Gaudí, Burnham, and Wagner: Architectural Innovators
Gaudí, Burnham, and Wagner: Architectural Innovators
1914 he decided to devote himself exclusively to the church. The builders’ hut
With his rejection of straight lines and symetrical became his new home. But when the architect died in 1926 after a tram
ground plans, Antoni Gaudí opened a new accident, this “sermon in stone” was still far from completion. Of the three
chapter in the architectural history of Barcelona. facades, only the eastern one had been begun, not to speak of the bell towers,
With their strong colors and glittering facades, it is the tallest of which was to grow to 170 meters. Even today, Gaudi’s masterpiece
his highly imaginative designs that still primarily presents itself as a building site—although this hardly detracts from its
characterize this Spanish port. overwhelming impact.
Fairytale Castles in the Heart of the City Major Works of Antoni Gaudí
The son of a coppersmith, Gaudí began his Cooperativa Obrera Mataronense (1878–1882) Mataró
architectural career on a not exactly promising El Capricho (1883–1885) Comillas
note: he left university with the lowest possible Casa Vicens (1883–1888) Barcelona
grade, a “pass.” However, private clients above Sagrada Família (1883–1926) Barcelona
all had confidence in his skill-to such an extent Güell Pavilions (1884–1887) Barcelona
that this unconventional architect was soon Palau Güell (1886–1890) Barcelona
inundated with [Link] sources of inspiration were unusual: he was Colegio de las Teresianas (1888–1889) Barcelona
passion-ate about both medieval Gothic and Moorish architecture, to which he Episcopal Palace of Astorga (1889–1915) Astorga
alluded when building the Casa Vicens. This home of a brickyard owner Casa Botines (1891–1894) León
fascinates above all by its wealth of contrasts: little turrets on the roof are Bodegas Güell (1895–1897) Sitges
reminiscent of the minarets of mosques, and patterns of colorfully glazed tiles Casa Calvet (1898–1900) Barcelona
cover the entire facade. Bellesguard (1900–1909) Barcelona
Parc Güell (1900–1914) Barcelona
The young architect soon found his most important client in the industrialist Casa Batlló (1904–1906) Barcelona
Eusebi Guell, for whom he first built a palatial residence, adorning its roof with a Artigas Gardens (1905–1906) La Pobla de Lillet
whole forest of fantastic chimneys. But Guell had greater things in mind; he Casa Milà (1906–1910) Barcelona
dreamt of a garden city, whose houses on a steep cliff were to offer a view of Church of Colònia Güell (1908–1915) Colònia Güell (Santa Coloma de Cervelló)
the Mediterranean. While Güell’s plan did not find widespread acceptance and
only two residential buildings were finally executed, Gaudi tackled his part of the
Daniel Hudson Burnham
work and transformed a 20-hectare area in the north of Barcelona into a walk-in
sculpture. Between pine and palm trees, mosaics of glass and ceramics sparkle After some failed attempts at academic and
on the steps, benches, and houses of Park Güell. political careers, Daniel Hudson Burnham started
working in an architects’ office in Chicago. His
At Home on the Building Site professional future was sealed when he met his
future businnes partner there, John Wellborn
Root. Together, they were to play a leading role in
“The straight line is the line of Man, the curve is the line of God”—this was
the creation of the modern skyscraper.
Gaudi’s fundamental belief. His masterwork, a church known as the Sagrada
Familia, was designed entirely according to this principle. When the 31-year-old
took over the construction of this church, a crypt was already being built. Gaudi The two architects complemented each other
only briefly followed the existing Gothic forms, however. Soon he had found his wonderfully: Daniel Burnham was considered the
model for the basic framework: nature itself. With their “branches,” the pillars pragmatist while Root was esteemed for his
and supports look like trees. The Sagrada Família, as a church of atonement, wealth of invention. Together the pair built a
was to be built exclusively from donated funds, which the master builder
frequently supplied in person.
1 2
significant proportion of the architecture that has become known as the Otto Wagner
“Chicago School.”
