Overview of Patent Law Essentials
Overview of Patent Law Essentials
Syllabus: Rights and Limitations – Rights under Patent Law –Patent Requirements –
Ownership and Transfer – Patent Application Process and Granting of Patent – Patent
Infringement and Litigation – International Patent Law –Double Patenting– Patent
Searching–Patent Cooperation Treaty–New developments in Patent Law.
1Q.INTRODUCTION:
Meaning of Patent: A patent is a legal right to exclude others from practicing the patented
inventionfor alimitedperiodoftime inexchangefor disclosingthedetailsofthe inventionto the
public.
Any useful, new and non obvious process, machine, article that is made, or chemical
composition, or improvement of any of the above can be patented. Business methods and
softwarecanalso bepatented, but lawsofnatureandabstract ideas cannot be patented. Types of
patents There are three types of patents
1. Design Patent: may be granted to anyone who invents a new, original, and
ornamental design for an article of manufacture .simple way External shape
of the product.
2. Utility Patent: may be granted to anyone who invents or discovers any new
and useful process, machine, article of manufacture ,or composition of matter,
or any new and useful improvement thereof Examples: Manufacturing
Process, Composition matters.
3. Plant Patent: may be granted to anyone who invents or discovers and
asexually reproduces any distinct and new variety of plant. Examples:
poinsettia plant named “Eckaddis”.
4. Reissue patents: Reissued patents with revised claims.
Patent process
1. Filing: Submit a patent application to the patent office.
2. Examination: The patent office reviews the application.
3. Allowance: The patent is granted.
4. Maintenance: Pay fees to keep the patent in force.
Patent rights and limitations
1. Exclusive rights: Patent owners can exclude others from making, using, or
selling the invention.
2. Territoriality: Patents are country-specific.
3. Time limits: Patents have a limited term.
4. Exceptions: Certain activities, like research and development, may be exempt
from patent infringement.
RIGHTS OF OWNER OF A PATENT: The owner of the patent has the right to preclude
any person from exploiting the protected invention by any of the following acts –
When the patent has been granted in respect of a product (Invention Is a Product)
making, importing, offering for sale, selling and using the product; or
stocking such product for the purposes of offering it for sale, selling or using the
product;
When the patent has been granted in respect of a process (Invention Is a Process) Using
the process, or doing any of the acts referred to in paragraph (1), in respect of a product
obtained directly by means of the process.
Enforcement of rights:
1. Exclusive right to make, use, and sell: The patent owner has the exclusive right to
make, use, and sell the invention.
2. Right to license: The patent owner can license others to use the invention.
3. Right to assign: The patent owner can assign the patent to another party.
4. Right to enforce: The patent owner can enforce the patent against infringers.
5. Right to defend: The patent owner can defend against challenges to the patent's
validity.
1. Mark products with the patent number: Mark products covered by the patent with
the patent number.
2. Use the patent to negotiate: Use the patent to negotiate with other companies.
3Q.LIMITATIONS OF PATENT RIGHTS:
The rights under the patent act done for industrial or commercial purposes and in
particular not to acts done for scientific research.
The rights under the patent do not extend to acts in respect of articles which have
been put on the market in Kenya or in anyother countryor imported into Kenya.
The limitationonthe rights under apatent above extends to acts inrespect ofarticles
that are imported from a country where the articles were legitimately put on the
market.Therightsunderthepatentdonotextendtotheuseofarticlesonaircraft,
land vehicles or vessels of other countries, which temporarily or accidentally enterthe
airspace, territory, or waters of Kenya. The rights under the patent are limited by the
provisions of the terms of the patent. The rights under the patent are limited bythe
provisions on compulsory licenses’ for reasons of public interest or based on
interdependence of patents and by the provisions on State exploitation of patented
inventions. The rights ofthe patent do not extend variants or mutants of living forms
orreplicablelivingmatterthatisdistinctively differentfrom theoriginalforwhich
patentswereobtainedwheresuchmutantsorvariantsaredeservingofseparate patents.
