Developmental Social Services Model
Developmental Social Services Model
Over the past decade, the notion of what constitutes developmental social
services has been a matter of debate, misunderstanding and misinterpretation.
Since 1994, we have been engaged in discussions at various levels to ensure
that our services benefit the poorest and most vulnerable sectors of society.
In reaching out to the millions of our people who live in conditions of abject
poverty, some deprived of access to even basic resources, there has been a
shift in approach, from a welfarist to a social development perspective. This
paradigm shift is premised on the notion that people are the masters of their
own destiny and, instead of helping the poor in the traditional way with
handouts, it moves on to the development and empowerment of individuals,
groups and communities, teaching them to be self-reliant. We believe that this
is the best way for the Department and its partners to combat the socio-
economic challenges facing the country.
Our belief is that such efforts will strengthen the system through which services
are rendered and promote the general welfare and development of our people.
This Service Delivery Model depicts our relentless efforts to improve service
delivery to the poorest of the poor and all the other vulnerable groups in our
society, while providing an indication of the resource requirements for effective
implementation.
1
We hope that the model will help all of us to confront the challenges of service
delivery that we have had to face in the past decade. More importantly, we
hope the Service Delivery Model will turn the tide and ensure the enhancement
of closer working relationships between all those striving for social justice and
working together to achieve the common goal of "a better life for all’’.
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
3
organs of civil society remains a key element in the Department’s efforts to
ensure optimal functioning and the fulfilment of its mandate.
4
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Introduction ……………………………………………………………….
4. Outcome statement………………………………………………………
19. Conclusion……………………………………………………………..…
5
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The major goal of the Service Delivery Model for Social Services is therefore to
provide a comprehensive national framework that clearly sets out the nature,
scope, extent and level of social services, and which will form the basis for the
development of appropriate norms and standards for service delivery.
6
The Service Delivery Model for Developmental Social Services acknowledges
the interdependent relationship between the main programmes of the
Department, namely Social Security, Social Welfare and Community
Development, and provides a framework for the integration of the services of
the Department's different programmes. However, social issues are complex
and multidimensional, so the need for service integration across departments
and the effective use of clusters to facilitate this integration of development
efforts is important. To this end the Department works on specific services with
other departments and spheres of government to ensure that communities
derive maximum benefit.
While recognising the role of social security, services are defined in terms of
two broad categories that constitute developmental social services, namely
developmental social welfare services and community development. These are
further delineated in terms of service classifications.
Core services are further classified into five broad categories, namely
promotion and prevention; rehabilitation; protection; continuing care; and
mental health and addiction services. These are then unpacked in terms of the
primary target groups of the Department, which broadly comprise the poor and
vulnerable sectors of society.
The nature and scope of community development are articulated. These are
classified in terms of the purpose and scope of services, and include a focus on
the development of the youth and women, poverty reduction programmes, and
7
the registration and facilitation of non-profit organisations (NPOs). These
services are further classified in terms of the community development process,
including the development of social relationships, community profiling, planning
and prioritisation, implementation, evaluation, documentation and facilitation,
integration and coordination. Some preferred approaches, such as sustainable
livelihood and participatory learning and action, are highlighted.
The Service Delivery Model acknowledges that developmental services are the
collective responsibility of various role players, including government, non-
governmental organisations and the private sector. The exact nature and
extent of the involvement of these service providers is determined by history,
expertise, statutory requirements and cost.
8
The success of the model depends largely on continuous review and
customisation to suit implementation settings. An implementation and change
management plan has therefore been drawn up.
9
SERVICE DELIVERY MODEL FOR DEVELOPMENTAL SOCIAL WELFARE
SERVICES
1. INTRODUCTION
In order to address the legacy of South Africa's colonial and apartheid history,
the government has adopted a transformative, developmental framework and is
moving towards becoming a developmental state. One of the government's
responsibilities is to facilitate the process of development through the various
institutions of government, its partners and civil society.
The developmental challenges facing South Africa, given its history, are many
and varied. A central priority of government, as required by the Constitution’s
Bill of Rights, is to ensure provision of a range of services to meet these
challenges, within the constraints of available resources. Against this
background, and in recognition of the need to promote the goals of sustainable
development to redress past imbalances, the social services sector has
adopted a developmental approach to service delivery, integrating social
interventions with economic development.
