Xray 24 Final
Xray 24 Final
Crystal Structure
and X-ray Diffraction
2024/10/29
Prof. Don-Hyung Ha
[Link]
Bragg’s diffraction
• Interference
Path Diffevence
Path difference between wave I and II
Sw
o / 2
Wave I + Wave I
constructive
Constructive interference
interference
0,
≈
no (n integer) A=2A0
no patu difference
Wave I + Wave II
☆
Destructive
Destructive interference
Interference
1
(n )o (n integer) A =
O
2
Wave I and Wave II ( o / 2 )
Intensity a
α A2
Nanomaterials and
2 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
1
2024-10-28
Bragg’s diffraction
• 3 waves with δ=0 and λ=constant incoming to the plane
1 , 2, 3 same path
ino path lif )
.
8 =
0
Paths of wave 1,2,3 are the same from WN1-WN1 to WN2-WN2 after
scattering at A,B,C independent of an angle
Nanomaterials and
3 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Bragg’s diffraction
• Path difference from wave 1,2,3 hitting the crystal plane with angle θ
1 ,2 3 path dif
. .
hkl sin
ABC 22ddnkesin θ
⑲ √
For constructive interference
ABC , DEF 2
a
[ √
andition tonave coms .
interference
nnλ=
2d2hklssin
d no
[Link]
[Link]
(
.
ppaggseq .
Nanomaterials and
4 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
2
2024-10-28
Bragg’s diffraction
William Henry Bragg William Lawrence Bragg
Bragg Interference
Constructive interference at
anst
52.3, 2 77.2, 2 99.6
2~
.
constmutive interferenme
Diffraation
Diffraction phenomenon
phenomenom (constructive
and destructive interference)
52 30
.
7 26
.
99 ‰.
Nanomaterials and
6 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
3
2024-10-28
• Diffraction
– Only occurs at the crystalline plane
plane of
of crystal that has periodic atomic array
– Only occurs at specific
specific angles
angies (that follows Bragg’s equation) by interference
of monochromatic x-ray
– Efficiency of diffraction is only a few percent when using x-ray
• If each plane were perfectly reflection, only first plane will see the radiation, and
any wavelength would be reflected.
– Possible up to 100%
Nanomaterials and
7 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Bragg’s diffraction
Incident X-ray
Diffracted 2θ
θ 2θ = diffraction angle
Specimen
Crystal plane
=
sin 0 0
, in 9 o =
• r
5
Bragg’s law
sin 1,
2d
22dd ; condition for diffractio n at any angles 2 .
K
• Interplanar spacing ~0.3 nm
– What’s the maximum wavelength? 0.6
λKnm(2)
( 0 3)
.
=
0 onm
.
Nanomaterials and
8 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
4
2024-10-28
Bragg’s diffraction
- e.g. 1. Uitraviolet
ultraviolet ( = 500 Ǻ, sample =Cu, a = 3.6 Ǻ)
d(111) = 3.6/(3)1/2 = 2.0 Ǻ
2d sin θ = λ,
sin θ = 500/4.0 >> 1; No θ can meet the diffraction condition! cannot seediffraEtion
- e.g. 2. Gamma
gamma-ray
ray ( = 0.0002 Ǻ, sample =Cu, a = 3.6 Ǻ)
-
2d sin θ = λ = 0.0002 Ǻ
sin θ = 0.0002/4.0, θ << 1o ; too small to be conveniently measured.
- e.g. 3. X
X-ray
ray ( = 1.54 Ǻ for Cu Kα, sample =Cu, a = 3.6 Ǻ)
-
2d sin θ = λ = 1.54 Ǻ
Δ
sin θ = 1.54/4.0, θ= 22.6o ; Angle is conveniently measured.
resonableang le
thatcaem be
easily
measured
Nanomaterials and
9 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Bragg diffraction
d (100)
• (100) and (200) plane d ( 200)
2
√
/ patht 'it .
LPEF )
200 δ
xisfixed .
2d100 sin θ100 = λ, 2d200 sin θ200 =O
λ, θ100 ≠ θ200
Smaller interplanar spacing, larger diffraction angle
i.e. d100>d200>d300 , θ300>θ200>θ100 , d 41 D α
Nanomaterials and
10 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
5
2024-10-28
Vector product
A1 3iˆ 0 ˆj 0kˆ A1 A2 A3
A A1 A2
A A1 A2 D
.
③
A1 A2 cos
A A1 A2 sin
Nanomaterials and
11 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Reciprocal lattice
,
a , f
a real laffice
,
vector
V =Volume
V a1 (a2 a3 ) a2 (a3 a1 ) a3 (a1 a2 )
1 1 1
b1 i(aaxas
2 a3
a3 l
b2 iia ; a
1 Dilaxas
b3 a1 a2
V V V
Gi &
G
Nanomaterials and
12 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
6
2024-10-28
Reciprocal lattice
lattice vector
reciprocase
• The magnitude and orientation Nimaginarrs
I
a1 a2 1
b3
V
dioon
d(001)
doo
the direction of b3 is normal to the
plane (001) which is defined by
a1 and a2
<Unit cell>
D
b3 normal to (001) crystal plane 1 / d ( 001)
I
b1 normal to (100 ) crystal plane Magnitude : 1 / d (100) "m
b2 normal to (010 ) crystal plane 1 / d ( 010)
( b1 , b2 , b3 = fundamental reciprocal lattice vector)
Nanomaterials and
13 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Reciprocal lattice
1
Rhkl Ance IR t α
1
&φ
d hkl
Nanomaterials and
14 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
7
2024-10-28
Reciprocal lattice
• Reciprocal lattice at (001) plane of simple cubic
∅
(
O )
d00
I
,
XC
00 |) apoas
⑦
-
\
t
s
Real daro
☆
(001) ·mnp = 0
∅ → mno
mn0sattice
latticepoints
pointssbown
shown
∅
Reciprocal I D
O
= . .
g 0
W
t
~
I%
..