4Q.PATENT REQUIREMENTS:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or
composition of matter, or any new and useful improvements thereof, may obtain a patent,
subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
Unfortunately, the actual test for patentability is a bit more complicated than this
sentence suggests. an invention is patentable only I fit meets the following four requirements,
which are discussed in more detail below:
1. Novelty: The invention must be new and not obvious to others in the same field.
5. Enablement: The patent application must provide enough detail for someone skilled
in the field to replicate the invention.
6. Written description: The patent application must include a clear and concise written
description of the invention.
7. Best mode: The patent application must disclose the best mode of carrying out the
invention.
Ownership and transfer of patents refer to the legal rights and processes involved in
owning and transferring patents. Here are some key aspects:
Ownership:
1. Initial ownership: The inventor or creators of the patent typically own the patent
rights.
Transfer:
Recordation:
1. Patent office recordation: Recording assignments, licenses, or other transfers with
the patent office.
Implications:
2. Transfer restrictions: Some agreements or laws may restrict the transfer of patent
rights.
3. Tax implications: Transferring patents can have tax implications, such as capital
gains tax.
Patentee meaning: A person or organization that obtains or holds a patent for something or
The person or organization that owns the legal right to make or sell something.
Rights:
A patent application is a request pending at a patent office for the grant of a patent for the
invention described and claimed by that application. An application consists of a description
of the invention (the patent specification), together with official forms and correspondence
relating to the application.
The term patent application is also used to refer to the process of applying for a
patent, or to the patent specification itself (i.e. the content of the document filed with a viewto
initiating the process of applying for a patent.
Granting of Patent:
Timeline:
Note: The timeline may vary depending on the jurisdiction and complexity of the
application.
Post-Grant:
The Third Schedule of the Patents Rules prescribes the Form that is issued on the
grant of patents. Section 43ofthe Patents Act, 1970 deals with the Grant of patents. Where a
patent application has not been refused by the Controller or the patent application does not
contravene any provisions of the Act and is deemed to be in order for grant of the patent,
the applicant shall be granted the patent immediately. 1 The patent must bear the seal of the
patent office and an entry should be made in the register mentioning the date of grant of
patent.
Once the patent has been granted, the fact that the patent has been granted must
be published by the Controller, following which the patent application, specification
and other documents related to the patent are open for public inspection.
The Third Schedule of the Patents Rules specifies the Form for grant of the
patent, which may be modified based on the circumstances of the case and it should
bear the applicationnumber. The patent certificate should be issued within7 days
fromthe dateofthe grant of patent. On a written request to the Controller, the patent
application along with the complete and provisional specification, drawings, abstract
and other documents can be inspected by paying the requisite fee.
PATENT INFRINGEMENT:
Equitable Remedy: An equitable remedy is one which does not involve the
payment of pecuniary (money) damages, but rather involves a court order to
take some action or cease from some behavior.
Civil Action: When the law permits one private party to sue another private
party it is known as a civil action, as opposed to criminal actions which are
brought by governmental entities (the state, the federal government, etc.)
Treble Damages: The law sometimes permits a court, at its discretion, to
award triple damages to a plaintiff, which is known as treble damages.
Injunctions: an authoritative warning order.
Governmentuse:section47ofIndianpatentAct1970
Research exemption
Supply of patented drugs to health institutions
Use of patented invention on foreign vessels
Patent infringement can have serious consequences, including:
PATENT LITIGATION:
Meaning: A patent litigation suit is filed when the patent owner and the alleged
infringer cannot agree to enter into a licensing agreement or if the patent owner is not
willing to share his technology at all. Patent litigation suits are typically very costly,
especially in the US, can last for many years and may cause expenses of millions of
dollars.
RemediesforpatentLitigation:
Monetary Damages: The partyaccused for patent infringement is sentenced in
court and compensates the patent owner. Such compensations include the
patent owner being entitled lost profits and/or royalties from the infringer.
