Ethical Issues in Assisted Reproductive Technology
Ethical Issues in Assisted Reproductive Technology
and Society
1
Module 9: Issues and
Concerns on Science and
Technology and its
impact to the Society
“As research and technology are changing society and the way we
live, scientists can no longer claim that science is neutral but must
consider the ethical and social aspects of their work” - Maurizio
Learning Outcome:
Analyze and critique specific issues and concerns on Science
and Technology and its impact to the Society.
97
F
GROUP 4
First Issue: The Effects of Assisted Human Reproduction
101
9
9
There are five basic steps to IVF:
The man's sperm is placed together with the best quality eggs. The
mixing of the sperm and egg is called insemination.Eggs and sperm are then
stored in an environmentally controlled chamber. The sperm most often enters
(fertilizes) an egg a few hours after insemination.If the doctor thinks the chance of
fertilization is low, the sperm may be directly injected into the egg. This is called
intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI).Many fertility programs routinely do ICSI on
some of the eggs, even if things appear normal.
102
100
• Issues and Concerns
112
109
Technological Issues:
113
110
Biosafety and Risk Assessment
GROUP 5
• Since the commercial release of GM crops in 1996, there have been many published
scientific articles on the food safety assessment of GM food crops based on substantial
equivalence. Since 2009, such studies have been summarized and reviewed and have
shown that many transgenic crops are similar in composition with their conventional
counterparts using compositional analyses from simple proximate chemical to complex
transcriptone analysis. However, various studies have also revealed the large
variability in the composition of non-transgenic crops. Thus, while some groups oppose
the use of the concept of substantial equivalence to provide evidence for food safety of
GM foods, others believe that evaluation should be restricted only to potentially
harmful coonstituents which are known to be present in some crops and which could
affect their safety. Recently, an examination of 20-years data on compositional
analyses of GM and nontransgenic counterparts revealed overwhelming evidence that
genetic engineering is “less disruptive of crop composition” than traditional breeding
and the authors concluded that the requirement for compositional analysis may not be
warranted.
114
111
Biosafety Regulation in the Philippines
Lab research
Field work
Concept/ Strategy;
choice of Agronomic or Product Advance
gene(s)sources of horticultural traits Evaluation of food and
gene(s); environmental evaluation; genetic feed safely; safety to
or ecological stability; impact on environment
consideration of gene environment.
or product
112
R & D and commercial products involving GM technology are regulated from
laboratory research, to field work and to product advancement in the market.
Assessment is strictly science-based, conducted by the regulatory body and its
Scientific and Technical Review Panels and done on a case- by-case basis. There
is
public consultation on any technology that will be field-tested or commercialized.
II. How the Smartphones Impacted the Society and our Personal Lives
Mobile phones have changed how we negotiate our relationships with
family, spouses and close friends. Increased levels of mobile phone
subscriptions are linked with improvements in education, gender equality and
political participation, particularly in developing countries. They are also
associated with higher economic growth.
1. Relationships: Mobile phones have altered our relationships with family,
spouses and close friends. But while they seem to promise a wider social
network, more than half of the average person’s calls and texts go to only four
to six different people.
2. Health: Mobile phones significantly help to maintain physical and
psychological health when family members move away from home. And they
enable women to maintain three roles within the household, simultaneously
being wives, mothers and wage earners.
3. Political participation: More mobile phone subscriptions are correlated with
more democratic participation, less gender inequality and longer time spent in
education. In all three areas, the impact of mobiles on social development
indicators is stronger in developing countries.
4. Economic growth: Mobile technologies contribute significantly to GDP growth,
with a forecast range of between 1.8% in the UK and 24.9% in Egypt over the
years 2010-2020, compared with today’s GDP. Again, the effects will be larger in
developing countries.
119
ISSUES AND CONCERNS
Smartphones has changed our lives for the better in some ways, but it definitely has its drawbacks, too.
Here are some issues and concerns about using smartphones:
1. Smartphones contribute to sleep issues. Research has found that using your smartphone before
bed can make it harder to fall asleep due to the blue light it emits, as Business Insider previously
reported. “Not only does the bright light emitted by digital devices impact in our sleep, but social
media content distracts and entertains us, too,” Dr. Flores said.
2. They can ruin romantic relationship. Smartphones could also be damaging people’s romantic
relationship. It’s probably happened to you at some point – the person you’re on a date with looks
at their phone more than you. Furthermore, some couples are spending more time engaged with
their significant others, which can take a toll on intimacy.
3. They have a negative influence on parenting. Research has shown that when parents are on their
smartphones while with their children, they are not fully present, which can lead to a host of
emotional issues in kids, according to Psychology Today. “Children feel loved when they obtain
attention from their parents; otherwise, they will feel emotionally neglected,” Dr. Flores said.
