Tutsi-Hutu Ethnic Dynamics in Rwanda
Tutsi-Hutu Ethnic Dynamics in Rwanda
German rule:
- Germany used to have control over Rwanda
- At the Paris Peace Conference, the Treaty of Versailles stripped Germany of its African
colonies, with Ruanda-Urundi going under Belgian control.
- The german rule was seen as harsh and unfair in Rwanda but didn’t contribute too much
1
- During this time period, many Tutsis were killed causing them to be displaced fleeing
into neighboring countries.
- From these exiled groups, rose Tutsi rebel movements, most notably the RPF.
2
- RPF (Tutsi) forces invaded Rwanda from their base in Uganda, sparking war
- Hutus were losing faith in Habyarimana, so the invasion was used to present the
government as a unifying force by promoting the idea of Hutu superiority
- Paul Kagame, commander of the RPF, used guerilla warfare tactics to help defeat
Habyarimana’s army.
- 1991, talks about a ceasefire were made, with both parties coming to an agreement in
1992
- The 1978 constitution made there no term limit for the President, and made the MRND
the sole legal party, meaning the Tutsi had no representation
- Goal of the war was for RPF to change this, which happened and Habyarimana and RPF
signed an agreement agreeing for a broad-based provisional government including the
RPF; Hutu extremists were angry
Kangura magazine:
- First published 1990 after first invasion from RPF
- Inspired by Josef Geobbels’ work (Nazi propaganda)
- In opposition to the Kanguka (newspaper) put out by the RPF
- Purpose was to promote ideas of Hutu power, and create hatred towards the Tutsi
- Habyarimana used this racial hatred to take down their enemy, and Kanguar was a vital
part of this
- It made it easier to spread the Hutu Power movement and their ideas
RTLM radio:
- Habyarimana government created a radio station 1993
- “Most successful hate radio in history”
- 60% population was illiterate - therefore radio was a very effective way to communicate
harmful rhetoric
- As well, almost every Rwandan home had a radio, and it was the average person’s
primary news source
- RTLM worked closely with Kangura magazine
- RTLM recorded anti-tutsi propaganda, and spread misinformation and slander
- Called the tutsis “cockroaches” and encouraged people to “cut down the tall trees”,
referring to the Tutsi people
- On the day that Habyarimana was killed, the radio sounded the instruction “Tutsis need to
be killed.”
3
Hutu power movement:
- Hutu Power was an ideology based off of Hutu supremacy and suppression of the Tutsi
race
- Habyarimana shaped much of the movements ideology
- December 1991 the MRND created a youth faction known as the Interahamwe which
became the center of the Hutu power movement and were responsible for much of the
genocide
- The Hutu Power Movement infiltrated many areas of society and the government.
- They became known as Network Zero, the name derived from their goal to reduce Tutsi
population to zero
Talks in Arusha:
- While the President officially supported reform, he secretly promoted Hutu extremism.
- International pressure and RFP's military success led to talks in Arusha 1992.
- Inside Rwanda, criticism of Habyarimana grew, creating more radicalism
- RPF forced agreement with the Hutu regime due to military strength and determination
- However, stalled peace negotiations caused the RPF to advance toward Kigali.
- French troops played a crucial role in preventing the RPF from capturing Kigali
- OAU condemned French support for the Habyarimana government
- Relative success of RPF increased Hutu extremist influence, weakened the government,
and caused Arusha agreements to be viewed as a victory for the RPF
- Both sides agreed to terms: ceasefire, reduced presidential powers, rule of law,
transitional government, power-sharing, repatriation, RPF integration into the military, a
national assembly, elections, and UN oversight
- Some believed Habyarimana had no intention of abiding by this agreement
- UNAMIR was established to oversee things in Rwanda led by Romeo A Dallaire.
Developments:
- Habyarimana failed to implement his promises in the Arusha Accords
4
- Increasing frustration among the RPF
- Growing confidence among the Hutu extremists, who stockpiled weapons and kept
making hatred with RTLM and Kangura.
