Indian Sociology: Historical Perspectives
Indian Sociology: Historical Perspectives
©Antara Chakrabarty
UGC NTA-NET
Sociology
INDIAN
SOCIOLOGY
TIMELINE
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• WESTERN Sociology:
The Intellectual Revolution embodied in the movement for
Enlightenment, Scientific revolution and Commercial Revolution,
which spanned the period between the 14th and the 18th
centuries, the French Revolution of 1789 and the Industrial
Revolution put a deadly blow to the age-old feudal system
monarchy and the church
• INDIA
• Socio-Political causes: British civil servants, missionaries, and
Western scholars during the eighteenth and nineteenth
centuries.
• Sociology in India was the product of intellectual response of the
Indians to the Western interpretations of Indian society and
culture by the Westerners, mainly after the colonial rule of the
British began in India
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• the ascription of inviolable sanctity to
the ancient texts, it is alleged, inhibited
the growth of critical and independent
thought in later periods.
• The truth is that the ancient texts,
shastras and smritis, despite their
philosophical and metaphysical content,
were not concerned with the eternal
verities of truths only and did not ignore 2
the existential reality of the time. perspectives
• One of the first practical books:
• Treatises like Kautilya’s Arthasastra
(324-296 B.C.) urging upon the king to
take regular census of the subjects Coloniser Indians
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• Among the Arab travelers, Al-Biruni (973-ca 1030) seems to have been
familiar with Sanskrit sources and the Indian systems of thought. He
mentioned the four varna theory of caste in his description of the social
life and customs of the people.
• Ibn Btutta, Arab traveller from Morocco, offered valuable information
regarding the geography of the land, or socio-cultural conditions and daily
life of the people of India between AD 1333 and AD 1347.
• For South India useful information may be obtained from the chronicles of
Marco Polo who visited that part of the country around AD 1293
• In the seventeenth century many translations were made from the
Sanskrit literature into Persian by Indo-Moslem scholars.
• They paved the way for a better understanding of Indian culture and
society Abul Fazl, the author of Ain-i-Akbari which was a late sixteenth
century gazetteer containing description of Akbar’s court, revenue, and
administrative system, was “an empiricist par excellence”
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Colonizer’s
perspectives
• The orientalists were enchanted by the Indian spiritual tradition mythology, philosophy, etc. static, timeless and
space less.
• The missionaries, looked at it as a socio-cultural and ethnic system which needed total religious conversion.
Both the groups agreed that Hinduism as practiced within the realm of their observation was filled with
‘superstition’ and ‘abuses’.
• The administrators sought to develop categories that would help them in ordering their ideas and actions
relating to the life of the natives of India avoiding the enormous complexities characterising it. For example, B.
H. Baden-Powell’s 3 volumes of The Land Systems of British India (1892) contained a series of arguments about
the nature of Indian village and its resources in relation to the state and its demand over these resources.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• Henry Maine’s view that there was only one type of Indian village, viz.,
• politically autonomous and economically selfsufficient village community.
• According to Baden-Powell, there were two distinct types of village in
India:
• (1) “ryotwari” or non-landlord or severalty and
• (2) landlord or joint-village.
• Rise of Educational Institutions [BOMBAY]
• Most notable was the Asiatic society of Bengal founded in 1797 by the world famous Sanskritist and
Indologist, Sir William Jones.
• W.H.R. River’s study of The Todas (1906) was based on intensive field work and was the first
monograph on a people of India in the modern anthropological tradition.
• Two of his students, G. S. Ghurye and K. P. Chottapadhyay came to play a significant role in the
development of sociology and anthropology in India. Rivers’ study was followed by A. R.
RadcliffeBrown’s on The Andaman Islanders
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
•SCOPE of SOCIOLOGY
Formalistic
Synthetic
/Specialist
FORMALISTIC
G. Simmel
Max Weber
Vierkandt
Small
Von Wiese
Tonnies
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Formalistic
• Formalistic or Specialistic School
• The sociologists who belong to the formalistic of specialistics school
believe that sociology deals with various forms of human or social
relations.
• They regard sociology as a pure and independent branch of
knowledge distinct from all social sciences.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
•George Simmel
• George Simmel, a leading German sociologist considers social
science. He feels that it should describe, classify, analyse and
explain the several forms of social relationship.
