Materials & Welding
Materials selection, welding, forming, Heat treatment, corrossion, NDT
Subscribe to Materials & Welding
Email: Subscribe
Visit this group
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 14, 2009
[MW:1453] Re: Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
When "100 % RT" OR "Full RT" is specified in data sheet, is it require to perform the radiography of
category D joints (nozzle to shell joint) ?
Regards,
Santosh
Sent by:
[email protected] To: <
[email protected]>
cc: <
[email protected]>
Subject: [MW:1443] Re: Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
01/10/2009 05:41 PM
Please respond to materials-welding
Yes.. I agree with the below answer..
To add it further..
Let us consider a cylinder on a vessel for a certain length and it has 4 Cir.
Seams and 4 Long. seams.
If the vessel calls for FULL radiography, then a spot ( i repeat a spot, means
not Spot radiography, it is aportion, say 100 to 200mm ) on all the 4 cir
seams, 4 long. seams have to be radiographed and all the T joints have to be
Radiographed.
If the vessel calls for 100% radiography, then the entire length of the Butt
joint welds have to be radiographed (thro full length).
Regards,
Prabhakar.H
On Fri, Jan 9, 2009 at 10:47 AM, Bathula Raghuram (Mumbai - PIPING)
<[email protected]> wrote:
Yes, it is true that in case of vessels designed as per ULT all butt welds are subjected to 100%
RT (note that name plate marking will also be RT1 in this case and in addition ULT under U
stamping will marked to distinguish)
However in case of UCS the term Full is meant as defined in UW11 and marked as RT-1 on
nameplate, as I said it is up to designer to specify/define 100%RT along with a note on the
datasheet.
In case of div 2 the 2007 Ed specifies in terms of % only for each type if joint (refer table 7.2)
I will try to compile and post the complete data on joint efficiency and RT markings as and
when time permits (if any body have pressure points published in year 2001 or 2002, you may
share. There was a clear explanation on this issue)
edfarman chan
Sent: Thursday, January 08, 2009 5:59 PM
To:
[email protected]Subject: Re: [Pressure Vessel] Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
Dear Bathula,
Actually ASME VIII-1 also specify the term of 100% radiography.
I found this wording some in ASME, for example:
<AA> Part UW Reqr't for PV Fabri'd by Weldings
UW-52, see at the last sentence of note.
100% RT shall be applied while the previous spot result radiographically disclosed
welds defects must be eliminated.
<BB> Part ULW,
See section ULT-57 Examination, all butt joints shall be examined by 100% radiography (for
me it means UW-11) except as permitted by UW-11 (a) (7) (for me that means UT instead of
Full or 100% RT).
Re to your response, it look like both of "100% RT" and "Full RT" have a different meaning.
If yes, then I believe, ASME should specify the detail terminology of 100% RT at least at the
same way of this code specified Full RT at section UW-11.
Unfortunaltely so far I can't find it. (That what i'm asking for in my query mail below).
Refer to the above references, in my humble opinion this 100% RT should be the same meaning
of Full RT.
However thank for your response and please have futher discussion if don't mind.
On 1/8/09, Bathula Raghuram (Mumbai - PIPING) <[email protected]> wrote:
No such requirement as 100% in ASME Sec VIII div1, you may refer UW11 for Full RT
requirements. Here there are some joints exmpted from RT even you specify as FULL. It
depends on designers specific requirements, whether to apply 100% or Full. In my opinion if the
datasheet specifies 100% all buttwelds shall be RT'ed irrespective of exmeptions given in UW11
(a).
edfarman chan
Sent: Thursday, January 08, 2009 4:45 PM
To:
[email protected]Subject: [Pressure Vessel] Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
Dears,
Does "Full RT" and "100% RT" has the same meaning of Radiography Test?
If NOT - which section of ASME Sect. VIII Div.1 (or 2 or 3) that describe in detail description
for both "Full RT" and "100% RT"?