10
Department of Social Development. Social development is concerned with the
development of society in its totality. Its efforts are directed at the development
of the total potential of human beings for the maximum improvement of the
material, cultural, political and social aspects of their lives.
According to the United Nations (UN) Economic Commission for Africa, social
development involves the participation of the people in bringing about
qualitative and quantitative changes in the social conditions of individuals,
groups and communities through planned measures such as social policy,
social welfare, social security, social services, social work, community
development and institution building. The developmental framework demands
that service delivery be intersectoral and integrated between the various
government departments and sectors. This collaboration and coordination is
possible only if it is reflected in attitudes, behaviour and values that promote a
developmental approach.
Over the past decade the notion of what constitutes developmental social
welfare service delivery has been a matter of debate, misunderstanding and
misinterpretation. The Service Delivery Model seeks to provide clarity on the
nature, scope and level of services in the developmental social services sector,
excluding social security. It also gives an indication of the resource
requirements for effective implementation. It provides a basis for setting
appropriate generic norms and standards for service delivery, which in turn
provide a realistic sense of the cost of such services.
The Service Delivery Model does not seek to address broader policy issues; it
is not a review of the White Paper. Neither is it a theoretical framework that
seeks to define practice domains. Rather, it is a guideline for social services
within the context of a developmental paradigm, and provides a value chain for
social development services.
11
conjunction with them. These documents include the Policy on Financial
Awards to Service Providers and its Procedure Manual, the Conceptual
Framework on Community Development and various other departmental
policies and minimum standards for service delivery.
12
• loss of skilled personnel due to poor salaries and working conditions;
Social security remains part of the mandate of the Department. However, the
burden of social security is increasing and becoming financially unsustainable.
The Service Delivery Model acknowledges the relationship between the main
functions of the Department, namely social security, social welfare services and
community development. Its major goal is therefore to provide a
comprehensive service that will reduce the burden on social security. Social
security should be a measure that largely provides immediate relief for those
that can be taken off the system and redirected to other services defined in this
model, namely developmental social welfare or community development
services, to ensure the sustainability of intervention efforts.
The sector is being called upon to account for what it does, and provincial
departments of social development, in particular, are facing the challenge of
repositioning themselves now that Social Security has become autonomous (it
is now the South African Social Security Agency).
13
The development of this Service Delivery Model presents an opportunity to
detail the nature, scope, extent and level of services that social service
practitioners should be delivering within one consolidated framework. The
rationale for the Service Delivery Model is as follows:
• It provides for ongoing learning and insight into a shared vision for the
developmental social services sector.
14
4. OUTCOME STATEMENT
5.1 Values
The values and ethos for service delivery are derived from the Batho Pele
principles as set out in the White Paper for the Transformation of the Public
Service.
The following values have been identified as the basis for social development
service delivery:
15
In addition, certain core values are intrinsic to the developmental approach.
The following must be observed:
• Acknowledgement and respect for people’s potential to develop and
change;
• recognition of the rights of all to participate in their own development and
decision-making, and to be accountable for their own lives; and
• commitment to facilitate social processes that build effective
relationships, and healthy organisations and communities.
5.2 Principles
16
• Equity: The disbursement of resources should be based on need,
priorities and historical imbalances.
These principles underpin the delivery of social services in the Department and
should be observed and complied with.
17
6. POLICIES AND CONSTITUTIONAL MANDATE
The Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (Act No. 108 of 1996),
contains the Bill of Rights, which provides for not only basic human rights but
social and economic rights. The Constitution, notably section 27(1)(c), also
provides for the right of access to appropriate social assistance for those
unable to support themselves and their dependants.
South Africa is one of the few countries where the Constitution enshrines a duty
to alleviate poverty. The South African government is obliged to meet basic
human needs and accords these needs the status of basic human rights.
The White Papers for Social Welfare (1997) and Population Policy (1998)
provide the overarching policy framework for the Department.
The Social Service Professions Act, 1978 (Act No. 110 of 1978), provides the
framework for the development of the Council, which is a statutory, autonomous
body, tasked with the development of the social service professions, protecting
the interests of beneficiaries and promoting the interests of registered social
service professionals. It also sets out the code of conduct for social service and
related professions and sets standards for education and training.
