Factors Influencing Capital Budgeting Decisions
Factors Influencing Capital Budgeting Decisions
BY
ABDISSA DIDA WODAJO
ADVISOR
PRASSAD (Dr.)
Ambo
1|Page
Table of Contents Pages
Abstract....................................................................................................................................................3
Chapter One.............................................................................................................................................4
1 Introduction...........................................................................................................................................4
1.1Statement of the Problem...............................................................................................................5
1.2Objectives of the study....................................................................................................................5
1.2.1General objective......................................................................................................................5
1.2.2Specific Objectives...................................................................................................................5
1.2.3Research questions...................................................................................................................6
Chapter Two............................................................................................................................................7
Review of literature.................................................................................................................................7
2.Review of Related literature.................................................................................................................7
2.1Theoretical Reviews..........................................................................................................................7
2.2Over views of Capital budgeting decision.......................................................................................7
2.3Significance of Capital Budgeting....................................................................................................8
2.4Capital budgeting Decision process.................................................................................................8
2.5Factors Affecting Capital Budgeting.............................................................................................9
2.6Capital Budgeting Techniques.....................................................................................................11
2.6.1Payback Period Method:.........................................................................................................11
2.6.2Accounting Rate of Return:.....................................................................................................11
2.6.3Net Present Value (NPV) Method:..........................................................................................12
2.6.4Profitability Index (PI):............................................................................................................12
2.6.5Internal Rate of Return (IRR):.................................................................................................12
2.7Empirical Review: Capital Budgeting Decision..........................................................................13
2.8Literature Gap..............................................................................................................................13
Chapter Three........................................................................................................................................15
3.Research Methodology.......................................................................................................................15
3.1 Research Design...........................................................................................................................15
3.2 Research approaches...................................................................................................................16
3.3 Source of data...............................................................................................................................16
3.3.1 Data collection methods........................................................................................................16
3.3.2 Sampling techniques and sampling size...............................................................................17
3.4 Data Analysis method..................................................................................................................18
3.5 Ethical Considerations.................................................................................................................19
References...............................................................................................................................................20
2|Page
Abstract
The purpose of this thesis is to validate the impact of various factors, which influence the capital
budgeting decisions taken by Ambo Mineral Water S.C. Capital budgeting decisions use the
structural equation modeling approach and case study after undergoing factor analysis, which
results in a better-developed model after various rotations with different variables for arriving at
the best-fit structural model. This paper will based on primary data with sample size of 15
managers participating in capital budgeting activities by categorizing the variables into four
factors - Size, Risk, Social Cost Benefit Analysis (SCBA) and Trait. A the researcher will
conduct regression analysis in which he will check first three factors (Size, Risk and SCBA) are
significant and influence the decision of acceptance of the Type of Capital Budgeting Technique
used in Ethiopia.
Keywords
Capital Budgeting, Trait, Size, Risk, Social Cost Benefit Analysis, DCF Techniques.
3|Page
Chapter One
1. Introduction
Capital budgeting is a company’s formal process used for evaluating potential expenditures or
investments that are significant in amount. It involves the decision to invest the current funds for
addition, disposition, modification or replacement of fixed assets. The large expenditures include
the purchase of fixed assets like land and building, new equipment, rebuilding or replacing
existing equipment, research and development, etc. The large amounts spent for these types of
projects are known as capital expenditure. Capital Budgeting is a tool for maximizing a
company’s future profits since most companies are able to manage only a limited number of
large projects at any one time. (Mid-market pulse,zzz Edu Pristine.com)
The crux of capital budgeting decision is profit maximization. There are two ways to it; either
increase the revenues or reduce the costs. If an investment proposal is accepted, the decision for
capital budgeting is that, a firm invests in it and if rejected the firm does not invest. Generally,
proposals that yield a rate of return greater than a certain required rate of return or cost of capital
are accepted and the others are rejected. All independent projects are accepted. Independent
projects are projects that do not compete with one another in such a way that acceptance gives a
fair possibility of acceptance of another. Mutually exclusive project decision compete with other
projects in such a way that the acceptance of one will exclude the acceptance of the other
projects. Only one may be chosen. Mutually exclusive investment decisions gain importance
when more than one proposal is acceptable under accept or reject decision.