• It should not be concerned with their contents which are dealt
with by other social sciences. He makes a distinction between
the forms of social relationships and their contents and subject
matter.
• In his view sociology should confine itself to the study of formal
behaviour and avoid the examination of actual behaviour.
• It means that the different forms of social relationship and not
the relationships between themselves, should be the subject of
sociology.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• This view-point turns sociology into a science dealing with the same
topics as other social sciences, but the topics are judged from a
different angle namely, the angle of different forms of social
relationships.
• George Simmel has referred to the several forms of social relationships
such as competition, domination, subordination, division of
labour etc.
• They have an important role to play in different spheres of social life.
The spheres-being economic, political, religious and the like.
• It is an important function of sociology to separate these relationships
from one another and study them in abstraction.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• Vierkandt :
• He maintains that sociology is an independent social
science or a special branch of knowledge. It should
concern itself with the ultimate forms of social or mental
relationships which bind people to one another in society.
• Sociology should not study concrete societies in detail like
history. It should study the irreducible categories of
science which are nothing but ultimate forms of social or
mental psychic relationships.
• These relationships consist in love and hate, attitude of
respect, submission, shame, co-operation, competition,
the approval of others etc, which bind individuals into
groups.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• Max Weber:
• Max Weber an eminent German sociologist expresses his own
view-point on the scope of sociology. He says that the scope of
sociology consists in interpreting or “understanding” social
behaviour. For him social behaviour does not refer to entire field
of human relation.
• He means by social behaviour what we call social activity or
social action. It is related to the behaviour of others and is
determined by them.
• For instance, a bicycle accident is merely a natural phenomenon,
the way in which the bicyclists behave with each other after the
accident in the form of avoiding or using the language reflects
their true social behaviour. Sociology is thus concerned with
fundamental types of social behaviour.
• In other words, sociology should aim at analysing and classifying
the various types of social behaviour or social relationships.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Synthetic School
• The synthetic school of thought holds the view that
sociology is a synthesis of all social sciences.
Emile LT
Durkheim Hobhouse
P. Sorokin
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• Emile Durkheim
• Emile Durkheim, an eminent French sociologist divides
sociology into three principal parts, namely social
morphology, social physiology and general sociology.
• Social morphology has direct reference ,to all those objects
which are basically or fundamentally geographical or
territorial in nature.
• These objects are of many kinds such as the problems of
population, its size, density and local distribution and the
like.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• Hobhouse
• P. Sorokin
• P Sorokin has also expressed his view on the subject-matter
of sociology. According to him, sociology should aim at
studying the relationship that exists between the different
aspects of social phenomena and between the social and
non-social phenomenas. It should study the general features
of social phenomena as well.
• From the foregoing discussions on the scope of sociology it
can be conveniently concluded that the range of this science
is very wide. Sociology is regarded as a general science as well
as a special science. Like all other sciences, the subject-matter
of sociology is society.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Functionalism
• Comte effectively linked sociology with the prestige of biological
science.
• It was Herbert Spencer who used the organismic analogy to create an
explicit form of functional analysis.
• Drawing upon materials from his monumental The Principles of
Biology (1864–1867), Spencer's The Principles of Sociology (1874–
1896) is filled with analogies between organisms and society as well
as between ecological processes (variation, competition, and
selection) and societal evolution (which he saw as driven by war).
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• Malinowski
• Radcliffe Brown
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• Durkheim
• Parsons
• Merton
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Structuralism
Structure-Functionalism Structuralism
• Structural-functional • Structuralism, on the other hand, endeavours to
approach is interested in find the structures of thought and the structure of
finding order within social society.
relations. • Structuralism subscribes to deductive logic. It
• Structural-functional begins with certain premises. They are followed
approach follows inductive carefully to the point they lead to.
reasoning; from the • Aspects from geometry and algebra are kept in
particular, it moves to the mind while working with structuralism.
general • For structuralism, logical possibilities are worked
out first and then it is seen, how reality fits. For
true structuralists, there is no reality except the
relations between things
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
• In The Totemism,
• The binary opposition of nature and culture that evolved in his
kinship study was further developed here. Rejecting the utilitarian
theory of totemism, Lévi-Strauss examined the merits of the second
theory of totemism that Radcliffe-Brown had proposed.
