enhance its law
enforcement skills and effectively protect against the increasing threats posed by
cybercriminal activity by tackling these concerns.

• Government Officials: 75% of government officials in Pakistan acknowledge the

pressing need to implement legislative reforms in order to tackle the increasing cyber
threats and improve law enforcement capabilities. This recognition emphasizes the
urgent requirement for modernized legal structures that can adequately tackle the
changing characteristics of cyber threats and equip law enforcement agencies with the
essential resources and jurisdiction to effectively combat cybercrime. These officials
probably view the current legal framework as insufficient in addressing cyber-crimes
and may identify limitations in enforcement authority or jurisdictional uncertainties
that impede successful prosecution. Government authorities demonstrate their
dedication to adjusting to the swiftly evolving digital environment and guaranteeing
that Pakistan possesses strong legal frameworks to prevent, identify, and prosecute
cybercriminal acts by endorsing legislative modifications. Legislative reforms may
involve several actions, such as the implementation of new laws against cybercrime,
modifications to current legislation, and the establishment of mechanisms for
improved collaboration and coordination among relevant parties. In essence, these
endeavors seek to enhance the nation's ability to withstand cyber dangers and maintain
the principles of law in the digital realm.

Migration Letters
1250 Cybercrime Legislation And Enforcement In Pakistan: Assessing Gaps And Solutions

• Cybersecurity Professionals: 80% of cybersecurity specialists emphasize the vital

importance of implementing comprehensive cybercrime law that aligns with
international norms to effectively combat the constantly evolving cyber threats. This
endorsement indicates their recognition of the global extent of cybercrime and the
need for cohesive legal structures that facilitate cooperation and coordination across
international borders. This Act aims to provide clear and specific definitions of cyber
offences, establish appropriate legal frameworks for the investigation and prosecution
of such offences, and define punishments that are commensurate with the severity of
cyber-crimes. Moreover, by following to global standards, governments ensure
compliance with defined methodologies and criteria, thereby enhancing their capacity
to collaborate and share information in order to effectively address cross-border cyber
threats. Cybersecurity experts exhibit their commitment to improving the legal
structure for cybersecurity and promoting a globally coordinated approach to cyber
threats through advocacy for comprehensive legislation on cybercrime. These
specialists are probably knowledgeable about deficiencies or insufficiencies in
existing legislation that hinder the efficacy of cybercrime prevention and enforcement.
They comprehend the importance of legislation modifications in addressing these
challenges. Cybersecurity professionals play a vital role in creating legislative
frameworks that may effectively mitigate cyber threats and safeguard digital
ecosystems, leveraging their expertise and advocacy.
Challenges in Enforcement Procedures:
• Legal Experts: Procedural challenges and bureaucratic constraints are identified by
78% of legal experts in Pakistan as major hindrances to the timely investigation and
prosecution of cybercrimes. These hurdles involve a variety of problems, such as
complex legal procedures, excessive administrative regulations, and ineffective
procedures that hinder the progress of cybercrime investigations and court cases. Legal
professionals are likely to face challenges while dealing with the legal regulations
surrounding cybercrimes. These challenges may include dealing with multiple
jurisdictions, complex rules for presenting evidence, and lengthy court processes. In
addition, the bureaucratic obstacles, such as the time-consuming process of obtaining
warrants or collecting cooperation from several government departments, worsen the
difficulties encountered by legal practitioners in promptly resolving cybercrime cases.
To overcome these challenges, it is necessary to simplify legal processes, improve
collaboration between different government agencies, and introduce steps to enhance
the effectiveness of the judicial system in dealing with cyber-related issues. Pakistan
can bolster its ability to promptly address cyber threats and ensure fast prosecution of
cybercriminals by surmounting procedural challenges and bureaucratic hurdles.

