Chemists Explore Anti-Acne Potentials
Chemists Explore Anti-Acne Potentials
T. Tukiran
ABSTRAK
ABSTRACT
Syzygium samarangense containing flavonoid compounds have been proven to be beneficial. Previous
research revealed that the aurentiacin, pinocembrin, stercurensin, and uvangoletin as bioactive chemicals were
present in the plant stem bark. These compounds have been found to have excellent antioxidant activity. However,
there has been no research on their potential as anti-melasma and anti-acne agents. This research attempts to look
into these four chemicals potential as anti-melasma tyrosinase inhibitors and anti-acne androgen inhibitors using
biocomputation technology. The study included druglikeness and molecular docking analyses using TYRP1 and
AR proteins with hydroquinone and clascoterone as control drugs. Further analysis was carried out with PASS-
Online predictions to support the potency of compounds. The results indicated that all compounds have the
potential to be effective anti-melasma and anti-acne agents, with pinocembrin (-7.4 kcal/mol for TYRP1; -8.8
kcal/mol for AR) being the most potent compound. These compounds fulfilled Lipinski's druglikeness rules and
were supported by PASSOnline's predictions that they have potential as skin whiteners and androgen antagonists.
However, further research, including in vitro and in vivo studies, is necessary to confirm their potential as anti-
melasma and anti-acne agents.
121
JURNAL KIMIA (JOURNAL OF CHEMISTRY) 18 (2), JULI 2024: 121 - 128
and Huntington (Jin et al., 2024; Yue et al., in the dichloromethane extract of a particular
2024). Tyrosinase enzyme plays a role in this plant fraction, namely aurentiacin,
process and is commonly used as a target for pinocembrin, stercurensin, and uvangoletin, in
hyperpigmentation treatment. There are reports which they have antifungal activity against
of a number of tyrosinase inhibitors being used Candida albicans (Tukiran et al., 2021) and
as both aesthetic and medicinal treatments for a potency as anti-inflammatory agent COX-2
variety of skin disorders and hyperpigmentation inhibitor (Sururi et al., 2022). Based on this
concerns (Kishore et al., 2018; Ashraf et al., report, these compounds can be developed as
2015). Tyrosinase inhibitors possess the ability natural ingredients for anti-acne and anti-
to effectively suppress elevated tyrosinase melasma. The goal of this work was to define
activity, hence assuming a significant possible chemicals from the dichloromethane
therapeutic function as pharmaceutical agents extract in selected fraction as a natural agent for
for many skin conditions. Hydroquinone is a anti-acne inhibitor testosterone and anti-
widely used receptor blocker (Carradori et al., melasma inhibitor tyrosinase as an in silico.
2024), but the use of this synthetic drug has side
effects such as exogenous ochronosis (Olumide MATERIALS AND METHODS
et al., 2008) and cancer (Polynice, 2024;
Shivaram et al., 2024); so that the main Protein Receptor Preparation
alternative is needed from natural materials. Tyrosinase-related protein 1 (TYRP1),
Apart from hyperpigmentation, acne is a which functions as an anti-melanoma receptor
skin problem that almost everyone experiences. and androgen receptor (AR), which functions as
Acne, also known as acne vulgaris, is a an anti-acne receptor, were both downloaded
multifactorial skin disorder that primarily from the RCSB server (rcsb.org). In order to
affects the sebaceous glands and hair follicles prepare a sterile protein and determine the
(Tollenaere et al., 2022; Zaenglein et al., 2016). binding locations (active site), the protein was
It is characterized by the development of generated using Discovery Studio (Sururi et al.,
comedones, papules, pustules, nodules, and 2023).