Pwint
plame ‰
. .=
Nanomaterials and
1 b, >
15 Electrochemical
=. NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Reciprocal lattice
<
a 0.1 nm a 0.2 nm
d 1 {
{
=
0 1 nm =
lomm 1
.
Rhkl =
but reciprocl
d hkl =
5 nm .
( de t Ra ?
Nanomaterials and
16 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
8
2024-10-28
Reciprocal lattice
X
• Crystalline planes that shows the diffraction
h2+k2+l2 P-lattice F-lattice I-lattice Diamond
Δ 1 100
2 110 110
3 111 111 111
d - spavin
a 200 200 200
4
5 210
α
6 211 211
7
8 220 220 220 220
9 300, 221
10 310 310
11 311 311 311
12 222 222 222
Nanomaterials and
17 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Reciprocal lattice
• (100) reciprocal plane on simple cubic, fcc, and bcc with l.p.=0.2nm
~
io 0
reaiprocal battice
simple cubic
: (
-
fcupeak
fcc
{111} {200} {220}..
D
-
bcc
{110} {200} {211}..
_
bcc a 0.2 nm
fcc
18
4N 003 NEED Lab
Nanomaterials and
Electrochemical
Energy
Design Laboratory
B[
reaiprocal[atfile F
9
2024-10-28
22
②
③ I2 2 BEE reciprocal lattice rFcC
=
FCC 1. BCC
① ih
e ABCC
reaiprocal
Nanomaterials and
19 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Reciprocal lattice
10 a1 2 nm
a2 3 nm
| freal hafficeoelR,
6
a3 4 nm
'
D 25
25" y
.
o5
I × reciprocal
nm
Nanomaterials and
20 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
10
2024-10-28
Reciprocal lattice
R01 1 R0 11 1.414 nm 1
* =
R11 1 R1 11 1.732 nm 1
*
u=
a1 1.0 nm
Nanomaterials and
21 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Wave function
• 5 waves
Destructive
1 / 2
]
_
~
Interference
18 *+ λ
Destructive
3 / 2
≈
~
Interference
Nanomaterials and
22 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
11
2024-10-28
Wave function
2
differance
r path phasedifference
0, , 2 , 3 ⑦ 0, 2 , 4 , 6
1 / 2 , 3 / 2 , 5 / 2 , 3 , 5
Nanomaterials and
23 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Wave function
– A : amplitude
– Φ : phase
3 3 3
sin(0 ) sin(2 ) sin(4 ) e i e3 i e5 i 1.0
2 2 2
1 1 1
sin(0 ) sin(2 ) sin(4 ) e 2 i e 4 i e6 i 1.0
2 2 2
Nanomaterials and
24 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
12
2024-10-28
• A A atom’s vector
• Incoming X ray and outgoing X ray with the angle θ have vectors of So , S
• So , S : unit vector with the amplitude of 1
Nanomaterials and
25 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
≈
≈
I
patendif .
Ac Ab Oa Od S
Oatod So AG
=
A ]
( S )- (A-
. A ( S S o )
5 =
~
δ( ) =
2π
φ=
2*π .
-
S
(
( S% So )
) A
Nanomaterials and
26 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
13
2024-10-28
~
^
Rnicl
Nanomaterials and
27 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
b
Ewald sphere
…
• Ewald
Ewaldsphere
sphereininreciprocal
reciprocalspake
space
1. Reciprocal lattice
unit : [nm-1]
P
L ,
(: λ ]
14
2024-10-28
Ewald sphere
Oreciprocal
point
Nanomaterials and
29 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Ewald sphere
S So
Rhkl hb1 kb2 lb3
I S / So / is the same as hkl constructive interference, or, diffraction
All the planes having reciprocal lattice of {hkl} plane that is on Ewald sphere
will show constructive interference
Nanomaterials and
30 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
15
2024-10-28
Ewald sphere
• Bragg’s law
S So
sin
2
S So
→
2sin
2sin S So ,
sin θ
S So
Rhkl hb1 kb2 lb3 θ
~
Λ
pee
2sin S So 1
Rhkl
d hkl
2d hkl sin Bragqslaw
∴
Ldnkesino =
λ
^
Bragg seq
'
Nanomaterials and
31 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Drdiffraction
p 00 C
100
Q 10
Q ~
:| 10
diftraltion
16
2024-10-28
{
I
P
diffraction
a 1.0 nm
In the case of simple cubic with 1nm of lattice parameter 0.25 nm
Interplanar spacing of d440 {440} is 0.17677nm, angle θ will be 45o from the Bragg eqs.
_
(
As 2θ is 90o, {440} satisfy the diffraction condition, as shown in the picture.
Nanomaterials and
33
λ= 2dsin θ
Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
d44o =+ sin θ
. θ= 45
= .
=
I6 d 176 77
θ
(000]
1Jaif raction
a 1.0 nm
1 0.4 nm, 2 0.2 nm
Nanomaterials and
34 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
17
μ
2024-10-28
(
diffraction
. .
