Cognitive Psychology Core Studies Overview
Cognitive Psychology Core Studies Overview
12
Psychology
Core Studies – G541
Processes involve
Perception
Language
Memory
Thinking
Along with beliefs and attitudes and their information.
Focuses on memory and eye witness testimony in particular. It explores the idea that a photographic
or a precise version of events. Participants were shown a variety of different car accidents then
asked leading questions about what they saw. This was in an attempt to prove that memory can
distort an individual’s recollection of what they witnessed.
Investigates the core problem experienced by people with autism. A disorder involving social
communication difficulties. And the links in theory of mind studies and being able to understand and
prediction how people are feeling and are thinking. This study showed that it’s not the case that
autistic aren’t clever/intelligent they just lack a theory of mind.
Teaching chimp’s sign language as they have similar hands, language accusation for the pygmy
chimpanzees (Kanzi & Mulika) were compared to that of a regular chimpanzee. It was found that the
pygmy chimps has a were quicker to learn then that of the common chimps. And researchers were
confident that Kanzi had learned to use language successfully.
Loftus & Palmer (1974)
‘Reconstruction of Automobile Destruction’
Background
Aims
Experiment one –
Group 1 – How fast were the cars going when they smashed into each other?
Group 2 – How fast were the cars going when they collided with each other?
Group 3 – About how fast were they cars going when the bumped into each other?
Group 4 – About how fast were the cars going when they hit each other?
Group 5 – About how fast were the car when they contacted one another?
Findings
Results were to be analysed statistically and was found to be significantly
So people were not good at estimating speed were not good at estimating speeds of cars are
traveling
1st explanation- response had Bias factors manipulating words may lead to demand characteristics
We cannot conclude weather the wording did influence the participants speed estimated as they
may have just been responding to demand characteristics
[So to make this more valid they decided to do another experiment – experiment 2]
Experiment two
Group 1 – how fast were the cars going when they hit each other?
Group 2 - How fast were the cars going when they smashed into each other
A week later subjects were asked the critical question ‘did you see the broken glass?’
Findings
In the second experiment it did alter people memory though the critical. This corresponded
to the verb used to describe as people who ‘smashed’ through the glass broke.
Conclusion
Loftus suggested 2 kinds of information go into memory
o Stage 1 – persons own perception
o Stage 2 – information reserved after event
They become integrated to make a whole memory. Reconstructed hypothesis.
Evaluation
Strength
Weakness
Students usually young and said that memory is better when your younger.
Students are used to taking on information all the time. And being tested on it.
Students may be fewer confidants at estimating speed so more influenced by verbs.
Students may be susceptible to demand characteristics
Quantitative data
o Allows us to compare easily
o Superficial – (not the whole picture)
Leading questions can effect memory – important implications for interviewing witnesses
Avoiding leading questions.
Baron-Cohen
‘Another advanced theory of mind evidence from high functioning adults with autism or
Asperger’s syndrome’
Background
Autism
Asperger’s
Classic Autism ‘Normality’
Syndrome
Autistic
Spectrum
Facts
Autistic Savants
Individuals diagnosed with autism who appear to have a particular skill (Math, Art, Music) or
gift there’s only about 100 in the world
Causes of autism
Refrigerator parenting
Genetics
Chromosomal abnormalities
Environmental catalysts
MMR vaccine
Extreme male brain
Cognitive defects ‘lack of theory of minds (TOM)’
Theory of mind
The ability to attribute mental states (feeling beliefs Etc.) to one’s self and to others Develops from
12 – 4 years
Method
Quasi experiment
Independent measures design
Self-report measures
Variables
o IV – Weather Participant had autism or not
o DV- correct responses to eyes test
Group One
High functioning
o Autistic participants – 4
o Asparagus participants – 12
o 13 males and 3 females ( All together)
o Mean age: 28.6
o Mean IQ: 106.31
o Self-selected
Group Two
Normal
o 50 participants
o 25 Males
o 25 Females
o All IQ’s Above 85
o Mean Age 30
Group Three
Torrets Syndrome
o 10 participants
o 8 Male
o 2 Female
o Mean age: 27
o Mean IQ: 103.5
Controlled for
Age + IQ
Extraneous and confounding variables.
Apparatus
Eyes task – Photos of 25 different faces were shown from just the eyes and had to select
which emotion the eyes were showing
Construction – Four judges (2 Male 2 Female) decided the mental state of eyes photos and
terms then tested a panel of 8 all blind to the hypothesis who all agreed with target words
shown (for 3 seconds)
Procedure
Each participant tested in 4 tests in random orders. (to try avoid Order effects)
o Eyes test
o Happé strange story’s
o Gender recognition
o Emotion test
Order effects – To stop people from getting better or getting worse because of changes
Control tasks – this was to find out whether autistic individuals had problems with face perceptions
Gender recognition
Basic emotion recognition ( Ekman)
Participants were tested either in a quiet room at a researcher clinic (lab at Cambridge University) or
at their own home
(They should have been tested in their own environment or the same environment)
Conclusion
Adults with autism had poorer performance on an advanced on Advance Theory of
mind test wasn’t due to
o Low intelligent
o Having a neurophytric disability
o Females did better emphasising system
o Why? – Evidence that autism partly caused by a cognitive defect.
Evaluation
Strengths
Experiments allows ‘cause and effect’ so its possible to control variables that could effects
subjects performance
Quasi- Experiments which has the advantage of studying naturally occurring situations
Various tests increasing validity
Weaknesses
Savage-Rumbaugh
‘Spontaneous symbol acquisition and communication use by pygmy chimpanzees’
Background
Components of language
2 months – coo-ing
6 months -replicated babbling
12 months- one word utterances
18-24 months two word utterances
3 years- Vocabulary of around 100 words
6-7 years – rules of grammar and language mastered
Exceptions!
