Baseball Fatiga
Baseball Fatiga
Fatigue in Baseball
Players
Timothy J. Suchomel, MS1 and Christopher A. Bailey, PhD1,2
1
Center of Excellence for Sport Science and Coach Education, Department of Exercise and Sport Sciences, East
Tennessee State University, Johnson City, Tennessee; and 2Department of Exercise Science, LaGrange College,
LaGrange, Georgia
ABSTRACT Baseball has one of the longest seasons a vastly popular sport, very little
in collegiate and professional sports. research has been published on moni-
CHRONIC FATIGUE AFFECTS
The length of the season may fluctuate toring and managing fatigue in baseball
ATHLETES’ ABILITIES TO MAINTAIN
depending on the level of competition players. As a result, it is difficult for sport
FORCE AND POWER CAPABILITIES
(i.e., professional, minor league, colle- scientists to find effective and feasible
OVER THE COURSE OF A SEASON. giate, etc.) and potential postseason play methods to monitor and manage base-
THE ABILITY FOR SPORT SCIEN- if a team is successful. A professional ball players’ fatigue levels throughout
TISTS AND COACHES TO MONI- major league baseball season consists a season. There are a number of both
TOR AND MANAGE FATIGUE IS of 162 games over 6 months, whereas field- and lab-based methods that
BENEFICIAL FOR ALL SPORTS, a full minor league season consists of appear to be promising when it comes
ESPECIALLY THOSE WITH 140 games for approximately 5 months. to monitoring and managing fatigue in
LENGTHY SEASONS. ALTHOUGH In addition, Division I collegiate baseball baseball players. Therefore, the purpose
METHODS OF MONITORING AND seasons can last approximately 5 of this article is to examine previous
MANAGING FATIGUE HAVE BEEN months with teams potentially playing literature that has investigated potential
SUGGESTED FOR VARIOUS around 70 games. indicators of fatigue in baseball players
SPORTS, THERE IS CURRENTLY Professional teams play spring training and to discuss prospective methods of
LIMITED RESEARCH EXAMINING games, whereas collegiate teams often monitoring and managing fatigue dur-
METHODS OF MONITORING play games during a fall season. These ing a professional or collegiate baseball
FATIGUE IN BASEBALL OVER THE additional games cannot be ignored season.
COURSE OF A SEASON. TO with regard to the total amount of
EFFECTIVELY MAINTAIN PEAK PER- games played during a season. It is pos- FIELD-BASED FATIGUE
FORMANCE, POTENTIAL METHODS sible that the overall performance of MONITORING
FOR MONITORING AND MANAGING players may suffer because of the accu- There are many different on-field
FATIGUE IN BASEBALL PLAYERS mulation of fatigue that results from the methods that can be used to monitor
NEED TO BE DISCUSSED. rigors of each game played, travel, and indicators of fatigue in baseball. Some
the training involved with maintaining of the field-based methods that may be
a high level of performance throughout most applicable to monitoring fatigue
the season. To manage the fatigue that in professional and collegiate baseball
INTRODUCTION
may result over the course of a pro- players are tracking throwing velocity,
hronic fatigue has been defined
Copyright Ó National Strength and Conditioning Association Strength and Conditioning Journal | [Link] 39
Fatigue in Baseball Players
these variables throughout a season, it season (6). The results of this study is not publicly reported like the other
may be possible to reduce, and possibly indicated that fastball velocity data used in this study; so, it could not
prevent, some fatigue accumulation increased throughout the season. It be evaluated. Another study by Olsen
that may affect players’ on-field perfor- should be noted that the data from et al. (39) indicated that adolescent
mance. Furthermore, these methods the study by Crotin et al. (6) were col- pitchers were 4 times more likely to
provide an economical way to collect lected during a short season where require surgery if they averaged more
valuable information that may allow pitchers only averaged 45 pitches per than 80 pitches per appearance. It
sport scientists to identify potential in- game and a little over 3 innings pitched should be noted that this study exam-
dicators of fatigue so that he or she can per outing. In fact, the authors indi- ined adolescent pitchers between 14
adjust a player’s training program as cated that the pitchers simply did not and 20 years of age. Regardless, their
necessary. accumulate enough fatigue to see neg- findings provide valuable insight on
ative changes in fastball velocity. Thus, the effect of pitch counts on pitching
it is possible that pitchers who play performance and potential injury.
