Aman Gupta RPR Sem 4
Aman Gupta RPR Sem 4
by
Session 2023-24
I hereby declare that the work presented in this report entitled “A STUDY ON PORTFOLIO
MANAGEMENT RISK AND INVESTMENT BEHAVIOUR”, was carried out by me. I have not
submitted the matter embodied in this report for the award of any other degree or diploma
of any other University or Institute. I have given due credit to the original authors/sources
for all the words, ideas, diagrams, graphics, computer programs, experiments, results, that
are not my original contribution. I have used quotation marks to identify verbatim
sentences and given credit to the original authors/sources.
I affirm that no portion of my work is plagiarized, and the experiments and results reported
in the report are not manipulated. In the event of a complaint of plagiarism and the
manipulation of the experiments and results, I shall be fully responsible and answerable.
(Student’s Signature)
G. L. BAJAJ
INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY & MANAGEMENT
Approved by A.I.C.T.E. & affiliated to Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam Technical University
Date:
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that Aman Kumar Gupta Roll No. 2201920700037 has
I wish him/ her all the best for his/her bright future ahead.
Project Supervisor
Department of Management
Studies
Head of Department
Department of Management
Studies
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I feel great pleasure to submit this report as the culmination of efforts by my teachers and
me. This is the last step of my path leading to graduate degree in Management through
M.B.A.
This project is the result of my hard work, sincerity, and devotion, & put my best to
complete and in turn, gain lots of knowledge and confidence from this project.
I am deeply thankful to my project guide Dr. Aarti Loomba, Faculty Guide, G.L Bajaj
Institute of Technology & Management, Gr. Noida for her constant support and guide this
Lastly, I am very thankful to my parents and all those people has been supported me
directly or indirectly, without their constant support and help this research report
(2201920700037)
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 3
CHAPTER ONE
Introduction to Investment 4-12
CHAPTER TWO
Literature Review of Portfolio Management 12-66
CHAPTER THREE
Research Methodology 66
Objective of the Study 67
CHAPTER FOUR
Analysis and Interpretation of Data 68-76
CHAPTER FIVE
Findings of study 78
Recommendations 79-80
Conclusion 81
Limitations 82
Bibliography 83
2
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
As we all know that every topic of research has its own importance and it’s slightly tough to gather
the information that is required completely for a particular subject. There are different ways of
presenting an idea in your report. It’s obvious that defining a topic and its objective is not easy,
but making the proper start in order to do something, which is of some use, is different.
It is matter of privilege for me that I got an opportunity to do Research work on the topic “Portfolio
Management Risk and Behavior of Investors”. The project includes study of various terms and
facts related with the portfolio management and study regarding how to create and manage
portfolio in order to increase its efficiency and effectiveness.
The aim of the research report is to get overview of Portfolio Management. To understand how to
diversify risk in portfolio. The objective is to cope with risk and return situations while making
investment. To make investment in securities which are more profitable as compared to others.
The research report is prepared in order to aware investors while making investment and as a result
investors make investment in more profitable securities which ultimately increase their earnings
and increase their economic status in society. The research report also helps in making balance
between risk and return in investment.
3
CHAPTER – 1
4
INVESTMENT
Investment is the application of money for earning more money. Investment also means savings
income in the long run is both examples of investments. Although there is a general broad
definition to the term investment, it carries slightly different meanings to different industrial
sectors.
Types of Investment
There are many ways to invest our money. Of course, to decide which investment vehicles are
suitable for us, we need to know their characteristics and why they may be suitable for a particular
investing objective.
1. Bonds
2. Stocks
3. Mutual funds
[Link], Futures
5. FOREX
6. Gold
5
1) Bonds
Grouped under the general category called fixed-income securities, the term bond is commonly
used to refer to any securities that are founded on debt. When we purchase a bond, we are lending
out our money to a company or government. In return, they agree to give interest on our money
The main attraction of bonds is their relative safety. If we are buying bonds from a stable
government, our investment is virtually guaranteed, or risk-free. The safety and stability, however,
come at a cost because there is little risk, there is little potential return. As a result, the rate of
2) Stocks
When we purchase stocks, or equities, as our advisor might put it, we become a part owner of the
business. This entitles us to vote at the shareholders meeting and allows us to receive any profits
that the company allocates to its owners. These profits are referred to as dividends.
While bonds provide a steady stream of income, stocks are volatile i.e., they fluctuate in value on
a daily basis. When we buy a stock, we aren't guaranteed anything. Many stocks don't even pay
dividends, in which case, the only way that we can make money is if the stock increases in value
– which might not happen. Compared to bonds, stocks provide relatively high potential returns.
Of course, there is a price for this potential: we must assume the risk of losing some or all of our
investment.
6
3) Mutual Fund
A mutual fund is a collection of stocks and bonds. When we buy a mutual fund, we are pooling
our money with a number of other investors, which enables us (as part of a group) to pay a
professional manager to select specific securities for us. Mutual funds are all set up with a specific
strategy in mind, and their distinct focus can be nearly anything: large stocks, small stocks, bonds
from governments, bonds from companies, stocks and bonds, stocks in certain industries, stocks
The primary advantage of a mutual fund is that we can invest our money without the time or the
experience that are often needed to choose a sound investment. Theoretically, we should get a
better return by giving our money to a professional rather than if we were to choose investments
our self. In reality, there are some aspects about mutual funds that we should be aware of before
choosing them.
So, generally there are two basic securities: equity and debt, better known as stocks and bonds.
While many investments fall into one of these two categories, there are numerous alternative
vehicles, which represent the most complicated types of securities and investing strategies. But we
don't need to worry about alternative investments at the start of our investing career. They are
generally high-risk/high-reward securities that are much more speculative than plain old stocks
and bonds. It is true that there is the opportunity for big profits, but they require some specialized
knowledge. So, if we don't know what we are doing, we get our self into a lot of trouble. Experts
and professionals generally agree that new investors should focus on building a financial
7
The Investment Process
As investors, we would all like to beat the market handily, and we would all like to pick "great"
investments on instinct. However, while intuition is undoubtedly a part of the process of investing,
it is just part of the process. As investors, it is not surprising that we focus so much of our energy
and efforts on investment philosophies and strategies, and so little on the investment process. It is
far more interesting to read about how Peter Lynch picks stocks and what makes Warren Buffett
a valuable investor, than it is to talk about the steps involved in creating a portfolio or in executing
trades. Though it does not get sufficient attention, understanding the investment process is critical
The investment process outlines the steps in creating a portfolio, and emphasizes the
sequence of actions involved from understanding the investor’s risk preferences to asset
provides for an orderly way in which an investor can create his or her own portfolio or
The investment process provides a structure that allows investors to see the source of
the hundreds of strategies that they see described in the common press and in investment
The investment process emphasizes the different components that are needed for an
that look good on paper never work for those who use them.
8
It does not emphasize individual investors or push an investment philosophy. It does not focus
heavily on coming up with strategies that beat the market, though there is reference to some of
them in the course of the book. Instead, it talks about the process of investing and how this process
The book is built around the investment process. The process always starts with the investor and
understanding his or her needs and preferences. For a portfolio manager, the investor is a client
and the first and often most significant part of the investment process understands the client’s
needs the client’s tax status and most importantly, his or her risk preferences. For an individual
investor constructing his or her own portfolio, this may seem simpler, but understanding one’s
own needs and preferences is just as important a first step as it is for the portfolio manager.
