Chair Guide
Chair Guide
AND
CHAIRING SCRIPT
Roll Call
Opening Debate
After you have set the agenda, the real fun begins and the main substance of the debate can
start! You will be in this section for a majority of the conference, likely one full day,
interrupted occasionally with suspending the debate (see the last section) and reopening
debate in the morning. You should make sure that after the speakers list is established and
speeches have started, that once enough speeches have been made for some key issues to
be raised (usually around 4 or 5) then you open the floor to points or motions.
Responding to Yields
“Thank you delegate, the next delegate to take the floor will be the delegate of X, Delegate of
X, you have the floor”
“Thank you delegate, the Delegate has yielded to points of information, do any delegates
have any points of information” *Delegate Raises Placard* “Yes Delegate of Y”
After the point has been raised “Delegate of X, do you accept this point of information”
Delegate X says yes, “Delegate of X, you have the remaining time to answer”
Delegate X says No, “Do any other delegates have a point of information to ask to the
delegate of X”
No delegate has a point, “There are no remaining points of information for the delegate, the
chairs will automatically assume the time”
Forgetting to Yield
“The floor is open for points and motions; all those with points and motions please raise your
placards now”
As mentioned, try to do this regularly within committee because these are what push the
debate substantially
After Motion with Seconds and Objections
“Seeing this motion has received seconds and objections, we will take some more motions,
are there any other points or motions on the floor?”
After all motions are defeated
“Seeing all motions defeated we will return to the general speakers list”
If one of the motion passes, see below.
Moderated Caucuses
Delegate motions for Moderated Caucus, Speaking time 1min, Overall time 10mins on the
Subject of X
“Thank you delegate, this is in order, the delegate has motioned for a 10 minute moderated
caucus, 1-minute speaking time on the subject of X, are there any seconds to this motion?”
Make sure to read out the motion just afterward to clarify with the delegate, and so people
understand what it is about.
Motion passes
“Seeing more votes in favor/no objections this motion passes, delegate of X, do you wish to
speak first or last in this moderated caucus?”
Always make sure to keep track of who is speaking in Mod Caucuses, stops you from
accidentally choosing spoken people and stops confusion.
Chair chooses someone to speak
“All those delegates who wish to speak in this moderated caucus please raise your placards
now, *time choosing* delegate of X, you have the floor”
Don’t let them raise their placards before now.
Delegate is done speaking and it is ready to choose the next delegate
“Thank you delegate, all those wishing to speak raise your placards now”
Motion Fails
“Seeing more votes against/no seconds this motion fails”
If there are more motions to vote upon go to them, otherwise if that was the last motion
to vote on and it has failed, then go to the general speaker’s list.
Delegate motions with a fault in their motion i.e ask for a 25min caucus
“Delegate you cannot motion for a moderated caucus of total duration over 20 minutes,
would 15 minutes be more reasonable?”
Always try and suggest something to overcome the fault a delegate makes, will make the
process a lot smoother.
Moderated Caucus ends
“Thank you delegate, The time for this moderated caucus has elapsed”
If you want to open the floor again for motions go to opening the floor, otherwise, go back
to the general speaker’s list.
Unmoderated Caucuses
Working Papers
Firstly, Working papers do not need to be in any specific format, and don’t need a motion to
be introduced. However, they do need chair approval and a way to be disseminated to the
committee. Therefore, you probably want them sent via email for you to look at, then put
onto either a google drive that everyone has access to, or a facebook group to put them on.