THROWING VELOCITY
a full season and average higher pitch Although the use of pitch counts
Much of the extant literature that has counts and more innings pitched may may be beneficial for monitoring start-
examined monitoring and managing produce different results. Furthermore, ing pitchers, their use may be limited
fatigue in baseball players has related it should be noted that the majority of with regard to relief pitchers and posi-
to pitch velocity and the number of short-season minor league teams con- tion players.
pitches thrown. Previous research has sist of newly drafted players who are
indicated that fatigued pitchers show adjusting to new coaching methods, al- RUNNING TIMES
a decrease in throwing velocity (10,36). terations in pitching mechanics, and dif- Monitoring pitching performance can
Thus, it appears that throwing velocity ferent pitch volumes, all of which could provide a large amount of data for
could be an important variable to mon- influence the results of the study (6). analysis as pitchers initiate every play
itor. Escamilla et al. (10) inferred that by throwing the ball. However, there
throwing velocity was statistically PITCH COUNT are 8 other players on the field and
decreased during the final 2 innings as At the professional and collegiate monitoring their fatigue throughout
compared with the initial 2 innings (P , baseball levels, regularly scheduled the season is equally as important. Bar-
0.01, from 37.7 6 1.8 to 33.7 6 1.5 m/s) games last 9 innings. Because of the ring sickness or injury, most of the
during a simulated baseball game in length of the game, it is possible for position players are on the field every-
which the pitchers threw between 105 a starting pitcher to throw in excess day, not just once every 5 days. Spe-
and 135 pitches for 7–9 innings. In addi- of 120 pitches. Thus, it makes sense cific indicators of fatigue for position
tion, the authors indicated that the that pitch counts in a single game, players within scientific literature have
pitchers’ trunk position became more and over a season, would be viewed yet to be determined. One area that
vertical (P , 0.01, from 348 6 128 to as a factor that will contribute to the may be promising is monitoring base
298 6 118), placing an increased reliance overall fatigue of a pitcher (11). A study running times throughout the season
on the throwing arm during pitching. In by Bradbury and Forman (2) analyzed (30). Baseball programs traditionally
addition, further changes in pitching the influence of pitch counts on pitch- evaluate baseline measures of perfor-
mechanics may increase the potential ing performance in major league base- mance at the start of a baseball season
for injury if a pitcher remains in ball players. Statistics from 20 seasons to distinguish performance differences
a fatigued state (10). Another study by and over 1,000 pitchers were used in between players (53). Timed runs from
Murray et al. (36) used high-speed video the study. Through a complex regres- home to first and from first to third
analysis to examine fastballs thrown dur- sion equation, the cumulative effect of may be among the battery of perfor-
ing the first inning of play and the final pitches thrown on future outings was mance tests (3). Unfortunately, these
inning of play in 7 major league baseball evaluated. A negative relationship was timed runs may not be evaluated beyond
pitchers. This study indicated that found between pitch counts and sub- the onset of a new season, and thus,
decreased ranges of motion at the shoul- sequent performances. Furthermore, performance changes cannot be evalu-
der and knee joints contributed to the authors attempted to evaluate the ated. Based on the authors’ observations
a decreased throwing velocity of about relationship between rest days and per- in both collegiate and professional base-
5 mi/h. Furthermore, the authors indi- formance, but a minimal effect was ball, many teams perform base running
cated that fatigue might have been a pos- observed. This could be because of drills on a weekly basis. Obtaining
sible mechanism of the kinematic and the fact that rest days are fairly stan- a weekly measure of 2 different base
kinetic changes that occurred. dardized in pitching rotations. For running skills (i.e., home to first and from
In contrast to the previous studies, example, a starting pitcher will gener- first to third) may provide a quantitative
another study evaluated changes in ally throw every 5 days regardless of measure of fatigue throughout a 5- or
fastball velocity of 12 pitchers over how many pitches were thrown pre- 6-month season, as decrements in run-
the course of a minor league short viously. Unfortunately, pitch velocity ning performance may be indicative of
recommend altering the athletes’ daily with the procedures, a measure of lean easily, and cheaply when using switch
routines as minimally as possible. body mass can be obtained by com- mats and jump and reach devices (33).
