Engineering Economics Learning Module
Engineering Economics Learning Module
Prepared by:
A Self-regulated Learning Module
Engr. Jasmin G. Madayag
Course Description:
Engineering economics is a three-unit course that deals with the analysis and evaluation of the best
use of capital in engineering projects and investment. The concept of money-time relationship and depreciation
will give the students an in-depth understanding in the value of an asset. The basic economy study methods
will help to evaluate alternatives for a certain investment as well as government projects. Decision analysis
models will be discussed to evaluate decision conditions under certainty, risk, and uncertainty. Lastly, the basic
accounting principles will help the future engineers to have knowledge in financial statement of engineering
firm.
Learning Outcome:
At the end of the course, the student shall be able to:
1. Describe the basic principle of engineering economics and apply it to related problems.
2. Apply the money-time relationship and depreciation analysis to tangible assets.
3. Use economy studies to evaluate the best alternatives for engineering problems.
4. Apply a rational decision-making to conditions certainty, risk, and uncertainty.
5. Identify costs component of financial statement in engineering firms.
PROBLEM SOLVING: Solve the problems with complete and neat solutions. Use blue or black ink only in
your answers. Erasures are considered wrong answers. See rubrics for distribution of points.
RUBRIC:
POINT SYSTEM
DESCRIPTION
(per requirement)
Complete solution with correct answer 5
Correct answer with missing solutions 3
Wrong solution or solutions that cannot be understood 1
No solution 0
ESSAY: Answer the following questions comprehensively and neatly. Use blue/black ink only. All answers
must be in engineering lettering. See rubrics for distribution of points.
RUBRIC:
Learning Outcomes:
At the end of this lesson, the students can use the basic concept of engineering economics to
understand economic costs and apply it to real-life problems.
Engineering
The profession in which a knowledge of mathematical and
natural science gained by study, experience, and practice is
applied with judgement to develop ways to utilize
economically the materials and forces of nature for the
benefit of mankind.
Economics
A social science concerned with the production, distribution,
and consumption of goods and services.
Types of Economics
1. Microeconomics – focuses on the behavior of individual
consumers and producers
2. Macroeconomics – focuses on the overall scale of economy
Engineering Economy
It is the analysis and evaluation of the factors that will affect the economic success of engineering
projects to the end that a recommendation can be made which will insure the best use of capital. (Sta.
Maria, Hipolito, 2000)
Consumer goods and services are those goods or services that are directly used by people to satisfy
their needs. Producer goods and services are those goods or services that are used to produce consumer
goods and services.
“Under conditions of perfect competition the price at which a given product will
be supplied and purchased is the price that will result in the supply and the
demand being equal.”
***This law is used to know the actual market price and volume of goods. At
higher prices, the demand is less and the supply of economic good will
increase.
Cost Terminologies
Fixed Cost
Those costs which remain constant whether or not a given change in operations or policy is
adopted.
Increment Cost
Those costs are the result of a change or adjustment in operation or policy.
It is the result of the difference of costs between alternatives.
Marginal Cost
These costs are the additional cost of producing one or more unit of product.
Sunk Cost
These costs are the investment that cannot be recovered for some reasons.
Sunk cost can be solved by SC = Book Value – Resale Value
o (-) Sunk Cost indicates gain
Opportunity Cost
It is incurred because of the use of limited resources such that the opportunity to use those
resources to monetary advantage in an alternative use is foregone.
Direct costs
These are costs that can be reasonably measured and allocated to a specific output or work
activity. Examples are labor and material costs.
Indirect costs
These are costs that are difficult to attribute or allocate to a specific output or work activity.
Examples are the costs of common tools, general supplies, and equipment maintenance.
Overhead cost
It consists of plant operating costs that are not direct labor or direct material costs. Examples
are electricity, general repairs, property taxes and supervision.
Standard costs
These are representative costs per unit of output that are established in advance of actual
production or service delivery.
Learning Outcome:
At the end of the lesson, the students can use the basic concept of present economy studies in the
selection of alternatives.
Sample Problem 1
The bottler of a popular soft drink can purchase glass bottles for Ᵽ 4.00 each or all-aluminum cans for Ᵽ
5.00 each. If the aluminum cans are used, she believes she can achieve a saving of Ᵽ 0.05 per can in shipping
and handling costs, owing to the reduced weight in addition, by setting up a reclamation drive, she believes
that she can recover about 50% of the cans by offering to pay Ᵽ 10.00 per pound for returned cans at four
return centers which she will establish in the area her company serves. The equivalent used cans are 20 per
pounds, and she can sell the used cans to the can manufacturer for Ᵽ 15.00 per pound. She estimates that the
overhead cost of operating the return centers will not exceed 20% of the cost of repurchasing the used cans. In
addition, she believes that she will obtain favorable response from ecology-minded customers. Which type of
beverage container would you recommend that she use?
Given:
Using Glass bottles
Unit Cost of Glass bottle = Ᵽ 4.00
Required:
Cheaper type of beverage container
The glass bottle is cheaper by Ᵽ 0.875 per can, therefore the bottle type of container should be
recommended.
Sample Problem 2
A company finds that, on the average, two of its engineers spend 60 hrs each month in flying time,
using commercial airlines, in making service calls to customers’ plants, always traveling together. It finds that
the cost for airline tickets, airport buses, car rental; and so on, costs approximately Ᵽ 2,000 per person per
month. An air charter service offers to supply a small business jet and pilot on 24-hour notice at a cost of Ᵽ
1,200 per month plus Ᵽ 125 per hour of flying time and Ᵽ 25 per hour for waiting time on the ground at the
destination. It states that experience for similar situations has shown that total travel time will be reduced by
50% by using the charter service.
The company estimates that the cost of car rental at destinations using charter service probably would
amount to about Ᵽ 250 per month and the average “waiting time” is 40 hrs per month. It also estimates that
each engineer’s time is worth Ᵽ 40 per hour to the company, should the charter be used?
Given:
Using the commercial airlines (Include Two Engineers)
Fare cost = Ᵽ 2,000 /person (including airline tickets, buses, car rental)
Flying time = 60 hrs/month
Flying time cost = Ᵽ 40 /hr
Using the air charter
Flying time = 50 % (60 hrs/month)
Flying time cost = Ᵽ 125/hr
Cost of Jet & pilot hire = Ᵽ 1,200 /month
Waiting time Cost= Ᵽ 25 /hr
Average waiting time = 40 hrs/month
Car rental = Ᵽ 250 /month
Required:
Total costs for Air Charter
The total expense for air charter is cheaper by Ᵽ 200 /month than the commercial airlines;
therefore air charter should be used.
Sample Problem 3
The assembly of a certain component for television sets has been done by two skilled workers, each of
whom is paid Ᵽ 40.00 per hour and can produce 10 units per hour (as a group). For the 10 units, one will be
defective and will have to be discarded at a material loss of Ᵽ 25.00. It has been proposed that this operation
could be done by three persons of lesser skill, who would be paid only Ᵽ 35.00 per hour, and who, as a group,
could complete 13 units per hour. It is estimated that the number of defects per hour would not be changed if
this alternative procedure is used. Which procedure would you recommend?
Given:
Two-skilled worker
Labor = Ᵽ 40.00 /hr
Produce units = 10 units /hr (1 out of 10 is defective)
Cost of material loss = Ᵽ 25.00
Three less skilled worker
Labor = Ᵽ 35.00 /hr
Produce units = 13 units /hr (1 out of 13 is defective)
Cost of material loss = Ᵽ 25.00
The second procedure gives the cheaper price per unit than the first procedure; therefore the
second group is to be recommended.
II. Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
Problem: An executive receives an annual salary of ₱ 600,000 and his secretary a salary of ₱180,000. A
certain task can be performed by the executives working alone in 4 hours. If he delegates the task to his
secretary it will require him 30 minutes to explain the work and another 45 minutes to check the finished work.
Due to the unfamiliarity of the secretary to the task, it takes her an additional time of 6 hours after being
instructed. Considering salary cost only, determine the cost of performing the task by each method, if the
secretary work 2,400 hours a year and the executive 3,000 hours a year.
Topics:
Simple Interest
Compound Interest
Continuous Compounding
Discount
Inflation
Annuity
Perpetuity
Capitalized Cost
Gradient Series
Learning Outcomes:
At the end of the lesson, the students should be able to:
1. Understand the concept of money-time relationship.
2. Apply the concept by solving engineering problems.
3. Know the application of this relationship to real life situation.
Interest
It is the amount of money paid for the use of borrowed capital or the income produced by money which
has been loaned.
Simple Interest
It is one way to calculate interest for a short-term loan or investment.
It is calculated using the principal only in days.
(1) Ordinary Simple Interest, (2) Exact Simple interest
Interest, I = Pni
Future Amount, F = P + I = P + Pni = P (1+ni)
Where:
P – Principal amount
n – Number of interest periods
i – Rate of interest per interest period
Types of Simple Interest
1. Ordinary Simple Interest
The interest is based on 30 days in each month.
1 interest period = 360 days/year
Sample Problem 1
A man borrowed ₱ 100,000 and promised to pay after 5 months at a simple interest of 8%. How much
is the ordinary simple interest?
Given:
Interest, I
Solution 1: (Converting n in days)
Calculate the total number of days, n = 5 mo x 30 days/mo = 150 days
Then substitute in the formula:
I = Pni
I = ₱ 100,000 x (150 days/360 days/yr) x 0.08
I= ₱ 3,333.33
Sample Problem 2
Determine the ordinary simple interest on P700 for 8 months and 25 days if the rate of interest is 15%.
Given:
P = ₱ 700 i = 15% n = 8 months and 25 days
Required:
Interest, I
Solution:
Number of days, n= (8) (30) + 15= 255 days
255
I = Pni = P700 x x 0.15
360
Interest, I = P74.38
Sample Problem 3
A loan of ₱ 2000 is made for a period of 13 months, from January 1 to January 31 the following year, at
simple interest of 20%. What is the future amount is due at the end of the loan period?
Given:
P = ₱ 2000 i = 20% n = 13 months
Required:
Future amount, F
Solution:
F = P(1 + ni)
255
F = ₱ 2000 [1 + 360
)(0.20)]
F = ₱ 2,433.33
Given:
P = ₱ 100,000
i = 8%
n = Sep. 18, 1898 – Feb. 28, 1899
Required:
Interest, I
Solution:
September 18-30 = 12
October = 31
November = 30
December = 31
January = 31
February = 18
Total = 153 days
Sample Problem 2
Determine the exact simple interest on P500 for the period from January 10 to October 28, 1996 at
16% interest.