cysts, which can lead to scarring if left
untreated. The pathogenesis of acne involves a Ligand Preparation
combination of factors such as increased sebum The phytochemicals of the
production, abnormal keratinization, bacterial dichloromethane extract in selected fraction of
colonization (often by Propionibacterium the plant namely pinocembrin, uvangoletin,
acnes), and inflammation (Dréno et al., 2015; stercurensin, and aurentiacin that were reported
Del Rosso et al., 2019), hormonal fluctuations, in previous studies (Tukiran et al., 2021) were
especially during adolescence, playing an used as ligand. The control drugs used to
important role in the development of acne. compare the TYRP1 receptor and the AR
Androgens, like testosterone, stimulate sebum receptor were hydroquinone and clascoterone,
production and contribute to forming respectively. The 3D structure of the ligand was
comedones and inflammatory lesions. Genetic obtained from the PubChem server
factors can also influence a person's (pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) which was then
susceptibility to acne (Bataille et al., 2002; minimized using OpenBabel on the PyRx
Alapatt & Matanaj, 2024). Hence, one way to program to obtain a flexible structure
deal with acne is to block androgen receptors (Pradeepkiran et al., 2016; Sururi et al., 2022).
(Bhat et al., 2017), the topical drug usually
given is clascoterone, a steroid anti- Druglikeness Lipinski Analysis
inflammatory drug (Santhosh & George, 2021). An analysis was done using Lipinski's
The use of this drug has side effects such as five rules to assess the pharmacological
hyperkalemia (Kalabalik-Hoganson et al., properties of compounds in the
2021), so it is needed other alternatives from dichloromethane extract. This approach
natural materials. Plant predicted having the allowed thorough examination of the extract's
potency of that is Semarang Guava plant (S. therapeutic potential and identification of
samarangense), which is a local Indonesian promising compounds for future studies. The
plant. following parameters are part of the rules:
This research is a follow-up to earlier molecular weight (MW) < 500 Da, hydrogen
investigations finding four flavonoid chemicals bond acceptors (HBA) < 10, hydrogen bond
122
Bioinformatics Study: The Potency of Syzygium Samarangense Stem Bark Dichloromethane Extract
as Anti-Melasma and Anti-Acne
(T. Tukiran)
donors (HBD) < 5, molar refractivity (MR) 40– RESULT AND DISCUSSION
130, and lipophilicity < 5 (Lipinski, 2004;
Lipinski et al., 2001). While, Druglikeness The receptors were prepared by
analysis was performed using the Scfbio web removing unnecessary molecules such as water
server (scfbioiitd.res.in) (Jayaram et al., 2012). and other protein chains, and obtaining the
active positions of each receptor using
Molecular Docking and Visualization Discovery Studio. Determination of the active
Molecular docking assays were positions was based on the native ligand
performed using the Vina Wizard (Trott & positions of each receptor, obtained from the
Olson, 2010) with docking coordinates for RCSB server, namely for TYRP1 receptor (X:
TYRP1 receptors (X: 15.993900; Y: -5.208800; 15.993900; Y: -5.208800; and Z: 25.220400)
and Z: 25.220400) and AR (X: 27.091714; Y: and AR receptor (X: 27.091714; Y: 2.278714;
2.278714; and Z: 4.949810). The conformer and Z: 4.949810). Ligand preparation was
compounds obtained were then interacted with performed by identifying the drug-likeness
and visualized using PyMOL and Discovery profile of each compound F1 fraction from the
Studio to determine the type and position of the dichloromethane extract, using the Lipinski's of
interaction between the ligands and the five rules to select compounds for molecular
receptors (Eberhardt et al., 2021). docking (Lipinski, 2004). The purposed
compounds used in this study were
PASSOnline Prediction pinocembrin, uvangoletin, stercurensin, and
PASS-Online prediction aurentiacin (Tukiran et al., 2021). The results of
(way2drug.com) was carried out to determine drug-likeness analysis using Lipinski's five
the potency of the ligand compounds by looking rules present in Table 1 showed that these
at the potential value of the Pa and Pi ligand compounds have the potential to be promising
compounds. PASS-Online predictions are used drug candidates, as they meet at least 3 of the
to strengthen the potential compounds as anti- Lipinski's five rules (Lipinski, 2004; Lipinski et
melasma and anti-acne agents (Lagunin et al., al., 2001)
2000; Rahmaningsih & Pujiastutik, 2019).