Language disorders ( Eg- aphalas, Dyslexia, mutum)
Autism
Individuals/ gender differences
Aim of study
To study and report on language acquisition of Kanzi a bonobo chimp and his younger sister Mulika
Note: No hypothesis as it wasn’t an experiment – as they didn’t control for confounding variables or
have any written IV’s / DV’s. although if IV and DV’s were present
Method
Subjects
Serendipitous results – as they did not set out to study Kanzi he just showed him to be bright to they
rolled with it
Procedure
Findings –
Between the ages of 6 – 16 months both ‘M&K’ spontaneously began to use gestures to
communicate
Similar gestures were observed in Sherman and Austin but when they were much older (2-4
years)
‘M&K’ gestures were often more explicit the ‘S&A’
Orange, peanut, 30
Symbols Age acquired (months)
banana, bedroom,
chase, Kanzi Milk 17
Key, t-room, surprise 20
Sweet potato, raisin, 31
ball, cherry, peaches, Juice, Water 22
coke, bite Groom 37
Egg 40
Melon, jelly, tomato, 32 Hamburger, Water , 41
orange drink M&M
Clover, Mutata, TV, 42
Trailer, milk 33 Orange juice
Key, Tickle 34 Mulika, Carrot 43
Grab, Tree house, 44
Coffee, juice, bread 35 Blanket, Blackberry
Mushroom trail 45
Refrigerator, hotdog 46
Finding – Formal tests
Conclusions
Pygmy chimpanzees exhibit symbolic and auditory perceptual skills that are distinctively different to
those of common chimps.
Evaluation
Many controls
Formal test to increase validity and more reliable
Lots of anecdotal evidence gathered in some studies
Logdituitnal study
Quanitive and qualitative data
High in ecological validity?
Ethical issues
o Humanising chimps
o Diet may harm
o Frustration of chimp
Cant re-release animals
Lack of control in some areas
Was sample representative?
o Small
o So larger sample must be used to generalise the results
Were they using language?
o K&M displayed some features of language however some may say that they didn’t
use it the way we do, so it can’t be generalised
Developmental Psychology
Developmental psychology is the study of psychology that changes over time, on the whole
Developmental psychology and behaviourism is split into two elements:
Behaviourists believe that all behaviour could be explained in term of what we have learnt and the
proses that takes place whilst learning.
Classical conditioning is when an animal/ human learns to associate something which naturally
causes a response (baby Albert & rat)
Drugs
Electrocution
Focuses on social possesses of Children and Imitating Aggressive behaviour using the influences of
models.
Freud
And his psychoanalytical theory’s about the unconscious and how events construct our behaviour.
Background – Piaget
Background:
Piaget’s theory:
Cognitive Development:
Conserve: When they understand that quantity does not change when appearance changers unable
to take in
Number
Mass
Volume
‘it looks different it must be different’
Aims
Methodology
252 Boys + Girls from a variety of schools & pre-schools around Devon
Each child carried out 3 tasks
o Counters for numbers
o Plasticine for mass
o Liquid in glass for volume
Making 12 trials for each child
Measures compared in independent measures design
o Each participant takes part in one condition and results are compared
o Advantages
Results not affected by order effects
Lab experiment
Easy to control
Easy to replicate
o Low in ecological validity
Quanitive Data
Easy to collect & analyse
o No in-depth reasoning at why respondent behaves or reacts in a way
Hypothesis
Asking only one question in a conservation task would lead to more correct answers (Piagets
experiment asked two)
Independent Variables:
o Age
o Experimental conditions
o Materials used
Dependant Variables:
Opportunity
o 252 participants
o Male and female
o Aged 5- 8 years
o Schools from around Devon
Split into
o 4 age groups of 63
o 21 for each IV
Findings
Finding would be recorded as the number of errors made during conservation tasks
They were twelve trails the maximum error would be 12 and the minimum error 0
Age: The mean number of errors decreases as children get older showing that the ability to conserve
get significantly better with age
Experimental condition: The mean number of errors is lower for the one- judgement condition this
is when only one post – transformational question is asked highest number of errors recorded was
for children who were only asked one question in a controlled condition ( child didn’t see the
transformation take place
Children are more successful and so make fewer errors and so make fewer errors when conserving
number compared with volume and mass
Conclusions
Children clearly can conserve better than Piagets though they would
Piagets study was to controlled by demand characteristics
One question procedure indicates that they have an understanding to conserve
Pre operational children can conserve number mass and volume
Ability to conserve gets better with age
Number better conserved then mass or volume
Evaluation
How useful?
We now know that children cognitive development is shown to be affected by environment, changes
the way we teach.
Background
In ‘ Gay’ Experiment the pictures were the condition stimulus and the electric shock was a
response
Problem with behaviourism is they can’t measure cognitive because they can’t measure it.
Animals have an automatic reaction to food & reinforcement
Behaviourists are too simplistic in there theory’s to apply to humans
People don’t always change for punishment as they way up the cost and rewards although
people may just like the attention and so they do it more.
Assumptions
Observable behaviour
People have no free will
When born mind is a clank slate
o Tabla rasa
Environment is everything
Aggression reward
Aggression punished
Neither rewarded/ punished
Although when asked to copy seeing reward of not showed no difference
Vicarious – Felt or undergone as if one were taking part in an experience or feelings of another
Language
Politeness
Cooking
Argue
Daily routines
Violence
Sarcasm
Instruments
Aims
To see if children will imitate aggressive behaviour in different environment and without and modal
present.