λ EM ( λ< O . O( )
m
<
[ ) To
– ~
Diffraction patterns on (uvw) plane normal to [uvw]
d:fFracfion patfern Nanomaterials and
35 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
TEM image
∅
←
internssityte <
"
* plane
(hkl)∙(001) = 0
Diffraction patterns on (001) reciprocal plane
Nanomaterials and
36 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
18
.
-
Diffraction :
~ edestructive
construct
Reciprocal Vector
.
⑥
Wave function
a Ewald sphere
2024-11-04
Crystal Structure
and X-ray Diffraction
2024/11/05
Prof. Don-Hyung Ha
[Link]
X-ray
:
whitex- ray
Jans : aray( contipnousx -ray/
*
-
ay
1
2024-11-04
X-ray
– When shine the fluorescent sheet with X-ray, visible light emits from
fluorescencing materials
– High penetration efficiency
Name of Frequency Wavelength Photon Energy
radiation [hertz] [nm] [eV]
Infrared 300 109 ~ 430 1012 7 102 ~ 1106 1.24 103 ~ 1.7
Nanomaterials and
3 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
X-ray
c
g
const .
, E hv
electromagnetic
x-ray
wave
( Eav )
λα )
(Planck's constant) h 6.626 1034 joule sec
c 2.998 108 m sec1
x x
E A s i n 2 ( ), H A s i n 2 ( )
Shorter wavelength : larger frequency, higher energy
X-ray : high energy of 20000eV
Could be dangerous. Should be careful.
Nanomaterials and
4 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
2
2024-11-04
Production of x-rays
• Acceleration voltage
– Ions or electrons could be transferred
by potential of accelerating voltage
– Examples of accelerating device
with cathode and anode
– 30kV of voltage is applied
(w)
electrons come
Nanomaterials and
5 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
biagnerintensity
,
shorterlead
Isuift
to
tonigmerE
N continuous
Vvotagessxsurs
raly
‰
Qrange : λ SWL N
• short
Short wavelength
Wavelength limit : the shortest wavelength that can produce the x-ray
Limitesuwy
Liotas
• When the potential energy eV is 100% transferred to x-ray energy, the short
wavelength could be calculated by eV=hvmax = hc/λshort wave length
4 tsmallerswr
Nanomaterials and
6 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
3
2024-11-04
eV h max
c hc 12. 4 102
SWL [nm]
max eV V
Qev
π
– υ is inversely proportional to λ
– When electrons accelerated by V
collides with the specimen,
continuous x-rays larger than λSWL are produced
– These are called as continuous
Confinuoans X-x-ray
ray ③ xray
(or white x-ray, heterochromatic x-ray)
~
broad
manydifferant
can
warelangth
Be Skem
• Intensity of X ray
– Proportional to current
current hisI and atomic number
atomic number (z )Z
Iα i , E
Nanomaterials and
7 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
when
change
peak also
'
continuous xray discomtinyoust Eharacteristic -
ray
Lused for medicoal ) • Characteristic X-rays are observed at specific wavelength when V>9kV_
(monocnromatic , used fordiffraations
(
Discontinuous-X-ray
ray or characteristic
characteristicx-ray
4
ray
-
,
0 13aamarlay peak n (fargefica)
Nanomaterials and
8 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
nay
ele
x -
-
diffranatioon
4
2024-11-04
if w 9 tintensitye
OV
Nanomaterials and
9 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
• Moseley’s relation
logscanle =A / ( Z
Z B)
2
Lit '
srelatedtoz
HigherEshorter tofka
T
einear
logscale 10
Nanomaterials and
Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
5
2024-11-04
⑦
29 Cu 0.1540562 Ah 0.1392218 1.2336 8.04
• Energy difference
m
>
DnsnaverErereased
→
bloelkenowt
ome
highert
bottom block tauken ouf
:
3m higherEcomingont
receased
Lmore Ewheen
blocksfall hown
Nanomaterials and
12 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
6
2024-11-04
stable
dsmallE
∠
largert
It requires more energy to remove the electrons that are more closed to nucleus.
Nanomaterials and
13 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Tossote
(excitation)
Nanomaterials and
14 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
7
2024-11-04
asvel s -snen
T noretkelythan
s
largerDE
D
-
ΔE=Ek-shell – EL-shell ^
harder toremoveer
Electrons falls from M to K-shell losertomnciensd
ΔE=Ek-shell – EM-shell
The wavelength and energy determined by the energy difference of each shell
Nanomaterials and
16 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
8
2024-11-04
M
Three sub-L shell exists (L1,L2,L3)
L for the elements of Z>13
(aMs L shelly
-
LIII EE4
Ψ
usually
D
K Wavelength: K K K
Qlevels Lonelevall
1 2
usejustarerage
siifted shifted
O . 154 mm
• Kα1 and Kα2 are almost the same in terms of energy (154.0 pm, 154.4 pm)
?
•
3
( 1 pm 10 1o
-
Nanomaterials and
17 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
• Acceleration voltage and energy to remove electrons from K and L III shell
Uaxk
^ ~
⑦
eNaie
Element V [KeV]
K EK shell [erg] VL III [KeV] EL III-shell [erg]
9
24 Cr 5.99 9.59 10 0.5990 0.96 109
27 Co
29 Cu
42 Mo
I 4
7.71
8.98
20.01
1 V4
12.35 109
14.29 109
32.06 109
1
9
0.7791
0.9331
2.5239
1.25 109
0.49 109
4.04 109
Nanomaterials and
18 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
9
μ
2024-11-04
X-ray absorption
dI
dx, linear absorption coeff.
