Evaluation of Geriatric Practices: Survey of 213 Patients
Evaluation of Geriatric Practices: Survey of 213 Patients
12(11), 1443-1452
Article DOI:10.21474/IJAR01/19961
DOI URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.21474/IJAR01/19961
RESEARCH ARTICLE
EVALUATION OF GERIATRIC PRACTICES: SURVEY OF 213 PATIENTS
The high level of care required by the elderly places a heavy burden on economies.
Morocco, like other countries around the world, has been facing the phenomenon of geriatrics linked to an ageing
population for many years. The proportion of this population is expected to rise to 11.5% by 2030. [1]
Aging is nothing more than a decline in the capacity and performance of the various organs and the functions that
depend on them, with a reduction in the subject's ability to adapt. Added to this are the many chronic diseases that
are likely to decompensate during the course of an intercurrent acute pathology.
Our project arose from the observation that efforts in the field of geriatrics in Morocco remain too timid, and also
from the paucity of Moroccan studies on drug consumption in the elderly and its consequences. We therefore set
1443
Corresponding Author:-I. Zhim
Address:-Pharmacy Unit, Mohammed V Military Training Hospital.
ISSN: 2320-5407 Int. J. Adv. Res. 12(11), 1443-1452
ourselves the main objective of our study, a comprehensive and detailed geriatric assessment at the pharmacy
counter.
In order to carry out our work, we included all patients aged fifty or over presenting themselves at the pharmacy
counter for one of the following purposes: seeking prescription treatment, asking for advice, self-medication or all
three.
Anyone under the age of fifty was excluded, as were all elderly subjects whose cognitive abilities did not allow them
to answer the questions.
The answers collected from the oral interview, based on the components of the standardized global geriatric
assessment proposed by the professional version of the MSD Manual (Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp., a subsidiary of
Merck & Co., Inc., Kenilworth, NJ, USA), were entered into Microsoft EXCEL and then processed using EPI INFO
software version 7.2.2.6.
Anonymity and confidentiality were ensured at the time of data collection, and patient names were not included in
the information collected.
Results:-
During this period, we collected 213 operating forms, representing a significant sample of the number of elderly
people admitted to the pharmacy counter. Our patients were questioned on several points, which we chose to
present mainly under five headings after data collection.
1444
ISSN: 2320-5407 Int. J. Adv. Res. 12(11), 1443-1452
Socio-professional activity, physical autonomy, patient loyalty to their GP, as well as abuse and bad habits, are all
points to which our patients responded, and which we have also included in this first section dedicated to general
geriatric assessment data (Table III).
Table III:- Association of general geriatric data with age.
Professional activity workforce Total prevalences Cumulative 95% confidence
percentages intervals
yes 10 4,69% 4,69% 2,27%-8,46%
No 203 95,31% 100,00% 91,54%-97,73%
Total 213 100,00% 100,00% -
Fixed prescriber Workforce Total prevalences Cumulative 95% confidence
percentages intervals
No 24 11,27% 11,27% 7,35%-16,30%
yes 189 88,73% 100,00% 83,70%-92,65%
Total 213 100,00% 100,00% -
Physical autonomy Workforce Total prevalences Cumulative 95% confidence
percentages intervals
Assigned 22 10,33% 10,33% 6,59%-15,22%
Normal 191 89,67% 100,00% 84,78%-93,41%
Total 213 100,00% 100,00% -
Aging is certainly a risk factor for many pathologies. With age, the accumulation of diseases and their interactions
within a given individual leads to polypathology. This phenomenon was observed in most of our patients, and is
presented in the second section.
Analysis of our results showed statistical significance for the associations: Age-Pathologies (figureIII), Age-
Polypathology/Polymedication, Polypathology-Chronic diseases of old age (table V).
1445
ISSN: 2320-5407 Int. J. Adv. Res. 12(11), 1443-1452
Table V:- Analysis of associations between polypathology and diseases of old age.
Analysis tools Exposure variables (explanatory)
Statistics
Diabetes I Diabetes II HTA Angor/IDM
Statistical Uncorrected X2 - 0,7105 13,1016 -
significance of X2 tests Observed
the P-value - 0,3992778818 0,0002950423 -
association Yates X2 1,0357 - - 4,1163
correction Observed
P-value 0,3088315964 - - 0,0424707475
Test Exact P-one- 0,1534933130 0,2658471636 0,0001920847 0,0096575445
de Fisher sided
value
P-value 0,2656197138 0,5389144209 0,0002831682 0,0171902505
bilateral
Kurska- H value 7,3571 4,5247 24,0672 10,8942
Walis test P-value 0,0067 0,0334 0,0000 0,0010
Strength of Odds Ratio OR 2,5974 1,4415 4,9349 Non défini*
the IC à 95% 0,5855- 0,6139- 3,3851
1,9487- Non défini*
association 11,5224 12,4972
Relative RR 2,3226 1,3650 3,9768 Non défini*
risk IC à 95% 0,5900- 9,1436 0,6540- 2,8489
1,7176- Non défini*
9,2077
Excess risk RD% 9,7969 4,6349 18,2254 18,0851
IC à 95% -1,4728 à -5,5777 à 9,0569 à 12,5831 à
21,0666 14,8475 27,3939 23,5871
*OR, RR and their 95% CIs not defined because at least one observed number in the contingency table is
zero.