• In The Savage Mind, Lévi-Strauss’s central point was that the
thoughts of the ‘primitive people’ were in no way inferior to those of
the ‘Westerners’.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Post Modernism
• Everything starts with STRUCTURALISM
• REMEMBER the points?
• Universal structure
• Binary opposite
• Dominant form of knowledge system.
Major criticisms
• structuralism did not pay heed to historical processes and is a-historical
• applied the rules of linguistics to societal processes which is a
questionable procedure
• it is assumed that a work has meaning in itself and this persists even
before it is discovered and
• the text is only a conduit between the subject and the structure of
rational.
• The Enlightenment view that the individual is separate and whole and that the
mind is the area where values evolve
• on the other hand the poststructuralists felt that the individual was embedded in
social interaction. Such symbolic beings are referred to by the word “subject”. We
can then say that the subjects are intertwined with society and culture and occupy
some place within them, and sociologically based sites
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Orientalists
History
Occidents
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Antara
Chakrabarty
UGC NTA-NET
SOCIOLOGY
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Waves
First Second Fourth
19th and early 20th 1960s and 1970s Third Internet-
century (equal legal and based
social rights) intersectionality
(Right to vote) movement
s
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
First wave
Second Wave
• Second-wave feminism of the 1960s-1980s focused on issues of
equality and discrimination.
• The second-wave slogan, “The Personal is Political,” identified
women’s cultural and political inequalities as inextricably linked and
encouraged women to understand how their personal lives reflected
sexist power structures.
• Betty Friedan was a key player in second-wave feminism. In 1963, her
book The Feminine Mystique criticized the idea that women could find
fulfillment only through childrearing and homemaking.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Third Wave
• early 1990s,
• responding to perceived failures of the second
wave and to the backlash against second-wave
initiatives.
• second-wave over-emphasized experiences of
upper middle-class white women.
• The third-wave sees women’s lives as
intersectional, demonstrating how race,
ethnicity, class, religion, gender, and nationality
are all significant factors when discussing
feminism.
• It examines issues related to women’s lives on an
international basis.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Fourth-wave
Liberals
Radicals
• Radical feminism views patriarchy and sexism as
the most elemental factor in women’s
oppression – cutting across all others from race
and age to culture, caste and class.
• It questions the very system and ideology
behind women’s subjugation.
• The term often refers to the women’s
movements emerging from the civil rights,
peace and other liberation movements at a time
when people increasingly were questioning
different forms of oppression and power.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Eco-Feminism
• This form of feminism views patriarchy and its focus on control and
domination not only as a source of women’s oppression but as being
harmful to humanity as well as destructive of all living creatures and
the earth itself.
• Combining a more comprehensive analysis of power often with a
greater spiritual vision, eco-feminists see women’s rights and
empowerment linked to political, economic, social and cultural
factors that benefit all living creatures and Mother Nature herself.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Post Moderns
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Standpoint feminism
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Antara
Chakrabarty
UGC NTA-NET
SOCIOLOGY
Telegram channel:
@antarachak
Telegram Channel
Youtube channel:
AntaraSquad
ANTARALIVE
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Quantitative
data
Positivism
Rationalism
Science
Qualitative data
Interpretivis
m
Empiricism
Are our
understandings
and experiences
only limited to
our senses??
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Hermeneutics
• takes a variety of forms but in essence is a means of interpretation,
principally of historical events, phenomena or texts.
• Hermeneutics has been described as the science of interpretation.
• Hermeneutics, although with a history stretching back to the Ancient
Greeks, developed in the Middle Ages as a mechanism for Biblical
understanding.
• It subsequently became transformed into a philosophical and
later sociological form of enquiry and, with the work of
Heidegger
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Subjectivity
Objectivity
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK
Interpretivists
• Sociological theory is often broadly divided
into positivism and interpretivism.
• Interpretivists argue that the study of human society must
go beyond empirical and supposedly objective
evidence to include subjective views, opinions,
emotions, values: the things that can't be directly
observed and counted.
• They are phenomena that require interpretation. Indeed
most interpretivists would go further and suggest that
research cannot really establish social facts, that society is
all about subjective values and interpretations and cannot
be understood just through facts and figures.
For FREE class PDFs Telegram Channel: @antarachak
Referral Code for Plus Subscription: ANTARACHAK