Mixed Convection in Porous Media Enclosure
Mixed Convection in Porous Media Enclosure
Abstract
Volume averaged equations governing unsteady\ laminar\ mixed convection ~ow in an enclosure _lled with a Darcian
~uid!saturated uniform porous medium in the presence of internal heat generation is formulated[ The two vertical walls
of the enclosure are insulated while the horizontal walls are kept at constant temperatures with the top surface is moving
at a constant speed[ The developed equations are nondimensionalized and then solved numerically subject to appropriate
initial and boundary conditions by the _nite!volume approach along with the alternating direct implicit "ADI# procedure[
Comparisons with previously published work are performed and found to be in excellent agreement[ A parametric study
is conducted and a set of graphical results is presented and discussed to elucidate interesting features of the solution[
Þ 0888 Elsevier Science Ltd[ All rights reserved[
9906!8209:88:, ! see front matter Þ 0888 Elsevier Science Ltd[ All rights reserved[
PII] S 9 9 0 6 ! 8 2 0 9 " 8 7 # 9 9 1 1 6 ! 9
1355 K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370
m e}ective dynamic viscosity ðPa s−0Ł results have shown that the ~ow features are similar to
n e}ective kinematic viscosity\ m:r9 those of a conventional driven!cavity of a non!strati_ed
r9 ~uid density at reference temperature TC ~uid for small values of the Richardson number[ Also\ it
t dimensionless time\ tU9:H has been found that when the Richardson number is very
c stream function ðm1 s−0Ł high\ much of the middle and bottom portions of the
c dimensionless stream function\ c:HU9 cavity interior is stagnant[
v dimensionless vorticity\ VH:U9 Flow through a con_ned porous medium has drawn
V dimensional vorticity\ "1v:1x#−"1u:1y#[ considerable attention in the last few years due to the
large number of technological and industrial applications
Subscripts such as geothermal energy systems\ prevention of sub!oil
C cold wall water pollution\ storage of nuclear waste\ etc[ "see\ for
H hot wall instance\ Kakak et al[ ð05Ł and Bejan ð06Ł#[ Free con!
i X location of a grid point vection heat transfer in a porous medium has been
j Y location of a grid point[ studied extensively in the literature[ Cheng ð07Ł provides
an extensive review of the literature on free convection
in ~uid!saturated porous media with regard to appli!
0[ Introduction cations in geothermal systems[ The state of art regarding
porous media models has been summarized in a recent
Mixed convection ~ow and heat transfer in enclosures book by Nield and Bejan ð08Ł[
is of interest in engineering and science[ Its applications Early works on ~ow in porous media have used the
include nuclear reactors ð0Ł\ lakes and reservoirs ð1Ł\ solar Darcy law which is applicable to slow ~ows and does not
collectors ð2Ł\ and crystal growth[ Moreover\ the ~ow and account for inertial and boundary e}ects "termed as non!
heat transfer in a shear driven cavity arises in industrial Darcy e}ects# which become important when the ~ow
processes such as food processing and ~oat glass pro! velocity is relatively high and in the presence of a bound!
duction ð3Ł[ ary[ The condition of high velocity is realized when the
The problem of a lid!driven cavity ~ow in enclosures pressure across the porous medium is a quadratic func!
has been used extensively as a standard test case for tion of the velocity[ Vafai and Tien ð19Ł have reported a
the evaluation of numerical solution procedures for the detailed discussion on these non!Darcian e}ects[ Mixed
NavierÐStokes equations ð4Ð09Ł[ Kose} and Street ð00Ł convection ~ows along vertical plates and other geo!