MI = Myocardial infarction.
1446
ISSN: 2320-5407 Int. J. Adv. Res. 12(11), 1443-1452
In summary, polypathology in the elderly requires a management approach that takes into account the complexity of
the situation, since it is often associated with increased drug consumption: the subject of section III.
1447
ISSN: 2320-5407 Int. J. Adv. Res. 12(11), 1443-1452
This increased drug consumption is justified by the polypathology and specific symptoms affecting this segment of
the population. This can only expose our patients to iatrogenic risks. In this respect, we have attempted to develop
the consequences of poly-medication, as well as the various drug-related problems, in section IV.
Table VI:- Descriptive statistics for polymedication in the geriatric population surveyed.
Polymedication: Qualitative aspect (patients on 5 or more molecules)
Presence of Workforce Total prevalences Cumulative 95% confidence
polymedication percentages intervals
No 155 72,77% 72,77% 66,27% - 78,63%
yes 58 27,23% 100,00% 21,37% - 33,73%
Total 213 100,00% 100,00% -
Table VII:- Descriptive statistics for medication use in the geriatric population surveyed.
Polymedication: Quantitative aspect
Number of Workforce Total prevalences(n=213) Cumulative 95% confidence
molecules per percentages intervals
patient
0* 1 0,47% 0,47% 0,01-2,59%
1 29 13,62% 14,08% 9,31-18,96%
2 49 23,00% 37,09% 17,53-29,05%
1448
ISSN: 2320-5407 Int. J. Adv. Res. 12(11), 1443-1452
Table VIII:- Numbers and prevalence of certain drug-related problems in polymedication patients.
Drug-related problems associated with Workforce Relative Total prevalences
polymedication prevalences* (nT=213)
Overdose (n=16) 3 18,75% 1,41%
Risk of drug-drug interactions (n=179) 57 31,84% 26,76%
Risk of drug-food interaction (n=181) 54 29,83% 25,35%
Non-adherence (n=66) 21 31,82% 9,86%
Potentially inappropriate medications in 42 34,15% 19,72%
elderly subjects (n=123)
Drugs to be used with caution in elderly 37 39,78% 17,37%
subjects (n=93)
*Relative prevalences: nT = Total number of patients with the drug problem.
Discussion:-
The results of our study go hand in hand with the results of several studies carried out in this direction, moreover the
age range most represented in our series is 65 to 74 years, and the average age noted was 66 years. This was cited by
the Haute Autorité de Santé in its methodological note (based on INSEE 2013 data) [2], of "la prise en charge des
personnes âgées polypathologiques en soins primaires", which had noted an increase in the population of patients
aged 65 or over, and that on January 1, 2013, 17.5% of the French elderly population were over 65. The female
predominance also observed in our study is the same on an international scale, with the Institut National de la
1449
ISSN: 2320-5407 Int. J. Adv. Res. 12(11), 1443-1452
Statistique et des Etudes Economiques (INSEE), which collects, analyzes and disseminates information on the
French economy and society, making the same observation, on the preponderance of women in the elderly
population, in a report on senior citizens published in 2019.[3]The link between normal aging and age-related
diseases has been the subject of several studies in the field of geriatrics. For example, the 1986 study by Jacob A.
BRODY and Edward L. SCHNEIDER classified diseases diagnosed in the elderly as age-related and age-dependent.
[4]
In our survey, 84.04% of elderly people had two or more diseases, compared with 15.96% who had no associated
defects. This result is similar to that of Z. Mokrani [5], who found that elderly people had an average of 2.4
pathologies, with cardiovascular pathology predominating at 70.6%. No link was found between gender and the risk
of cardiovascular disease or diabetes.
Typically afflicted with chronic diseases, defined by the WHO as "health problems that require long-term care (over
a number of years or decades), their common feature is that they systematically affect the social, psychological and
economic dimensions of the patient's life" [6], the elderly require medication to manage these conditions. As a
result, these patients often have several prescriptions, which may come from different doctors, and are sometimes
self-medicated. In addition to the risks associated with polypathology, there are also those associated with
polymedication and iatrogenic medication.
