FOL Module 7 Codes, Standards, and Practice
FOL Module 7 Codes, Standards, and Practice
OF LIGHTING:
MODULE 7
CODES,
STANDARDS AND
PRACTICE
www.ies.org
Partial attendance will not be eligible for the IES CEU certificate of
completion. Individuals are responsible for their respective
credential maintenance reporting requirements.
Module 7 covers the Codes and Standards that pertain lighting systems regarding safety and energy
usage, and the Economics of lighting systems.
Participants will become familiar with some of the more prominent trends in energy usage codes, the
standards that are emerging with regards to energy consumption, and see how code compliance, energy
usage and costs interact
• Introduction
• Energy Codes
• Aspirational Standards
• Lighting Standards
• Economics
Post-
Schematic Design Construction Bidding Construction
Programming Occupancy
Design Development Documents Negotiation Administration
Evaluation
Gather relevant Create lighting Detail the chosen Fully document Evaluate bidders, Review submittals Assess installed
information about concepts for lighting concept the design in bids, and and RFI; project; modify
owner’s approval by owner in preliminary drawings, submissions; manage change aiming and controls
requirements and documents, specifications, Consider proposed orders; punch list; commissioning
constraints including luminaires schedules, and alternates aim luminaires;
and controls compliance supervise
submissions commissioning
Regardless of the planning strategy employed on a project, a lighting design process that parallels and
complements the building design process will make the most of lighting and of the architectural
resources involved.
Post-
Schematic Design Construction Bidding Construction
Programming Occupancy
Design Development Documents Negotiation Administration
Evaluation
Building codes
Energy, NEC, etc.
Lighting standards
IES RPs.
Aspirational standards
LEED, WELL, etc.
www.ies.org | © Illuminating Engineering Society, 2023 FOL 7-8
Lighting must address a variety of prescribed components including codes, safety standards, ordinances,
federal mandates, and certification programs that affect lighting.
Human Well-
being
Visual Energy
Performance conservation
Compliance
Performance
Preservation
of the natural
Cost Safety
environment
Mitigation of Historic
climate preservation
change
www.ies.org | © Illuminating Engineering Society, 2023 FOL 7-9
Numerous design goals must be balanced when lighting any space. Each project must simultaneously
meet code, regulatory and financial requirements.
Codes are laws that govern behaviors and are enacted by legislatures
• Codes may be enacted by Federal, State/Provincial, or Municipal
governments
• Regulations are rules promulgated by executive bodies
• The Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) interprets and enforces codes
• The AHJ varies with the code (eg, energy vs. electrical vs. fire)
MUST
MUST NOT
Standards are “the recommended way to do things”, and refer to best practices as determined by a body
of experts working under the auspices of a standards setting organization (like IES) that then publish
them.
Codes are laws, regulations, ordinances. These are set by various levels of government.
Having provided those definitions, the two meanings can become blurred because state laws will often
wholly incorporate standards, making them codes, and standards setting organizations are aware of this.
But a standard is not a code until so adopted.
It should be reinforced that to know which codes affect a project, jurisdiction is key: the location where
the project is located will determine the jurisdiction.
It is the case that sometimes codes will conflict even within a jurisdiction-- the team members on a
project being affected by those conflicts needs to determine how those conflicts might be best resolved,
and work with the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ).
A representative of the AHJ can help with the version of a standard that is in force as code, and can help
resolve conflicts when provisions in those codes seem to conflict.
The AHJ will also send out any inspectors that codes may require.
SHOULD
SHOULD NOT
It is important that participants recognize that codes and standards are in constant evolution. The best
source many of these standards, particularly sustainability standards, are their websites.
Standards are “the recommended way to do things”, and refer to best practices as determined by a body
of experts working under the auspices of a standards setting organization (like IES) that then publish
them.
However, state laws will often wholly incorporate standards, making them codes, and standards setting
organizations are aware of this. But a standard is not a code until so adopted.
It should be reinforced that to know which codes affect a project, jurisdiction is key: the location where
the project is located will determine the jurisdiction.
Overlapping codes and codes which vary by state or region can add significant complexity to the design
process. It takes a professional engineering and architecture team to evaluate a design, and accomplish
a project that is code-compliant.
• Introduction
• Electrical and Building Codes
• Energy Codes
• Aspirational Standards
• Lighting Standards
• Economics
• Ampere
• Capacitance
• Circuit
• Ohm
• Panel
• Red tag
• Volt
• Watt
Review these key electrical terms, which are critical for comprehension of many electrical and building
codes.
People who need to know this code are equipment manufacturers (particularly wiring devices and
luminaire manufacturers), electrical contractors, and of course, building inspectors.