The aim of the molecular docking study involved the investigation of bioactivities that
is to evaluate a compounds potential as a specifically targeted the tyrosinase (TYRP1)
medication with particular bioactivities by receptor for anti-melasma effects and the
blocking the target protein receptors. Prior to androgen (AR) receptor for anti-acne effects.
the molecular docking analysis, the ligand The TYRP1 receptor plays a role in the
structures are minimized using OpenBabel to hyperpigmentation pathway through
achieve flexible ligands. When the ligands are dopaquinone production (Carradori et al., 2024;
flexible, they are expected to obtain minimal Zolghadri et al., 2019), while AR receptor is
(stable) binding affinities (Pradeepkiran et al., involved in acne formation due to excessive
2016). The primary objectives of this study androgen hormone production (Kircik, 2021;
123
JURNAL KIMIA (JOURNAL OF CHEMISTRY) 18 (2), JULI 2024: 121 - 128
Alapatt & Matanaj, 2024). The resulted negative value signifies greater stability of the
molecular docking analysis (as seen in Table 1) complex. Enhanced stability of the formed
revealed that all four compounds interact with complex leads to optimal inhibitory activity
the TYRP1 and AR receptors due to their (Jensen, 2017; Pires et al., 2018). The findings
negative binding affinity values. The outcomes of the investigation indicated that pinocembrin
indicated that these compounds exhibit lower exhibits the most pronounced negative binding
binding affinities compared to the control drugs affinity for both receptors in a synergistic
hydroquinone (-4.8 kcal/mol) and clascoterone manner. These compounds are potential
(-5.9 kcal/mol), indicating their promising compounds that will be visualized to gather data
potential as anti-melasma and anti-acne agents. on the positions and types of interactions within
Binding affinity represents the stability value of the formed receptor-ligand complexes.
the protein-ligand complex formed. A more
Table 1. Druglikeness and Molecular Docking Analysis using TYRP1 and AR Receptors
Ligands Lipinski Parameter Binding affinity (kcal/mol)
1 2 3 4 5
MW AH DH MR Log P TYRP1 AR
Hydroquinone - `- - - - -4.8 -
Clascoterone - - - - - - -5.9
Pinocembrin 256.25 4 2 69.55 2.48 -7.4 -8.8
Uvangoletin 272.30 3 2 76.47 2.92 -6.7 -8.1
Stercurensin 284.31 3 2 81.75 3.20 -6.9 -8.1
Aurentiacin 298.33 4 1 86.22 3.51 -6.3 -7.2
Note: 1MW = molecular weight < 500 Da; 2AH= Hydrogen Bond Acceptor < 10; 3DH = Hydrogen
Bond Donor < 5; 4MR = Molar Refractivity 40 – 130; 5Log P = liphopility < 5
The four potential compounds are then visualized, and the results of the 2D visualization are
presented in Figure 2a for the TYRP1 complex and Figure 2b for the AR complex. The outcomes
revealed the formation of various types of interactions, including hydrogen bonding, hydrophobic
interactions, and electrostatic bonding. These interactions can be observed in Figure 2a and Figure 2b
above; surface area interaction can be observed in Figure 3. Hydrogen bonding refers to the
intermolecular interactions that occur between hydrogen atoms and highly electronegative atoms, such
as fluorine, oxygen, and nitrogen (Sururi et al., 2024). Hydrophobic interactions occur between
hydrophobic groups of the receptor and ligand (King et al., 2014). Electrostatic bonding arises from
charges between the receptor and ligand (Kamila et al., 2024; Njoroge et al., 2008).
124
Bioinformatics Study: The Potency of Syzygium Samarangense Stem Bark Dichloromethane Extract
as Anti-Melasma and Anti-Acne
(T. Tukiran)
125
JURNAL KIMIA (JOURNAL OF CHEMISTRY) 18 (2), JULI 2024: 121 - 128
126
Bioinformatics Study: The Potency of Syzygium Samarangense Stem Bark Dichloromethane Extract
as Anti-Melasma and Anti-Acne
(T. Tukiran)
127
JURNAL KIMIA (JOURNAL OF CHEMISTRY) 18 (2), JULI 2024: 121 - 128
discovery and design. Springer: 271–284. Jurnal Kimia Riset, 7(2): 94–100.