Given:
P = ₱ 100,000
i = 8%
n = Sep. 18, 1898 – Feb. 28, 1899
Required:
Interest, I
Solution:
Jan 10-31 = 21 (excluding Jan 10)
February = 29
March =31
April =30
May =31
June =30
July =31
August =31
September =30
October = 28 (including Oct.28)
Total = 292 days
292
Exact simple interest =₱ 500
366 (0.16)
2. Arrows represent cash flow and are place at the specified period. If distinctions are needed to be made,
downward arrows represent cash outflows (expenditures, disbursements) and upward arrows
represents cash inflows (income).
3. Depends on the person’s viewpoint. Unless otherwise indicated, all such cash flows are considered
to occur at the end of their respective periods.
Example: A loan of 100 at simple interest of 10% will become P150 after 5 years.
P100
0 1 2 3 4 5
P150
Cash flow diagram on the viewpoint of the borrower
1. Single Cash Flows: The simplest case involves the equivalence of a single cash present amount
and its future worth. Thus, the single-cash flow formula deal with only two amounts: the single
present amount P, and its future worth F.
2. Equal Uniform Series: Probably the most familiar category includes transactions arranged as a
series of equal cash flows at regular intervals, known as an equal-payment series (or uniform series)
3. Linear Gradient Series consists of cash flows that increase or decrease by uniform amount each
periods.
4. Geometric Gradient Series consist of cash flows that increase or decrease by a fixed percentage.
5. Irregular Series consists of cash flows that change with no pattern.
Compound Interest
It is an interest that is earn from the principal and the accumulated interest.
Where:
n – Number of interest periods
i – Rate of interest per interest period
0 1 2 3 n
F
Cash flow diagram for compound interest (Borrower’s Viewpoint)
Derivation of Formula
F = P (1+i)n
The quantity (1+i)nis commonly called the “single payment compound amount factor” and is designed
by the functional symbol F/P, i%, n. Thus,
F = P (F/P, i%, n)
The symbol F/P, i% n is read as “F given P at per cent in n interest period.” From Equation (2-3),
P = F(1+i)-n
The quantity (1-i)-nis called the “single payment present worth factor” and is designated by the
functional symbol P/F, i% ,n. Thus,
P = F (P/F i% n)
The symbol P/F, i%, n is read as “P given F at i percent in n interest periods.”
Sample Problem
A P2000 loan was originally made 8% simple interest for 4 years. At the end of this period th loan was
extended for 3 years, without the interest being paid, but the new interest rate was made 10% compounded
semi annually. How much should the borrower pay at the end of the 7 years?
Solution:
Rate of Interest
is defined as the amount earned by one unit of principal during a unit of time
If the nominal rate o interest is 10%compounded quarterly, then i= 10%/4= 2.5%, the rate of interest per
interest period.
Sample Problem
The sum of P10, 000 was deposited to a fund earning interest 10% per annum compounded quarterly,
what was the principal in the fund at the end of a year?
Given:
P = 10,000
r= 10% per year compounded quarterly
n= 3 years (4) = 12 quarters
Required:
The amount in the fund at the end of 3 years
Solution:
Solving for the rate of interest per period,
� 10
i= =
� 12
i = 2.5% per quarter
Sample Problem 1
Consider, one unit of principal for one unit a time invested in a nominal interest of 12% compounded
For two or more nominal rates to be equivalent, their corresponding effective rates must be equal:
Nominal rate Effective rate
�
r% compounded quarterly 1 + 4 -1
4
0.12
12% compounded monthly 1+ -1
12
12
� 4
1+ − 1 = 1(0.01)12-1
4
�
1 + 4= (1.01)3 =1.0303
Sample Problem 3
A loan of P10,000 for 3 years at 10% simple interest per year. Determine the interest earned and the
Given:
P = P10,000
n = 3 years
i = 10% per year
Required:
a. Total Interest, I
b. Accumulated amount, F
Solution:
a. The total interest earned:
I = Pni
I = P10,000 (3 years) (0.1/year)
I = P3,000.00
Amortization Schedule
- A table showing the mode of payment.
Equation of Value
If cash flows occur on different periods, comparison of such should be made on a same focal date.
Equation of values is obtained by setting the sum of one set of obligation on a certain comparison or focal date
equal to the sum of another set of obligation on the same date.
An equation of value is obtained by setting the sum of the values on a certain comparison or focal date
of one set of obligations equal to the sum of the values on the same date of another set of obligations.
Application of Compound Interest
Deposits ------- withdrawals
Loans ---------- repayments
Investment ---- income
Cash inflow --- cash outflow
Sample Problem
A man bought a lot worth ₱1,000,000 if paid in cash. On the installment basis, he paid a down payment
of ₱20,000; ₱300, at the end of one year, ₱400, at the end of three years and a final payment at the end of five
0 1 2 3 4 5
₱300,000
300,000(P/F,20%,1)
₱400,000
₱400,000(P/F,20%,3) Q5
Q(P/F,20%,5)
Where:
r = nominal rate of interest per year
�
�
= rate of interest per period
m = number of interest periods per year
n = number of interest periods in n years
m
Let r
= k, then m = rk, as m increases so must k
� 1 rkn 1 k rn
1+� mn
= 1+ = 1+
� �
� k
The limit of 1 + � as k approaches infinite is e
1 k rn rn
1+ =e
�
Sample Problem
Compare the accumulated amounts after 5 years of P1,000 invested at the rate of 10% per year
compounded (a) annually, (b) semiannually, (c) quarterly, (d) monthly, I daily, and (f) continuously.
Given:
P = ₱ 1,000
n = 5 years
Required:
Future amount, F
Solution:
Using the formula, F = P(1+i)nm
(a) F = ₱ 1,000 (1+0.10)5(1) = ₱ 1,610.51
0.10 2(5)
(b) F = ₱ 1,000 1 + = ₱ 1,628.89
2
0.10
(c) F = ₱ 1,000 1 + 4 4(5)
= ₱ 1,638.62
0.10
(d) F = ₱ 1,000 1 + 12(5)
= ₱ 1,645.31
12
0.10
(e) F = ₱ 1,000 1 + 365(5)
= ₱ 1,628.89
365
(f) F = Pern = ₱ 1,000e(0.10x5) = ₱ 1,648.72
1. If you borrow money from your friend with simple interest of 12%, find the present worth of ₱ 20,000,
which is due at the end of nine months.
2. By the condition of a will, the sum of ₱ 25,000 is left to be held in trust by her guardian until it amounts
to ₱ 45,000. When will the girl receive the money if the fund is invested at 8% compounded quarterly?
3. A debt of ₱ 80,000 is to be paid after 6 years at an interest rate of 4% compounded monthly. Find the
amount to be paid after 6 years.
4. Convert 12% compounded quarterly per year into compounded semi-annually per year.
5. A man borrowed ₱ 75,000 on September 18, 1898 and promised to pay on May 17, 1904 at a simple
interest of 12% per annum. How much will be the total interest?
1. A man wishes his son to receive ₱ 200,000 ten years from now. What amount should he invest if it will
earn interest of 10% compounded annually during the first 5 years and 12% compounded quarterly
during the next 5 years?
2. At a certain interest rate compounded semiannually ₱ 5,000 will amount to ₱20,000 after 10
years. What is the amount at the end of 15 years?
3. Jones Corporation borrowed ₱ 9,000 from Brown Corporation on Jan. 1, 1978 and ₱ 12,000 on Jan. 1,
1980. Jones Corporation made a partial payment of ₱ 7,000 on Jan. 1, 1981. It was agreed that the
balance of the loan would be amortized by two payments one of Jan. 1, 1982 and the other on Jan. 1,
1983, the second being 50% larger than the first. If the interest rate is 12%. What is the amount of each
payment?
4. How long will it take the money to double itself if invested at 4% compounded annually?
5. If ₱ 5,000 shall accumulate for 10 years at 8% compounded quarterly. Find the compounded
interest at the end of 10 years.
6. In how many years is required for ₱ 2,000 to increase by ₱ 3,000 if interest at 12%
compounded semi-annually?
7. A loan was made 3 years and 4 months ago at 6% simple interest. The principal amount of the
loan has just been repaid along with ₱ 800 of interest. Compute the principal amount of the
original loan.
8. You loan from a firm an amount of ₱100,000 with a rate of simple interest of 20%, but the
interest was deducted from the loan at the time the money was borrowed. If at the end of one
year, you have to pay the full amount of ₱100,000, what is the actual rate of interest?
Sample Problem
A man borrowed ₱5,000 from a bank and agreed to pay the loan at the end of 9 months. The bank
discounted the loan and gave him ₱4,000 in cash. (a) What was the rate of discount? (b) What was the rate of
interest? (c) What was the rate of interest for one year?
Given:
P = ₱5,000
F = ₱4,000
n = 9 mo
Required:
a) d, b) i, c) i for 1 year
Solution:
�������� �1,000
(a) d = = = 0.20 or 20%
��������� � 5,000
� 0.20
(b) i = = = 0.25 or 25%
1−� 1−0.20
Another solution,
�������� �1,000
i= = = 0.25 or 25%
������� ����ℎ (� 4,000)
� �1,000
(c) i =
��
= 9 = 0.3333 or 33.33%
(� 4,000)
12
Inflation
Inflation is the increase in the prices for goods and services from one year to another, thus decreasing
the purchasing power of money.
FC = PC (1+ f)n
In an inflationary economy, the buying power of money decrease as cost increase. Thus,
�
F=
1+� �
If interest is being compounded at the same time that inflation is occurring. The future worth will be
�(1+�)� 1+� n
F= =P
(1+�)� 1+�
where:
P = present worth of a commodity
F = future worth of the same commodity
f = annual inflation
n = number of years
Sample Problem 1
An economy is experiencing inflation at the annual rate of 8%. If this continuous, what will ₱1000 be
worth two years from now, in terms of today’s peso?
Given:
f = 8%
P = ₱ 1000
n = 2 years
Required:
Future Worth, F
Solution:
� �1000
F= � =
(1+�) (1+0.08)�
F = ₱857.34
Sample Problem 2
A man invested ₱10,000 at an interest rate of 10% compounded annually. What will be the final amount
of his investment, in terms of today’s pesos, after five years, if inflation remains the same at the rate of 8% per
year?
Given:
P = ₱ 10,000
i = 10%
r = 8%
n = 5 years
Required:
Future Amount, F
ANNUITY
An annuity is a series of equal payments made at equal intervals of time. Financial activities like
installment payments, monthly rentals, life-insurance premium, monthly retirement benefits, are familiar
examples of annuity.
