Sher 1985
Sher 1985
1'1
I
di~~;.
iii,
~l,
$.\ M
850085
I nternational Congress
& Exposition
Detroit, Michigan
February 25 - March 1, 1985
Downloaded from SAE International by University of New South Wales, Sunday, August 19, 2018
The appearance of the code at the bottom of the first page of this paper indicates
SAE's consent that copies of the paper may be made for pers~ma! or intern~1 use, or
for the personal or internal use of specific clients, This consent is given on the con-
dition, however, that the copier pay the stated per article copy fee through the
Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., Operations Center, P.O. Box 765, Schenectady,
N.Y. 12301, for copying beyond that permitted by Sections 107 or 108 of the U,S.
Copyright Law. This consent does not extend to other kinds of copying such as
copying for general distribution, for advertising or promotional purposes, for
creating new collective works, or for resale.
Papers published prior to 1978 may also be copied at a per paper fee of $2,50
under the above stated conditions.
SAE routinely slocks printed papers for a period of three years following date of
publication. Direct your orders to SAE OrdRr Deparlment.
ISSN0148-7191
Copyright © 1985 Society of Automotive Engineers,lnc.
This papt:'r is sllhjt:'\·t 10 revision. Statements and opinions ad- Persons wishinl; 10 submit papers to be considered for pre-
vanced in papt:'rs or disclls~ion arc tht:' aUlhor\ ami arc his sentation or publication through SAt should send the manu-
responsibility. not SAt's; ho\\,\'ve(, the paper has been edited script or a 300 word abstract of a proposed manllS\"ript to:
by SAl for uniform ~t}'ling and format. Discussion will be Senl'tary. Fnginccring :\\,tivily Board, SAL
printed with the paper ifit is published in SAL Transal'tions.
lor pt:'rrnL~sion to publish this paper in full or in parLl'ontad Printed in U.S.A,
the SA!: Publi\:ations Division,
Downloaded from SAE International by University of New South Wales, Sunday, August 19, 2018
850085
2 850085
quite close to the actual performance for old mixture. The e function represents the
engines design. instantaneous exhaust gas composition. Its
Benson (4) has suggested a O-dimensional variation with time has been found by many
gas dynamic model to simulate the scavenging investigators, to exhibit in most cases if not
process. The cylinder was divided into three in all, an IIsn type curve. Figure 1 shows some
zones - an air zone, a gas zone and a mixing experimental results as measured by Sher (7) in
zone, where the scavenge process was considered a motorized flow visualization rig using a loop
to be in three phases - a displacement phase, a scavenged (Schnilrle type) two-stroke engine. In
short-circuiting phase and a mixing phase. The that rig, both the fresh charge and the burnt
model consists of two differential equations for gas were simulated by water (isothermal model)
each zone to consider the mass and energy and therefore lower values for the B function
balance, a prescribed function to specify the are expected, however the TlSTI type curve is
flow rates of the air and gas into the mixing clearly seen, In the same paper, the author has
zone, and two constants which represent the presented a calculated curve as obtained by
phases timing. Benson (4) has demonstrated how running a detailed computer program for the same
close are the results of his model to the actual experimental conditions, and this shows a
performance of a modern engine design. However, similar behavior. Figure 1, also presents four
in spite of its high complexity (numerical other calculated curves for the exhaust gas
integration of six dependent differential composition; the isothermal mixing model, the
equations), the model does not consider the non-isothermal mixing model, the Benson (4)
method of scavenging and the cylinder geometry, model, and a detailed computation model (7)
although these may be considered by the running for a modern engine design. The latest
prescribed function of the mixing rates or by two show an "SII type curve, while the simplest
the phases timing. do not. The failure of these curves is
In another work of the present author (5), emphasized at the first half of the scavenge
an attempt was made to investigate the mechanism process where the perfect mixing concept is very
of the scavenge process by solving numerically far from reality.
the relevant conservation equations inside the In general, the "Sit type curve may be
cylinder to yield the time variation of the represented by an exponential function as
spatial profiles of the temperature and mixture follows:
composition. The calculations resulted in the
time development of the interface profile
between the fresh charge and the burnt gas, and B 1 - exp[-c • A (5)
allowed the identification of poor scavenging
regions inside the cylinder for prescribed
cylinder geometry and a set of operation where e is the crank angle, band c are the form
conditions. However, although this model can and shape factors, and the SUbscripts 10 and Ie
present a realistic and clear picture of the in- are the Inlet Opens and Inlet Closes
cylinder events, and although it can be used to respectively.