18
• Advisory Board on Social Development Act, 2001 (Act No. 3 of 2001)
• Mental Health Care Act, 2002 (Act No. 17 of 2002)
• Prevention of Domestic Violence Act, 1998 (Act No. 116 of 1998)
• Divorce and Mediation Act, 1979 (Act No. 70 1979)
• Maintenance Act, 1998 (Act No. 99 of 1998)
• Criminal Procedures Act, 1977 (Act No. 51 of 1977).
These Acts constitute the legal framework for developmental social service
delivery in South Africa. To remain relevant, however, legislation must be
reviewed whenever necessary.
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights lays the basis for all other
commitments “to promote social progress and better standards of life in larger
freedom” and to finding mechanisms “to promote the economic, social and
cultural rights of all peoples”.
19
7. KEY CONCEPTS
This section explains key concepts used in the model in order to promote
consistency in terms of their usage within the Department and other sectors.
20
Social services refers to the broad, comprehensive range of services relating
to social welfare and community development services provided in a continuum
to ensure the integration and sustainability of intervention efforts.
Social services approaches from the pre-1994 era were criticised as not being
appropriate or developmental, and for creating dependency. Services were
individualistic and were similar to a medical model in which the focus was on
the diagnosis and treatment of the client, with the latter being a passive
recipient of services.
What makes this approach effective is not its individual components but the
synergy created when the key elements are combined or integrated to augment
21
what local people already do well, together with the resources and assets to
which they have access. The sustainable livelihoods approach also respects
people’s capacity to exercise choice and access opportunities and resources,
and to use them for a livelihood in ways that do not disadvantage others,
currently and in the future.
Within this context, the meaning of social welfare and community development
must then be reviewed and redefined.
22
8.1 Social welfare
Social welfare covers a range of services and programmes that are directed at
enhancing the capacities of people to address the causes and consequences of
poverty and vulnerability. A range of professionals provide these services, key
among which are social workers.
The social work profession promotes social change, problem solving in human
relationships, and the empowerment and liberation of people to enhance well-
being. Utilising theories of human behaviour and social systems, social work
intervenes at the point where people interact with their environment. Principles
of human rights and social justice are fundamental to social work.
The Social Service Professions Act states that social work means a
professional service performed by a social worker, aimed at the improvement of
the social functioning of people. Social functioning means the role performance
of an individual in its entirety at all levels of his or her existence, in interaction
with other individuals, families, groups, communities and situations in his or her
environment.
23
Social work services are rendered using three primary methods, namely case
work, group work and community work/development.
Case work is a method that utilises a variety of skills, techniques and other aids
to facilitate the clients’ participation and decision-making in efforts to improve
their social functioning.
In addition, social workers have two secondary methods, namely research and
administration, which are intrinsically linked to and support service delivery.
There are other categories of personnel that provide support services to social
workers, such as social auxiliary workers, child and youth care workers and
other paraprofessionals. Some of these categories have become
professionalised, for example child and youth care. Their functioning is defined
within the context of social work.
24
8.2 Community development
With the shift to the social development approach, a new cadre of community or
social development officers/workers were introduced to focus on community
development.
25
Government facilitates institutional support development with the focus on
creating and strengthening existing government institutions and civil society
organisations.
Various models are used in the development domain, most of which subscribe
to the sustainable development approach, and key among which is participatory
learning and action (PLA). PLA can be seen as an umbrella term for a variety
of approaches and methods used by local people to appraise, plan, implement
and evaluate their own development processes. The PLA approach is by its
nature empowering, and the whole process belongs to the community.
Outsiders are learners first and facilitators second.
9. SERVICE INTEGRATION
26
the meeting of emergency needs of vulnerable households, individuals and
communities while assessing the cause and effect of their vulnerability,
recognising their strengths, and developing appropriate strategies for
sustainable socio-economic development.
27
E
X
Social I
T
Security
Beneficiary Community
Point Assessment by and Development Or
of social service community
entry: professionals profiling
R
Social
E
Services F
E
R
R
A
L
The entry point is the point at which clients (individuals, groups, families or communities) first
make contact with the system. This could be through one of the Department's service points or
various other agencies. One or more social service professionals then make an assessment.