The acceptance of the best alternative eliminates the other alternatives. Capital rationing
decision required in a situation where the firm has unlimited funds, capital budgeting becomes a
very simple process. In that, independent investment proposals yielding a return greater than
some predetermined level are accepted. However, actual business has a different picture. They
have fixed capital budget with large number of investment proposals competing for it. Capital
rationing refers to the situation where the firm has more acceptable investments projects
requiring a greater amount of finance, than that is available with the firm. Ranking of the
investment project employed because of some predetermined criterion as the rate of return. The
project with highest return ranked first and the acceptable projects then ranked thereafter.
4|Page
This research will be organized with First section starting with introduction, the second section
will outline the literature review, third section will describe the sample, methodology, analysis &
discussion and finally, section four will draw the conclusions and recommendation of the study.
Therefore, the motivation for this study emanates from the lack of methodological research on
capital budgeting decision and factors affecting/influencing it. Hence, this study serves two
purposes, the first is to survey capital budgeting methods applied by Ambo Mineral Water S.C
and the second is to validate the impact of various factors, which influence the capital budgeting
decisions taken by Ambo Mineral Water S.C.
1.2 Objectives of the study
1.2.1 General objective
The main objective of this research is to assess that Factors Affecting Capital Budgeting
Decision (CBD) in the case of Ambo Mineral Water S.C (AMW SC.
1.2.2 Specific Objectives
The specific objectives of this research will be:
To assess the capital budgeting decision and factors affecting it in AMW S.C one by one
To investigate capital budgeting decision trend analysis AMW S.C for during 2018 & 2019
To assess the challenges of current capital budgeting decision and process of AMW S.C’s
To check which capital budgeting method adopted by AMW SC for decision-making.
5|Page
1. What are factors affecting capital budgeting decision at Ambo Mineral water SC
2. What CBD trends are there at AMW SC to make things smooth with lower cost and higher
return in the last two years?
3. What are the challenges at AMW SC that hinder their CBD process during the last two years
4. What are method of capital budgeting techniques is/are maintained at AMW SC for long-
term investment decision?
6|Page
Chapter Two
Review of literature
2. Review of Related literature
This part of the researcher’s proposal presented in detail theoretical, conceptual framework
and/or empirical related to the subject matter under the study. Theories concerning capital
budgeting decisions will reviewed and addressed in detail topics. Empirical literatures will
reviewed and presented to show the studies done on the theme and literature gap.
For Quirin (1967) capital budgeting is a process for analyzing and selecting long-term
investment projects. Concerning the need for capital budgeting analysis need Gilman (2008)
states that long term investments represent sizable out lays of funds that commit a firm to some
course of action. Consequently, the firm needs procedures to analyze and properly select its long-
term investments.
Hagos (2007) described investing is incurring costs in order to gain benefit during the estimated
life of the plant assets or current assets in the future. Therefore, investment activities should
evaluated with its factors affecting its decision very carefully. According to Kolb (1968), the
theory of capital budgeting calls for;
7|Page
1. Estimating in terms of a rate of return the benefits expected to result from carrying out a
capital investment project,
2. Estimating the overall cost of capital to the firm (also in terms of a rate)
3. Basing approval of the project up on whether or not the benefits exceed the cost of
capital.