Delegate submits a working paper and it is approved:
“Delegates, we have received one working paper from the Delegate of X, this working paper
is approved and has been added to the (whatever you’re using to share). This working paper
will now be known as working paper 1.1”
Note that if you are on the first topic, the first number is 1, if you are on the second topic,
the first number is 2
Also, the second number relates to the number of working papers, 1.1 is the first WP of the
first topic, 1.2 is the second WP of the first topic, ect…
You can have multiple working papers, but try not to have too many, because the main act of
working papers is a bridge to the draft resolution
Draft Resolutions
Draft resolutions are where the real substance comes in. They require a specific format (a
good example is found on WiseMee here) and require some level of motioning to introduce
and some extra motions afterward. In brief, a Draft Resolution needs signatories (and
sometimes sponsors) and will need some back and forth on the clauses to make sure that
they are formatted properly and are all correct. However, once a Draft Resolution is all
formatted correctly and ready to introduce, then that’s where we start
A Draft Resolution has been submitted and is ready to be introduced
“Delegates, we have received one Draft resolution from the delegate of X, this draft
resolution is ready to be introduced”
You need to “approve” the DR first before it can be properly introduced
Motion to introduce the Draft Resolution is called by a delegate
“Delegates, a motion to introduce Draft Resolution 1.1 has been raised, this motion does not
require seconds nor a vote, and thereby passes automatically, it has been uploaded to the
Drive, would the sponsors of the resolution please like to read out the operative clauses of
the resolution”
So a few things, firstly the numbering is the same as for Working Papers
Secondly, depending on ROPs you might not need seconds or a vote, but motion is always
needed, and it is very rare for a motion to introduce a DR is ever failed
Thirdly the resolution does need to be read out, unless you are pressed for time
Motion for a Question and Answer Session is called
“Delegates, there has been a motion for a Question and Answer session on Draft Resolution
1.1, could the sponsors of the resolution please come up to the dais. They will have 10
minutes to answer any technical questions about the resolution”
This motion is only in order straight after the introduction of a resolution, and it’s also
good to mention this after the resolution is introduced
In addition, this Q&A session should NOT be about the substance of the resolution, just
technicalities such as clarification of wording ect…
Amendments
Amendments are always the hardest part of the committee to get right. By the time you’re at
this stage you’ve had 2 days debating and endless drafting. Still, amendments are some of
the most important parts of the committee as it allows for constructive debate towards the
end.
The ROPs regarding amendments are almost ALWAYS different too, so I would ask you to
take this section with a grain of salt. Here I’m going to use what I call UNA-USA Simplified.
For a brief rundown:
Amendments need to be sent in and do one of three things, Modify, Strike (delete) or Add a
Clause. You can only do ONE of these per amendment. They must be sent digitally and
approved first before being able to be introduced
There are two types of amendments, Friendly and Unfriendly, Friendly amendments are those
with all the sponsors of the resolution as signatories to the amendment. When Friendlies are
approved and then introduced through a motion, they are automatically put into effect.
UNfriendlies require signatories to the amendment and are not approved by all sponsors.
Therefore when they are introduced via a motion there are 2 speakers in favour and 2 against,
then a vote to introduce it.
If all else fails, relying on this method will save you time and energy, but for a more
comprehensive overview, do check your MUNs ROPs as it will be different.
After an amendment has been sent and is approvable
“Delegates, we have received one (Friendly/unfriendly) amendment from the delegate of X,
this amendment is ready to be introduced as Amendment 1.1. “
Number for an amendment is dependent on which topic and how many have preceded it,
1.1 is the first, 1.2 the second ect…
Motion to introduce Amendment 1.1 (which is friendly) is raised
“This motion is on order, are there any seconds?”
*Seconds and no objections, motion passes*
*Chair briefly reads out amendment*
“Sponsors of resolution 1.1, (read out the sponsors), are you all in favour of this amendment?”
*They all say yes*
“This amendment is therefore automatically introduced into the draft resolution 1.1”
Motion to introduce Amendment 1.1 (which is unfriendly) is raised
“This motion is in order, are there any seconds to this motion?”
