India's Economic Future: 2035 Strategy
India's Economic Future: 2035 Strategy
T H E M AC R O S TO RY
22
CHAPTER ONE
Summary24
SUMMARY
■■ India’s economy is of global importance. It has a large and young population and an open and
democratic political system. It is already the third largest economy and contributor to global
economic growth, yet there is considerable untapped potential. With more than a sixth of
the world’s population, India produces only 7 per cent of the world’s output.
■■ India has enjoyed a step up in growth rates over the past few decades supported by
reform efforts and the expansion of its aspirational, consumer class. This report assumes
a growth rate of 6–8 per cent annually over the next two decades, underpinned by
productivity improvements.
■■ Given the challenges of policy making in such a large, diverse country with a federal
structure of government, reforms will likely proceed incrementally and be politically
opportunistic. Both the central and state governments have important roles to play. Making
the most of India’s demographic advantages will require labour market reforms, measures
to improve education and skills and significantly improving women’s participation in the
economy. Constraints on investment and infrastructure pose a challenge, while India’s
services-oriented growth path will take it into uncharted territory.
■■ India’s economic progress will not be linear. It will be subject to structural shifts and will be
shaped by technological and environmental disruptions.
24
CHAPTER 1: The Macro Story
Source: International Monetary Fund. World Economic Outlook - April 2018. International Monetary Fund; 2018.
Note: GDP is in purchasing-power parity terms. Data refers to 2017.
India’s population has benefited from this strong rise from an average annual rate of less than
economic performance. India’s steps towards 3 per cent in the 1970s (the so-called ‘Hindu rate
liberalisation and openness in the 1980s, which of growth’) to over 7 per cent in recent years
accelerated in the 1990s, saw India’s GDP growth (Figure 3).
25
INDIA ECONOMIC STRATEGY TO 2035
Source: 1) The World Bank. GDP growth (annual %). World Bank national accounts data and OECD National Accounts. The World Bank; 2018.
2) International Monetary Fund. World Economic Outlook - April 2018. International Monetary Fund; 2018. 3) Ministry of Statistics and Programme
Implementation (ID). Summary of macro-economic aggregates at constant prices. New Delhi ID: Government of India; 2018.
Note: Data in India fiscal years (April to March)
Since 1970, India’s real GDP per capita has BASELINE SCENARIO
increased fivefold. As a result, millions of people
have been lifted out of poverty. Key development Under even moderate policy progress, the
indicators such as infant mortality and life Australian Treasury’s long term projection
expectancy have steadily improved. framework projects that over the next two
decades (and beyond) India can maintain the
These trends have contributed to the creation relatively high economic growth required to lift
of a substantial and aspirational consumer-class its share of global output.
that, since household consumption accounts for
60 per cent of India’s GDP3, is an important source
of optimism for growth in the Indian economy.
i
Annual percentage growth rate of GDP at market prices based on constant local currency. Aggregates are based on
constant 2010 USD. GDP is the sum of gross value added by all resident producers in the economy plus any product taxes and
minus any subsidies not included in the value of the products. It is calculated without making deductions for depreciation of
fabricated assets or for depletion and degradation of natural resources.
26
CHAPTER 1: The Macro Story
Under Treasury’s projections, India will enjoy an be increasingly weighted towards Asia, as India,
average of around 6 per cent annual growth over China and the ASEAN economies catch up to
the next two [Link] As population growth slower-growing advanced economies. Even with
continues to slow, improved productivity will an average annual growth rate of only 6 per cent,
remain the critical driver of GDP growth (Figure 4). India’s economy would be more than two times
Based on the incremental reforms outlined in the larger than it was in 2017. In PPP terms, India’s
next section, this Strategy judges India is likely to share of the global economy will likely increase
grow at 6–8 per cent annually to 2035. from 7 per cent in 2016 to around 13 per cent
(Figure 5), making it one of the major poles of
India’s success will have significant implications
global economic power and on par with the
for its international economic and strategic
United States.
weight. In 2035, the global economy is likely to
Source: 1) International Monetary Fund. World Economic Outlook - April 2018. International Monetary Fund; 2018. 2) Treasury (AU); The Commonwealth
of Australia; 2018
Note: Years in Figure 4 refer to five year periods ending in that year. GDP is in PPP terms.
