FMDS0132
FMDS0132
Table of Contents
Page
List of Figures
Fig. 1.1-1 Hail damage to 20-year-old “alligatored” built-up roof .................................................................. 2
Fig. 3.1-1. Debris blocking roof drain ............................................................................................................. 6
Fig. 3.1-2. Clogged roof drain ......................................................................................................................... 6
Fig. 3.1-3. Flashing easily lifted (follow appropriate safety procedures when near the roof edge) ............... 7
Fig. 3.1-4. Cuts in PVC cover at the edge of a stress plate .......................................................................... 7
Fig. 3.1-5. Mechanically attached PVC cover with lighter areas over plastic stress plates that may
indicate plasticizer loss and increase in brittleness ...................................................................... 7
Fig. 3.1-6. Shrinkage and embrittlement of a thermoplastic single-ply roof with flacking of an
incompatible asphaltic coating ...................................................................................................... 8
Fig. 3.1-7. Rubber walkway pad secured to the PVC membrane with heat-welded tabs ............................. 8
Fig. 3.1-8. Severe blistering of a built-up roof ................................................................................................ 9
Fig. 3.1-9. Built-up roof with discolored area where water ponds (note exposed roof areas missing gravel) . 9
Fig. 3.1-10. Scrim showing where gravel is missing .................................................................................... 10
Fig. 3.1-11. Spray polyurethane foam flaking and delaminating .................................................................. 10
Fig. 3.1-12. Corroded and deformed roof clip on standing seam roof in coastal area ................................ 11
©2019-2020 Factory Mutual Insurance Company. All rights reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced,
stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in whole or in part, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical,
photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without written permission of Factory Mutual Insurance Company.
1-32 Inspection and Maintenance of Roof Assemblies
Page 2 FM Global Property Loss Prevention Data Sheets
1.0 SCOPE
This data sheet provides guidelines for establishing an effective loss prevention inspection and maintenance
program for existing roof assemblies.
For repair of wind-damaged roofs, or repair of unadhered areas of adhered roofs, refer to Data Sheet 1-30,
Repair of Wind-Damaged Single-Ply and Multi-Ply Roof Assemblies.
For new or re-cover roofs, see Data Sheet 1-28, Wind Design; Data Sheet 1-29, Above-Deck Roofing
Components; Data Sheet 1-31, Panel Roof Systems; Data Sheet 1-34, Hail Damage; and Data Sheet 1-54,
Roof Loads for New Construction.
1.1 Hazard
Roof assemblies are critical to keeping the weather (water, wind, snow, cold, and heat) out of buildings, and
assisting in maintaining proper interior conditions (e.g., temperature, humidity, and cleanliness) in order to
protect a building’s contents and maintain operations. A comprehensive roof inspection and maintenance
program is vital to ensure roofs continue to perform these functions.
Inspections are recommended semi-annually and before and after storms with high winds or heavy rain
because roof damage such as cuts or holes can occur anytime. The weather, heat, water, ozone, and the
sun’s UV light deteriorate roofs as they age, lowering their wind, hail, and water resistance. Single-ply,
multi-ply, and spray polyurethane foam roofs can also become brittle and prone to damage from much smaller
hail and lower wind speed than they were originally tested to resist. All roofs eventually require replacement
but they can last longer with a comprehensive inspection and maintenance program.
Figure 1.1-1 shows damage to a more than 20-year-old four-ply built-up roof from only 1 in. (25 mm) diameter
hail, which has “chipped“ parts of the asphalt flood coat that has “alligatored” as a result of age and loss
of solvents (resulting in brittleness and loss of adhesion to the fiberglass felts). The alligatored appearance
is a clear indication that the roof has aged and is vulnerable to damage from small hail..
1.2 Changes
July 2020. Interim revision. Minor editorial changes were made in Section 4.2.
2.1 Introduction
2.1.1 Use FM Approved equipment, materials, and services whenever they are applicable and available.
For a list of products and services that are FM Approved, see the Approval Guide and RoofNav, as applicable.
2.1.2 Have the building owner’s qualified representative provide thorough supervision during all roof work
to ensure quality of workmanship and adherence to FM Approved standards and project specifications. Follow
DS 1-52, Field Verification of Roof Wind Uplift Resistance.
2.1.3 When reroofing, remove only that portion of roof covering and insulation that can be replaced the same
day. This will reduce possible wetting of the insulation and limit water damage.
2.1.4 Consult with the membrane manufacturer and/or warrantor prior to making repairs or conducting hail
impact or other testing that requires removing a section of the roof. A reinspection by the manufacturer may
be needed in order to maintain warranty coverage.
2.1.5 Use repair methods that do not require a torch whenever possible, such as using cold-applied adhesives
when repairing base flashings. If torch-applied repairs are made, adhere to the recommendations in DS 1-33,
Safeguarding Torch-Applied Roof Installations.