3 4
Modern Buildings for Modern Times Theory and Practice
Thus no trace of revivalism was to be found in the Viennese Post Office Savings Semper sympathized with revolutionary ideas, and so after the uprisings of 1848
Bank, one of Wagner’s masterworks, built 1904-1906 in the center of Vienna. had been put down he fled to Paris. Over the decades that followed, one move
The exterior is clad in granite and marble panels, supported by aluminum succeeded another; failing as a German to get a foothold in France, he moved
bolts—a new material, like the reinforced concrete that was also used. The on to London. There too he had hardly any opportunity to make his mark as an
center of the building is the banking hall, above which is stretches a glass barrel architect, and so he resumed his work as a professor. Now aged 52, in the hope
vault. of supplementing his teaching work with building commissions, he took
advantage of an offer from Switzerland.
The entire interior of the Savings Bank was also designed by Wagner in the
same clear and rational way. His unprecedented designs were very influential, He had to remain patient for a little longer, but in 1860 he was finally able to go
and among the successors of this architect, urban planner, furniture designer ahead with the building of the Polytechnikum in Zurich. Further commissions,
and theorist was, not least, Adolf Loos, who ultimately maintained that all and not only from Switzerland, followed. At the same time. Semper consolidated
decorative ornamentation was “a crime.” his reputation as an architectural theorist with his influential publication Style. A
further success involved yet another move: Semper’s designs for the
Kaiserforum on the Ringstrasse in Vienna were accepted. The master builder
Gottfried Semper now settled in Vienna and began work on the great building complex of
museums and Burg-theater, which however was subjected to wide-ranging
Before he decided to study mathematics, alterations after his death.
Gottfried Semper chose a career as a professional
army officer. Even when he finally attended the
Munich academy of architecture, his enthusiasm
Karl Friedrich Schinkel
for it was still muted. Yet he was to have a
profound impact on German architecture.
One of the most prolific German architects of the
first half of the 19th century, Karl Friedrich
Born in Hamburg, Semper was initially drawn to Schinkel created more than 150 buildings in
foreign parts. In Paris he again took up the study Germany and Poland, most of which are still to be
of architecture, and this time it clearly took hold of seen today-churches and museums, palaces and
him In southern Europe he traveled to the classical monuments, bridges, schools, theaters and
temples and studied their coloration. Fascinated castles. He was also a accomplished painter,
by the interplay of the arts of architecture, painting stage set designer, and interior decorator.
and sculpture, Semper presented his findings from
Italy and Greece in book form.
Fitness For Purpose
Renaissance Revival on the Elbe
His career proceeded rapidly; as early as 1815, in
his mid-1930s, he was appointed chief building
As soon as this project was completed, the 31-year-old was appointed to a advisor and was given important commissions,
professorship in architecture, and in 1834 he began teaching at the Dresden including the construction of a guardhouse for the royal palace. After the theater
Academy. With his approach of linking theory and practice, Semper was striking in the center of Berlin, in the Gen-darmenmarkt, had burnt down, the king’s
out on new paths. At the same time, the teacher and author was given his first choice fell once again on the master builder from Brandenburg. Its replacement,
major project: his design for the Dresden Court Theater had been approved, built from 1818 to 1821, represents one of Schinkel’s masterworks. The worthy
and he began work in 1838. Having a semicircular form, and being integrated framework for the new theater was already in place: the symmetrically designed
into the existing Baroque backdrop of buildings, the theater caused a sensation. square could already boast two church buildings close by, the German and the
Semper now began to receive commissions from all over Germany: his adoption French cathedrals.
of the Renaissance style had immediately found admirers.
5 6
The Schauspielhaus in the center of the Gendarmenmarkt welcomes visitors suddenly transplanted to a time several centuries ago. The portal of this
with its classical, well-proportioned forms, more precisely with a Greek temple residence already resembles the front of a temple; mighty columns support a
frontage built according to all the rules of the textbooks. In the interior of the profiled cornice on which rests a classical pediment. At the rear, too, a similar
building, the design strictly follows the law of fitness for purpose. Schinkel made portico leads into the building.