1. Ordinary Annuity
An ordinary annuity is a series of payment which starts at the end of each year until a definite
period of time.
0 1 2 3 n-1 n
A A A A A
A(P/F,i%,1)
A(P/F,i%,2)
A(P/F,i%,3)
A(P/F,i%,n-1)
A(P/F,i%,n)
Pi =A – A (1+i)-n
The quantity in brackets is called the “uniform series present worth factor” and is designated by the
functional symbol P = A (P/A, i%, n), read as “P given A at I percent in the interest periods. “
0 1 2 3 n-1 n
A A A A A
A(F/P,i%,1)
A(F/P,i%,n-3)
A(F/P,i%,n-2)
A(F/P,i%,n-1)
Fi = -A + A (1+i) n
The quantity in brackets is called “Uniform series compound amount factor” and is designated by the
functional symbol F/A, i%, n, read as “F given at I percent in n interest period.”
Finding A When F is Given
Taking Equation and solving for A, we have
�
A=F �
1+� −1
F = ₱203,037.00
Sample Problem 2
What is the present worth of P500 deposited at the end of every three months for 6years if the interest
rate is 12% compounded semiannually?
Given:
P = ₱ 500
n = 6 years
m=2
i = 12% CS
Required:
Present Worth, P
Solution:
Solving for the interest rate per quarter,
2
(1+i) 4 – 1 = 1 + 0.12
2 –1
1 + i = (1.06) .5
i = 0.0296 or 2.96% per quarter
P = A (P/A, 2.96%, 24)
1−(1+0.0296)−24
= ₱500
0.0296
= ₱500 (17.0087)
P = ₱ 8,504.00
Sample Problem 3
Today, you invest ₱100,000 into a fund that pays 25% interest compounded annually. Three years later,
you borrow ₱50,000 from a bank at 20% annual interest and invest in the fund. Two years later, you withdraw
enough money from the fund to repay the bank loan and all interest due on it. Three years from this withdrawal
you start taking ₱20,000 per year out of the fund. How much was withdrawn?
Withdrawal
₱50,000(1.20)2 (F/P, 25%, 7)
₱50,000(1.20)2
₱20,000(F/25%, 5)
₱20,000 each
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
₱50,000
₱50,000 (F/P, 25%, 9)
₱100,000
₱100,000 (F/P, 25%, 12)
Investment
Using 12 years from today as the focal date, the equation of value is
Q + P20,000 (F/A, 25%, 5) + P50,000 (1.20)2(F/P, 25%, 7) = P100,000 (F/P, 25%, 12) + P50,000 (F/P, 25%, 9)
(1+.25)5−1
Q + P20,000 + P50,000 (1.20)2 (1.25)7 = P100,000 (1.25)12 + P50,000 (1.25)9
.25
Q + P20,000 (8.2070) + P50,000 (1.20)2(4.7684) = P100,000(14.5519)+P50,000 (7.4506)
Q = P1,320,255
Sample Problem 4
A debt of P5,000 with interest at 12% compounded semi-annually is to be amortized by equal semi-annual
payments over the next 3 years, the first due in 6 months. Find the semi-annual payment and construct an
amortization schedule.
Solution:
� �5,000
A =� = 1−(1.06)−6
= ₱ 1,016.81
, 6%,6
� .06
Amortization Schedule
m periods n periods
0 1 2 n-1 n
0 1 2 m
A A A A
A (P/A,i%,n) (P/F,i%,n) A (P/A,i%,n)
Sample Problem 1
On the day his grandson was born, a man deposited to a trust company a sufficient amount of money
so that the boy could receive five annual payments of P80,000 each for his college tuition fees, starting with his
18th birthday. Interest at the rate 12% per annum was to be paid on all amounts on deposit. There was also a
provision that the grandson could select to withdraw no annual payments and received a single lump amount
on his 25th birthday. The grandson chose this option.
(a)How much did the boy received as the single payments?
(b)How much did the grandfather deposit?
Solution:
Let P=the amount deposited
X=the amount withdrawn
X
P80,000 P80,000 P80,000 P80,000 P80,000
The P80,000 supposed withdrawals are represented by broken lines, since they did not actually occur.
Three separated cash flows diagrams can be drawn.
(a)
X
P80,000 (F/A, 12%, 5) ₱80,000(F/A,12%,5)(F/P,12%,3)
P80,000P80,000P80,000P80,000P80,000
17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
(b)
₱ 80,000(P/A,12%,5)(P/F,12%,17) ₱80,000(P/A,12%,5)
P80,000
0
17 18 19 20 21 22
A A A A
₱10,000
₱10,000(P/A, 14%, 9)
1−(1+.14)−8 1−(1+.14)−9
A (1+.14)-9 = P10,000
.14 .14
A (4.63886) (0.30751) = P10,000 (4.94637)
A = P34,675
3. Annuity Due
An annuity due is series of uniform cash flows that occur at the beginning of each period
Finding P When A is Given
P
0 1 2 3 n-1 n
1−(1+�)−(�−1)
P=A +A
�
1−(1+�)−(�−1)
P=A � + 1
A A A A A
1−(1+�)−(�−1)
F=A -A
�
(1+�)(�+1)−1
F=A � − 1
Sample Problem
A certain property is being sold and the owner received two bids. The first bidder offered to pay
P400,000 each year for 5 years, each payment is to be made at the beginning of each year. The second bidder
offered to pay P240,000 first year, P360,000 the second year and P540,000 each year for the next years, all
payments will be made at the beginning of each year. If money is worth 20% compounded annually, which did
should the owner of the property accept?
Solution:
First bid
P1
0 1 2 3 4 5
1−(1+.20)−4
= P400,000 1 +
.20
= P 400,000 (3.5887)
P1 = P1,435,480
Second bid
P2
240,000
360,000
1−(1+.20)−3
= P240,000 + P360,000 (1+.20)-1 + P540,000 (1+.20)-1
.20
=P240,000 + 360,000(0.8333) + P540,000 (2.1065)(0.8333)
P2 =P1,487,875
The owner of the property should accept the second bid.
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. Mr. J dela Cruz borrowed money from a bank. He received from the bank ₱ 1,340.00 and
promised to pay ₱ 1,500.00 at the and of 9 months. Determine the following:
a. Simple interest rate.
b. Banker’s discount.
2. Mr. Reyes borrows ₱ 600,000 at 12% compounded annually, agreeing to repay the loan in 15
equal annual payments. How much of the original principal is still unpaid after he has made the
8th payment?
3. What is the future worth of ₱ 600 deposited at the end of every month for 4 years if the interest
is 12% compounded quarterly?
4. Find the difference between the sums of an annuity due and an ordinary annuity for the
following data:
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. A bill for motorboat specifies the cost as ₱ 1,200 due at the end of 100 days but offers a 4% discount
for cash in 30 days. What is the highest rate, simple interest at which the buyer can afford to borrow
money in order to take advantage of the discount?
2. Calculate the present worth of the money if the ₱ 300.00 is invested at the end of each year for 8 years
and the first payment was made 3 years from now. Use an annual interest rate of 8%.
3. Determine the accumulated amount of an annuity consisting of 6 payments of ₱12,000.00 each, the
payments are made at the beginning of each year. Money is worth 15% compounded annually.
6. A man deposits ₱ 50,000 in a bank account at 6% compounded monthly for 5 years. If the
inflation rate of 6.5% per year continues for this period, will this effectively protect the
purchasing power of the original principal?
7. A man borrowed a sum of money and promised to pay annually for 8 years at an interest rate
of 12% compounded annually. If the total interest for his debt will be ₱ 185,000 after 8 years,
how much will his annual payments be?
Perpetuity
Perpetuity is a series of uniform cash flows where they extend indefinitely.
P
0 1 2 3 n→∞
A A A
Cash flow diagram to find P given A
The expression (1 + i)−∞ approaches o when n approaches infinity. Thus, the present worth of perpetuity
becomes;
�
P= �
(Ordinary Perpetuity)
�
P= �
(1 + i)-m (Deferred Perpetuity)
Where :
m = deferred period
Sample Problem
What amount of money invested today at 15% interest can provide the following scholarship: ₱30,000
at the end of each year for 6 years; ₱40,000 for the next years and ₱50,000 thereafter?
Given: F11 - ∞ = ₱50,000
Required:
i = 15%
Present worth, P
F6 = ₱30,000
F10 = ₱40,000
Solution:
�50,000 � �50,000
, 15%, 12
0.15 � 0.15
P40,000(P/A,15%,6)(P/F,15%,6)P40,000(P/A,15%,6)
P50,000 P50,000
P30,000(P/A,15%,6)(P/F, 15%, 6) P40,000P40,000P40,000
0 1 2 6 7 8 12 13 14
Where:
FC = first cost (initial investment)
PO&M= Present worth of all perpetual operation and maintenance cost
Sample Problem
Determine the capitalized cost of a structure that requires an initial investment of ₱10,000,000 and an
annual maintenance of ₱950,000. i = 15%
Given:
FC = ₱10,000,000
Annual maintenance = ₱950,000 i = 15%
Solution:
₱950,000 ₱950,000
0 1 2
P
� �950,000
P = = = ₱6,333,334.00
� 0.15
0 1 2 3 k-1 k
Xi Xi Xi Xi Xi
A A A S S S
0 1 2 3 0 1 2 3
P X
� �
P= X =
� (1+�)� −1
P is the amount invested now at i% per period whose interest at the end of every period forever is A
while X is the amount invested now at i% per period whose interest at the end of every k periods forever is S. If
k = 1, then X = F.
Replacement cost
Let: X = present worth of perpetual replacement
S = amount of replacement
K = replacement period or the life of the property
Sample Problem
A new engine was installed by a textile plant at a cost of P300,000 and projected to have a useful life of
15 years. At the end of its useful life, it is estimated to have a salvage value of P30,000. Determine its
capitalized cost if interest is 18% compounded annually.
0 15 30 45
0 15 30 45
Sample Problem
Determine the capitalized cost of a research laboratory which requires P5,000,000 for original
construction; P100,000 at the end of every year for the first 6 years and then P120,000 each year thereafter for
operating expenses, and P500,000 every 5 years for replacement of equipment with interest at 12% per
annum?
Solution:
P120,000 P P120,000
, 12%, 6
.12 F .12
P100,000P100,000P100,000P100,000P100,000P100,000
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Replacement:
P500,000 P500,000 P500,000
X
Let X = the present worth of cost of perpetual replacement
� �500,000
X = = = P655,873.88
(1+�)� −1 (1+.12)5 −1
Capitalized cost = First cost + Q + X
= P5,000,000 + P917,740 + P655,873.88
CC = P6,573,613.88
Gradient Series
Gradient series is the series of cash flow where the amounts change every period.