The next part of the process is the actual construction of the portfolio, which we divide into
three sub-parts. The first of these is the decision on how to allocate the portfolio across
different asset classes defined broadly as equities, fixed income securities and real assets
(such as real estate, commodities and other assets). This asset allocation decision can also be
framed in terms of investments in domestic assets versus foreign assets, and the factors driving
this decision. The second component is the asset selection decision, where individual assets are
picked within each asset class to make up the portfolio. In practical terms, this is the step where
the stocks that make up the equity component, the bonds that make up the fixed income component
and the real assets that make up the real asset component are picked. The final component is
execution, where the portfolio is actually put together, where investors have to trade off
transactions cost against transactions speed. While the importance of execution will vary across
investment strategies, there are many investors who have failed at this stage in the process.
9
The final part of the process, and often the most painful one for professional money managers, is
the performance evaluation. Investing is after all focused on one objective and one objective
alone, which is to make the most money you can, given the risk constraints we operate under.
Investors are not forgiving of failure and unwilling to accept even the best of excuses, and loyalty
to money managers is not a commonly found trait. By the same token, performance evaluation is
just as important to the individual investor who constructs his or her own portfolio, since the
feedback from it should largely determine how that investor approaches investing in the future.
These parts of the process are summarized in Figure 1. The first major section is on understanding
client needs and preferences, where we look at not only how to think about risk in investing but
also at how to measure an investor’s willingness to take risk. The second section looks at the asset
allocation decision, while the third section examines different approaches to selecting assets. The
fourth section takes a brief look at the execution decision, and the fifth section develops different
10
Investment Process Chart
11
CHAPTER – 2
12
PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT
What is Portfolio?
A portfolio may be defined as a collection of assets or a carefully blend combination of assets,
which are related and which gives a maximum return with minimum risk. Portfolio is a collection
of businesses, each of which makes a distinct contribution to the overall corporate performance
Objective of financial management: the finance manager concern with the selecting 'basket of
asset and the basket of securities. This basket of investment is also known as portfolio of assets
or investment.
The portfolio management means achieving and maintaining a portfolio so as to get the best
The art and science of making decisions about investment mix and policy, matching investments
to objectives, asset allocation for individuals and institutions, and balancing risk against
performance.
Portfolio Theories
13
1. Traditional Portfolio Theory
Traditional portfolio theory is a portfolio management practice in which only two parameters
of investment avenues are considered, i.e. (a) returns and (b) risk. The correlation between
securities is not considered. Generally, investors have following concepts while formulating
the portfolio:
Diversification under the portfolio is generally done on the basis of class of securities-
Allocation of funds
Execution
14
1. Modern Portfolio Theory
Modern Portfolio Theory was for the first time given by Harry Markowitz. This theory stress
upon the fundamentals that, creation of portfolio depends upon the relationship between the
returns, expected returns represented by mean and the variability of these returns represented
by standard deviation/variance. Portfolio The modern portfolio theory favors the concept of
Efficient Frontier. Modern Portfolio Theory believes that investors possess utility curve, with
the help of which portfolio selection can be done by tracing the efficient frontier.
Securities should not be included in the portfolio only on the basis of their returns.
with the help of diversification. This can be done by considering the correlation of
securities with each other. The securities to be included in the portfolio should have as far
as possible negative correlation coefficient. In a two-security portfolio the risk can even be
c. Principle of Portfolio Effect: This principle of portfolio says that one should never put all
his egg in one basket. A portfolio should contain more than one share/debenture. By
risk. This happens because poor performance of one gets adjusted against the better
performance of another.
15
d. Principle of Dominance: MPT advocates that fundamental of dominant portfolio/share.
A dominant portfolio is the one which out performs others on risk return parameter. A
portfolio or security attains such position if it provides maximum returns for a given level
of risk or has minimum risk for a given level of returns as compared to any other
e. Principle of market risk: It is the market risk which is much more important while
selecting the securities for a portfolio. Market risk means the risk of a share on account of
its association with market wide factors. These market wide factors influence the
f. Principle of beta: Beta represents sensitivity of a security with respect to the market
movements. Beta is calculated by considering the covariance of the share with the market
portfolio/index.
g. Principle of trade-off between risk and return: The MPT believes that investors are
rational investors and they make the investment by following the fundamentals of higher
the risk, higher will be the returns and lower the risk, lower will be the returns.
h. Principle of avoidance: This principle states that we can eliminate investment in such
securities which have a high degree of non-systematic risk, because such security is likely
to wipe out the returns of rest of the securities in the portfolio. This means non-systematic
risk can be avoided completely by not investing in a risk having high non-systematic risk
component.
16
Process of Portfolio Management
Security
Analysis
Portfolio Portfolio
Evaluation Construction
Portfolio Portfolio
Revision Selection
1. Security Analysis
This step consists of examining the risk-return characteristics of individual securities. A basic
strategy in securities investment is to buy underpriced securities and sell over-priced securities.
a) Fundamental Analysis
b) Technical Analysis
17
2. Portfolio Construction
A portfolio is a group of securities held together as investment. Investors invest their funds in a
portfolio of securities rather than in a single security because they are risk averse. By constructing
a portfolio, investors attempt to spread risk by not putting all their eggs into one basket. Thus,
3. Portfolio Selection
Portfolio analysis provides the input for the next phase in portfolio management which is portfolio
selection. The goal of portfolio construction is to generate a portfolio that provides the highest
returns at a given level of risk. The inputs from portfolio analysis can be used to identify the set of
efficient portfolios. From this set of efficient portfolios, the optimal portfolio has to be selected for
investment.
4. Portfolio Revision
The investor has to revise his portfolio in the light of the developments in the market. This revision
leads to purchase of some new securities and sale some of the existing securities from the portfolio.
The mix of securities and their proportion in the portfolio changes as a result of the revision.
5. Portfolio Evaluation
Portfolio evaluation provides a mechanism for identifying weaknesses in the investment process
and for improving these deficient areas. It provides a feedback mechanism for improving the entire
18
CONCEPT OF RISK AND RETURN
Investor has many motives for investing. The most important of all is to earn a return on their
investment. The investors not only like return but also dislike risk. So, in order to discuss he
portfolio selection with risk and return context, what is required is the
1. Return
Investments involve the tradeoff between current and future consumption. It is this trade off, the
delay of current consumption by allocating resources into investment assets with an expectation
of generating more resources for future consumption, that determine the rate of return and risk.
The return is actually a mode for compensating the loss of current consumption opportunity. Hence
the rate of return is also described as the rate of exchange of between future and current
consumption.