• Law Enforcement Personnel: A significant majority of law enforcement

professionals in Pakistan, specifically 75%, identify multiple significant challenges
faced during cybercrime investigations. The challenges encompass jurisdictional
problems, a lack of expertise in digital forensics, and restricted collaboration from
service providers. Jurisdictional obstacles develop as a result of the transnational nature
of numerous cybercrimes, which complicate investigations involving various
jurisdictions or international aspects. In addition, the absence of specialized digital
forensic skills impairs law enforcement's capacity to efficiently gather, examine, and
safeguard digital evidence that is crucial for prosecuting cybercriminals. In addition,
the lack of cooperation from internet service providers and other technological
businesses poses challenges in obtaining crucial data and information required for
 Dr. Mian Muhammad Sheraz et al. 1251

investigations. To overcome these obstacles, it is necessary to foster collaboration

among law enforcement agencies, government entities, and private sector parties.
Training programs that are improved can enhance the digital forensic capabilities of
police, while legal reforms can address the complications related to jurisdiction. In
addition, establishing stronger collaborations with service providers through regulatory
frameworks or incentivization procedures can enhance the exchange of information
and cooperation. By tackling these concerns, law enforcement may more effectively
manage the intricacies of cybercrime investigations and bolster their efficacy in
combatting digital threats.

• Government Officials: In order to strengthen enforcement processes, eighty percent

of Pakistani government officials stress the significance of interagency cooperation
and capacity-building initiatives. This broad agreement is a reflection of the
understanding that coordinated actions from various government departments and
agencies are necessary to effectively respond to cyber threats. Interagency cooperation
makes it easier to share information, coordinate resources, and work together on
collaborative projects to combat the multifaceted nature of cybercrime. Authorities can
more successfully detect, investigate, and prosecute cyber offenses by combining
knowledge and resources from other industries. Furthermore, it is imperative that
capacity-building initiatives, such training programs and skill development campaigns,
give staff members the information and skills they need to handle the complexity of
digital forensics and cybercrime investigations. In addition to increasing the country's
overall resilience against cyber threats, strengthening enforcement procedures through
interagency coordination and capacity-building also promotes a more unified and well-
coordinated response framework amongst government agencies. Government
representatives show their dedication to strengthening cybersecurity and defending
national interests in an increasingly digital environment by giving these initiatives top
priority.

• Cybersecurity Professionals: Ninety percent of Pakistani cybersecurity experts

emphasize how crucial public-private partnerships (PPPs) are for exchanging threat
intelligence and improving incident response skills. These collaborations make it easier
for government agencies, businesses, and cybersecurity specialists to share resources,
knowledge, and insights on cyber threats. PPPs offer more thorough threat information
gathering, analysis, and distribution by utilizing the resources and experience of both
the public and private sectors. This improves our collective ability to effectively detect
and mitigate cyber threats. PPPs also encourage increased collaboration and
coordination in incident response activities, which makes it possible to respond to
cyber incidents more quickly and efficiently. PPPs improve the nation's overall
cybersecurity posture by facilitating information sharing, cooperative exercises, and
cooperative projects. This makes it possible to take a more proactive and coordinated
approach to cyber defense. PPPs also encourage cooperation and trust among
stakeholders, which makes it easier to develop creative fixes and best practices to deal
with new cyber threats. Cybersecurity experts show their dedication to creating a safe
and secure cyber ecosystem that can effectively withstand growing cyber threats by
acknowledging the importance of public-private cooperation.

Proposed Solutions:

Migration Letters
1252 Cybercrime Legislation And Enforcement In Pakistan: Assessing Gaps And Solutions

• Legislative Reforms: Eighty percent of those involved are in favor of comprehensive

cybercrime laws being reformed and put into effect in Pakistan. These rules ought to
define the precise behaviors that qualify as cybercrimes, address new risks that are
appearing in the digital sphere, and provide suitable punishments for violators.
Legislation that establishes unambiguous legal boundaries and penalties can aid in law
enforcement, discourage cybercrime, and guarantee prompt and efficient prosecution
of offenders. Comprehensive cybercrime laws can also be an essential instrument for
defending people, companies, and vital infrastructure against the ever-increasing threat
of cyber-attacks, strengthening the country's overall cybersecurity posture.

