Maneesh Gupta Paper
Maneesh Gupta Paper
Summary
A wide range of non-ballasted track structures have been developed for transit railways throughout the
world, especially on tunnelled and viaduct sections of metro and light rail systems, as well as high speed
railways.
The currently operating Australian rail networks have relatively small lengths of non-ballasted track
within tunnelled sections, bridges and viaducts on the major metropolitan rail systems. An analysis of
new and future metropolitan projects suggests an increasing proportion of railway length involves
tunnels and associated non-ballasted track systems. It is therefore imperative, that rich experience
gained globally are systematically evaluated in the context of the specific requirements of Australian rail
projects which need to occur in already developed areas, and often includes stringent noise and
vibration performance.
This paper captures a detailed survey of various slab track systems currently being used around the
world and identifies best practices in the context of the typical design and performance requirements for
the tunnelled section of the rail projects within Australia.
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
In almost all slab track structures, the rail is Ground-borne noise refers to noise that is first
discretely supported to the concrete slab by transmitted to the ground by a train as vibration,
means of a fastening system selected from the which then travels to a sensitive location (such
considerations stipulated in the project design as a house) through the ground and
criteria. The choice of the fastening system and foundations, where the walls, floor and ceiling
slab support is strongly influenced by the noise then radiate this vibration as audible noise. The
and vibration constraints and possible ground-borne noise is also commonly termed
mitigation measures. regenerated noise. Ground-borne noise levels
are more difficult to predict than noise that is
2 DISCUSSION ON NOISE AND transmitted through the air only. This is because
VIBRATION the transmission of ground-borne noise
The broad principles for achieving vibration depends on the ground strata, coupling
isolation of railways aim to reduce the natural between the ground and buildings and internal
frequency of the track. Generally, these specify acoustical characteristics of buildings.
a reduction of the dynamic stiffness of the track Indicative ground-borne noise trigger levels are
support, introduction of (or increase in the mass provided in Table 1. An example of a rail
of) specific structural elements for track support, vibration source, propagation and receiver
and adjustments to damping. In general, the system (ISO 14837) is provided in Figure 1.
lower the natural frequency of the track support
system, the better the vibration isolation and the
low natural frequency is achieved by increased
mass and reduced dynamic stiffness [4].
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
Areas
Private When in use 40 dBA Floating Slab Track (FST) systems
using short, long or continuous slabs
Offices and with rubber or spring elements
Lowest Noise and Vibration
Conference
Rooms
Cinemas, When in use 35 dBA Figure 2 Acoustic performance impacts for generic
track form layouts in tunnelled sections
Public
Halls and 2.1 Airborne noise within train passenger
Lecture
Theatres
and driver cabin areas
Workshops NA NA When trains are moving on track surface, in-car
/ Industrial
noise levels are controlled by airborne noise
Buildings
generated at the wheel-rail interface,
Table 1 Ground Borne Noise Trigger Levels
predominantly transmitted through the floor of
Potential ground-borne noise mitigation options the train. Other contributors to in-car noise are
at the design stage for a new tunnelled railway air conditioning systems (particularly at low
line can include: speeds), and structure radiated noise
generated by vibration of surfaces inside the
Review of options to adjust the vertical and
car. Trains with well-sealed windows and doors
horizontal alignment to avoid key sensitive
receptors, in particular maximising the
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
are quieter in tunnels than trains with operable An example of an acoustic floor panel system
windows or poorly-sealed doors. (Quietstone) is shown in Figure 4.
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
Repair and renovation friendly system. Figure 7 Recent Shinkansen Slab System Schematic
A key disadvantage is their high cost, which can
be up to four times more than ballasted track.
The high level of mechanisation may also be
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
Rubber boot
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
Static Dynamic
Fastener Type Stiffness Stiffness Comments
Direct Fixation with Standard Rail Fasteners
Normal "stiff" rail pads
usually only used on
Pandrol HDPE > 100 kN/mm > 100 kN/mm surface tracks
Resilient Rail Fasteners
Pandrol VIPA 17 - 20 kN/mm 17 - 20 kN/mm
Stiffness options can be
Delkor Alt 1 12 - 30 kN/mm 17-42 kN/mm varied to suit
Sonneville Standard 18 kN/mm 27 kN/mm
Highly Resilient Rail Fasteners
Pandrol Vanguard 3 - 5 kN/mm 5 - 7.5 kN/mm
Stiffness options can be
Low Profile Delkor Egg 6 kN/mm 7.2 kN/mm varied to suit
Sonneville High Attenuation 9 kN/mm
Choice of a system often depends on client Delkor Alternative 1 Elastic Rail Fastener
preference. For example, the Public Transport (Type SL-065); and,
Authority in Western Australia code of practice
specifies the following preferences for slab
Delkor Egg Elastic Rail Fastener.
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide
Maneesh Gupta Non-Ballasted Track Forms –
AECOM Australia Pty Ltd A Survey Of Global Best Practices
The design approach should include verification systems which are trending to converge into a
of the following: limited number of relatively more generic
systems. The selection of a particular type of
Rail deflections and bending stress from non-ballasted track and associated fastening
compound multiple axle vertical and lateral
system will be dictated by specific requirements
loads;
of a project and a range of factors covered in
Loads on each fastener; this paper. However, on network expansion
projects in Australia, the past experience with
Rail break gap for the assumed fastener
spacing and rail clip (more critical on the incumbent system and avoidance of
viaducts exposed to the elements); proliferation of multiple systems will continue to
be the dominant consideration.
Adequate longitudinal rail restraint, generally
necessary on grades of 3% or greater if 10 REFERENCES
elastic rail clips are intended for use;
1. SLR Consulting. North West Rail Link - Noise
Adequate lateral fastener restraint; and Vibration Technical Paper for Operations
Fastener anchor bolt pull out capacity within and Additional Construction Works. Sydney:
the limits of minimum slab depth Transport for NSW; 2012.
requirements. Requires evaluation of the
anchor bolt torque to restrain lateral loads 2. Yokoyama A. Introduction of High-Speed Rail
and the anchor bolt insert capacity at the in Japan. Presentation presented at; 2010; Los
required bolt torque and minimum insert Angeles.
depth; and,
3. SLR Consulting. Bus and Train Tunnel
Sensitivities of a design to tolerance Environmental Impact Statement Operation
accumulation that could affect performance. Noise and Vibration. Brisbane; 2014.
Common rail size used in Australia and
4. Transport for NSW. Track Slabs. Sydney:
internationally on slab track systems is the
Transport for NSW; 2015.
60kg/m profile. Fastening spacing varies from
600mm to 760mm with 700mm being more 5. Low Vibration Track (LVT). Sonneville. 2015;
frequently adopted on Australian systems.
6. Esveld C. Recent developments in slab track.
9 CONCLUSION Delft: Delft University of Technology; 2003.
The current state of non-ballasted track 7. European Union. Council Directive 96/48/EC.
systems has evolved from popular historical European Union; 1996.
AusRAIL 2016
22-23 November, Adelaide