8|Page
a. Identifying Potential Investment Opportunities: The Company has various options for
capital employment on a long-term basis. In the initial stage, the management needs to
analyze the strengths and weaknesses of every project for foreseeing the potential of each
option.
b. Evaluating and Assembling Investment Proposals: In the next step, the management
assembles and compiles all the investment proposals on the grounds of cost, risk
involvement, future profits, return on investment, etc.
c. Decision Making: Now, the company needs to decide as to which investment option it may
select to suit its pocket and yield a high profit for the company in the end.
d. Capital Budgeting and Apportionment: The next step is to classify the investment as per
its duration. The long-term investment is generally considered under capital budgeting. This
step helps in monitoring the performance of an individual investment.
e. Implementation: After the apportioning of the long-term investment, the company comes
into action for the execution of its decision. To avoid complications and excess time-
consumption, the management should lay out a detailed plan of the project in advance.
f. Performance Review: The last but the most crucial step is the follow-up and analysis of the
project’s performance. While the company’s operations are steady, the management needs to
measure and correlate the actual performance with that of the estimated one to figure out the
deviation and take corrective actions for the same.
9|Page
Fig, 1 (https://theinvestorsbook.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/FACBD.jpg)
Capital Structure: The Company’s capital structure, i.e., the composition of shareholder’s funds
and borrowed funds, determines its capital budgeting decisions.
Working Capital: The availability of capital required by the company to carry out day-to-day
business operations influences its long-term decisions.
Capital Return: The management estimates the expected return from the prospective capital
investment while planning the company’s capital budget.
Earnings: If the company has a stable earning, it may plan for massive investment projects on
leveraged funds, but the same is not suitable in case of irregular earnings.
Lending Policies of Financial Institutions: The terms on which financial institutions provide
loans such as interest rates, collateral, duration, etc. contributes to capital budgeting decisions.
Management Decisions: The decision of the management to take a risk and invest funds in
high-value assets or holding some other plan, also determines the capital budgeting of the
company.
Project Needs: The Company needs to consider all the essentials of a new project. In addition,
the means to fulfil the requirements along with the estimate of the related expenses should be
clear.
10 | P a g e
Accounting Methods: The accounting rules, principles and methods of the company is another
factor considered while capital budgeting to frame the reporting of such expenses and revenue to
be generated in the future.
Government Policy: The restrictions imposed and the exemptions allowed by the government
to the companies while investing in capital nature, affects the company’s capital budgeting
decisions.
Taxation Policy: The taxation procedure and policy of the country also influences the long-term
investment decision of the firm since additional capital will be required for such expenses.
Project is Economic Value: The total cost estimated for the long-term investment and the
capacity of the company determines the capital budgeting decisions.
The shorter is the payback period of the project, the more suitable it is for the company.
11 | P a g e
2.6.2Accounting Rate of Return:
The accounting rate of return depicts the future profitability of a project with the help of
accounting information mentioned in financial statements.
The higher is the ARR of the investment proposal, the more preferable it is for the company.
2.6.3Net Present Value (NPV) Method:
Net present value is the discounted cash flow method. It functions on the principle that the
cash inflow from the project will be acquired in a future period when the value of money
will change. Hence, the future cash flow needs to be discounted at present value to compare
the estimate performance with the actual one.
i.e.,
Where, A1, A2, A3 are the cash inflows in consecutive years; k is the cost of capital of the
project; we assume that all the cash outflows are done in the first year (t) and therefore, t=1.
Or,
To denote the Profitability Index in percentage, Profitability Ratio of a new project is
calculated. Its formula is:
Where NPV (LR) is the net present value at a lower rate,NPV (HR) is the net present value
at a higher rate.Analysis: If the IRR≥Co, the project is accepted; but if IRR<Co, the project
is rejected.
2.7 Empirical Review: Capital Budgeting Decision
As indicated in the over view of the chapter of the study section the main point to address in this
study is to assess how capital budgeting decision was practiced in Ambo Mineral water SC
Capital budgeting process involves many activities that ensure the existence of good business
practice in organization. Therefore, the study tried to review and presented empirical research
conducted in capital budgeting practices worldwide and presented as follows:
Lazaridis (2004) argue that companies mostly use capital budgeting techniques for evaluating
projects intended to be launched that leads for companies operation to be profitable. This ensures
the management to commit resources on profitable projects that meet the minimum threshold. In
addition Hornstein & Zhao (2011) indicates that a significant relationship exist between value
enhancing capital budgeting decisions and stronger internal linkage. Moreover, Batra & Verma
(2017) found that corporate practitioners largely follow the capital budgeting practices using
discounted cash flow techniques of net present value and internal rate of return. Non-financial
criteria are also given due consideration in capital budgeting decision.