no secret of his motto: “In architecture everything must be true, all masking or
disguising of the structure is a fault.” The theater was opened with a production Projecting side wings are set back from the prominent porch, and the house is
of Mozart’s opera The Magic Flute. The sets were designed by the great music- crowned by a central dome. For his new building, Jefferson made use of
lover Friedrich Schinkel. European architectural models, such as the Roman Pantheon, but also a
masterwork of Renaissance architecture, the Villa Rotonda, which itself was
The Old an the New based on classical buildings. This central-plan building, which had been built
well over 200 years earlier near Vicenza in Italy by Andrea Palladio, was the
With his references to the architecture of classical antiquity, Schinkel was American’s chief inspiration, above all in the matter of the design of the facade.
following a current trend. In the late 18th century, both clients and architects
saw in the temples of classical Greece the epitome of perfect beauty and thus Jefferson’s Other Architectural Works
the model for contemporary architecture. Accordingly, it was Schinkel’s
buildings in the Neo-Classical style that met with the greatest approval, above Jefferson’s comfortable countryseat was only the beginning of his career as an
all the Old Museum in the Lustgarten. A flight of stairs leads into the building, architect. As his next project, Jefferson took on the seat of government of his
which, with its rotunda as a central hall, also alludes to the Roman Pantheon. home state, Virginia. In its capital, Richmond, he built the Virginia State Capitol.
Anyone who had expected modern architecture for the young nation must have
But Schinkel was perfectly capable of enthusiasm for other eras. In building the had quite a surprise. On a hill above the city, from 1785 a classical temple
Friedrichswerder church in Berlin, for example, he was alluding to medieval began to arise, its declared model this time being a temple from Roman times,
Gothic. Schloss Kamenz in Silesia is likewise reminiscent of a medieval castle, the Maison Carree in Nimes, in the south of France.
and other designs demonstrate Schinkel’s weakness for the Romantic. Not only
with regard to his building assignments, but also in respect of his models, Politicians gathered there for the first time after seven years of building. At the
Friedrich Schinkel shows himself to have always been open to the old—and to very top of the agenda for the delegates and Governor Jefferson were topics
the new. such as the abolition of feudal privileges, the separation of church and state,
and the setting up of a public education system. The latter was energetically
taken in hand by Jefferson himself; after his term of office as third president of
Thomas Jefferson
the United States had come to an end, he built and financed the University of
In Virginia in the east of the newly founded Virginia, designing a whole “academic village.” For each of the ten faculties to
United States of America, architecture largely be taught he designed a separate pavilion, which contained teaching and
followed European styles. It was above all the residential areas.
buildings of classical Rome that inspired master
builders, and so both private and public buildings In designing the library, Jefferson seems to have once again had the Pantheon
displayed temple facades, columned entrance in mind; an impressive dome adorns the building and provides daylight. In
halls, and elegant domes. America’s March 1825 the first 123 students began their studies in Virginia. Jefferson also
third president was among these enthusiastic concerned himself with their physical well being, and several of them enjoyed
builders. Sunday dinner in the ex-president’s house. Among the students there were
some of the finest minds of the young nation, including the founder of crime
Classical Sources fiction, Edgar Allan Poe.
11 12
rely on the patronage of several popes. If he fell out of favor with the Vatican, Andrea Palladio
there were still illustrious secular patrons to be found to make use of Bernini’s
services, including King Louis XIV of France. No wonder that Bernini did not
hide his light under a bushel. When there was criticism of the nose in a newly Palladio’s career reads like a rags-to-riches story:
completed portrait of Louis, he responded curtly: “That is how I see it.” a miller’s son from Padua, married, in accordance
with his social status, to the daughter of a
carpenter, he became one of the most sought-
Resurgent Rome after architects of the wealth). More than 60 villas,
churches, and city mansions were built to his
Bernini combined his talents as a sculptor and architect in his largest and most designs. And he not only immortalized himself in
spectacular fountain. In the middle of the Piazza Navona in Rome, four marble stone, but also left behind a series of widely
river gods are enthroned on a rock, representing the parts of the earth known at influential writings.