The client participates actively in intervention efforts that best suite their circumstances and
needs in order to ensure that they derive full benefit from available services. Movement of the
client within the system is dynamic, and is not a linear process. Clients can exit the system at
any point. The aim of the intervention at all levels is achievement of the desired level of social
functioning. However, there are those whose functional capacity will require continued
intervention, for example people with severe disabilities.
This approach will ensure that there is an exit strategy that will result in the
enhanced sustainability of intervention efforts. The focus is on the interventions
that the sector has the capacity to deliver on at different levels, but does not
exclude referrals to local government, other government departments or organs
of civil society, should there be a need.
28
In practice, there is a growing awareness that policy needs to be coordinated
across government. Social issues are often complex and multidimensional, and
they need to be understood in a holistic manner. Owing to the interrelatedness
of social phenomena and the impact that one department’s functions have on
the next, it is crucial to understand the roles and responsibilities of all the other
sector departments and how their functions relate to those of the Department of
Social Development. The challenge is to utilise the clusters set up by
government effectively to facilitate the integration of development efforts. The
Department of Social Development therefore also works with the Departments
of Health, and Justice and Constitutional Development, among others, through
legislative and other mandates.
There are a number of ways to classify the services provided in the sphere of
social services. The following section will use two classifications which,
although different in theory, are in practice integrated when services are
provided.
29
The levels of intervention are as follows:
• Prevention
This is the most important aspect of social service delivery. Services
delivered at this level are aimed at strengthening and building the
capacity and self-reliance of the client. At this level the client is
functioning at an adequate level but there is a possibility of at-risk
behaviour at a later stage.
30
These levels can be represented schematically as follows:
It must be noted that clients can enter or exit the system at any of the levels
(see arrows). The intervention method should be agreed with the clients after
assessment and development of an intervention programme. This programme
serves as a contract between the service provider and client, with both
committing to a developmental programme that will enhance the client’s
capacity to achieve their own desired level of social functioning. The client is
therefore not a passive recipient of services, but participates and develops
his/her own treatment goals.
31
10.1.2 Classification in terms of the nature of services
Social welfare services focus on meeting the needs of and building on the
strengths of individuals, families, communities and other social groups through
the provision a comprehensive range of services and programmes that extend
beyond the inherent capacity of individuals and their natural support networks.
The Service Delivery Model must in broad terms describe the range of services
that clients can expect to have access to, either in their communities or
elsewhere, and how such services can assist beneficiaries to reach an optimal
state of social functioning and lead productive lives in the context of healthy
families and communities.
Core services rendered by the social services sector have been grouped into
five broad categories:
• Promotion and prevention services
• Rehabilitation services
• Protection services
• Continuing care services
• Mental health and addiction services
In the next section, a brief exposition is given of these. The actual services
provided to each focus group are then described in terms of this classification.
32
Promotion and prevention services work towards the upliftment of all people
and communities by promoting well-being, encouraging people to make
healthy choices, and supporting them in these choices.
• Protection services
Protection services aim to safeguard the well-being of individuals and
families. Protection services are usually provided within the context of a
legislative and/or policy framework and include statutory services. These
empower designated people or institutions to take specific actions that are
deemed necessary to protect the integrity and well-being of the person
within the social context of the family and community.
• Rehabilitation services
Rehabilitation services are aimed at improving and maintaining the social
functioning of clients whose functioning is impaired as a result of injury,
disability or any chronic condition. In addition to improving the quality of life
of an individual, rehabilitation services are an effective way of reducing the
demands on families and publicly funded support systems. Services are
provided in a wide range of settings, including the home, service agencies
and residential facilities.
33
The vision for rehabilitation services is to enable clients to maximise their
functional abilities, minimise the impact of their impairment and maintain a
healthy, independent lifestyle.
Continuing care services work toward meeting needs in the least intrusive
manner possible, and provide the greatest opportunity for lasting well-being
and functional independence.
This section will provide the scope of services in terms the above classification
as well as the target group.
34
10.2.1 Services to children
• Prevention services
Early childhood development (ECD) services include the establishment
and registration of facilities for children under six years old, and the
monitoring and evaluation of services. Social Development also works
with cases that come before the family advocate.
