LECTURE 8.

Modes of Speciation

Speciation is the evolutionary process by which new biological species arise. There are four

modes of natural speciation, based on the extent to which speciating populations are

geographically isolated from one another: allopatric, peripatric, parapatric, and sympatric.

Speciation may also be induced artificially, through animal husbandry or laboratory experiments.

Observed examples of each kind of speciation are provided throughout. [1]

Natural speciation

All forms of natural speciation have taken place over the course of evolution, though it still

remains a subject of debate as to the relative importance of each mechanism in driving

biodiversity. [2]

There is debate as to the rate at which speciation events occur over geologic time. While some

evolutionary biologists claim that speciation events have remained relatively constant over time,

some palaeontologists such as Niles Eldredge and Stephen Jay Gould have argued that species

usually remain unchanged over long stretches of time, and that speciation occurs only over

relatively brief intervals, a view known as punctuated equilibrium.

Allopatric speciation

During allopatric speciation, a population splits into two geographically isolated allopatric

populations (for example, by habitat fragmentation due to geographical change such as

mountain building or social change such as emigration). The isolated populations then undergo

genotypic and/or phenotypic divergence as they (a) become subjected to dissimilar selective

pressures or (b) they independently undergo genetic drift. When the populations come back
into contact, they have evolved such that they are reproductively isolated and are no longer

capable of exchanging genes.

Observed instances

Island genetics, the tendency of small, isolated genetic pools to produce unusual traits, has

been observed in many circumstances, including insular dwarfism and the radical changes

among certain famous island chains, like Komodo and Galápagos, the latter having given rise to

the modern expression of evolutionary theory, after being observed by Charles Darwin. Perhaps

the most famous example of allopatric speciation is Darwin's Galápagos Finches.

Peripatric

In peripatric speciation, new species are formed in isolated, small peripheral populations which

are prevented from exchanging genes with the main population. It is related to the concept of a

founder effect, since small populations often undergo bottlenecks. Genetic drift is often

proposed to play a significant role in peripatric speciation.

Observed instances

 Mayr bird fauna

 The Australian bird Petroica multicolor

 Reproductive isolation occurs in populations of Drosophila subject to population

bottlenecking

The London Underground mosquito is a variant of the mosquito Culex pipiens which entered in

the London Underground in the nineteenth century. Evidence for its speciation include genetic

divergence, behavioral differences, and difficulty in mating.[3]

In parapatric speciation, the zones of two diverging populations are separate but do overlap.

There is only partial separation afforded by geography, so individuals of each species may come

in contact or cross the barrier from time to time, but reduced fitness of the heterozygote leads

to selection for behaviours or mechanisms which prevent breeding between the two species.

Ecologists refer to parapatric and peripatric speciation in terms of ecological niches. A niche

must be available in order for a new species to be successful.

Observed instances

 Ring species

o The Larus gulls form a ring species around the North Pole.

o The Ensatina salamanders, which form a ring round the Central Valley in California.

o The Greenish Warbler (Phylloscopus trochiloides), around the Himalayas.

 the grass Anthoxanthum has been known to undergo parapatric speciation in such cases as

mine contamination of an area.

Sympatric

In sympatric speciation, species diverge while inhabiting the same place. Often cited examples

of sympatric speciation are found in insects which become dependent on different host plants

in the same area. However, the existence of sympatric speciation as a mechanism of speciation

is still hotly contested. People have argued that the evidences of sympatric speciation are in

fact examples of micro-allopatric, or heteropatric speciation. The most widely accepted

example of sympatric speciation is that of the cichlids of Lake Nabugabo in East Africa, which is

thought to be due to sexual selection. Sympatric speciation refers to the formation of two or
more descendant species from a single ancestral species all occupying the same geographic

location.

Until recently, there has a been a dearth of hard evidence that supports this form of speciation,

with a general feeling that interbreeding would soon eliminate any genetic differences that

might appear. But there has been at least one recent study that suggests that sympatric

speciation has occurred in Tennessee cave salamanders. [4]

The three-spined sticklebacks, freshwater fishes, that have been studied by Dolph Schluter

(who received his Ph.D. for his work on Darwin's finches with Peter Grant) and his current

colleagues in British Columbia, provide an intriguing example that is best explained by

sympatric speciation. They have found:

 Two different species of three-spined sticklebacks in each of five different lakes.

o a large benthic species with a large mouth that feeds on large prey in the littoral zone

o a smaller limnetic species — with a smaller mouth — that feeds on the small plankton in

open water.

 DNA analysis indicates that each lake was colonized independently, presumably by a

marine ancestor, after the last ice age.

 DNA analysis also shows that the two species in each lake are more closely related to

each other than they are to any of the species in the other lakes.

 Nevertheless, the two species in each lake are reproductively isolated; neither mates with

the other.

 However, aquarium tests showed that

lakes and

o likewise the limnetic species from the different lakes will spawn with each other.

o These benthic and limnetic species even display their mating preferences when presented

with sticklebacks from Japanese lakes; that is, a Canadian benthic prefers a Japanese benthic

over its close limnetic cousin from its own lake.

 Their conclusion: in each lake, what began as a single population faced such competition

for limited resources that

o disruptive selection — competition favoring fishes at either extreme of body size and

mouth size over those nearer the mean — coupled with

o assortative mating — each size preferred mates like it - favored a divergence into two

subpopulations exploiting different food in different parts of the lake.

o The fact that this pattern of speciation occurred the same way on three separate occasions

suggests strongly that ecological factors in a sympatric population can cause speciation.

Sympatric speciation driven by ecological factors may also account for the extraordinary

diversity of crustaceans living in the depths of Siberia's Lake Baikal.