optimize the cylinder geometry, it is not a I. 0 , - - - , - - - , - - - - , - - - - - , - - - - - - - - ,
practical model for an engine simulation to
predict the overall engine performances. ~
.. EXPERIMENTS SHER (7)
It is the purpose of the present paper to z
Q .8 MIXING
propose a new model for the scavenging process l-
in a two-stroke engine which is a realistic
model for modern engine design on one hand, and
(/)
0
Q.
/ "
a practical model for engine simulation on the :z:
0 .6 ISOTHERMAL OETAILEo/
COMPo /
other. u MIXING
SHER{S
(/)
THE "S" SHAPE CONCEPT <>:
t'l
One of the most accurate methods to I- .4
(/)
evaluate the charging efficiency in a fired two- :::>
stroke engine, is to situate a sampling valve in <>:
J:
the exhaust pipe just outside the exhaust ports x
w .2
(Kannapan (6) and others), and to trace the ~
,
exhaust gas composition with time. For this en.
purpose it is convenient to define the B
function as follows:
dm /dt .2 .4 .6 .8 1.0
a,e
B diii-/dt-- (~)
t*- [(O-Oro)/(Orc-8ro)]
e
where dm /dt is the mass flow rate of the Figure 1 - Some calculated curves for the
mixture ~merging from the cylinder through the exhaust gas composition vs. time,
exhaust ports, and dm /dt is the fresh charge and an experimental observation in a
mass flow rate which fsecontained in this flow visualization rig.
Downloaded from SAE International by University of New South Wales, Sunday, August 19, 2018
850085 3
The charging efficiency (equation 1) may be the form and the shape factors, band c; a
then expressed in terms of 8 as follows: The perfect displacement process is represented by
mass of delivered charge retained is always: c=O, an isothermal pure mixing process by c=l
and b=O, and a pure short-circuiting process by
c+ m • However, as observed experimentally in a
rt flow Visualization rig "'by Sher (7), no definite
m
a,c ortm a,s • dt -
0
•
ma,e
• dt ( 6)
phases can be identified during the process, but
rather a complex combination of the three phases
where ma,s is the mass flow rate of the entering occurs, and thus the approach of a perfect
displacement process - charging losses, may be
fresh charge through the scavenge ports. which preferable over any pure phases model.
is related to the delivery ratio by: Figures 2 and 3 show the effect of the form
factor, b, artd the shape factor, c, on the
m
a,s
= m0 • dA/dt
1.0
If we assume a constant volume constant pressure ~
where
'"
I-
(f)
.4 1.5
2.0
:::> 2.5
<t
I
T = S . T + (1 - S) • Tg (10) X
e a,s w .2
~
,
and T is the temperature of the unmixed burnt CQ
gas. g
Substitution of equations 4, 7. 8, 9 and 10 o L--=~2:::::-L_---.l._-.---J1------J
into equation 1 results: o 2 A .6 .8 1.0
t- [(8-8rol/<8rc81Ol]
t * S • dAidt * dt * ( 11)
n
c
= A - J B-~-(l-:-B)-:-T-/T- Figure 2A - The effect of the form factor, b, on
o ga,e
the exhaust gas composition.
where the non-dimensional time - t * is defined
as 1.0 r----,r----,----,---r---"
lu .2
'" The rig dimens'ions and the physical conditions ".
of ope:eation lJe1 e se leeted so as to conse:pve a
7
4 850085
5
850085
TA8LE 1
Comparisons between the present model rsults and predictions of a detailed
computer program (ref. 5) for three different make 2-8 engines at nominal
engine speed. (See Table 2 for the engine specifications). Here, BC, Ie and
EC stand for Bottom Center, Inlet Closes, and Exhaust Closes respectively.
Engine 2 3
Comparison:
n at Be -
c
Detailed model .468 .460 .461
Present model .470 .460 .460
no at Ie -
Detailed model .801 .725 .784
Present model .799 .727 .786
TABLE 2
Engine specifications. The three engines are crankcase-scavenged two-stroke,
spark ignition engines having a piston controlled port and a loop scavenging
of the SehnUle type.