Generally, the rate of a return of an investment act as an incentive for deferring current
consumption. The other rationale for rate of return is the time value of money in which the degree
of purchasing power in the future is affected by inflation. For instance, the value of money today
is greater than the future as in the event of a future inflation rise, more money is needed to purchase
The compensation does end with the tradeoff but it’s also affected by uncertainty as inflow of
resources (future cash flow) is contingent upon future events that are favorable to the investment
asset. But future events that negatively affect the future cash flow could occur as well; therefore,
19
the issue of risk arises. And as such taking the risk in investing requires compensation as well, and
Measurement of Return
Expected Return
So far the discussion of return was in the context of realized return, another important element is
expected return, which is the future return of an investment asset subjected to future conditions or
events. Realized return and expected return will be the same if future expectations are met. There
could be a range of possible returns, which are usually forecasted beforehand, and each of the
forecasted return will be given a probability weight obtained from analyzing data and prudent
extrapolation.
Alternatively, expected return can be described as the expected average return of an investment.
2. Risk
The mathematical notion of investment risk is fronted by the statistical measure of variance, which
is the deviation of each observation (returns) from the expected value (average return). Each point
is then given a weight with heavier weights given to observations nearer to the average.
However, the standard practice is to use standard deviation rather than deviation which is the
square root of the variance and therefore retains the same risk ranking.
20
Types of Risk
risk is associated with every company. Causes are things like inflation rates, exchange
rates, political instability, and war and interest rates. This type of risk is not specific to a
b) Diversifiable Risk: This risk is also known as "unsystematic risk", and it is specific to a
company, industry, market, economy or country; and it can be reduced through
diversification. The most common sources of unsystematic risk are business risk and
financial risk. Thus, the aim is to invest in various assets so that your assets are not all
The basic concepts of risk and return, which form the main elements of the investment framework,
there are no clear-cut prescribed methods of making a successful investment but these two
elements provide an investor with the tools to evaluate the choice of alternatives. For instance,
Asset A and Asset B have the same expected return of 10% but A has a lower standard deviation
(risk) of 0.02 and B is 0.05, and in the assumption of a risk adverse investor, Asset A will be the
Anyone who has invested in anything is familiar with the trade-off between risk and return whether
we have consciously weighed the options and thought about it or not. Before we have bought into
an investment, we have decided that we are able to stomach the risk is hopes of certain returns.
And in order to make long term financial progress we need to decide what level of risk you can
handle while at the same time remaining comfortable with our investments.
21
Investment risk can be defined as the chance that an investment’s actual return will be different
than expected. Risk also means that there is the possibility of losing some, if not all, or our whole
investment. Where there are low levels of uncertainty, there are low potential returns. The opposite
However, it is important, that higher risk does not equal higher returns. Higher risk only gives us
the possibility for higher returns. There are also greater potential losses.
Now, it is important to bring up the concept of the risk premium. Too many try to balance their
risk against the wrong return. If they’re going to take a risk in the stock market, they’re looking
for a return of about %11 percent or so. Now, would we be willing to take the same risk for only
Take a look at U.S. Government bonds and what they are paying. Let’s say that they’re offering a
5% return. Because these types of bonds are virtually risk free, they represent a risk-free rate of
return. Mutual funds may have losses of -6% one year and gains of 20% the next for an average
of around 11%. The difference between the 11% and the 5% is called the risk premium. The risk
Risk Premium
Risk premium refers to the amount which is by an investor as a result of profit from a risky
22
PORTFOLIO AND DIVERSIFICATION
Diversification in finance is a risk management technique, related to hedging, that mixes a wide
variety of investments within a portfolio. Because the fluctuations of a single security have less
impact on a diverse portfolio, diversification minimizes the risk from any one investment.
A simple example of diversification is this one. On a particular is land the entire economy consists
of two companies: one that sells umbrellas and another that sells sunscreen. If a portfolio is
completely invested in the company that sells umbrellas, it will have strong performance during
the rainy season, but poor performance when the weather is sunny. The reverse occurs if the
portfolio is only invested in the sunscreen company, the alternative investment: the portfolio will
be high performance when the sun is out, but will tank when clouds roll in. To minimize the
weather-dependent risk in the example portfolio, the investment should be split between the
companies. With this diversified portfolio, returns are decent no matter the weather, rather than
1. Spread the portfolio among multiple investment vehicles, such as stocks, mutual funds, bonds,
and cash.
2. Vary the risk in the securities. A portfolio can also be diversified into different mutual fund
investment strategies, including growth funds, balanced funds, index funds, small cap, and large
cap funds. When a portfolio includes investments with varied risk levels, large losses in one area
23
3. Vary securities by industry, or even by geography. This will minimize the impact of industry-
or location-specific risks. The example portfolio above was diversified by investing in both
umbrellas and sunscreen. Another practical application of this kind of diversification is mixing
investments between domestic and international funds. By choosing funds in many countries,
events within any one country's economy have less effect on the overall portfolio.
Although diversification reduces the risk of a portfolio, it does not necessarily reduce the returns.
1) Types of diversification
a) Horizontal diversification
Horizontal diversification is when a portfolio is diversified between same-type investments. It
narrowed (investing in several stocks of the same branch or sector). In the example above, the
usual, the broader the diversification the lower the risk, from any one investment.
24
In the above graph, the portfolio represented by point A is inefficient. Following the horizontal
line, there are other portfolios with the same returns but lower risk. Along the vertical line, there
are other portfolios that have the same risk but higher returns.
b) Vertical diversification
Vertical diversification is investment between different types of securities. Again, it can be a very
broad diversification, like diversifying between bonds and stocks, or a more narrowed
diversification, like diversifying between stocks of different branches. Continuing the example
from the introduction, a vertical diversification would be taking some money from umbrella and
sunscreen stock and investing it instead in bonds issued the government of the island.
While horizontal diversification lessens the risk of investing entirely in one security, vertical
diversification goes beyond that and protects against market and/or economical changes.
The average of all the returns in a diverse portfolio can never exceed that of the top-performing
investment, and will almost always be lower than the highest return. This is unavoidable, and is
the cost of the risk insurance that diversification provides. However, strategies exist that allow the
portfolio's manager to maximize returns while still keeping risk as low as possible. Although
detailed calculations are beyond the scope of this article, these strategies seek to maximize returns
by giving different portfolio weights to investments based on their risk and return expectations.
3) Intra-portfolio correlation
measurement between negative one and positive one that measures the degree to which the various
assets in a portfolio can be expected to perform in a similar fashion or not. A measure of -1 means
25
that the assets within the portfolio perform perfectly oppositely: whenever one asset goes up, the
other goes down. A measure of 0 means that the assets fluctuate independently, i.e., that the
performance of one asset cannot be used to predict the performance of the others. A measure of 1,
on the other hand, means that whenever one asset goes up, so do the others in the portfolio. To
Where Q is the intra-portfolio correlation, Xi is the fraction invested in asset I, Xj is the fraction
invested in asset j, Pij is the correlation between assets i and j (another number between 1 and -1
that measures how similarly assets i and j perform compared to each other), and n is the number
of different assets.
For establishing a strategy that tempers potential losses in a bear market, the investment
community preaches the same thing that the real estate market preaches for buying a house:
Diversification is a battle cry for many financial planners, fund managers, and individual investors
alike. When the market is booming, it seems almost impossible to sell a stock for any less than the
price at which you bought it. When the indices are on their way up, it may seem foolish to be in
26
anything but equities. But because we can never be sure of what the market will do at any moment,
we cannot forget the importance of a well-diversified portfolio (in any market condition).