Speciation via polyploidization

Speciation via polyploidy: A diploid cell undergoes failed meiosis, producing diploid gametes,

which self-fertilize to produce a tetraploid zygote. Example is IITA’s polyploidy cassava.

Polyploidy is a mechanism often attributed to causing some speciation events in sympatry. Not

all polyploids are reproductively isolated from their parental plants, so an increase in

chromosome number may not result in the complete cessation of gene flow between the

incipient polyploids and their parental diploids (see also hybrid speciation).

Polyploidy is observed in many species of both plants and animals. In fact, it has been proposed

that all of the existing plants and most of the animals are polyploids or have undergone an

event of polyploidization in their evolutionary history.

Hybridization between two different species sometimes leads to a distinct phenotype. This

phenotype can also be fitter than the parental lineage and as such natural selection may then

favor these individuals. Eventually, if reproductive isolation is achieved, it may lead to a

separate species. However, reproductive isolation between hybrids and their parents is

particularly difficult to achieve and thus hybrid speciation is considered an extremely rare

event.

Reinforcement

Reinforcement is the process by which natural selection increases reproductive isolation.[5] It

may occur after two populations of the same species are separated and then come back into

contact. If their reproductive isolation was complete, then they will have already developed

into two separate incompatible species. If their reproductive isolation is incomplete, then

further mating between the populations will produce hybrids, which may or may not be fertile.

If the hybrids are infertile, or fertile but less fit than their ancestors, then there will be no

further reproductive isolation and speciation has essentially occurred (e.g., as in horses and

donkeys.) The reasoning behind this is that if the parents of the hybrid offspring each have

naturally selected traits for their own certain environments, the hybrid offspring will bear traits

from both, therefore would not fit either ecological niche as well as the parents did. The low

fitness of the hybrids would cause selection to favor assortative mating, which would control

hybridization. If the hybrid offspring are more fit than their ancestors, then the populations will

merge back into the same species within the area they are in contact.
Reinforcement is required for both parapatric and sympatric speciation. Without

reinforcement, the geographic area of contact between different forms of the same species,

called their "hybrid zone," will not develop into a boundary between the different species.

Hybrid zones are regions where diverged populations meet and interbreed. Hybrid offspring are

very common in these regions, which are usually created by diverged species coming into

secondary contact. Without reinforcement the two species would have uncontrollable

inbreeding. Reinforcement may be induced in artificial selection experiments as described

below.

Artificial speciation

New species have been created by domesticated animal husbandry, but the initial dates and

methods of the initiation of such species are not clear. For example, domestic sheep were

created by hybridisation, and no longer produce viable offspring with Ovis orientalis, one

species from which they are descended.[6] Domestic cattle, on the other hand, can be

considered the same species as several varieties of wild ox, gaur, yak, etc., as they readily

produce fertile offspring with them.[7]

The best-documented creations of new species in the laboratory were performed in the late

1980s. William Rice and G.W. Salt bred fruit flies, Drosophila melanogaster, using a maze with

three different choices of habitat such as light/dark and wet/dry. Each generation was placed

into the maze, and the groups of flies which came out of two of the eight exits were set apart to

breed with each other in their respective groups. After thirty-five generations, the two groups

and their offspring were isolated reproductively because of their strong habitat preferences:
they mated only within the areas they preferred, and so did not mate with flies that preferred

the other areas. [8]

Diane Dodd was also able to show allopatric speciation by reproductive isolation in Drosophila

pseudoobscura fruit flies after only eight generations using different food types, starch and

maltose.[9] Dodd's experiment has been easy for many others to replicate, including with other

kinds of fruit flies and foods.[10]

The Drosophila experiment conducted by Diane Dodd in 1989.

The history of such attempts is described in Rice and Hostert (1993).[11]

Hybrid speciation

Hybridization between two different species sometimes leads to a distinct phenotype. This

phenotype can also be fitter than the parental lineage and as such natural selection may then

favor these individuals. Eventually, if reproductive isolation is achieved, it may lead to a

separate species. However, reproductive isolation between hybrids and their parents is

particularly difficult to achieve and thus hybrid speciation is considered an extremely rare

event. The Mariana Mallard arose from hybrid speciation.

Polyploid speciation, which involves changes in chromosome number, is a more common

phenomena, especially in plant species.

Gene transposition as a cause

Theodosius Dobzhansky, who studied fruit flies in the early days of genetic research in 1930s,

speculated that parts of chromosomes that switch from one location to another might cause a

species to split into two different species. He mapped out how it might be possible for sections

of chromosomes to relocate themselves in a genome. Those mobile sections can cause sterility

in inter-species hybrids, which can act as a speciation pressure. In theory, his idea was sound,

but scientists long debated whether it actually happened in nature. Eventually a competing

theory involving the gradual accumulation of mutations was shown to occur in nature so often

that geneticists largely dismissed the moving gene hypothesis.[13]

However, recent research shows that jumping of a gene from one chromosome to another can

contribute to the birth of new species.[14] This validates the reproductive isolation mechanism, a

key component of speciation.[15]

Interspersed repeats

Interspersed repetitive DNA sequences function as isolating mechanisms. These repeats protect newly

evolving gene sequences from being overwritten by gene conversion, due to the creation of non-

homologies between otherwise homologous DNA sequences. The non-homologies create barriers to

gene conversion. This barrier allows nascent novel genes to evolve without being overwritten by the

progenitors of these genes. This uncoupling allows the evolution of new genes, both within gene
families and also allelic forms of a gene. The importance is that this allows the splitting of a gene pool

without requiring physical isolation of the organisms harboring those gene sequences.