I
m ≈
uniform
Integration gives I x I 0 e x
const , constant ( / )
menims
Dng D
I I abs 0 Ix
labsorpfion coefficient
Massabsomption
Mass absorption coefficient
coefficient (u !0 ) (μ/ρ)
μ :linear absorption coefficient
ρ : density of material
x
μ/ρ depends on the element type, wavelength of x-ray
Unit : cm2/gm
Constant regardless of phase (gas, liquid or solid)
Nanomaterials and
19 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
X-ray absorption
Nanomaterials and
20 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
10
2024-11-04
X-ray absorption
1 2 3
( ) MIX X wt X wt X wt
mixture 1 2 3
i
X wt : weight fraction of element i
For chemical compound, solid solution, or intermetallic compound
Mass absorption coefficient depends on weight fraction
Nanomaterials and
21 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
X-ray absorption
decrease ~ ≈
– Shorter wavelength : smaller mass absorption coefficient
– Drastic increase of mass absorption coefficient at 0.1744nm and 1.7525nm
~ _
∞
xs E ×
x b . 3 b
1 1
☆ IF 44
,
1 75a5
.
Nanomaterials and
22 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
11
2024-11-04
X-ray absorption
k λ 3ZZ 3
" 3
x ray
-
Nanomaterials and
23 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
X-ray absorption
Fe LAbs Edge 1.7525 nm,
• Mass absorption coefficient and energy III
OEforks
h h K 1
Ab s Ed g e
K h LIII
Ab s Ed g e
1 1 1
K 1
Ab s Ed g e
K
Ab s Ed g e
LIII
h KAb s Ed g e EK -s h ell
_
absorptionedge
for lkshell
Nanomaterials and
24 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
12
2024-11-04
X-ray absorption
Nanomaterials and
25 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
X-ray absorption
• Auger electron
– Electron emission from A-shell when electron falls off from B-shell to C-shell
– Ex) Electron emission from LII state when electron falls off from LIII shell to K-
shell
ka
nduce
outere fo
-
be released
EAuger ( EK EL II ) EL III
13
2024-11-04
X-ray absorption
n o . o f at o ms emi t K-rad i at i o n
PK
n o . o f at o ms wi t h a K-s h ell vacan cy
– Depends on Element
(higher Z : higher PK) Onotprefferedfortray
generation
K Auger
k .
radiation
releuse 4
Auger e φ
-
Nanomaterials and
27 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
X-ray tube
□ ∞
I e
≈
target
Nanomaterials and
28 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
14
2024-11-04
X-ray filter
I K 1.0
With filter
☆
500
C
1 I K 500
I K 1.0
500
rabsorptiongraph
P
sron
filfer
Beak
less hoise , monwchromatic Kβ .
X-ray filter that block the Kβ and only allow the Kα transmission
Fe : λKAbsEdge = 0.0174nm : absorb Kβ
After Fe filter, the intensity of Kα becomes half, and that of Kβ will be very low
Nanomaterials and
29 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
X-ray filter
27 Co Target
24
27 Cr
Co Filter
23
26 Fe 26 V
Fe Thickness
0.015 [mm]
0.017
0.017 75.06 (by2Co
[cm
56.25
56.25 (by /gm]
(byofCo
Cr ) K
Filter )
29 Cu 27 Co
24Cu
Cr
Target
29 2623FeV
Filter
28 Ni 28 Ni 0.017
0.015 [mm]
Thickness
0.020
0.020 56.25
75.06 (by2Cu
[cm
48.83
48.83 (by Co
Cr
/gm] )) KK )
(by ofCuFilter
42 Mo 27
29
42 Co
Cu
24MoCr 26
28
40 Zr 40 Fe
Ni
23Zr
V 0.017
0.020
0.116
0.116
0.015 56.25
48.83
16.10 (by
(by
(by
16.10
75.06 Co
Cu
(byMo
(by K )
Cr Mo)) K
4229 Cu
27Mo
Co 28
40 Ni
26Zr
Fe 0.020
0.116
0.017 48.83
16.10 (by
56.25(by Cu
(byMo
Co )))
42
29Mo
Cu 40
28 Zr
Ni 0.116
0.020 16.10
48.83(by
(byMo
Cu )
42 Mo 40 Zr 0.116 16.10 (by Mo )
Nanomaterials and
30 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
15
2024-11-04
Monochromator
• Monochromator
τ
n 2d
↑ ①
hkl sin λ 1 θ 200
}
,
λ 1 θ 200 F
monocuromater
diffraction ()
Ci ffrac5ion
λ =
IdsinD
asually use si
monochvomater ldnke
0 2%
.
λ
• Even after X-ray filter, wavelength other than λKα is included ~0.2%.
• For single crystalline or thin film materials, exact X-ray is required
• Monochromator is made by single crystalline material β
_
mve ,
Nanomaterials and
31 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Nanomaterials and
32 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
16
2024-11-04
Synchrotron X-ray
~
le
[Link]
x tuabe
- ray
x
→
ray t
- -
[Link]
Nanomaterials and
33 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Nanomaterials and
34 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
17
2024-11-11
Crystal Structure
and X-ray Diffraction
2024/11/12
Prof. Don-Hyung Ha
[Link]
1
2024-11-11
• Laue camera
thinsample ?
needel (aO lum
.