Equities are wonderful, but spread the wealth. Don't put all of your investment in one stock
or one sector. Create your own virtual mutual fund by investing in a handful of companies
you know, trust, and perhaps even use in your day-to-day life. People will argue that
investing in what we know will leave the average investor too heavily retail-oriented, but
knowing a company or using its goods and services can be a healthy and wholesome
Consider adding index funds or fixed-income funds to the mix. Investing in securities that
track various indices make a wonderful long-term diversification investment for our
portfolio. By adding some fixed-income solutions, we are further hedging our portfolio
Add to our investments on a regular basis. Lump sum investing may be a sucker's bet. If
we have $10,000 to invest, utilize the technique called dollar-cost-averaging. This approach
is used to smooth out the peaks and valleys created by market volatility: we invest money
Know when to get out. Our long-term investments should not be our short-term
investments gone awry. Buying and holding and dollar-cost-averaging are wonderful
strategies with which to interact with the markets for a long period of time. But just because
we have our investments on autopilot does not mean that we should ignore the forces at
work. Stay current with your investment and remain in tune with overall market conditions.
Keep a watchful eye on commissions. If we are not the trading type, understand what you
27
are getting for the fees you are paying. Some firms charge a monthly fee, while others charge
transactional fees. Be cognizant of what we are paying and what we are getting for it. So, the
Investing can (and should) be fun. It can be educational, informative and rewarding. By taking a
strategies, we may find investing rewarding even in the worst of times. Keep an eye on our future.
Diversification is a technique that reduces risk by allocating investments among various financial
instruments, industries and other categories. It aims to maximize return by investing into different
areas that would each react differently to the same event. Most investment professionals agree that,
although it does not guarantee against loss, diversification is the most important component of
reaching long-range financial goals while minimizing risk. Here we look at why this is true, and
The beta coefficient, in terms of finance and investing, describes how the expected return of a
An asset with a beta of 0 means that its price is not at all correlated with the market; that asset is
independent. A positive beta means that the asset generally follows the market. A negative beta
shows that the asset inversely follows the market; the asset generally decreases in value if the
28
1.1) Definition
Where ra measures the rate of return of the asset, rp measures the rate of return of the portfolio
of which the asset is a part and Cov (ra,rp) is the covariance between the rates of return. In the
CAPM formulation, the portfolio is the market portfolio that contains all risky assets, and so the
rp terms in the formula are replaced by rm, the rate of return of the market.
Beta is also referred to as financial elasticity or correlated relative volatility, and can be referred
to as a measure of the sensitivity of the asset's returns to market returns, its non-diversifiable
risk, its systematic risk or market risk. On an individual asset level, measuring beta can give
clues to volatility and liquidity in the marketplace. On a portfolio level, measuring beta is
thought to separate a manager's skill from his or her willingness to take risk.
The beta coefficient was born out of linear regression analysis. It is linked to a regression
analysis of the returns of a portfolio (such as a stock index) (x-axis) in a specific period versus
the returns of an individual asset (y-axis) in a specific year. The regression line is then called the
where, α is called the asset's alpha coefficient and βa is called the asset's beta coefficient. Both
29
For an example, in a year where the broad market or benchmark index returns 25% above the risk-
free rate suppose two managers gain 50% above the risk-free rate. Since this higher return is
theoretically possible merely by taking a leveraged position in the broad market to double the beta
so it is exactly 2.0, we would expect a skilled portfolio manager to have built the outperforming
portfolio with a beta somewhat less than 2, such that the excess return not explained by the beta is
positive. If one of the managers' portfolios has an average beta of 3.0, and the others has a beta of
only 1.5, then the CAPM simply states that the extra return of the first manager is not sufficient to
compensate us for that manager's risk, whereas the second manager has done more than expected
given the risk. Whether investors can expect the second manager to duplicate that performance in
1.2) Investing
By definition, the market itself has an underlying beta of 1.0, and individual stocks are ranked
according to how much they deviate from the macro market (for simplicity purposes, the S&P 500
is usually used as a proxy for the market as a whole). A stock that swings more than the market
(i.e., more volatile) over time has a beta whose absolute value is above 1.0. If a stock moves less
than the market, the absolute value of the stock's beta is less than 1.0.
More specifically, a stock that has a beta of 2 follows the market in an overall decline or growth,
but does so by a factor of 2; meaning when the market has an overall decline of 3% a stock with a
beta of 2 will fall 6%. Betas can also be negative, meaning the stock moves in the opposite direction
of the market: a stock with a beta of -3 would decline 9% when the market goes up 3% and
30
Higher-beta stocks mean greater volatility and are therefore considered to be riskier, but are in turn
supposed to provide a potential for higher returns; low-beta stocks pose less risk but also lower
returns. In the same way a stock's beta shows its relation to market shifts, it also is used as an
indicator for required returns on investment (ROI). If the market with a beta of 1 has an expected
return increase of 8%, a stock with a beta of 1.5 should increase return by 12%.
This expected return on equity, or equivalently, a firm's cost of equity, can be estimated using the
Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). According to the model, the expected return on equity is a
function of a firm's equity beta (βE) which, in turn, is a function of both leverage and asset risk
(βA):
Where:
Because:
And
31
Firm Value (V) = Debt Value (D) + Equity Value (E)
To estimate Beta, one needs a list of returns for the asset and returns for the index; these returns
can be daily, weekly or any period. Next, a plot should be made, with the index returns on the x-
axis and the asset returns on the y-axis, in order to check that there are no serious violations of the
linear regression model assumptions. The slope of the fitted line from the linear least-squares
Beta has no upper or lower bound, and betas as large as 3 or 4 will occur with highly volatile
stocks.
Beta can be zero. Some zero-beta securities are risk-free, such as treasury bonds and cash.
However, simply because a beta is zero does NOT mean that it is risk free. A beta can be zero
simply because the correlation between that item and the market is zero. An example would be
betting on horse racing. The correlation with the market will be zero, but it is certainly not a risk-
free endeavor.
A negative beta simply means that the stock is inversely correlated with the market. Many
A negative beta might occur even when both the benchmark index and the stock under
consideration have positive returns. It is possible that lower positive returns of the index
32
coincide with higher positive returns of the stock, or vice versa. The slope of the regression
Using beta as a measure of relative risk has its own limitations. Most analysis considers
only the magnitude of beta. Beta is a statistical variable and should be considered with its
statistical significance (R square value of the regression line). Higher R square value
implies higher correlation and a stronger relationship between returns of the asset and
benchmark index.
EFFICIENT FRONTIER
Harry Markowitz first defined the efficient frontier in his ground-breaking (1952) paper that
launched portfolio theory. That theory considers a universe of risky investments and explores what
1. For any level of volatility, consider all the portfolios, which have that volatility. From
among them all, select the one, which has the highest expected return.
2. For any expected return, consider all the portfolios which have that expected return. From
among them all, select the one, which has the lowest volatility.
33
Definition (1) produces an optimal portfolio for each possible level of risk.