Thanks & Regards,
edfarman
Regards,
edf
__._,_.___
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected]
For more options, visit this group's bolg at http://materials-welding.blogspot.com/
The views expressed/exchnaged in this group are members personel views and meant for educational
purposes only, Users must take their own decisions w.r.t. applicable code/standard/contract documents.
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
Posted by BR at 5:13 PM
Email This BlogThis! Share to Twitter Share to Facebook Share to Google Buzz
0 comments:
Post a Comment
Newer Post Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
BLOG ARCHIVE
z ► 2006 (1)
{ ► February (1)
z ► 2007 (94)
{ ► September (72)
{ ► October (13)
{ ► November (5)
{ ► December (4)
z ► 2008 (983)
{ ► January (25)
{ ► February (89)
{ ► March (69)
{ ► April (54)
{ ► May (59)
{ ► June (70)
{ ► July (107)
{ ► August (93)
{ ► September (100)
{ ► October (87)
{ ► November (105)
{ ► December (125)
z ▼ 2009 (2497)
{ ▼ January (59)
[MW:1432] Hot Tapping contractors in Abudhabi
[MW:1434] RE: 1432] Hot Tapping contractors in Abu...
[MW:1433] Re: Hot Tapping contractors in Abudhabi
[MW:1435] RE: 1434] RE: 1432] Hot Tapping contract...
[MW:1436] Cladding Pipe Manufacturer
[MW:1437] Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
[MW:1438] Re: Cladding Pipe Manufacturer
[MW:1439] Re: Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
[MW:1440] Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
[MW:1442] Re: Cladding Pipe Manufacturer
[MW:1441] Re: Hot Tapping contractors in Abudhabi
[MW:1444] Re: Cladding Pipe Manufacturer
[MW:1443] Re: Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
[MW:1445] Re: GOST 1050-88 CT 3
[MW:1446] Eq. ASTM Material
[MW:1447] Re: Eq. ASTM Material
[MW:1448] Membership with the groups
[MW:1449] Re: 1432] Hot Tapping contractors in Abu...
[MW:1450] RE: 1448] Membership with the groups
[MW:1451] Re: Eq. ASTM Material
[MW:1452] US Equivalent of Workstoff Nrs.
[MW:1453] Re: Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
[MW:1454] RE: 1453] Re: Radiography Test : FULL Vs...
The whats, whys, and whens of GTAW
Inspection Connection: Radiographic and ultrasonic...
[MW:1455] Re: 1453] Re: Radiography Test : FULL Vs...
[MW:1457] Re: Cladding Pipe Manufacturer
[MW:1456] Re: Radiography Test : FULL Vs 100%
[MW:1458] Level III name & contact required
[MW:1459] Re: Level III name & contact required
[MW:1461] Re: Level III name & contact required
[MW:1460] Re: Level III name & contact required
[MW:1462] Flange dimensions for size above 12" rat...
[MW:1463] RE: 1462] Flange dimensions for size abo...
[MW:1464] Flange dimensions for size above 12" rat...
[MW:1466] Flange dimensions for size above 12" rat...
[MW:1465] RE: 1463] RE: 1462] Flange dimensions fo...
[MW:1467] RE: 1462] Flange dimensions for size abo...
[MW:1468] Welded Joint over sleeper
[MW:1469] radiography of aluminium
[MW:1470] Re: radiography of aluminium
[MW:1471] Re: radiography of aluminium
[MW:1472] Required API 650 personal for Bahrain
[MW:1473] Re: Required API 650 personal for Bahrai...
[MW:1474] Re: Required API 650 personal for Bahrai...
[MW:1475] RE: 1474] Re: Required API 650 personal ...
[MW:1476] Materials Technology Workshop Middle Eas...
[MW:1477] RE: 1475] RE: 1474] Re: Required API 650...
[MW:1478] Required API 653 personal for Bahrain
[MW:1479] CHLORINE INSTITUTE PAMPHLET 6 CLASS II -...
[MW:1480] RE: 1479] CHLORINE INSTITUTE PAMPHLET 6 ...
[MW:1481] RE: 1480] RE: 1479] CHLORINE INSTITUTE P...
