6 - Apportionment Methods
6 - Apportionment Methods
METHODS
MATHEMATICS IN THE MODERN WORLD
Learning
Objectives
1. Hamilton’s Method
(1852-1911)
2. Jefferson’s Method
(1791-1842)
3. Adam’s Method (1832)
4. Webster’s Method (1842)
5. Huntington-Hill Method
(1940-PRESENT)
Hamilton’s Method
States Population
A 27500
B 38300
C 46500
D 76700
Total 189000
Step 1. Compute for the Standard divisor (SD).
𝑆𝐷 =
𝑆𝐷 = = 6300
States Population SQ
A 27500
B 38300
C 46500
D 76700
Total 189000
Step 1. Compute for the Standard divisor (SD).
𝑆𝐷 =
𝑆𝐷 = = 6300
States Population SQ
A 27500 4.3651
B 38300 6.0794
C 46500 7.3810
D 76700 12.1746
Total 189000
Step 3. Use the concept of Lower Quota (SQL).
SQL – round down all values in the Quota.
Child Pages
Alan 580 How many souvenir items will each
Antonio 230 get using Hamilton’s Plan?
Alex 180
Lucas 130
Answer:
Number of
Name Pages SQ SQL Souvenir
Items
Alan 580
Antonio 230
Alex 180
Lucas 130
Total 1,120
Answer:
Number of
Name Pages SQ SQL Souvenir
Items
Alan 580 5.1786 5 5
Antonio 230 2.0536 2 2
Alex 180 1.6071 1 2
Lucas 130 1.1607 1 1
Total 1,120 9 10
DECISION: Alan will get 5 souvenirs, Antonio 2 souvenirs, Alex 2
souvenirs, and Lucas 1 souvenir from their teacher.
Quota Rule
The quota rule says that the final number of representatives a state
gets should be within one of that state’s quota. Since we’re dealing
with whole numbers for our final answers, that means that each state
should either go up to the next whole number above its quota, or
down to the next whole number below its quota.
Jefferson’s Method
Provinces Population
(2015 data*)
Cavite 3,678,000
Batangas 2,694,000
Quezon 2,123,000
Rizal 2,884,000
Laguna 3,035,000
Answer:
Number of
Population (2015 Doctors by
Provinces SQ SQL
data*) Jefferson’s
Plan
Cavite 3,678,000
Batangas 2,694,000
Quezon 2,123,000
Rizal 2,884,000
Laguna 3,035,000
Total 14,414,000
First step: Find the Second step: Divide each province’s Third step: Since we’re still
Standard Divisor. population to get the SQ using the short of 2 doctors, we need to
14,414,000 / 63 divisor. Just put up to 4 decimal places modify the divisor by reducing it
= 228,793.6508 for the quota. to yield higher quota.
Answer:
Number of
Population (2015
Provinces SQ SQL Doctors by
data*)
Jefferson’s Plan
Cavite 3,678,000
Batangas 2,694,000
Quezon 2,123,000
Rizal 2,884,000
Laguna 3,035,000
Total 14,414,000
First step: Let’s go back to first step, Second step: Divide each
this time, we’re going to change our province’s population to get the
divisor quota using the MSD. Just put up
to 4 decimal places for the quota.
Initial SD = 228,793.6508
Note: Getting the MSD is by trial and error. The only clue is that the MSD must be
Modified Standard Divisor
lesser than the SD.
(MSD)= 220,793
Answer:
Number of
Population (2015
Provinces SQ SQL Doctors by
data*)
Jefferson’s Plan
Cavite 3,678,000 16.6581
Batangas 2,694,000 12.2015
Quezon 2,123,000 9.6153
Rizal 2,884,000 13.0620
Laguna 3,035,000 13.7459
Total 14,414,000
First step: Let’s go back to first step, Second step: Divide each Third step: Since we achieved 63,
this time, we’re going to change our province’s population to get the now we are set to use the modified
divisor quota using the MSD. Just put up divisor of 220,793 for this problem.
to 4 decimal places for the quota.