that time: the Ganges and the Nile, the Danube and the Rio de la Plata form the
basis of the monumental Fountain of Four Rivers, from whose center a Roman The skilled stonemason Andrea di Pietro was in
obelisk towers up. In 1656, on the opposite bank of the Tiber, and within the his mid-20s when the writer and aristocrat
Vatican City, Bernini began his most important project, the redesign of St Giangiorgio Trissino recognized his talent. He
Peter’s Square. From the viewpoint of the existing square, the effect of the bestowed the name Palladio on his protege and
mighty dome of the basilica was hardly to be perceived. traveled with him to Rome – a momentous trip for the young man. Back in the
Veneto, over the next four decades Palladio followed classical principles of
Bernini first designed a trapezoid arrangement, and then toyed with the idea of a building— mainly for very wealthy clients, for Trissino opened many doors in
circular shape. Finally, he decided in favor of two adjoining areas, appropriate to high society to the young man in his lateral career move. In the 16th century,
the huge dimensions of the church: the Piazza Obliqua, 140 meters in depth, few prosperous families were without their own country villa, and their preferred
consists of an ellipse running diagonally to the church, to which is adjoined the architect was Andrea Palladio.
Piazza Retta, which widens in trapezoid shape to 90 meters towards the basilica
of St Peter. At the edges of both areas, Bernini placed wide rows of columns to His client Paolo Almerico commissioned from him a villa on a hill at the outskirts
enclose the Baroque complex effectively. of Vicenza. A circular hall surmounted by a cupola forms the center of the
building and gave it its name: the “Rotonda” is presented as a central-plan
A tireless worker, Bernini continually pursued parallel tasks to this one, including building—a daring design, for this ground plan was more usual in ecclesiastical
the building of the church of Sant’Andrea on the Quirinal Hill. The decisive buildings than in private houses. In the design of the entrance to the Rotonda,
shape of this Jesuit church is the oval, and the ground-plan oval is even set Palladio oriented himself to the temple frontages of classical antiquity, and gave
diagonally. A circular staircase leads up to the portal, which in its turn is the Rotonda no fewer than four of these. The comfort of the residents was not
shielded by a canopy. Curved walls project on to the street from the portal. forgotten by the architect: he placed the utility rooms in the basement, while the
Bernini’s urge to design did not stop at the facade: the design extends to the piano nobile was reserved for celebrations, and the family lived in the
interior too, where the oval forms are continued. The architect himself often mezzanine floor above.
visited the little church even after its completion, considering it one of his
masterpieces. All’antica
13 14
“Il Redentore,” the church of the Redeemer, came into being as a memorial of Giorgio Vasari, friend and biographer of Michelangelo, noted the tatter’s
the end of a plague epidemic, and this building too is adorned by a tiered, enthusiastic reaction to the enquiry from Rome: “At last His Holiness decided,
brilliantly white temple frontage. Palladio could no longer complain of a lack of as I believe, by divine inspiraton, to send for Michelango. Michelangelo tried to
variety. His final commission too was a challenge: he was to build a theater avoid the burden, saying that architecture was not his real field, and since his
all’antica (in the antique style) for the scholars of Vicenza. Once again he requests were of no avail, the Pope in the end positively ordered him to
needed to satisfy cultured tastes, and once again he fell back on his studies of accept the commission.” Admittedly, Paul III sweetened the pill for his chosen
classical buildings and architectural treatises. With the help of ingenious candidate, appointing the Florentine as chief director of building in 1547 and
perspective, the architect of villas was now in addition creating the theater of the granting him powers that no other architect was ever to be given by a client:
Renaissance. Michelangelo alone was to decide what should be torn down and what should
be added. So much freedom summoned envious rivals who were not sparing
with their criticisms.
Michelangelo
By his mid-30s, Michelangelo was alredy used to One reproach was that Michelangelo was designing only a small church of St
illustrious clients lining up to secure his services Peter, a “San Pietrino,” instead of the greatest church in Christendom.
for their projects. So it seems only logical that at Undeterred, Michelangelo reduced the size of hi; predecessor’s model, certain
the advanced age of 71 he was personally that the effect of the central-plan building would only be increased as a
requested by the pope to take over the most result. The chief architect of St Peter’s was already 71 when he took over the
important building project of the era, the building project, and to provide against further changes to his plans by potential
completion of St Peter’s Basilica in Rome. successors he ordered work to begin simultaneously on all the important areas
of the building. It was a strategy that largely worked.