Hypothesis
Study
o Non-aggressive model
o Aggressive Model
o No model
o Male
o Female
o 8 experimental groups
o 1 control group
o Stickers
o Potato prints
o Colourful toys
o Spinning top, fire engine, jet planes
o Nice new shiny toys
Imitate aggression
Partial imitation
Non-immersive aggression
Results:
They recorded behaviour every 5 second for 20 mins (0.9 – Very high inter-rater reliability)
Conclusions
Neo- behaviourists - behaviour is learnt though social learning theory and not though rewards and
punishments.
Evaluation
Ethics
Sample
Freud (1909)
‘Analysis of phobia in a 5 year old boy’
Background
Dynamics of behaviour
Behaviour is driven / motivated by un-conscience factors
E.g. Super Ego
Defence mechanisms
The psychodynamic approach emphasises the importance of change and development in behaviours
it believes that this development is mainly driven by un-conscience forces.
Personality types
Erotic
o ID controlled
o Love
o Sex
o Pleasure
o Hedonistic
Narcissistic
o Ego controlled
o Selfish
o Self-loving
o Look after number 1
Obsetinal
o Super Ego controlled
o Religious people
o Fear of punishment
o Amish
Electra complex
Identification
Towards end of phallic stage kinds identify with the same sex parent
Identification develops with superego & adopts models & gender identity & roles
Psychodynamic approach
Aim
To cure little Hans phobia of horses and allowed fraud to develop this theory about children having
sexual desires/ Oedipus complex
Method
Procedure
No set way about collecting data unlike lab experiment were everything has been calculated as
wasn’t standard
Recordings
Hans farther recorded events and conservations with Hans and sent there to Freud for
analysis
Freud sent recomadtions by returns of post
Hans met Freud once
Findings
Conclusions
100 pages long but only part of his research he concludes that Hans was exhibiting the Oedipus
complex and supports infinite sexually and theory of psychosexual development and phobias
Evaluation
Individual Difference
This is the principle that everybody is different, as most other studies studied things as a whole and
used a lot of statistical analysis as they believed that this was the only way of getting valid and
reliable data.
As it’s quite understandable that people are not as likely to be as trustworthy of a study on one
person compared to one that was on a sample of 300 people, as the more people used the easier it
is to relate.
So with individual psychologists they tried to show that were not all average and that we all are not
average and are all better or worse at certain things. And believe we can learn a lot from the not so
average beings.
Griffiths
Provides detailed insight into thought processes of fruit machine gamblers. And discovered some
interesting findings about how regular gamblers have a particularly irrational set of beliefs about
their own ability and understanding of the machines. Also gave us an insight into the thought
processes of gamblers.
Rosenhan
Challenges the normal/ abnormal debate as he highlighted the difficulty in diagnosing people in the
mental health industry as they found it was remarkable how the sane were being diagnosed as
insane, ( and later Vice versa) and the difficulty of shaking of labels once you have them
Study into multiple personality disorders and goes into detail though a ordeal that most people will
never come into contact or experience in there life’s. This provides great insight into this condition.
Although the study has been criticized for whether it was reliable or not.
Griffiths (1994)
‘The role of cognitive bias and skill in fruit machine gambling’
Gambling addiction
Characteristics of an addict
Aims – 4 Hypotheses
Method
Quasi-Experiment
Research design – Independent measures
Independent Variable
o Weather participants were regular or non-regular gamblers
Dependant Variables
o Cognitive ability ( thinking aloud) and perception of skill (post experimental – semi
structured interview)
o Additionally they looked at the behavorable variables
Total Plays – Per session
Total Time – Mins of play
Play Rate – Total number of plays per Min (Significant)
End Stake – Total Winnings in 10p pieces
Wins – Total numbers of wins (Non-Regular thinking aloud had most)
Win Rate (time) – Total number of mins between each win
Win Rate (play) – Total numbers of play between each win
Field Experiment
30 Regular Gamblers
o Played at least once a week
o 29 Males
o 1 Females
o Mean age : 21.6
30 Non-Regular Gamblers
o Played at least once before
o 15 Males
o 15 Females
o Mean age: 25.3
Volunteer Sample ( self-selected)
o Mainly recruited Via posters around Plymouth university
o Or though Griffiths ( Friends)
Fruit machine called Fruit Skill.
Took place in a real Amusement arcade
Groups were divided into two random groups
o Thinking aloud
o Not thinking aloud
In the thinking aloud group they had to verbalise every thought they had whilst playing the
fruit machine no matter how irrelevant it may be
Each participant was given £3 (30 Gambles)
Their aim was to stay on the machine for 60 Gambles
After the 60 Gambles they were allowed to take the money they made or keep on playing.
Findings
Rational Verbalisations
Conclusion
Regular + Non-regular gamblers have differences on how they deal cognitively with the idea
of skill in relation to fruit machine gambling
Regular gamblers think that there’s more skill involved- when only minor influences on the
outcome
Regular gamblers have ‘Irrational Gambling bias’ and can be modified and indicates some
level of success by allowing them to listen to recordings of verbalisations
o Many of them were shocked with what they were thinking/ saying
o Once aware of irrational thoughts they could change them
Cognitive Bias
Perceived Skill
Regular gamblers play until they loose
Irrational thoughts a lot less then what they thought
More research is needed into heuristics
‘Idiot skill’
Evaluations
Strengths
Weaknesses
Validity of Thinking out-loud technique
o Hard for participant to do.
o Most of verbalisations had nothing to do with gambling.
o Requires more research
Low in inter rater reliability.
Data-rich study
o Qualitive
o Quantive
o All available in great detail.
Hypothetical Construct
Can be observed
We can only observe behaviour
Extrovert – Sociable, Parties, Many friends, Craves Excitement, Likes change, has a need to talk.