Initial SD = 228,793.6508
Note: Getting the MSD is by trial and error. The only clue is that the MSD must be
Modified Standard Divisor
lesser than the SD.
(MSD)= 220,793
Answer:
Number of
Population (2015
Provinces SQ SQL Doctors by
data*)
Jefferson’s Plan
Cavite 3,678,000 16.6581 16
Batangas 2,694,000 12.2015 12
Quezon 2,123,000 9.6153 9
Rizal 2,884,000 13.0620 13
Laguna 3,035,000 13.7459 13
Total 14,414,000 63
First step: Let’s go back to first step, Second step: Divide each Third step: Get the SQL.
this time, we’re going to change our province’s population to get the Since we achieved 63, now we are
divisor quota using the MSD. Just put up set to use the modified divisor of
to 4 decimal places for the quota. 220,793 for this problem.
Initial SD = 228,793.6508
Note: Getting the MSD is by trial and error. The only clue is that the MSD must be
Modified Standard Divisor
lesser than the SD.
(MSD)= 220,793
Answer:
Number of
Population (2015
Provinces SQ SQL Doctors by
data*)
Jefferson’s Plan
Cavite 3,678,000 16.6581 16 16
Batangas 2,694,000 12.2015 12 12
Quezon 2,123,000 9.6153 9 9
Rizal 2,884,000 13.0620 13 13
Laguna 3,035,000 13.7459 13 13
Total 14,414,000 63 63
Decision:
The number of doctors to be assigned in Cavite, Batangas, Quezon,
Rizal, and Laguna are as follow: 16, 12, 9, 13, and 13 respectively.
Solve this using A college in DLSMHSI is procuring 30
microscopes for first years this school year
Jefferson’s 2024-2025. How many microscopes will be
Method distributed to each section?
Number of
No. of SQ Microscopes
Section SQ SQL SQL
Students (with MSD of __) per Section by
Jefferson’s Plan
1A 42 5.9716 5
1B 51 7.2512 7
1C 35 4.9763 4
1D 23 3.2702 3
1E 60 8.5308 8
Total 211 27
Answer:
Number of
SQ Microscopes
No. of
Section SQ SQL (with MSD of SQL per Section by
Students
6.5) Jefferson’s
Plan
1A 42 5.9716 5 6.4615 6 6
1B 51 7.2512 7 7.8462 7 7
1C 35 4.9763 4 5.3846 5 5
1D 23 3.2702 3 3.5385 3 3
1E 60 8.5308 8 9.2308 9 9
Total 211 27 30 30
Districts Population
Malaya 55,000
Masaya 30,012
Makabangon 25,758
Makabayan 15,123
Answer:
Number of
Districts Population SQ SQU Pills per
District
Malaya 55,000
Masaya 30,012
Makabangon 25,758
Makabayan 15,123
Total 125,893
Standard Divisor = 125,893/ 1200 Since our initial allocation is above our
= 104.9108 total number of pills then we need to
increase our standard divisor to yield
Get the standard quota upper. smaller quota. Thus, choosing an MSD
Then the sum of the SQU. which must be greater than the SD.
Answer:
Number of Pills
Districts Population SQ w/ MSD SQU per District by
Adam’s Method
Malaya 55,000 523.3111 524
Masaya 30,012 285.5566 286
Makabangon 25,758 245.0809 246
Makabayan 15,123 143.8915 144
Total 125,893 1200
Decision:
The number of pills to be given to districts Malaya, Masaya,
Makabangon, and Makabayan are as follows: 524, 286, 246, and
144, respectively.
A college in DLSMHSI is procuring 30
Solve this using microscopes for first years this school year
Adam’s Method 2024-2025. How many microscopes will be
distributed to each section?