- Habyarimana broke his promise to keep the extremist members of CDR out of the
transition process
- Habyarimana lost much of his power and credibility with the Hutu, rumours of
assassination spread.
Effects of Somalia:
- In Somalia, 18 US soldiers were shot at and killed creating the “Somalia syndrome”, a
belief that the US public would not tolerate military interventions that endangered US
lives.
- Therefore, this caused a lack of American interest and political will leading to oversight
on what was happening in Rwanda right before the genocide
- UNAMIR was barely equipped and understaffed for their missions.
Assassination of presidents:
- Above Kigali airport presidential jet travelling back from Arusha talks including
Habyarimana was shot down
- This was the catalyst that preceded the genocide
- Theories to who did it:
- Disaffected soldiers, who wanted the peace talks to fail
- Leader of an extremist Hutu group Colonel Théoneste Bagosora who had the
resources to do this
- RPF rebels who hoped the presidents' deaths would provoke a Hutu government
response against the Tutsi, enabling them to seize power.
- Prime Minister Agathe Uwilingiyimana, with an attempted coup d’etat to seize
power.
- Responsibility for this act is still disputed and we have no definitive answer as to who did
it.
- A French judge blamed Paul Kagame, leader of the RPF for the attack, this spread
through the Hutu, leading them to blame the Tutsis for the attack.
Causes of genocide:
- Economic factors:
- The lack of resources, great poverty
- Competition for land, rising prices, and overpopulation was the perfect storm for
social violence
- High unemployment rates, foreign debt, and informal economies such as growing
black markets in Rwanda setting the stage for the genocide.
5
- Before the Genocide over 85% of Rwanda’s population lived below the poverty
line due to the coffee price fall however mid 1980 this stat got worse
- Colonial roots:
- Belgian colonists set the stage for this dividing the two groups
- Frances's military support for the Habyarimana regime, the presence of French
troops in the country, and the financial, political, and diplomatic support for the
government from France all helped to create the conditions for the genocide to
happen.
Course:
Start of genocide:
- Killing began right after the death of Habyarimana
- Killing of the opposition and moderate Hutu members
- Prime Minister Agathe Uwilingiyimana gained power, but was murdered and sexually
assaulted
- Belgian soldiers were tortured and murdered by soldiers who were told that they were
responsible for the shooting down of Habyarimana’s aircraft
- Presidential guard started Tutsi, RPF came out of their camps to fight
- Hutu extremists gaining an upper hand in government, putting figurehead president
Theodore Sindikubwabo and prime minister Jean Kambanda in charge, who were Hutu
Power extremists
- RTLM played a huge role in the genocide, telling common Hutus about what was going
on,and telling extremists who they wanted dead
6
- Methods of killing were brutal; wooden spiked clubs, machetes, spears, and crude
instruments
- Used to incapacitate victims so that they were left disabled to slowly die because there
were so many Tutsi and couldn’t be killed fast enough
- Rape was a huge weapon, especially by perpetrators with HIV, which was used against
and to kill tens of thousands of women and girls
- Four of the 10 Hutu Commandments portrayed Tutsi women as sexual weapons used to
weaken and destroy Hutu men.
- Attackers mutilated women and then raped them, cutting off or puncturing their body
parts and them making them watch their husbands being killed
- Sexual violence like this erodes the fabric of a community, as women are seen as the
source of a community’s cultural values
- Organized propaganda contributed significantly to the violence against Tutsi women, and
were often publicized.
Role of RPF:
- Wouldn’t negotiate with government
- They began winning and lots of people left
7
- The international media had failed Rwanda:
- The lack of media didn’t allow those in international community to take action
- Media more interested in Yugoslavia, the OJ Simpson case, and Nelson Mandela’s
election
- Media was important, demonstrated in UN tribunal where hate speech and words were
prosecuted as a war crime (first time since Nuremberg Trials)
UNAMIR:
- General Dallaire and the UNAMIR were helpless. Dallaire requested for help, and
warned the UNSC of the prospect of genocide asking for a increase in peacekeeping
forces.