• Protection services
Child protection services are aimed at preventing the abuse, neglect and
abandonment of children. Programmes are aimed at protecting and
promoting the well-being of children, especially those in difficult
circumstances. These include services to children who are the victims of
child labour and the commercial sexual exploitation of children; services
to children affected and infected by HIV and Aids; international social
services including inter-country adoptions, and intermediary services in
criminal court cases.
35
• Rehabilitation services
These include services to children living and working on the streets, such
as the registration of, and provision of services in, shelters and drop-in
centres for street children.
• Prevention services
Life-skills programmes, parenting skills programmes, and services in
terms of the Maintenance Act are all prevention services in this category.
36
There are also a number of international conventions that inform
probation services including the -
o The Beijing Rules (UN Rules for the Administration of Juvenile
Justice)
o United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Protection of
Juveniles Deprived of their Liberty
o The Riyadh Guidelines (UN Guidelines for the Prevention of
Juvenile Delinquency) etc.
• Prevention services
These include crime prevention services.
37
10.2.4 Services to the youth
• Prevention services
Included here are education and awareness programmes on HIV and
AIDS, life orientation and substance abuse, among other things.
Capacity building through information and life-skills programmes
(including development of soft skills) is crucial.
38
10.2.5 Prevention and treatment of substance abuse
• Prevention services
These include programmes for the prevention and treatment of
substance abuse, community awareness programmes and the
implementation of the National Drug Master Plan.
39
• Prevention services
These include the prevention of gender-based violence, trafficking in
human bodies and abuse of the ageing population; promotion of CEDAW
objectives and girl child programmes; women’s empowerment and
development services; education and training; and recreational
programmes.
• Protection services
Services include those offered to victims of domestic violence and
gender-based violence, the establishment (with other departments) of
victim support centres, referral to both physical and mental health
services, and home help services.
40
o Madrid Plan of Action for Older Persons 2002
o AU Policy Framework and Plan of Action on Ageing (2004).
• Prevention services
These include the implementation of international conventions, the
dissemination of information, raising awareness about ageing being a
part of the life cycle, community education and information regarding the
abuse of older persons, the promotion of intergenerational programmes
to keep older persons in the community for as long as possible, and
early intervention programmes to promote the well-being of older
persons.
• Protection services
These include preventive actions and interventions in respect of the
abuse of older persons, awareness and advocacy programmes on the
rights of older persons and home help services.
41
10.2.8 Services to people with disabilities
• Prevention services
These include promoting the inclusion and mainstreaming of people with
disabilities, the rights of people with disabilities, awareness of disability
issues, and the accessibility of services, community and public
resources; the prevention of discrimination against people with
disabilities; programmes for the early identification of genetic disorders
and awareness regarding the prevention of the transmission of genetic
disorders; life-skills and capacity-building programmes; and skills
development services.
• Rehabilitation services
Services to people with chronic illnesses like HIV and AIDS, community-
based services like stimulation centres and protective workshops, and
counselling services fall in this category.
42
10.2.9 Services to those affected/infected by HIV and AIDS
• Prevention services
These include awareness and prevention programmes, the training of
peer counsellors, facilitating HIV/AIDS awareness and the
implementation of programmes to reduce the risk of acquiring HIV and
AIDS.
• Protection services
The establishment and management of drop in centres, and the
establishment and management of child care forums at community level
fall in this category.
43
Some services are generic and broad based, responding to the full range of
social services across the life cycle from a single point of delivery, and require a
knowledge and skills base that is enhanced through knowledge acquired over
time. Other services are specialist, in which case the focus is on a specific area
of need in which a particular skill is required. It is critical, however, that
knowledge and skills acquired in these specialist areas must be continuously
fed into generic workstreams and policy development processes, and fully
integrated into the broad service delivery network.
The primary target groups of the Department are the poor and vulnerable
sectors of the community. People infected and affected by HIV and AIDS,
people with disabilities and those who have other special needs are
mainstreamed across all the target groups.
• Children
Children who are under the age of 18 years and who are abused,
neglected, orphaned, abandoned and/or living in other especially difficult
circumstances.