“What’s worse is when parents are physically present, but their attention is absorbed elsewhere.
The message children receive is they are not an important part of their parent’s lives (compared to
their contacts on social media networks).”
4. They’re replacing in-person communication and conflict. Some people now choose to have in-depth
“discussions” and disagreements via phone messaging instead of in person, from ending
relationships to having heated debates.
5. People expect us to be online and connected to our phones all the time. In the smartphone era,
people often expect you to be digitally connected 24/7 and to get back to them instantaneously,
too — especially with email and social media read receipts. However, this is not realistic, and can
cause problems when one party has the 24/7 availability mindset and the other does not.
6. Studies show that reading on a smartphone is worse for learning and comprehension. With a mini-
computer in your pocket everywhere you go, it’s easy to opt for reading on your smartphone rather
than carrying around a newspaper, magazine, or book. Despite the convenience, some research
indicates that you may want to rethink ditching paper reading material altogether. For example,
one study found that students learned better from print textbooks versus screens. “A healthy
practice is to limit digital exposure, and this includes the types of reading you do on your
smartphone,” Dr. Flores said. “Plus, doing so will help minimize the negative effects of over-
exposure to negative messages and news articles seen on social media networks.”
7. Some research says smartphones are not great for our brains. Smartphones can encourage mental
laziness. For instance, instead of doing math in your head or with pen and paper — say, when you’re
splitting a restaurant bill with friends — you may just use your phone calculator instead. But research
shows that smartphone use can slow down your thinking process, as Business Insider previously
reported.
8. They may not be good for our mental health. Increased smartphone use may also lead to
depression. For instance, according to researchers who studied college students, the more they used
Facebook, the more their well-being decreased. “I recommend putting smartphones away as much as
possible, and doing so may be quite beneficial towards your mental health,” Dr. Flores said.
9. Security related hardships. Most individuals are concerned about the security of their information or
the physical security of their device.
10. Some research says smartphones are not great for our brains. Smartphones can encourage mental
laziness. For instance, instead of doing math in your head or with pen and paper — say, when you’re
splitting a restaurant bill with friends — you may just use your phone calculator instead. But research
shows that smartphone use can slow down your thinking process, as Business Insider previously
reported.
11. They may not be good for our mental health. Increased smartphone use may also lead to
depression. For instance, according to researchers who studied college students, the more they used
Facebook, the more their well-being decreased. “I recommend putting smartphones away as much as
possible, and doing so may be quite beneficial towards your mental health,” Dr. Flores said.
12. Security related hardships. Most individuals are concerned about the security of their information
or the physical security of their device.
117
FOURTH ISSUES: Effects of Using Internet and Its Issues
and Concerns.
The Internet has turned our existence upside down. It has revolutionized
communications, to the extent that it is now our preferred medium of everyday
communication. In almost everything we do; we use the Internet. Ordering a pizza,
buying a television, sharing a moment with a friend, sending a picture over instant
messaging. Before the Internet, if you wanted to keep up with the news, you had to
walk down to the newsstand when it opened in the morning and buy a local edition
reporting what had happened the previous day. But today a click or two is enough to
read your local paper and any news source from anywhere in the world, updated up to
the minute.
The Internet itself has been transformed. In its early days—which from a historical
perspective are still relatively recent—it was a static network designed to shuttle a
small freight of bytes or a short message between two terminals; it was a repository of
information where content was published and maintained only by expert coders.
Today, however, immense quantities of information are uploaded and downloaded over
this electronic leviathan, and the content is very much our own, for now we are all
commentators, publishers, and creators.
The emergence of web 2.0 in the first decade of the twenty-first century was itself a
revolution in the short history of the Internet, fostering the rise of social media and
other interactive, crowd-based communication tools.
The Internet was no longer concerned with information exchange alone: it was a
sophisticated multidisciplinary tool enabling individuals to create content,
communicate with one another, and even escape reality. Today, we can send data
from one end of the world to the other in a matter of seconds, make online
presentations, live in parallel “game worlds,” and use pictures, video, sound, and text
to share our real lives, our genuine identity. Personal stories go public; local issues
become global.
It is the guiding technology of the IT Age just as the electrical engine was of the
Industrial Age. The internet is a global network of inter-linked networks that mainly
provide wireless interactive communication. Though the internet was first deployed in
1969, it was only in the 1990s that it became available to the public.
From there onwards, its use has diffused rapidly throughout the world with
there being around 7 billion users of wireless devices currently that employ internet
technology. With about 7.7 billion people in this world and with limited use among
those under 5 years of age, it’s almost safe to say that the entire humanity is now
connected to the internet! There are however variations in the bandwidths available,
the efficiency and cost of its use.
It’s been postulated that about 95% of all information available has been
digitized and made accessible via the internet. The internet has also led to a complete
transformation in communication, availability of knowledge as well as social
interaction. However, as with all major technological changes, there are positive and
negative effects of the internet on the society too.
Since the 1970s and the 1980s, human diets have been changing from raw,
unprocessed foods and traditional dishes to an increasing intake of ultra-processed food and
beverages. Advances in food science and technology and globalized food distribution have made
these foods more accessible and convenient at relatively low prices.
Industrial processing creates food products with ingredients and food additives to
enhance flavor, increase durability and contribute to the consumer’s convenience. However,
these food products have more calories, higher glycemic indexes, more trans fats, sugars, and
sodium, also being lower in fiber, micronutrients, and phytochemicals. There is growing evidence
that the increased consumption of ultra-processed foods is associated with overweight obesity
and chronic diseases including diabetes.
Between the paleo diet, the keto craze and the debate over whether low-carb or low-
fat diets are better for your health, deciding what to eat can seem more complicated than ever.
One issue that health experts seem to agree on is that we should all be eating fewer processed
foods. What exactly are processed foods, why are they so bad for our health and how can we
replace them in our diet?
Processed food is any food that’s altered during preparation to make it more
convenient, shelf-stable, or flavorful. Some foods are much more processed than others. A
bagged salad or pre-cut green beans technically count as processed, but it’s only minimally
processed because its natural state hasn’t changed. In other words, it looks pretty much the
same as you’d find it in nature. A box of macaroni and cheese or a microwavable dinner, on the
other hand, are considered heavily processed (also called ultra-processed) because they’ve been
chemically altered with artificial flavors, additives, and other ingredients.
Most foods we eat have been processed in some way by the time they reach our
plates. However, the concern about processed food isn’t over items like canned tomatoes or
canned tuna, which are processed to lock in freshness and nutrients. The concern is over more
heavily processed foods like crackers, jarred pasta sauces and cake mixes. And we eat a lot of
these foods – it’s estimated that more than half the calories in the average American diet come
from ultra-processed foods. In Canada, the percentage is slightly lower, at 48 percent.
1. Increased cancer risk. A five-year study of over 100,000 people found that every 10 percent
increase in consumption of ultra-processed food was associated with a 12 percent higher risk for
cancer.
2. Too much sugar, sodium, and fat. Heavily processed foods often include unhealthy levels of
added sugar, sodium, and fat. These ingredients make the food we eat taste better, but too
much of them leads to serious health issues like obesity, heart disease, high blood pressure and
diabetes.
3. Lacking in nutritional value. Heavy processing strips many foods of their basic nutrients, which is
why many foods today are fortified with fiber, vitamins, and minerals.
4. Calorie dense and addicting. It’s very easy to overindulge in unhealthy food and consume more
calories than we realize. For example, an Oreo cookie contains about 50 calories, while an entire
cup of green beans is only 44 calories. Processed foods like these are also designed to stimulate
our brain’s “feel-good” dopamine center, making us crave more of them in the future.
5. Quicker to digest. Processed foods are easier to digest than unprocessed, whole foods. That
means our bodies burn less energy (hint: calories) digesting them. It’s estimated we burn half as
many calories digesting processed foods compared to unprocessed foods. This fact combined
with the calorie density of processed foods in general can make it easy to pack on the pounds.
6. Full of artificial ingredients. There are about 5,000 substances that get added to our food. Most
of them have never been tested by anyone other than the company using them. That includes
additives to change color, texture, flavor, and odor as well as ingredients like preservatives and
sweeteners.
Even if you wanted to, it would be very difficult to remove all heavily processed foods from your diet.
That would mean not eating out at most restaurants and skipping that hot dog at the family
barbeque.
However, there are many things you can do to reduce the amount of processed food you consume:
1. Check the label. The longer the ingredient list, the more processed a food is. If most of the
ingredients are hard-to-pronounce chemicals instead of actual food, it’s a safe bet that food is
heavily processed.
2. Shop the outside aisles at the grocery store. The center aisles of most grocery stores are full of
packaged items and ready-made foods that are heavily processed. Aim to buy more foods from
the produce and dairy aisles.
3. Opt for minimally processed meats. Choose meats that have been minimally processed (e.g.,
seafood, chicken breast) while avoiding heavily processed meats (e.g., sausage, cured meats
like bacon).
4. Start slowly. It’s okay to slowly replace processed foods in your diet with more fresh foods. In
fact, it may make you more likely to stick to these changes long-term.
5. Cook more meals at home. You might not always be in control of your diet while traveling, but
you are at home. Make your own frozen meals by cooking a larger batch and freezing the
leftovers, or whip up your own salad dressing.
While many aspects of our health can be complicated, eating less processed food doesn’t have to be.
When in doubt, just start with real food.
123