Therefore, it is suggested that the prac- pleting skinfolds with skinfold calipers.
titioners may only want to use one By using the sum of skinfolds, sport RATE OF FORCE DEVELOPMENT
of the previously mentioned methods, scientists will be able to monitor the RFD has previously been defined as the
as the incorporation of all 3 may dis- stability of a player’s lean body mass ability to accelerate objects or system
rupt the daily routines of their athletes (47). Sport scientists can then use this mass rapidly (44) and is considered to
to a greater extent. information to provide basic nutritional be an indicator of explosive strength
recommendations and updated train- (34,49). Like other performance varia-
LAB-BASED FATIGUE ing programs to each player so that bles, RFD can be very sensitive to both
MONITORING he can, at a minimum, maintain his acute and chronic fatigue (9,52). As
Although the above field-based fatigue lean body mass. Based on the number compared with jump height, Fowles
monitoring and management methods of athletes on a professional or colle- (16) suggested that measurements of
can be effective, more thorough meth- giate baseball team, it is recommended RFD and power may better reflect
ods that have received stronger sup- that practitioners should use a 3-site fatigue during vertical jumps. Based on
port within the scientific literature skinfold protocol to reduce the time the physical demands of a baseball sea-
can be used given the availability of needed for monitoring purposes (25). son, one could draw the conclusion that
specific equipment, such as skinfold It is suggested that sport scientists the RFD of professional and collegiate
calipers, accelerometers, linear position should use statistical process control to baseball players may be affected if a cer-
and force transducers, and/or force form acceptable ranges for each athlete tain amount of fatigue has accumulated
plates. Obviously, the availability of so that the athletes can more effectively throughout the season.
funds and facilities will determine if maintain their lean body mass (42).
these types of devices can be purchased Previous research has indicated that an
and used. However, if the resources are VERTICAL JUMP HEIGHT increased amount of volume load and
available, weekly measurements of Another lab-based method of monitor- work over an extended period of time
player’s body composition, jump height, ing fatigue for the whole baseball team can result in decreased levels of RFD
and rate of force development (RFD) that seems to be promising may be the (18,19,40,48). Because activities, such
during squat and countermovement inclusion of weekly jumping assess- as hitting, throwing, running, and
jumps can be used to monitor and man- ments using accelerometers, linear jumping, require baseball players to
age any fatigue that may exist. position and force transducers, and/ perform explosively, RFD seems to
or force plates. Vertical jumping evalu- be a vital component to the overall
BODY COMPOSITION ations have been indicated as a good performance of each player and thus
During a long season that includes measure for monitoring fatigue (16). should be monitored throughout the
a large of number of games, training ses- Specifically, jump height has been used season as an indicator of fatigue. To
sions, and the potential for the accumu- within the scientific literature to moni- monitor RFD, sport scientists would
lation of other physical and emotional tor fatigue (5,37,41). Ronglan et al. (41) need to purchase additional equip-
stressors, it is possible that baseball play- were able to observe a decrease in coun- ment, such as accelerometers, linear
ers may lose lean body mass, which may termovement jump height after several position and force transducers, and/
decrease the physiological cross- days of handball competition. Similarly, or force plates. The ability to do this
sectional area of muscles leading to Nimphius (37) indicated that jump may be dependent on the funds avail-
a decreased amount of maximal force height was a sensitive enough measure able to do so. However, if sport scien-
a muscle can produce (49). Previous to monitor declines in performance dur- tists have the means to purchase a force
research indicates that accumulated ing an 8-day baseball tournament. plate, the RFD during both squat and
fatigue that results from a chronic In contrast, Coutts et al. (5) indicated countermovement jumps may serve as
increase in volume load may significantly that jump height may not be sensitive indicators of fatigue if decreased values,
decrease the testosterone:cortisol ratio, enough to show alterations because of as compared with previous or baseline
putting the body in a state of catabolism fatigue. It is clear that further research measures, are frequently present.