• The youth
Young people who are between the ages of 14 and 28 years and who
are at risk, in conflict with the law, out of school and/or unemployed.
• Families
Families that are vulnerable, including single-parent, child-headed,
destitute and/or refugee families.
44
• Women
Vulnerable women including victims of violence, poor and/or
unemployed.
• Older people
Vulnerable older people including those who are abused, frail and/or
indigent.
12.1 Purpose
• Youth development
Socio-economic programmes
Moral regeneration programmes
45
• Development of women
Women empowerment programmes
Socio-economic programmes for women
Promoting gender issues
46
• Development of social relationships
Delimitation of the community; gaining their trust and getting to know the
current community services, history, resources and state of the
community.
• Community profiling
Assessment of the community’s structures, historical background, profile
resources, strengths and needs; identification of community leadership;
and strengthening and building of structures that can assist in this
regard.
• Implementation
Facilitation of the implementation of identified development activities,
according to the plans developed by involving the community;
appointment of leaders in the community; mobilisation of resources;
monitoring of implementation; and development and strengthening of
community organisations and leadership within the community.
• Evaluation of implementation
Monitoring of implementation of jointly planned activities, giving feedback
to the community and re-planning actions where required.
• Documentation of activities
Documentation of all interactions and interventions by facilitators and
practitioners for future reference.
47
• Facilitation, integration and coordination
Liaison with social workers on issues relating to specific individuals and
families in the community thereby promoting the integrated approach;
liaison with all relevant role players (e.g. departments/provinces, NGOs,
local community structures, faith-based organisations) and stakeholders
to facilitate intersectoral collaboration and to establish partnerships to
ensure the sustainability of development actions within the community;
and the provision of direct support to communities and administrative
support on community development and related activities. This would
entail the following, among other things:
48
• Disseminating information to communities on social services.
49
The range of service providers includes -
• national government
• provincial government
• local government
• civil society, including NGOs, CBOs and FBOs
• private sector entities
50
• Undertakes international liaison and coordinates the implementation of
international commitments.
• Engages in continuous research projects that assist in informing,
improving, advancing, monitoring and evaluating comprehensive social
services to vulnerable groups.
• Lobbies for adequate provision of resources to ensure social service
delivery.
• Regulates fundraising at all levels of government.
• Markets and promotes the image of the Department.
• Funds national organisations rendering social services in accordance
with the Policy on Financial Awards.
• Reports as necessary to different parliamentary structures on social
services.
51
• Maintain an information management system for all services and
programmes.
• Manage and plan a human resource development programme.
• Market and promote awareness regarding social services programmes.
• Facilitate provincial parliamentary processes relating to social services.
• Promote interprovincial relations and develop and maintain intersectoral
and working agreements.
52
• Provide direct services to clients
53
13.3.2 Non-governmental organisations and faith-based organisations
54
• Policy development and project management
• Facility management
All the above service providers must ensure that services are integrated,
coordinated and managed to maximise the benefit for communities.
55
ECD caregivers
Home and community-based caregivers
Sign language interpreters
Professional Medical practitioners
support Physiotherapists
Speech therapists
Occupational therapists
Nursing personnel
Psychologists
Psychiatrists
Researchers
Information management specialists
Administrative Information technology specialists
support Administrative officers
personnel Typists
Drivers
Data capturers
Cleaners
General assistants
Security personnel
Other Volunteers
Temporary Student social workers
personnel Interns
Contract workers
Escorts for vulnerable groups
Student, child and youth care workers
56
14.2 Education, training and development
This also entails research, which should inform debates about policy
formulation, the development of models for training and service delivery within
the South African context, as well as monitoring and evaluating the impact of
current practice.
57
14.4 Infrastructure and equipment
This list is not exhaustive and does not include the infrastructure required for
numerous facilities and other community-based services that may require an
array of other equipment and infrastructure suitable for the needs of clients, e.g.
older people, people with disabilities, etc.
58
It is legally expected of social workers and other social services professions to
keep records of their interaction with their clients and the treatment process.
This is critical to ensure accountability and maintenance of a high standard of
care on the part of the social service professions. It is also meant to ensure
that the interests of clients are protected and enable the professional to follow
the progress of the client and to plan future intervention programmes.