[MW:1482] ASME VIII
[MW:1483] RE: 1482] ASME VIII
[MW:1484] RE: 1482] ASME VIII
[MW:1485] HYDRO TEST OF VESSELS
[MW:1486] RE: 1485] HYDRO TEST OF VESSELS
[MW:1487] FW: 1485] HYDRO TEST OF VESSELS
[MW:1490] Dent in pipe
{ ► February (184)
{ ► March (181)
{ ► April (217)
{ ► May (207)
{ ► June (312)
{ ► July (253)
{ ► August (239)
{ ► September (297)
{ ► October (182)
{ ► November (199)
{ ► December (167)
z ► 2010 (5182)
{ ► January (225)
{ ► February (234)
{ ► March (255)
{ ► April (385)
{ ► May (327)
{ ► June (488)
{ ► July (462)
{ ► August (588)
{ ► September (479)
{ ► October (667)
{ ► November (474)
{ ► December (598)
z ► 2011 (2161)
{ ► January (569)
{ ► February (449)
{ ► March (489)
{ ► April (347)
{ ► May (307)
[MW:11170] Re: Pickling Passivation of Hastalloy
[MW:11171] electrode selection
Re: [MW:11172] pittings on surface of Shell
Re: [MW:11173] pittings on surface of Shell
Re: [MW:11174] WATER FILLUP TEST FOR API 650 STORA...
[MW:11175] Renewal of Welder Qualification
[MW:11176] Re: 11128] QW 304: Welders
Re: [MW:11177] pittings on surface of Shell
[MW:11178] Re: pittings on surface of Shell
[MW:11179] Any idea of Twin Tig welding of Duplex ...
[MW:11180] Re: Minimum length of shell
Re: [MW:11181] Any idea of Twin Tig welding of Dup...
Re: [MW:11182] Renewal of Welder Qualification
[MW:11183] I NEED TWI LATEST VERSION COURSE MATTER...
[MW:11184] any one can explain how welding CRACKS ...
[MW:11185] Root Pass Welding
Re: [MW:11186] any one can explain how welding CRA...
[MW:11187] Difference Between Blowing and Purging
Re: [MW:11188] any one can explain how welding CRA...
Re: [MW:11189] any one can explain how welding CRA...
[MW:11190] welding of carbon steel to cast iron
Re: [MW:11191] Renewal of Welder Qualification
Re: [MW:11192] Any idea of Twin Tig welding of Dup...
Re: [MW:11193] Fw: about A335 Gr P11
Re: [MW:11194] any one can explain how welding CRA...
Re: [MW:11195] purging/backing gas...............
Re: [MW:11196] Root Pass Welding
Re: [MW:11197] Difference Between Blowing and Purg...
[MW:11198] RE: 11185] Root Pass Welding
RE: [MW:11199] Root Pass Welding
[MW:11200] RE: 11185] Root Pass Welding
RE: [MW:11201] pittings on surface of Shell
[MW:11202] Welding consumable for CD3Mn
Re: [MW:11203] Root Pass Welding
[MW:11204] Crater distance
[MW:11205] Re: welding of carbon steel to cast iro...
[MW:11206] ARC Blow
RE: [MW:11207] Root Pass Welding
Re: [MW:11208] Renewal of Welder Qualification
[MW:11209] Hydrotest Pressure of Pipe SA 312 TP 30...
RE: [MW:11210] Welding consumable for CD3Mn
RE: [MW:11211] ARC Blow
RE: [MW:11212] Renewal of Welder Qualification
[MW:11213] AISI 4130 MATERIALS
[MW:11214] Re: any one can explain how welding CRA...
Re: [MW:11215] pittings on surface of Shell
Re: [MW:11216] ARC Blow
Re: [MW:11217] AISI 4130 MATERIALS
Re: [MW:11219] any one can explain how welding CRA...
[MW:11218] RE: 11149] Re: Reduction temperature fo...
SEARCH THIS BLOG
Loading...
FOLLOWERS
Simple template. Powered by Blogger.