Eysenck believed biological differences determine personality (nervous system) If Eysenck theory is
correct then multiple personality’s cant exist as you can’t change your nervous system
Nervous
Shy
Uncomfortable
Distant
Giddy
Smiley
Flirty
Relaxed
Childlike
Jane
Confidant
Involved / Responsive
Optimistic
Aim
Were 25 and was referred to Thigpen after severe headaches and Amnesia – Fuges. She was then
tested with psychometric tests (IQ & memory) & Rochach Test (Inkblot) Initial interviews with Eve
White
Blinding headaches
Blackout
Marital Problems
Personal Problems
Eve White
IQ- 110
Excellent Memory
Repressive personality
Conservative (Formal), Shy, Dutiful.
Loving Wife and mother
Hard Worker.
‘Hey Doc…….’
Eve Black
IQ – 104
Poor memory
Representative – childish
Childish, Extrovert, Mischievous
Denied being wife and mother
As treatment continued:
Jane seemed to be the person most likely to being a solution to the troubled minds.
Ethics
Conclusion
They wonder if they had become so involved they had lost their judgement and over
dramaticised the case
But they still said that they witnessed multiple personality’s
Simulates of EW&EB
o Both were under stressful situations
o Bother unaware of Jane
Differences Of EW&EB
o Personality differences
o IQ
Evaluation
Strengths
Weakness
Thigpen thought they were being severely hoodwinked by a extremely talented actress
Case study
o Difficult to generalise
They weren’t 100% sure it was MPD
Raised a number of important questions
Ethics
o Threatened Eve Black
o Mental Euthanasia
o Killing of a personality
Physiological Psychology
Physiological Psychology- Try’s to explain human behaviour though an understanding of biological
and neurological processes.
Physiological psychologlogists study the structure and function of parts of the brain and nervous
system.
The Electroencephalogram (EEG) – Involves electrodes attached to the scalp, to detect in brain
activity, DERMIT AND KLEITMAN used EEG measurements of the brain activity during sleep.
Recently though techniques such as PET scans, these can supply coloured images of brain activity;
this allows psychologists to examine what parts of the brain control what.
MRI scans provide details of the size of different brain structures and can do this extremely
precisely. MRI scans are used in the study by MAGUIRE ET AL. to calculate the size of the
Hippocampus.
In physiological psychology use Case Studies. But people who endure such studies normal have
some sort of brain damage, so studying them can tell us a lot about them.
Used MRI scans to see if experiences could make a difference to the brain. The work was mostly on
navigation skills in taxi drivers, and the effects it had on the part of the brain that deals with skill –
The Hippocampus.
This was a very early study of Sleep and Dreaming. Volunteers who agreed to sleep in a laboratory
with electrodes attached to their scalps to measure brain activity. And were the first people to
discover the relationship between stages of sleep and the occurrence of dreaming.
Sperry (1968)
Studied a small amount of people who had there Corpus Callosum severed. These people had
extreme surgery to control their epilepsy but severing this did not sure epilepsy just stopped
seizures from spreading from one hemisphere to another
Background
The hippocampus is located at the Medial temporal lobe and is part of the Limbic System a human
have two hippocampi. The role of the hippocampus is disputed but is believed to play a part in
Memories and new memories.
It is believed that the Hippocampus could change size dependant on what/ how much information
could be taken in. Without the hippocampus we would not be able to know how to get to where we
wanted to be or remember where we had been.
So the whole taking about how Men are better navigators or map readers, is just because they have
a larger Hippocampal volume.
Participants were 16 Male Licensed cab drivers who had passed ‘The Knowledge’. All where Right
Handed and aged between 32 and 62 years of age, with a mean age of 44. They all had been licenced
for at least 18 months. But the range was from 18 months to 42 years with a mean of 14.3 years.
And all were healthy both physically and mentally.
For the control group the researchers took 50 scans from the MRI scan database all fit the same
criteria of the cab group. (Right handed, Male, Aged 32-62. All physically and mentally sound).
Methodology
Quasi –experiment. Although. No manipulation was made. Data was collected through two different
techniques of analysing MRI scans. (Voxel- based morphology and pixel counting)
MRI- Method that uses radio waves to obtain 3D Images of brain and body tissue.
Results
Analysis using Voxel- Based morphology showed increase amounts of grey matter volume in both
left and right hippocampi but this was found in the posterior hippocampus. Whereas the control
sample had a greater volume in the anterior hippocampus.
Also the longer the participants were taxi drivers the larger the hippocampus was,
Conclusions
There was a correlation between the amount of cab driving experience and the volume of grey
matter in the posterior hippocampus
Evaluation
Method
+ they didn’t need to manipulate the IV (Taxi drivers & non-taxi drivers)
- Difficult to draw conclusions from data because it could have been from a number of reasons
+ Strong correlation established between the length of time taxi driving and hippocampus size.
Data collected
+ No demand characteristics.
- Although not suitable for people with pacemakers or who suffer from claustrophobia.
- Taxi drivers aren’t representative of the whole population although this was never the aim.
+ Taxi drivers selected all had similar knowledge as they had passed ‘the knowledge’ although
experience maybe varied
+ Results show evidence of plasticity in the brain and its response to change.
+ ‘ Normal activities can include changes in the relative volume in grey matter in the brain’ – So grey
matter can improve and change and adapt to different times, so if brain damage occurs they may be
able to regenerate and reform to work again .
Dement & Kleitman (1957)
Aim of study
Participants
Lab experiment
Participants had to report to the lab.
o At normal bed times
o Avoided caffeine & alcohol on the day
o Otherwise routines as normal.
Electrodes to be attached near the eyes to measure eye movements
Electrodes attached to the scalp to measure brain activity ( to see sleep patterns)
Then placed in a dark, quite room
Electrodes attached to EEG
At various times during the night by a doorbell and were asked to talk into the tape
recorder. And state whether they had dreamt and the content of them.