Some problems involve cash flows that are projected to increase or decrease by a uniform amount
each period, thus constituting an arithmetic sequence of cash flows.
Sample Problem
Engr. Jay wants to marry his girlfriend after 4 years so he invested in a mutual fund that gives 14%
compounded quarterly. If his first deposit is ₱ 10,000 at the end of the first quarter, ₱15,000 at the end of the
2nd quarter and increases by ₱5,000 at the end of every quarter, what is the calculated present worth of the
investment?
Given: G = ₱5,000
i = 14% CQ Required:
Q1 = ₱ 10,000 Present Worth, P
Q2 = ₱ 15,000
P = PA + PG
1 2 3 4 5 14 15 16
₱ 10,000.00
₱ 15,000.00
₱ 20,000.00
₱ 25,000.00
₱ 30,000.00
₱ 75,000.00
₱ 80,000.00
₱ 85,000.00
PA
1 2 3 4 5 14 15 16 +
=
A = ₱ 10,000.00
PG
1 2 3 4 5 14 15 16
G = ₱ 5,000.00
2G 3G 4G
13G
14G
(n-1)G
Using equation of value, “0” as focal date:
P(1 + 0.14)0 = ₱10,000(1 + 0.14)-1 + ₱15,000(1 + 0.14)-2 + ₱20,000(1 + 0.14)-3 + ₱25,000(1 + 0.14)-4 +
₱30,000(1 + 0.14)-5 + …. + ₱85,000 (1 + 0.14)-16
P = ₱ 216,178.93
0
A Self-regulated Learning Module 45
1 2 3 … n
.
�1 �2 �3
�1 = the amount of first cash flow
�2 = A1 + A1f = A1 (1+f)
�3 = A1 ( 1+f )2
�4 = A1 (1+f) n-1
1+�
Icr = −1
1+�
1+�
��� − 1
1+�
P=A1 (1+iCR)-1 [(1+iCR)-1 + (1+iCR)-2 + … (1+iCR)-n]
Simplifying:
�1 1+(1+�)�
P= [ ]
(1+�) �
C(1+r)n-1 C(1+r)n-2
C(1+r) 2
C(1+r)
C
0 1 2 3 n-1 n
P F
� 1−� � 1−� �
P = F = C (1+i)n-1
1+� 1−� 1−�
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
P=? i=12% , r = 10%
Solution:
1+� 1 + .10 55
x= = =
1+� 1+.12 56
5 55
�1,000 (1− 56)
P = = P4,307.67
1+.12 (1− 55)
56
(1− 55
56
)5
F = P1,000 (1+.12) 5-1
(1.12)3 = P10,665.63
(1− 55
56
)
Sample Problem 2
P10,000
P9,920
P9,126.4 P8,306.29
P7,724.58 P7,106.62
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
i = 10% , r = 8%
P=? F=?
Solution:
6 46
�10,000 (1− 45 )
P = 46 = ₱ 36,540.47
1+.10 (1− )
45
(1− 46
45
)6
F = P10,000 (1+.10) 6-1
= ₱ 64,733.67
(1− 46
45
)
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. A contract has been signed to lease a building at ₱ 20,000 per year with an annual increase of ₱ 1,500
for 8 years. Payments are to be made at the end of each year, starting one year from now. The
prevailing interest rate is 7%. What lump sum paid today would be equivalent to the 8-year lease
payment plan?
2. Find the present value of perpetuity of ₱ 2,000 payable every month. If money is worth 20%
compounded monthly and the first payment starts at the end of 5th month.
3. The first cost of certain equipment bought by Kartahira Construction is Ᵽ324, 000 and has a
salvage value of Ᵽ50, 000 at the end of its life of 4 years. If money is worth 6% annually,
compute:
a. Capitalized cost
b. If there is no salvage value and the annual maintenance cost is Ᵽ18, 000, find the capitalized
cost.
4. The maintenance of room air conditioner is expected to be Ᵽ2, 000 at the end of the first year
and is expected to increase by Ᵽ100 each year for the following 7 years. Assuming rate of
interest is 6%, compute the equivalent uniform annual maintenance cost.
5. It costs ₱ 50,000 at the end of each year to maintain a section of Kennon road in Baguio City. If money
is worth 10%, how much would it pay to spend immediately to reduce the annual cost to ₱ 10,000?
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
3. An equipment has a first cost of ₱ 324,000 and a salvage value of ₱ 50,000 at the end of its life of 4
years. If money is worth 4% compounded annually, find the capitalized cost.
4. A new equipment worth ₱ 500,000 with a salvage value of ₱ 50,000 must be replaced at the end of
each 10 years. If the annual maintenance required is ₱ 10,000, find the capitalized cost if money yields
5%.
5. Deposits are made to an account as indicated in the table below which bears interest at the rate of 10%
compounded annually. How much will there be in the account at the end of the sixth year?
Lesson 4 – Depreciation
Learning Outcomes:
At the end of the lesson, the students should be able to:
1. Understand the concept and methods of depreciation.
2. Solve engineering problems using the methods of depreciation.
Depreciation
It is the decrease in the value of physical property with the passage time. (Sta. Maria, H.)
Purpose of Depreciation:
1. To provide for the recovery of capital which has been invested in physical property
2. To enable the cost of depreciation to be charged to the cost of producing products or services that
result from the use of the property. Depreciation cost is deductable in computing profits on which
Types of Depreciation
1. Normal Depreciation
a. Physical – a less in value of a property due to the lessening of the physical ability of a property
to produce results.
Common causes: Wear and deterioration
b. Functional - a less in value of a property due to the lessening in the demand for the function
which the property designed to render.
Common causes: Inadequacy, changes in styles, Efficiency of machine
Terminologies in Depreciation:
Value – the present worth of all future profits that are to be received through ownership of a particular
property.
Book Value – the original cost basis of the property including any adjustments, less all allowable
depreciation deductions.
Market Value – the amount paid to a willing seller by a willing buyer of an asset.
Fair Value – the value which is usually determined by a disinterested third party in order to establish a
fair price to both seller and buyer.
Salvage Value or Resale Value – the estimated price of the property at the end of its life.
Scrap Value – the worth of the property as junk
Usual Life – the number of years as an asset’s recovery
Utility or Use Value – the worth of the property to the owner as an operating unit
Recovery period – the anticipated period of a property’s life
Methods in Depreciation
1. Historical Methods
1. The Straight Line Method
2. The Sinking Fund Formula
3. Declining Balance Method
4. Double Declining Balance Method
5. The Sum-of-the-Year’s Digits (SYD) Method
A. Historical Methods
Problem: The cost of equipment is Php 500,000 and the cost of installation is Php 30,000. If the salvage value
is 10% of the cost of equipment at the end of 5 years, determine the book value at the end of the fourth year
using the straight line method.
Given:
First Cost, CO= ₱ 500,000 + ₱ 30,000= ₱ 530,000
Salvage value, CL = 0.10 (₱ 500,000) = ₱ 50,000
L = 5 years
Required:
Book Value at the end of 4 years (C4)
Solution:
I. Using Formula
Annual depreciation, d = 530,000 – 50,000
5
d = ₱ 96,000
Problem: A certain machinery costs Php 50,000 last 12 years with a salvage value of Php 5,000. The money
is worth 5%. If the owner decided to sell it after using it for 5 years, what should his price be so that he will not
lose or gain financially in the transaction? Use sinking fund method of depreciation.
Given:
First Cost, Co= Php 50,000
L = 12 years
i = 5%
n = 5 years
Required:
Book Value at the end of 5 years, C5
Solution:
Annual depreciation, d = (50,000 – 5, 000) (0.05) = Ᵽ 2,827.14
(1 + 0.05)12 -1
Salvage value,
Rate of depreciation,
Problem: A certain office equipment has a first cost of Php 20,000 and a salvage value of Php 1,000 at the
end of 10 years. Determine its book value at the end of 6 years using declining balance method.
Given:
First Cost, Co = Php 20,000
Salvage Value, CL = Php 1,000
L = 10 years
n = 6 years
Required:
Book Value at the end of 6 years, C6
Solution:
I. Using Formula
Salvage value,
Problem: An equipment costs Php 500,000 and has a salvage value of Php 25,000 after its 25 years of useful
life. Using double declining balanced method, what will be the book value of the equipment at the end of 8
years?
Given:
First Cost, Co = ₱ 500,000
Salvage Value, CL = ₱ 25,000
L = 25 years
n = 8 years
Required:
Book Value at the end of 8 years, C8
Solution:
I. Using Formula
2 2
�= = = 0.08
� 25
YEAR BOOK VALUE AT THE DEPRECIATION DURING BOOK VALUE AT THE END
BEGINNING OF YEAR THE YEAR OF YEAR
1 Ᵽ 500,000 Ᵽ 500,000 (0.08) = Ᵽ 500,000 - Ᵽ 40,000 =
Ᵽ 40,000 Ᵽ 460,000.00
2 Ᵽ 460,000 Ᵽ 460,000 (0.08) = Ᵽ 460,000 - Ᵽ 36,800 =
Ᵽ 36,800 Ᵽ 423,200
3 Ᵽ 423,200 Ᵽ 423,200 (0.08) = Ᵽ 423,200- Ᵽ 33,856 =
Ᵽ 33,856 Ᵽ 389,344
4 Ᵽ 389,344 Ᵽ 389,344 (0.08) = Ᵽ 389,344 - Ᵽ 31,147.52 =
Ᵽ 31,147.52 Ᵽ 358,196.48
5 Ᵽ 358,196.48 Ᵽ 358,196.48 (0.08) = Ᵽ 358,196.48 - Ᵽ 28,655.72=
Ᵽ 28,655.72 Ᵽ 329,540.76
6 Ᵽ 329,540.76 Ᵽ 329,540.76 (0.08) = Ᵽ 329,540.76 - Ᵽ 26,363.26 =
Ᵽ 26,363.26 Ᵽ 303,177.50
7 Ᵽ 303,177.50 Ᵽ 303,177.50 (0.08) = Ᵽ 303,177.50 - Ᵽ 24,254.20 =
Ᵽ 24,254.20 Ᵽ 278,923.30
8 Ᵽ 278,923.30 Ᵽ 278,923.30 (0.08) = Ᵽ 278,923.30 - Ᵽ 22,313.86 =
Ᵽ 22,313.86 Ᵽ 256,609.44
Problem: An asset is purchased for Php 9,000. Its estimated life is 10 years, after which it will be sold for Php
1,000. Find the book value at the end of third year if the sum-of-the-years’ digit (SOYD) depreciation is used.