Exclusion Order: If the case is taken to the International Trade Commission
they might issueanexclusionorder.This isthesameas apermanent injunctionthat
forbids the patent infringer fromimporting the productthat usesthe infringed
technologyinto
the markets coveredbythepatent.
Mediation: Using a mediator to settle the litigation outside of the courtroom
and to avoid a potentially long and costly trial.
Negotiated Settlement: If the patent owner has support from an experienced
and well-financedfirm itmightbeabletoavoidgoing to trial
andnegotiateasettlement
withthe infringer. Thissettlement usuallyincludesa licensing agreement
betweenthe parties. Most infringement cases are settled like this.
Injunctive Relief: The infringing party is forced to cease production and/or
sale ofthe infringing product or service. This does not provide the patent owner
with any compensation, but it puts pressure on the infringing company.
8Q.INTERNATIONALPATENTLAW:
As per Section 39 of the Indian Patent Act, any inventor of India seeking for
International patent are required to file the patent application initially in India. Upon
patent application filing in India, the inventor can request for an International patent
application within twelve months of the date from the filing of the first patent
application.
Any person who is a resident in India will not apply for the grant of the patent for
an invention outside India from the concerned authority or controller until the
following conditions are satisfied. They are
An application for a patent for the corresponding invention has been performed
in India, which should not be less than six weeks for making the application
outside India.
No direction is givenunder sub-section(1)ofsection35concerning the application
in India, or all such directions have been revoked.
The controller can dispose of application in case if the invention is relevant for
defence purpose or atomic energy, the grant of permission from the central government
is not approved.
1. Promote innovation
2. Encourage global trade
3. Protect inventors' rights
4. Simplify patent procedures
5. Foster cooperation among nations
9Q.DOUBLE PATENTING:
Double patenting prevents the same inventor or owner form obtaining a second
patent on the same invention or an obvious variant thereof. Double patenting only
concerns cases of two or more patents or applications with common inventors or
owners.
Double patenting occurs when two or more patents are granted for the same
invention or substantially similar inventions, often to the same inventor or assignee.
This can happen due to:
4. Invalidation of patents
Criteria for restriction: The examiner must show the application claims independent
or distinct inventions and examining all claimed inventions in a single application
would be a serious burden. A restriction may be required in a divisional application,
even though inventions were grouped together in a requirement in a parent application.
Restriction procedure–
10Q.PATENT SEARCHING:
After choosing that you can search for patents or applications published based
on any of the following search parameters:
Applicant Name Search: The Indian patent search database allows you to search for
patent applications/patents by entering the name of the applicant against the relevant
row. All you have to do is enter the Applicant's name and press search. The result will
display the title of all inventions published or granted in the name that you entered.
Inventor Name Search: Similar to the applicant name search, you can also search the
name in the relevant row and the result display.
In addition to the above searches, you can perform various search queries to
retrieve the results based on your requirements. You may also read the 'Help' provided
on the tab to learnmoreabouthowtouseBooleanoperatorsandWildcards.Ifyouarefamiliar
withUSPTO patent searchor WIPO patentsearch, you can easily conduct the
patentsearch in India.
Patent E-register
The Indian patent search database allows you to the check the legal status of the
granted patent.Inthe 'Patent E-register'tab, enterthe patent number along the displayed
code and click to Show E-register. The result will display the legal status of the patent,
date next renewal date, and Bibliographic data of patent.
Application Status
Similar to patent grant search, the Indian patent search database allows you to
check the status of the patent application. In the 'Application Status' tab, enter the
application number along withthe displayed code and click on 'Show
ApplicationStatus'. The result will displaythedetailsofapplicationsuchasapplication
number, applicant number, dateoffiling, priority date, title of the invention, publication
date and also application status. Besides, you will be able to view all the documents
relevant to the patent application in the 'View Documents' tab provided at the bottom
page of result.