Actually, the two definitions are equivalent. The set of optimal portfolios obtained using one
definition is exactly the same set, which is obtained from the other. That set of optimal portfolios
Efficient Frontier
The shaded region corresponds to the achievable risk-return space. For every point in that region,
there will be at least one portfolio that can be constructed and has the risk and return corresponding
to that point. The efficient frontier is the gold curve that runs along the top of the achievable region.
Portfolios on the efficient frontier are optimal in both the sense that they offer maximal expected
return for some given level of risk and minimal risk for some given level of expected return.
34
In fig, the green region corresponds to the achievable risk-return space. For every point in that
region, there will be at least one portfolio constructible from the investments in the universe that
has the risk and return corresponding to that point. The yellow region is the unachievable risk-
return space. No portfolios can be constructed corresponding to the points in this region.
The gold curve running along the top of the achievable region is the efficient frontier. The
portfolios that correspond to points on that curve are optimal according to both definitions (1) and
(2) above.
35
CONSTRUCTION & MANAGING PORTFOLIO
The liquidity of an investment signifies the ease or ability to convert investments to cash without
a substantial loss in the principal or original amount invested. The rate of return pertains to an
investment's gain or loss over a specific time period. Return levels usually parallel risk levels;
meaning a high-risk level investment may yield a higher return. The risk tolerance of a client will
play a major role in portfolio management, as comfort levels towards potential for loss differ
2) Portfolio Construction
Portfolio Construction is all about investing in a range of funds that work together to create an
investment solution for investors. Building a portfolio involves understanding the way various
types of investments work, and combining them to address your personal investment objectives
and factors such as attitude to risk the investment and the expected life of the investment.
Together with the fact find completed by IFAs, we have created a Risk Profiler that helps
identify an investor’s attitude to risk and therefore better identify a combination of investments
to build a portfolio
With over 2,000 investment funds domiciled in the UK, spanning the full range of asset classes
36
and world markets it is easy to become confused when choosing which investments to make. It is
even more difficult to choose the right combination of investment to potentially meet your
investment goals.
c) Asset Allocation – determining the right combination of assets – the most important part of
e) Regular review
If we want to make the most of our money, every decision we make about our portfolio is as
Ascertaining our individual financial situation and investment goals is the first task in constructing
a portfolio. Important items to consider are age, how much time are needed to grow our
A second factor to take into account is our risk tolerance. Are we the kind of person who is willing
to risk some money for the possibility of greater returns? Everyone would like to reap high returns
year after year, but if we are unable to sleep at night when our investments take a short-term drop,
chances are the high returns from those assets are not worth the stress. As we can see, clarifying
our current situation and our future needs for capital, as well as our risk tolerance, together will
determine how our investments should be allocated among different asset classes. The possibility
37
of greater returns comes at the expense of greater risk of losses (a principle known as the risk/return
trade off) -we don't want to eliminate risk so much as optimize it for our unique condition and
style. For example, the young person who won't have to depend on his or her investments for
income can afford to take greater risks in the quest for high returns. On the other hand, the person
nearing retirement needs to focus on protecting his or her assets and drawing income from these
Generally, the more risk we can bear, the more aggressive our portfolio will be, devoting a larger
portion to equities and less to bonds and other fixed-income securities. Conversely, the less risk
that's appropriate, the more conservative our portfolio will be. Here are two examples: one suitable
for a conservative investor and another for the moderately aggressive investor.
The main goal of a conservative portfolio is to protect its value. The allocation shown above would
yield current income from the bonds, and would also provide some long-term capital growth
38
A moderately aggressive portfolio satisfies an average risk tolerance, attracting those willing to
accept more risk in their portfolio in order to achieve a balance of capital growth and income.
Once we've determined the right asset allocation, we simply need to divide our capital between the
appropriate asset classes. On a basic level, this is not difficult: equities are equities, and bonds are
bonds. But we can further break down the different asset classes into subclasses, which also have
different risks and potential returns. For example, an investor might divide the equity portion
between different sectors and market caps, and between domestic and foreign stock. The bond
portion might be allocated between those that are short term and long term, government versus
There are several ways we can go about choosing the assets and securities to fulfill our
asset allocation strategy (remember to analyze the quality and potential of each investment
you buy - not all bonds and stocks are the same):
39
Stock picking - Choose stocks that satisfy the level of risk we want to carry in the equity
portion of our portfolio - sector, market cap and stock type are factors to consider. Analyze
the companies using stock screener s to short-list potential picks, than carry out more in-
depth analysis on each potential purchase to determine its opportunities and risks going
forward. This is the most work-intensive means of adding securities to our portfolio, and
requires us to regularly monitor price changes in our holdings and stay current on company
and industry news. Bond picking - When choosing bonds, there are several factors to
consider including the coupon, maturity, the bond type and rating, as well as the general
Mutual funds - Mutual funds are available for a wide range of asset classes and allow you
to hold stocks and bonds that are professionally researched and picked by fund managers.
Of course, fund managers charge a fee for their services, which will detract from your
returns. Index funds are another choice as they tend to have lower fees since they mirror an
Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) - If we prefer not to invest with mutual funds, ETFs can
be a viable alternative. We can basically think of ETFs as mutual funds that trade like a
stock. ETFs are similar to mutual funds in that they represent a large basket of stocks -
usually grouped by sector, capitalization, country and the like - except they are not actively
managed, but instead track a chosen index or other basket of stocks. Because they are
passively managed, ETFs offer cost savings over mutual funds while providing
diversification. ETFs also cover a wide range of asset classes and can be a useful tool to
40
2.1.3) Step 3: Re-assessing Portfolio Weightings
Once we have an established portfolio, we need to analyze and rebalance it periodically because
market movements may cause our initial weightings to change. To assess our portfolio's actual
asset allocation, quantitatively categorize the investments and determine their values' proportion
to the whole.
The other factors that are likely to change over time are our current financial situation, future needs
and risk tolerance. If these things change, we may need to adjust our portfolio accordingly. If our
risk tolerance has dropped, we may need to reduce the number of equities held. Or perhaps we're
now ready to take on greater risk and your asset allocation requires a small proportion of our assets
to be held in riskier small-cap stocks. Essentially, to rebalance, you need to determine which of
For example, say we are holding 30% of our current assets in small-cap equities, while our asset
allocation suggests us should only have 15% of your assets kept in that class. We need to determine
how much of this position we need to reduce and allocate to other classes.
Once we have determined which securities we need to reduce and by how much, decide which
under-weighted securities we will buy with the proceeds from selling the over-weighted securities.
When selling assets to rebalance our portfolio, take a moment to consider the tax implications of
readjusting our portfolio. Perhaps our investment in growth stocks has appreciated strongly over
the past year, but if we were to sell all of our equity positions to rebalance our portfolio, we may
41
incur significant capital gains taxes. In this case it might be more beneficial to simply not
contribute any new funds to that asset class in the future while continuing to contribute to other
asset classes. This will reduce our growth stocks' weighting in our portfolio over time without
incurring capital gain taxes. At the same time, however, always consider the outlook of our
securities. If we suspect that those same over-weighted growth stocks are ominously ready to fall,
we may want to sell in spite of the tax implications. Analyst opinions and research reports can be
useful tools to help gauge the outlook for our holdings. And tax-loss selling is a strategy we can
The process of dividing a portfolio among major asset categories such as bonds, stocks or cash.