Michelangelo was already widely regarded as the
greatest sculptor and painter of his day when he Donato Bramante
turned to architecture. The friend of his youth,
Giovanni de’ Medici, now Pope Leo X, had great Bramante’s father had decided that his son
plans for the family buildings in his home city of should be a painter. Donato submitted, but met
Florence. From 1516, Michelangelo gave with a distinct lack of success, as recorded bj the
expression to these wishes. For the church of San biographer Vasari: “So he determined, in order to
Lorenzo he designed a facade without equal: twelve monumental columns, each view an important building at least once, to go to
one several tonnes in weight, were to adorn the marble frontage. Milan and look at the cathedral.”
However, only one of these survived unbroken from the quarry on the building Bramante’s visit to Milan was momentous, for the
site, and the many failures caused the building costs to soar. Michelangelo young painter decided on the spot to become an
raged, the pope cancelled the contract, and promptly signed up the architect for architect. He began by making an intensive study
another project. It was not the facade but a family vault that Michelangelo was of the classical buildings of Rome. His first
now to tackle in San Lorenzo: in 1520-1534 the New Sacristy took shape (as a commissions brought him back to Milan, but
counterpart to Brunelleschi’s Old Sacristy). The next commission followed finally, after all he settled in the capital. In the
immediately with the next Medici Pope: Clement VII had Michelangelo plan and early 16th century Rome was a great and
execute the library of the monastery of San Lorenzo. prestigious place to build, and above all it was the popes who brought many
notable architects to the city.
The Biblioteca Lauren-ziana, designed in close co-operation with the pope,
became Michelangelo’s most important architectural work: the most prestigious Symmetry
one was still to come. An Architect Against His Will Equally at home with all
genres of art, Michelangelo was now known as simply the universal genius. It It was on the Gianicolo, a hill on the right bank of the Tiber, Donato Bramante
was only to him that Pope Paul III would entrust the task of bringing the work on worked on his first architectural commission. The monastery of San Pietro in
St Peter’s, which had been dragging along for decades, to a successful Montorio was to be enriched by a memorial building to recall the martyrdom of
conclusion.
15 16
the Apostle Peter, which was said to have taken place there. Bramante decided Leon Battista Alberti
in favor of a central-plan structure on a circular base—that the surrounding
monastery courtyard would eventually be rectangular was something the Archaeologist and painter, musician and scientist,
architect could not have guessed. and moreover fascinated by mathematics—to call
Leon Battista Alberti multi-talented would be an
Three steps, arranged in circles around the structure, lead up to the little temple, understatement. Particularlj since the Genoese
the “Tempi-etto.” Columns surround the circular building, crowned with a dome, Alberti also found time to dedicate himself to
and there is a balustrade on the upper level. Bramante’s Tempietto was architecture, and thus definitively secure his
regarded by the next generation as a perfect central-plan building, an reputation as a Renaissance “universal man.”
architectural type that was considered the epitome of ideal beauty.
Alberti approached architecture in a roundabout
St Peter’s Basilica way. At first he made an intensive study of the
buildings of classical antiquity, above all as they
were still to be admired in Rome, and at the same
The Renaissance embodiment of the mania for building was undoubtedly Pope time read with enthusiasm the writings of classical
Julius II. Soon after his election in 1503 he took in hand the rebuilding of St architects. Spurred on by their works, Alberti also
Peter’s Basilica—the old building could neither accommodate the throngs of wrote atreatise on architectural theory, De re aedificatoria. But his knowledge of
pilgrims nor satisfy the pope’s ambitious demands. Julius had big plans and classical buildings was reflected not only on paper: the palaces and churches
Bramante was part of them: he was to build a church that would do justice to the designed by him also clearly mirror this deep adr ration.
importance of Rome as the heart of Christendom.