have studied experimentally as well as numerically the metries embedded in porous media with Darcian and
recirculation ~ow patterns for a wide range of Reynolds non!Darcian e}ects have been reported by many authors
and Grashof numbers[ Their results show that the three! "e[g[ ð10Ð14Ł#[
dimensional features\ such as corner eddies near the end The objective of the present work is to consider the
walls\ and TaylorÐGortler!like longitudinal vortices\ Brinkman!extended Darcy equation of motion with the
have signi_cant e}ects on the ~ow patterns for low Rey! convective terms included and to examine the in~uence of
nolds numbers[ Both thermally stable and unstable lid! the Richardson number\ Darcy number\ and the internal
driven ~ows inside enclosures have been investigated Rayleigh number on mixed convection ~ow inside a
numerically by Torrance et al[ ð01Ł for _xed values of square enclosure _lled with a ~uid!saturated porous
Reynolds and Prandtl numbers[ Their numerical results medium[ Therefore\ a two dimensional numerical model
have indicated that the Richardson number is a con! will be used to solve the vorticity\ stream function and
trolling parameter for the problem[ Recently\ Prasad and energy equations governing buoyancy!driven mixed con!
Kose} ð02Ł have performed an experimental investigation vection ~ow inside a cavity[
of a recirculating mixed convection ~ow in a cavity _lled
with water[ For the range of the governing parameters
studied\ their results indicate that the overall heat transfer 1[ Problem formulation
rate is a very weak function of the Grashof number for
the examined range of the Reynolds number[ The e}ects The physical model considered in this investigation is
of the Prandtl number on laminar mixed convection heat shown in Fig[ 0[ A two!dimensional square enclosure of
transfer in a lid!driven cavity have been considered height H is _lled with a ~uid!saturated porous medium
numerically by Moallemi and Jang ð03Ł[ Their numerical of uniform porosity and permeability which generates
simulations have revealed that the in~uence of the buoy! heat at a uniform rate[ The top surface of the enclosure
ancy on the ~ow and heat transfer inside cavities is pre! is moving from left to right at a constant speed U9[ The
dicted to be more pronounced for higher values of the two vertical walls of the enclosure are insulated while the
Prandtl number[ Later on\ Iwatsu et al[ ð04Ł have studied top lid and the bottom surfaces are maintained at con!
numerically mixed convection heat transfer in a driven stant temperatures\ TH and TC\ respectively such that
cavity with a stable vertical temperature gradient[ Their TH×TC[ The directions of the acceleration due to gravity
K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370 1356
Eqs[ "1# and "2# do not include the porous medium inertia
e}ects which have been shown by many investigators
such as Lage ð15Ł and Chan et al[ ð16Ł to have very
little e}ect on heat transfer[ This will be in line with the
problem considered herein when the Reynolds number is
small[
The initial and boundary conditions for the above sys!
tem of equations corresponding to the geometry in Fig[
0 can be written as follows]
J
u v 9\ T 9 at all x\ y and t³9G
u v 9 on x 9\ H^ y 9\ H G
Fig[ 0[ Flow con_guration and coordinate system[ G
1T f
9 on x 9\ H "4#
1x F
G
T TH on y H G
g and the coordinate axes are also shown in Fig[ 0[ The
porous medium is assumed to be hydrodynamically and T TC on y 9 for t−9[ G
j
thermally isotropic and saturated with a ~uid that is in
local thermodynamic equilibrium with the solid matrix[ It is convenient to non!dimensionalize Eqs[ "0#Ð"4# using
The ~ow in the above problem is assumed to be unsteady\ the following dimensionless variables]
laminar\ incompressible\ and the ~uid physical properties x J y
are assumed constant except the density variation in the X \ G Y
H G H
body force term of the momentum equation according
u v G
to the Boussinesq approximation[ In addition\ pressure U \ V G
work\ and viscous dissipation are all assumed negligible[ U9 U9 f
"5#
The governing equations of the problem under con! T−TC tU9 F
sideration are based on the balance laws of mass\ linear u \ t G
TH −TC H G
momentum\ and thermal energy[ Taking into account the
VH c G
above mentioned assumptions\ these equations\ ex! v \ C G
pressed in dimensional form\ can be written as U9 HU9j
1u 1v where c and V are the dimensional stream function and
¦ 9 "0# vorticity\ respectively[
1x 1y
De_ning the stream function c and the vorticity V "see
1u 1u 1u 0 1P
¦u ¦v − the nomenclature section# in the usual way and sub!