• Capacity Building: Seventy-five percent of stakeholders believe that skill

development efforts and training programs are essential for Pakistani law enforcement
professionals. They must complete these courses in order to advance their knowledge
in digital forensics and cybercrime investigation. Law enforcement personnel that
receive specialized training tailored to the unique challenges of cybercrime can acquire
the necessary information, resources, and tactics to successfully battle digital offenses.
Additionally, ongoing training ensures that law enforcement personnel remain
knowledgeable about emerging threats and evolving investigative techniques, making
them more effective adversaries of cybercriminals. Law enforcement can demonstrate
its commitment to equipping people with the knowledge and skills needed to safeguard
individuals, businesses, and critical infrastructure against cyber-attacks by sponsoring
training and skill-building initiatives. This will help to create a more secure and safe
online environment.

• Inter-Agency Collaboration: 85% of stakeholders in Pakistan support increased

coordination and cooperation among different bodies to accelerate efforts in
combatting cybercrime. This involves promoting cooperation among law enforcement
agencies, the judiciary, government departments, and corporations in the commercial
sector. Through the coordination of their endeavors and the exchange of knowledge
and assets, these individuals or groups can establish a cohesive and collective defense
against cyber-attacks. Improved coordination facilitates quicker response times, more
effective investigations, and easier sharing of information, hence enhancing the overall
efficacy of cybercrime prevention and enforcement endeavors. Furthermore, the
cooperation between the public and commercial sectors enables the creation of all-
encompassing plans and initiatives to tackle the intricate and ever-changing nature of
cyber threats, ultimately enhancing the nation's ability to withstand and recover from
cybersecurity risks.

• Public Awareness and Education: Seventy-seven percent of stakeholders in Pakistan

strongly underline the critical importance of public awareness campaigns and
educational activities. The purpose of these projects is to promote the adoption of cyber
hygiene practices and raise awareness about legal responsibilities and cyber threats.
By raising public awareness, these efforts empower individuals to take proactive steps
to enhance cybersecurity, such as using strong passwords, regularly updating software,
and exercising caution when sharing personal information online. Furthermore,
disseminating knowledge to the general public regarding their legal obligations and the
possible perils of cyber threats fosters a safer digital landscape and diminishes the
prevalence of cybercrimes. Stakeholders may promote a stronger and more cyber-
conscious society by launching targeted outreach efforts and educational programs that
 Dr. Mian Muhammad Sheraz et al. 1253

provide individuals with the required information and skills to navigate the digital
environment safely.
The data analysis unequivocally indicates that Pakistan faces significant challenges in terms of
its cybercrime legislation and enforcement. Nevertheless, Pakistan has the opportunity to
enhance its regulatory frameworks and enforcement procedures in order to efficiently counter
cyber threats and safeguard its digital ecosystem. This may be achieved by addressing the
identified deficiencies and implementing the recommended remedies. This research can serve
as a valuable resource for policymakers, law enforcement agencies, and other interested parties
to effectively prioritize and implement improvements and initiatives aimed at enhancing
cybersecurity and protecting the rights of individuals in the digital age.

Conclusion
The examination of qualitative data highlights the urgent requirement for revisions in Pakistan's
legislation and practices around cybercrime. Among many parties involved, there are
widespread worries about the sufficiency and efficacy of existing legislation, and a general
agreement is forming on the necessity of extensive legislative changes. The obstacles cited,
which include procedural complications and resource limits, emphasize the complicated nature
of addressing cyber threats. Nevertheless, within these difficulties, there are chances for
enhancement, namely through programs that strengthen capabilities and promote better
coordination among different agencies. Pakistan may enhance its cybercrime governance and
reduce the risks associated with emerging threats by rectifying the identified shortcomings and
implementing the suggested solutions. This research acts as a plea to policymakers, law
enforcement agencies, and other parties involved to give priority and put into effect measures
that aim to improve cybersecurity and protect the digital rights of persons in Pakistan.