2.1.6 Provide at least one 10 lb (4.5 kg) ABC multipurpose dry-chemical portable fire extinguisher within 20
ft (6.1 m) horizontal travel distance of torch-applied roofing equipment. Use charged hose lines or additional
extinguishers for roof areas larger than 10,000 ft2 (929 m2). Adhere to the recommendations in DS 1-0,
Safeguards During Construction, Alteration, and Demolition, and DS 1-33, Safeguarding Torch-Applied Roof
Coverings.
2.1.7 Follow safety precautions and jurisdiction rules when on roofs and using ladders. Maintain a safe
distance from roof edges, skylights, and open roof hatches.
or metal walls; areas that are subject to ponding water or have sediments; areas near exhaust vents,
especially those with chemicals, grease, or oil; and heavily trafficked areas such as roof access points and
paths to rooftop equipment.
2.2.1.10 Follow manufacturer’s guidelines and inspect and correct the following deficiencies (see Section
3.1 for a list of publications with roof inspection checklists and detailed inspection information):
A. Leaks on the underside of the roof deck, ceilings, and interior and exterior walls. Roof components
above any leaks should be carefully inspected, although the source of a roof leak can be far from where
the inside damage is visible.
B. Flashing that has loose or missing fasteners, is loose (see Figure 3.1-3), bent, or missing; missing
joint covers; holes or corrosion; and cracked or weathered sealants. Also loose, open, or deteriorated
stripping material sealing the roof to the flashing.
C. Loose rooftop equipment and lightning protection cables and fasteners missing from rooftop equipment.
D. Vegetation, including leaves and branches; debris, including nails and leftover construction materials;
and tree branches overhanging the roof.
E. Debris blocking or restricting roof drains (see Figures 3.1-1 and 3.1-2), scuppers, gutters and
downspouts. Check for missing debris covers over interior roof drains.
F. Improper roof drainage, including ponding (see Fig. 3.1-9).
G. HVAC condensate or other liquids discharging onto roof surfaces.
H. Unsecured roof access points.
I. Single-ply membranes for holes, cuts (inspect closely at stress plates where the membrane can be
cut, including by hail; see Figure 3.1-4), ridges, open seams, crazing, erosion, deterioration or the scrim
(reinforcement) showing, screws pulling out of the deck, unsupported areas of the membrane (caused
by warping, bowing, or shrinkage of insulation boards), unbonded membranes in adhered roofing systems
(billowing when windy), improper ballast distribution and coverage of the membrane, peeling or flaking
of coatings (see Figure 3.1-6), or non-fleece-backed PVC roof covers installed directly (i.e., without a
separating layer) over asphalt or polystyrene insulation.
Additional signs of possible embrittlement as follows:
1. Stretching or tightening of the membrane. Usually noticeable at the edges and seams, flashings,
roof penetrations or walkway pads (see Figure 3.1-7).
2. Darkening of the membrane, with originally white membranes turning yellow or brown, or areas over
plastic stress plates becoming lighter (see Figure 3.1-5). Plastic stress plates can cause increased
plasticizer migration in PVC roofs.
J. Multi-ply roof covers (built-up or modified bitumen): Punctures, cracks, open roof seams, blisters (see
Figure 3.1-8), wrinkles, ridges, missing granules, fastener back-out, unadhered areas, continuous
distribution of aggregate (if present), and continuous and nondeteriorated surface coatings (if present).
Also deteriorating felts (e.g., scrim is showing as in Figure 3.1-10), and alligatored surfaces (see Figure
1.1-1).
K. Spray polyurethane foam roofs for pinholes, cracks, splits, blisters, or erosion, peeling or deterioration
of the coating or polyurethane foam (Fig. 3.1-11). It is critical that the elastomeric top coat over the foam
is in good condition or the foam will deteriorate.
L. Asphalt shingles: Missing, cracked, or loose shingles, missing or corroded fasteners, loss of surface
granules, or the reinforcing matt is showing or other deterioration.
M. Metal roof systems: Missing or loose fasteners; fasteners with missing or deteriorated flexible gaskets;
panels that have holes, cracks, severe deformation or severe corrosion; panel clips with severe corrosion
(see Figure 3.1-12) or damage to seams that can leak water.
N. Clay, concrete, and slate tile roofs: Missing, cracked, or loose tiles; missing or corroded fasteners;
spalling, flaking, erosion or other deterioration of the tiles. Discoloration is usually not a concern.
O. Crushed or water-damaged insulation (does not feel firm).
− Membrane and Flashing Condition Indexes for Built-Up Roofs - Volume II: Inspection and Distress.
CERL-TR-M-897-13-2
− ROOFER: Membrane and Flashing Condition Indexes for Single-Ply Membrane Roofs-Inspection
and Distress Manual. CERL-TR-FM-93-11
− Membrane and flashing condition indexes for modified bitumen roofs: inspection and distress manual
• Spray Polyurethane Foam Roof Systems Maintenance Manual. SPFA-127 (available online)
• SPRI/NRCA Manual of Roof Inspection, Maintenance, and Emergency Repair of Existing Single-Ply
Roofing Systems
Eventually even the best-maintained roofs will require replacement, with the average useful life for most
single-ply and multi-ply roof covers being between 14 and 18 years, and minimum service lives between 7
and 10 years (Cash 2006). Roof life is affected by many factors, including roof type, quality, installation,
maintenance, and weather conditions.