The ideal asset allocation differs based on the risk tolerance of the investor. For example, a young
executive might have an asset allocation of 80% equity, 20% fixed income, while a retiree would
The important task of appropriately allocating your available investment funds among different
assets classes can seem daunting, with so many securities to choose from. Here we will illustrate
what asset allocation is, its importance and how you can determine your appropriate asset mix and
maintain it.
42
What Is Asset Allocation?
Asset allocation refers to the strategy of dividing your total investment portfolio among various
asset classes, such as stocks, bonds and money market securities. Essentially, asset allocation is an
To help determine which securities, asset classes and subclasses are optimal for our portfolio, let's
Large-cap stock: These are shares issued by large companies with a market get
Mid-cap stock: These are issued by mid-sized companies with a market cap generally
between $2 billion and $10 billion.
Small-cap stock: These represent smaller-sized companies with a market cap of less
than $2 billion. These types of equities tend to have the highest risk due to lower liquidity.
International securities: These types of assets are issued by foreign companies and listed
or her country, but they also have exposure to country risk - the risk that a country will not
Emerging markets: This category represents securities from the financial markets of a
return, there is also higher risk, often due to political instability, country risk and lower
liquidity
Fixed-income securities - The fixed-income asset class comprises debt securities that pay
43
the holder a set amount of interest, periodically or at maturity, as well as the return
of principal when the security matures. These securities tend to have lower volatility than
equities, and have lower risk because of the steady income they provide. Note that though
the issuer promises payment of income, there is a risk of default. Fixed-income securities
Money market: Money market securities are debt securities that are extremely liquid
investments with maturities of less than one year. Treasury bills make up the majority of
Real-estate investment trusts (REITs) - REITs trade similarly to equities, except the
company.
The main goal of allocating our assets among various asset classes is to maximize return for our
chosen level of risk, or stated another way, to minimize risk given a certain expected level of
return. Of course, to maximize return and minimize risk, we need to know the risk-return
characteristics of the various asset classes. The following chart compares the risk and potential
44
As we can see, equities have the highest potential return, but also the highest risk. On the other
hand, Treasury bills have the lowest risk since the government backs them, but they also provide
The chart also demonstrates that when we choose investments with higher risk, our expected
returns also increase proportionately. But this is simply the result of the risk-return trade-off. They
will often have high volatility and are therefore suited for investors who have a high-risk tolerance
(can stomach wide fluctuations in value), and who have a longer time horizon.
It's because of the risk-return trade-off - which says we can seek high returns only if we are willing
to take losses - that diversification through asset allocation is important. Since different assets have
varying risks and experience different market fluctuations, proper asset allocation insulates our
entire portfolio from the ups and downs of one single class of securities. So, while part of our
portfolio may contain more volatile securities - which we've chosen for their potential of higher
returns - the other part of our portfolio devoted to other assets remains stable. We might be familiar
with the risk-reward concept, which states that the higher the risk of a particular investment, the
45
higher the possible return. But many investors do not understand how to determine the level of
risk their individual portfolios should bear. This article provides a general framework that any
investor can use to assess his or her personal level of risk and how this level relates to different
investments.
Because of the protection it offers, asset allocation is the key to maximizing returns while
minimizing risk.
As each asset class has varying levels of return for a certain risk, our risk tolerance, investment
objectives, time horizon and available capital will provide the basis for the asset composition of
our portfolio.
To make the asset allocation process easier for clients, many investment companies create a series
of model portfolios, each comprising different proportions of asset classes. These portfolios of
different proportions satisfy a particular level of investor risk tolerance. In general, these model
46
Conservative portfolios generally allocate a large percent of the total portfolio to lower-risk
securities such as fixed-income and money market securities.
Our main goal with a conservative portfolio is to protect the principal value of our portfolio. As
Even if we are very conservative and prefer to avoid the stock market entirely, some exposure
can help offset inflation. We could invest the equity portion in high-quality blue-chip companies,
A moderately conservative portfolio is ideal for those who wish to preserve a large portion of
the portfolio’s total value, but are willing to take on a higher amount of risk to get some inflation
protection.
47
A common strategy within this risk level is called "current income". With this strategy, we choose
Moderately aggressive model portfolios are often referred to as “balanced portfolios" since the
asset composition is divided almost equally between fixed-income securities and equities in order
Since these moderately aggressive portfolios have a higher level of risk than those conservative
portfolios mentioned above, select this strategy only if we have a longer time horizon (generally
more than five years), and have a medium level of risk tolerance.
Aggressive portfolios mainly consist of equities, so these portfolios' value tends to fluctuate
widely. If we have an aggressive portfolio, our main goal is to obtain long-term growth of capital.
As such the strategy of an aggressive portfolio is often called a "capital growth" strategy.
48
To provide some diversification, investors with aggressive portfolios usually add some fixed-
income securities.
Very aggressive portfolios consist almost entirely of equities. As such, with a very aggressive
portfolio, our main goal is aggressive capital growth over a long-time horizon.
Since these portfolios carry a considerable amount of risk, the value of the portfolio will vary
49
2.4) Maintaining Our Portfolio
Once we have chosen our portfolio investment strategy, it is important to conduct periodic
portfolio reviews, as the value of the various assets within our portfolio will change, affecting
the weighting of each asset class. For example, if we start with a moderately conservative portfolio,
the value of the equity portion may increase significantly during the year, making your portfolio
more like that of an investor practicing a balanced portfolio strategy, which is higher-risk.
In order to reset our portfolio back to its original state, we need to rebalance our portfolio.
Rebalancing is the process of selling portions of our portfolio that have increased significantly,
and using those funds to purchase additional units of assets that have declined slightly or increased
at a lesser rate. This process is also important if our investment strategy or tolerance for risk has
changed.
We might be familiar with the risk-reward concept, which states that the higher the risk of a
particular investment, the higher the possible return. But many investors do not understand how to
determine the level of risk their individual portfolios should bear. This article provides a general
framework that any investor can use to assess his or her personal level of risk and how this level
50
With so many different types of investment to choose from, how does an investor
determine how much risk he or she can handle? Every individual is different, and it’s
hard to create a steadfast model applicable to everyone, but here are two important things
Time Horizon: Before we make any investment, we should always determine the amount
of time we have to keep our money invested. If we have $20,000 to invest today but need
it in one year for a down payment on a new house, investing the money in higher-risk
stocks is not the best strategy. The riskier an investment is, the greater its volatility or price
fluctuations, so if our time horizon is relatively short, we may be forced to sell your
With a longer time, horizon, investors have more time to recoup any possible losses and are
therefore theoretically be more tolerant of higher risks. For example, if that $20,000 is meant for
a lakeside cottage that we are planning to buy in ten years, we can invest the money into higher-
risk stocks because there is be more time available to recover any losses and less likelihood of
Bankroll: Determining the amount of money we can stand to lose is another important
factor of figuring out our risk tolerance. This might not be the most optimistic method of
investing; however, it is the most realistic. By investing only money that you can afford to
lose or afford to have tied up for some period of time, we won't be pressured to sell off any
51
Investment Risk Pyramid
After deciding on how much risk is acceptable in our portfolio by acknowledging our time horizon
and bankroll, we can use the risk pyramid approach for balancing our assets.