Section No. of
Students
1A 42
1B 51
1C 35
1D 23
1E 60
Answer:
Number of
SQ
No. of Microscopes
Section SQ SQU (with MSD of SQU
Students per Section by
__)
Adam’s Plan
1A 42 5.9716 6
1B 51 7.2512 8
1C 35 4.9763 5
1D 23 3.2702 4
1E 60 8.5308 9
Total 211 32
Answer:
Number of
SQ
No. of Microscopes
Section SQ SQU (with MSD of SQU
Students per Section by
7.5)
Adam’s Plan
1A 42 5.9716 6 5.6000 6 6
1B 51 7.2512 8 6.8000 7 7
1C 35 4.9763 5 4.6667 5 5
1D 23 3.2702 4 3.0667 4 4
1E 60 8.5308 9 8.0000 8 8
Total 211 32 30 30
Determine how many people each representative should represent. Do this by dividing
the total population of all the states by the total number of representatives. This answer
is called the Standard Divisor.
Divide each state’s population by the standard divisor to determine how many
representatives it should have. Record this answer to several decimal place. This
answer is called Standard Quota or Quota.
Round all the Quotas to the nearest whole number (but don’t forget what the decimals
were). Add the values, which can be called initial allocation or initial apportionment.
If the total from Step 3 is less than the total number of representatives, reduce the
standard divisor and recalculate the quota and allocation. If it is larger, then increase
the divisor and recalculate the quota and allocation. Continue doing this until we meet
the desired total number of allocation needed.
DLSMHSI is planning to conduct a region –
wide medical mission. Sixty-three doctors
pledged to be part of it. If the number of
Sample Problem doctors that will be assigned to each province
is based on their population, how many
doctors will be assigned to each province?
Provinces Population
(2015 data*)
Cavite 3,678,000
Batangas 2,694,000
Quezon 2,123,000
Rizal 2,884,000
Laguna 3,035,000
Answer:
Number of
Population (2015
Provinces SQ SQ (RO) Doctors by
data*)
Webster’s Plan
Cavite 3,678,000
Batangas 2,694,000
Quezon 2,123,000
Rizal 2,884,000
Laguna 3,035,000
Total: 14,414,000
Decision:
The number of doctors to be assigned in Cavite, Batangas,
Quezon, Rizal, and Laguna are as follow: 16, 12, 9, 13, and 13,
respectively.
A college in DLSMHSI is procuring 30
Solve this using microscopes for first years this school year
Webster’s Method 2024-2025. How many microscopes will be
distributed to each section?
SQL (Standard Quota Lower) Note: In the Huntington-Hill Method (last column) if the
- values in the Quota round Quota > GM round up otherwise round down
down
Answer
Number of Health
Barangay Population Quota SQU SQL GM Workers by
Huntington-Hill Plan
Zone 1 10,019 27.9491 28 27 27.4955 28
Zone 2 1,258 3.5093 4 3 3.4641 4
Zone 3 5,168 14.4167 15 14 14.4914 14
Zone 4 3,271 9.1248 10 9 9.4868 9
Total 19,716 55
Decision:
The number of health workers to be assigned in Zone 1, Zone 2,
Zone 3, and Zone 4 are 28, 4, 14, and 9, respectively.
PRACTICE PROBLEM:
Find the apportioned values using the five different
methods of apportionment
The national government procured a total of 1550 test kits for the
five regions in the country. If the distribution will be solely based
on the total number of PUIs and PUMs combined in the region.
How many test kits will each region receive? Assume that the
total population of the five regions is 560,506.
Regions PUIs and PUMs Population (by
percent)
A 10%
B 15%
C 20%
D 30%
E 25%
Video References:
1. Hamilton’s Method
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWfEqWLz9pc
2. Jefferson’s Method
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=weGGVmy9yLc
3. Webster’s Method
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNybGTvz_hQ
4. Adams’ Method
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=irHEV2TmUas
5. Huntington-Hill’s Method
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l74j-auLjZE