ii
Treasury’s long term projection model is based on assumptions about productivity and working age population growth. For
productivity, the model estimates each country’s ‘steady state’ level of productivity relative to the United States, based on an
assessment of the country’s competiveness (the World Economic Forum Global Competitiveness Index, or GCI). The model
then assumes that countries approach this steady state level over time. Reforms that increase a country’s competitiveness, and
hence its GCI score, would lead to a higher estimated steady state level of productivity relative to the United States and an
upward revision to projected productivity growth. All else equal, this in turn would mean higher projected GDP growth. The
working age population projections are based on those published by the United Nations.
27
INDIA ECONOMIC STRATEGY TO 2035
Source: 1) International Monetary Fund. World Economic Outlook - April 2018. International Monetary Fund; 2018. 2) Treasury (AU); The Commonwealth
of Australia; 2018
INCREMENTAL REFORMS ARE LIKELY, Weak capacity, at both the central and state level,
to implement challenging policy changes is a key
WHICH WILL BOOST GROWTH constraint. Attempts to circumvent the ‘licence Raj’
In recent years, a greater recognition in India of by moving regulatory approval systems online will
the urgency for reforms to lift productivity has improve the business environment in some areas.
led to important policy achievements, including
Recently enacted fiscal targets and formal
implementation of a national GST in 2017. As well
guidelines for monetary policy will also continue
as simplifying the tax system the GST sets new
to support a favourable environment for growth.
precedents for cooperation among the states.
Macro stability through improvements in external
Future reforms will likely proceed incrementally.
indicators such as current account, foreign
Both the central and state governments have
exchange reserves and inflation have also helped.
the political appetite to do more, and both levels
However, fiscal pressure continues to pose a risk
of government have important roles to play.
for many state governments, where borrowing has
The Central Government has direct control over
increased rapidly in recent years and the scope to
several important areas, including the financial
increase debt and expenditure appears limited.
sector, [see Chapter 10: Financial Services Sector],
international trade [see Chapter 16: Trade Policy India’s economic reform agenda must address
Settings] and investment policy [see Chapter 2: three themes: its growth model and international
The Investment Story]. openness, its workforce, and building the
infrastructure to improve productivity.
India’s state governments control crucial elements
of the business environment [see Chapter 14:
A Collection of States]. The Central Government India’s growth model
has fostered a political dynamic in favour of Like other emerging economies, India’s growth
reform, which will see uneven progress between has been marked by major shifts in the structure
states. Organisations such as NITI Aayog have of its economy, most notably away from low
used initiatives like competitive federalism to help productivity agriculture (Figure 6).
states recognise the need for, and speed up the
pace of, reform.
28
CHAPTER 1: The Macro Story
Source: 1) CEIC Asia Database | CEIC [Internet]. Available from: [Link] 2) Treasury (AU); The Commonwealth of Australia; 2018. 3)
Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (ID). New Delhi ID: Government of India; 2018
Note: Data in India fiscal years (April to March). Data prior to 2011–12 use Treasury calculations based on discontinued series.
The shift away from agriculture and strong by the Indian Government through the 1990s
growth in services is not unusual for a developing and early 2000s. Notable reforms included
economy like India. What is less common is the financial market deregulation, a relaxation of
limited role that manufacturing has played in foreign ownership regulations and moves to
India’s development. For a typical developing increase competition in a wide range of service
economy, manufacturing drives growth and industries. Along with the relatively high cost of
employment in the early development phase capital, policy choices also appear to explain India’s
before giving way to services. For many East Asian relative underperformance in manufacturing.
economies, this last stage typically has occurred at Burdensome regulations – including outdated
much higher levels of development than in India.4 labour laws and complex land acquisition
regulations – have been particularly onerous
However, in many parts of South Asia, the services
for manufacturing.
sector has grown ahead of manufacturing. In the
traditional growth model, the services sector in India’s services success extends to exports, where
developing economies is considered to be of lower a range of Indian services are globally competitive,
productivity than manufacturing.5 In South Asia, particularly in information and communication
and particularly in India, the reverse has been technology and in back-office processing tasks.
true. The level of India’s services productivity is This reflects India’s comparative advantages:
comparable with China and Thailand, countries a relatively low-cost workforce with a small
with substantially higher GDP per capita. As a high-skilled component, many of whom are
result, India’s early shift to services has supported, English-speaking.
rather than hindered, rapid growth.