Polynice, V.M. 2024. Toxicity of mercury and Sururi, A.M., Tukiran, T., Aisa, E.R. & Raihan,
hydroquinone in skin lightening products: M. 2024. Identification of bioactive
popular practice in non-white compounds and ADMET profile of stem
communities. bark of Syzygium samarangense and their
Pradeepkiran, J.A., Yellapu, N.K. & Matcha, B. potential as antibreast cancer and
2016. Modeling, molecular docking, antiinflammatory. Journal of Applied
probing catalytic binding mode of acetyl- Pharmaceutical Science, 14(02): 273–
CoA malate synthase G in Brucella 280.
melitensis 16M. Biochemistry and Tollenaere, M. De, Boira, C., Chapuis, E.,
Biophysics Reports. Lapierre, L., Jarrin, C., Robe, P.,
Rahmaningsih, S. & Pujiastutik, H. 2019. An in Zanchetta, C., Vilanova, D., Sennelier-
vitro and in silico evaluation of the Portet, B. & Martinez, J. 2022. Action of
antibacterial activity of the bioactive Mangifera indica leaf extract on acne-
compounds in Majapahit (Crescentia prone skin through sebum harmonization
cujete L.) fruit. Veterinary world, 12(12): and targeting C. acnes. Molecules, 27(15):
1959–1965. 4769.
Del Rosso, J.Q., Gold, L.S., Segal, J. & Trott, O. & Olson, A.J. 2010. AutoDock Vina:
Zaenglein, A.L. 2019. An open-label, improving the speed and accuracy of
phase IV study evaluating lidose- docking with a new scoring function,
isotretinoin administered without food in efficient optimization, and multithreading.
patients with severe recalcitrant nodular Journal of computational chemistry,
acne: low relapse rates observed over the 31(2): 455–461.
104-week post-treatment period. The https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/194995
Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic 76.
Dermatology, 12(11): 13. Tukiran, T., Suyatno, S. & Safitri, F.N. 2021.
Santhosh, P. & George, M. 2021. Clascoterone: Identification of the Chemical
a new topical anti‐androgen for acne Constituents of the Selected Fraction of
management. International Journal of the Dichloromethane Extract of Syzygium
Dermatology, 60(12): 1561–1565. samarangense Stem Bark Using LC-ESI-
Sheth, V.M. & Pandya, A.G. 2011. Melasma: a MS and Evaluation Its Potential as
comprehensive update: part II. Journal of Antifungal Agent. Indonesian Journal of
the American Academy of Dermatology, Chemistry, 21(2): 340–349.
65(4): 699–714. Yue, Y., Liao, Z., Wang, Y., Liu, Q., Dong, J.,
Shivaram, K., Edwards, K. & Mohammad, T.F. Zhong, M., Chen, M., Pan, Y., Zhong, H.
2024. An update on the safety of & Shang, J. 2024. Translocator protein
hydroquinone. Archives of ligand Ro5-4864 promotes melanogenesis
Dermatological Research, 316(7): 378. in a TSPO independent manner.
Sururi, A.M., Maharani, D.K. & Wati, F.A. Zaenglein, A.L., Pathy, A.L., Schlosser, B.J.,
2023. POTENSI SENYAWA EUGENOL Alikhan, A., Baldwin, H.E., Berson, D.S.,
DARI CENGKEH (Syzygium Bowe, W.P., Graber, E.M., Harper, J.C. &
aromaticum) SEBAGAI INHIBITOR Kang, S. 2016. Guidelines of care for the
PROTEASE HIV-1 (PR). Unesa Journal management of acne vulgaris. Journal of
of Chemistry, (Vol 12 No 1 (2023): 26–30. the American Academy of Dermatology,
https://ejournal.unesa.ac.id/index.php/une 74(5): 945–973.
sa-journal-of- Zolghadri, S., Bahrami, A., Hassan Khan, M.T.,
chemistry/article/view/52025/42268. Munoz-Munoz, J., Garcia-Molina, F.,
Sururi, A.M., Raihan, M., Aisa, E.R., Safitri, Garcia-Canovas, F. & Saboury, A.A.
F.N., Constaty, I.C. & Tukiran. 2022. 2019. A comprehensive review on
Anti-Inflammatory Activity of Stem Bark tyrosinase inhibitors. Journal of enzyme
Dichloromethane Fraction Syzygium inhibition and medicinal chemistry, 34(1):
samarangense Extract as COX-2 279–309.
Inhibitor: A Bioinformatics Approach.
128