Results.
Hypothesis 1: Will people be more likely to report dreams if they are woken in periods of REM than
during NREM?
To begin with subjects were woken at varied times and asked to estimate how long they had
been dreaming but then this was to complex
So examiners decided to change it so participants were woken either 5/ 10 minutes into
REM and were asked whether they had been dreaming 5/ 10 minuets
Results show that participants were more accurate in there estimate of dream length.
Interestingly only one participant was responsible for a large proportion of the incorrect
estimates.
51 tests 60 tests
45 6 47 13
Hypothesis 3: Is the direction of eye movement during REM related to dream content?
Originally researchers asked subjects to accounts for every eye movement made
chronologically although not many participants could remember dreams in such detail.
The final approach subjects were awoken when one of four main patterns of eye movement
had persisted for one minute and were asked to recall what they had been dreaming about.
Total of 35 awakenings were collected from 9 participants.
Periods of mainly vertical and horizontal eye movement were rare
Results support the idea that eye movement is related to dream content.
Strengths-
Weaknesses-
Data Collected
Quantitative
Relatively easy to collect
Can be analysed easily
Some qualitative (question 3)
Ecological validity
Sperry (1968)
‘Hemisphere disconnection and unity in conscious awareness’
Background
The brain is made of two half (hemispheres) which as both capable of different things.
Aim
To look at the effects of the disconnection of the brain & to map out the functions of the two sides –
laterisation of the brain.
Participants
Procedure
Sperry used a specially designed apparatus that allows information to reach just one
hemisphere.
Images were then flashed on the screen for a 10th of a second so that information could not
be seen by the other hemisphere
Then stimuli would be placed either left or right of the fixation point and then participants
would be asked to say or Draw what they saw.
Tactile tasks- objects would be placed in one of the subjects hands (screened from view) and
then were asked to take the same item from a bag with alternative/ the same hands.
Controls
Results
Information if one seen in one visual field can only be recollected by the corresponding
hemisphere (left visual field – right Hemisphere) and vies versa.
Visual material shown to the right visual field (left hemisphere) can be described in speech
and writing. And if the same material is shown in the left visual field (Right Hemisphere) they
could not pick it out of a group of items.
If a different figure is flashed to each hemisphere (dollar sign LVF Question mark RVF) and if
participant was asked to draw what he had seen with her left hand, they would draw what
they saw in the LVF. But if you asked what they had seen in the Left visual field and to draw
it with their Right hand, they could not.
Right hand side ‘speechless’
Right had side could also:
o Select similar items (E.g. Clock – Watches)
o Can perform simple arithmetic operations
o Can understand both written and spoken word, but can’t be understood.
o Can identify objects but can’t be spoken
o Can understand instruction
o Shows Emotion
Conclusion
Evaluation
Strength
Quasi-experimental design
o Allows researchers to investigate variables that are not able to be investigated in
strict laboratory conditions
Highly controlled
Fairly representative
Quantitive and qualitative data
Weaknesses
Social Psychology
An Introduction
Social psychology attempts to explain our behaviour though an understanding of social processes.
(were influenced by the people around us) eg. We adopt other peoples characteristics and morals in
an attempt to fit in.
Social psychology can be studied in a number of ways but the most likely ways are though laboratory
experiments or though field experiments.
Milgram (1963)
Conducted an controlled observation into the nature of obedience when under an authorial figure.
Looked at group dynamics and how they can change under certain conditions eg, Guards and
Prisoners. And focus on group identity’s ect.
Focused on the bystander effect on a NY subway and if people would help a ‘fellow passenger’ if
they fell down unexpectedly.
Milgram (1963)
Background.
After the holocaust made people think that Germans were different but Milgram thought that we all
would kill if put under an authority figure.
Two hypothesis-
Situational hypothesis – That everybody would kill if put under a certain situation.
Aim.
Methods.
Laboratory Experiment
Sample participants
Yale University
Participant – Teacher
Subject (Actor) – Learner
Scientist (Actor)
Convincing participants
Learning task
Task was to match a word with another word and to indicated though a series of buttons
which flashed in the participants room and this would tell them to administer the shocks.
Shock generator
Looked, sounded and was perceived to be real consisted of 30 horizontal switches each
switch was clearly labelled from 15 to 450 volts groups were labelled:
Slight Shock
Moderate Shock
Strong Shock
Very Strong Shock
Intense Shock
Extreme intense shock
Danger: Extreme Shock
XXX
When a switch was pressed a corresponding light would flash and various clicks were heard
Wrong answers were given at a ratio of 3:1 and no vocal response was given until 300 volts
was heard the banging could be heard by the ‘teacher’ (participants).
Experimenter Feedback
Any attempt by the teacher to ask questions or to seek reassurance or to go on was met by a
series of prods
Prod 1 – ‘Please continue’
Prod 2 – ‘The experiment requires you continue’
Prod 3 – ‘its absouloutly essential you continue’
Prod 4 – ‘You have no choice you must continue’
If participants asked if the learner would suffer any permanent damage other prods were
applied.
Teachers were reunited with learner and told that it wasn’t real and had questionnaires to
assure participants were mentally ok after the experiment.
Findings
During many participants showed extreme nervousness upon administering the powerful
shocks one person had a seizure so violent the study had to be stopped.
Out of the 40 participants who took part 26 administered the lethal 450 volts.