(i.e., breakdown of proteins) (21,22,35). using jump height as an indicator of Although the cost of this equipment
This state of catabolism may affect fatigue is needed. It should be noted is usually higher than instruments that
a player’s lean body mass, fat mass, max- that vertical jump height can be as- only evaluate jump height, the authors
imum strength, RFD, and power sessed using several different methods, are not suggesting that professional
(20,23,24). including field-based devices such as baseball teams cannot afford them. In
Because monitoring the testosterone: switch mats and jump and reach devi- fact, some professional organizations
cortisol ratio may not be feasible ces. Although they may not derive as have several of these instruments (45).
throughout a season with a large num- many variables, field-based testing It is up to the sport scientist to dem-
ber of players, and the cost associated methods can be administered quickly, onstrate the value of the instruments
prevent high levels of fatigue that are suggested: (a) in regard to field- 4. Coutts AJ and Reaburn P. Monitoring
may affect their playing abilities. While based methods of monitoring fatigue, changes in rugby league players’ perceived
it is recommended that sport scientists stress and recovery during intensified
pursuing methods of monitoring and training. Percept Mot Skills 106: 904–916,
managing fatigue, sport scientists record the throwing velocity of each
2008.
should consider both field- and lab- pitch and the pitch count of each
pitcher every time they throw; (b) ses- 5. Coutts AJ, Reaburn P, Piva TJ, and
based methods based on the availabil- Rowsell GJ. Monitoring for overreaching in
ity of equipment. The field-based sion RPE and perceived recovery status
rugby league players. Eur J Appl Physiol
methods that seem to be the most eco- should be recorded at every training 99: 313–324, 2007.
nomical and practical for baseball session and/or event; (c) timed base
6. Crotin RL, Bhan S, Karakolis T, and
include tracking throwing velocity, running and athlete tracking question- Ramsey DK. Fastball velocity trends in
pitch counts, base running times, ses- naires should be used at a minimum of short-season minor league baseball.
sion RPE, players’ perceived recovery once per week; and (d) if possible, J Strength Cond Res 27: 2206–2212,
status, and player responses on athlete weekly lab-based measures of each 2013.
tracking questionnaires. The lab-based player’s body composition, vertical jump 7. Day ML, McGuigan MR, Brice G, and
methods that may relate the best to base- height, and RFD should be obtained to Foster C. Monitoring exercise intensity
ball players’ fatigue and fatigue-induced provide sport scientists with valuable during resistance training using the session
fatigue monitoring information. RPE scale. J Strength Cond Res 18: 353–
performance alterations are monitoring 358, 2004.
measures of each player’s body compo-
Conflicts of Interest and Source of Funding: 8. Egan AD, Winchester JB, Foster C, and
sition, vertical jump height, and RFD dur-
The authors report no conflicts of interest McGuigan MR. Using session RPE to
ing squat and countermovement jumps. monitor different methods of resistance
and no source of funding.
If sport scientists can monitor fatigue exercise. J Sports Sci Med 5: 289–295,
over the entire baseball season, it may 2006.
be possible to manage and prevent ac- Timothy J. 9. Enoka RM and Duchateau J. Muscle
cumulations of fatigue, allowing play- Suchomel is fatigue: What, why and how it influences
muscle function. J Physiol 586: 11–23,
ers to perform at their highest level a doctoral candi-
2008.
throughout the entire season. Sport date in the
10. Escamilla RF, Barrentine SW, Fleisig GS,
scientists should take caution when Department of
Zheng N, Takada Y, Kingsley D, and
using methods of monitoring fatigue Exercise and Andrews JR. Pitching biomechanics as
that may not have an abundant Sport Sciences at a pitcher approaches muscular fatigue
amount of supporting literature. Many East Tennessee during a simulated baseball game. Am J
of the discussed monitoring methods State University. Sports Med 35: 23–33, 2007.
11. Fortenbaugh D, Fleisig GS, and Andrews JR. 24. Hakkinen K, Pakarinen A, Kyrolainen H, 37. Nimphius S. Monitoring neuromuscular
Baseball pitching biomechanics in relation to Cheng S, Kim DH, and Komi PV. fatigue in amateur baseball players during
injury risk and performance. Sports Health 1: Neuromuscular adaptations and serum a national tournament. J Aus Strength
314–320, 2009. hormones in females during prolonged Cond 19: 110–114, 2011.
12. Foster C. Monitoring training in athletes power training. Int J Sports Med 11: 91– 38. Nimphius S, McGuigan MR, and Newton RU.
with reference to overtraining syndrome. 98, 1990. Changes in muscle architecture and
Med Sci Sports Exerc 30: 1164–1168, 25. Jackson AS and Pollock ML. Practical performance during a competitive season in
1998. assessment of body composition. Phys female softball players. J Strength Cond Res
13. Foster C, Daines E, Hector L, Snyder AC, Sports Med 13: 76–90, 1985. 26: 2655–2666, 2012.
and Welsh R. Athletic performance in 26. Kallus KW. Der Erholungs-Belastungs- 39. Olsen SJ, Fleisig GS, Dun S, Loftice J, and
relation to training load. Wis Med J 95: Fragebogen [The Recovery Stress- Andrews JR. Risk factors for shoulder and
370–374, 1996. Questionnaire]. Frankfurt, German: Swets elbow injuries in adolescent baseball
14. Foster C, Florhaug JA, Franklin J, & Zeitlinger, 1995. pitchers. Am J Sports Med 34: 905–912,
Gottschall L, Hrovatin LA, Parker S, 27. Kellmann M. Preventing overtraining in 2006.
Doleshal P, and Dodge C. A new approach athletes in high‐intensity sports and stress/ 40. Painter KB, Haff GG, Ramsey MW,
to monitoring exercise training. J Strength recovery monitoring. Scand J Med Sci McBride J, Triplett T, Sands WA,
Cond Res 15: 109–115, 2001. Sports 20: 95–102, 2010. Lamont HS, Stone ME, and Stone MH.
15. Foster C, Hector LL, Welsh R, Schrager M, 28. Kellmann M and Günther KD. Changes in Strength gains: Block versus daily
Green MA, and Snyder AC. Effects of stress and recovery in elite rowers undulating periodization weight training
specific versus cross-training on running during preparation for the Olympic among track and field athletes. Int J Sports
performance. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup games. Med Sci Sports Exerc 32: 676– Physiol Perform 7: 161–169, 2012.
Physiol 70: 367–372, 1995. 683, 2000. 41. Ronglan LT, Raastad T, and Borgesen A.
16. Fowles JR. Technical issues in quantifying 29. Kellmann M and Kallus K. The Recovery- Neuromuscular fatigue and recovery in elite
low-frequency fatigue in athletes. Int J Stress Questionnaire for Athletes. female handball players. Scand J Med Sci
Sports Physiol Perform 1: 169–171, Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics, 2001. Sports 16: 267–273, 2006.
2006. 30. Kohmura Y, Aoki K, Yoshigi H, Sakuraba K, 42. Sands WA. How can coaches use sport
17. Guevara AJ and Fidler DP. Stealing Lives: and Yanagiya T. Development of science? Mod Athlete Coach 36: 8–12,
The Globalization of Baseball and the a baseball-specific battery of tests and 1998.