Given:
First Cost, Co = Ᵽ 9, 000
Salvage Value, CL = Ᵽ 1, 000
L = 10 years
n = 3 years
Required:
Book value at the end of 3 years. C3
Solution:
SYD = 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 6 + 7 + 8 + 9 + 10 = 55
6. Service Output
It is assumed that the results in the cost basis allocated equally over the output
(produced units) of the property during the period of tangible properties.
Let:
T = total units of output up to the end of life
Qn = total number of units of output during the nth year
Depreciation in n years,
Problem: A machine costs Php 400,000 with a salvage value of Php 20,000. Life of it is six years. In the first
year, 4,000 hours, in the second year, 6,000 hours and 8,000 hours on the third year. The expected flow of the
machine is 38,000 hours in six years. What is the depreciation at the end of the second year?
Given:
� �
Depreciation at first Year, �� = � �
(�� )
�
Depreciation at nth year, �� = �
�� − �� − ��−�
Problem: The cost of equipment is Ᵽ 500,000 and the cost of installation, labor, taxes and miscellaneous
expenses is Ᵽ30,000. If the salvage value is 10% of the cost of equipment at the end of its life of 5 years,
compute the book value at the end of the 3rd year using the MACRS method.
Given:
First Cost, Co = 500,000 + 30,000 – Php 530,000
L = 5 years
n = 3 years
i = 10%
Required:
Book value at the end of 3 years. C3
Solution:
1st year Depreciation = ½ [2/5 (530,000)] = Ᵽ 106,000
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. A contractor imported a bulldozer for his job, paying ₱ 250,000 to the manufacturer. Freight
and insurance charges amounted to ₱ 18,000; customs’, broker’s fees and other services,
₱8,500; taxes, permits, and other expenses, ₱ 25,000. If the contractor estimates the life of the
bulldozer to be 10 years with a salvage value of ₱ 20,000, determine the book value at the end
of 6 years, using the:
a) Straight-line Method
b) Sinking Fund Formula at 8%
c) Sum-of-the-years’ digit Method
d) Declining Balance Method
e) Double Declining Method
2. A telephone company purchased microwave radio equipment for ₱ 6M. if the equipment shall
be depreciated over a period of 8 years with a salvage value of 5% of the cost of the
equipment. Determine the book value at the end of 4 years. Use the Modified Accelerated Cost
Recovery System (MACRS) method.
1. An engineer bought equipment for ₱ 500,000. He spent an additional amount of ₱ 30,000 for
installation and other expenses. The estimated useful life of the equipment is 10 years. The
salvage value is 10% of the first cost. Using the straight line method of depreciation, find the
book value at the end of 4 years.
2. An equipment was bought for ₱ 1,800, 000 with a salvage value of ₱ 350,000 after its life of 8
years. Using the double declining balance method of depreciation, find its book value after 5
years.
4. An asphalt and aggregate mixing plant having a capacity of 50 m3 every hour costs
₱2,500,000. It is estimated to process 800,000 m3 during its life. During a certain year it
processed 60,000 m3. If its scrap value is ₱ 100,000, determine the total depreciation during
the year and the depreciation cost chargeable to each batch of 50 m3 using the production
units method.
5. The original cost of a certain piece of equipment is ₱ 500,000. The value after its useful life of
5 years is ₱ 100,000. The cost of money is 8% per year. Using the sinking fund method, find
its book value after 3 years.
6. A machine is depreciated using the sum of the years’ digit method. The
Equity totalFinance
Capital depreciation after
12 years is ₱ 16,253,532.67 and the depreciation
Financial
on the 17 th
year is ₱ 541,784.42.
obtains from selling an Its book
value at the end of the 14th year is ₱ 7,603,291.41. ownership stake
Capital
a. Compute the life of the machine. - refers to the
b. Find the total depreciation of the machine after its life.
money Debt Capital Finance
invested borrowed from lending
c. Find the first cost of the machine.
companies
7. An earth moving equipment that cost Ᵽ 90,000 will have an estimated salvage value of Ᵽ18,000 at the
end of its life of 8 years. Use modified accelerated cost recovery system (MACRS) method.
a. Determine the total depreciation at the endof
Types of 2nd year.
b. What would be its worth after 3 years?Capital
Human Natural Capital
Capital - refers to the
- refers to the natural
manpower of resources to
an be used in the
organization business
Topics:
Types of Capital
Types of Organization
Capitalization of Corporation
Bond Value
Learning Outcomes:
At the end of the lesson, the students can differentiate the types of organization and able to solve bond
problems.
Capitalization of a Corporation
A. Capital stocks
Stocks – an equity instrument carrying ownership interest (dividend).
Return of investment: Price change, dividend and interest payments
Classification of Bonds
1. Registered Bonds - Doesn’t need action from the holder.
2. Coupon Bonds - Needs to surrender his bond to redeem.
Bond Value
- The value of a bond is the present worth of all future amounts that are expected to be received
through ownership of the bond.
Sample Problem
A bond with a par value of ₱ 1,000 and with a bond rate of 9% payable annually is to be redeemed at ₱
1,050 at the end of 6 years from now. If it is sold now, what should be the selling price to yield 8%.
Given:
F = ₱ 1,000
r = 9%
₱ 90 ₱ 90 ₱ 90 ₱ 90 ₱ 90
₱ 90
P 1 2 3 4 5 6
P= + C (1 + i)-n
P= + ₱ 1,050 (1 + 8%)-6
P = ₱ 1,077.74
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. A bond with a par value of ₱ 1,000 and with a bond rate of 10% payable annually is sold
now for ₱ 1,080. If the yield is to be 12%, how much should the redemption price be at the
end of 8 years?
2. A company has issued 10-year bonds, with a face value of ₱ 1,000,000, in 1,000 units. Interest at
16% is paid quarterly. If an investor desires to earn 20% nominal interest on ₱ 100,000 worth of
these bonds, what would the selling price have to be?
1. A man wants to make 14% nominal interest compounded semi0anually on a bond investment.
How much should the man be willing to pay now for a 12% - ₱ 10,000 bond that will mature in
10 years and pays interest semi-annually?
2. A ₱1,500-bond which will mature in 10 years and with a bond rate of 15% payable annually is
to be redeemed at par at the end of this period. If it is sold now for ₱ 1,390, determine the yield
at this price.
3. A Corporation sold an issue of 20-year bonds, having a total face value of 10,000,000 for 9,500,000.
The bonds bear interest at 16%, payable semiannually. The company wishes to establish a sinking
fund for retiring the bond issue and will make semiannual deposit that will earn 12%, compounded
semiannually. Compute the annual cost for interest and redemption of these bonds.
Topics:
Rate of Return (ROR)
Annual Worth (AW)
Present Worth (PW)
Future Worth (FW)
Payback (Payout) Period
Benefit-Cost Ratio
Learning Outcomes:
At the end of the lesson, the students should be able to:
1. Understand the methods in economy studies.
Economy studies are necessary to be conducted in order to determine the needed capital investment and
the possibility of the investment to recover over time with an additional return which is called profit.
Basic patterns for making economy studies
1. Rate of Return (ROR)
2. Annual Worth (AW)
3. Present Worth (PW)
4. Future Worth (FW)
5. Payback (Payout) Period
INTERNAL RATE OF RETURN - It involves finding the interest rate at which the present worth of the
cash inflow equals the present worth of the cash outflow
EXTERNAL RATE OF RETURN - It involves finding the interest rate at which the future worth of the
outflows equals the future worth of the inflows.
EXPLICIT RATE OF RETURN – It involves dividing a net profit amount by the initial investment, where
the net profit is calculated using a depreciation charge based on the sinking fund.
Sample Problem: A businessman is considering building a 25-unit apartment in a place near a progressive
commercial center. He felt that because of the location of the apartment it will be occupied 90% at all time. He
desires a rate of return of 20%. Other pertinent data are the following:
Land investment ₱ 5,000,000.00
Building Investment ₱ 7,000,000.00
Study period 20 years
Cost of land after 20 years ₱ 20,000,000.00
Cost of building after 20 years ₱ 2,000,000.00
Rent per unit per month ₱ 6,000.00
Upkeep per unit per year ₱ 500.00
Property taxes 1.00% of investment
Insurance 0.50% of investment
Is this a good investment?
Solution:
Annual Revenue:
Building rental per year ₱ 6,000.00/[Link]. (25 units)(12 mo.)(90%) = ₱ 1,620,000
Worth of Land = ₱ 80,347.96
Total = ₱ 194,282.65
Net Annual Profit = Annual Revenue – Annual Costs
= ₱ 1,700,347.96 - ₱ 194,282.65
Net Annual Profit = ₱ 1,506,065.31
The computed rate of return is lesser than the desired rate of return, therefore the business is
not a good investment.
Since the net annual worth is less than zero, the business is not justified.
1 2 3 4 5 18 19 20
PW
I. Using Equation of Value (All cash flow going to the right, “0” as focal point)
∑PWinflow = ₱ 1,620,000 (1+20%)-1 + ₱ 1,620,000 (1+20%)-2 + ₱ 1,620,000 (1+20%)-3 + ₱ 1,620,000
(1+20%)-4 + ₱ 1,620,000 (1+20%)-5 + …. + ₱ 23,620,000 (1+20%)-20
∑PWinflow = ₱ 8,462,568.34
∑PWinflow = ₱ 8,462,568.34
PW
Aoutflow = ₱ 167,500
₱ 5,000,000 + ₱ 7,000,000
= ₱ 12,000,000.00
Since the net present worth is less than zero, the business is not justified.
Outflow:
Upkeep/Maintenance of unit ₱ 500.00/unit (25 units) = ₱ 12,500.00
Property tax (Land & Building) 1.00% (₱ 12,000,000.00) = ₱ 120,000.00
Insurance (Building only) 0.50% (₱ 7,000,000.00) = ₱ 35,000.00
Total = ₱ 167,500
Ainflow = ₱ 1,620,000.00
1 2 3 4 5 18 19 20
FW
= ₱ 1,620,000 + ₱ 22,000,000
∑FWinflow = ₱ 324,434,559.40
FW
Aoutflow = ₱ 167,500
₱ 5,000,000 + ₱ 7,000,000
= ₱ 12,000,000.00
I. Using Equation of Value (All cash flow going to the right, “20” as focal point)
∑FWoutflow = ₱ 12,000,000 (1+20%)20 + ₱ 167,500 (1+20%)19 + ₱ 167,500 (1+20%)18 + ₱ 167,500
(1+20%)17 + ₱ 167,500 (1+20%)16 + …. + ₱ 167,500 (1+20%)0
∑FWoutflow = ₱ 491,321,439.00
∑FWoutlow = ₱ 491,321,439.00
Since the net future worth is less than zero, the business is not justified.