This is explained by the fact that the elderly become more sensitive to drug interactions and their adverse effects
than younger subjects, due to the effects of aging on the body and less resistance to drug aggression. Indeed,
physiological aging leads to changes in drug pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic parameters. An American
study showed that 18% of people over 65 took at least 10 drugs a day [7].in our study, two participants reporting 11
pathologies were the only ones to take 11 and 14 drugs a day. Their polymedication was associated with
polypathology and chronic morbidities (type 1 diabetes, angina/myocardial infarction, dyslipidemia, arterial
hypertension): these elements are risk factors for polymedication according to the analysis of our results.
Overall, the prevalence of diseases in the elderly varies between geriatric surveys. Sample size, selected geriatric age
threshold, study setting, institutions where participants are collected, time and geographical area are all factors that
influence the prevalence of diseases of old age and the strength of the association that may exist between age and
pathologies. A comparison of our results with 2011 data from the Caisse Nationale de l'Assurance Maladie des
Travailleurs Salariés (CNAMTS, France) [8] shows that the average number of diseases increases with age, with
patients aged 75 and over accumulating the most diseases. The difference in the average number of pathologies
observed in the two studies highlights the vulnerability of the Moroccan geriatric patient population. These
differences can be explained in part by the nature of the diseases included in the study.
Polymedication is one of the major problems in geriatrics, where numerous studies associate advancing age with
polymedication in both qualitative and quantitative terms. The analysis of our results is in line with data from the
2018 National Survey of Family Health Protection in Morocco (ENPSF) [9], which revealed the absence of
correlation associating polymedication with age and gender.
Drug iatrogenicity - defined by the WHO as any harmful and unintended response to a drug that occurs at doses
used for prophylactic, therapeutic or diagnostic purposes [10]; and the risk of drug interactions, are the
consequences of this polymedication that intertwine and revolve around non-adherence to treatment. Thus, good
adherence is not an end in itself, but a good tool for ensuring therapeutic satisfaction. The term "treatment
adherence" is increasingly used to avoid the controversial image of non-adherence, which reflects a certain
discordance in the doctor-patient relationship. Adherence in the elderly is a highly complex behavior that is difficult
to assess, due to the heterogeneity of the diseases and populations studied, the absence of conventional methods
defining a "gold standard", and the scarcity of studies on the adherence of elderly patients to treatment [11]. There is
still a tendency to link adherence to the patient's adapted and active behaviour alone, but this overlooks the main
components [12], which govern patient adherence to treatment, namely: the patient, the prescriber and the
pharmacist.
The patient:
Poor patient compliance with treatment is often involuntary, but can sometimes be intentional. Elderly patients, by
taking medication throughout the day without understanding the purpose of each treatment, end up taking some that
1450
ISSN: 2320-5407 Int. J. Adv. Res. 12(11), 1443-1452
they find useless, especially in the absence of symptoms or signs of improvement between the time the medication is
taken and the onset of effect. Adherence is therefore an interpersonal process in which the patient's motivation to
maintain treatment cannot be ensured without organization and discipline, which themselves depend on conditions
linked to: the disease, the treatment, the patient and the relationship of trust between patient and healthcare
professionals. [10]
Prescriber:
An observational study [13] in which the adherence of 100 elderly, multi-medicated hospitalized patients was
monitored in two phases: at the time of hospitalization and three months after discharge. The results of this study
confirm the decrease in adherence to treatment, from 45% at the time of hospitalization to 30% three months after
discharge. Hospitalization was also and reciprocally linked to a high risk of iatrogenic drug interactions. In a
literature review by the French National Authority for Health (HAS), 5.2% of hospital admissions are linked to
iatrogenic accidents, with the rate of drug interactions ranging from 16.6% to 60.6% of cases [14]. According to the
same source, the errors leading to iatrogenic accidents are mainly linked to inappropriate prescriptions for both
hospitalized and home-care patients, with errors in drug administration being added when the patient is hospitalized.
The pharmacist
Pharmacists play a key role in reinforcing therapeutic adherence. In the hospital setting, close collaboration between
physicians and clinical pharmacists is the key to successfully combining appropriate therapeutic choice with
restrictions on inappropriate prescribing and improved adherence. In the dispensary, rigorous prescription analysis,
appropriate advice and the clarification of adverse effects and other drug-related problems considerably improve
adherence. Nevertheless, errors in reading and interpreting prescriptions, the infrequency or absence of drug
histories at the pharmacy counter due to lack of time, and the lack of access to the patient's medical file, reduce the
quality of the dispensing act. The sale of certain pharmaceutical or parapharmaceutical products without a medical
prescription further encourages the occurrence of drug interactions. [12]
As we have just seen, an overall geriatric assessment provides a general view of the elderly person and all his or her
difficulties. This will then enable the frail person to be referred to the appropriate healthcare professionals, with
possible intervention from socialservices to try and manage these difficulties as best as possible.