This would require that certain prerequisites be met, such as understanding the
needs of users, and making sure that adequate resources are allocated and
change management processes are in place. Social service practitioners and
59
managers need to be innovative to make sure that there is administrative
efficiency. Extensive training and capacity building is imperative to ensure that
information technology becomes an integral part of social service practice.
Support for effective service delivery extends beyond available human, financial
and infrastructural resource. There also has to be a readiness to embrace new
and changing technologies so that services delivery can make the shift from a
paper-based profession to an electronic one.
The White Paper for Social Welfare, Notice No. 1108 of 1997, states that the
government has a responsibility to determine and regularly review basic
guidelines for norms and standards. The norms and standards are required to
ensure respect for human rights, social justice, redress and creating
opportunities for the development of benchmarks for social service
practitioners.
Under the Constitution, national government shares the responsibility for the
provision of basic social services with the provincial governments. National
government may determine appropriate, essential or minimum levels and
standards for services. The Constitution provides for the setting of norms and
standards to ensure equal access to government services. In addition, human
rights instruments such as the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child set out
minimum service delivery standards for various groups.
The main reasons for having norms and standards are as follows:
• To increase operational efficiency and effectiveness by measuring
performance against them
60
• To standardise the quality of service given to all citizens at national,
provincial, regional and district levels
Monitoring and evaluation tools for the management of norms and standards
must be introduced.
When norms and standards have been developed the result should be
predictable service delivery and gains in efficiency. For the purpose of this
exercise, the focus is on generic norms and standards. These are meant to
determine the basic requirements for generic service delivery for all social
service professionals, rather than for specific services. To achieve this, the
following factors should be taken into account:
61
15.2.2 Child and youth care workers in residential facilities
• Number of children
• Shifts
• Nature of the programme
• Nature of the cases
• Intensity of supervision
• The type of child
• Age cohort
• Distance to related services
• Span of control
• Number of reports
• Legal and policy obligations
All or most of these factors need to be taken into account when generic norms
and standards are developed. However, this Service Delivery Model will
determine norms and standards based mainly on population size, and as far as
possible will integrate urban/rural imperatives.
In addition, it needs to be noted that for each service area, for example older
people, more specific minimum norms and standards for particular types of
services such as residential care services will still need to be determined by line
functionaries at the national Department.
62
The established national and international norm for the ratio of social workers to
population is 1:5 000. This norm applies to developed countries but, because
of the high levels of poverty and deprivation in South Africa, it has to be
adjusted to reflect different conditions and needs.
The proposed norms for social workers to population are therefore as follows:
• 1:5 000 Urban (Gauteng)
• 1:4 500 Combined Urban/Rural (KwaZulu-Natal and
Western Cape)
• 1:3 000 All other provinces
The norms for community-based and institutional care can be divided into four
categories. These norms have been tested in practice and are recommended:
CATEGORIES NORMS
63
2. Administrative processes and procedures
• Report writing - generic (process/progress/etc.) 60 min
- court reports 20 reports per month
- probation
• Registration and referral of the file 2 days
• Completing forms 30 minutes
• Registration of facilities and organisation 6 months
• Management/team meetings At least once per
month
• Distribution of minutes Within 7 days
3. Service delivery
• Short-term intervention No more than 12
contacts of 60
minutes each
• Crisis intervention Within 24 hours
• Assessment of children awaiting trial Within 48 hours
• Completion of statutory service No more than 6
months
• Admission to residential facility 2 to 3 hours
• Medical assessment Within 72 hours
• First contact with client after admission by professional Within 24 hours
person
• Multidisciplinary evaluation of client Within 4 weeks
• Review panels Every 6 months
• Supervision 60 minutes
• Interviews 45 minutes
• Group work 60 minutes
• Time spent in waiting room before making contact No more than 1/2
hour
64
• Response time for appeals 48 hours
• Response time to acknowledge enquiries/complaints Within 5 days
The provinces will determine their own norms based on the above factors as
well as considerations that are unique to their operational environment.
16. WORKSTREAMS
65
DEVELOPMENTAL SOCIAL SERVICES
SOCIAL WELFARE WORKSTREAMS
PROFESSIONAL COMMUNITY
SERVICES SUPPORT DEVELOPMENT
66
The success of the Social Development Service Delivery Model depends
largely on continuous review, customisation to suit settings of implementation,
and identification with and total ownership by the sector. This is a sector model
and the Department of Social Development is a lead stakeholder in facilitating
processes for initiation and implementation of the model.