At 300 volts – 5 refused
At 315 volts – 4 refused
At 330 volts – 2 refused
At 345, 360 and 375 – 1 refused
Evidence Supports the situational hypothesis ( Anybody would kill if in the right situation)
“Obedience is deeply ingrained behaviour tendency, indeed a potent
Impulse over idealing training in ethics, Sympathy and moral conduct”
- Stanley Milgram (1963)
Strengths
Weaknesses
Ethics
Deserved – didn’t tell the whole story
Didn’t give informed consent
Right to withdraw unclear (Prods)
Protection of participants (Physical + psychological) I.e. Stress – seizure
Lacks Ecological Validity
Artificial situation
Low in mundane realism – but that was the point
Demand characteristics
I.e. Participants may want to please the researcher
Ethnocentric
No women
Unrepresentative sample.
No self-report data
Data gaps.
Conclusion
People can enter an agentic state (Individuals relinquish their personal views and act in agent of
somebody else’s view) Under a malevolent authority good people will do bad things.
Us and them
o In groups and out-groups
o In-groups – superior/ nicer cleverer
o Once applied by authority figures people believe in its effects
Obey authority/ order
o Field experiment on the train
50% of people give up there seat.
Do ‘em’ hard
o Leaders take responsibility
o Agentic states
o Good people will do evil if there’s an ideology of science
Standby aperty
o Desensitise, Disagree
o Passive bystander
Extermination
o SPE (Stanford prison experiment)
o Microcosm
Background
Aims
To identify the conditions that lead individuals to identify with the group.
To identify conditions that lead individuals to accept or challenge intergroup inequality
o Power (student- teacher)
o Status (Police – Prisoner)
o Money ( Rich- Poor)
o Feminism
o Trade unions.
Data on the unfolding interactions between groups of unequal power ( through observation)
To examine the role of social organisation and clinical factors e.g., mood in group behaviour
To develop practical and ethical; guidelines for examining social psychology issues in large –
scale studies
DE individualisation – where people loose their individuality and adapt to group identities
Does your group identity determine what your like- depends if you identify with group social
identity theory.
Group identity
Authority views
Methods
Male participants were recruited through leaflets and advisements the initial pool of participants
was 332 which was reduced down to 15 after a series of screens
1. Psychometric tests that measured social variables (authorise, social dominance, racism) and
clinical variables (depression, anxiety, social isolation, paranoia aggressiveness etc.)
2. A full weekend of assessment by independent clinical psychologists
3. Medical and character references were obtained + police checks conducted.
Sample considerations
For ethical reasons only well-adjusted and pro-social people were included in the study
‘pure random’ to start 5 guards & 10 prisoners
o Controlled measurements – ( confounding variables)
Don’t want all aggressive guards and all passive prisoners
Because it would just be unrepresented off studies not able to identify cause
if you have confounding variables.
The guards
o Five percipients were invited to a hotel and were told they were to be guards and
were given a variety of things to do and prison time tables.
o They were given no guidelines about how to reach goals and were taught the
ethically prepared ‘basic prisoner rights’ and were told any physical rights would not
be tolerated
o They were next shown around the prison
o And were given uniforms
Prisoners
o Arrived one at a time and had their head shaved on arrival and were given a t-shirt
with a printed 3 digit number, loose trousers and flimsy trousers ( to remove
identity)
o They were given no information apart from a set of prison rules.
How did the researchers safe guard against harming the participants?
Prior to the study it was safeguarded by the BPS ( British psychologist sociality) ethics
committee
There was clinical, medical and background screening
There was a comprehensive consent form
Two independent clinical psychologist monitoring the study throughout
Paramedics constantly on standby
On site guards
Round the clock independent ethics committee
Findings
They claim that the events were not determined by the participants being in groups or there
social groups or their social roles but by the failed of those groups
Guards failed to develop a shared identity and value of the commune prompted possibility
of positive change being slim
They were no cognitive alternatives left for the participants hence the acceptance of a
proposal authoritarian regime
Researchers agreed with earlier studied SPE that tranny is a product of group proses and not
down to individual deviance
Individual’s inanity with a group only when it makes sense to do so. Continuously attempts
to implement group values
After day 3 stress levels went down for prisoners and up for guards
Rejected inequality’s in commune but then that failed because how do you punish if you
equals?
Started a new regime embracing inequality’s
Evaluation
strengths
o Ecological validity
Experimental realism
Difficult to act for 8-9 days
People were acting naturally
Hard to fake clinical stress
o Lots on ethical safe guards as one of the aims was to develop ethic guidelines
o High levels of control
Legitimacy
Permeability
Cognitive alternatives
5 groups
o Can identify causes
o Varied representative sample
o Quantitative and qualitative data
o Con-current validity
Weaknesses
o Lacks EV
Televised
Artificial
What the BBC wants
National TV
Demand characteristics
o Possible psychological effects
o So many controls (too artificial?)
o Self-selected sample
o Lack of self-report data
o Reductionist psychologist tries to explain things by reducing it to one factor –
cortisol levels / stress levels.
Piliavin (1969)
‘Good Samaritan an underground phenomenon’
Background
Asch & conformity
Smoke filled room
Kitty Genovese
Diffusion of responsibility
Bystander effect, the more people who are present the less likely people will react because
of diffusion of responsibility – This means no one helps because everyone thinks somebody
else will help
Evidence- Darley and Latant Experiment more people less likely people would help
Pluralistic ignorance
Modelling Effect
People are more likely to help if they see somebody else helping
Empathy putting yourself in their shoes- Us and them, in and out groups – The others.