While India’s services sector output has grown
POLICY SETTINGS HAVE SUPPORTED THE substantially, services sector employment has
been far more modest. This has meant that a
DOMINANCE OF SERVICES relatively small proportion of India’s population
The strong expansion of India’s service sector has has seen direct benefits. The more large scale
been enhanced by a series of reforms introduced
29
INDIA ECONOMIC STRATEGY TO 2035
employment the services sector can provide India, intensive production, encourage innovation and
the greater the benefit for India’s development. lift productivity.
Over coming decades, the services share of the Greater openness to foreign investment would
economy is likely to gradually continue rising also support growth by providing additional
and the share of manufacturing stabilise. As sources of capital and technology [see Chapter 2:
incomes rise, the demand for consumer goods and The Investment Story].
services is expected to grow strongly, creating
opportunities for domestic manufacturing. Global India’s workforce is an opportunity
manufacturing firms are also likely to be attracted
by India’s large and growing consumer class and its
and a challenge
relatively low operating costs. India has a great economic opportunity
provided it can create an environment that
INTERNATIONAL OPENNESS supports education, training and job creation
India’s structural transformation towards higher for the millions of young Indians set to enter the
value added production would be aided by labour force. Over the next two decades India’s
further moves to open the economy. Historically, working age population is predicted to increase
India’s size and the appeal of self-sufficiency has by almost 200 million, to over one billion, to
encouraged a degree of insularity. While the trend become the world’s largest.1 While the rate of
is positive, India’s openness to trade remains increase is expected to slow, the working age
among the lowest in Asia6 [see Chapter 16: Trade share of the population will continue to rise out
Policy Settings]. While India is unlikely to pursue an to 2035 (Figure 7). The working age populations
export-oriented growth model to the same extent in southern states will peak by around 2020 but
as East Asia, greater openness would enable India further increases in workers are expected to come
to leverage its comparative advantage in labour from the northern states for decades to come.7
Source: United Nations. World Population Prospects 2017 [Internet]. United Nations; 2017. Available from: [Link]
publications/[Link]
iii
In economics, BRIC is an acronym that refers to the countries of Brazil, Russia, India and China, which are all deemed to be at a
similar stage of newly advanced economic development.
30
CHAPTER 1: The Macro Story
31
INDIA ECONOMIC STRATEGY TO 2035
Source: United Nations. World Population Prospects 2014 [Internet]. United Nations; 2014. Available from: [Link]
publications/[Link]
Strong investment will be needed to way to determining its growth path. For example,
some 240 million Indians still lack access to
sustain growth electricity.10 The Indian Government has estimated
To achieve high growth in the coming decades, that its infrastructure gap over the next decade
India will need to sustain strong investment. will be over USD1.5 trillion.11 As a result, the
Capital in India has traditionally been mobilised central and state governments are developing new
by raising domestic savings and investing it in financing models to attract private, and particularly
productive assets. foreign, capital.
India’s investment and savings rates, as a Improving India’s business climate will also help
proportion of GDP, have fallen in recent years increase investment. The Indian Government’s
(Figure 9). Private investment has started to renewed focus on achieving reforms has
shrink – contracting by 22 per cent between 2014 contributed to India’s jump of 30 places in
and 2016 according to World Bank data. Turning the 2018 World Bank’s global ease of doing
this trend around will require a supportive business ranking.100 Important areas that continue
environment for business, an efficient and to affect the business environment in India include
innovative financial sector and dealing with the effectiveness and pace of the judicial system,
the non-performing assets (NPAs) that have and business licencing regulations. Improving
impaired new lending and weigh heavily on India’s India’s business climate will take time, but will be
dominant public sector banks [see Chapter 2: important in shifting focus toward opportunities
The Investment Story]. available in India [see Chapter 15: Understanding the
Business Environment].