"
Xray
Oaiffraction
points
Nanomaterials and
3 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
• Debye-Scherrer camera
( ε l ) ) )
↑ krag
<
diffract x-
)
monocnromatiu
– Use black and white film for powder specimen Paul Scherrer
2
2024-11-11
• Debye-Scherrer camera
come
L
film
s
∞ ☆
ZO}
_
r
, ∞
2D ,
measure
angle
X ray diffraction pattern
1 : {hkl} with the largest interplanar
spacing smallest θ=s largest d
xraly 2 : {hkl} with the second largest
L L CD
=
brametoDdiffractionangle
=CD× x22θ
sBeEimen
interplanar spacing
…
– Monochromatic X-ray is incident on the specimen, and diffraction cones are
shown for the {hkl} satisfying the λ=2dsinθ
– In powder, they do have equal probability to have {hkl} satisfying the
diffraction condition
Nanomaterials and
5 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
– Disadvantage
• The results will be shown at the film, and difficult to quantify the intensity at
~
×
specific angle
• One-time used film, and limited surrounding
Nanomaterials and
6 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
3
2024-11-11
X-ray Diffractometer
araysone ①
I x
-
ray
9 O - coanter
Detector
~
deteat x
-
ray
X-ray Diffractometer
" ↑
.
.
.
4
2024-11-11
X-ray Diffractometer
Qconatmectire
o
powdery only some are oriented
propeaply
Iitfatioromewenitwenimes
08080
④
0.154 nm
– For bulk specimen, the diffractometer will show same 2θ but different intensity
– For powder specimen with less than 10um in size, they will show same intensity
~ ~
diffraatiom peak
and angle on average.
• For every set of planes, there would be a small percentage of crystallites that are
properly oriented to diffract (the plane perpendicular bisects the incident and
diffracted beams)
• basic assumptions of powder diffraction are that for every set of planes there is an
equal number of crystallites that will diffract and that there is a statistically relevant
number of crystallites, not just one or two.
Nanomaterials and
9 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Diffraction
nktl = event
(112)
(0023
– 2dsinθ=nλ
– X ray source : 0.179nm of Co Kα X-ray beam
– 10113 , 10021
XRD peak is observed at 2θ = 52.3o, 77.2o, 99.6o corresponding to {011}, {002}, {112} .
– Not all planes shows XRD peaks amnot 1001 , ( 117 ? 4 Bluintktl -
(
(
even
Nanomaterials and
10 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
5
2024-11-11
Diffraction
< C-base centered orthorhombic > < Body centered orthorhombic >
0. )3
Nanomaterials and
11 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Diffraction
• At θ=17.4, the path difference, DEF, < C-base centered orthorhombic >
is 0.0895nm, same as λ/2
PO
• Destructive interference
Opathdifference blw ① &③ ← BEF
– Not all angles that satisfy the Bragg’s Ocdoesnit omatch?
scestrucfive
equation shows peaks or intense imterference
peak no peak for oo 1
θ
Nanomaterials and
12 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
6
2024-11-11
Scattering
• X-ray scattering results from the interaction between x-ray and outer
electrons, not nuclei.
– ElasticScattering
Elastic scattering : wavelength and energy are conserved
• After x-ray of λ1 interacts with electrons, scattered x-ray still has wavelength of λ1.
– inelasticscattering
Inelastic scattering : wavelength and energy are not conserved
• After x-ray of λ1 interacts with electrons, scattered x-ray has different wavelength of
λ2 where λ1 <<
< λ .
2
Nanomaterials and
13 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Scattering
• Scattering at one atom
2
I A2 Aei Aei Aei
distance blav & defector
-
detector
velectron
– Incident beam intensity Io, after scattering with 2θ, The scattering beam
intensity, Ip, will be
I P I0
r2 (
①①
K 1 cos 2 2
2
7
2024-11-11
Scattering by an atom
Dumimetei ⑤
i
.
patrdiffaren IO AB & CG
interferenue B -
scattering
Nanomaterials and
15 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Scattering by an atom
f
lifference AElectron
Damplitude scattered from eletron
nopatn
– When 2θ=0o,
m
Aatom = Z Aelectron, and therefore f is Z
– f decreases as sinθ increases or λ decreases θ ∞ ☆ 13
⑥
=
θ
• f <=> sinθ/ λ
5 sA Al =☆
– Example of Al
• f=13 when θ=0o
Nanomaterials and
16 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
8
2024-11-11
Nanomaterials and
17 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
• Phase difference ϕ
– Diffraction condition in (hkl) plane depends on uvw
– Diffraction condition is determined by hkl, and uvw, not the lattice parameter
– Phase difference is defined as
22 ((nutkutlw
hu kv ) lw)
π
Nanomaterials and
18 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
9
2024-11-11
)
– At atom (uvw= ½ ½ 0 )
same
1 1
2 (0n 0 e1 0) 0
2 K 2 u
aV
– Constructive lnterference
Constructive interference
s
diffraction for C basedcenter
-
orthornombic occur
2 (hu kv lw)
Nanomaterials and
19 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
1 1 1
2 (0 0 1 )
2 2 2
Odifferent
• Destructive
Destructive interference
no
No diffraction
diffraction
– At (002) plane
• At atom (uvw=000)
Q
2 (0 0 0 0 1 0) 0
• At atom (uvw= ½ ½ ½ )
difference
= ZT)
1 1 1
2 (0 0 2 ) 2
2 2 2
• constractive
Constructive interference
diffraction
diffraction
2 (hu kv lw)
Nanomaterials and
20 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
10
2024-11-11
Aei fez
fe2( butkutlowl
( hu kv lw)
π
– The structure factor, F, is obtained by simply adding together all the waves
scattered by the individual atoms.
– If a unit cell contains atoms 1,2,3,…,N, with fractional coordinates, u1v1w1,
u2v2w2,…, then the structure factor for the hkl reflection is given by
Fhkl f1e2 ( hu1 kv1 lw1 ) f1e2 ( hu2 kv2 lw2 ) f1e2 ( hu3 kv3 lw3 ) ...
N
Fhkl fFrez
f n e2chutkuntlwas
( hun kvn lwn )
π
Nanomaterials and
21 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
AAupit
Fhkl Unit Cell
call
AAelectron
Electron
2
– The diffraction intensity of a unit cell is proportional to IFnkek
Fhkl
Nanomaterials and
22 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
11
2024-11-11
Structure factor
N
Fhkl f n e 2 i ( hun kvn lwn )
1
1
f e 2 i ( h0 k 0l 0) f e 2 i (0) f UVW OOO
+
2
– Diffraction intensity, I, is proportional to Fhkl f 2
Nanomaterials and
23 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Structure factor
1 1 1
2 i ( h k l )
Fhkl f e 2 i ( h0 k 0l 0) f e 2 2 2
f 1 e i ( h k l )
Lelther | F = 2f
{
4
O
F can be 0Oor
or 22ff - 1
F =
rt
Ctlceven number = BCC
n i 2 i 4 i
e e e 1
2
Fhkl 0 k bll )=
when ((hutk ) odd
0 number =
Nanomaterials and
24 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
12
2024-11-11
Structure factor
Face centered -
1 1 1 1 1 1
2 i ( h k l 0) 2 i ( h k 0 l ) 2 i ( h 0 k l )
Fhkl f e 2 i ( h0 k 0l 0) f e 2 2
fe 2 2
fe 2 2
2 n i 2 i 4 i
Fhkl 0 when indices of ((hh, kil
k , )l )are
aremixed
mixed number
namber
, e e e 1
Nanomaterials and
25 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
e +ea
ex .
unmixed # ( 1 β
= f ( ItH π i
+ez
π : τ :
] =F ( l + + + 13 = 4f F
'=
16f
mixed # # 110 F
>
= f
( iHez πi + :← e ") =
f +-1 - 1) ω =
:2 =
O
e π ( π
[ =
Structure factor
( -
based center
• Structural factor Fhkl in C-based-lattice
– In F-lattice, there are two atoms
– at 000 and ½½0
1 1
2 i ( h k l 0)
Fhkl f e 2 i ( h0 k 0l 0) f e 2 2
f 1 e i ( h k )
F can be 0Ooraf
or 2f
2
Fhkl 4 f 2 h k) )are
when (Catk areeven
even number
number en i e1 i e3 i 1
n i 2 i 4 i
Fhkl 0
2
h k) )are
when (cutk areodd
odd number
namber e e e 1
Nanomaterials and
26 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
13
2024-11-11
Structure factor
2 110 X 110
3 111 111 X 111
4 200 200 200
5 210
6 211 211
7
8 220 220 220 220
9 300, 221
10 310 310
11 311 311 311
12 222 222 222
Nanomaterials and
27 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
14
2024-11-18
Crystal Structure
and X-ray Diffraction
2024/11/19
Prof. Don-Hyung Ha
[Link]
X-ray Diffractometer
amorpnous arystalline
Nanomaterials and
2 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
1
2024-11-18
0
x ray
-
[ *]
I
Xray
Nanomaterials and
3 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
"100 n
di ffract
– At specific angle of 2θ, only 1/100 powder
can contribute to the signal
efficieny
∴
2
2024-11-18
diffract anystallife
– For every set of planes, there would be a small percentage of crystallites that
[
are properly oriented to diffract (the plane perpendicular bisects the incident
assumption and diffracted beams)
– basic assumptions of powder diffraction are that for every set of planes there
is an equal number of crystallites that will diffract and that there is a
I
statistically relevant number of crystallites, not just one or two.
Nanomaterials and
* 5 Electrochemical
aiffrac cystalite NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
[Link]
watch?v=1IWuOUF1_LU&a
b_channel=IAMMDiffractio
nFacility
• Grind or abrade the sample into powder
• Anneal at T>T(recrystallization) to remove the dislocation and residual strain
• Use sieve, collect the powder with the size <10um
*
3
2024-11-18
XRD applications
Nanomaterials and
7 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Qualitative analysis
~
Can ko . = 0 th4 mm
D
D
-
-Beakintamssity
aifferent
Q Cu stronger since cu (x5] 3 Ae (253
]
(
– As the XRD diffraction data for each elements are known (find the reference),
conduct Bragg-Brentano XRD experiment, and measure the 2θ and intensity
I2θ. Based on the result, we can tell which phase (crystalline structure) the
specimen have
Nanomaterials and
8 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
4
2024-11-18
Quantitative analysis
~
Nanomaterials and
9 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Quantitative analysis
creference)
5
2024-11-18
θ :
×
] ∞ θ better
00
,
DsinD
1 1
D
θ (90
Nanomaterials and
11 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
• Au-Pt equilibrium phase and atomic fraction of Pt for the lattice parameter of
solid solution Au 100%
( affise parameter : 6 4 Dt
4 0t O
,
3 az
(pt : 50% An : 58%
.
) t+
O - Pt 108 % e
)
(Am& βE lnkficaparkmetev
FECmetal
Au &Pt -
– Au Pt can have solid solution through all fraction, and the crystal structure is FCC
FCC
. on average pt
– At room temperature the lattice parameter of Au and Pt are 0.407 and 0.392nm, ~
respectively. The l.p. of solid state has linear relationship of atomic fraction of Pt
(
cattale parumeter
– From Bragg Brentano XRD experiment, calculate 2θ and then extract the lattice
parameter, and achieve the atomic fraction XPt
Nanomaterials and
12 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
(affice parameter
Beak shift ( θ)
hha
An pt
n Pe
Lole tee µ
L Auptu
6
2024-11-18
~ Powroad
Ea ∞
13
!
NEED Lab
Nanomaterials and
Electrochemical
Energy
Design Laboratory
diffration .
• Size extraction
– In powder, the diffraction peak has intensity I and width FWHM (full width at
half maximum)
1
B (2 2 21 ) 2 1
FWHM
2 smatlersize
grange
φ esbroader peak
– At smaller size, the x-ray diffraction range of 2θ1 and 2θ2 increases.
– Scherrer’s equation : the size, t, is determined by FWHM, B _
!
o g)
rconstantlusually
.
k
tgos
?cos
K=0.9, θB = 49°, λ = 0.15 nm
B Q
B=0.00001°
0 000010 for t= 1.0 mm B
fbroader
.
size [ ]
B=0.23°
8 230
. for t= 50 nm
B=2.3°
2 0 for t= 5 nm
.
IC 1 λ B &② ε
, graph
Nanomaterials and
14 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
7
2024-11-18
Residual stress
de
← →
suomaller θ
laraer D
,
broaaer
peak
– (d) Bending does not change 2θ, but induces the increase of FWHM B
Nanomaterials and
15 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Residual stress
CFOOH 14 )
Nanomaterials and
16 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
8
2024-11-18
utfile pararmeter
samne
O ⑨
latfile oura meter
laffice ×
paramefer
stress Iaffice parameter
Nanomaterials and
17 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Specimen
Nanomaterials and
18 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
9
2024-11-18
X-ray Detector
Nanomaterials and
19 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
X-ray Detector
• Gas detector
– Ar, Xr and Kr gas in the chamber
tae
imert ogas
– Several hundreds volts of potential exists
≈
current
Iinertgas
Ipotential
Nanomaterials and
20 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
10
2024-11-18
X-ray Detector
• Scintillation detector
h
wisible ligut ~~
– Sodium iodide (NaI) crystal doped with thallium produces visible light when x-
ray comes
– Visible light produces creates electrons in photocathode
– A electron create 4-5 electrons in dynode
– After photomultiplier, number of electrons are amplified by a factor of 107.
– Intensity of x-ray is measured indirectly by the current (electrons)
4
ray
-
Nanomaterials and
21 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
X-ray Detector
• Scintillation detector
l
– Most of XRD use scintillation detector
. otamo 22
Nanomaterials and
Electrochemical
efficienary gooad NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
11
2024-11-18
X-ray Detector
• holepain
Nelectron
semiconductor detector -
e current s
intensity
Nanomaterials and
23 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Detector
• 0D 1D and 2D detector
– Point detector or line detector or plane detector
…
better better
,
,
O Dalefector
-
1 Ddetector
-
2-
Ddetector
Nanomaterials and
24 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
12
2024-11-18
0D Detector
• Point detector
Nanomaterials and
25 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
2D Detector
• 2D detector
Nanomaterials and
26 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
13
2024-11-18
exture
-
O
2D
…
detector integration
Gtexture
Nanomaterials and
27 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
14
2024-11-25
Crystal Structure
and X-ray Diffraction
2024/11/26
Prof. Don-Hyung Ha
[Link]
※ Interplanar spacing
• Interplanar spacings 1 2 3
– Determined by crystal system, lattice parameters, plane (hkl)
In cubic system
1 h2 k 2 l 2 1 02 12 02 1 02 22 02
, ,
d2 a2 d 010 2 a2 d 020 2 a2
a a
d 010 , d 020
1 2
1 h2 k 2 l 2
Cubic
d2 a2
1 h2 k 2 l 2
Tetragonal 2
d2 a2 c
1 4 h 2 hk k 2 l 2
c 2
Hexagonal d 2 3 a2
1
h 2 k 2 l 2 sin 2 2hk kl hl cos 2 cos
Rhombohedral
d2
a 2 1 3 cos 2 2 cos 3
1 h2 k 2 l 2
Orthorhombic
d 2 a 2 b2 c2
1 1 h 2 k 2 sin 2 l 2 2hl cos
2
Monoclinic d 2 sin 2 a 2 b2 c ac
Nanomaterials and
2 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
1
2024-11-25
Structure factor
Nanomaterials and
3 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Structure factor
• Actual example 3
2 different nement
– CsCl : Simple cubic (P)
11 1 1 11
• Cs+ 000, 0, 0 , 0
22 2 2 22
• Cl- : 1 1 1 , 00 1 , 0 1 0, 1 00
222 2 2 2
1 1 1
2 i ( h k l )
i ( h0 k 0 l 0)
Fhkl f C s e 2o fC le 2 2 2
f C s f C l e i ( h k l )
≈
Lintensig differ
mikil
depenaring on
2
FF
hkl
hkl
= f h k ) leven
+ ffcl2 when ((Gxctl
cs 4 )= even
#
number
=
FF
hkl
hkl
=2 f - fcl
cs 0 ktl) l )=odd
when ([hntk odd
# number
=
Nanomaterials and
4 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
2
2024-11-25
BStructure factor
m
• Actual example
– CsCl : Simple cubic (P)
2
Fhkl ( f Cs f Cl )2 when (h k l ) are even number
2
Fhkl ( f Cs f Cl ) 2
when (h k l ) are odd number
Nanomaterials and
5 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
revan
brighminteansity
ad
loaw intensity
Nanomaterials and
6 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
3
2024-11-25
Structure factor
• Actual example
– NaCl : FCC
11 1 1 11
• Na+ 000, 0, 0 , 0
22 2 2 22
• Cl- : 1 1 1 , 00 1 , 0 1 0, 1 00
222 2 2 2
1 1 1 1 1 1
2 i ( h k ) 2 i ( h l ) 2 i ( k l )
2 i (0)
Fhkl f Na e f Na e 2 2
f Na e 2 2
f Na e 2 2
1 1 1 1 1 1
2 i ( h k l ) 2 i ( l ) 2 i ( k ) 2 i ( h )
f Cl e 2 2 2
f Cl e 2
f Cl e 2
f Cl e 2
정리하면
Fhkl 1 e i ( h k ) e i ( h l ) e i ( k l ) f Na f C l e i ( h k l )
For indices h, k , l are unmixed, Fnke = llt ItIt ( JIfmattfor -eπ ichtatus !
2
Fhkl 16( f Na f Cl ) 2
k l )are
when (hIntkteJ are even
even number
number
2
Fhkl 16( f Na f Cl ) 2
k l )) are
when ((hntkte are odd
odd number
nurmner
Nanomaterials and
7 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Structure factor
Dsrighintensuty
sodd
Fhkl 16( f Na f Cl ) 2 when (h k l ) are even number
m
2
Fhkl 16( f Na f Cl ) 2 when (h k l ) are odd number
Nanomaterials and
8 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
4
2024-11-25
Diffraction intensity
• Structure factor
}
• Polarization factor
• Lorentz factor factors influencong diffraction intensity
• Multiplicity factor
• Temperature factor
Nanomaterials and
9 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Polarization factor
• Polarization factor
K 1 cos 2 2
I P I0 2
r 2
PF
– Scattering by an electron
– Intensity depends on r and 2θ
Nanomaterials and
10 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
5
2024-11-25
Lorentz factor
• Lorentz factor I
– In a powder form, diffraction occurs between 2θ1 and 2θ2. Integrated intensity
is proportional to the area.
1 1
in , B2 1 2 io
I 2max
sin cos θ
– Therefore, the total intensity is
1 1 1
I 2Integral
I 2max
B2 oso
sin inB 2
B cos .
sin 2 B
Nanomaterials and
11 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Lorentz factor
• Lorentz factor II
– Over the surface area of sphere, 4πr2,
– The diffraction cone occurs only at 2θ
that satisfies the Bragg’s law
– The radius of circumference is
r sin (90o-θB)
– Therefore the circumference is
2π r sin (90o-θB)
Single crystal
i
⑥ m
Powder
Nanomaterials and
12 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
6
2024-11-25
Lorentz factor
• Lorentz factor II
– For powder, a slight deviation from the 2θ can contribute to the diffraction
– The intensity can be integrated from band with a width of rΔθ
– Therefore, a fraction of powders contributing to the diffraction intensity to all
powders is described as
I 2Integral
cos B 두 번째 Lorentz 인자
I cos( OB ))
cos (
(3
~
( oSO
Nanomaterials and
13 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Lorentz factor
OO
≈
conesize φ
intensity →
infensitq
("
11 .
I
2 B
sinzDB
100m
sin 100
D α
s
ontensityp
Nanomaterials and
14 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
7
2024-11-25
1 cos 2 2
L PF = 60
1H
B cos
sin 2DBCoso
b
• Max L-PF is achieved at 2θB=0o or 180o intensiy
LorentEfactor
• Min L-PF is achieved as 2.7 at 2θB=100o explain 3
Nanomaterials and
15 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Multiplicity factor
• Multiplicity factor
– The relative proportion of hkl planes contributing to the same reflection
enters the intensity equation as the quantity p, the multiplicity factor, that
may be defined as the number of permutations of position and sign of ±h, ±k,
±l for planes having the same d and F2.
Multiplicity
uvw Equivalent indices
factor
001 [100],[100],[010],[0 10],[001],[00 1] 6
8
2024-11-25
Multiplicity factor
I
Hexagonal hkl hh·l 0k·l hk·0 0k·0 00·l
Rhombohedral 24 12 12 12 6 2
hkl hhl 0kl hk0 0k0 00l
Tetragonal
16 8 8 4 4 2
hkl h0l 0kl hk0 h00 00l
Orthorhombic
8 4 4 4 2 2
hkl h0l 0k0
Monoclinic
4 2 2
hkl
Triclinic
2
Nanomaterials and
17 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Temperature factor
• Temperature factor
– At 0K, atoms are fixed, but at higher temperature, atoms are vibrating.
– Atomic scattering factor at 0K is defined as fo, and atomic scattering factor at
temperature T is defined as fT, and they show the relationship of
fT f 0 e M
– M is proportional to (u/d)2, where u is displacement and d is the interplanar
spacing (d=λ/2sinθ)
– Diffraction intensity is proportional to fT2, and therefore e-2M, which is called as
temperature factor TF.
Nanomaterials and
18 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
9
2024-11-25
Temperature factor
• TF and sinθ/λ
– As sinθ/λ increases f decreases
Nanomaterials and
19 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
Temperature factor
• TF effect
– (a) : simulation of 4 peaks with same intensity
– (b) : simulation of same situation with consideration of atomic vibration
• Background increases with 2θ
Nanomaterials and
20 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
10
2024-11-25
Temperature factor
2 1 cos 2 2
I Integral
2 = Fhkl 2 PFhkl TF
sin B cos
Nanomaterials and
21 Electrochemical
NEED Lab Energy
Design Laboratory
11