*Motion passes*
*Chair Reads out the amendment*
“We will now take two delegates who wish to speak in favor of this amendment, and two
against. All those wishing to speak in favor of this amendment please raise your placards
now”
*Chair chooses 2 speakers to speak in favor, adds to a speakers list*
“All those wishing to speak against this amendment please raise your placards now”
*Chair chooses 2 speakers to speak against, adds to a speakers list, alternatives speakers so it
is for, against, for and against*
“Delegate of X, you have the floor for 60 seconds speaking in favor of this amendment”
*The rest of the speeches occur*
“We will now close the debate on the amendment and move swiftly to the voting procedure
on amendment 1.1, remember delegates this is a substantive vote, so the options to vote are
in favor, against and abstain. If you declared yourself present and voting, you cannot abstain.
All those in favor raise your placards now”
*Delegate raise, e.g. 10 in favor, 9 against, 2 abstentions*
“With 10 in favor, 9 against and 2 abstentions this motion passes, it will be added to the draft
resolution shortly”
Voting Procedure
Now you’re done! You have a good draft resolution, it’s been amended enough and you’re on
the home stretch. There’s no substantive debate left, maybe some competing draft
resolutions but it’s time now to move to voting procedure. This part can be very complicated
for delegates, so it is important to explain at every stage what’s necessary. You can look at it
like this, firstly you close debate and move to voting, then there are a few motions you can do
firstly, then you vote. Simple enough, but believe me, it can get confusing.
Moving to Voting
The floor is open and there is a motion to close debate and move to the voting procedure
“This is in order, this motion does not require seconds or objections but a 2/3rds procedural
vote in favour, all those in favour please raise your placards now”
*The 2/3rds threshold is met*
“Delegates we are now in voting procedure, the use of electronics is forbidden and the doors
are now locked”
*Close the doors, make sure that no-one has their laptops open*
– Sometimes there is also a 5 or 10-minute unmod caucus when this happens, to give people
time to do some final lobbying, check your ROPs
Normal Voting
Well now you’re done with that, it’s time for the voting procedure finally! This might be
repeated a few times but it’s unlikely to take long. In the normal voting procedure, you merely
do the voting via raised placards and entertain In favour, Against or Abstentions. Make sure
to check the roll call at the beginning of the session for who made themselves present and
voting
“We are now moving onto the voting procedure for Draft Resolution 1.2, All those in favor
raise your placards now”
*12 raise their placards*
“All those against raise your placards now”
*7 raise their placards*
“And all those abstaining*
*2 raise their placards*
“With 12 in favor, 7 against and 2 abstentions, this Draft Resolution passes and all others are
discarded, clapping is now in order”
Note that because we reordered the draft resolutions earlier, Draft resolution 1.2 is the first
we vote on
Roll-Call voting
In roll-call voting, the situation is similar except you have to go round every delegate and ask
whether they are voting in favor, against, Yes with rights, No with rights, Abstaining or
Passing.
“We are now moving onto the voting procedure for Draft Resolution 1.2, Delegate of A how
do you vote”
*Votes In favor*
“Delegate of B how do you vote”
*Passes*
“Delegate of C how do you vote”
*Votes in Favour*
*goes through all other delegates, returns to Delegate of B*
“Delegate of B, do you vote in favor or against”
*Votes Against*
*More votes in favor than against*
“With 12 votes in favor, 7 against and 2 abstentions, this draft resolution passes, all others are
discarded and clapping is in order”
If there is another topic to discuss, and enough time to do it, then a motion to set the agenda
is once again in order
Motion to set the agenda to topic B is set
“This is in order, seeing no other topic to set the agenda to this motion will immediately go to
seconds, are there any seconds?”
*There are seconds, no objections*
“This motion passes, the Agenda has now been set to topic B, the floor is open for points and
motions, and the chairs would look favorably on a motion to open the general speaker’s list”
Return to the section on the general speaker’s list and go from there!
Well now the debating is done, it’s time to relax, cool down and have some fun. At this point,
many committees might do superlatives or funny awards, get to signing placards and also get
feedback from chairs. Revel in the enjoyment you had and the good and bad times.
Points
Suspending Debate