Engine
2 3
Manufacturer Karl Schmidt USSR Limbach
6 850085
TA8LE 3
The effect of the engine speed on the selection of the best fitting values for
band c.
Engine 2 3
75% of nominal speed
h, .78 .74 .79
b 2.03 2.04 2.01
c 1. 74 2.49 1. 70
Nominal speed:
h, .96 .95 .94
b 2.06 2.00 1. 96
c 1. 73 2.53 1. 68
>- .8 b = 2.0
u C = I. 7
(A=AO.t*). An increase of 20% in AQ results in z
an increase of 15% in the charging efficiency w Tg / To = 2.5
while the pure mixing suggests an increase of !,d
u..
11%. A reduction of 20% in AQ results in a u.. .6 PRESENT~~~~~
decrease of 17% in the charging efficiency as W
compared with 13% of the pure mixing model. The to
difference between the predictions of the two Z
models is attributed to the "SIl shape of the to .4
0::
exhaust gas composition; although the charging «
I
efficiency as predicted by the present model is u
higher, the exhaust gas at the end of the ~
I .2
scavenging process, contains a higher fraction
of fresh air, and thus the charging efficiency "'U
is much more sensitive to the exhaust mass flow
rate, or alternatively to the delivery ratio.
Figures 5A, 58, and 5C present the effect .2 .4 .6 .8 1.0
of changing the time dependence rate of the
introducing charge. It seems that the mode of t- [(8- 8 10 )1 (8r e 8 10 l]
introducing the fresh charge has a profound
effect on the rate of the charging process Figure 4 - The effect of the overall delivery
(Figure 5C) and to a certain extent on the ratio on the charging efficiency.
overall charging efficiency. Introducing the
fresh charge at a rate proportional to -/t*
results in a higher mass fraction of fresh air
content in the eexhaust gas during the entire
process, than introducing it at a rate -t*2 CONCLUSIONS
(Fig. 58). However, since the mass flow rate of
the exhausted gas at the early stages is high, A practical new model has been proposed to
and since the mass fraction of the fresh air represent the scavenging process in a two-stroke
content at this stage is low. it is expected cycle engine. The model is based on the
that a high overall charging efficiency would be assumption that the time variation of the mass
obtained. In general, in any case where the fraction of the fresh air content in the gas
exhaust gas composition exhibits an liS" type passing through the exhaust port exhibits an "slt
curve, the higher is the negative derivative of type curve. An exponential function has been
the mass flow rate of the introducing fresh suggested to fit this curve, from which the
charge, the higher is expected the overall charging efficiency has been derived.
charging efficiency. The following conclUsions were drawn:
Downloaded from SAE International by University of New South Wales, Sunday, August 19, 2018
850085 7
1.0,----,---,---,---,----__=_ I.O,--,------,,----,--~--~
~
b" 2.0 z b" 2.0
.8
C" 1.7 Q .8 C" 1.7
I-
~
~/ /
> <!>
..J .4 I- .4 A"fi*
W (f)
o ::J '
~
I
-<
.2 ~
<t
I
X
.2
,4//
Q).
,
,
~ / /-(d
b //
0
0 .2
--- .4 .6 .8 1.0
,*- [(B-B ro ) I (B rc Bro )]
Figure 5A - Some possible forms of the delivery Figure 58 - The effect of the delivery ratio
ratio function. function on the exhaust gas
composition.
1. The selection of the form and the shape attributed to the deterioration of the
factor, band c depends on the engine type. charging efficiency, it is suggested to
For modern loop-scavenged engines it is correct the charging efficiency by using
recommended to select b-2. and 0-1.7. the appropriate correction factor for the
indicated power.
2. As the mechanism of scavenging the burnt
gas by the fresh charge does not change 4. The higher is the negative derivative of
noticeably with the engine speed, the the mass flow rate of the introducing fresh
selection of band c doesn't depend on the charge, the higher is expected the overall
engine speed. charging efficiency.