2.8 Literature Gap
Lazardis (2004) clearly showed the importance of capital budgeting techniques for profitable
operation thereby ensuring the management commits resources on profitable projects only. In capital
budgeting practices, Slagmulder et al. (1995) found that pre-established criterion governs capital
budgeting practices and strategic considerations receive attention in decision-making processes.
Verbeeten (2005) found that firms use advanced capital budgeting practices in case of financial
uncertainties. Concerning efficient utilization of resources Hornstein & Zaho (2011) found that
13 | P a g e
corporate over investment significantly reduced with better information sharing across units. In case
of capital budgeting techniques used Chittenden and Derregia (2013) found that payback period is
the most widely used technique in capital budgeting practices. Contrary to this, finding Anand and
Monoj (2002), Jain, and Yadev (2002) found that the discounted cash flow techniques are more
popular.
As we can see from the above summary, there are serious issues considered in capital budgeting
practices to bring efficient utilization of resources. There is also a contradiction in findings of
different researchers. In addition, these researches done in developed economies and no previous
study is there concerning the subject matter in Ethiopian context. Therefore, this gap derives the
attention of the researcher to engage in assessing the capital budgeting decision of Ambo Mineral
Water SC.
Chapter Three
3. Research Methodology
The research tend to determine check those factors affecting capital budgeting decision in Ambo
Mineral Water SC and will preceded by an extensive literature review. The review embraced
literature on investment appraisal methods and the organization of the investment process. In
particular, it included research into the diffusion of capital budgeting methods and factors
influencing budgeting decision (e.g. Klammer et al., 1991; Graham and Harvey, 2001; Sandahl
and Sjögren, 2003; Brounen et al., 2004; Verbeeten, 2006; Bennouna et al., 2010; Daunfeldt and
Hartwig, 2011).
As previous studies show companies in North America, Asia and Pacific countries most
commonly use DCF methods. DCF methods are less common among companies from Western
Europe and they are not commonly used in the countries of Central and Eastern Europe and
Africa.
14 | P a g e
problem solving, evaluation, and strategy. This detail secured from multiple sources of
information. It allows evidence in order to verify and avoid missing of the data.
In order to get answer to the research questions the researcher used descriptive research design.
Descriptive research includes surveys and fact-finding enquires of different kinds in addition to
case study. The main purpose of descriptive research is description of the state of affairs as it
exists at present and it helps to portray accurately the characteristics of a particular individual,
situation or group. Descriptive research design is appropriate for this study since it is useful
when the problem has been defined specially and where the researcher has certain issue to be
described by respondents about the problem.
15 | P a g e
3.3.1.1 Questionnaire instruments
Data that will collected through questionnaire will be from senior experts who extensively
involve in the preparation of capital budgeting decision as well as from senior managers who
supervises the operation. The questionnaire will developed and refined based on field interviews
with some senior managers in the company. The questionnaire will compose 52 closed ended
questions, which will grouped in to 9-sub sections. The first sub section designed to provide
general information about respondents and the other eight sub sections designed to provide basic
information that can help the researcher to assess how capital budgeting decision conducted at
the company. The questionnaire feedback will also be collected using 5-point likert scale and the
data will analyzed and interpreted using frequency, mean score and standard deviation. Because
of the sensitivity nature of some of the questions that will asked, the level of detail sought, and
the anonymity of the respondents may be occurred in cover letter explaining the purpose of the
study.
In the questioners, five-point Likert scale ranging from strongly disagree (1) to - strongly agree
(5) will be used. The main advantage of likert scale questions is that they use a scale,
respondents will not be forced to express an extreme opinion allowing them to be neutral should
they so choose. The researcher will prefers to use a likert- type scale because it is very easy to
analyze statistically (Jackson, 2009). The questionnaire will also include open-ended questions to
collect other additional relevant data that will be there for the respondents that cannot be
included in the closed ended questionnaires.