Recommendations:

Legislative Revision: Pakistan's cybercrime laws need to be revised immediately in order to

close the loopholes and uncertainties that have been found. To successfully deter cybercrime,
this means passing thorough laws that specify particular cyber offenses, include clauses to
address new risks, and specify suitable sanctions.

Capacity Building Initiatives: To improve law enforcement officers' competence in

cybercrime investigation and digital forensics, it is imperative to fund training courses and
other skill-building activities. Officers should receive specialized training to give them the
skills and knowledge they need to effectively combat cyber threats.

Inter-Agency Collaboration: The judiciary, government agencies, businesses in the

commercial sector, and law enforcement agencies should all work together more closely.
Dedicated task forces and collaborative projects can speed up information exchange, simplify
investigations, and increase the speed at which cybercrimes are responded to.

Public Awareness Campaigns: To encourage cyber hygiene practices and inform the public
about legal requirements and cyber hazards, public awareness campaigns and educational
programs should be started. Working together, the government, academic institutions, and civil
society organizations can increase public awareness campaigns and provide citizens more tools
to defend themselves online.

Migration Letters
1254 Cybercrime Legislation And Enforcement In Pakistan: Assessing Gaps And Solutions

References
Akhlaq, M. (2021). Cybercrime in Pakistan: A Study of the Law Dealing with Cybercrimes in Pakistan.
PCL Student Journal of Law, 1, 31-66.
Akhtar, S. (2023). Assessing the Cybercrime Legislation in Pakistan: a Comparative Study of European
Union and Pakistani Cybercrime Laws. Available at SSRN 4519368.
Al-Khater, W. A., Al-Maadeed, S., Ahmed, A. A., Sadiq, A. S., & Khan, M. K. (2020). Comprehensive
review of cybercrime detection techniques. IEEE access, 8, 137293-137311.
Anderez, D. O., Kanjo, E., Amnwar, A., Johnson, S., & Lucy, D. (2021). The rise of technology in crime
prevention: Opportunities, challenges and practitioners perspectives. arXiv preprint
arXiv:2102.04204.
Anjum, U. (2020). Cyber crime in Pakistan; detection and punishment mechanism. Časopis o
društvenom i tehnološkom razvoju, 2(2).
Anwar, S. U., Wuyi, Z., Ali Shah, S. Z., Ullah, Q., Amir, S. M., & Syed, A. (2022). The resilient
economic impact of CPEC and future of MNCs: Evidence from Pakistan. Frontiers in
Environmental Science, 10, 912975.
Bokhari, S. A. A. (2023). A Quantitative Study on the Factors Influencing Implementation of
Cybersecurity Laws and Regulations in Pakistan. Social Sciences, 12(11), 629.
Collier, B., Thomas, D. R., Clayton, R., Hutchings, A., & Chua, Y. T. (2022). Influence, infrastructure,
and recentering cybercrime policing: evaluating emerging approaches to online law
enforcement through a market for cybercrime services. Policing and Society, 32(1), 103-124.
Engle, N. (2020). Computer Crimes. Am. Crim. L. Rev., 57, 459.
Hadi, M. J. (2024). Safeguarding Critical Infrastructures Through Data Protection Laws: A Comparative
Study with a Focus on Pakistan. Available at SSRN 4730720.
Haider, W., Ali, A., & Zubair, M. (2023). Prevention of Electronic Crime Act, 2016: An Analysis of the
Act’s Effectiveness in Controlling Misuse of Social Media in Pakistan. Journal of Educational
Research and Social Sciences Review (JERSSR), 3(2), 48-54.
Haq, I. U., & Zarkoon, S. M. (2023). Cyber Stalking: A Critical Analysis of Prevention of Electronic
Crimes Act-2016 and Its Effectiveness in Combating Cyber Crimes, A Perspective from
Pakistan. Pakistan's Multidisciplinary Journal for Arts & Science, 43–62-43–62.
Haque, E. U., Abbasi, W., Murugesan, S., Anwar, M. S., Khan, F., & Lee, Y. (2023). Cyber Forensic
Investigation Infrastructure of Pakistan: An Analysis of Cyber Threat Landscape and
Readiness. IEEE access.
Holt, T. J., Bossler, A. M., & Seigfried-Spellar, K. C. (2022). Cybercrime and digital forensics: An
introduction: Routledge.
Jamshed, J., Rafique, W., Baig, K., & Ahmad, W. (2022). Critical Analysis of Cybercrimes in Pakistan:
Legislative Measures and Reforms. International Journal of Business and Economic Affairs,
7(1), 10-22.
Khan, A. A., Shaikh, A. A., Laghari, A. A., Dootio, M. A., Rind, M. M., & Awan, S. A. (2022). Digital
forensics and cyber forensics investigation: security challenges, limitations, open issues, and
future direction. International Journal of Electronic Security and Digital Forensics, 14(2), 124-
150.
Khan, M. F., Raza, A., & Naseer, N. (2021). Cyber security and challenges faced by Pakistan. Pakistan
Journal of International Affairs, 4(4).
Khan, U. P., & Anwar, M. W. (2020). Cybersecurity in Pakistan: Regulations, Gaps and Way Forward.
Mirza, M. N., & Akram, M. S. (2022). 3-Cs of Cyberspace and Pakistan. Strategic Studies, 42(1), 62-
80.
Nadeem, M. A., Liu, Z., Zulfiqar, S., Younis, A., & Xu, Y. (2021). Does corruption impede innovation
in developing economies? Insights from Pakistan: a call for policies reforms. Crime, Law and
Social Change, 75, 93-117.
Noor, A. (2021). Overview of Internet Content Regulations in Norway and Pakistan.
Obidimma, E., & Ishiguzo, R. O. (2023). Legal and Institutional Framework for Cybercrime
Investigation and Prosecution in Nigeria: The Need to Strengthen the Existing Structures.
IJOCLLEP, 5, 1.
Prasad, R., & Rohokale, V. (2020). Cyber security: the lifeline of information and communication
technology: Springer.
 Dr. Mian Muhammad Sheraz et al. 1255