Outflow:
Upkeep/Maintenance of unit ₱ 500.00/unit (25 units) = ₱ 12,500.00
Property tax (Land & Building) 1.00% (₱ 12,000,000.00) = ₱ 120,000.00
Insurance (Building only) 0.50% (₱ 7,000,000.00) = ₱ 35,000.00
Total = ₱ 167,500
The use of payback period for making investment decisions should be avoidedas it may
produce misleading results.
F. Benefit-Cost Ratio
Benefit-cost Ratio is method used to determine the relationship between the costs and the benefit of a
certain project. It can be computed by:
������� − ����������
BCR = ����
o For alternative comparison using Benefit/cost Analysis, the benefit and costs used will be the
differences among the alternatives.
Sample Problem
Determine the B/C ratio for the following project:
First Cost ₱ 100,000
Project Life 5
Salvage Value ₱ 10,000
Annual Benefits ₱ 60,000
Annual O and M ₱ 22,000
Interest rate 15%
Solution:
A. Using Annual Cost Method
Annual Benefit = ₱ 60,000
Annual Cost:
₱100,000−₱10,000
Depreciation 1+15% 5 −1
= ₱13,348.40
15%
Annual O and M =₱22,000.00
Interest on Capital ₱ 100,000 (15%) = ₱ 15,000.00
Total = ₱ 50,348.40
Benefit−Disbenefit ₱ 60,000
BCR = Cost
= ₱ 50,348.40 = 1.19> 1.0
1 2 3 4 5
A = ₱ 22,000.00
₱ 100,000.00
Convert to
1 2 3 4 5
EUACD
Using the formula for Annuity
EUACD= (A/P,%,n) + A- (A/F,%,n)
15% 15%
= ₱ 100,000 −5 + ₱ 22,000 - ₱ 10,000
1 − 1 + 15% 1+15% 5 −1
EUACD = ₱ 50,348.40
Benefit−Disbenefit ₱ 60,000
BCR = Cost
= ₱ 50,348.40 = 1.19 > 1.0
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. A fixed capital investment of ₱ 10,000,000.00 is required for a proposed manufacturing plant and an
estimated working capital of ₱2,000,000.00. Annual depreciation is estimated to be 10% of the fixed
capital investment. Determine the rate of return on the total investment and the payout period if the
annual profit is ₱ 2,500,000.00.
2. A food processing plant consumed 600,000 kW of electric energy annually and pays an average of ₱
2.00 per kWh. A study is being made to generate its own power to supply the energy required in the
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. A company is considering equipment A as a replacement for old equipment. Pertinent date are
as follows: first cost = ₱ 200,000, annual operating cost = ₱ 32,000, annual labor cost = ₱
50,000, insurance and taxes = 3%, payroll taxes 4%, estimated life = 10 years, estimated
annual income = ₱ 135,500, interest rate = 15%. Determine if the equipment A is a good
investment using:
a. Rate of Return Method
b. Annual Worth Method
c. Present Worth Method
d. Future Worth Method
2. The Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) is considering the construction of a
new highway through a scenic rural area. The road is expected to cost ₱ 50 million with annual
use estimated at ₱ 400,000. The improved accessibility is expected to result in additional income
from tourists of ₱ 7 million per year. The road is expected to have a useful life of 25 years. If the
rate of interest is 15%, should the road be constructed? Use benefit-cost analysis.
Topics:
Comparing Alternatives
Replacement Studies
Break-even Analysis
Learning Outcomes:
At the end of the lesson, the students can apply the methods of economic studies to evaluate
alternatives under certainty condition.
Good information
is available.
Information is
incomplete.
Comparing Alternatives
A. Evaluation of Mutually Exclusive Alternatives
In this evaluation, the alternatives have common characteristics (having costs and/or revenues) and
only one alternative will govern. As soon as the best alternative is identified, all of the others are
automatically excluded.
Basic Philosophy
The method that requires the minimum investment of capital will produce satisfactory functional results
and will always be used unless there are definite reasons why an alternative requiring a larger investment
should be adopted.
Methods/ Patterns in comparing alternatives
1. Rate of Return on Additional Investment Method
2. Annual Cost (AC) Method
3. Equivalent Uniform Annual Cost (EUAC) Method
4. Present Worth Cost (PWC) Method
5. Capitalized Cost
6. Payback (Payout) Period Method
7. Benefit-Cost Ratio
Procedure of analysis
1. Calculate annual expenses of each alternative.
Make sure to convert all cost per year.
Use cash flow diagram for EUAC and PWC.
2. Compare the annual cost based on the condition of each method.
3. Make a conclusion.
Sample Problem: It is proposed to place a cable on an existing pole line along the shore of a lake to connect
two points on opposite sides. The lifespan of cable is 15 years.
LAND SUBMARINE
ROUTE ROUTE
Length, miles 10 5
First Cost of cable per mile ₱ 40, 000 ₱ 68, 000
Annual maintenance per mile ₱ 950 ₱ 3, 500
Interest on Investment 18% 18%
Taxes 3% 3%
Net Salvage Value per mile ₱ 12, 000 ₱ 22, 000
Solution:
Step 1: Recognize a decision problem
Placement of cable on two opposite points
Annual Costs:
Maintenance of cable ₱ 950/mile(10 mile) = ₱ 9,500.00
Tax 3% (₱ 40,000.00x 10 mile) = ₱ 12,000.00
Depreciation ₱400,000 − ₱120,000 = ₱ 4,592.78
1+18% 15 −1
18%
Total = ₱ 26,092.78
For Submarine Route
First Cost of cable =₱ 68, 000/mile x 5 mile = ₱ 340, 000.00
Salvage Value of cable =₱ 22, 000/mile x 5 mile = ₱ 110, 000.00
Annual Costs:
Maintenance of cable ₱ 3,500/mile (5 mile) = ₱ 17,500.00
Tax 3% (₱ 68,000.00 x 5 mile) = ₱ 10,200.00
Depreciation ₱340,000 − ₱110,000 = ₱ 3,772.64
1+18% 15 −1
18%
Total = ₱ 31,472.64
Since the computed ROR on the additional investment does not satisfy the given rate of
return, then the lower capital should be chosen which is the Submarine route with
₱340,000 investment.
Annual Costs:
Maintenance of cable ₱ 950/mile (10 mile) = ₱ 9,500.00
Tax 3% (₱ 40,000.00x 10 mile) = ₱ 12,000.00
₱400,000 − ₱120,000
Depreciation = ₱ 4,592.78
1+18% 15 −1
18%
Interest on Capital 18%(₱ 400,000) = ₱ 72,000.00
Total = ₱ 98,092.78
For Submarine Route
Annual Costs:
Maintenance of cable ₱ 3,500/mile (5 mile) = ₱ 17,500.00
Tax 3% (₱ 68,000.00 x 5 mile) = ₱ 10,200.00
Depreciation ₱340,000 − ₱110,000 = ₱ 3,772.64
1+18% 15 −1
18%
Interest on Capital 18%(₱ 340,000) = ₱ 61,200.00
Total = ₱ 92,672.64
Annual Costs:
Maintenance of cable ₱ 950/mile (10 mile) = ₱ 9,500.00
Tax 3% (₱ 40,000.00x 10 mile) = ₱ 12,000.00
Total = ₱ 21,500.00
1 2 3 4 5 13 14 15
A = ₱ 21,500.00
₱ 400,000.00
Convert to
1 2 3 4 5 13 14 15
EUACA
Using the formula for Annuity
EUACA= (A/P,%,n) + A+ (A/F,%,n)
18% 18%
1 − 1 + 18% −15 1 + 18% 15 − 1
A Self-regulated Learning Module 78
= ₱ 400,000 + ₱ 21,500 - ₱ 120,000.00
EUACA= ₱ 98,092.78
Annual Costs:
Maintenance of cable ₱ 3,500/mile (5 mile) = ₱ 17,500.00
Tax 3% (₱ 68,000.00 x 5 mile) = ₱ 10,200.00
Total = ₱ 27,700.00
Cash flow Diagram
₱ 110,000.00
1 2 3 4 5 13 14 15
A = ₱ 27,700.00
₱ 340,000.00
Convert to
1 2 3 4 5 13 14 15
EUACB
Using the formula for Annuity
EUACB= (A/P,%,n) + A+ (A/F,%,n)
18% 18%
= ₱ 340,000 + ₱ 27,700 - ₱ 110,000.00
1 − 1 + 18% −15 1 + 18% 15 − 1
EUACB = ₱ 92,672.64
EUACA> EUACB
The submarine route should be chosen since it has a lesser EUAC.
Annual Costs:
Maintenance of cable ₱ 950/mile (10 mile) = ₱ 9,500.00
1 2 3 4 5 13 14 15
A = ₱ 21,500.00
₱ 400,000.00
Annual Costs:
Maintenance of cable ₱ 3,500/mile (5 mile) = ₱ 17,500.00
Tax 3% (₱ 68,000.00 x 5 mile) = ₱ 10,200.00
Total = ₱ 27,700.00
1 2 3 4 5 13 14 15
A = ₱ 27,700.00
PWCA> PWCB
The submarine route should be chosen since it has a lesser present worth cost.
� ₱ 340,000 − ₱ 110,000
1+� �−1 1 + 18% 15 − 1
A Self-regulated Learning Module 81
X= = = ₱ 20,959.11
CCA> CCB
The submarine route should be chosen since it has a lesser capitalized cost.
Sample Problem 2
Two routes are under consideration for a new highway. Route A would be located about five miles from
the central business district and would require longer travel distances by local commuter traffic. Route B would
pass directly through the down town area and, although its construction cost would be higher, it would reduce
the travel time and distance for local commuters. The costs for the two routes are as follows:
Route A Route B
Initial Cost ₱ 200,000,000 ₱ 250,000,000
Maintenance per year ₱ 700,000 ₱ 1,100,000
Road-user cost per year ₱ 10,000,000 ₱ 4,000,000
If the roads are assumed to last 30 years with no salvage value, which route should be accepted on the
basis of a benefit/cost analysis using an interest rate of 15%.
