Clinical Differentiation Between
Lung Collapse (Atelectasis) vs Pulmonary Fibrosis
Onset:
Collapse (Atelectasis): Sudden
Pulmonary Fibrosis: Gradual and progressive
History:
Collapse: Acute, e.g., post-surgery, airway obstruction.
Fibrosis: Chronic, progressive SOB, dry cough.
Symptoms:
Collapse: Acute dyspnea, chest pain possible.
Fibrosis: Chronic dry cough, progressive dyspnea.
Trachea:
Collapse: Shifted toward the side of collapse.
Fibrosis: Usually midline or slight shift if extensive.
Chest Expansion:
Collapse: Decreased on affected side.
Fibrosis: Decreased over fibrosed area (less marked).
Percussion:
Collapse: Dull (loss of air).
Fibrosis: Dull (dense fibrotic tissue).
Auscultation:
Collapse: Breath sounds decreased or absent.
Fibrosis: Fine end-inspiratory crepitations (Velcro crackles).
Vocal Resonance:
Collapse: Decreased or absent.
Fibrosis: Normal or slightly increased.
Clubbing:
Collapse: Usually absent.
Fibrosis: Commonly present (chronic hypoxia).
Cyanosis:
Collapse: Can occur if massive collapse.
Fibrosis: May be present in advanced stages.
Chest X-ray:
Collapse: Dense opacity, volume loss, tracheal shift toward collapse.
Fibrosis: Reticulonodular shadows, honeycombing (late).
Key Clinical Clues:
- Collapse: Acute onset, tracheal deviation toward affected side, silent chest area, no early clubbing.
- Fibrosis: Chronic course, fine Velcro crackles, clubbing common, trachea midline.
Mnemonic:
"Collapse is sudden, silent, and shifts the trachea; fibrosis is slow, crackling, and clubs the fingers."