This code has its roots in fire prevention through ensuring safe wiring and is a vitally important code with
particular sections pertaining to lighting as noted here.
• Circuits
• Capacity determined by protective device
• Maximum circuit loading to 80% of capacity
• Separation of line and low voltage conductors
• Accessible connections for conductors
• Luminaires
• Supported from structure
• Consistent with NEC (UL/ETL listed)
• Suitable for installed location
Canada has several standards and codes organizations that are unique to Canada.
• Introduction
• Energy Codes
• Aspirational Standards
• Lighting Standards
• Economics
ANSI/ASHRAE/IES 90.1
• American National Standards Institute (ANSI)
• American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air
Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE)
• Illuminating Engineering Society (IES)
INTERNATIONAL ENERGY CONSERVATION CODE (IECC)
• STATE ENERGY CODES (For example, CA Title 24)
• NOM – Norma Oficial Mexicana
• NRCan – Natural Resources Canada
• 3-year update cycle
www.ies.org | © Illuminating Engineering Society, 2023 FOL 7-22
ANSI/ASHRAE/IES 90.1 is one of the more important codes having to do with energy-saving standards
for buildings in the context of electric lighting and with systems that can interact with electric lighting.
In the United States, IECC is also one of the more important international energy conservation
standards, being widely adopted.
Provisions in the two are often identical or nearly so, but the standard and version adopted by the AHJ
will be that which is enforced.
Adoption of the ANSI/ASHRAE/IES 90.1 Standard by state, giving the year of the Standard that is used
in each jurisdiction.
States showing no state-specific energy policy are governed by the federal one.
Mandatory Provisions
Lighting controls
Exterior Power Allowance
Exit signs
Documentation and commissioning
ILPA ECB
(Interior Lighting Power Allowance) (Energy Cost Budget)
Building Area
(Building Area Method) (Space-by-Space Method)
Table shows how controls vary by space, note only that REQ means required. ADD indicates an option.
ILPA ECB
Includes impact of controls
and system interaction
Typical for major projects
Area
Building
More complicated, but more
Fast and simple, ideal for developer
“generous”
Overview of ASHRAE 90.1 Mandatory Provisions and calculation methods: pros and cons
• Introduction
• Energy Codes
• Aspirational Standards
• Lighting Standards
• Economics
• Intrinsic value
• Brand value
• Real estate value
LIVING
PRODUCT
CHALLENGE
LIVING
BUILDING
CHALLENGE
A variety of rating systems address the need for sustainability goals, stipulating measures which can be
categorized, scored, and rated. LEED®, which is one of the best known rating systems in North America,
established a language for most other rating systems.
Sustainable lighting design strategies and specifications can play an important supporting role for
projects seeking LEED certification. Several points in the LEED system pertain directly to lighting design,
including goals for minimizing outdoor light pollution, reducing energy use, and optimizing daylighting, as
well as commissioning and enhanced metering.
In addition, the Cascadia Green Building Council, which covers Oregon, Washington, British Columbia,
and Alaska, and the International Living Future Institute (an environmental non-governmental
organization committed to catalyzing a global transformation toward true sustainability), has developed
the Living Building Challenge, which extends the concept to buildings and has further restrictions related
to the avoidance of twelve red-listed materials that cannot be used, including mercury.
Declare labels are an increasingly widespread program for manufacturers to voluntarily report product
ingredient information.
• Introduction
• Energy Codes
• Aspirational Standards
• Lighting Standards
• Economics
While standards are “the recommended way to do things” and are not written as requirements, they may
be adopted by state or local law – and may be invoked in case of legal disputes.
With nearly 50 technical committees comprised of over 1,000 volunteer subject matter experts, the IES
provides stability and predictability to the lighting market for the benefit of the industry and the public
through its standards development initiatives as an American National Standards Institute (ANSI)
Accredited Standards Developer. All content within the Library has been vetted and approved by an
ANSI-approved IES consensus process, with most of the nearly 100 standards having attained American
National Standards status. The Lighting Science Collection is free to all IES members.
The practice of lighting design and illuminating engineering are detailed in this collection, providing basic
design principles for indoor and outdoor environments, descriptions light sources, luminaires, and control
systems, and providing design and engineering guidance for lighting upgrades, lighting system
commissioning, lighting economics, lighting maintenance and other aspects involved with the design,
installation, and construction of lighting systems.