- However, after the deaths of the Belgian peacekeepers, instead of bolstering the mission
as requested by Dallaire, the Belgian government turned and withdrew all its troops
- UNAMIR continued to save lives only because of the men that stayed behind, and
because of the will of General Dallaire.
- By the end of April, the RPF took control of eastern parts of the country as killing
increased.
- The UNAMIR always sought to intervene between the Hutu killers and the Tutsi
civilians, and mediate between the RPF and the Rwandan army.
- UNAMIR’s inability to play more of a role was also partially due to Jacques-Roger
Booh-Booh, appointed head of the mission. He consistently downplayed the significance
of the genocide
- The Security Council, at the request of the USA, voted to withdraw all but a remnant of
the UNAMIR mission
- UNAMIR was hampered from the beginning by the lack of support from countries
- Was understaffed, poorly equipped, underfunded
- Most people in Rwanda saw the violence as a genocide, however people in the outside
world chose not to see it as a genocide
- Dallaire blamed the UN, especially the US, France, and UK
Role of Belgium:
- When UNAMIR was formed in 1993, Belgians contributed the most troops, presenting
themselves as specialists in African affairs
- However the genocidaires were counting on the fact that the Western countries would
pull out of the mission when their peacekeepers were killed, knowing the Somalia
syndrome
- After the murder of the peacekeepers from Belgium, there was a mission to withdraw the
remaining Belgian and French citizens from Rwanda
- The success of this mission had shown that they had the capacity to do something if they
wished to do so.
8
- Many Belgian peacekeepers forced to withdraw “threw down their blue berets” in disgust
- This was a death sentence for an untold number of Tutsi.
- Furthermore, the role of Belgium important in their past in Rwanda creating the ethnic
divide between Tutsi and Hutu
- Belgium, in conclusion, was the best informed and most eligible country to support and
help Rwanda, but its decision to withdraw was negatively critical to the genocide.
Role of France:
- Openly supported the regime of Habyarimana.
- Trained the Rwandan army, the Interahamwe militia, and undercover operatives trailed
the presidential guard.
- They sent 600 elite troops when the RPF invasion began, saving Kigali from an attack.
- Their policy was to avoid a military victory for the rebel RPF, and supported the
legitimate Hutu government
- Also against the RPF to prevent Rwanda from being the first domino to fall in the feared
anglophone invasion
- Historians argue that France enabled the genocide by supporting the Hutu regime before,
during and after the killing of 1994.
- The French government discriminated against the RPF
- France continued to send weapons to the genocidaires despite the arms embargo.
Operation Amaryllis:
- April 8th 1994, two days after Habyarimana was killed, France launched Operation
Amaryllis
- Dispatched 500 French soldiers to evacuate foreign residents
- Evacuated Habyarimana’s wife and gave her $40,000 from a sum set for Rwandan
refugees.
- This shows what could have been done immediately to enhance UNAMIR’s chances of
preventing violence
9
- Elite French troops landed and deployed soldiers, however they arrived with massive
equipment and firepower, horribly inconsistent with a humanitarian mission.
- The Interim Government welcomed the French and RTLM even told Hutu girls to make
the French feel welcome
- However, once in Rwanda French realized what was going on, and that the Hutu were not
the good guys or the victims.
- On July 4th, Paul Kagame’s rebel RPF took control of Kigali and announced the
formation of a new government, two weeks later a ceasefire was declared.
- This French operation saved many Tutsi lives as the RPF advanced. However, they were
also responsible for helping a number many people responsible for the genocide escape
the country.
- French flew genocidaires to unidentified destinations like Colonel Theoneste Bagosora,
who was the leader of the genocide
- Former members of the interim government were even given asylum in France.
- Operation Turquoise ended in August 1994, when the RPF had won
- During and after the genocide, France had remained considered itself to be blameless for
any aspect of the Rwandan tragedy.