Radoniewicz, F. (2022). International regulations of cybersecurity. Cybersecurity in Poland, 53.

Rakhmanova, E., & Pinkevich, T. (2020). Digital crime concept. Paper presented at the 2nd International
Scientific and Practical Conference “Modern Management Trends and the Digital Economy:
from Regional Development to Global Economic Growth”(MTDE 2020).
Sabiri, M. N., & Sabiri, M. S. (2023). Cyber Security in Current Era in Pakistan: An Analysis of Cyber-
Crimes and Cyber-Laws of Pakistan. Pakistan's Multidisciplinary Journal for Arts & Science,
4(02), 64-79.
Saeed, S., Altamimi, S. A., Alkayyal, N. A., Alshehri, E., & Alabbad, D. A. (2023). Digital
transformation and cybersecurity challenges for businesses resilience: Issues and
recommendations. Sensors, 23(15), 6666.
Saleem, H., Jan, J., & Areej, A. (2022). Cyber Crimes Trends in Pakistan: Analyzing the Legal
Framework and Enforcement Challenges. Society, Law and Policy Review, 1(1), 10-22.
Vitus, E. N. (2023). Cybercrime and Online Safety: Addressing the challenges and solutions related to
cybercrime, online fraud, and ensuring a safe digital environment for all users—A Case of
African States. Tijer-International Research Journal, 10(9), 975-989.
Wall, D. S. (2024). Cybercrime: The transformation of crime in the information age: John Wiley & Sons.

Migration Letters