How do I design a lighting system for a (fill in the blank)? This collection has detailed design criteria for
commercial, residential, industrial, museum, sports, healthcare and many other applications. Each
standard also includes detailed recommended illuminance criteria, laid out in clear and concise tables, all
designed to guide you to design a quality lighting installation.
https://www.ies.org/lighting-library/interactive-illuminance-selector-user-guide/
https://www.ies.org/lighting-library/the-interactive-illuminance-selector/
www.ies.org | © Illuminating Engineering Society, 2023 FOL 7-44
A variety of recommended illuminance metrics are provided in the IES illuminance tables, including
horizontal & vertical illuminance ranges, uniformity ratios, and a variety of other metrics depending upon
the task selected.
The IES Illuminance Selector is a new search tool that allows you to quickly and easily find the
Recommended Maintained Illuminance Target values for all of the IES standards and is available
through subscriptions to the Applications Collection of The Lighting LibraryTM.
Selecting an application opens the tables, and tailored search filters enable you to quickly complete your
search.
You can save and recall your searches, and print your customized report as record documentation for
yourself and your clients.
This collection establishes the testing and measurement standards for light sources and luminaires, with
the goal of providing a reliable and consistent system for designing and calculating and measuring the
quantitative effect of illumination systems. Photometric, color and color maintenance, life testing, and
thermal testing and measurement standards are all included in this Collection.
The concepts we talked about in Module 6 can be achieved by LM-79 and LM-80 in a photometric lab.
ANSI/IES LS-1-22 Lighting Science: Nomenclature and Definitions for Illuminating Engineering
ANSI/IES LS-2-20 Lighting Science: Concepts and Language of Lighting
ANSI/IES LS-3-30 Lighting Science: Physical and Optics of Radiant Power
ANSI/IES LS-4-20 Lighting Science: Measurement of Light – The Science of Photometry
ANSI/IES LS-5-21 Lighting Science: Color
ANSI/IES LS-6-20 Lighting Science: Calculation of Light and Its Effect
ANSI/IES LS-7-20 Lighting Science: Vision – Eye and Brain
ANSI/IES LS-8-20 Lighting Science: Vision – Perceptions and Performance
ANSI/IES RP-27-20 Recommended Practice: Photobiological Safety for Lighting Systems
BSR/IES RP-27.1-22 Recommended Practice: UV Germicidal Irradiation Risk Group Classifications
IES TM-18-18 An Overview of the Impact of Optical Radiation on Visual, Circadian, Neuroendocrine, and Neurobehavioral Responses
ANSI/IES TM-30-20 IES Method for Evaluating Light Source Color Rendition
Every engineering discipline requires a solid scientific foundation. This collection of standards includes
the language and physics of lighting, vision and visual performance, color science, color appearance and
rendition, photometry, non-visual effects of lighting, photobiology, lighting calculations and more.
The Lighting Science collection is now included free with every IES membership.
We talked about IES TM-30 in Module 1 and 6.
Jurisdiction is key: the location where the project is located will determine the jurisdiction.
• Introduction
• Energy Codes
• Aspirational Standards
• Lighting Standards
• Economics
Costs Benefits
Design
Equipment Economic (Productivity)
Installation Safety and Security
Energy Social
Maintenance Aesthetic
Well-being
Initial Cost
• Design
• Equipment (material)
Comparing
• Installation (labor) Systems
Operating Cost
Include all costs
• Energy Equal Performance
• Maintenance (material + labor) Same life-cycle
Maintenance cost over the life of the system (mainly cleaning and lamp and ballast
replacement)
HVAC system impact (lower energy use by lighting saves on cooling, but adds to
heating costs)
Recycling costs
Approximately what percentage of a typical lighting project is related to the equipment cost itself?
General
$$$
Benefits
Absentee rates
Brand value
Aesthetic Crime rates
Economic/productivity Engagement
Safety and security Errors
Social and Well-being Injuries/deaths (Safety)
Quantitative performance
Tourism
How do you place a dollar value on these benefits? What role can Recommended Practice standards
play in communicating this value to clients? We know that lighting benefits exceed the costs, but it takes
effort to run the numbers
What benefits might be included with any quality lighting design beyond simple energy savings?
• If you lent $100 today, how much would you want to be repaid in two
years?
• That’s the time value of money, or interest.
• You are going to receive $100 in two years, what is it worth right now?
• That’s its present value.
• You discount future payments by the interest rate to determine
present value.
• The higher the interest rate, the lower the present value of future
payments.
• Net Present Value (NPV) = Present Value of benefits – Present Value
of costs
• NPV is used by electric utilities to analyze investments and incentives
The value of money doesn’t stay the same. The value of spending $100K on a project now, might be as
valuable as spending $125K 5 years from now. Anyone considering a retrofit should consider the current
value of their money (Net Present Value).
www.ies.org