Investment into infrastructure that enables
growth, particularly in transport, energy and
communications, is critical to India’s prospects.
How well India can deliver on this will go a long
32
CHAPTER 1: The Macro Story
Source: World Development Indicators | DataBank [Internet]. 2018. Available from: [Link]
pment-indicators
33
INDIA ECONOMIC STRATEGY TO 2035
34
CHAPTER 1: The Macro Story
Together, these two factors – poverty and Out to 2035, on current participation rates,
inequality – influence the structure of India’s women will represent one of the largest
economy in three ways. First, the acute hardship underutilised economic forces in the country. The
and deprivation of large scale poverty mean India extent to which India can achieve progress on
will continue to have a significant unmet need closing the gender gap in employment, education
for basic services, such as water and sanitation, and in financial and digital inclusion will determine
energy and health care. Second, poverty and not only how equitable a society it has, but
inequity sharpen political sensitivities and how dynamic and fast growing its economy is.
shape the political space for economic reforms. According to the International Monetary Fund,
A primary objective of India’s reform program raising women’s participation in the labour force
is to lift basic incomes and many of the Indian to the same level as men could boost India’s GDP
Government’s market interventions, from price by as much as 27 per cent.17 Failure to remove
controls to tariffs, are designed to minimise social barriers to women’s economic participation will
disruption amongst its poorest constituents. Third, prevent India from reaching its potential.
inequality constrains growth, limiting the potential The rate of women’s workforce participation in
for consumption-led growth and discretionary India has declined over 15 years despite India’s high
[Link] levels of growth. India has one of the world’s lowest
iv
OECD analysis finds a negative and statistically significant correlation between income inequality and economic growth.
35
INDIA ECONOMIC STRATEGY TO 2035
36
CHAPTER 1: The Macro Story
37
INDIA ECONOMIC STRATEGY TO 2035
Responses to climate change and environmental management and climate finance. Our shared
pollution will open up opportunities for Australian interest in transitioning to a low emissions, climate
capabilities. This includes areas as diverse as resilient global economy should see us continue
renewable energy, sustainable cities, climate to work closely together bilaterally, regionally
smart agriculture and infrastructure, water and multilaterally.
Source: Department of Home Affairs (AU). 2016–17 Migration Programme Report. Canberra: The Commonwealth of Australia; 2017.
38
CHAPTER 1: The Macro Story
The age profile of Australia’s population is also Over the coming decades, the proportion of
projected to change as the overall population the population participating v in the workforce is
grows. Australians are projected to live longer expected to decline as a result of the population
and continue to have one of the longest life ageing highlighted previously.
expectancies in the world. As a result, there will be
Of the three key drivers of economic growth,
fewer people of traditional working age compared
productivity vi has historically been the most
with the very young and the elderly. This trend is
important to Australia’s economic performance
already visible, with the number of people aged
(Figure 11).
between 15 and 64 for every person aged 65 and
over having fallen over the past few decades.
Source: 1) Australian Bureau of Statistics (AU). ABS cat. no. 5206.0; MYEFO 2017–18. Canberra AU: The Commonwealth of Australia; 2018. 2) Treasury
(AU), The Commonwealth of Australia.
Note: Growth rates are average annualised growth for five financial years, 1985 represents growth from 1979–80 to 1984–85. Historical GDP growth rates
have been used up to 2016–17. Australian projections use published growth rates from the 2017–18 MYEFO from 2017–18 to 2020–21, 3 per cent for the
first three years after the forward estimates, then 2.75 per cent beyond. On average, over the next two decades annual economic growth is estimated to be
around 2.75 per cent.
v
Participation refers to the proportion of the population of people aged 15 years and over who are actively engaged in
the workforce.
vi
Future productivity growth is inherently uncertain, so historical productivity growth is used as a guide. Labour productivity is
assumed to grow at the average annual growth rate of the previous 30 years (1.5 per cent at the time of the Intergenerational
Report).
vii
The projections of the drivers of potential growth are developed using a range of assumptions and therefore are not without
uncertainty. The sensitivities of economic growth to assumptions for the projection of annual net overseas migration, the
participation rate and productivity growth are presented in the Intergenerational Report.
39