1. Google Patents
OFCOUNTRIESBYFILINGAN"INTERNATIONAL"PATENTAPPLICATION.SUCHANAPPLICATION
MAYBEFILEDBYANYONEWHOISANATIONALORRESIDENTOFAPCTCONTRACTINGSTATE .IT
The Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) standardizes how patent applications are
filed, allowing inventors and business owners to protect their inventions in 150
countries at the same time. As a result, anyone with a novel idea can safeguard it by
filing a single internationalpatent application rather than multiple nationaland
regionalpatent applications.
The Advantages of PCT for Inventors
Applying for PCT confers significant benefits for patents because it is administered
by the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO).
The PCT establishes a streamlined procedure for filing patent applications in each
country that has agreed to process PCT applications. As a result, the treaty makes a
wide range of technical knowledge and information related to those inventions more
accessible to the public.
The PCT has increased the likelihood of the patent office granting protection.
Currently, there are an estimated 156 contracted countries worldwide, including the
United Arab Emirates.
It is essential to remember that just because a PCT application is referred to as
an "international patent application," that does not mean that all contracting states
willgrant the patent automatically.
Ingeneral, there is no suchthingasaglobalpatent. Tobe moreprecise, a"patent"
isa privilege or right granted by each country or region. Whether or not a PCT
application is granted depends on the national or regional law in each country.
ThePCT applicationmust be filed byacertaindate forthe innovationto moveontoa
national or regional phase. During this phase, the patent can be evaluated and accepted
based on the laws of the contracting nations where the patent is being sought. This
provides businesses with an abundance of chances to expand their innovation and
global influence.
Insight into the PCT Application Procedure
To begin the patenting process, you must first file an "international
patentapplication" with the appropriate patent office, known as a Receiving Office
(RO).
Youmustfileaninternationalapplication,alsoknownasaPCTapplication.
The application is then filed in the language of the applicable jurisdiction, although a
translation of the application may be required for the international search and
publication procedure.
Expert Insight: This largely depends on the official language of the country of
application and the International Searching Authority tasked with evaluating the
patent.
Prior to an incorrectly assigned PCT filing date, it is vital for the applicant to confirm
that they are nationals of a contracting state.
Intheeventthatthisisnotdone,the"ReceivingOffice,"orRO,maydeclarethe
applications to be repealed or withdrawn within four months of the filing date.
Iftheapplicant'snationalityorplaceofresidencechangesinthefuture,the international
application will remain valid.
Moving Forward:
AfterfilingaPCTapplication,thepatentapplicationisautomaticallyassignedtoallcontracti
Afterfiling,aninternational patentofficecanprovideinformationaboutthepotentialor
patentability of your innovation.
Key features:
Benefits:
1. Cost-effective: Reduce translation and filing costs.
2. Time-efficient: Postpone national phase entry and focus on commercialization.
3. Increased patent coverage: Seek protection in over 150 countries.
4. Improved patent quality: Benefit from international search and examination
reports.
PCT stages:
1. International filing: File the PCT application.
2. International search: Receive the search report.
3. International publication: Application is published.
4. International preliminary examination: Receive the examination report.
5. National phase entry: Enter national phases in selected countries.
The development of strains of plants and crops that are resistant to brought and disease
has also led to an increasing number of patents issued, and attendant litigation. In the
field of “agbiotech”
.
13Q.Invention Developers and Promoters:
Invention developers and promoters play a crucial role in bringing new ideas to life. Here are some
key players:
4. Patent Attorneys: Help protect inventions through patent applications and intellectual property
law.
6. Incubators and Accelerators: Support startups and early-stage companies in developing and
launching inventions.
7. Crowd funding Platforms: Enable inventors to raise funds and generate buzz around their
inventions.
8. Licensing Agents: Connect inventors with companies interested in licensing their inventions.
9. Manufacturing Partners: Help scale up production and bring inventions to market.
10. Marketing and Sales Experts: Assist in promoting and commercializing inventions.
These players work together to transform ideas into successful products and businesses, driving
innovation and progress.