Fig. 3.1-3. Flashing easily lifted (follow appropriate safety procedures when near the roof edge)
Fig. 3.1-5. Mechanically attached PVC cover with lighter areas over plastic stress plates that may indicate plasticizer loss
and increase in brittleness
Fig. 3.1-6. Shrinkage and embrittlement of a thermoplastic single-ply roof with flacking of an incompatible asphaltic coating
Fig. 3.1-7. Rubber walkway pad secured to the PVC membrane with heat-welded tabs
Fig. 3.1-9. Built-up roof with discolored area where water ponds (note exposed roof areas missing gravel)
4.0 REFERENCES
4.1 FM Global
Data Sheet 1-28, Wind Design
Data Sheet 1-29, Above-Deck Roof Components
Data Sheet 1-30, Repair of Wind Damaged Single-Ply and Multi-Ply Roof Systems
Data Sheet 1-31, Panel Roof Systems
Data Sheet 1-34, Hail Damage
Data Sheet 1-54, Roof Loads for New Construction
Emergency Checklist: Wind (P9807)
Fig. 3.1-12. Corroded and deformed roof clip on standing seam roof in coastal area
FM Approvals LLC, Test Procedure, Test Method for Determining the Susceptibility to Hail Damage of Roof
Coverings. June 2017.
FM Approvals LLC, Test Standard for Impact Resistance Testing of Rigid Roofing Materials by Impacting
with Freezer Ice Balls, ANSI FM 4473, 2011.
RoofNav, an online resource of FM Approvals for roofing professionals
4.2 Other
Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) and the National Roofing Contractors Association
(NRCA). ARMA/NRCA Manual for Inspection & Maintenance of Built-Up and Modified Bitumen Roof Systems.
1996.
Cash, Carl, G. “2005 Roofing Industry Durability and Cost Survey.” Proceedings of the RCI 21rst International
Convention. Roof Consultants Institute, 2006.
National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA). NRCA Repair Manual for Low-Slope Membrane Roof
Systems.
Rosenfield, Myer J. Evaluation of Sprayed Polyurethane Foam Roofing and Protective Coatings. Technical
Report M-297. Construction Engineering Research Laboratory, US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), 1981.
http://www.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/a109696.pdf (accessed April 25, 2018).
Single Ply Roofing Institute (SPRI) and the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA). SPRI/NRCA
Manual of Roof Inspection, Maintenance, and Emergency Repair of Existing Single-Ply Roofing Systems.
Spray Polyurethane Foam Alliance (SPFA). Spray Polyurethane Foam Roof Systems Maintenance Manual
SPFA-127.2015.
Tile Roofing Institute & Western States Roofing Contractors Association. Concrete and Clay Roof Tile
Installation Manual. 2015. https://tileroofing.org/resources/installation-guides (accessed April 30, 2020).
US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). Membrane and Flashing Condition Indexes for Built-Up Roofs Volume
II: Inspection and Distress. CERL-TR-M-897-13-2.
US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) ROOFER: Membrane and Flashing Condition Indexes for Single-Ply
Membrane Roofs-Inspection and Distress Manual. CERL-TR-FM-93-11.
US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). Membrane and Flashing Condition Indexes for Modified Bitumen
Roofs: Inspection and Distress Manual. ERDC/CERL TR-10-05.
US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE).ROOFER Inventory Procedures and Inspection Manual for Metal
Panel Roofing. ERDC-TR-12-15.
Roof area divider: A break in the continuity of above deck roof components only, where the roof cover is
flashed to secured wood nailers on each side.
Roof coating: A roof coating is a layer of liquid material applied to a surface for protection or appearance
Severe hail hazard area: Areas in which the hail size exceeds 1.75 in. (44 mm) but does not exceed 2 in.
(51 mm) for the 15-year mean recurrence interval (MRI). This area is shown for the contiguous United States
as “Severe” in the Hailstorm Hazard Map of the Contiguous United States in DS 1-34, Hail Damage.
Thermoplastic: Materials that soften when heated and harden when cooled. This process can be repeated
provided the material is not heated above the point at which decomposition occurs.
Thermoplastic polyolefin (TPO) roof membrane: A thermoset membrane composed of ethylene and higher
alpha-olefin polymers, copolymers, and their mixtures. These materials hose meeting ASTM D6878 thereof
in amounts greater than 50% by weight of the total polymer content and contain reinforcing fabrics or scrim.
Thermoset: Materials that harden or set irreversibly when heated. This usually occurs during the
manufacturing process. Thermoset roof membranes cannot be heat welded.
Very severe hail hazards area: Areas in which the hail size exceeds 2 in. (51 mm) for the 15-year mean
recurrence interval (MRI). This area is shown for the contiguous United States as “Very Severe” in the
Hailstorm Hazard Map of the Contiguous United States in DS 1-34, Hail Damage.