16 | P a g e
3.3.1.3 Document sources
Document sources like Capital budget activities documents, policy and procedure guide lines of
capital budget process and strategic plan of the AMW SC for the period covered 2018 to
2019G.C. will used for this analysis purposes. The review will help to gather background
information about the corporation’s capital budgeting work process guideline and how actual
work will conducted. The results of the review work will help the researcher to triangulate results
from questionnaire analysis and it will include in chapter four of the study report.
According to the information obtained from Resource management service of the company
(2019G.C.), the total number of senior managers and experts who directly engaged in the capital
budgeting activities are 27. From the total population of 27 the researcher chooses 15
17 | P a g e
professionals who have extensive work experience on capital budgeting practices. The work
experience level provides advantage in providing relevant and reliable information to the study.
As the study focuses in assessing the capital budget practices of the AMW SC, using purposive
sampling provided chance of getting better information from employees who judged to do so.
The sampled employees were selected based on their regular engagement on preparation of
annual plan (Budget proposal), evaluation of annual plan (Budget proposal), and approval of
annual plan (Budget proposal).
The researcher will exercise due diligence in designing the research work which can provide a
platform on which to conduct the study. In addition, secret of the company must be protected and
the concerned authority acknowledges all data used in the study. The privacy of the people that
will be engaged in providing data will protected securely. Data that will collected through
interview will be included in the report with consent of the interviewee.
Budget
References/Bibliography
References
1.Abigail S. Hornstein & Minyuan Zhao (2011), Corporate Capital Budgeting Decisions and
Information Sharing: Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, pp1135- 1170.
2. Anand & Manoj (2002), CF Practice in India: A survey, Vikalpa, Vol.27, PP 29-56.
3. Antony R.N., Dearden j. & Bedford N (1984) MCS, 5th edition, pp124-128.
4.Arthur J. Keown, John D. Martin, J. William petty & David F. Scott, JR (2003), FMP &
Applications, Prentice Hall of India private limited, New delhi-110001, PP274-277.
5. Burton A.Kolb (1968), Problems and Pitfalls in CB, Investment Management, pp170-175.
6.C.R.Kothari (2004), Research Methodology; Methods and Techniques, 2nd edition, New Age
International Publishers, New Delhi, pp 2-10.
7.David Quirin (1967), The Capital Expenditure Decision, Richard D. Irwin Inc. pp 75-79.
8. Dessalegn Getie Mihret & Getachew Zemeune Woldeyohannes (2008), ‘’ Value added role of
Internal Audit: an Ethiopian case study’’, MAJ, Volume 23 issue: 6,pp 567-595.
9.Donald R.Cooper & C.William Emory (1995), BRM, Irwin McGraw- Hill, 5th edition, pp 114-117.
10. Eric W. Noreen, Peter C. Brewer & Ray H. Garrison (2011), Managerial Accounting for Managers,
2nd edition, McGrawHill, pp535.
11. Hermanson, Edwards & Ivancevich (2011), Accounting Principles: Management Accounting,
A textbook equity open college textbook, Textbook Equity, Inc. pp 280- 289.
12. Gyorgy Andor, Sunil K.Mohanty &Tamas Toth (2015), Capital Budgeting Practices: A survey
of Central and Eastern European Firms, Emerging Markets Review 23, pp 148- 172.
19 | P a g e
13. Ioannis T.Lazaridis (2004), Capital Budgeting Practices; A survey in the firms in Cyprus,
Journal of small business management, pp 427-433.
14. Jackson,S.L.(2009),Research methods and Statistics: A critical thinking approach,3rd
edition,Belmat,CA:Wadsworth,pp.89.
15. Jain, P.K. and Surendra S.Yadav (2002), Financial Management Practices in India, Singapore
& Thiland- A “comparision”. Management & Accounting Research, Vol.3 No.4, PP 55-103.