Effects:
The refugee crisis:
- More than 200,000 Rwandans crossed into Tanzania marking the start to one of the
biggest refugee crises of the century
10
- 5 million people left the country from 1993-1999
- Just in 1994 2-3 million people fled (mostly Hutu)
- Surrounding countries such as Zaire, Burundi, Tanzania and Uganda took in a massive
amounts of Rwandan refugees
- Conditions in these camps were not up to living standards
- Overcrowded, dirty, many people died from diseases, such as cholera epidemic of Goma
that claimed around 50000 lives
- Frequently faced resource issues, being short on clean drinking water and shelters
- Security was appalling, with many women and girls being traumatized and raped
- Interahamwe would frequently take control of these refugee camps and use them as
safehouses to attack the RPF from
- This made it harder for humanitarian aid to get in as it was a massive security breach
11
- However by 1998, the total prison population had risen to 130,000 whereas only 1,200
people had been brought before the courts, had to be faster
- Decided to adapt the traditional Gacaca community justice system to deal with the crimes
of the genocide
- The Gacaca court consisted of people from the local community to elect judges
- Defendants were given shorter sentences in exchange for confessing and asking for
forgiveness from their victim’s family
- Two million cases were tried in the Gaca courts during a 10 year period before they
officially closed in 2012
Social impact:
- Rwanda was having significant difficulty rebuilding its society
- “Rwanda is the only nation where hundreds of thousands of people who took part in mass
murder live intermingled at every level of society with the families of their victims.”
- Death toll at 800,000, significant impact on the society and culture
- Because most of the victims were men, women became more important to society
- Female literacy rose significantly over the next decades
- 30% of all seats in local and national government must be held by women
- As many girls as boys receive primary and secondary education
- Women now comprise the majority of Rwanda’s working population
- The genocide forced Rwandans to recognize the need to rebuild their social structure in a
more sustainable way
Political impact:
- New government called The Broad Based Government of National Unity
- Run by a Hutu who was part of the RPF
- The new government tried to stop any discrimination of ethnicity and race and stressed
unity and reconciliation.
- The new government also reopened schools and looked over the school curriculums to
make sure to teach the importance of Rwandan history.
- RPF has dominated politics after the Genocide and has retained power through the years.
Economic impact:
- The genocide and events leading up to it (including the crash in world coffee prices)
destroyed Rwanda’s already unstable economic base.
- In 1994, Rwanda had a 58% decrease in GDP.
- Rebuilding the economy was one of the major challenges for the new government.
- Rwanda made major progress in attracting foreign investments, stabilising and restoring
the economy.
12
- Since 1995 Rwanda has had one of the fastest growing economies in Africa with a GDP
increasing about 8.2% every year from 1995 to 2001.
- Foreign donors helped a lot, and many believe this is a form of compensation for ignoring
the genocide
- Coffee and tea make up about 80% of Rwanda’s export revenues.
- Poverty remained a persistent problem with an estimated 45% of the population living in
poverty with an income of less than $1.50 a day.
- Rwanda has very few natural resources so a driving economic problem is diversifying
crops.
Important people:
Phillipe Gaillard:
- Head of the Red Cross in Rwanda
- Stayed in Rwanda for the entirety of the genocide
- Red Cross was a safe haven for thousands of Rwandans in need of medical support
- Gaillard risked his life bring wounded Hutu and Tutsi survivors to the Red Cross for
treatment
- He worked with the support of the International Committee of Geneva to tell the
international media about the genocide
- He is believed to have helped the Red Cross save over 65,000 lives
13
Romeo Dallaire:
- Commander of the UNAMIR in Rwanda
- From 1993 until the end of the genocide in 1994
- Maintained safe areas for Rwandans threatened by Hutu killers and government soldiers
- He did all of this despite having little support from the UN and the international
community, and having less than 1000 troops
Carl Wilkens:
- Carl Wilkens was the head of the Adventist Development and Relief Agency (ADRA)
- Wilkens was an American pastor
- He was the only American to remain in the capital Kigali throughout the entire genocide.
- He hid his Tutsi servants in their house where they stayed hidden for three weeks.
- He negotiated with known genocidaires to save the lives of people
- When the Hutu militia threatened to massacre everyone inside a orphanage, he petitioned
Kigali police to stop the attack, saving the lives of hundreds of children
14