1t 1x 1y r9 1x stituting Eqs[ "5# into the previous governing equations
11 u 11 u results in the following dimensionless equations]
0 1
mu
¦n ¦ − "1#
11 C 11 C
0 1
1x 1
1y 1 r9 k
v − ¦ "6#
1X 1 1Y 1
11 v 11 v
0 1
1v 1v 1v 0 1P
¦u ¦v − ¦n ¦ 1C 1C
1t 1x 1y r9 1y 1x1 1y1 U \ V− "7#
1Y 1X
mv
0 11 v 11 v
0 1
¦`b"T−TC #− "2# 1v 1v 1v
r9 k ¦U ¦V ¦
1t 1X 1Y Re 1X 1 1Y 1
Ke 11 T 11 T
0 1
1T 1T 1T q1
¦u ¦v ¦ ¦ "3# Gr 1u v
1t 1x 1y r9 cp 1x1 1y1 r 9 cp ¦ − "8#
1 1X Da Re
Re
where u and v are the pore velocity components in the x!
11 u 11 u
0 1
and y!directions\ respectively[ t is the time\ T is the ~uid 1u 1u 1u 0 RaI 0
¦U ¦V ¦ ¦ =
temperature\ P is the ~uid pressure\ b is the volumetric 1t 1X 1Y Pr Re 1X 1
1Y 1 RaE Pr Re
thermal expansion coe.cient\ k is the permeability of the
porous medium\ and Ke\ n\ m\ r9\ and cp are the e}ective "09#
thermal conductivity of the porous medium\ e}ective where
kinematic viscosity\ e}ective dynamic viscosity\ ~uid den!
sity\ and the speci_c heat\ respectively[ q1 is the volu! U9 H `bDTH 2
Re \ Gr \
metric internal heat generation[ It should be noted that n n1
1357 K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370
n¦"0:1# n¦"0:1#
−ai−0\j fi−0\j ¦ai\jn¦"0:1# fi\jn¦"0:1# −ai¦0\j
n¦"0:1# n¦"0:1#
fi¦0\j bn
7
k n
Da \ Pr \
H1 ae −an¦0 n¦0 n¦0 n¦0 n¦0 n¦0
i\j−0 fi\j−0 ¦ai\j fi\j −ai\j¦0 fi\j¦0 b
n¦"0:1#
$ %
i¦0\j # ¦"Ci−0\j # i\j¦0 # ¦"Ci\j−0 # #
$ % $ %
1f 1 1f 1 1f
¦ Uf−Gf ¦ Vf−Gf Sf "01# −1"0¦o1 #"Cn¦0 k 1 n¦0
i\j # ¦DX vi\j
1t 1X 1X 1Y 1Y
"05#
where f stands for v or u and Gf and Sf are given by
where o is the ratio of the step sizes\ such that o DX:DY\
0 RaI 0
Gu \ Su = n and k are the time step and the iteration step\ respect!
Pr Re RaE Pr Re
ively\ and l represents the relaxation factor which is given
0 Gr 1u v by
Gv \ Sv − [ "02#
Re 1 1X Da Re
Re
7−3z3−d1
The average Nusselt number at a given height of the l \
enclosure may be expressed as d1
01 01
p p
0 d cos ¦sin "06#
g0 1
1u
Nu −Pr Re V dX[ "03# M N
9 1Y
where M and N are the total number of grid points along
In the above\ the _rst and second terms denote the con!
the X! and Y!directions\ respectively[ Once cn¦0
i\j is calcu!
tributions from the conductive and the convective heat!