16. John W. Creswell (2003), Research design: qualitative, quantitative and mixed approach.
United States of America: saga publication.inc.
17. John W. Creswell (2014), Research Design, Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods
Approaches, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, pp 32-35
18. 21. John Miline (2009), Questionnaires: Some advantages and disadvantages, Center for CBL
in land use and environmental sciences, Aberdeen University, pp 52.
19. Lawerence J. Gitman (2008), Principles of managerial finance, 11th edition, Sandi ago State
University, pp 175-189.
20. Machuki Carolyene kemuma (2011), Effects of investment decisions on the performance of
firms listed in the Nairobi securities Exchange.
21. Melles Hagos Tewelde (2007), Investment Decisions in a firm as part of business financial
decision system, Institute of Economics, Illyes Gyula College of the University of Pecs.
22. Michael C. Ehrhardt & Eugene F. Brigham (2011), Financial Management, Theory and
Practice, 13th edition, South-Western Cengage Learning, pp 379-385.
23. M.Y.Khan & P.K Jain (2007), Financial Management, 5th edition, Tata McGraw Hill
education private limited, New Delhi, PP 9.4-9.5 27. Pamela P.Peterson & Frank J. Fabozzi
(2002), Capital Budgeting; Theory and Practice, John Willey & Sons.
24. Paula De Souza & Rogerio Joao Lunkes (2016), Capital Budgeting Practices by large Brazilian
companies, Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Brazil, pp. 526-529. 29. Prasanna Chandra
(2004), FM, Theory and practice, 6th edition, Tata McGraw Hill Publishing Company ltd, pp5
25. Regine Slagmulder,Warner Bruggeman & Luk Van Wassenhoue,(1995), An empirical study of
capital budgeting practices for strategic investments, IJoP Economics, pp. 121-152.
26. Robert K. Yin (2009), Case Study Research; Design and Methods, 4th edition, Applied Social
Research Methods Series, Volume 5, SAGE Publications, Inc. pp10-14.
27. Roopali Batra & Satish Verma (2017), Capital Budg Practices in Indian Companies. pp 29.
20 | P a g e
28. Stefan Debois (2016), Advantages and Disadvantages of questionnaire, SurveyAnyPlace Blog.
29. Stephen A. Ross, Randolph W.Westerfield & Jeffrey Jaffe (1999), Corporate Finance,5th
edition,Irwin Mc Graw Hill,pp154.
30. V.K.Bhalla (2004), Financial Management and Policy, 4 th edition, Anmol Publications
Pvt.Ltd.,New Delhi-110002(India),PP 390-445.
31. Vongai Maroyi (2011), Capital Budgeting Practices: A South African Perspective,
Wageningen University, Department of Social Sciences, pp 10.
32. Ryan P., Ryan G. (2002), Capital budgeting practices of the Fortune 1000: how have things
changed?, „Journal of Business and Management”, vol. 8 (4), pp. 355–364.
33. Sandahl G., Sjögren S. (2003), Capital budgeting methods among Sweden’s largest groups of
companies. The state of the art and comparison with earlier studies, „International Journal of
Production Eco-nomics”, vol. 84 (1), pp. 51–69.
34. Sangster A. (1993), Capital investment appraisal techniques: a survey of current usage,
„Journal of Busi-ness Finance and Accounting”, vol. 20, pp. 307–332.
35. Smith K., Sullivan C. (1990), Survey of Cost Management Systems in Manufacturing,
Working Paper, Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, [after:] Ch.T. Horngren S.M.
Datar, G. Foster (2003), Cost Accounting. A Managerial Emphasis, Prentice Hall.
36. Soni K. (2006), Capital Budgeting Practices in India, Ph.D. Dissertation, Nottingham
University Busi-ness School, University of Nottingham, [after:] M. Ghahremani, A. Aghaie,
M. Abedzadeh (2012), Capital budgeting technique selection through four decades: with a
great focus on real option, „In-ternational Journal and Management”, vol. 7 (17), pp. 98–119.
21 | P a g e