Solution:
A. Using Annual Cost Method
For Route A
Annual Benefit = ₱ 10,000,000
Annual Cost:
₱ 200,000,000
Depreciation 1+15% 30−1
= ₱460,039.64
15%
Maintenance = ₱700,000.00
Interest on Capital ₱ 200,000,000(15%) = ₱30,000,000.00
Total = ₱ 31,160,039.64
For Route B
Annual Benefit = ₱ 4,000,000
Annual Cost:
₱ 250,000,000
Depreciation 1+15% 30 −1
= ₱575,049.55
15%
Maintenance = ₱1,100,000.00
Interest on Capital ₱ 250,000,000 (15%) = ₱ 37,500,000.00
Total = ₱ 39,175,049.55
Benefit−Disbenefit ₱ 6,000,000
BCR = Cost
= ₱ 8,015,009.91 = 0.75
For Route A
Cash flow diagram for annual benefit
1 2 3 4 5
EUACA = ₱10,000,000
Cash flow Diagram for annual cost
1 2 3 4 5
A = ₱ 700,000
₱ 200,000,000
Convert to
1 2 3 4 5
EUACA
Using the formula for Annuity
EUACA= (A/P,%,n) + A 15%
= ₱ 200,000,000 + ₱ 700,000
1 − 1 + 15% −30
EUACA = ₱ 31,160,039.64
For Route B
Cash flow diagram for annual benefit
1 2 3 4 5
EUACB = ₱4,000,000
A = ₱ 1,100,000
₱ 250,000,000
Convert to
1 2 3 4 5
EUACB
Using the formula for Annuity
EUACB = (A/P,%,n) + A 15%
= ₱ 250,000,000 −30 + ₱ 1,100,000
1 − 1 + 15%
EUACB = ₱ 39,175,049.55
Benefit−Disbenefit ₱ 6,000,000
BCR = Cost
= ₱ 8,015,009.91 = 0.75
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. In building their plant, the officers of the International Leather Company had the choice
between alternatives:
One alternative is to build in Metro Manila where the plant would cost ₱ 2,000,000. Labor would
cost annually ₱ 120,000 and annual overhead ₱ 40,000. Taxes and insurance would total 5% of the
first cost of the plant.
Second alternative would be to build in Bulacan a plant costing ₱ 2,250,000. Labor would cost
annually ₱ 100,000 and overhead would be ₱ 55,000. Taxes and insurance would be 3% of the first
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. Data for two alternatives are as follows:
A B
Investment ₱ 35,000 ₱ 50,000
Annual benefits ₱ 20,000 ₱ 25,000
Annual O and M ₱ 6,450 ₱ 13,830
Estimated life, years 4 8
Net Salvage value ₱ 3,500 0
a. Equipment A has a first cost of ₱ 50,000, salvage value of ₱ 2,000, annual maintenance of ₱ 6,000,
and an economic life of 5 years. Equipment B has a first cost of ₱ 150,000, salvage value of ₱ 6,000,
annual maintenance of ₱ 3,000, and an economic life of 15 years. The maximum rate of return for both
equipments is 12% annually.
a. Find the annual cost of equipment A
b. Find the present worth of equipment B.
c. Find the rate of return for the additional investment on equipment B.
b. An electric cooperative is considering the use o f a concrete electric pole in the expansion of its power
distribution lines. A concrete pole costs 18,000 each and will last 20 years. The company is presently
using creosoted wooden poles which cost 12,000 per pole and will last 10 years. If money is worth 12
percent, which ole should be used? Assume annual taxes amount to 1 percent of first cost and zero
salvage value in both cases. Determine the best alternative using: (i = 12%)
a. Rate of Return on Additional Investment Method
b. Annual Cost (AC) Method
c. Equivalent Uniform Annual Cost (EUAC) Method
d. Present Worth Cost (PWC) Method
Replacement analysis
It is a method of capital budgeting which involves analyzing effectively whether to replace an existing
asset (the defender) with a new one (the challenger).This aims to maximize the profit or minimize the
costs for a certain production.
3. Obsolescence
This may cause either by lessening the demand for rendering the service or the availability of
more efficient asset with lower operational cost.
Procedure of analysis
1. Calculate annual costs of each alternative.
Make sure to convert all costs per year.
Use cash flow diagram for EUAC.
2. Compare the annual cost based on the condition of each method. (See Module 4)
3. Make a conclusion.
Sample Problem 1
A decision must be made whether to replace a certain engine with a new one, or to rebore the cylinder
of the old engine and thoroughly recondition it. The original cost of the old engine 10 years ago was ₱ 70,000;
to rebore and recondition it now will cost ₱ 28,000, but would extend its useful life for 5 years.
A new engine will have a first cost of ₱ 62,000 and will have an estimated life of 10 years. It is expected
that the annual cost of fuel and lubricants with the reconditioned engine will be about ₱ 20,000 and that this
cost will be 15% less with the new engine. It is also believed that repairs will be ₱ 2,500 a year less with the
new engine than with the reconditioned one. Assume that neither engine has any net realizable value when
retired. If money is worth 16%, what would you recommend?
Solution:
A. Using Rate of Return on Additional Investment
For Reconditioned engine:
Annual Cost:
₱ 28,000
Depreciation 1+16% 5 −1
= ₱ 4,071.46
16%
Fuel and lubricants = ₱ 20,000.00
Repairs = ₱ 2,500.00
Total Annual Cost = ₱ 26,571.46
₱ ��,���.��−₱ ��,���.��
ROR on additional investment = ₱ 62,000− ₱ 28,000
= 19.60%> 16%
Since the computed ROR on the additional investment is greater than the given rate of return,
then higher investment should be chosen which is the New engine.
Since the annual cost for new engine is more economical than the reconditioned engine, then
the engine should be replaced.
A = ₱ 22,500.00
₱ 28,000.00
Convert to
1 2 3 4 5
EUACA
Using the formula for Annuity
EUACA= (A/P,%,n) + A
16%
= ₱ 28,000 + ₱ 22,500
−5
1 − 1 + 16%
EUACA = ₱ 31,051.46
1 2 3 4 5 10
A = ₱ 17,000.00
₱ 62,000.00
Convert to
1 2 3 4 5 10
EUACB
Using the formula for Annuity
EUACB= (A/P,%,n) + A
16%
= ₱ 62,000 −10
+ ₱ 17,000
1 − 1 + 16%
EUACB = ₱ 29,827.87
Since the equivalent uniform annual cost for new engine is more economical than the
Break-even analysis
It is a method to determine the number of products or services at a stage where income is equal to the
total costs. Hence, there is no gain or loss expected in break-even point.
REVENUE = FIXED COSTs + VARIABLE COST
Components of Break-even Analysis
1. Fixed Cost
Also called as Overhead Cost
These costs are directly related to the level of operation.
Examples: Taxes, Salaries, Energy Cost, etc.
2. Variable Cost
These costs may increase or decrease the operational cost.
Examples: Cost of raw materials, Utility cost, etc.
Break-even chart is a graphical representation of break-even analysis. It shows the stage where a
company can get a loss or profit by the number of produced units.
Profit
Break-even point
Loss
Sample Problem 1
A manufacturer produces certain items at a labor cost of ₱ 315.00 each, material cost of ₱100.00 each
and variable cost of ₱ 3.00 each. If the item has a unit price of ₱ 995.00, how many units must be produced
each month for the manufacturer to break-even if the monthly overhead is ₱ 461,600.00? Present algebraic
and graphical solution.
Given:
Labor Cost = ₱ 315.00
Material Cost = ₱ 100.00
Variable Cost = ₱ 3.00
Unit Price of item = ₱ 995.00
Overhead = ₱ 461,600.00/month
Solution:
Algebraic Solution
Let X = number of produce unit per month
Graphical Solution
Solution:
Algebraic Solution
Let X = number of produced blocks
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. A small shop in Bulacan fabricates portable threshers for palay producers in the locality. The shop can
produce each thresher at a labor cost of ₱ 1,800. The cost of materials for each unit is ₱ 2,500. The
variable costs amount to ₱ 650 per unit, while fixed charges incurred per annum totals ₱ 69,000. If the
portable threshers are sold at ₱ 7,800 per unit, how many units must be produced and sold per annum
to break-even? Present algebraic solution.
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
1. Determine the break-even point in terms of number of units produced per month using the
following data:
Selling price = ₱ 600.00 /unit
Total overhead expenses = ₱ 428,000 /month
Labor Cost = ₱115.00 /unit
Cost of Materials = ₱ 76.00 /unit
Other variable cost = ₱ 2.32 /unit
Topics:
Expected Monetary Value of Alternatives
Discounted Decision Tree Analysis
Learning Outcomes:
At the end of the lesson, the students can apply the economic analysis to evaluate alternatives under
risks condition.
Risk is present when there may be two or more observable values for a parameter and it is possible to
estimate the chance that each value may occur.
Probability is a component of risk analysis which means the likelihood of an event to happen. The
following is an example of probability scale:
Likelihood Description
Relative Numerical
Very Low 0.1 High unlikely to occur
Low 0.3 Unlikely to occur
Moderate 0.5 Possible to occur
High 0.7 Likely to occur
Very High 0.9 High likely to occur
Impact is the effect of the risk event on the project objectives. The following is an example of impact scale:
Objective Relative/Numerical Scale
Very Low / Low / 0.1 Moderate / 0.2 High / 0.4 Very High /
0.05 0.8
Cost Insignificant < 10% 10 – 20% 20– 40% >40%
change in cost increase increase increase increase
Insignificant < 5% 5 – 10% 10 – 20% >20%
Time change in increase increase increase increase
schedule
Barely Minor areas Major areas Unacceptable Project end
Scope noticeable affected affected reduction item
scope effectively
decrease useless
Barely Only Quality Unacceptable Project end
Quality noticeable demanding reduction quality item
quality applications requires sponsor reduction effectively
degradation effected approval useless
Sample Problem 1
You have identified an opportunity with a 40% chance of happening. However, it may help you gain
₱2,000 if this risk occurs. Calculate the expected monetary value (EMV) for the risk event.
Given:
Probability of risk = 40%
Impact of risk = ₱2,000 (positive impact because of the word “gain”)
Required:
EMV
Solution:
EMV = 0.40 x ₱2,000
EMV = ₱800
Sample Problem 2
During risk management planning, your team has identified three risks with probabilities of 10%, 50%
and 35%. If the first two risks occur, they will cost you ₱5,000 and 8,000; however, the third risk will give you
₱10,000 if it occurs. Determine the expected monetary value of these risk events.
Given:
Probability of risk1 = 10% Impact of risk1 = - ₱5,000 (Cost)
Probability of risk2 = 50% Impact of risk2 = - ₱8,000 (Cost)
Solution:
Step 1: Draw the decision tree representing the options.