Conclusion:-
Given the multitude of social, medical, and psychological issues that interlink in sick elderly individuals, it is
necessary to propose comprehensive care and develop interventions that reduce the prevalence of these diseases,
slow their progression, and delay the onset of functional dependency. It is important to note that the primary
1451
ISSN: 2320-5407 Int. J. Adv. Res. 12(11), 1443-1452
objective of geriatric care is to reduce both the prevalence of disability and diseases related to aging and to enhance
the quality of life for the elderly. This will lead to improved geriatric care offerings and the strengthening of
professional skills among healthcare personnel. In Morocco, the Ministry of Health has implemented a national
strategy aimed at universalizing access to healthcare and combating territorial inequalities through the appropriate
rationalization of healthcare expenditures, which will favor improvements in research, innovation, and access to
healthcare structures, particularly geriatric ones. A multidisciplinary partnership program (both national and
international) has been established. This has led to improved geriatric care offerings, enhanced professional
competencies, and the establishment of a national strategy in geriatrics. However, there remains a need to develop
more geriatric evaluation indicators, beyond those related to old-age diseases, to address the social coverage of the
elderly, the coverage rate by geriatric practitioners, and the number of geriatric structures.
References:-
[1] Haut-Commissariat au Plan du Maroc. National Survey on the Elderly in Moroc
Survey Report. [Online]. 2006. Accessed September 15, 2020. Available at:
https://www.hcp.ma/file/103241/.
[2] Haute Autorité de Santé (HAS), France. www.has-santé.fr. [Online].; 2015. Acceso 9 de Septembre de
2020. Disponible en: https://www.has-
sante.fr/upload/docs/application/pdf/201504/note_methodologique_polypathologie_de_la_personne_agee.pdf.
[3] Institut National de la Statistique et des Etudes Economiques (INSEE), France. www.insee.fr. [Online];
2019. Acceso 25 de 09de 2020. Disponible en:
https://www.insee.fr/fr/statistiques/4238381?sommaire=4238781#:~:text=Au%201er%20janvier%202019,soit%202
0%20%25%20de%20la%20population.&text=La%20vie%20%C3%A0%20domicile%20demeure,les%20nonag%C
3%A9naires%20(figure%201).
[4] Brody JA, Schneider EL. Diseases and disorders of aging: An hypothesis. J Chronic Dis. 1986; 39(11): p.
871-876.
[5] Z.Mokrani et al. Analyse épidémiologique des patients âgés de plus de 75 ans, admis
aux urgences du centre hospitalier de Salon-De-Provence ne disposant pas d’équipe
mobile de gériatrie. JEUR 2009 ; 03 : 264.
[6] « Former les personnels de santé du XXIe siècle : le défi des maladies chroniques ».Available at: _271 Insides
FR 12jun.indd
[7] Budnitz DS, Lovegrove MC, Shehab N, Richards CL. Emergency hospitalizations
for adverse drug events in older Americans. N Engl J Med 2011;365:2002–12.
[8] Haute Autorité de Santé. Prendre en charge une personne âgée polypathologique en soins primaires,
2015. Note méthodologique et de synthèse documentaire. HAS, Service communication – information.
[9] Ministère de la Santé, Direction de la Planification et des Ressources Financières, Division de la
Planification et des Etudes. Enquête Nationale sur la Population et la Santé Familiale (ENPSF) 2018.
Rabat, Maroc:, Service des Etudes et de l'Information Sanitaire.
Schwartz RH. The war on drugs. New Engl J Med, 1994, 331, 126-127.
[10] schneider MP, Locca JF, Bugnon O, et al. L’adhésion thérapeutique du patient âgé ambulatoire : quels
detereminants et quel soutien ? Revue Médicale Suisse, 2006, 56, 664-670
[11]
[12] Petermans J, Samalea Suarez A, Van Hees T. Observance thérapeutique en gériatrie. Rev Med Liège.
2010; 65: p. 5-6.
[13] Pasina L, Brucato AL, Falcone C, Cucchi E, Bresciani A, Sottocorno M, et al. Medication Non-
Adherence Among Elderly Patients Newly Discharged and Receiving Polypharmacy. Drugs Aging. 2014;
31(4): p. 283-9.
[14] Haute Autorité de Santé, Legrain S. Consommation Médicamenteuse chez le Sujet Agé : Consommation,
Prescription, Iatrogénie et Observance.; 2005. Acceso 12 de Juin de 2021. Disponible en: https://has-
sante.fr/upload/docs/application/pdf/pmsa_synth_biblio_2006_08_28__16_44_51_580.pdf.
[15] Oudrhiri M. Doctinews. [Online]; 2010. Acceso 14 de Juinde 2021. Disponible en:
https://www.doctinews.com/index.php/archives/38-fondamentaux/250-medication-et-seniors-comment-
mieux-prescrire-chez-la-personne-agee.
1452