This pyramid can be thought of as an asset allocation tool that investors can use to diversify their
portfolio investments according to the risk profile of each security. The pyramid, representing the
Base of the Pyramid: The foundation of the pyramid represents the strongest portion,
which supports everything above it. This area should be comprised of investments that are
low in risk and have foreseeable returns. It is the largest area and composes the bulk of our
assets.
Middle Portion: This area should be made up of medium-risk investments that offer a
stable return while still allowing for capital appreciation. Although riskier than the assets
52
creating the base, these investments should still be relatively safe.
Summit: Reserved specifically for high-risk investments, this is the smallest area of the
pyramid (portfolio) and should be made up of money we can lose without any serious
don't have to sell prematurely in instances where there are capital losses.
Not all investors are created equally. While others prefer less risk, some investors prefer even more
risk than others who have a larger net worth. This diversity leads to the beauty of the investment
pyramid. Those who want more risk in their portfolios can increase the size of the summit by
decreasing the other two sections, and those wanting less risk can increase the size of the base. The
It is important for investors to understand the idea of risk and how it applies to them. Making
informed investment decisions entails not only researching individual securities but also
understanding our own finances and risk profile. To get an estimate of the securities suitable for
certain levels of risk tolerance and to maximize returns, investors should have an idea of how much
time and money they have to invest and the returns they are looking for.
53
THEORIES OF PORTFOLIO SELECTION
If we were to craft the perfect investment, we would probably want its attributes to include high
returns coupled with little risk. The reality, of course, is that this kind of investment is next to
impossible to find. Not surprisingly, people spend a lot of time developing methods and strategies
that come close to the "perfect investment". But none is as popular, or as compelling, as modern
portfolio theory (MPT). Here we look at the basic ideas behind MPT, the pros and cons of the
One of the most important and influential economic theories dealing with finance and investment,
MPT was developed by Harry Markowitz and published under the title "Portfolio Selection" in the
1952 Journal of Finance. MPT says that it is not enough to look at the expected risk and return of
one particular stock. By investing in more than one stock, an investor can reap the benefits
of diversification - chief among them, a reduction in the riskiness of the portfolio. MPT quantifies
the benefits of diversification, also known as not putting all of our eggs in one basket.
For most investors, the risk they take when they buy a stock is that the return will be lower than
expected. In other words, it is the deviation from the average return. Each stock has its
own standard deviation from the mean, which MPT calls "risk".
54
The risk in a portfolio of diverse individual stocks will be less than the risk inherent in holding any
single one of the individual stocks (provided the risks of the various stocks are not directly related).
Consider a portfolio that holds two risky stocks: one that pays off when it rains and another that
pays off when it doesn't rain. A portfolio that contains both assets will always pay off, regardless
of whether it rains or shines. Adding one risky asset to another can reduce the overall risk of an
all-weather portfolio.
In other words, Markowitz showed that investment is not just about picking stocks, but about
choosing the right combination of stocks among which to distribute one's nest eggs.
Modern portfolio theory states that the risk for individual stock returns has two components:
Systematic Risk - These are market risks that cannot be diversified away. Interest rates,
Unsystematic Risk - Also known as "specific risk", this risk is specific to individual stocks
and can be diversified away as we increase the number of stocks in our portfolio (see
Figure). It represents the component of a stock's return that is not correlated with general
market moves.
For a well-diversified portfolio, the risk - or average deviation from the mean - of each stock
contributes little to portfolio risk. Instead, it is the difference - or covariance - between individual
stocks' levels of risk that determines overall portfolio risk. As a result, investors benefit from
55
Figure
Now that we understand the benefits of diversification, the question of how to identify the best
For every level of return, there is one portfolio that offers the lowest possible risk, and for every
level of risk, there is a portfolio that offers the highest return. These combinations can be plotted
on a graph, and the resulting line is the efficient frontier. Figure shows the efficient frontier for
just two stocks - a high risk/high return technology stock (Satyam) and a low risk/low return
56
Figure
Any portfolio that lies on the upper part of the curve is efficient: it gives the maximum expected
return for a given level of risk. A rational investor will only ever hold a portfolio that lies
somewhere on the efficient frontier. The maximum level of risk that the investor will take on
Modern portfolio theory takes this idea even further. It suggests that combining a stock portfolio
that sits on the efficient frontier with a risk-free asset, the purchase of which is funded by
borrowing, can actually increase returns beyond the efficient frontier. In other words, if we were
to borrow to acquire a risk-free stock, then the remaining stock portfolio could have a riskier profile
57
1.4) What MPT Means for Us
Modern portfolio theory has had a marked impact on how investors perceive risk, return and
portfolio management. The theory demonstrates that portfolio diversification can reduce
investment risk. In fact, modern money managers routinely follow its precepts.
That being said, MPT has some shortcomings in the real world. For starters, it often requires
investors to rethink notions of risk. Sometimes it demands that the investor take on a perceived
risky investment (futures, for example) in order to reduce overall risk. That can be a tough sell to
an investor not familiar with the benefits of sophisticated portfolio management techniques.
Furthermore, MPT assumes that it is possible to select stocks whose individual performance is
independent of other investments in the portfolio. But market historians have shown that there are
no such instruments; in times of market stress, seemingly independent investments do, in fact, act
Then there is the question of the number of stocks required for diversification. How many is
enough? Mutual funds can contain dozens and dozens of stocks. Investment guru William J.
Bernstein says that even 100 stocks are not enough to diversify away unsystematic risk. By
contrast, Edwin J. Elton and Martin J. Gruber, in their book "Modern Portfolio Theory and
Investment Analysis" (1981), conclude that you would come very close to achieving optimal
58
2) CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL
The Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) is used in finance to determine a theoretically
appropriate required rate of return of an asset, if that asset is to be added to an already well-
diversified portfolio, given that asset's non- diversifiable risk. The model takes into account the
asset's sensitivity to non- diversifiable risk (also known as systemic risk or market risk), often
represented by the quantity beta (β) in the financial industry, as well as the expected return of the
Jack Treynor, William Sharpe, John Lintner and Jan Mossin introduced the model independently,
building on the earlier work of Harry Markowitz on diversification and modern portfolio theory.
Sharpe received the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economics for this contribution to the field of
financial economics.
(The Security Market Line, seen here in a graph, describes a relation between the beta and
59
.)
An
estimation of the CAPM and the Security Market Line (purple) for the Dow Jones
The CAPM is a model for pricing an individual security (asset) or a portfolio. For individual
security perspective, we made use of the security market line (SML) and its relation to expected
return and systematic risk (beta) to show how the market must price individual securities in relation
to their security risk class. The SML enables us to calculate the reward-to-risk ratio for any security
in relation to that of the overall market. Therefore, when the expected rate of return for any security
is deflated by its beta coefficient, the reward-to-risk ratio for any individual security in the market
60
Reward-to-risk ratio Reward-to-risk ratio
The market reward-to-risk ratio is effectively the market risk premium and by rearranging the
above equation and solving for E (Ri), we obtain the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM).