Model B nc comments
Present dt *
Downloaded from SAE International by University of New South Wales, Sunday, August 19, 2018
8 850085
p - pressure
I. 0 r - - - r - - - - - ; r - - - , - - - , - - - " R - universal gas constant
T - temperature
t - time
~ t* - dimensionless time (eq. 12)
>- .8 v - volume
u
z
w GREEK SYMBOLS
~ B the instantaneous exhaust gas composition
tt .6 (eq. 4)
w n - charging efficiency (eq. 1)
c
to n - scavenging efficiency
Z
to
osc - crank-angle
0: A - cumulative delivery ratio
<>: Ao - total delivery ratio
I
U w - air humidity ratio
~
SUBSCRIPTS
o - standard conditions
1 - at the end of the gas exchange process
l.j - at the end of the bloH-dmm process
.2 .4 .6 .8 1.0 a - air
e - exhaust
1*- [(B-B ra ) I (BIC - Bra)] g - burnt gas
Ie - Inlet closes
Figure 5C - The effect of the delivery ratio Ee - Exhaust closes
function on the charging efficiency. s- scavenge
REFERENCES
APPENDIX I
1. SAE. "Recommended Practice, Engine
Terminology and Nomenclature,lI SAE J60LJC, THE PURE MIXING MODEL
SAE, p. 24.01, 1979.
2. B. Hopkinson, Trans. N.E. Cst. Tostn. Engrs. The pure mixing model assumes the
scavenging process to occur at constant pressure
Shipbuilders Vol. 30, pp 433-462, 1914.
and constant volume process in which the two
3. B.S. Benson and N.D. Whitehouse, Internal
Combustion Engines, Chapter 7, Pergamon gases are ideal with identical constant specific
Press, 1979. heat, c. A perfect mixing occurs inside the
cylindeF to form a homogeneous mixture.
4. R.S. Benson, "A New Gas Dynamic Hodel for
The energy balance on the cylinder surface
the Gas Exchange Process in Two-Stroke Loop
resul ts:
and Cross Scavenged Engines,lI Int. J. Mech.
Sci, Vol. 19, pp 693-711, 1977.
5. E. Sher, npredicting of the Gas Exchange Iii ·c·T lii·c·T· d(m • c 'T)/dt (I-1)
a p a e p e v
Performance in a Two-Stroke Cycle Engine,"
SAE 850000, 1985.
6. A. Kannapan, "Cumulative Sampling Technique however P·V const. and thus:
for Investigating the Average Process in
TWo-Stroke Engines,lI ASHE paper 74, DGP-11, me m·T IT
a a e
(I-2)
1974.
7. E. Sher, IIInvestigating the Gas Exchange and
Process of a Two-Stroke Cycle Engine with
Flow Visualization Rig," J. Israel Tech., m·T = -t'm
Vol. 20, pp 127-136, 1982.
8. E. Sher, IIImproving the Performance of a The mass conservation law results:
Crankcase-Scavenged Two-Stroke Engine with a
Fluid Diode," Proc. Instn. Mech. Egnrs., Iii • Iii - Iii • Iii '(1-T IT ) (I-4)
Vol. 196, pp 23-34, 1982. a e a a e
9. E. Sher, liThe Effect of Atmospheric and the oerfecttmixing assumEtion states, T
=1'. A SUOstltU Ion or eq. 1 If e
Conditions on the Performance of an Air-
Borne TWo-Stroke Spark Ignition Engine,n into eq. 1-3 results:
Proc. Instn. Mech. Egnrs., Vol. 198 D, No.
1, 1984. T· (m·T)
- 1':(1'=1'-5 (I-5)
NOTATION a
b - form factor (eq. 5) If we assume that the inlet conditions =
c - shape factor (eq. 5) the standard conditions, then equation r-5 may
m - mass be integrated as follQ\ols:
Downloaded from SAE International by University of New South Wales, Sunday, August 19, 2018
850085 9
l·m
f a dm
a
-em a ·T a ) •
o
T = (1-7)
1
(1-8)
and
(I-g)
(1-10)
(I-11)
This paper is subject to revision. Statements and opinions ad- Persons wishing. to submit papers to be considered for pre-
vanced in papers or discussion are the author's and arc his sentation or publitation through SAE should send the manu-
responsibility, not SA ['s; however, the paper has been edited script Or a 300 word abstract of a proposed manuscript to:
by SAT for uniform styling and format. Discussion will be Secretary, Engineering Attivity Board, SAE.
printed with the paper if it Is published in SAl:: Transactions.
ror pcnnL~sion to publish this paper in full or in part, contatt Printed in U.S.A.
the SAl:: Publitations Division,