Aim of study
Researchers predicted that a person who was drunk would reserve less help that somebody
who was ill
Race of the victim was predicted to affect the rate of helping. People may be more inclined
to help somebody if they were of the same race
It was predicted that the less people on the train the more likely people were to help ( due
to diffusion of responsibility)
Methodology
Location
Study was carried out on the A and D trains of 8th avenue in NYC this was because there
were no stops for about 7 ½ min's 103 trials
Participants
Opportunity sample
4450 men & women used the trains between the hours of 11am and 3pm
Between April & June
Avg. amount of people per carriage 43 and people in critical zone was 8
Confederates
4 teams of 4 ( 2 male, 2 female)
In those group there were one victim (3 white, 1 black)
The emergency
The team of 4 enter the train at different doors to the location of the experimental cart
were emergency would take place a victim would stagger out and then lay on the floor
facing up until they were helped or until they reached the stop at this point part of the
team would go up and to the opposite side of the tracks where the experiment would
happen again
Victim and model conditions
Drunk victim – on 38 trials the victims smelt of alcohol and carried a brown bag
Cane Victim – on 65 trials victim appeared sober and carried a black cane
Early Model (C) – Model stood in the critical area and waited passing the forth station to
help
Late Model (C) – Model stood in the critical area and waited till passing the sixth station
to help
Early Model (A) – Model stood in the adjacent to the critical area and waited until
passing the 4th station
Late Model (A) – Model stood in the area adjacent to the critical area and waited until
passing the sixth station.
Observations Recorded
On each trial one observer noted the sex and location of everyone standing/ seated in
the critical area she also noted the total number of people in the carriage
Second coded sex and location of everybody in the adjacent area and noted the time
taken after modal arrived
Both observers recorded comments made spontaneously by passengers next to them
Findings
Victims who appeared to be ill were more likely to reset help that people who were drunk
Of the spontaneous helpers 90% were male
There was some tendency towards same race helping especially when victims appeared drunk.
There was no strong relationship between the number of bystanders and the speed of helping so
the diffusion of responsibility didn’t account in this instance
The longer the emergency continued without help being offered
The less impact on a modal had on helping behaviour of observers
The more likely it was that individuals left the immediate area to avoid the situation
Spontaneous comments were far more likely in the drunk trials
Longer the experemnt continued without help the less impact the modal had.
Piliavin suggested that bystander’s responses are determined why weighing up the costs and
rewards of helping.
Lack of diffusion of responsibility because people couldn’t escape and get away from there
unpleasant state
Evaluation
Strengths
High in ecological validity
No demand characteristics
Social desirably effects
Several control methods
Time it took for modals to help
Victims ore the same clothes
This helps with validity and reliability ( Can be Repeated & tested)
Reprehensive sample
Collected both Quantitive and qualitlve data ( full Picture)
Weaknesses
Lack of control over extraneous variables as they can’t control
Temp
Trains
Number of people
Whether they saw it twice
Personality dispositional confused the results.
Ethics
Description
No informed consent
No debriefing
Harm to respondents – stress
No withdrawal
Do the ends justify the means?
Uses of piliavin?
Individuals make a calculation of whether to help by waying up costs and benifits if rewards are
higher than costs then they would help could influence government laws
Key Points
Cognitive psychology
The verb ‘smashed’ in experiment 1 led participants to estimate higher speeds than other
verbs
The verb ‘smashed’ in experiment 2 led participants to say ‘yes’ to the question ‘did you see
any broken glass?’ more often than the verb ‘hit’
The conclusions are
o Memory of events is not always reliable
o Memory can be influenced by information that we can receive after the event
o Memory can be influenced by our schemas and expectations of events
Baron-Cohen
Previous test of theory of mind skills were only suitable for children up to the age of about 6.
Baron-Cohen et al. wanted to test the theory of mind capabilities of adults.
The ‘eyes task’ is a test of advanced theory of mind skills.
Subjects with autism or Asperger’s syndrome were significantly impaired on this task
compared to a group of age- matched normal adults and a clinical control group with
Tourette’s syndrome
This provides evidence for impaired theory of mind skills in very high functioning individuals
on the autistic continuum
Developmental Psychology
Children perform better in the conversation task if they are asked one question after the
material has been changed
The ability to carry out a conservation task correctly increases with age
Number is conserved better than mass or volume
New behaviour can be learnt by observing a modal in one situation and then imitating these
acts in another situation
Observing adult models acting aggressively has the effect of weakening aggressive inhibitors
in children, therefore making aggressive behaviour more likely.
Boys are more physically aggressive than girls
Boys are more likely than girls to imitate the behaviour of the same-sex models
Freud
The study confirmed for Freud the existence of sexuality in infants/ children
It offered support to the theory that phobias can be related to the unconscious defence
mechanisms.
It presented evidence that psychoanalysis could be us therapeutically with children
Physiological psychology
Maguire
Cab drivers had significantly greater volume of grey matter in the posterior hippocampus,
whereas the control group had a greater hippocampus
There was a correlation between the amount of cab-driving experience and the volume of
grey matter in the posterior hippocampus
People are more likely to report dreams If they are woken during periods of REM than
during periods of NREM.
People can estimate the duration of dreaming to an extent.
The direction of eye movement during REM seems to be related to dream content
Sperry
The hemispheres have different functions. Language skills are based in the left hemisphere
Information resaved by only one hemisphere is not accessible to the other hemisphere
Information received by the left hemisphere can be responded to verbally
Information received by the right hemisphere cannot be responded to verbally, although this
‘minor’ hemisphere can respond in a variety of non-verbal ways
Social psychology
Milgram
Of the participants 65% continued to the 450-volt shock level; 100% continued to 300 volts
The conflict raised in the participants led to signs of extreme tension
High levels of obedience can be brought about in any individual with the appropriate
situational conditions.
Characteristics of A victim do effect whether or not help is offered, including the perceived
reasons for the victim’s situation, i.e. Drunks/ill
The tendency for same-race helping only occurred in ‘drunk’ conditioning
Diffusion of responsibility did not occur in this study.
The bystander makes the decision to help or not based on the costs and rewards involved
A model of response to emergency situation is offer dint the form of arousal cost-reward
model this can be used as heuristic device to predict when help will be given.
Individual Differences
Rosenhan
The diagnosis of Mental illnesses is influenced by the context in which the behaviours are
observed and the expectations of others.
Once a patient has been labelled with a mental illness its hard to remove the label
Type 1 Errors appear to be common in medical diagnosis
It is more useful to focus on individual behaviour’s when over reaching diagnosis.
Patients may benefit more from community heath car then being institutionalised
Eve White was a woman who suffered from head aches and blackouts
EB Emerged during therapy as a person in EW Body, who looked and behaved differently
from Eve White
EW has not known about EB until therapy EB had known about EW since early childhood.
A 3rd more responsible, person Jane emerged, called Jane who offered a solution
Griffiths
Regular and non-regular fruit-machine gamblers think differently about the role of skill and
its effect on gambling success
There may be some skills related to the knowledge of fruit machines that can be used to
boost small wins into larger gains
Thinking aloud offered effective therapeutic treatment to addicted gamblers
Key Words
Agentic State – When individuals relinquish their personal views or opinions and act as an agent
of someone else’s will
Anecdotal Evidence – Evidence gathered without a systematic approach - often just researchers’
accounts of what they have been observed – and therefore open to bias.
Blind Test – the use of an experimenter who does not know the details of a study and cannot
influence the outcome
Cause and effect – the ability to establish one variable and its effect on another. By controlling
all variables other than the independent, you can be sure it has caused any effect that was
found.
Commune – A Democratically-run society whose members all have a say in its organisation.
Confounding Variables – a feature that is not controlled for but could affect the outcome
Corpus Callosum – the bundle of nerve fibres that connects the two hemispheres of the brain.
Cover Story – A false explanation of the aim of a study, told to participants in order to change
their behaviour.
Demand Characteristics- A feature of a procedure ( other than IV) that influences a participant
to try to guess what a study is about and look for clues as to how to behave.
Determinism- The idea that our behaviour is determined by factors beyond our control, E.g. The
situation, The Environment and our Biology.
Dispositional Hypothesis – The idea that a person’s characteristics determine their behaviour,
e.g. personality traits.
Free association- is a psychoanalytical technique that encourages the speaking out of weather
thoughts a person has weather they make sense or not. This is ment to provide insight into
unconscious thoughts
Fugue - A state of mind in which an individual forgets who they are, characterised by loss of
their memory and personality.
Happe’s ‘strange stories’ – A test of advanced theory of mind skills that involves answering
questions on a selection of stories and the characters in them.
Heuristics- common- since sets of rules that are used to solve problems
Hippocampus- part of the brain that is concerned with memory and spatial navigation.
Hysteria- The display of physical symptoms like paralysis with no obvious cause.
Independent measure design - A method that involves comparing the results from separate
groups/ populations
Inter- rater reliability- describes how well independent observers score events: 1 = Perfect
match
Lexigram- A visual symbol system, a bored covered with geometric symbols that brighten when
touched
Limbic system- A set of brain structures including the hippocampus and the amygdala that
support a variety of functions including emotion and long-term memory.
Modelling- The way behaviour can be changed by observational learning, when participants in a
study base their behaviour on the behaviour of a model.
MRI (Magnetic resonance imaging) Scan- A method that used radio waves to obtain 3D images
of the brain and body tissue.
Mundane realism- the extent to which a procedure or task relates to everyday life
Neurosis- A mental illness in which an individual remains in touch with reality but suffers
psychological problems related to anxiety.
Neurospecificity- The way in which Neurons are hard wired to attach one to another in a certain
pre-determined ways during the development of the brain.
Observational learning- Is when we acquire new behaviours by observing the actions of others
and selecting those that are perceived to receive social rewards, such as affirmation.
Oedipus Complex- The conflict between a boy’s desire towards his mother and the fear of his
father will desire to castrate him.
Order Effects- Effects such as improvement in performance, boredom or tiredness that occurs as
a result of the order in which conditions or tasks are experienced.
Psychometric testing- tests that attempt measure psychological characteristics such as mood
and self-esteem. These normally produce a quantitative score.
Psychosis- A mental illness in which the individual has difficulty relating to reality and their
intellect and emotions are often divorced
Quasi-experiment- an experiment where the independent variable varies naturally without the
need for manipulation by the experimenter.
Reductionist- Any explanation or method that simplifies behaviour and expertise in such a way
that complexity of a human condition may be lost or underestimated.
Repeated-measures design- where the same participants experience each condition of the
indecent variable
Sally- Anne test- A simple test involving two dolls, one doll leaves the room he other moves an
object, the first doll returns and a child is asked where the doll will look for the object. It is
applied to the theory that you have to have a basic theory of mind to be able to pass this test.
Situational Hypothesis- The idea that conditions in a situation determine behaviour, E.g. Orders
from authority figure (Milgram)
Social Identity theory- The theory that proposes a group membership affects our identity, self-
esteem and behaviour
Social Learning theory- tries to understand social behaviour by focusing on how individual
imitate the actions of others to model their own behaviour
Standardised- Refers to any aspect of the procedure that is kept exactly the same for each
participant.
Stages of development- in the oral stage, children derive pleasure from there body’s by sucking,
in the Anal stage, children experience control; of their bodies by retaining or expelling faeces;
and in the Phallic Stage, children become aware of their genitals and sexual differences.
Theory of mind- An individual’s theory about how minds in general work, including their own
and other people’s
Time-series approach- a study introduces changes to the independent variable over time.
Triangulation- The use of a varity of methods to study one issue in an attempt to avoid bias and
reduce the limitations of using one technique
Unsolicited participants- People who are not aware that they are taking part in a study