lated from Eq[ "05#\ U n¦0 n¦0
i\j \ V i\j are then computed from
transfer modes\ respectively[
Cn¦0 n¦0 J
i\j¦0 −Ci\j−0
U n¦0
i\j G
1DY f
2[ Numerical algorithm n¦0 n¦0 F
"07#
C i−0\j −C i¦0\j
V n¦0
i\j G
In the present work\ the control volume method ð17Ł 1DX j
is used to solve the transient dimensionless governing
Eqs[ "6#Ð"09# subject to their corresponding initial and In addition to the distributions of U and V\ the vorticity
boundary conditions given in Eqs[ "00#[ In this algorithm\ on the boundaries can be computed according to the
the alternating direct implicit "ADI# procedure along following expressions which are obtained from Eq[ "6#]
with the successive grid re_nement scheme are respect! "1Ci\0 −4Ci\1 ¦3Ci\2 −Ci\3 # J
ively implemented in the spatial and temporal environ! vi\0 − G
1
DY G
ments to accelerate the convergence of the solution
towards steady state[ Additionally\ the application of the "1Ci\N−4Ci\N−0 ¦3Ci\N−1 −Ci\N−2 # G
vi\N − G
ADI procedure enhances the accuracy of the solution DY 1 f
since it allows the power!law scheme to be applied locally "1C0\j −4C1\j ¦3C2\j −C3\j # F
in a one!dimensional sense for each sweep in the coor! v0\j − G
1
DX G
dinate directions[ The _nite!di}erence formulation of the
general Eq[ "01# in both X! and Y!directions\ respectively "1CM\j −4CM−0\j ¦3CM−1\j −CM−2\j # G
vM\j − [G
are given by] DX 1 j "08#
K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370 1358
Fig[ 1[ Velocity and temperature pro_les for various mesh sizes at Re399 and Da9[0[
of the mechanically!driven circulations[ For large values values of the Darcy number\ the permeability of the
of Ri "see Fig[ 7#\ the buoyancy e}ect is dominant and medium approaches zero causing the ~ow eventually to
the streamlines are almost stagnant in the bulk of the cease in the bulk of the cavity[ Also\ Figs[ 4Ð6 indicate
cavity interior except at portions close to the sliding top that as Da:9\ the convection heat transfer mechanism
wall[ is almost suppressed and the isotherms are nearly parallel
It is interesting to note that\ as the Darcy number to the horizontal walls indicating that a quasi!conduction
decreases\ the ~ow circulation is progressively inhibited regime is reached[ Moreover\ the vertical temperature
except at the portion close to the top surface by the ~ow strati_cation is substantially linear in the stagnant bulk
retarding e}ect of the porous medium[ For very small of the interior regions[ This shows that the overall heat
K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370 1360
Fig[ 2[ Comparison of the isotherms between the present prediction and Iwatsu et al[ ð04Ł in the absence of porous medium and internal
heat generation for Re092 and Gr091[
Table 1
Comparison of the maximum and minimum values of the horizontal and vertical velocities at the
mid!sections of the cavity between the present solution and those of Iwatsu et al[ ð04Ł for a vertical
cavity at Gr099 and Reynolds number of 099 and 399\ respectively
Re099 Re399
Fig[ 4[ Steady!state ~ow patterns and isotherms for various Darcy numbers at Ri09−1 and RaI9[
1363 K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370
Fig[ 5[ Steady!state ~ow patterns and isotherms for various Darcy numbers at Ri5[14×09−3 and RaI9[
K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370 1364
Fig[ 6[ Steady!state ~ow patterns and isotherms for various Darcy numbers at Ri09−3 and RaI9[
1365 K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370
Fig[ 7[ Steady!state ~ow patterns and isotherms for various Darcy numbers at Ri09 and RaI9[
K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370 1366
Fig[ 8[ Steady!state ~ow patterns and isotherms for various internal Rayleigh numbers at Da9[0 and Ri09−3[
1367 K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370
Fig[ 09[ Velocity pro_les at mid!sections of the cavity for various Da and Ri at RaI9[
K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370 1368
Fig[ 00[ Temperature pro_les at mid!sections of the cavity for various Da and Ri at RaI9[
Fig[ 01[ E}ect of Ri on the temperature and velocity pro_les at mid!sections of the cavity for Da9[0 and RaI9[
Fig[ 02[ E}ect of Ri on the average Nusselt number for various Darcy numbers at RaI9[
K[M[ Khanafer\ A[J[ Chamkha:Int[ J[ Heat Mass Transfer 31 "0888# 1354Ð1370 1370