Step 2: Add the chance nodes, the probabilities and the outcomes.
Step 4: Calculate the net expected monetary values and interpret the result.
Net EMVExpand = [₱ 2.4M + ₱ 1.2M] - ₱ 1.5M = ₱ 2.1M
Net EMVNo Expand = [₱ 1.2M + ₱ 0.6M] – 0 = ₱ 1.8M
Since ₱ 2.1M > ₱ 1.8M, then Mary should expand the factory.
Problem Solving: See instructions and rubric at the start of this module.
A property owner is faced with a choice of:
a. A large-scale investment to improve her flats. This could produce a substantial pay-off in terms of
increased revenue net of costs but will require an investment of 1.4 million pesos. After extensive
market research it is considered that there is a 40% chance that a pay-off of 2.5million will be obtained,
but there is a 60% chance that it will be only 800,000 pesos.
b. A smaller scale project to re-decorate her premises. At 500,000 pesos this is less costly but will
produce a lower pay-off. Research data suggests a 30% chance of a gain of one million pesos but a
70% chance of being only 500,000 pesos.
c. Continuing the present operation without change. It will cost nothing but neither will it produce any pay-
off. Clients will be unhappy and it will become harder to rent the flats out when they become free.
What is the best alternative? Use decision tree analysis.
Topics:
Methods of Decision Making under Uncertainty
Sensitivity Analysis
Learning Outcomes:
At the end of the lesson, the students can apply the concept of economic analysis to evaluate
alternatives under uncertainty condition.
Sources of Uncertainty
1. Possible inaccuracy of the cash-flow estimates used in the study
2. Type of business involved in relation to the future health of the economy
3. Type of physical plant and equipment involved
4. Length of the study period
Example : Let there be a situation in which a decision-maker has three possible alternatives A1, A2 and A3,
where the outcome of each of them can be affected by the occurrence of any one of the four possible
events S1, S2, S3 and S4. The monetary payoffs of each combination of Ai and Sj are given in the following
table:
Solution: Since 17 is maximum out of the minimum payoffs, the optimal action is A2.
2. Maximax Criterion: This criterion, also known as the criterion of optimism, is used when the
decision-maker is optimistic about future. Maximax implies the maximization of maximum payoff.
The optimistic decision-maker locates the maximum payoff for each possible course of action. The
maximum of these payoffs is identified and the corresponding course of action is selected. The
optimal course of action in the above example, based on this criterion, is A3.
From the payoff matrix (given below), the payoffs corresponding to the actions A1, A2, ...... An under the
state of nature Sj are X1i, X2j, ...... Xnj respectively. Of these assume that X2j is maximum. Then the regret in
selecting Ai, to be denoted by Rij is given by X2j - Xij, i = 1 to m.
We note that the regret in selecting A2 is zero. The regrets for various actions under different states of
nature can also be computed in a similar way.
The regret criterion is based upon the minimax principle, i.e., the decision-maker tries to minimize the
maximum regret. Thus, the decision-maker selects the maximum regret for each of the actions and out of
these the action which corresponds to the minimum regret is regarded as optimal. The regret matrix of
example can be written as given below:
From the maximum regret column, we find that the regret corresponding to the course of action is A3 is
minimum. Hence, A3 is optimal.
4. Hurwicz Criterion: The maximax and the maximin criteria, discussed above, assume that the
decision-maker is either optimistic or pessimistic. A more realistic approach would, however, be to
take into account the degree or index of optimism or pessimism of the decision-maker in the
process of decision-making. If a, a constant lying between 0 and 1, denotes the degree of optimism,
then the degree of pessimism will be 1 - a. Then a weighted average of the maximum and
minimum payoffs of an action, with a and 1 - a as respective weights, is computed. The action with
highest average is regarded as optimal.
We note that a nearer to unity indicates that the decision-maker is optimistic while a value nearer to zero
indicates that he is pessimistic. If a = 0.5, the decision maker is said to be neutralist.
We apply this criterion to the payoff matrix of example 17. Assume that the index of optimism a = 0.7.
5. Laplace Criterion: In the absence of any knowledge about the probabilities of occurrence of
various states of nature, one possible way out is to assume that all of them are equally likely to
occur. Thus, if there are n states of nature, each can be assigned a probability of occurrence = 1/n.
Using these probabilities, we compute the expected payoff for each course of action and the action
with maximum expected value is regarded as optimal.
Sensitivity Analysis
A sensitivity analysis is a graphical representation to measure the effect of uncertainty in an
economic decision. This can be done by plotting the economic criteria as a function of a parameter. A
flat plot indicates insensitivity.
Sensitivity analysis is used to explore what happens to a project’s profitability when the
estimated value of study factors is changed. For example, if annual expenses turn out to be10% higher
than expected, will the project still be acceptable? Sometimes, sensitivity is specifically defined to mean
the percent change in one or more factors that will reverse a decision among project alternatives or
reverse a decision about the economic acceptability of a single project. This percent change is called
sensitivity with respect to decision reversal. (Sullivan, et. al., 2015)
Tornado chart shows how sensitive the objective is to each decision variable as they change
over their allowed ranges. This chart shows all the decision variables in order of their impact on the
objective.
Learning Outcomes:
At the end of this lesson, the students can use the basic concept of accounting to understand asset and
liabilities of engineering firms.
Accounting Principles
Accounting is the process of recording all the transactions of the company which affect any investment
of capital so that at any given time results of the investment may be known.
After a decision to invest capital in a project has been made and the capital has been invested, those
who supply and manage the capital want to know the financial results. Financial accounting and cost
accounting are the procedures that provide these necessary services in a business organization.
Balance Sheet
Balance sheet is a financial statement that reports a company’s assets, liabilities and shareholder’s
equity at a specific point in time and provides a basis for computing rates of return and evaluating its capital
structure.
Cash and cash equivalents are the most liquid assets and can include Treasury bills and short-
term certificates of deposit, as well as hard currency.
Marketable securities are equity and debt securities for which there is a liquid market.
Accounts receivable refers to money that customers owe the company, perhaps including an
allowance for doubtful accounts since a certain proportion of customers can be expected not to pay.
Inventory is goods available for sale, valued at the lower of the cost or market price.
Prepaid expenses represent the value that has already been paid for, such as insurance,
advertising contracts or rent.
Fixed assets include land, machinery, equipment, buildings and other durable, generally capital-
intensive assets.
Intangible assets include non-physical (but still valuable) assets such as intellectual property and
goodwill. In general, intangible assets are only listed on the balance sheet if they are acquired,
rather than developed in-house. Their value may thus be wildly understated – by not including a
globally recognized logo, for example – or just as wildly overstated.
Liabilities
o Current liabilities
o Long-term liabilities
***Note: Some liabilities are considered off the balance sheet, meaning that they will not appear on the balance
sheet.
Shareholders' Equity
o Shareholders' equity is the money attributable to a business' owners, meaning its
shareholders. It is also known as "net assets," since it is equivalent to the total assets of a
company minus its liabilities, that is, the debt it owes to non-shareholders.
o Retained earnings are the net earnings a company either reinvests in the business or use to
pay off debt; the rest is distributed to shareholders in the form of dividends.
o Treasury stock is the stock a company has repurchased. It can be sold at a later date to raise
cash or reserved to repel a hostile takeover.
BALANCE SHEET
Name of Company
Date
ASSETS:
Current Assets
Cash on hand and in banks………………………………………………..
Notes and Accounts Receivable…………………………………………...
Notes receivable customers………………………………………..
Accounts receivable customers……………………………………
Other receivable (give details)……………………………………..
Less: reserve for bad debts…………………………………………
Inventories (goods and materials on hand)………………………………
Total Current Assets…………………………………………………
Fixed Assets
Land
Building or Manufacturing plant ---------------------------
Less Reserve for depreciation ----------------
Properties other than buildings ----------------------------
Less Reserve for depreciation ------------------____________
Total Fixed Assets -------------------------
Prepaid Expenses
These includes amount paid in advance -----------
For insurance, rental, interest, supplies, etc ------- _____________
Total Prepaid Expenses ------------------
Other Assets
Sinking funds -------------------------------------------------------
Investments in securities such as bonds, etc -------
Goodwill -------------------------------------------------------------
Patents, franchises, licenses --------------------------------
Other intangibles --------------------------------------------------
Miscellaneous (give details) ----------------------------------- _____________
Total of Other Assets -----------------------
TOTAL ASSETS --------------- _____________
LIABILITIES:
Current Liabilities
Notes Payable ----------------------------------------------------
Accounts Payables ----------------------------------------------
Accrued Expenses (taxes, wages, interest, etc) ---------
Declared and unpaid dividends ----------------------------------
Other current liabilities (give details) -------------------------- ____________
Total Current Liabilities ----------------------
Fixed Liabilities
Mortgage payable --------------------------------------------------
OWNERSHIP
Preferred Shares ………………………………………………………..
Common Shares …………………………………………………………
Undivided Surplus ( retained earnings )………………………
TOTAL OWNERSHIP …………………………..
TOTAL : LIABILITIES - OWNERSHIP ………………………………
INCOME STATEMENT
Income statement is a financial statement that shows the profit and loss of a company over a period of
time.
Revenue – Expenses = Profit (or loss)
This relationship defines the format of the income statement (also known as a profit and loss statement), which
summarizes the revenue and expense result of operation over a period of time.
Gross Profit
Gross Profit is calculated by subtracting Cost of Goods Sold (or Cost of Sales) from Sales Revenue.
Interest
Interest Expense is common for companies to split out interest expense and interest income as a separate line
item in the income statement. This is done in order to reconcile the difference between EBIT and EBT. Interest
expense is determined by the debt schedule.
Other Expenses
Businesses often have other expenses that are unique to their industry. Other expenses may include things
such as fulfillment, technology, research and development (R&D), stock-based
compensation (SBC), impairment charges, gains/losses on the sale of investments, foreign exchange impacts,
and many other expenses that are industry or company-specific.
Income Taxes
Income Taxes refer to the relevant taxes charged on pre-tax income. The total tax expense can consist of both
current taxes and future taxes.
Net Income
Net Income is calculated by deducting income taxes from pre-tax income. This is the amount that flows into
retained earnings on the balance sheet, after deductions for any dividends.
Income Statement
Company
For the year ending December 31. ____
Question Yes No
1. The syllabus was discussed at the beginning of the course
2. The delivery of the course followed the structure of the syllabus
3. The instructor explained the grading system of the course
4. The activities were related to the course learning outcomes
5. I was able to achieve the learning outcomes of the course
Comment/Suggestion
References: