Cold War: USA vs USSR Tensions
Cold War: USA vs USSR Tensions
Definition
A period of prolonged confrontation, tension and rivalry between the USA and
The Soviet Union and their respective allies from the end of World War II to
the end of the 1980s. The period is characterised by mutual mistrust and
suspicion of each other’s intentions.
The confrontation was generated and sustained by a clash of ideological
interests and was underpinned by a nuclear arms race and a permanent
threatening shadow over the politics of the world.
There was no actual fighting or “hot” war. However, there were occasional
areas of conventional warfare in which the super powers supported opposing
sides – wars by proxy such as in Korea, Vietnam and China.
USA USSR
1945- 1953 Harry Truman 1927 - Josef Stalin
1953
1954 - Dwight Eisenhower 1953 - George Malenkof
1961 1955
1961 - John F. Kennedy 1955 - Nikita Khrushchev
1963 1964
1963 - Lyndon B. Johnson 1964 - Leonard Brezhnev
1968 1982
1969 - Richard Nixon 1982 - Yuri Andropov
1974 1984
1981 - Ronald Reagan 1984 - Konstantin Chernenko
1989 1985
1989 - George Bush 1985 - Mikhail Gorbachev
1993 1991
Our focus will be on the Cold War in Germany as it became the “playground” for both
sides.
1
The Roots of the Cold War
Although we refer to the Cold War beginning in 1945, it has its roots much earlier in
history.
2. Civil War 1918 – The USA and her allies – the “Whites”- fought against the
“Reds” – this caused the communists to feel threatened and betrayed by the
West.
AMERICAN CAPITALISM
SOVIET COMMUNISM
Rich people are wicked and selfish. They should be forced to share their
wealth.
Factories and other property should be owned by the state on behalf of all the
people.
A communist government should get involved in every aspect of life.
At elections people should only be allowed to choose communists for
government.
The Press should never criticise a communist government.
Religious belief is nonsense and should be wiped out by the government.
2
4. Stalin’s policies during his reign (1927 onwards)– The USA disliked his
dictatorial and violent approach to power. The Purges resulted in 40 million
Russians being murdered by Stalin.
5. Stalin signed a non-aggression pact with Hitler in 1939 – this caused the
West to mistrust the USSR who were seen to appease Hitler and tolerate
German Nazi aggression against the West
1. The West delayed opening a 2nd front in 1941 to assist Russia when she
was attacked by Germany. When Stalin asked the Allies for assistance, they
delayed responding and sent troops to North Africa instead. Russia
experienced massive losses initially and blamed the West. Suspicion and
mistrust increased.
2. The USA remained silent and secretive about testing the atomic bomb
and did not inform the USSR of their decision to drop the bomb on Japan in
August 1945. (FDR started this program and Truman continued it after FDRs
death). In reality, Stalin knew of the program but was still mistrustful of the
West.
After World War II and the defeat of Nazi Germany there seemed to be no need for
this uneasy alliance.
Shortly before his death, Hitler predicted the start of the cold war.
3
Tension after World War II centred around the
decisions taken over the partition and
administration of Germany. (Immediate Causes)
Yalta Conference
February 1945 (Before Germany had surrendered) –
Leaders present to discuss the issue of Germany: “The Big 3” - Churchill, Stalin and
Roosevelt
Potsdam Conference
4
July/August 1945
Leaders present to continue discussions about Germany: Stalin, Clement Atlee
(who replaced Churchill who had lost elections in UK), Truman (FDR had died in
April)
WHY?
Clash over reparations – Stalin did not keep his side of the agreement.
5
After 1945 the Soviet Union took control of much of Eastern Europe. Historians are
still debating the motives behind this take-over. Was this a defensive move or was
this a step towards a take-over of the whole of Europe?
The Soviet take-over was completed by 1948 but it began before the end of WW2.
As countries were liberated from the Germans, the Red Army made sure
governments friendly towards the Soviets replaced the Nazi imposed governments.
In most countries the Soviet government set up anti-fascist coalition governments
but gave local communists a leading position.
6
Stalin justified his expansion as follows: He was concerned about the future security
of the Soviet Union and wanted to safeguard the Soviet Union from any future attack.
The satellite states would therefore ensure loyal governments along the borders of
the Soviet Union. These states would act as a “buffer” between him and the west. In
particular, Stalin wanted to ensure that Germany could never again invade the
borders of the Soviet Union. The satellite states would also act as trading partners
with the Soviet Union and their raw materials could be used to help bolster the
industrialisation of the Soviet Union and help her to recover after the devastation of
World War II where Russia experienced massive losses – the most of all allies in the
war.
However, the west viewed this expansion and control of Eastern Europe as
aggressive and deliberate. The spread of communism threatened the freedoms of
countries and should be contained at all costs.
How did the USA react to the Soviet take-over of eastern Europe?
After 1945 the USA moved away from isolationism and built up its own ‘sphere of
interest’: a group of pro-American states that included all of the world’s richest
industrialised countries.
He went further and declared that American support was available for any people
who wanted to fight communism. This became known as the Truman Doctrine. It
was based on the idea of containment – the USA would use its wealth and
power to stop or contain the spread of communism. It was not an action but
rather a political statement.
Through the Truman Doctrine the USA had rejected isolationism and announced it
would play a leading role in world politics.
7
The Marshall Plan (The Economic Response)
(The Truman Doctrine was translated into action via the Marshall Plan)
The USA committed millions of dollars to assist Europe to rebuild after World War II
as there was a belief that communism could only be stopped if Western Europe
became wealthy. By the spring of 1947 it was clear that without American help there
was little chance of economic recovery.
In June 1947, General George Marshall (minister of foreign affairs) announced the
scheme whereby the USA would offer economic aid to Western Europe. This money
was available to all countries; including the Soviet Union in theory. But Stalin refused
to have anything to do with it, and also ordered Poland and Czechoslovakia to not
take part as well. He saw the plan as an attempt to impose capitalist ideas on
European countries. Stalin was right. The Plan was based on a belief that
communism would be much less attractive to ordinary people if they had good jobs
and were well paid.
The Plan was a great success. Over four years, $13,000 million of help was
provided. By 1952 when the Marshall Plan officially ended, the countries were much
more economically prosperous. The Plan was also useful to the USA as by
rebuilding Western Europe, America was creating wealthy trade partners who would
want to buy large amounts of American goods.
Communists in Western countries were told to wreck the Marshall Plan through
strikes. Stalin viewed the Marshall Plan as a deliberate attempt on behalf of the USA
to spread capitalism and spread her influence in Europe to her own benefit. Stalin
viewed The Marshall Plan as ‘dollar diplomacy” and capitalist propaganda. Despite
the strikes, American money flowed into Western Europe and eventually the
demonstrations and strikes came to an end. Stalin forbid the Satellite States to
accept Marshall Aid.
Thus the Marshall Plan aggravated Cold War Tensions and some
historians call it the “first shot fired in the Cold War”.
8
countries and eventually the Soviet Union used it to encourage each country to
specialise in different products.
To take revenge for the war and to keep Germany weak, Russia plundered her zone
and the western zones into depression. Stalin also ensured that the Communist
Party rose to great strength in the eastern zone of Germany (hoping to spread
communism to the western zones of the country eventually)
9
the new currency – the Deutsch Mark (DM). At an ACC meeting, negotiations
around this issue broke down and Stalin walked out of the meeting. The western
allies introduced the DM into their zones of Germany and Berlin and Russia
introduced her own currency reform into the soviet zone of Germany and Berlin.
Stalin could not prevent the airlift unless he chose to shoot down the transport
aircraft – this was too risky because the USA possessed the atomic bomb (USSR
had not yet perfected their bomb). America had based their Super fortress aircraft
capable of carrying the atomic bomb, in the US zone of Germany.
10
The airlift demonstrated to the West Berliners that the Western Allies were
prepared to fight for them and their freedom
This episode ended ALL further negotiations and co-operation between
East and West – Stalin and communism was seen as the enemy of Western
Europe
Truman doctrine (of containment) was seen to be a reality that worked
NATO was formed by Western Allies
Germany becomes divided into TWO countries – separate from each
other:
The West combine their three zones to create German Federal Republic
(GFR) in May 1949 (became fully independent in 1955 with Bonn as the
capital)
Russia sets up the German Democratic Republic (GDR) in the Eastern
Zone (Fully independent in 1955 – East Berlin as the capital)
Germany had become the major ‘Battlefield of the Cold War in Europe and
would remain the focal point in the next two decades.
The organisation was dominated by America, reflected in the fact that every supreme
commander of NATO has been American. The formation of NATO was a milestone
in American foreign policy. Never before had the USA been a member of a
peacetime military alliance. The fact that Truman broke with all traditions of
American foreign policy shows how determined he was to stop the spread of
communism.
All NATO members agreed to go to war if any one of them was attacked. The
alliance was supported with large numbers of troops on the ground. There was a
permanent presence of American forces in Europe. In particular there were large
numbers of NATO forces in West Germany. The Soviet Union felt threatened
by this, which increased when West Germany joined NATO in 1955.
11
called the Warsaw Pact. For the next three decades NATO and Warsaw Pact forces
faced each other and prepared for war.
The Warsaw Pact was based in Moscow and was essentially a collective security
organisation against the threat of NATO. The Soviet Union controlled all decisions of
the pact inside all satellite states and through this, the Soviet Union essentially
maintained control over satellite states by keeping troops stationed inside each state.
These troops would keep the satellite states compliant and squash any uprisings
against communism. Satellite states became markets for soviet military hardware
and they had to trade with the Soviet Union and no one else.
This was an attempt to improve the lives of east Berliners and East Germans in an
attempt to stop them from leaving and flooding into west Berlin and then to West
Germany. Berlin was a “hole in the Iron Curtain”.
The workers reacted violently by rioting and protesting to the governments new
proposed working hours.
The Russian troops in east Berlin and East Germany had to crush the uprising
violently. Soviet tanks arrived en masse in East Berlin. This action resulted in many
more people flooding to the west in response to the oppression of the Russian troops
inside East Germany. As life deteriorated, the hole in the iron curtain was becoming
an increasing concern for the Russians. The most wealthy and productive people
were the ones leaving through the “hole” – the Brain Drain affected the economy of
East Germany and threatened the collapse of East Germany itself.
12
Stalin was the dictator of the Soviet Union from the late 1920s to
1953. His regime was cruel and repressive, using secret police and
force. When Stalin died in 1953, Nikita Khrushchev became the new
leader (1955) who immediately started to relax the Soviet state’s
grip on its citizens.
Statues of Stalin came down, cities were renamed, the secret police became less
active, and more consumer goods were produced. This whole process was called
‘destalinisation’. It was very popular in the Soviet Union, as the Soviet people
seemed to be gaining more freedom – this made it more popular in the West too.
Khrushchev had a different attitude to the West as well. He replaced the old policy of
confrontation with peaceful co-existence. The USSR would recognise the Western
powers’ right to exist – this led to a ‘thaw’ in the Cold War.
These satellite states and the West had misunderstood Khrushchev’s motives. He
wasn’t going to grant widespread concessions in the satellite states, as this could
lead to the end of communism in Eastern Europe and the destruction of the Soviet
buffer against the West.
Revolts in East Germany, Poland and Czechoslovakia were ruthlessly put down,
ending the ‘thaw’ in the Cold War.
Kennedy refused the demands and maintained that Germany must reunite and be a
free, democratic country. Kennedy sent more troops to Berlin as he was not
prepared to be intimidated. Refugees from East Germany continued to pour into
West Germany via the “hole” in the iron curtain.
13
1. American aid had made West Berlin into a showpiece of capitalism.
2. West Berliners enjoyed luxury goods whilst East Berliners were suffering with
long hours and food shortages.
3. East Berlin tried to rebel in 1953, but this was suppressed by the Soviet army.
4. East Berliners were fleeing to West Berlin: more than 2 million had fled by
1961. Around 2000 skilled workers were leaving for the West every day.This
was easy to do as there weren’t strong fortifications between the two sides of
Berlin.
5. Western governments used Berlin as headquarters for spying
There was no free access from east to west Berlin except via controlled access
points such as “Checkpoint Charlie” in the American zone of Berlin. Over the years
there were many escape attempts by people who were desperate to escape to the
west.
If anyone tried to cross the wall, they were shot. In the first year after the wall was
built, 41 East Berliners were shot trying to cross the wall. Families and friends were
separated. East Berliners saw the wall as a sign of inferiority in comparison to the
West Berliners and the wall was seen in the west as a “wall of shame” and a visible
symbol of communism.
The Americans used the Berlin Wall for propaganda: if the communist system was
so perfect, why was it necessary to turn it into a prison?
14
In 1963 Kennedy visited West Berlin. They applauded him warmly when he declared,
‘Ich bin ein Berliner’ (I am a Berliner). He promised the USA’s commitment and that
they would never desert West Berlin.
The Soviets saw this visit and speech as a deliberate attempt to cause trouble.
Who gained and who lost from the building of the Berlin wall?
1. Flow of refugees stopped which allowed the communists to consolidate their
control over East Germany.
2. Enemies of communism could argue that communism was so awful that
people had to be walled in to make sure that they did not run away from
communism.
3. People in East Germany who did not support communism were trapped
4. The building of the wall was the beginning of a period of calm in Europe. On
both sides people accepted that there was no immediate prospect of change
but tensions increased in the Cold War and both sides resumed nuclear
testing.
15
The Cuban Missile Crisis 1962
An example of containment and brinkmanship in the Cold War
The tactic of ‘Brinkmanship’ was a feature of the Cold War. Both the USSR and
the USA tried to push each other to see just how much they could get away with
before the opposing side would react. These pushing each other to the ‘brink’ of an
open declaration of war was a dangerous tactic once both sides possessed nuclear
weapons as the threat of MAD (mutually assured destruction) was very real.
BACKGROUND
The nuclear arms race
When the USA dropped nuclear bombs on Japan in 1945, the USSR viewed this as
a threat to her security. By 1949, the USSR had in her possession her own nuclear
bomb. This unleashed a nuclear arms race between the superpowers. By 1961,
both the USSR and the USA had large stores of short and medium-range nuclear
missiles and were working on long-range missiles. The USA was at an advantage
as she could store her missiles in Europe, within range to attack the USSR at any
moment. The USSR did not have the same ability to reach mainland USA since
long-range missiles had not yet been developed and the Soviet Union did not have
military bases near enough to the USA to be able to use medium-range missiles.
Cuba is an island about 145km off the coast of the United States. Traditionally,
Cuba had been dominated by her powerful neighbour, the USA. The USA had a
large naval base on the island at Guantanamo Bay. American companies controlled
much of the economic wealth of Cuba. This included oil refineries, mines, cattle
16
ranches, hotels and railways. Cuba was a popular destination for American tourists.
The USA also purchased the bulk of Cuba’s main exported product – sugar.
However American investment did not translate to the wealth of ordinary Cuban
citizens. Many Cubans were poor peasants and illiterate. There was a dire shortage
of teachers, doctors and hospitals. Only a very small percentage (3%) of the Cuban
population were very wealthy and owned about 50% of the land. In 1952 a Cuban
anti-communist dictator seized power in Cuba. He was Fulgencio Batista.
17
These moves antagonised US economic interests and many US businesses faced
major losses in a market that had previously been so lucrative.
The USA responded to Castro’s actions by
1) banning Cuban sugar imports to the USA (a trade embargo) and
2) broke off diplomatic relations with Cuba (this involves breaking ties between
ambassadors and embassies) - the US Government hoped that this would force
Castro’s Government to change its policies.
Castro, now needed an economic trading partner owing to the worsening relationship
with the USA. He sought a partner in Khrushchev and the USSR who were looking
to build a military base close to the USA. This partnership infuriated President
Kennedy who was determined to contain communism which now seemed to be at
the doorstep of the USA. This would pose a great threat to American security.
Kennedy was convinced that Castro would turn Cuba into a communist country.
18
The Cuban Missile Crisis 1962
In an attempt to protect Cuba from another invasion from the USA, as well as to
appease his new ally, Fidel Castro agreed to allow the Soviet Union to build nuclear
missile bases in Cuba. The USSR felt threatened by NATO missile bases in Turkey.
In October 1962, American spy planes flew over Cuba on a routine mission to check
on military activity on the island. One of the pilots took detailed photographs of a
nuclear weapons site.
Aerial photograph of
Soviet Missile base as
photographed by spy
planes
Kennedy warned that any missile attack from Cuba will be regarded as an
attack on the USA from the Soviet Union
A US U2 spy plane was shot down over Cuba
Excom met secretly in White House to discuss options regarding the
crisis in Cuba
19
Excom came up with several strategies:
26 October – USSR offer to withdraw missiles from Cuba in return for guarantee
that US would not invade Cuba
Kennedy publically accepted 1st deal (US would not invade Cuba if USSR
withdrew weapons from Cuba)
but privately sends brother Robert F Kennedy to accept 2nd deal (US
withdrawal of weapons from Turkey) – requested that Khrushchev keep
this part of the deal secret
20
28 October – Kennedy announced he had ordered Soviet withdrawal of weapons
from Cuba
30 November – End of blockade – US lift the blockade and the crisis ended just 14
days after the crisis began, Khrushchev agreed to back down. The USA agreed to
remove her weapons from Turkey, although this part of the agreement was kept
secret and was not made public knowledge.
21