67
• The MIAT, in consultation with leadership and following appropriate
internal protocol, should cost model implementation and seek budget
approval. Even if only a portion of the funds required is made available,
implementation should start. The model can be implemented in phases.
If leadership buy-in is lacking and necessary resources are not allocated, the
model cannot be implemented, and will merely gather dust while the sector
regresses 10 years and an ever-increasing backlog builds up.
68
17.2 Implementation plan
• It must be a small manageable team of not less than five or more than
10 members at each level. The number will depend on resources
allocated to drive this process.
69
17.2.2 Scope, role and mandate of a MIAT
70
o Some stakeholders such as institutions and civil society
organisations may identify practice elements of the model and
align their strategies accordingly.
Stakeholders may choose to align their model with some or all of the
following:
71
o Alignment with business plan: When the model begins to
inform stakeholders’ business plans, the sector will be on the road
to successful implementation of the model.
72
The phasing in of the model described here is not a linear process. It is
dynamic and acknowledges the value of concurrently implementing elements
as needed. No one phase is more important than any other. They are all
negotiable and renegotiable until the ultimate goal of the model - a better life for
all - is achieved.
73
o Ensure that roles are evaluated to determine their complexity, grade
and monetary value.
74
their role as agents of change they will make an automatic switch. They are
only human, and normal responses will range from denial, shock, retreat
and resistance, to commitment and acceptance. As with organisational
change, individuals must be assisted through a planned process to navigate
this transition curve.
75
o Staff must be given regular updates on the change process. Both
progress and what remains to be done must be clearly indicated.
Everyone has the capacity to change. All that is needed is to help people see
that the change will bring more benefits than disadvantages.
76
• Launch the model: Perhaps this should be the first communication
strategy to be implemented once the model has been approved by the
MINMEC.
77
18. MONITORING AND EVALUATION
The following criteria are among those to be used for monitoring and evaluating
implementation of the Service Delivery Model:
• Reports to the Department
• Client satisfaction surveys
• Quality assurance
The service areas responsible for social service provision will be the central
vehicle to report on the service delivery targets, the results of implementing the
model, and the achievement of significant milestones. Specific reporting
guidelines will be developed and made available to all service providers. These
guidelines will serve as accountability frameworks for each service area and will
indicate who is accountable to whom, and for what purpose.
78
18.2 Client satisfaction surveys
The Department will target both internal clients (service providers) and external
clients (consumers of social services) in assessing the level of satisfaction in
the utilisation of services. The client satisfaction information as well as
performance of the service providers will guide operational decisions to
continually improve actual service delivery.
The following issues will be addressed in order to increase the level of client
satisfaction:
• Range of services available
• Competency of service providers
• Continuity of care
• Access to services
The recipients of social services are entitled to know what they can expect from
the Department. The Service Delivery Model serves as a basis for the
determination of appropriate norms and standards. This will in turn serve as a
basis for determining the expected quality of service.
79
services provided. Service managers will be expected to monitor compliance
with set standards on an ongoing basis and address issues which impact on the
quality of service.
19. CONCLUSION
As indicated earlier, this document must be read in conjunction with others such
as the Community Development Framework, the Policy on Financial Awards,
the White Paper on Social Welfare, and relevant policies of the Department.
The Service Delivery Model will set the basis for the design and costing of
generic norms and standards for developmental social services, which will
require input from various experts. Once generic norms and standards have
been developed and costed, they will be used to monitor implementation at
both national and provincial level.
This document does not purport to cover all aspects of service delivery, as
some services are still being developed. It will be reviewed and updated from
time to time to ensure that it is in line with new developments.
It is, however, critical that the Service Delivery Model be utilised to reposition
the Department so that the services it provides are understood by the country
as a whole. The model should be used as a yardstick to measure the
performance of the Department and its partners.
80
The Service Delivery model should be further unpacked at all levels of
government in accordance with the defined responsibilities of various
stakeholders, so that strategic objectives, outputs and targets are formulated to
operationalise the model.
81