Tragic Story of Alexis Quiroz. Bloomington, a testing protocol for college baseball 43. Sands WA and Stone MH. Monitoring the
IN: Indiana Press, 2002. players. J Strength Cond Res 22: 1051– elite athlete. USOC Olympic Coach E-Mag
18. Hakkinen K. Neuromuscular fatigue and 1058, 2008. 17(3): 4–12, 2005.
recovery in male and female athletes during 31. Komi PV. Stretch-shortening cycle: 44. Schmidtbleicher D. Training for power
heavy resistance exercise. Int J Sports Med A powerful model to study normal and events. In: Strength and Power in Sport.
14: 53–59, 1993. fatigued muscle. J Biomech 33: 1197– Komi PV, ed. London, UK: Blackwell
19. Häkkinen K. Neuromuscular adaptation 1206, 2000. Scientific, 1992. pp. 381–395.
during strength training, aging, detraining, 32. Laurent CM, Green JM, Bishop PA, 45. Schoneberger A. Rockies team up with
and immobilization. Crit Rev Phys Rehabil Sjokvist J, Schumacker RE, SPARTA. [Link]
Med 6: 161–168, 1994. Richardson MT, and Curtner-Smith M. p=1596. 2013.
20. Hakkinen K, Kallinen M, Komi PV, and A practical approach to monitoring 46. Sikorski EM, Wilson JM, Lowery RP,
Kauhanen H. Neuromuscular adaptations recovery: Development of a perceived Joy JM, Laurent CM, Wilson SM,
during short-term “normal” and reduced recovery status scale. J Strength Cond Res Hesson D, Naimo MA, Averbuch B, and
training periods in strength athletes. 25: 620–628, 2011. Gilchrist P. Changes in perceived
Electromyogr Clin Neurophysiol 31: 33. McGuigan MR, La Doyle T, Newton M, recovery status scale following high-
35–42, 1991. Edwards DJ, Nimphius S, and Newton RU. volume muscle damaging resistance
21. Hakkinen K, Keskinen KL, Alen M, Komi PV, Eccentric utilization ratio: Effect of sport exercise. J Strength Cond Res 27: 2079–
and Kauhanen H. Serum hormone and phase of training. J Strength Cond Res 2085, 2013.
concentrations during prolonged training in 20: 992–995, 2006. 47. Slater GJ, Duthie GM, Pyne DB, and
elite endurance-trained and strength- 34. McLellan CP, Lovell DI, and Gass GC. The Hopkins WG. Validation of a skinfold
trained athletes. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup role of rate of force development on vertical based index for tracking proportional
Physiol 59: 233–238, 1989. jump performance. J Strength Cond Res changes in lean mass. Br J Sports Med 40:
22. Hakkinen K, Pakarinen A, Alen M, 25: 379–385, 2011. 208–213, 2006.
Kauhanen H, and Komi PV. Neuromuscular 35. McMillan JL, Stone MH, Sartin J, Keith R, 48. Stone MH and Fry AC. Increased training
and hormonal adaptations in athletes to Marples D, Brown C, and Lewis RD. 20- volume in strength/power athletes. In:
strength training in two years. J Appl hour physiological responses to a single Overtraining in Sport. Kreider RB, Fry AC,
Physiol 65: 2406–2412, 1988. weight-training session. J Strength Cond and O’Toole ML, eds. Champaign, IL:
23. Hakkinen K, Pakarinen A, Alen M, and Res 7: 9–21, 1993. Human Kinetics, 1998. pp. 87–105.
Komi PV. Serum hormones during 36. Murray TA, Cook TD, Werner SL, Schlegel TF, 49. Stone MH, Stone M, and Sands WA.
prolonged training of neuromuscular and Hawkins RJ. The effects of extended play Principles and Practice of Resistance
performance. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup on professional baseball pitchers. Am J Training. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics,
Physiol 53: 287–293, 1985. Sports Med 29: 137–142, 2001. 2007.