Where:
also,
(the difference between the expected market rate of return and the risk-free rate of return).
Note 1: The expected market rate of return is usually measured by looking at the arithmetic average
61
Note 2: The risk-free rate of return used for determining the risk premium is usually the arithmetic
average of historical risk-free rates of return and not the current risk-free rate of return.
All Investors:
4) Can lend and borrow unlimited under the risk-free rate of interest.
This model presents a very simple theory that delivers a simple result. The theory says that the
only reason an investor should earn more, on average, by investing in one stock rather than another
is that one stock is riskier. Not surprisingly, the model has come to dominate modern financial
It's not entirely clear. The big sticking point is beta. When Professors Eugene Fama and Kenneth
French looked at share returns on the New York Stock Exchange, the American Stock Exchange
and Nasdaq between 1963 and 1990, they found that differences in betas over that lengthy period
62
did not explain the performance of different stocks. The linear relationship between beta and
individual stock returns also breaks down over shorter periods of time. These findings seem to
While some studies raise doubts about CAPM's validity, the model is still widely used in the
investment community. Although it is difficult to predict from beta how individual stocks might
react to particular movements, investors can probably safely deduce that a portfolio of high-beta
stocks will move more than the market in either direction, or a portfolio of low-beta stocks will
The model assumes that asset returns are (jointly) normally distributed random
63
variables. It is however frequently observed that returns in equity and other markets are not
normally distributed. As a result, large swings (3 to 6 standard deviations from the mean)
occur in the market more frequently than the normal distribution assumption would expect.
The model assumes that the variance of returns is an adequate measurement of risk. This
might be justified under the assumption of normally distributed returns, but for general
return distributions other risk measures (like coherent risk measures) will likely reflect the
The model does not appear to adequately explain the variation in stock returns. Empirical
studies show that low beta stocks may offer higher returns than the model would predict.
Some data to this effect was presented as early as a 1969 conference in Buffalo, New York
in a paper by Fischer Black, Michael Jensen, and Myron Scholes. Either that fact is itself
rational (which saves the Efficient Market Hypothesis but makes CAPM wrong), or it is
irrational (which saves CAPM, but makes the EMH wrong – indeed, this possibility makes
The model assumes that given a certain expected return investors will prefer lower risk
(lower variance) to higher risk and conversely given a certain level of risk will prefer higher
returns to lower ones. It does not allow for investors who will accept lower returns for
higher risk. Casino gamblers clearly pay for risk, and it is possible that some stock traders
The model assumes that all investors have access to the same information and agree about
the risk and expected return of all assets (homogeneous expectations assumption).
The model assumes that there are no taxes or transaction costs, although this assumption
64
The market portfolio consists of all assets in all markets, where each asset is weighted by
its market capitalization. This assumes no preference between markets and assets for
individual investors, and that investors choose assets solely as a function of their risk-return
profile. It also assumes that all assets are infinitely divisible as to the amount, which may
be held or transacted.
The market portfolio should in theory include all types of assets that are held by anyone as
an investment (including works of art, real estate, human capital...) In practice, such a
market portfolio is unobservable and people usually substitute a stock index as a proxy for
the true market portfolio. Unfortunately, it has been shown that this substitution is not
innocuous and can lead to false inferences as to the validity of the CAPM, and it has been
said that due to the unobservability of the true market portfolio, the CAPM might not be
empirically testable. This was presented in greater depth in a paper by Richard Roll in
65
CHAPTER – 3
66
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The research report is prepared with the help of secondary sources. The data collected while
preparing the report is mainly from Secondary data.
1) Secondary Sources
67
CHAPTER – 4
68
ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA
PORTFOLIO - A PORTFOLIO – B
BHEL
Ri
EXPECTED RETURN E (Ri)
N
69
PORTFOLIO-A
1 JULY
45.65 0.815 0.664
(X-X') 2 = 17.553
70
RELIANCE ENERGY
(X-X)2 =14.437
71
CROMPTON GREAVES
(X-X') 2 = 785.6
72
PORTFOLIO - B
WIPRO
(X-X') 2 = 230.86
73
JINDAL STEEL
(X-X') 2 = 1105.67
74
PORTFOLIO-A
IN PORTFOLIO A IS:
PORTFOLIO-B
75
INTERPERATION
From the above figures, it is clear that in total there is a high return on portfolio B companies when
compared with portfolio A companies. But at the same time if we compare the risk, it is clear that
risk is less for companies in portfolio B when compared with portfolio A companies. As per the
Markowitz an efficient portfolio is one with “Minimum risk, maximum profit” therefore, it is
advisable for an investor to work out his portfolio in such a way where he can optimize his returns
76
CHAPTER – 5
77
FINDINGS OF THE STUDY
The study includes a number of findings which is revealed while preparing a research report in
order to increase the effectiveness of the report. The findings are as follows:
78
RECOMMENDATIONS
tips.
Before buying a security, it’s better to find out everything one can about the company, its
Don't try to buy at the bottom and sell at the top. This can't be done-except by liars.
Learn how to take your losses and cleanly. Don't expect to be right all the time. If you have
Don't buy too many different securities. Better have only a few investments that can be
watched.
Make a periodic reappraisal of all your investments to see whether changing developments
Study your tax position to known when you sell to greatest advantages.
Always keep a good part of your capital in a cash reserve. Never invest all your funds.
Purchasing stocks, you do not understand if you can't explain it to a ten-year-old, just don't
invest in it.
79
Over diversifying: This is the most oversold, overused, logic-defying concept among
Not recognizing difference between value and price: This goes along with the failure to
compute the intrinsic value of a stock, which are simply the discounted future earnings of
Failure to understand Mr. Market: Just because the market has put a price on a business
does not mean it is worth it. Only an individual can determine the value of an investment
Failure to understand the impact of taxes: Also known as the sorrows of compounding, just
as compounding works to the investor's long-term advantage, the burden of taxes because
Too much focus on the market whether or not an individual investment has merit and value
80
CONCLUSIONS
A high-performing portfolio is every investor's goal. First, we need to develop our own
a) Determine what items or events we're saving for. These can be retirement, a new home,
b)Determine when we want to retire, purchase a home or send your children to college, to help
c) Decide how much money to invest. Invest what we can comfortably afford now; keeping in
d)Determine how much risk we are willing to take. Many investments generate high returns and
e) Once we decide the amount, we are willing to invest, the returns we want to achieve, when we
need the money and how much risk we are willing to accept, put together our investment
portfolio.
1. More transparency should be maintained in order to increase the effectiveness and efficiency
of investment.
2. NAV should be disclosed from time-to-time so that investors know status of their funds
regularly.
4. Awareness regarding various investment policies should be created from time to time.
Portfolio is collection of different securities and assets by which we can satisfy the basic objective
"Maximize yield minimize risk. Further' we have to remember some important investing rules.
81
LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
The research is for current market situations, which changes with time
The responses depend on individual behavior which may be affected by psychological factors,
social factors like family, friend and peer group.
82
BIBLIOGRAPHY
BOOKS
WEBSITES
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
83