Symmetry and Proportion
By 1506 Bramante’s plans had progressed so far that the foundation stone
could be laid. Bramante designed St Peter’s on the ground plan of a Greek
cross, with four arms of equal length—another central-plan building, again Alberti’s first large commission came from the Rucellai, a wealthy Florentine
crowned with a mighty dome. With the basilica of St Peter, Bramante had taken family of merchants; he was to design their spacious residence on the central
on the most important project in Rome, but the pope was no ordinary client: “To Via dellaVigna. Alberti drew up the plans and the Rossellino workshop carried
be honest,” Bramante once summed it up, “they give you water and words, out the execution. The facade of the palace alone showed the architect to be a
smoke and hot air. If you ask for more, you are dismissed.” fan of the classical style: he adorned the house with an order of columns similar
to those of the Colosseum in Rome. But in doing this he did not use rounded
columns, but flat wall columns know as pilasters for the vertical emphasis. At the
His fee was a comparatively small expense; the horrendous costs of the new same time, he stressed the horizontal lines by placing cornices between the
building, despite the lively and controversial trade in indulgences, could not be stories. In this way, the facade of the mansion appears clearly structured, and
covered. When Bramante died in 1514, only the choir area had made any the impression is achieved of symmetry and fine proportions.
progress, and subsequent generations of architects largely overruled his
design—today’s basilica reflects Bramante’s plans at most in its gigantic
proportions. The High Art of the Facade
It was not only Giovanni Rucellai who had confidence in Alberti’s talents. Not far
from his city mansion, the Dominican church of Santa Maria Novella was
awaiting completion. The Gothic structure was already nearly finished, and even
the foundation of the facade had already been begun when the clients
commissioned Alberti to complete it. He therefore had to incorporate his
knowledge of classical temple architecture into the existing fabric.
Thus Gothic pointed arches stand under niches and portals in the lower zone,
and above them are superimposed round arches. Sweeping volutes lead from
the broad substructure to the sharp gable, forms from the Gothic and
17 18
Renaissance styles combine harmoniously, and everything glows in white and rather hesitant. It was a question of crown ing the cathedral, the flagship of the
green stone. It was on Alberti, who remained unmarried all his life, that the city, with a dome. The diameter of the octagonal substructure already stood at a
choice of the ruler of Rimini fell when he planned to erect a memorial to his wife. proud 45 meters There was no question – for such a task, a first class master
architect had to be engaged Several applicants believed themselves capable of
Sigis-mondo Pandolfo Malatesta commissioned a tomb for himself and his it and took part in a competition.
family, conceived, in disregard of Christian traditions, as a pagan temple. He
himself and his Isotta were to be buried there, and instead of symbols of the The judges were undecided It was only after two years that they were convinced
cross, it was decorated with the entwined letters S and I in abundance, Alberti by Brunelleschi’s proposal The new project manager was not afraid of
admittedly did not concern himself with the adornment of the interior, but once innovations he clothed the dome in two shells, of which only the inner one is
again designed the facade. In the Tempio Malatestiano too the architect did not load-bearing, so that he could reduce the overall weight of the dome.
conceal his preference for classical forms: the central part of the frontage for Brunelleschi was also inventive with regard to the organization of the work, in
example goes back to the closely related triumphal arch of the Roman Emperor order to spare the workers in the dome the tedious and timeconsuming climb up
Augustus. and down at midday, he had wine taverns and kitchens built under the church
roof. But the clients were skeptical about Brunelleschi’s inventiveness.
Filippo Brunelleschi
In 1432, when it was a question of the design of the crowning lantern of the
A skilled goldsmith who was also active as a dome, the guild preferred to hold a further competition, rather than leave this
painter and sculptor, Brunelleschi became one of task to Brunelleschi. In the end it was his design that was executed, but he did
the great architects of the early Renaissance. He not live to see the completion of the dome: he died m 1446. The historian Vasari
could not complain of a lack of commissions—in reported on the funeral of the great architect in Florence cathedral, without con
the wealthy city-state of Florence influential cealing that his native land “honored htm far more greatly after his death than it
families and guilds were building an abundance of had done during his lifetime.”
architectural works in their own honor.
But not alt Florentines expected great things of Brunelleschi. The wool workers’
guild, for example. which was responsible for building the cathedral, seemed
19 20